Standard sonography and arthrosonography in the study of rotator cuff tears

PURPOSE: The aim of this study was to evaluate the sensitivity of ultrasonography, integrating standard ultrasound and arthrosonography after injecting a saline solution into the glenohumeral cavity in cases of suspected rotator cuff tears. MATERIALS AND METHODS: We prospectively examined 40 patients awaiting shoulder arthroscopy for suspected or diagnosed tears of the rotator cuff. A radiologist, unaware of the pre-operative diagnosis, performed an ultrasound scan on all the patients before and after the injection of saline solution into the glenohumeral cavity. The parameters considered were presence or absence of a rotator cuff injury; type of injury according to Snyder and its extent along the longitudinal and transverse planes; presence or absence of effusion into the articular cavity; subacromial/subdeltoid bursal distension. All the patients underwent arthroscopy either the same day or the day after the ultrasound examination. RESULTS: Standard sonography showed 26 complete rotator cuff tears (type C according to Snyder), 2 partial tears (type B according to Snyder) and 12 intact rotator cuffs.Arthrosonography detected 31 complete rotator cuff tears (type C according to Snyder), 1 partial tear (type B according to Snyder) and 8 intact rotator cuffs.Arthroscopy identified 32 complete rotator cuff tears (type C according to Snyder), 1 partial tear (type B according to Snyder) and 8 intact rotator cuffs.Analysis of the results shows that, taking arthroscopy as the gold standard, the sensitivity of normal sonography is 81.2%, whereas that of arthrosonography is 96.8% (p < 0.05). CONCLUSIONS: On the basis of the data obtained in this study, standard sonography, integrated with the injection of a saline solution into the glenohumeral cavity, considerably increases the diagnostic sensitivity for rotator cuff tears. The authors suggest that arthrosonography can be used in the event of suspected rotator cuff tears, when MRI is contraindicated.     

Rotator cuff tears in asymptomatic individuals: a clinical and ultrasonographic screening study

OBJECTIVE: To determine the prevalence and clinical impact of rotator cuff tears in asymptomatic volunteers. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Sonographic examinations of the shoulder of 212 asymptomatic individuals between 18 and 85 years old were performed by a single experienced operator. The prevalence and location of complete rotator cuff tears were evaluated. The clinical assessment was based on the Constant Score. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) of the shoulder was obtained in those patients where US showed rotator cuff pathology. RESULTS: Ultrasound showed a complete rupture of the supraspinatus tendon in 6% of 212 patients from 56 to 83 years of age (mean: 67 years). MRI confirmed a complete rupture of the supraspinatus tendon in 90%. All patients reported no functional deficits, although strength was significantly lower in the patient group with complete supraspinatus tendon tear (P < 0.01). CONCLUSION: There is a higher prevalence in older individuals of rotator cuff tendon tears that cause no pain or decrease in activities of daily living.     

Ultrasonography in lesions of the rotator cuff and biceps tendon

Ultrasonography (US) of the shoulder joint was performed in 88 patients, 15 of whom were referred for surgery. US was made with a real-time linear-array scanner, provided with a transducer of 7.5 MHz. Subsequently, all patients underwent single-contrast arthrography of the shoulder. When compared with the arthrographic findings, diagnosis by US showed 21 true positive, 3 false positive, 57 true negative and 7 false negative cases of a full-thickness tear of the rotator cuff. Small tears (2 cm or less in diameter) may be the most difficult to assess. US readily revealed biceps tendinitis and rupture of the biceps tendon, as well as fluid collection in the bursae above the rotator cuff tendons.     

Supraspinatus tendon tears: comparison of US and MR arthrography with surgical correlation

The aim of this study was to compare the diagnostic reliability of US with MR arthrography in diagnosing supraspinatus tendon tears. Surgical findings were used as the gold standard in detecting tears. A total of 44 patients were assessed with transverse and longitudinal US scans with respect to the long axis of the rotator cuff tendons and then examined with MR arthrography. This technique involved free-hand injection of contrast medium into the shoulder joint. At surgery 20 incomplete and 24 complete tears were observed. Ultrasound offered good results for the large tears, but its sensitivity decreased proportionally with the size of the tears. Magnetic resonance arthrography correctly diagnosed 43 tears, whereas only one false-negative diagnosis of tendinosis was made for a partial tear on the bursal side. Since it improves the diagnosis of small tears, MR arthrography must be performed on all patients for whom surgical repair is necessary in order to restore normal functions.     

