Clinical screening score for the fragile X (Martin-Bell) syndrome

A clinical score based on the manifestations of the fragile(X) syndrome has been formulated and applied to all individuals included in a fragile(X) case finding program in New South Wales. The total score can vary from 0 to 10. Individuals are scored 0, 1, or 2 in each of 5 categories considered indicative of the fragile(X) phenotype: family history of intellectual handicap, face length, ear configuration, personality, and body habitus. In a study of 1,206 individuals where the clinical scores were prospective (i.e., they had been given before the cytogenetic results were known) the percentage of those with the fragile(X) increased from 0.6% of those with scores of 4 or less to 14.6% with scores 5-7 and to 67% of those with scores 8-10. We have found the score simple to use in the circumstances where screening takes place (sheltered workshops and schools) and have reduced the number of individuals tested cytogenetically by 45%.     

Multivariate analysis of body shape in fragile X (Martin-Bell) syndrome

Human body shape measures can be more informative in studies of developmental abnormalities than distances between body landmarks. Such measures were obtained by an appropriate transformation of 34 distances between trunk/limbs and head/face landmarks in 43 men and 72 women with the Martin-Bell Syndrome (MBS), and in 99 and 103 normal men and women, respectively. The transformation of the original distances was performed by adjusting individual measures for an overall size measure using regression analysis. Thus obtained body shape variables were used in discriminant analysis in order to obtain unbiased classification probabilities of individuals having the MBS or being normal. The average percent correctly classified male and female individuals was high (93 and 87, respectively). Moreover, the body shape variables were used to obtain shape dimensions by means of principal component analysis. There was no difference between the MBS and normal individuals in the first (most important) principal component (shape dimension). This component represents the relative proportions between trunk and limb lengths and widths, or between midfacial lengths and widths. However, there were appreciable differences in some succeeding components. The problem of interpretation of shape dimensions as derived from principal component analysis and of their relevance to abnormal development in the MBS individuals is discussed.     

Is there a fragile(X) negative Martin-Bell syndrome?

During the course of the preventative screening program for the fra(X) syndrome, we identified 32 men with the phenotype but who were fra(X) negative. These were reviewed and none fitted the full criteria, so we were unable to confirm the existence of the fra(X) negative Martin-Bell syndrome. The literature and 4 families previously thought to have the fra(X) negative Martin-Bell syndrome were also reviewed. We were unable to make a concrete diagnosis of the fra(X) negative Martin-Bell syndrome.     

Speech disturbances (cluttering) in mildly impaired males with the Martin-Bell/fragile X syndrome

The language characteristics of fra(X) males (n = 10) with an IQ greater than or equal to 70 were evaluated. Language testing demonstrated relatively stronger receptive vocabulary skills compared to weak auditory memory and processing skills. A characteristic speech and language disturbance, cluttering, was present in 9 of the 10 study patients. Their speech was characterized by a fast and fluctuating rate of speech, and repetitions of sounds, words or phrases. Other aspects of cluttering including attentional problems, hyperactivity, motor delays and reading difficulties are commonly seen in the fra(X) syndrome. Cluttering may be helpful in identifying the fra(X) syndrome in a male who is not retarded.     

Gonadal function in men with the Martin-Bell (fragile-X) syndrome

We evaluated testicular function in 15 men with the Martin-Bell (fragile-X) mental retardation syndrome. Macro-orchidism was present in all subjects. Their mean serum LH and FSH levels and plasma testosterone and dihydrotestosterone levels were normal. The mean plasma levels of androstenedione, 17-hydroxyprogesterone, and progesterone were slightly elevated above the normal range, whereas the plasma levels of dehydroepiandrosterone and dehydroepiandrosterone-sulfate were normal. The response in the levels of plasma testosterone following a 5 day period of hCG stimulation was normal in 8 subjects and there was no abnormal accumulation of androgen precursors. The level of 5 alpha-reductase activity and androgen receptor binding was normal in genital skin fibroblasts derived from 3 of these patients. The response of gonadotropin secretion to GnRH stimulation was normal in the 8 men who were tested. Therefore, our data are consistent with the hypothesis that testicular enlargement in men with the Martin-Bell syndrome is not mediated by hormonal factors.     

Martin-Bell syndrome in Greece,with report of another 47,XXY fragile X patient

A cytogenetic investigation was carried out among 200 mentally retarded boys in Greece for the detection of the fragile X [fra(X)] syndrome. Thirteen patients were found to carry fra(X) (6.5%). Of those, six boys had a history of familial X-linked mental retardation, two had the phenotype of the Martin-Bell syndrome, four had only mental retardation of unknown etiology, and one was a mentally retarded patient with Klinefelter syndrome. The remaining 187 boys were fra(X) negative. Our findings emphasize the importance of early identification of this syndrome in the diagnosis and prevention, through proper genetic counselling, of mental retardation.     

Crown size asymmetry in males with fra (X) or Martin-Bell syndrome

We measured the mesio-distal and bucco-lingual crown diameters of 13 males with the fra(X) or Martin-Bell syndrome. Fluctuating crown-size asymmetry was calculated and compared with values obtained in normal Caucasian children and also with a sample of 19 males with Down syndrome. A statistically significant increased asymmetry was found in the fra(X) males when compared to normal control individuals. In the maxilla, Down syndrome males showed a significantly higher tooth crown asymmetry than fra(X) males. (less than 0.02); in the mandible, no significant differences were found between the 2 groups. It is suggested that crown size asymmetry be included in the evaluation of fra(X) males.     

