Influence of core suture purchase length on strength of four-strand tendon repairs

PURPOSE: Recently the length of core suture purchase has been identified as a variable affecting the strength of tendon repairs. The influence of the length of the core suture purchase on the strength of multistrand locking and grasping suture repairs, however, has not been studied extensively in transversely lacerated tendons. We assessed the effects of the length of the core suture purchase on the strength of three 4-strand grasping or locking repair techniques. METHODS: Seventy-four fresh adult pig flexor tendons were cut transversely and repaired with 1 of 3 methods: double-modified Kessler, locking cruciate, and modified Savage. Each method was assessed using 2 different lengths of core suture purchase (1.0 and 0.4 cm). The tendons were subjected to a linear noncyclic load-to-failure test in a tensile testing machine. We recorded the forces required for gap formation, ultimate strength, stiffness of the tendon, and the mode of repair failure. RESULTS: The resistance to gap formation, the ultimate strength of all 3 repairs, and the stiffness of the tendons with the double-modified Kessler and modified Savage repairs decreased significantly as the length of core sutures decreased from 1.0 to 0.4 cm. Locking and grasping repairs had a similar decrease in strength when the purchase was decreased from 1.0 to 0.4 cm. All tendons with modified Savage repairs with 1.0-cm purchase failed by suture breakage and tendons with 0.4-cm purchase failed predominantly by pullout. CONCLUSIONS: The length of core suture purchase significantly affects the strength of these 4-strand tendon repairs. The forces required for gap formation and the ultimate failure of repairs with 0.4-cm purchase were 20% to 45% lower than those of the repairs with 1.0-cm purchase. Locking repairs did not show a greater capacity to offset the decrease in strength than grasping repairs when the length of core suture purchase was decreased from 1.0 to 0.4 cm. Our study indicates that the length of suture purchase directly influences the strength of both locking and grasping core tendon repair methods.     

Does Strand Configuration and Number of Purchase Points Affect the Biomechanical Behavior of a Tendon Repair? A Biomechanical Evaluation Using Different Kessler Methods of Flexor Tendon Repair

This study compares the mechanical properties of modified Kessler and double-modified Kessler flexor tendon repair techniques and evaluates simple modifications on both methods. Forty fresh sheep flexor tendons were divided equally into four groups. A transverse sharp cut was done in the middle of each tendon and then repaired with modified Kessler technique, modified Kessler with additional purchase point in the midpoint of each longitudinal strand, double-modified Kessler technique, or a combination of outer Kessler and inner cruciate configuration based on double-modified Kessler technique. The tendons were tested in a tensile testing machine to assess the mechanical performance of the repairs. Outcome measures included gap formation and ultimate forces. The gap strengths of the double-modified Kessler technique (30.85 N, SD 1.90) and double-modified Kessler technique with inner cruciate configuration (33.60 N, SD 4.64) were statistically significantly greater than that of the two-strand modified Kessler (22.56 N, SD 3.44) and modified Kessler with additional purchase configuration (21.75 N, SD 4.03; Tukey honestly significant difference test, P < 0.000). There were statistically significant differences in failure strengths of the all groups (analysis of variance, P < 0.000). With an identical number of strands, the gap formation and ultimate forces of the repairs were not changed by additional locking purchase point in modified Kessler repair or changing the inner strand configuration in double-modified Kessler repair. The results of this study show that the number of strands across the repair site together with the number of locking loops clearly affects the strength of the repair; meanwhile, the longitudinal strand orientation and number of purchase points in a single loop did not affect its strength.     