The effectiveness of diagnostic imaging methods for the assessment of soft tissue and articular disorders of the shoulder and elbow

There are no clear guidelines for diagnostic imaging of articular and soft tissue pathologies of the shoulder and elbow. Several methods are used, including magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), magnetic resonance arthrography (MRA) and ultrasound (US). Their cost-effectiveness is still unclear. We performed a meta-analysis of the relevant literature and discussed the role of MR imaging of the shoulder and elbow compared with other diagnostic imaging modalities. For the shoulder impingement syndrome and rotator cuff tears, MRI and US have a comparable accuracy for detection of full-thickness rotator cuff tears. MRA and US might be more accurate for the detection of partial-thickness tears than MRI. Given the large difference in cost of MR and US, ultrasound may be the most cost-effective diagnostic method for identification of full-thickness tears in a specialist hospital setting (Evidence level 3). Both MRA and CT arthrography (CTA) are effective methods for the detection of labrum tears. More recently, multidetector CTA has offered the advantages of thinner slices than with MRA in a shorter examination time. Still, MRA has the advantage towards CTA to directly visualize the affected structures with a better evaluation of extent and location and to detect associated capsuloligamentous injuries. For the elbow pathologies, plain MRI or MRA have the advantage towards CTA to detect occult bone injuries. CTA is better for the assessment of the thin cartilage of the elbow. Both US and MRI are reliable methods to detect chronic epicondylitis; US is more available and far more cost-effective (Evidence level 2). MRA can differentiate complete from partial tears of the medial collateral ligament. US or MRI can detect partial and complete biceps tendon tears and/or bursitis. MRI can provide important diagnostic information in lesions of the ulnar, radial, or median nerve.     

MRI and sonography of the shoulder

We prospectively evaluated the diagnostic value of sonography and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) in 24 shoulders in 23 patients with suspected rotator cuff tears using arthrography as gold standard. Sonography demonstrated 14 of 15, MRI 10 of 15 rotator cuff tears, respectively. Sonography diagnosed seven of nine intact rotator cuffs correctly, MRI eight of nine. In a retrospective study we reviewed the diagnostic value of sonography and MRI in other pathologies of the shoulder including intra-articular pathology, humeral head and acromioclavicular joint pathology, and calcification. We conclude that with regard to cost and patient compliance, sonography should be the first radiologic examination in suspected rotator cuff tears if performed by an experienced sonographer. MRI is superior in depicting additional pathology and is less operator dependent. It may thus become the method of choice for the evaluation of the rotator cuff and related pathology in the future.     

Peribursal fat plane of the shoulder: anatomic study and clinical experience

A comprehensive anatomic and radiographic analysis of the peribursal fat plane in 12 cadavers confirmed that the fat plane seen on radiographs represents extrasynovial fat lining the subacromial bursa and documented the anatomic relations of the bursa. A three-part retrospective clinical evaluation of rotator cuff tears, calcific tendinitis, and rheumatoid arthritis was performed. Two osteoradiologists blindly graded the appearance of the peribursal fat plane with the shoulder in external versus internal rotation in 21 patients with arthrographically intact rotator cuffs and 21 patients with disrupted rotator cuffs. The peribursal fat plane was seen better with disrupted rotator cuffs. The peribursal fat plane was seen better with the shoulder in internal rotation and was seen in 60% of control subjects but only 21% of patients with rotator cuff tears. Partial or complete obliteration of this fat plane is a sensitive (79%) but less specific (60%) indicator of rotator cuff tears. Obliteration of the peribursal fat plane by inflammatory processes in adjacent tissues, including calcific tendinitis and rheumatoid arthritis, occurred with a high frequency.     

Rotator cuff disorders: How to write a surgically relevant magnetic resonance imaging report?

Evaluation of rotator cuff is a common indication for magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scanning of the shoulder. Conventional MRI is the most commonly used technique, while magnetic resonance (MR) arthrography is reserved for certain cases. Rotator cuff disorders are thought to be caused by a combination of internal and external mechanisms. A well-structured MRI report should comment on the relevant anatomic structures including the acromial type and orientation, the presence of os acromiale, acromio-clavicular degenerative spurs and fluid in the subacromial subdeltoid bursa. In addition, specific injuries of the rotator cuff tendons and the condition of the long head of biceps should be accurately reported. The size and extent of tendon tears, tendon retraction and fatty degeneration or atrophy of the muscles are all essential components of a surgically relevant MRI report.     

