Improving infant sleep and maternal mental health: a cluster randomised trial

Objectives

To determine whether a community‐delivered intervention targeting infant sleep problems improves infant sleep and maternal well‐being and to report the costs of this approach to the healthcare system.

Design

Cluster randomised trial.

Setting

49 Maternal and Child Health (MCH) centres (clusters) in Melbourne, Australia.

Participants

328 mothers reporting an infant sleep problem at 7 months recruited during October–November 2003.

Intervention

Behavioural strategies delivered over individual structured MCH consultations versus usual care.

Main outcome measures

Maternal report of infant sleep problem, depression symptoms (Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale (EPDS)), and SF‐12 mental and physical health scores when infants were 10 and 12 months old. Costs included MCH sleep consultations, other healthcare services and intervention costs.

Results

Prevalence of infant sleep problems was lower in the intervention than control group at 10 months (56% vs 68%; adjusted OR 0.58 (95% CI: 0.36 to 0.94)) and 12 months (39% vs 55%; adjusted OR 0.50 (0.31 to 0.80)). EPDS scores indicated less depression at 10 months (adjusted mean difference −1.4 (−2.3 to −0.4) and 12 months (−1.7 (−2.6 to −0.7)). SF‐12 mental health scores indicated better health at 10 months (adjusted mean difference 3.7 (1.5 to 5.8)) and 12 months (3.9 (1.8 to 6.1)). Total mean costs including intervention design, delivery and use of non‐MCH nurse services were £96.93 and £116.79 per intervention and control family, respectively.

Conclusions

Implementing this sleep intervention may lead to health gains for infants and mothers and resource savings for the healthcare system.

Trial registration

Current Controlled Trial Registry, number ISRCTN48752250 (registered November 2004).Maternal depression impacts adversely on maternal quality of life, mother–child relationships and child development.^1,2 Despite a prevalence of 15% in the first year postpartum,³ depression often remains undiagnosed and, even if detected, many mothers reject the diagnosis, the treatment or both.⁴Maternal depression is linked to poor infant sleep. Problems with frequent night waking and difficulties settling to sleep are reported by over a third of parents in the second 6 months of life^5,6 and are consistently associated with poor maternal health.^7,8,9In a previous efficacy trial, we demonstrated that treating infant sleep problems (simple behavioural techniques delivered in local well‐child centres over two to three sessions) significantly reduced maternal reports of depression symptoms as well as infant sleep problems.¹⁰ However, efficacy and generalisability may be limited by the predominantly middle‐class status of participating families and the fact that the intervention was delivered by a single paediatrician (HH). In another randomised trial,¹¹ a single, nurse‐led consultation emphasising ways to help very young infants settle to sleep independently resulted in intervention infants sleeping more than controls at age 12 weeks but in no change in maternal depression. All other sleep intervention trials have been limited by selection bias, small sample sizes, short follow‐up and/or lack of randomisation.¹²The trial reported here was conducted within an existing universally available, state‐wide primary health care service, training the well‐child care providers themselves to manage infant sleep problems in families from a broad sociodemographic sample. We hypothesised that a brief behavioural intervention designed to reduce infant sleep problems would result in improved infant sleep and maternal well‐being. We also documented the costs of the intervention and costs to the healthcare system.     

Infant colic: empirical evidence of the absence of an association with source of early infant nutrition

BACKGROUND: The etiology of infant colic remains unknown, despite an abundance of research on the topic. OBJECTIVE: To determine whether breastfeeding has a protective effect in colic's development. DESIGN: A prospective cohort study of 856 mother-infant dyads. Eligible participants included English-speaking adult residents of a region in Ontario, who gave birth, at term, to a live singleton whose birth weight was appropriate for gestational age. Self-administered questionnaires, mailed to mothers at 1 and 6 weeks post partum, requested information on several infant and maternal factors, including source of infant nutrition (exclusively breastfed, complementary fed, and exclusively formula fed). Cases of colic were identified by applying modified Wessel criteria to data recorded in the Barr Baby Day Diary or by interpreting responses to the Ames Cry Score. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Prevalence of colic among breastfed, formula-fed, and complementary-fed infants; and adjusted odds ratios (AORs) reflecting the prevalence of colic among formula- and complementary-fed infants relative to those who were breastfed. RESULTS: Of 856 mothers, 733 (86%) completed the first questionnaire and 617 (72%) completed the second questionnaire. Overall, the prevalence of colic at 6 weeks was 24%. No association was seen between the source of infant nutrition and colic's development. In multivariate analyses, higher levels of maternal trait anxiety (AOR, 1.22; 95% confidence interval [CI], 0.96-1.54), maternal alcohol consumption at 6 weeks (AOR, 1.57; 95% CI, 1.03-2.40), and shift work during pregnancy (AOR, 1.27; 95% CI, 0.73-2.21) were associated with an increased likelihood of colic, after controlling for feeding method, maternal age, and parity. In these same analyses, being married or having a common-law partner (AOR, 0.30; 95% CI, 0.10-0.87) and being employed full-time during pregnancy (AOR, 0.60; 95% CI, 0.32-1.14) were associated with a reduced likelihood of colic. CONCLUSIONS: Breastfeeding did not have a protective effect on the development of colic. Although colic was statistically associated with several variables, including preexisting maternal anxiety, much of colic's etiology remains unexplained.     

