Passive terminal extension causes anterior tibial translation in some anterior cruciate ligament-deficient knees

The purpose of the present study was to accurately measure anterior tibial translation during passive terminal extension (ATT-PTE) in anterior cruciate ligament (ACL)-deficient knees, and to investigate correlations between various characteristics of such knees and the magnitude of ATT-PTE. The subjects were 79 patients with unilateral ACL-deficient knees and little flexion contracture. All patients were confirmed to have ACL injury of one knee by arthroscopy. Lateral radiographs of the bilateral knees in passive terminal extension were compared, and ATT-PTE was measured using an original superimposition method. The inter-observer and intra-observer reproducibility of measurement was significantly greater for this method than for the method without superimposition. In 42 of the 79 patients (53%), ATT-PTE was greater than 1 mm, while it was greater than 4 mm in 15 patients (19%). ATT-PTE was significantly larger in patients with a large anterior displacement difference (as measured with the KT-1000 arthrometer) (ATT-KT), a long period since injury, a history of reinjury, injury to the meniscus, and the presence of gross pivot shift. On the other hand, ATT-KT was equal to or greater than 2.5 mm in all 79 patients and showed no significant correlation with the time since initial injury, history of reinjury, on injury to the meniscus. Received for publication on March 29, 1999; accepted on Oct. 7, 1999     

Functional testing of braces for anterior cruciate ligament-deficient knees

Previous studies into the efficacy of bracing anterior cruciate ligament (ACL)-deficient knees have lacked objective functional testing. In this study of function the authors compare the effectiveness of three custom-made and three off-the-shelf braces in stabilizing symptomatic, unilateral, chronic, non-reconstructed, ACL-deficient knees. Ten subjects randomly performed six functional tests with each of the six test braces. Knee function was evaluated both objectively and subjectively. Two customized functional braces (Generation II Polyaxial Knee Cage and Lenox Hill Derotation Brace) provided the most objective improvement during ACL-dependent activities and also the most subjective stability. Laterally hinged braces were as effective as the more commonly used double-hinged models. Based on this study, the authors recommend the use of laterally hinged customized functional braces in the nonoperative treatment of the symptomatic ACL-deficient knee.     

Quantitative assessment of functional limitations in normal and anterior cruciate ligament-deficient knees

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the effectiveness of five hopping, jumping, and cutting-type (shuttle run) tests in determining lower extremity functional limitations in anterior cruciate ligament- (ACL) deficient knees. Ninety-three normal subjects were tested. No statistical significance was found between right and left lower limb scores (limb symmetry index) as related to sports activity level, gender, or dominant side. This allowed an overall symmetry index score to be established for the population as a whole. An 85% symmetry index score was found in more than 90% of the normal population for the one-legged hop for distance test and the one-legged timed hop test. Thirty-five patients with ACL-deficient knees were tested. The patients also had KT-1000 and Cybex testing and completed questionnaires rating symptoms, sports activity levels, and sports functional limitations. The cutting-type tests and the vertical jump test did not detect functional limitations in a reliable manner. In the one-legged hop tests, 50% of the patients performed normally, however, all reported giving-way episodes with sports, indicating a lack of sensitivity of these tests in defining functional limitations. Patients with abnormal one-legged hop test scores were considered at serious risk for giving way and limitations during sports activities. Statistically significant relationships were found among abnormal scores on the one-legged hop-type tests and (1) self-assessed difficulty with pivoting, cutting, and twisting, (2) quadriceps weakness (Cybex), and (3) patellofemoral compression pain.     

Human knee joint sound during the Lachman test: Comparison between healthy and anterior cruciate ligament-deficient knees

Background

The Lachman test is clinically considered to be a reliable physical examination for anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) deficiency. However, the test involves subjective judgement of differences in tibial translation and endpoint quality. An auscultation system has been developed to allow assessment of the Lachman test. The knee joint sound during the Lachman test was analyzed using fast Fourier transformation. The purpose of the present study was to quantitatively evaluate knee joint sounds in healthy and ACL-deficient human knees.