卡锁环肌腱缝合法在伸指肌腱修复中的作用

目的：以改良Kessler法作为参照，研究卡锁环缝合法在修复伸指肌健中的抗拉力作用效果。方法：术中随机对50根断裂伸指肌腱平均分为两组，分别采用卡锁环（Locking loop）法和改良Kessler法进行修复，然后进行屈指活动抗拉力测试观察。结果：两组肌腱出现拉松和缝线拉脱的例数分别为：卡锁环法组2，0，改良Kessler组7，5。结论：卡销环法抗拉力作用显，适合于伸指肌腱的修复。     

Locking repairs for obliquely cut tendons: Effects of suture purchase and directions of locking circles

PURPOSE: Oblique cuts in tendons weaken conventional repairs but locking sutures improve the repair strength of the tendon. In this study we assessed how suture purchase and direction (or type) of locking sutures affect the repair strength. METHODS: Ninety-three fresh pig flexor tendons were transected obliquely (45 degrees to the long axis of the tendon) and repaired with either a locking Kessler repair (with perpendicular or horizontal locking circles) or a locking cruciate method (with oblique locking or perpendicular locking circles). The suture purchase in the short side of the tendon stump with a perpendicular locking Kessler repair ranged from 0.3 to 1.2 cm. The gap formation and ultimate strength were measured to compare the biomechanical performance for each repair. RESULTS: The repair strength increased significantly as the suture purchase increased from 0.3 to 1.0 cm in oblique tendon lacerations, with a suture span of 1.0 cm being the strongest. The strength decreased significantly when the span was 1.2 cm. The repairs with horizontal locking sutures were significantly weaker than those with perpendicular locking sutures. The locking cruciate repair with the perpendicular locking circles had strength identical to that of the cruciate with oblique locking circles. CONCLUSIONS: Both suture purchase and the direction of locking circles affect the repair strength remarkably. For locking repairs the suture purchase of 1.0 cm in an obliquely cut tendon produced the highest strength; the repairs with a purchase less than 0.4 cm had significantly reduced strength. The strength of the repairs with locking circles perpendicular to the long axis of the tendon was significantly greater than that of the repairs with locking circles parallel to the long axis of the tendon.     

Gliding characteristics and gap formation for locking and grasping tendon repairs: a biomechanical study in a human cadaver model

PURPOSE: The purpose of this study was to compare the frictional characteristics and mechanical properties of various locking and grasping suture techniques in a human in vitro model of flexor tendon repair. METHODS: Forty-five cadaveric human flexor digitorum profundus tendons were transected in zone II and repaired using 1 of 5 core suture methods (n = 9 per group): either grasping (modified grasping Kessler, modified Lee) or locking (Pennington, modified Pennington, locking Lee) loop suture techniques. All repairs used 4-0 Supramid looped core suture and an epitenon running suture of 6-0 nylon. Gliding resistance at the tendon-pulley interface was measured along with failure strength and gap formation. The force to produce 0.5-, 1.0-, 1.5-, and 2.0-mm gaps were measured. RESULTS: One of the locking repairs, the locking Lee, had a gliding resistance significantly higher than that of one of the grasping repairs (modified grasping Kessler) and the other 2 locking repairs (Pennington, modified Pennington) (p <.05). There was no significant difference between the other grasping (modified Kessler, modified Lee) and locking (Pennington, modified Pennington) suture configurations (p =.21). The maximum force of one of the locking repairs, the modified Pennington repair (48.0 N; standard deviation, 3.9) was significantly higher than the other locking and grasping repairs (p <.05). The force required to produce more than 1.5 mm of gap for the modified Pennington repair was also significantly higher than that for some of the other grasping (modified Kessler, modified Lee) and locking (Pennington) repairs (p <.05). CONCLUSIONS: The lack of significant difference in gliding resistance among the similarly designed modified grasping Kessler, Pennington, and modified Pennington repairs (overall mean, 0.87 N; standard deviation, 0.16) suggests that the locking loop configuration itself does not adversely affect tendon gliding resistance. The modified Pennington repair increased not only ultimate strength but also resistance to gap formation more than 1.5 mm.     

The effect of locking loops on the strength of tendon repair

A multiple X-raying method has been developed which allows examination of how the particular features of suturing techniques collapse or pull out of the tendon during tensile testing. This technique was used to examine the locking loop tendon sutures, such as the modified Kessler, Verdan and Ketchum techniques. Locking loops did not contribute towards the strength when small diameter sutures (5/0) of various materials were applied to the tendon, collapsing at 12 Newtons. Larger diameter sutures (4/0) slightly reduced the risk of failure of locking loops, but they still collapsed at 15 Newtons or less, so suture techniques which depend on locking loops will often lead to gap formation at low loads and hence poor results.     