Rotator cuff tears: prospective comparison of MR imaging with arthrography, sonography, and surgery

Thirty-eight patients with suspected rotator cuff tears were examined at 1.5 T by using a loop-gap resonator surface coil. The MR findings were compared prospectively in a blinded fashion with the results from double-contrast arthrography in all 38 patients, high-resolution sonography in 23 patients, and surgery in 16 patients. In the total group of 38 patients, MR imaging detected 22 of 22 tears and 14 of 16 intact cuffs as determined by arthrography. In the 16 surgically proved cases, MR and arthrography showed identical results, with 92% sensitivity in the diagnosis of 12 tears and 100% specificity in the diagnosis of four intact cuffs. In a subgroup of 23 patients, sonography detected nine of 15 tears and seven of eight intact cuffs as determined by comparison with arthrography. In 10 surgically proved cases, sonography was 63% sensitive in the diagnosis of eight rotator cuff tears and 50% specific in the diagnosis of two intact cuffs. For the diagnosis of rotator cuff tears, MR imaging is comparable to arthrography in both sensitivity and specificity. In this study, sonography was not as accurate in the diagnosis of rotator cuff tears as were the other two techniques. These results suggest that MR imaging should be considered the noninvasive test of choice for patients with suspected rotator cuff disease.     

Sonography of the Shoulder

A great amount of work in musculoskeletal sonography has focused on evaluation of the shoulder and rotator cuff. This is primarily due to the fact that the shoulder is a common site of symptomatology and clinical evaluation is difficult. Even though sonography of the rotator cuff is more difficult than other large tendons, there has been constant incentive to develop and refine shoulder sonography. In the past five years there have been dramatic improvements in high resolution transducers, as well as advances in our understanding of the technique of shoulder sonography and more widespread agreement of the findings seen with rotator cuff tears. All of these factors have contributed to making the exam easier to perform and interpret than in the past. Ultrasound has now evolved into a mature modality for evaluating rotator cuff tears with expected sensitivities of better than 90%.     

Shoulder after rotator cuff repair: MR imaging findings in asymptomatic individuals--initial experience

PURPOSE: To assess the magnetic resonance (MR) imaging appearance of the successfully repaired rotator cuff in an asymptomatic population. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Fifteen subjects who had undergone clinically successful rotator cuff repair were included in the study. All underwent functional testing of the affected shoulder and had good to excellent scores on the Constant scale. Standard MR imaging sequences were performed at 1.5 T, including oblique coronal fast spin-echo T2-weighted MR imaging with fat saturation. RESULTS: Three (10%) of 30 supraspinatus and infraspinatus tendons had normal signal intensity, and 16 (53%) had mildly increased signal intensity on fast spin-echo T2-weighted fat-saturated images, compatible with tendonitis or tendinosis. Three partial and four complete tears of the supraspinatus tendon and two partial and two complete tears of the infraspinatus tendon were seen. Other findings included subacromial-subdeltoid effusion (10 subjects), joint effusions (five subjects), and bone marrow edema (six subjects). CONCLUSION: Postoperative signal intensity changes consistent with tendonitis or tendinosis were common, and clinically "silent" partial and complete rotator cuff tears were seen. Such postoperative MR imaging findings should be interpreted with caution, and meticulous correlation with symptoms and clinical results is recommended.     

MR arthrography of the shoulder: comparison with conventional MR imaging

Twenty-three patients underwent both conventional MR imaging of the shoulder and MR shoulder arthrography for clinically suspected labral or rotator cuff abnormalities. Images obtained before and after contrast administration were studied independently, and without knowledge of clinical findings, by two radiologists for the presence of abnormalities of the glenoid labrum or rotator cuff. Results were correlated with surgical findings in all patients. Nine patients had surgically proved labral tears. MR arthrography detected all nine labral abnormalities, while six of the nine were missed on conventional MR imaging. Fourteen patients had surgically proved rotator cuff tears. MR arthrography detected 11 of the 14 tears and missed three partial tears on the bursal surface. Conventional MR imaging detected nine cuff tears and missed five tears; two of these were complete rotator cuff tears and three were partial tears of the undersurface of the rotator cuff. Our results suggest that MR arthrography enhances the accuracy of MR in the evaluation of the glenoid labrum and rotator cuff tendon.     