Proprioception in people with anterior cruciate ligament-deficient knees: comparison of symptomatic and asymptomatic patients

STUDY DESIGN: Nonrandomized prospective study. OBJECTIVE: To evaluate proprioception in 2 groups of patients with anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) deficiency who had different severity of symptoms. BACKGROUND: Defective proprioception has previously been found in patients with ACL-deficient knees. It has been suggested that sensory receptors of the ACL and other knee joint ligaments contribute to proprioception and knee joint function and stability. METHODS AND MEASURES: A total of 17 patients with ACL deficiency (mean [SD] age, 28.8 +/- 5.6 years; range, 22-39 years) with few, if any, symptoms were compared with 20 patients with ACL deficiency (mean [SD] age, 26.6 +/- 6.1 years; range, 18-39 years) having instability and episodes of giving way. The groups were compared with each other and with an age-matched reference group of 19 nonimpaired subjects. Their mean (SD) age was 25.6 +/- 3.7 years (range, 20-37 years). Three tests of proprioception were used: threshold to detection of passive motion from 2 starting positions (20 degrees and 40 degrees of knee flexion) toward flexion and extension, active reproduction of a 30 degrees passive angle change, and visual reproduction of a 30 degrees passive angle change. The Wilcoxon rank sum test was used for between-group comparisons. RESULTS: Symptomatic patients had higher threshold to detection of passive motion in their injured side in the flexion trial from 20 degrees (median of 1.5 degrees vs median of 0.5 degree) and in the extension trial from 40 degrees (median of 1.0 degree vs median of 0.5 degree) than the asymptomatic patients. No differences were found in the other threshold tests, active or visual reproduction tests. CONCLUSIONS: Patients with severe symptoms related to ACL deficiency were found to have inferior proprioceptive ability in some measurements compared with patients with a good knee function. The findings indicate that proprioceptive deficits might influence the outcome of an ACL injury treated nonoperatively.     

Reduced anterior tibial translation associated with adaptive changes in the anterior cruciate ligament-deficient joint: goat model.

Adaptive changes in the menisci and adjacent posterior capsule were documented within anterior cruciate ligament-deficient knee (stifle) joints in the goat model. These physical changes in the menisci and capsule developed over time and were associated with reduction in the initial (time zero) abnormal anterior tibial translation following transection of the anterior cruciate ligament. At 50 N of applied force, the normal goat knee joint has a total anterior-posterior translation of 0.6+/-0.1 mm (+/- SEM) at 45 degrees of flexion and 0.3+/-0.1 mm at 90 degrees. The translation immediately after transection (time zero) with 50 N of force was 8.2+/-0.5 mm at 45 degrees and 4.9+/-0.9 mm at 90 degrees. Within 8 months after transection and at 50 N of force, the treated knees had reduced translation values of 5.3+/-0.6 mm at 45 degrees of flexion and 2.9+/-0.5 mm at 90 degrees, or 35 (p<0.001) and 40% reductions, respectively, compared with the values at time zero. Magnetic resonance images of the ligament-deficient stifle joints, as well as gross measurements and image analysis after dissection, consistently demonstrated increases in cross-sectional area and volume of the menisci compared with the contralateral controls. These secondary changes were most pronounced in the posterior portion of the medial menisci, and histologic evaluation demonstrated hypercellularity with the accumulation of poorly organized collagen, reduced safranin O staining (proteoglycan matrix synthesis), a thickened capsule and capsule attachment, and increased vascularity at the meniscal capsule interface.     

Lateral thrust of anterior cruciate ligament-insufficient knees and posterior cruciate ligament-insufficient knees

Leaving anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) insufficiency and posterior cruciate ligament (PCL) insufficiency untreated frequently leads to osteoarthritis (OA). The purpose of this study was to evaluate dynamically the lateral thrust of ACL-insufficient knees and PCL-insufficient knees, and from the findings investigate the relationship between cruciate ligament insufficiency and OA occurrence. An acceleration sensor was attached to the affected and control anterior tibial tubercles, acting in medial-lateral and perpendicular directions. The lateral thrust immediately after heel strike was measured continuously by a telemeter under stabilised walking conditions. When compared to the contralateral healthy knee, the peak value of lateral acceleration immediately after heel strike was significantly larger in the ACL-insufficient knee; and lateral thrust was increased, but not significantly, in the PCL-insufficient knee. Given that lateral thrust of the knee during walking increases due to ACL or PCL injury, it may be a principal contributor to OA progression.     

Instrumented measurement of anterior-posterior translation in knees with chronic anterior cruciate ligament tear

Anteroposterior translation of the knee joint was measured with a Knee Signature System device on 12 women and 14 men with a unilateral, chronic, isolated, anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) tear. A control group with stable knees consisted of 10 women and 10 men. Anterior translation at 178 N load of the uninjured knees was 8.0 mm (± 2.2 mm) and in knees with an ACL tear, 14.2 mm (± 4.2 mm). Corresponding values for anteroposterior translation were 12.1 mm (± 2.5 mm) and 19.3 mm (± 4.9 mm), respectively. A difference of 3 mm or more in anteroposterior translation at 178 N load between injured and uninjured knees indicated an ACL tear with 85% specificity and 88% sensitivity.     