四种与Kessler相关的屈肌腱缝合方法的生物力学研究

目的 研究四种与Kessler相关的屈肌腱缝合方法 对肌腱修复抗张强度的影响.方法 采用新鲜猪后肢跖深屈肌腱,将40根肌腱分为4组,每组10根,横行切断,以Kessler法、DoubleKessler法、Running suture法、Kessler+Running suture法缝合.检测缝合后肌腱2mm间隙形成的负荷、最大抗张强度,采用ANOVA法进行统计分析.结果 对于肌腱的横断伤,最大抗张强度DoubleKessler法Kessler+Running suture法Kessler法Running suture法. 2mm间隙形成的负荷Kessler+Running suture法Double Kessler法Rumming suture法Kessler法.结论 肌腱横行损伤修复时,采用强生3-0编织缝合线,Kessler+Running suture法能够满足临床早期功能锻炼的强度要求.     

Comparison of the holding capacity of round monofilament, round multifilament, and flat multifilament nitinol suture loops in human cadaveric flexor tendon

Tendon repairs done with strong suture materials fail by suture pull out. To avoid pull out, suture loop needs to have a strong grip on the tendon. The aim of this study was to determine whether a single suture loop has a better grip of the tendon when multifilament or flat sutures are used compared with a conventional monofilament round suture. A cross-locking or simple grasping suture loop was placed into the distal end of a human cadaveric tendon using nitinol wire sutures in the following configurations: round monofilament (200 μm), round multifilament (4 × 100 μm), and flat multifilament (4 × 30 μm × 445 μm). The mean pull-out strength of the round multifilament (49.4 N) and flat multifilament sutures (50.7 N) were significantly higher than that of the round monofilament nitinol suture (36.5 N) when a locking loop was used. Suture grip can be improved by using a multifilament suture and a locking type of suture configuration.     

Effect of suture size on locking and grasping flexor tendon repair techniques

An experimental study was performed using human cadaver flexor tendons to investigate the effect of locking and grasping loop techniques on the tensile properties of repaired flexor tendons, which closely resemble the clinical model. Statistically significant improvement was observed only with the locking loop technique for ultimate and gap strength values using 2-0 core suture and ultimate strength values using 3-0 core suture. There was no statistically significant increase in tensile strength values using 4-0 core suture material. A heavier core suture used with the locking loop technique provided greater ultimate and gap strength of a repaired tendon than when used with the grasping loop technique.     

Biomechanic comparison of the Teno Fix tendon repair device with the cruciate and modified Kessler techniques

PURPOSE: To compare the mechanical behavior of a novel internal tendon repair device with commonly used 2-strand and 4-strand repair techniques for zone II flexor tendon lacerations. METHODS: Thirty cadaveric flexor digitorum profundus tendons were randomized to 1 of 3 core sutures: (1) cruciate locked 4-strand technique, (2) modified Kessler 2-strand core suture technique, or (3) Teno Fix multifilament wire tendon repair device. Each repair was tested in the load control setting on a Instron controller coupled to an MTS materials testing machine load frame by using an incremental cyclic linear loading protocol. A differential variable reluctance transducer was used to record displacement across the repair site. Cyclic force (n-cycles) to 1-mm gap and repair failure was recorded using serial digital photography. RESULTS: There was no significant difference in differential variable reluctance transducer displacement between the cruciate, modified Kessler, and Teno Fix repairs. The cruciate repair had greater resistance to visual 1-mm repair-site gap formation and repair-site failure when compared with the Kessler and Teno Fix repairs. No significant difference was found between the modified Kessler repair and the Teno Fix repair. In all specimens, the epitenon suture failed before the core suture. Repair failure occurred by suture rupture in the 7 cruciate specimens that failed, with evidence of gap formation before failure. Seven of 10 modified Kessler repairs failed by suture rupture. All of the Teno Fix repairs failed by pullout of the metal anchor. CONCLUSIONS: The Teno Fix repair system did not confer a mechanical advantage over the locked cruciate or modified Kessler suture techniques for zone II lacerations in cadaveric flexor tendons during cyclic loading in a linear testing model. This information may help to define safe boundaries for postoperative rehabilitation when using this internal tendon repair device.     