The fragile (X) syndrome: the mutation problem

In an attempt to understand the nature of the mutational event leading to the fra(X) syndrome, we have searched for sporadic cases in 3 populations: affected males, affected females, and non-affected transmitting females. In all 3 populations there was a dearth of isolated cases, and the reasons for this are discussed.     

Normal male carriers in the fra(X) form of X-linked mental retardation (Martin-Bell syndrome)

Evidence for the transmission of X-linked mental retardation through normal male carriers is reviewed in 6 kindreds. In these pedigrees we identified 15 unaffected males who likely had passed the gene on through their daughters. Fifty-one mentally retarded grandsons or great grandsons descended from these male carriers. In total, these males had 50 daughters with only 2 of them being of low intelligence. Two of the male carriers were recently identified through fra(X)- positive results in their mentally normal daughters. Among the sibs of these males, mentally retarded brothers were found in 3 families. This was unexpected since earlier observations suggested that the risk for mental retardation among sibs of nonmanifesting carriers is exceedingly low.     

The predictive value of dermatoglyphic anomalies in the diagnosis of fra(X)-positive Martin-Bell syndrome (MBS)

In a representative group of 160 institutionalized mentally retarded males without Down syndrome, prospective dermatoglyphic-cytogenetic studies were performed in order to assess the utility of the dermatoglyphic index system of Rodewald [1986] for an efficient ascertainment of patients with Martin-Bell syndrome (MBS). A negative (abnormal) score was found in 32 men (20 +/- 3%), 14 of whom (predictive value: 44 +/- 9%) were fra(X)-positive. This prevalence of 14/160 = 9 +/- 2% patients with fra(X)-positive MBS indicates that in our study most, if not all, MBS patients have been detected by the simple pre-screening of dermatoglyphics. In the MBS patients, there was no correlation between the dermatoglyphic scores and percentage of fra(X)-positive cells.     

Dilemmas in counselling females with the fragile X syndrome

The dilemmas in counselling a mildly retarded female with the fragile X syndrome and her retarded partner are presented. The fragile X syndrome is an X linked mental retardation disorder that affects males and, often less severely, females. Affected females have an increased risk of having affected offspring. The counselling of this couple was complicated by their impaired comprehension which subsequently impaired their thinking on the different options. The woman became pregnant and underwent CVS, which showed an affected male fetus. The pregnancy was terminated. Whether nondirective counselling for this couple was the appropriate method is discussed and the importance of a system oriented approach, through involving relatives, is stressed.     

Female relatives in families with the fragile X syndrome

Three problems--mental retardation, having retarded children, and fear of having retarded children--are described in women in families with the fragile X syndrome. The investigation of one family with a counselling dilemma is presented in detail.     

Survey of the fragile X syndrome and the fragile X E syndrome in a special education needs population

To begin to understand the population dynamics of the fragile X (FRAXA) mutation and to learn more about the fragile X E (FRAXE) syndrome, we have initiated a survey of children in special needs education programs in the public school system. With respect to the FRAXA syndrome, we found approximately 1/1,000 full mutations among males. No large alleles at the FRAXE locus were observed among 462 individuals. The allele distributions at the two loci among Caucasians and among African Americans were examined as well as the level of heterozygosity. We found a significant difference in the FRAXA allele distribution among the two ethnic groups; the major difference was due to the lack of smaller alleles among the African Americans. No difference was found for the FRAXE allele distribution among the two groups. The level of heterozygosity was less than predicted by the allele distribution at both loci. This is probably due to unidentified large alleles among females with a test result of a single band. Alternatively, this excess may indicate that the population is not at equilibrium. © 1996 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Problem behavior in boys with fragile X syndrome

This study examines problem behavior over time in 59 boys with fragile X syndrome (FXS), aged 4-12 years, using the Child Behavior Checklist (CBCL). Approximately 49% of the boys scored within the borderline or clinical range on total problem behavior, while 56-57% scored in the borderline or clinical range on the attention and thought problems subscales, and 26% scored in this range on the social problems subscale. With a mean of 2.5 assessments per child, behavior problems were stable during the 3-year period of study. Total problem behavior was higher for children who displayed autistic behavior, were rated as low in adaptability, had mothers with higher maternal education levels, and were on medication. Mothers with more education also rated their children as having more attention, thought, and total problems. Children taking medication differed from boys who were not taking medication on social problems, but not on attention and thought problems. Low adaptability and more autistic characteristics predicted thought problems.     

Reverse mutations in the fragile X syndrome

Three females were identified who have apparent reversal of fragile X premutations. Based on haplotype analysis of nearby markers, they were found to have inherited a fragile X chromosome from their premutation carrier mothers, and yet had normal size FMR1 repeat alleles. The changes in repeat sizes from mother to daughter was 95 to 35 in the first, 145 to 43 in the second, and 82 to 33 in the third. In the first family, mutations of the nearby microsatellites FRAXAC2 and DXS548 were also observed. In the other two, only mutations involving the FMR1 repeats were found. We suggest differing mutational mechanisms such as gene conversion versus DNA replication slippage may underlie such reversions. We estimate that such revertants may occur among 1% or less of premutation carrier offspring. Our results indicate that women identified to be carriers by linkage should be retested by direct DNA analysis. © 1996 Wiley-Liss, Inc.