Soleus and gastrocnemius muscle loading decreases anterior tibial translation in anterior cruciate ligament intact and deficient knees

This study evaluated the effect of the gastrocnemius and soleus muscles on dynamic knee stability by studying the effect of passive calf muscle loading on anterior tibial translation in normal and anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) deficient knees. Anterior tibial translation was measured bilaterally in 12 anesthetized patients with unilateral ACL-deficient knees using a KT-1000 arthrometer. An ankle-foot orthosis was used to passively dorsiflex the ankle and generate tension in the calf muscles. As the ankle flexion angle was progressively changed from 30 degrees plantar flexion to 10 degrees dorsiflexion, anterior tibial translation decreased 43% and 37% with manual maximum force in normal and ACL-deficient knees, respectively (P < .0001). These findings suggest that the calf muscles may function as dynamic knee stabilizers. Anterior tibial translation also was measured in four cadaver knees. Significant decreases were seen in anterior tibial translation with progressive ankle dorsiflexion in ACL-intact specimens and after the ACL had been cut (P < .05). This effect persisted when the gastrocnemius muscle was cut, but was lost when the soleus muscle was released. The data suggest that the soleus muscle may play a role in dynamically stabilizing the knee.     

Anterior tibial translation during different isokinetic quadriceps torque in anterior cruciate ligament deficient and nonimpaired individuals

STUDY DESIGN: Factorial quasi-experimental design. OBJECTIVES: To quantify the effect of different levels of isokinetic concentric and eccentric knee extensor torques on the anterior tibial translation in subjects with anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) deficiency. Electromyogram (EMG) activity of 4 leg muscles was recorded in order to detect any co-activation of extensors and flexors. BACKGROUND: The rehabilitation after an ACL injury is of importance for the functional outcome of the patient. In order to construct a rehabilitation program after that injury, it is important to understand the in vivo relationships between muscle force and tibial translation. METHODS AND MEASURES: Twelve patients with unilateral ACL injury and 11 uninjured volunteers performed 36 repetitions of a quadriceps contraction at different isokinetic concentric and eccentric torque levels, on a KinCom machine (60 degrees x s(-1)), with simultaneous recordings of tibial translation (CA-4000) and EMG activity from quadriceps and hamstrings muscles. Tibial translations and EMG levels were normalized to the maximum of each subject. RESULTS: The individual anterior tibial translation increased with increased quadriceps torque in a similar manner in both quadriceps contraction modes in all legs tested. During concentric mode, translation was similar in all groups, but during eccentric mode, the mean translation was 38% larger in the ACL injured knees. No quadriceps-hamstrings co-activation occurred in any test or group. CONCLUSIONS: An ACL deficient knee can limit the translation within a normal space during concentric muscle activity but not during eccentric activity. That limitation depends on other mechanisms than hamstrings co-activation.     

Meniscectomy and repair in the anterior cruciate ligament-deficient patient

Meniscal injuries are frequently associated with acute injuries to the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL). With the passage of time, this frequency increases significantly. The management of the torn meniscus varies with the type of lesion and the patient's goals. When possible, meniscus repair combined with ACL reconstruction is recommended in young, athletically active patients. Repair may be accomplished by open or closed techniques. Because of significant risks associated with arthroscopic approaches, an outside-in type of repair has been devised. Overall, the clinical success approaches 90% if the ACL is reconstructed. Failure rates of 30% to 40% ensue if the knee remains unstable.     

A comparison of joint stability between anterior cruciate intact and deficient knees: a new canine model of anterior cruciate ligament disruption.

Transection of the canine anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) is a well-established osteoarthritis (OA) model. This study evaluated a new method of canine ACL disruption as well as canine knee joint laxity and joint capsule (JC) contribution to joint stability at two time points (16 and 26 weeks) after ACL disruption (n=5/time interval). Ten crossbreed hounds were evaluated with force plate gait analysis and radiographs at intervals up to 34 weeks after monopolar radiofrequency energy (MRFE) treatment of one randomly selected ACL. Each contralateral ACL was sham treated. The MRFE treated ACLs ruptured approximately eight weeks (mean 52.5 days, SEM+/-1.0, range 48-56 days) after treatment. Gait analysis and radiographic changes were consistent with established canine ACL transection models of OA. Anterior-posterior (AP) translation and medial-lateral (ML) rotation were measured in each knee at 30 degrees, 60 degrees, and 90 degrees of flexion with and then without JC with loads of 40 N in AP translation and 4 Nm in ML rotation. A statistically significant interaction in AP translation included JC by cruciate (P=0.02), and there was a trend for a cruciate by time (P=0.07) interaction. Significant interactions in ML rotational testing included the presence of joint capsule (P=0.0001) and angle by cruciate (P=0.0012). This study describes a model in which canine ACLs predictably rupture approximately eight weeks after arthroscopic surgery and details the contribution of JC to canine knee stability in both ACL intact and deficient knees. The model presented here avoids the introduction of potential surgical variables at the time of ACL rupture and may contribute to studies of OA pathogenesis and inhibition. This model may also be useful for insight into the pathologic changes that occur in the knee as the ACL undergoes degeneration prior to rupture.     