Biomechanical testing of epitenon suture strength in Achilles tendon repairs

BACKGROUND: Recent evidence that early, active mobilization protocols after Achilles tendon repairs increase recovery speed and strength make operative repair strength critical to positive outcomes after Achilles tendon ruptures. While previous research has focused on core (tendon proper) repair techniques, no previous literature has reported testing of core repairs augmented with epitenon sutures, which have been shown to increase the strength of repairs of flexor tendons of the hand. METHODS: Five matched pairs of fresh frozen human Achilles tendons were tested with and without the addition of an epitenon suture to the core repair suture. All specimens were repaired using a No. 2 Ethibond Krakow locking loop core suture. The epitenon suture was added to one tendon randomly chosen from each pair, using a 4-0 nylon suture. All specimens were mounted on an MTS testing machine (MTS Systems Corp., Eden Prairie, MN) and loaded to failure, which was defined as a 1-cm gap formation. RESULTS: The addition of epitenon sutures significantly increased the force necessary to produce a 2-mm gap as compared to core sutures alone by 74%, and it increased the average load to failure by 119%. Also, initial tendon stiffness was 173% greater in tendons reinforced with epitenon sutures. CONCLUSIONS: This study demonstrates that greater resistance to gap formation, approximation of tissue ends, and tensile strength were achieved by the addition of an epitenon suture. Clinical relevance may improve healing by decreased gap formation at the repair site and a lower risk of adhesion formation.     

Initial pull-out strength of tendon sutures: an in vitro study in sheep Achilles tendon

Forty-eight fresh frozen sheep Achilles tendons were used to compare the pull-out strengths of Kessler, Bunnell and locking loop techniques which are the standard configurations described for Achilles tendon repair. A simulated Achilles tendon rupture was done with a tenotomy made 2 cm proximal to the calcaneal insertion. One of the configurations was placed at the distal end of the proximal portion of the tendon specimens using No. 5 Ticron. The distal ends of the suture materials were left free and were not used to connect the proximal and distal portions of the tendon. Using a servohydraulic materials testing machine, each tendon was tested to failure in tension at a displacement rate of 20 mm/min. All the specimens failed due to pull-out of the suture material. Since the cause of failure was suture material breakage in the previous studies reporting repair strength, they were unable to represent the effect of configuration on the strength. This study is the first to represent the effect of configuration on the initial strength since there is no failure due to suture material breakage.     

Biomechanical studies of running suture for flexor tendon repair in dogs

A new running-locking loop suture technique has been developed to increase tendon repair strength and to provide better tendon edge inversion. Biomechanical analysis documented the failure mechanism and the failure strength of various circumferential repair techniques. When compared with two well-known techniques, the simple circumferential running suture and Lembert running suture, the locking suture technique was shown to have 3.77 and 1.68 times greater tensile failure strength and 1.73 and 1.26 times greater stiffness than these traditional suture methods. A running peripheral locking suture may help augment the strength of tendon repair.     

Double loop locking suture: a technique of tendon repair for early active mobilization. Part I: Evolution of technique and experimental study

This article describes a technique of tendon repair and two variations using double loop locking sutures. Experimental study on human tendon specimens showed that the average tensile strength of tendon junctures was 4400 grams by double loop locking sutures and 2252 grams by Kessler's technique. The study also showed that the weakest point of the tendon juncture by double loop locking sutures was the sutures.     