MR imaging of rotator cuff tears: is there a diagnostic benefit of shoulder exercise prior to imaging

The purpose of this study was to determine if shoulder exercise prior to MR imaging accentuates findings related to rotator cuff tears. In 32 consecutive patients undergoing MR imaging to evaluate the rotator cuff, after routine MR examination, the joint was moved by active or passive exercise (circumduction, including abduction, if possible) in an attempt to redistribute any joint fluid. The exercise was performed according to pain tolerance and for no longer than 4 minutes. The coronal oblique fast spin-echo T2-weighted images of these patients performed before exercise were reviewed by consensus agreement of two musculoskeletal radiologists who were blinded to clinical information. The appearance of the rotator cuff tendons and the distribution of fluid in the glenohumeral joint were determined. The identical postexercise MR images then were placed alongside the corresponding preexercise MR images, and a direct comparison of findings was made with regard to any change in the appearance of the rotator cuff or joint fluid by consensus opinion of the same two radiologists. Five patients (five shoulders) could not perform exercise because of pain. In the remaining 27 patients (27 shoulders), changes in the location of joint fluid were seen when the preexercise and postexercise images were reviewed together, the diagnosis of partial rotator cuff tear (n = 8) was changed to normal in two cases, and the diagnosis of partial tear was made with more confidence in one case. The diagnoses of normal rotator cuff (n = 16) and complete rotator cuff tear (n = 3) were unchanged. Eight patients had arthroscopy; in each of these, the preexercise and postexercise images showed similar results, and proved to be correct surgically (six normal, one partial rotator cuff tear, and one complete rotator cuff tear). Although postexercise MR images show changes in the distribution of joint fluid when compared to preexercise images, the diagnostic benefits of the postexercise images in the analysis of the rotator cuff appear to be limited.     

肩关节疼痛的MRI检查价值评估

目的评价MRI检查对肩关节疼痛疾病诊断的应用价值。方法分析34例肩关节疼痛患者的MRI表现,并与手术所见相对比,评估MRI对疾病诊断的准确性。结果34例患者肩关节磁共振成像扫描发现:肩袖完全撕裂、肩袖部分撕裂、肌腱炎、盂唇撕裂、滑膜炎、关节积液、肱二头肌长头腱鞘炎及肌腱脱位、肿瘤等。13例手术,其中1例MRI诊断为肌腱炎,手术结果为肩袖浅表部分撕裂;1例MRI表现正常,关节镜发现肱二头肌长头肌腱炎,其余11例手术所见与MRI表现基本一致,另21例经保守治疗,症状消失或好转。结论肩关节MRI能清晰显示出肩关节的复杂解剖结构,对慢性肩关节疼痛的病因诊断有较高的准确性,是一项有价值的检查方法。     

Rotator cuff lesions: evaluation with RM and US

Physical and instrumental examination of the patients with an "aching shoulder" is often difficult and a positive out-come of surgical treatment may be impaired by the late diagnosis of long-standing rotator cuff lesions causing tendon adhesions and muscle atrophy. The authors report the results obtained in 25 selected patients with an aching shoulder examined with arthrography, real-time ultrasound (US) with a 5 MHz linear probe, and high-field (1.5 T) Magnetic Resonance (MR) imaging. Arthrography was able to demonstrate a cuff tear in 14/25 cases; US detected signs of tear in 14/25 (1 false negative); MR imaging showed a cuff lesion in 16/25 patients, and in one case allowed a partial cuff tear to be demonstrated, which had not been visualized with arthrography. MR imaging could also demonstrate other signs of periarticular pathologies (tendinitis, longhead of biceps inflammation, and bursitis) that may represent the early stages of the inflammatory-degenerative process underlying most of cuff lesions. The high diagnostic accuracy of US (95%) is stressed in the detection of cuff tears, in patients with an aching shoulder; as for questionable cases at US, MR imaging is indicated as a valid alternative to arthrography, which is more invasive and less accepted by the patients.     

Surgically repaired massive rotator cuff tears: MRI of tendon integrity, muscle fatty degeneration, and muscle atrophy correlated with intraoperative and clinical findings

OBJECTIVE: Our goal in this study was to evaluate by means of MRI the clinical significance of tendon integrity, muscle fatty degeneration, and muscle atrophy in surgically repaired massive rotator cuff tears and to correlate these and other prognostic factors with intraoperative and clinical findings. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Twenty-eight surgically proven massive rotator cuff tears were retrospectively included in the study. Twenty-two patients underwent complete repair, and six patients underwent partial repair. Preoperative and postoperative clinical assessment was performed by using the University of California at Los Angeles score. Preoperative and postoperative MRI studies were evaluated for the presence and extent of rotator cuff tear and for the degree of fatty degeneration and atrophy of the rotator cuff muscles. RESULTS: At a mean 44.4 months' follow-up, 20 patients (71.4%) had a favorable result. A total of 25 patients (89.2%) showed postoperative full-thickness rotator cuff tear, 19 of which were reruptures. A sagittal preoperative rotator cuff tear of less than or equal to 34 mm showed a specificity of 100% for predicting a favorable outcome. A coronal postoperative rotator cuff tear of less than or equal to 34 mm showed a specificity of 85.7% and a positive predictive value of 92.9% for predicting a favorable outcome. A postoperative fatty degeneration of infraspinatus muscle less than or equal to 2 had a specificity of 87.5% and a positive predictive value of 90.9% for predicting a favorable outcome. CONCLUSION: Open repair of massive rotator cuff tears may reach a favorable outcome in a significant proportion of patients, despite a high rate of recurrent or residual tears. Oblique coronal sizes of the recurrent or residual tear of less than or equal to 34 mm and postoperative fatty degenerations of infraspinatus muscle of less than or equal to 2 may allow a favorable outcome.     