Anterior laxity and MR signals of the knee after exercise: A comparison of 9 normal knees and 6 anterior cruciate ligament reconstructed knees

9 healthy volunteers and 6 patients with anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) grafts underwent anterior knee laxity measurements and MRI examinations of their knees before and after intensive physical exercise. In the volunteer group, anterior displacement of the knee at 89 and 133 newtons of loading, measured with a KT-2000 knee arthrometer, increased after exercise, compared to before it. In addition, anterior terminal stiffness decreased at 133 newtons of anterior loading. In the ACL group, anterior displacement at 89 and 133 newtons of loading also increased, while no difference was found in anterior terminal stiffness before versus after exercise. On MRI, the signal intensity of normal ACLs after exercise was higher than before it. In contrast, the signals from the grafts showed no differences before versus after exercise. Our findings suggest that the ACL grafts are biomechanically and biochemically different from normal ACLs, even 15 months after ACL reconstruction.     

The variable functional disability of the anterior cruciate ligament-deficient knee

The goal of the authors has been to define the syndrome of the anterior cruciate ligament-deficient knee. These concepts have been applied to pertinent articles in order to explain the discrepancies and contrasting opinions in the literature. The authors have suggested guidelines for treatment based on the quantification of risk factors and a method for the prediction of the functional disability level of patients. Functional disability is activity level-related and is also related to the type of sport and the intensity level of play. Functional disability is symptomatically expressed by pain, swelling, and giving way, which must be correlated with a specific activity level.     

Quantitative evaluation of anterior tibial translation during isokinetic motion in knees with anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction using either patellar or hamstring tendon grafts

We studied 79 patients with unilateral injury to the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL). The patients were randomly allocated to reconstruction with autologous patellar bone-tendon-bone (BTB) grafts (49 knees) or hamstring tendon (ST) grafts (30 knees). We measured anterior tibial translation (ATT) during isokinetic concentric contraction exercise 18-20 months after surgery using a computerized electrogoniometer. In both groups the highest ATT during exercise was observed at a knee flexion of about 20 degrees and was 13.5+/-3.0 mm in the BTB group and 13.9+/-3.4 mm in the ST group. There was no difference in the ATT between the reconstructed and healthy knees. For a range of knee flexion between 30 and 50 degrees the ATT in the ST group was significantly higher on the reconstructed side than on the healthy side. In the BTB group, the mean ATT in the reconstructed group was similar to that on the healthy side at a knee flexion angle between 0 and 90 degrees .     

Proprioception in anterior cruciate ligament deficient knees and its relevance in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction

Injury to the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) not only causes mechanical instability but also leads to a functional deficit in the form of diminished proprioception of the knee joint. “Functional” recovery is often incomplete even after “anatomic” arthroscopic ACL reconstruction, as some patients with a clinically satisfactory repair and good ligament tension continue to complain of a feeling of instability and giving way, although the knee does not sublux on clinical testing. Factors that may play a role could be proprioceptive elements, as the intact ACL has been shown to have significant receptors. Significant data have come to light demonstrating proprioceptive differences between normal and injured knees, and often between injured and reconstructed knees. ACL remnants have been shown to have proprioceptive fibers that could enhance functional recovery if they adhere to or grow into the reconstructed ligament. Conventionally the torn remnants are shaved off from the knee before graft insertion; modern surgical techniques, with remnant sparing methods have shown better outcomes and functional recovery, and this could be an avenue for future research and development. This article analyzes and reviews our understanding of the sensory element of ACL deficiency, with specific reference to proprioception as an important component of functional knee stability. The types of mechanoreceptors, their distribution and presence in ACL remnants is reviewed, and suggestions are made to minimize soft tissue shaving during ACL reconstruction to ensure a better functional outcome in the reconstructed knee.