Comparison between Alzheimer's disease and vascular dementia: implications for treatment

Virtually 90% of the elderly with late-onset dementia exhibit neuropathological features consistent with Alzheimer's disease (AD), vascular dementia (VaD) or dementia with Lewy bodies (DLB), alone or in combination. Both AD and DLB reveal extensive senile plaques containing amyloid beta whereas neurofibrillary tangles evident as tau pathology are fewer in DLB, which also bears diffuse cortical Lewy bodies. Interestingly, however, there is considerable overlap between AD and VaD in terms of both risk factors and pathology. Cholinergic deficits are also encountered in VaD, which like AD may respond to cholinergic therapy. Cerebrovascular pathology, ischemic brain damage and autonomic dysregulation resulting in cerebral hypoperfusion appears fundamental in the pathogenesis of late-onset dementias.     

Treatment of vascular dementia-evidence from clinical trials with cholinesterase inhibitors

Cerebrovascular disease (CVD), as well as secondary ischemic brain injury from cardiovascular disease, are common causes of dementia and cognitive decline in the elderly. Also, CVD frequently contributes to cognitive loss in patients with Alzheimer's disease (AD). Progress in understanding the pathogenetic mechanism involved in vascular cognitive impairment and vascular dementia (VaD) has resulted in promising treatments of these conditions. Cholinergic deficits in VaD are due to ischemia of basal forebrain nuclei and of cholinergic pathways and can be treated with the use of the cholinesterase inhibitors used in AD. Controlled clinical trials with donepezil, galantamine, and rivastigmine in VaD, as well as in patients with AD plus CVD, have demonstrated improvement in cognition, behavior and activities of daily living.     

Treatment of vascular dementia—evidence from clinical trials with cholinesterase inhibitors

Abstract

Cerebrovascular disease (CVD), as well as secondary ischemic brain injury from cardiovascular disease, are common causes of dementia and cognitive decline in the elderly. Also, CVD frequently contributes to cognitive loss in patients with Alzheimer's disease (AD). Progress in understanding the pathogenetic mechanism involved in vascular cognitive impairment and vascular dementia (VaD) has resulted in promising treatments of these conditions. Cholinergic deficits in VaD are due to ischemia of basal forebrain nuclei and of cholinergic pathways and can be treated with the use of the cholinesterase inhibitors used in AD. Controlled clinical trials with donepezil, galantamine, and rivastigmine in VaD, as well as in patients with AD plus CVD, have demostrated improvement in cognition, behavior and activites of daily living.     

Treatment of vascular dementia--evidence from clinical trials with cholinesterase inhibitors

Cerebrovascular disease (CVD), as well as secondary ischemic brain injury from cardiovascular disease, are common causes of dementia and cognitive decline in the elderly. In addition, CVD frequently contributes to cognitive loss in patients with Alzheimer's disease (AD). Progress in understanding the pathogenetic mechanism involved in vascular cognitive impairment (VCI) and vascular dementia (VaD) has resulted in promising treatments of these conditions. Cholinergic deficits in VaD are due to ischemia of basal forebrain nuclei and of cholinergic pathways and can be treated with the use of the cholinesterase inhibitor agents used in AD. Controlled clinical trials with donepezil, galantamine and rivastigmine in VaD, as well as in patients with AD plus CVD, have demonstrated improvements in cognition, behavior and activities of daily living.     

Cholinergic denervation in a pure multi-infarct state: observations on CADASIL

Circumstantial evidence suggests that vascular dementia (VaD) may be associated with cholinergic denervation. The specificity of this association has been difficult to assess because many of the patients are elderly and have the additional cholinergic lesions of aging and AD. A patient with cerebral autosomal-dominant arteriopathy with subcortical infarcts and leukoencephalopathy (CADASIL) who died at age 36 showed that pure white matter infarcts, similar to those seen in VaD, can cause cortical cholinergic denervation, but in patterns that vary from those seen in AD.     

Absence of cholinergic deficits in "pure" vascular dementia

Choline acetyltransferase in temporal cortex was evaluated as a marker of cholinergic function in autopsied dementia cases (9 vascular dementia [VaD] cases, 12 "mixed" VaD and Alzheimer disease [AD] cases, 10 AD cases, 12 control subjects). Patients with AD (t = 2.5, p = 0.02) and "mixed" VaD and AD (t = 3.8, p = 0.001) had greater cholinergic deficits than age-matched control subjects and patients with "pure" VaD. The absence of cholinergic deficits in "pure" VaD may be relevant to the pharmacologic treatment of these patients.     

