‘Good’ patient/‘bad’ patient: clinical learning and the entrenching of inequality

This article develops sociological understanding of the reproduction of inequality in medicine. The material is drawn from a longitudinal study of student experiences of clinical learning that entailed 72 qualitative in‐depth interviews with 27 medical students from five medical schools in the USA. To highlight the subtle, yet powerful, ways in which inequality gets entrenched, this article analyses ideas of the ‘good’ and the ‘bad’ patient. Bad patients question not only biomedical knowledge but also medical students’ commitment to helping people. Good patients engage with medical students in a manner that upholds biomedical knowledge and enables students to assume the role of the healer and the expert. At the same time, good patients possess cultural skills that align with those of medical practitioners. This alignment is, furthermore, central to definitions of the good patient. Distinctions drawn between good and bad patients thus both embody as well as enforce social inequality. The subtle reproduction of inequality is, however, difficult to discern because judgements about patients entwine with emotion.     

Treatment of asthma in children: more than merely 'puffing'

Five children, four boys aged 6, 9, 12 and 13 years and one girl aged 6 years, had persistent asthmatic symptoms despite maintenance treatment with inhaled corticosteroids and short-acting bronchodilators on demand. One of them required the addition of a long-acting beta 2-agonist to become symptom-free. The other four patients did not need to step up their asthma medication after correction of poor inhaler technique, treatment of dysfunctional breathing, treatment of allergic rhinitis, and elimination of passive cigarette-smoke exposure, respectively. All current guidelines on the treatment of asthma in children advise, in case of persistent asthmatic symptoms despite inhaled corticosteroids and short-acting bronchodilators, the addition of long-acting beta 2-agonists. However, various factors may play a role in the persistence of asthma despite adequate therapy and these factors should be evaluated before stepping up the medication.     

‘Bourdieu’, medical elites and ‘social class’: a qualitative study of ‘desert island’ doctors

Sociologists of professions draw on Weberian theories of closure. However they have tended to ignore Bourdieu's work, which rejects Weberian notions of class and status groups as distinct ideal types and sees these concepts as inextricably linked. Bourdieu emphasises the importance of a class‐based habitus which generates orientations, inclinations and dispositions that organise practices and the perception of practice. For Bourdieu, because individuals perceive one another primarily through the status that attaches to their practices (through a symbolic veil of honour) they fail to perceive the real basis of these practices: the forms of capital that underlie the different habitus and enable their realisation. This article draws on interviews with 17 elite doctors appearing on a national (UK) radio show during which they choose eight discs to take to a desert island. According to Bourdieu, ‘nothing more clearly affirms one's “class”, nothing more infallibly classifies, than one's taste in music’. An analysis of the doctors' musical tastes and their mode of acquisition (largely, for these elites, via their family and education at independent schools), as well as other insights into their cultural capital reveals the importance of linking class and status when exploring professional status and prestige.     

‘Every space is claimed’: smokers’ experiences of tobacco denormalisation

Over the past decade, the strategy of ‘denormalising’ tobacco use has become one of the cornerstones of the global tobacco control movement. Although tobacco denormalisation policies primarily affect people on the lowest rungs of the social ladder, few qualitative studies have explicitly set out to explore how smokers have experienced and responded to these legislative and social changes in attitudes towards tobacco use. Drawing on a qualitative study of interviews with 25 current and ex‐smokers living in Vancouver, Canada, this paper examines the ways they interpret and respond to the new socio‐political environment in which they must manage the increasingly problematised practice of tobacco smoking. Overall, while not opposed to smoking restrictions per se, study participants felt that recent legislation, particularly efforts to prohibit smoking in a variety of outdoor settings, was overly restrictive and that all public space had increasingly been ‘claimed’ by non‐smokers. Also apparent from participants’ accounts was the high degree of stigma attached to smoking. However, although the ‘denormalisation’ environment had encouraged several participants to quit smoking, the majority continued to smoke, raising ethical and practical questions about the value of denormalisation strategies as a way of reducing smoking‐related mortality and morbidity.     

Poststructuralism and other ‘species’ in public health—a ‘Darwinian’ view

Abstract: The concepts and methods of poststructuralism are emerging as useful tools to increase our understanding of public health. This paper discusses poststructuralism within the context of a metaphoric ‘evolutionary ecology’ of knowledge (an epistemecology). It argues that claims for the importance of any programs (such as poststructuralism) are problematic. Using evolutionary and ecological metaphors, it suggests that public health may benefit from its advocates fostering the recombination of elements of knowledge to produce epistemes which adapt us congruently to the general and specific goals of public health, which should include a primary aim of minimising suffering. Choosing to act in an ethical way in regard to our construction and use of knowledge may be one way of achieving those aims. The term ‘ethical fitness’ is a way of conceptualising an evolving epistemic ethic.     

‘Quality is job 1’– new directions for medical risk management

With the advent of managed care, the determination of who is a successful healthcare provider often depends on the selection process used by the managers of employee health plans and their managed care plans. Employee satisfaction and cost containment are factors relied on in selecting healthcare providers. This article discusses the risk management professional's increasingly important role in assisting healthcare providers in meeting the requirements of these third‐party decision makers.     

‘Fat girls’ and ‘big guys’: gendered meanings of weight loss surgery

Over 80% of weight loss surgery (WLS) patients are women, yet gender is overwhelmingly absent in WLS research. This article discusses the findings of 54 interviews with twenty‐one women and six men waiting for WLS in Newfoundland and Labrador, Canada. We critically examine the ways that gender shapes the meaning of WLS in these narratives. We explore gendered meanings in participants’ perspectives on their embodied experiences before surgery, social support as they decided to undergo the procedure, and their expectations for their lives after WLS. We draw on feminist theory to explain how these findings counter the dominant gender‐neutral medical model of obesity.