A mechanical comparison of gluteus medius attachment methods in a canine model

Seven techniques of gluteus medius attachment were compared in vitro in a canine model. Four methods were used for tendon to tendon attachment: (a) two modified Bunnell-Mayer stutures, (b) two Kessler locking loop sutures, (c) two horizontal mattress sutures, and (d) two sutures with a looped suture technique. The two methods of tendon to bone attachment were repair with a 1 cm spiked staple and repair with a spiked washer and screw, and the method of bone to bone attachment involved two figure-eight cerclage wires. The colitralateral limb served as a control. Compared with the bone to bone attachment, the four tendon to tendon attachments and the two tendon to bone attachments had significantly less strength (31 and 30% of the ultimate load for bone to bone repair, respectively) and tensile stiffness (24 and 39% of the tensile stiffness for bone to bone attachment, respectively) (p ≤ 0.0001). The control specimens were significantly stronger and stiffer than all specimens (p ≤ 0.05) except those that had bone to bone fixation. There were no significant differences among the four tendon to tendon suture repairs with regard to either strength or stiffness; the values ranged from 28–45% of those of the controls. Among the tendon to bone repairs, fixation with a spiked washer and screw was significantly stronger than that with a spiked staple (p = 0.032), but there was no difference between these two techniques with regard to stiffness.     

Optimizing biomechanical performance of the 4-strand cruciate flexor tendon repair

PURPOSE: The purpose of this study was to determine whether increasing the size of the locking loop increased the repair strength of the cruciate 4-strand suture technique and to quantify the biomechanical properties that various peripheral suture techniques provide in the cruciate 4-strand suture technique. METHODS: Fifty-six deep flexor tendons harvested from adult sheep hind limbs were divided randomly into 7 groups of 8. Four groups were repaired using the cruciate core technique without a peripheral suture. The locking loops were set using 10%, 25%, 33%, or 50% of the tendon width and loaded to failure using a distraction rate of 20 mm/min. The 3 groups of tendons then were repaired by using the established optimal locking loop size. These 3 groups were combined with a simple running, cross-stitch, or the interlocking horizontal mattress (IHM) peripheral suture. Repairs were tested to failure and the load at a 2-mm gap, load at failure, and stiffness were determined for all samples. RESULTS: Repairs with locking loops of 25% had the greatest biomechanical properties with load to 2-mm gap formation, load to failure, and stiffness of 10 N, 46.3 N, and 3.9 N/mm, respectively. Those with 33%, 50%, and 10% locking loops followed. Repairs with 10% locking loops failed owing to the suture cut out of the tendon. All other groups failed because of suture breakage. By using the cruciate core technique with a 25% locking loop the IHM/cruciate combination was markedly better than both the cross-stitch/cruciate and simple running/cruciate combinations. CONCLUSIONS: The ideal-sized bite of the locking loops for the cruciate repair is 25% of the tendon's width. Peripheral sutures are vital to the biomechanical properties of the repair. The IHM peripheral suture technique provided the greatest improvement in biomechanical properties.     

Effects of direction of tendon lacerations on strength of tendon repairs

PURPOSE: We compared the tensile strength of different repair configurations on tendons with oblique and transverse lacerations. METHOD: Seventy-two fresh pig flexor tendons were divided randomly and repaired using the modified Kessler, the cruciate, or the 4-strand Massachusetts General Hospital (MGH) repair methods. The tendons were lacerated either transversely or obliquely. They were repaired with conventional and oblique suture repairs. The 2-mm gap formation force and ultimate strength were determined as biomechanical performance for each repair. RESULTS: The gap formation and ultimate strength of the tendons vary with orientations of tendon lacerations and suture methods. In the tendons repaired with the modified Kessler or the cruciate methods, the 2-mm gap formation and ultimate strength of obliquely cut tendons were significantly lower than those of transversely cut tendons. The obliquely placed modified Kessler or cruciate sutures significantly improved the repair strength in the tendons with an oblique laceration. In the tendons repaired with the MGH method, no statistical differences were found in the repair strength of obliquely and transversely lacerated tendons. CONCLUSIONS: The direction of tendon lacerations affects strength of certain repair configurations. The nonlocking modified Kessler or the cruciate tendon repairs are weakened considerably when the tendon laceration is oblique but their mechanical performance is strengthened by re-orienting the repair strands to lie parallel to the laceration. The cross-locked configuration of the MGH repair is not affected by the obliquity of the tendon laceration.     