In vivo functional evaluation of central cholinergic circuits in vascular dementia

OBJECTIVE: Central cholinergic circuits of human brain can be tested non-invasively by coupling peripheral nerve stimulation with transcranial magnetic stimulation of motor cortex. This test, named short latency afferent inhibition (SAI) has been shown in healthy subjects to be sensitive to the blockage of muscarinic acetylcholine receptors and it is impaired in Alzheimer disease (AD) patients, a cholinergic form of dementia, while it is normal in non-cholinergic forms of dementia such as fronto-temporal dementia. The objective of present study was to evaluate central cholinergic circuits in patients with Vascular Dementia (VaD). METHODS: We evaluated SAI in a group of patients with VaD and compared the data with those from a group of AD patients and a control group of age-matched healthy individuals. RESULTS: Mean SAI was normal in VaD patients while it was significantly reduced in AD patients. The analysis of individual data showed abnormal SAI in 75% of AD and in only 25% of VaD. CONCLUSIONS: SAI is normal in most of VaD patients in contrast with AD patients. This test might be used for the functional evaluation of central cholinergic circuits in VaD patients. SIGNIFICANCE: SAI testing may represent a useful additional tool for the evaluation of patients with VaD however, further studies are required in order to evaluate whether this method can be used for the differential diagnosis between pure VaD and different forms of dementia.     

The distribution pattern of pathology and cholinergic deficits in amygdaloid complex in Alzheimer's disease and dementia with Lewy bodies

We studied the distribution pattern of pathology and cholinergic deficits in the subnuclei of the amygdaloid complex (AC) in five patients with Alzheimer's disease (AD), eight with dementia with Lewy bodies (DLB) and five normal controls. In controls, the basal nucleus contained the highest choline acetyltransferase activity; the activity in the lateral and central nuclei and those in the cortical, medial and accessory basal nuclei were comparable. In AD, there was a significant decrease in choline acetyltransferase activity in the accessory basal and lateral nuclei, in DLB a significant decrease was observed in the accessory basal, lateral and cortical nuclei. Compared to controls the hyperphosphorylated tau-pathology burden was significantly higher in the basal, central and medial nuclei in AD and in the central, cortical, lateral and medial nuclei in DLB. The amyloid plaque burden was significantly higher in the accessory basal, basal, lateral and cortical nuclei in AD and in all nuclei in DLB. The α-synuclein burden was significantly higher in all nuclei in both AD and DLB. Compared to AD α-synuclein burden was higher in all nuclei in DLB. There were no correlations between the distribution pattern of hyperphosphorylated tau-pathology, amyloid plaques and α-synuclein-positive structures, and choline acetyltransferase activity, except the lateral nucleus in DLB. In conclusion we found no relationship between the pattern of cholinergic deficits and the distribution pattern of lesions in the AC of patients with AD or DLB. Cholinergic deficits were more prominent in the nuclei of basolateral (BL) group in AD, whereas the nuclei of both BL and corticomedial groups were involved in DLB, which may be due to the involvement of both basal forebrain and brainstem cholinergic nuclei in the latter.     

Overlap between pathology of Alzheimer disease and vascular dementia

There is overwhelming evidence to suggest that the neuropathology of Alzheimer disease (AD) extends beyond amyloid plaques and neurofibrillary tangles. Review of various consortium data shows that more than 30% of AD cases exhibit cerebrovascular pathology. However, certain vascular lesions such as cerebral amyloid angiopathy, microvascular degeneration, and periventricular white matter lesions are evident in almost all cases of AD. Whether these vascular lesions are coincidental or causal in the pathogenetic processes of AD remains to be defined. Although systemic vascular influences such as hypertension, coronary artery disease, and other cardiovascular disturbances may be responsible for such pathology in AD, it is equally intriguing that about one third of patients diagnosed with vascular dementia (VaD) will have AD-type pathology at autopsy. Moreover, previous studies have revealed that deficits in cholinergic indices related to the basal forebrain neurones are apparent in multi-infarct dementia. In this short review, we evaluate cerebrovascular pathology of AD in light of peripheral vascular pathophysiology implicated in the etiopathogenesis of the dementia. We also consider pathological findings in relation to genetic influences such as apolipoprotein E that may shed light on the link between AD and VaD. In view of these commonalties, it is reasonable to consider the same treatment strategies for both AD and VaD.     