Improving infant sleep and maternal mental health: a cluster randomised trial.

OBJECTIVES: To determine whether a community-delivered intervention targeting infant sleep problems improves infant sleep and maternal well-being and to report the costs of this approach to the healthcare system. DESIGN: Cluster randomised trial. SETTING: 49 Maternal and Child Health (MCH) centres (clusters) in Melbourne, Australia. PARTICIPANTS: 328 mothers reporting an infant sleep problem at 7 months recruited during October-November 2003. INTERVENTION: Behavioural strategies delivered over individual structured MCH consultations versus usual care. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Maternal report of infant sleep problem, depression symptoms (Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale (EPDS)), and SF-12 mental and physical health scores when infants were 10 and 12 months old. Costs included MCH sleep consultations, other healthcare services and intervention costs. RESULTS: Prevalence of infant sleep problems was lower in the intervention than control group at 10 months (56% vs 68%; adjusted OR 0.58 (95% CI: 0.36 to 0.94)) and 12 months (39% vs 55%; adjusted OR 0.50 (0.31 to 0.80)). EPDS scores indicated less depression at 10 months (adjusted mean difference -1.4 (-2.3 to -0.4) and 12 months (-1.7 (-2.6 to -0.7)). SF-12 mental health scores indicated better health at 10 months (adjusted mean difference 3.7 (1.5 to 5.8)) and 12 months (3.9 (1.8 to 6.1)). Total mean costs including intervention design, delivery and use of non-MCH nurse services were 96.93 pounds sterling and 116.79 pounds sterling per intervention and control family, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: Implementing this sleep intervention may lead to health gains for infants and mothers and resource savings for the healthcare system. TRIAL REGISTRATION: Current Controlled Trial Registry, number ISRCTN48752250 [controlled-trials.com] (registered November 2004).     

Bases for maternal perceptions of infant crying and colic behaviour

According to the commonest definition, infant colic is distinguished by crying which is 'paroxysmal'-that is, intense and different in type from normal fussing and crying. To test this, maternal reports of the distress type of 67 infants whose fuss/crying usually exceeded three hours a day ('persistent criers') were scrutinised using 24 hour audiorecordings of the infants' distressed vocalisation. 'Moderate criers' (n = 55) and 'evening criers' (n = 38) were also assessed. Most of the distress in all three groups was fussing. In the audiorecordings the persistent criers showed a higher crying: fussing ratio than the moderate criers, but intense crying was rare. A third of the persistent criers were reported by their mothers to have occasional, distinct colic bouts of 'intense, unsoothable crying and other behaviour, perhaps due to stomach or bowel pain.' In the audiorecordings these periods were longer, but not paroxysmal in onset or more intense than the crying of persistent criers not judged to have colic. The audible features of the crying may be less important than its unpredictable, prolonged, hard to soothe, and unexplained nature.     

Bases for maternal perceptions of infant crying and colic behaviour.

According to the commonest definition, infant colic is distinguished by crying which is ''paroxysmal''-that is, intense and different in type from normal fussing and crying. To test this, maternal reports of the distress type of 67 infants whose fuss/crying usually exceeded three hours a day (''persistent criers'') were scrutinised using 24 hour audiorecordings of the infants'' distressed vocalisation. ''Moderate criers'' (n = 55) and ''evening criers'' (n = 38) were also assessed. Most of the distress in all three groups was fussing. In the audiorecordings the persistent criers showed a higher crying: fussing ratio than the moderate criers, but intense crying was rare. A third of the persistent criers were reported by their mothers to have occasional, distinct colic bouts of ''intense, unsoothable crying and other behaviour, perhaps due to stomach or bowel pain.'' In the audiorecordings these periods were longer, but not paroxysmal in onset or more intense than the crying of persistent criers not judged to have colic. The audible features of the crying may be less important than its unpredictable, prolonged, hard to soothe, and unexplained nature.     

Culture and infant mental health

The purpose of this article is to summarize key findings in cross-cultural research to guide infant mental health practice in pediatric settings. This overview highlights 3 main themes: the distribution of care-giving in families and communities, the persistent and paramount importance of physical health and survival, and the need to understand diverse practices of infant socialization. In each of these areas, simple guidance that can be implemented by diverse clinicians is offered.     