Magnetic resonance imaging of sports-related injuries to the shoulder: impingement and rotator cuff

MR imaging provides clinically useful information in detecting and characterizing sports-related pathology of the rotator cuff and other shoulder disorders in a non-invasive fashion. Complete and partial tears of the rotator cuff, as well as factors contributing to impingement, can be detected and characterized with MR imaging. The size and location of complete tears of the rotator cuff can be accurately determined with MR imaging.     

Shoulder MRI: routine examinations using gradient recalled and fat-saturated sequences

Although the signs of complete rotator cuff tears on MRI are well established, tendinitis and partial rotator cuff tears cannot always be readily depicted. In order to optimize the soft-tissue contrast of shoulder imaging without increasing imaging time for routine applications, we compared spin-echo and gradient-echo sequences with and without fat saturation and studied the soft-tissue contrast of spoiled gradient-echo sequences with several different parameters. We conclude, that fat-saturation is not necessary in order to improve the soft-tissue contrast. Successful fat suppression was only achieved in 50% of cases. We found a gradient-echo sequence with a double echo acquisition (echo times TE: 11 and 34 ms) with a long repetition time (TR: 600 ms) and a moderate flip angle (20°) very helpful in diagnosing rotator cuff pathology. Offprint requests to: Harry K. Genant     

Ultrasonography of the rotator cuff: a comparison with arthroscopy in one-hundred-and-ninety consecutive cases

PURPOSE: To evaluate the accuracy of high-resolution ultrasonography compared to arthroscopy in the detection of rotator cuff tears. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Preoperative ultrasonography (US) with a 10-MHz commercially available linear-array transducer and a standardized study protocol was performed in 190 consecutive shoulders in 185 patients with a history of shoulder pain for more than 3 months. The findings at US were classified into intact cuff, partial-thickness, and full-thickness rotator cuff tears, and correlated with findings at shoulder arthroscopy. RESULTS: US correctly depicted 118 of 124 rotator cuff tears with sensitivity 95%, specificity 94%, PPV 97%, NPV 91% and accuracy 95%, all 94 full-thickness tears (sensitivity 100%, specificity 91%, PPV 91%, NPV 100%, and accuracy 95%), 24 of 30 partial-thickness tears (sensitivity 80%, specificity 98%, PPV 86%, NPV 96%, and accuracy 95%). CONCLUSION: US is a highly accurate diagnostic method for detecting full-thickness rotator cuff tears, but is less sensitive in detecting partial-thickness rotator cuff tears.     

Diagnosis of tears in rotator-cuff-injuries

Pathology of the rotator cuff is the cause of most common problems at the shoulder joint. Acute injuries are not as frequent as chronic cuff disease, but often they aggravate inflammatory or degenerative tendon alterations, even if they are of minor severity. Traumatic rotator cuff tears predominantly affect the supraspinatus tendon or the rotator interval. The subscapularis tendon is involved in anterior dislocations of the glenohumeral joint or in direct trauma. Plain film radiography still remains the base of all further imaging studies. If only full-thickness tears must be ruled out, double-contrast arthrography and ultrasound are acceptable imaging modalities. However, the former has a drawback in being invasive and does not detect partial tears at the bursal site of the cuff or rotator cuff tendinopathy, whereas the latter heavily depends on the experience of the radiologist and is restricted to the rotator cuff. Nowadays the most comprehensive imaging method is magnetic resonance (MR) imaging. MR imaging enables the detection or exclusion of complete rotator cuff tears with a reasonable accuracy and is also suitable to diagnose further pathologies of the shoulder joint. MR arthrography is valuable in the detection of subtle anatomic details and further improves the differentiation of rotator cuff diseases. Although in comparison MR imaging is still the most expensive imaging method, its high negative predictive value for the diagnosis of complete rotator cuff tears and its reliability evaluating different shoulder joint pathologies make it the preferred imaging modality.