Neuropsychiatric profiles in patients with Alzheimer's disease and vascular dementia

OBJECTIVE: To explore the neuropsychiatric manifestations in patients with Alzheimer's disease (AD) and cortical and subcortical vascular dementia (VaD). METHODS: We investigated consecutive patients with dementia. All the participants received brain computed tomography. The diagnosis of dementia was confirmed by clinical criteria and the imaging findings. Only patients with probable AD, and subcortical and cortical VaD were included. The Mini Mental State Examination (MMSE) was used to evaluate global cognitive function, and the Neuropsychiatric Inventory (NPI) was used to assess neuropsychiatric symptoms. RESULTS: Of the 536 participants with dementia, 320 (59.7%) had AD, 161 (30%) had subcortical VaD, 35 (6.4%) had cortical VaD, and 16 (2.9%) had mixed cortical and subcortical VaD. Cortical VaD patients had the highest mean composite NPI scores in all domains and AD patients had the lowest composite scores in most domains. The mean composite scores of the apathy and sleep disturbance domains in patients with cortical VaD were significantly higher than those in the patients with AD after controlling for years of education and MMSE score (p < 0.01). CONCLUSIONS: There were few differences among the patients with AD, subcortical VaD and cortical VaD. The most consistent differences were the high sleep disturbance scores in those with cortical VaD.     

Executive dyscontrol in dementia, with emphasis on subcortical pathology and the role of butyrylcholinesterase

Executive functions describe a variety of cognitive processes responsible for structuring behaviors around goals, and developing plans to achieve those goals in relation to the environment. In addition to deficits in basal forebrain cholinergic neuronal input into the frontal cortex, impaired control of executive function has been associated with lesions to the frontal cortex and its basal ganglia-thalamic connections. In addition to executive dysfunction, features that imply fronto-subcortical pathology include profound slowing of cognition, attentional deficits, apathy and changes in mood. Fronto-subcortical systems are vulnerable to white matter change, atrophy, and certain forms of neurotransmitter depletion. The diffuse, and likely non-cholinergic, projections of acetylcholinesterase (AChE)-containing thalamic neurons innervate all cortical areas. Butyrylcholinesterase (BuChE) activity is relatively high in thalamic nuclei that project to frontal cortical structures involved in attention, executive function, and behavior. However, the largest pool of BuChE in the brain is found in the glia, particularly those in deeper cortical and subcortical structures. These findings suggest that BuChE may also be an important therapeutic target in the management of symptoms due to subcortical pathology. Whereas 'pure' Alzheimer's disease (AD) may involve significant subcortical pathology in addition to cortical pathology, AD with cerebrovascular disease, vascular dementia (VaD), Parkinson's disease dementia (PDD) and dementia due to Lewy bodies (DLB) may involve a generally greater degree of subcortical, in addition to cortical, pathology. It may be hypothesized that these dementia types, which are characterized by executive dysfunction, might derive particular benefits from cholinesterase inhibitors such as rivastigmine that inhibit BuChE in addition to AChE.     

Do lesions involving the cortical cholinergic pathways help or hinder efficacy of donepezil in patients with Alzheimer's disease?

AIMS: To investigate the influences of vascular lesions detected by MRI, lesions involving the cortical cholinergic pathways and hippocampal thickness on therapeutic responsiveness to donepezil in patients with Alzheimer's disease (AD). METHODS: The study cohort contained 67 patients with probable AD. We used the revised Hasegawa Dementia Rating (HDS-R) and the Clock Drawing Test (CDT) to evaluate drug efficacy for 24 months. The Cholinergic Pathways Hyperintensities Scale (CHIPS), a newly developed visual scale, was used to semiquantify lesions on the cholinergic pathways. RESULTS: Over the 24-month period, the results of the CDT showed more apparent and constant association with white matter hyperintensities (WMH) and lesions on the cholinergic pathways than the HDS-R. WMH may enhance, while lesions on the cholinergic pathways may attenuate sensitivity to donepezil treatment when judged by the CDT. No apparent association between the thicknesses of hippocampi with baseline cognition or therapeutic responsiveness to donepezil was found. CONCLUSION: Donepezil may be more efficacious when further executive dysfunction caused by WMH is added to AD dementia and less so when cholinergic reserves are further impinged upon by lesions involving the cortical cholinergic pathways.     