Characterization of the tensile properties and histologic/biochemical changes in normal chicken tendon at the site of suture insertion

The hypothesis of this study is that inserting a grasping suture into tendon tissue causes adverse changes at the suture-to-tendon interface and thus compromises the outcome of tendon repair. This study characterized the histologic, biomechanical, and biochemical effects that 2 types of grasping sutures, Kessler and Savage, produced on normal chicken flexor tendon in the digital flexor sheath. Variables caused by a healing response were avoided by not cutting the tendon. Findings included a reduction in ultimate tensile strength beginning soon after the suture was inserted, cell proliferation, lysis of types I and III collagen by collagenase, and presence of gelatinase. No histologic or biochemical differences were detected between the 2 suture patterns. These findings are presumed to be adverse and suggest an additional reason why the ultimate tensile strength of repaired tendon may be too low to allow patients to move tendons actively without a high risk for causing gap formation or rupture in the early weeks of healing.     

A biomechanical study of Tang's multiple locking techniques for flexor tendon repair

This study was designed to biomechanically compare Tang's multiple looped locking techniques with various suture techniques for flexor tendon repair in the hand. Fifty flexor digitorum profondus tendons taken from pig toes were used as models; The tendons were transected in the middle part of zone 2 defined as the area beneath bifurcation of the flexor digitorum superficialis tendons, and were repaired by five different suture methods: (1) modified Kessler, (2) Tsuge's suture, (3) double Kessler, (4) modified Kessler plus Tsuge, and (5) Tang's suture. The repaired tendons were placed in an Instron tensile testing machine to determine the tensile properties of the repair. 2 mm gap formation force and ultimate tensile strength were measured during the test. Maximal work to failure were calculated according to area under the load-displacement curve of the test. 2 mm gap formation force was 21.5 N for the Kessler, 20.6 N for the Tsuge, 31.6 N for double Kessler, 30.9 N for the Kessler plus Tsuge and 41.4 N for the Tang. Ultimate tensile strength was 23.5 N for the Kessler, 22.9 N for the Tsuge, 34.5 N for the Kessler plus Tsuge and 45.6 N for the Tang. Statistically, Tang's suture had the greatest gap formation force, ultimate strength and energy for failure among the five techniques (p < 0.01 or p < 0.001). Gap formation force, ultimate strength and energy to failure for double Kessler or the Kessler plus Tsuge were significantly greater than those for the Kessler or the Tsuge (p < 0.05 or < 0.01). The tendons repaired by Tang's method tolerated a significantly higher tensile load (133 to 198% of the other techniques) than the other methods. Among the methods tested, Tang's multiple looped locking suture provides sufficient gap resistance and tensile strength that may be able to withstand early active mobilization after primary flexor tendon repair.     

Biomechanical comparison of double grasping repair versus cross-locked cruciate flexor tendon repair

Purpose

This study was conducted to compare the in vitro biomechanical properties of tensile strength and gap resistance of a double grasping loop (DGL) flexor tendon repair with the established four-strand cross-locked cruciate (CLC) flexor tendon repair, both with an interlocking horizontal mattress (IHM) epitendinous suture. The hypothesis is that the DGL-IHM method which utilizes two looped core sutures, grasping and locking loops, and a single intralesional knot will have greater strength and increased gap resistance than the CLC-IHM method.

Methods

Forty porcine tendons were evenly assigned to either the DGL-IHM or CLC-IHM group. The tendon repair strength, 2-mm gap force and load to failure, was measured under a constant rate of distraction. The stiffness of tendon repair was calculated and the method of repair failure was analyzed.

Results

The CLC-IHM group exhibited a statistically significant greater resistance to gapping, a statistically significant higher load to 2-mm gapping (62.0 N), and load to failure (99.7 N) than the DGL-IHM group (37.1 N and 75.1 N, respectively). Ninety percent of CLC-IHM failures were a result of knot failure whereas 30 % of the DGL-IHM group exhibited knot failure.

Conclusions

This study demonstrates that the CLC-IHM flexor tendon repair method better resists gapping and has a greater tensile strength compared to the experimental DGL-IHM method. The authors believe that while the DGL-IHM provides double the number of sutures at the repair site per needle pass, this configuration does not adequately secure the loop suture to the tendon, resulting in a high percentage of suture pullout and inability to tolerate loads as high as those of the CLC-IHM group.