Rivastigmine in vascular dementia

Vascular dementia (VaD), like Alzheimer's disease (AD), is associated with cholinergic deficits. Rivastigmine provides sustained, brain-selective inhibition of acetylcholinesterase and butyrylcholinesterase. Preliminary data suggest that rivastigmine may provide significant benefits in patients with AD and cerebrovascular disease (mixed dementia), and in patients with VaD. Open-label rivastigmine treatment has been associated with improved cognitive and functional abilities, behavioral symptoms, and reduced caregiver stress in a small pilot study in these patients. Larger, prospective, double-blind studies of rivastigmine in patients with VaD are under way. These studies will confirm whether rivastigmine is an efficacious treatment option for a range of patients for whom, until now, there have been few symptomatic therapies.     

The prevention of the dementia epidemic

Alzheimer's disease (AD) is considered to be the most common dementing disorder. The understanding of this disorder has greatly advanced over the past few years, and new therapeutic options have been developed. Another disorder, vascular dementia (VaD), is a syndrome with multiple etiologies operating through a variety of different mechanisms. The combination of AD and VaD is extremely common, making mixed dementia the most common type of dementia. Risk factors for VaD, which are the common vascular risk factors, are presently known to apply also to AD. Cholinergic deficits occur in both conditions. The identification of several genetic factors that can contribute to vascular damage, as well as possible auto-immune damage to vascular components, are important. It is remarkable that amyloid precursor protein (APP) mutations can cause the typical pathological changes of AD as well as amyloid deposition around blood vessels. These may lead to deficient blood perfusion to the brain, changes of the blood-brain barrier, as well as cerebral hemorrhages. Interestingly, attention to risk factors, such as hypertension, coronary artery disease, hyperlipidemia and smoking could reduce or delay the incidence of dementia, both vascular and AD.     

The contribution of transcranial magnetic stimulation in the diagnosis and in the management of dementia

Transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) is emerging as a promising tool to non-invasively assess specific cortical circuits in neurological diseases. A number of studies have reported the abnormalities in TMS assays of cortical function in dementias. A PubMed-based literature review on TMS studies targeting primary and secondary dementia has been conducted using the key words “transcranial magnetic stimulation” or “motor cortex excitability” and “dementia” or “cognitive impairment” or “memory impairment” or “memory decline”. Cortical excitability is increased in Alzheimer’s disease (AD) and in vascular dementia (VaD), generally reduced in secondary dementias. Short-latency afferent inhibition (SAI), a measure of central cholinergic circuitry, is normal in VaD and in frontotemporal dementia (FTD), but suppressed in AD. In mild cognitive impairment, abnormal SAI may predict the progression to AD. No change in cortical excitability has been observed in FTD, in Parkinson’s dementia and in dementia with Lewy bodies. Short-interval intracortical inhibition and controlateral silent period (cSP), two measures of gabaergic cortical inhibition, are abnormal in most dementias associated with parkinsonian symptoms. Ipsilateral silent period (iSP), which is dependent on integrity of the corpus callosum is abnormal in AD. While single TMS measure owns low specificity, a panel of measures can support the clinical diagnosis, predict progression and possibly identify earlier the “brain at risk”. In dementias, TMS can be also exploited to select and evaluate the responders to specific drugs and, it might become a rehabilitative tool, in the attempt to restore impaired brain plasticity.     

Galantamine in the treatment of vascular dementia

Vascular dementia (VaD) is a disorder with no cure and limited treatment options. Similarities between VaD and Alzheimer's disease (AD) arise on a number of levels. Both involve progressive decline in cognition, functional ability, and behavior, and there is evidence for a central role of reduced cholinergic neurotransmission in the two illnesses. Treatment strategies in VaD have historically focused on prevention, although evidence of cognitive benefits with preventative treatment is scarce. Acetylcholinesterase inhibitors represent a rational treatment possibility for symptomatic therapy of patients with VaD. A recent large-scale trial of galantamine in patients with VaD or AD with cerebrovascular disease (AD + CVD) represents the first placebo-controlled trial showing clinically relevant benefits in these important patient populations.     

CT brain findings in clinical dementia investigation--underestimation of mixed dementia

Dementia has been found to display a more heterogeneous clinical picture than previously recognized. We investigated brain changes on computed tomography (CT) in a clinical dementia population consisting of 67 cases with Alzheimer's disease (AD), 13 with mixed dementia (AD and vascular dementia, VaD), 71 with VaD, and 12 cases that were not demented. Temporal cortical atrophy and atrophy around the temporal horns were more common in patients with mixed dementia compared to patients with VaD and the non-demented, respectively. Frontal white matter changes were present in 64% of AD, in 85% of mixed dementia and in 79% of VaD cases, but there were no differences between the dementia groups. Lacunes were present in almost 40% of AD cases and in 80 and 85% of VaD and mixed dementia cases, respectively. Only 14% of the VaD cases had large infarcts on the CT. We conclude that large infarcts were rare, even in VaD cases. The increased incidence of white matter changes and lacunes in AD patients strongly indicates an underestimation of the mixed dementia diagnosis. More distinct criteria for this diagnostic category are warranted.     

Cholinergic neuronal and axonal abnormalities are present early in aging and in Alzheimer disease

A large body of evidence indicates that basal forebrain cholinergic neurons are selectively vulnerable to degeneration early in Alzheimer disease (AD). Recent studies, however, demonstrate reductions in cortical activity of the cholinergic enzyme choline acetyltransferase only in late stages of AD. To address this apparent contradiction, we compared abnormalities in magnocellular basal forebrain cholinergic neurons and their axons in nondemented young (<65 years; n = 6), nondemented old (>65 years; n = 7), pathologically mild (n = 5), and pathologically severe (n = 5) AD cases. Cholinergic axon abnormalities (i.e. thickened fibers and ballooned terminals) were evident in nondemented middle-aged cases, increased in nondemented old cases, and reduced in density in severe AD. This suggests that loss of cortical cholinergic axons in AD occurs preferentially in fibers with these abnormalities. Paired helical filament 1-immunoreactive pretangles and tangles were observed as early as the third decade prior to their appearance in entorhinal/perirhinal cortex; they were increased in mild and severe AD. These results indicate that basal forebrain cholinergic neuron abnormalities are present very early in aging and in the course of AD. Therefore, despite the morphologic alterations, choline acetyltransferase activity, but not necessarily normal neuron functions, may be preserved.     

Does perfusion CT enable differentiating Alzheimer's disease from vascular dementia and mixed dementia? A preliminary report

The purpose of the study was to evaluate the usefulness of perfusion CT (pCT) in differentiating Alzheimer's disease (AD) from vascular dementia (VaD) and mixed dementia (MixD). pCT was performed in 41 patients (mean age, 68.3 years): 24 with AD, 8 with VaD, and 9 with MixD. Regional perfusion parameters (rCBF, rCBV, and rMTT) were calculated from 31 ROIs in the grey and white matter of the frontal and temporal lobes, basal ganglia, and internal capsules bilaterally. The obtained data for the subgroups of AD, VaD, and MixD patients were compared statistically. CONCLUSIONS: On the basis of rCBF and rCBV values, pCT may be a valuable method of distinguishing between AD and VaD but it seems to be of little significance in differentiating MixD from VaD and of no usefulness in distinguishing between AD and MixD.     

Nicotinic receptors in dementia of Alzheimer, Lewy body and vascular types

Objectives - Comparisons were made of nicotinic receptors in 3 major forms of dementia in old age. Although it is well established the involvement of nicotinic receptors in Alzheimer's disease (AD), their status in the other two main causes of dementia in old age – dementia with Lewy bodies (DLB) and vascular dementia (VaD) is not widely reported. Methods – Temporal cortex was examined for epibatidine and α-bungarotoxin binding, and immunoreactivity of α4 and α7 nAChR subunits. Results – There were selective abnormalities in nicotinic receptor subtypes in the disorders examined. In AD there is a loss of high affinity receptor binding, reflecting a selective loss of α4 subunit, but no change in α7 subunits. Similar abnormalities in ligand binding are also apparent in DLB. In the VaD series, there was no overall loss of epibatidine binding or immunoreactivity for α4 or α7 subunits. Conclusions – Loss of cortical receptor α4 subunit appears to be a characteristic feature of neurodegenerative dementia but not dementia of vascular origin. Since nicotinic receptors control cerebral vasodilation, the relative integrity of the receptors in VaD may auger well for nicotinic therapy in this disorder in which there is a cholinergic abnormality, to judge by the loss of the presynaptic enzyme.