Prematurity and neonatal noxious events exert lasting effects on infant pain behaviour

BACKGROUND: There is concern that exposure of preterm infants to noxious insults over a prolonged period may have long term effects on their developing nervous system. AIMS: To investigate medium and long term effects of heel pricks in infants over the first year of life. STUDY DESIGN: Study 1-a longitudinal study, 2 days and 4 weeks after heel prick. Study 2-a cross sectional study over the first year of life. SUBJECTS: Study 1-13 healthy preterm (PT) infants. Study 2-63 full term (FT) and 62 PT infants, divided into 3 timed groups (0-20, 21-37 and 38-52 weeks postterm and corrected for prematurity). OUTCOME MEASURES: Threshold responses (flexion withdrawal (FWR) , gross body movements (GBM) and grimace (G)) to increasing mechanical force applied with Von Frey filaments. RESULTS: Study 1-Thresholds were all significantly lower (more sensitive) from the pricked heel compared to the contralateral side at 2 days and 4 weeks. Study 2-There were significant differences in threshold between PT and FT infants at all time points for both FWR (P=0.001, <0.001, <0.001) and GBM (P=<0.001, <0.001, 0.009 respectively), the preterm infants always being lower. The threshold for the FWR in FT infants steadily increased, but the threshold for the PT infants remained the same. GBM thresholds increased during the year in both FT and PT infants, but were always significantly lower in the ex-preterm group (P<0.012). CONCLUSIONS: Either PT birth or repetitive procedures associated with such birth alters the sensitivity threshold of PT infants compared with FT infants for at least the first year of life.     

Chronic childhood illness and maternal mental health

The relationship between the health status of a child and the psychiatric symptoms of a mother is examined for an inner-city sample (n = 209) of chronically ill children with heterogeneous physical diagnoses. Whereas no relationship exists between the mother's psychiatric symptoms and a medical provider's report of the burden that the child's condition entails, there is a relationship between the functional status of the child and the mental health status of the mother. Children with more functional limitations have mothers who are more symptomatic. The presence of other stressors in the family, familial impact of the illness, poor physical health of the mother, and the absence of a confidant for the women are also associated with the mother's psychiatric symptoms in a multivariate analysis that includes traditional predictors of women's mental health. In contrast with the results from more general population studies, a greater number of children may be protective for a mother of a child with a chronic illness.     

Fatty acid status and maternal mental health

Maternal mental health (MMH) problems are a major public health concern with adverse consequences for women, their offspring and families. Intake of long-chain polyunsaturated fatty acids, especially the n-3 fatty acids docosahexaenoic acid (DHA) and eicosapentaenoic acid, which are found predominantly in cold water fish, has been associated with a range of mental health outcomes and may improve MMH. The demands for these fatty acids are increased during pregnancy and lactation, and may influence MMH as they are integral parts of cell membranes especially in the brain and play a role in physiological processes such as membrane fluidity and neurotransmitter function. Observational studies and intervention trials that have examined the role of fatty acids and MMH disorders especially post-partum depression (PPD) were identified using Pubmed and have been reviewed. Only three well-designed large prospective studies were identified; these studies examined the relationship between dietary intakes of n-3 fatty acids and fish during pregnancy, and found limited evidence of an association with PPD. Several intervention trials (n=8) have been done but generally suffer from small sample size and vary in terms of the study subject characteristics and timing, duration and dosage of the intervention. The results are mixed, but one recently completed large trial found no evidence of benefit among women who received DHA during pregnancy. Few studies have been conducted in developing countries, and gaps remain on the influence of other nutrient deficiencies, genetic polymorphisms that influence n-3 fatty acid synthesis and total fatty acid intake.     

Poverty,underdevelopment and infant mental health

Very great advances have occurred in disciplinary and professional knowledge of infant development and its influence on subsequent development. This expertise includes the ways in which early experiences affect the capacity of mature individuals for social adjustment and productive competence, and promising methods of intervention to promote infant mental health and prevent adverse sequelae of risk conditions. However, very little of this knowledge has been applied in work among infants and children living in conditions of poverty and underdevelopment. This lack of application continues despite the enormous threats to the well-being of infants and young children brought about by the combined effects of poverty and the AIDS pandemic, especially in southern Africa. Protein-energy malnutrition, maternal depression, and institutional care of infants and small children are cited as illustrative of areas in which interventions, and their evaluation, are desperately needed in resource-poor countries. An argument is made for the critical importance of considering and addressing psychological factors in care givers and children in conditions of extreme material need. An example is provided of a simple intervention model based on sound developmental principles that can be implemented by trained non-professionals in conditions of poverty and underdevelopment.     

Post-neonatal infant mortality in Malawi: the importance of maternal health

In a cohort study of mothers and their infants, information was collected from women attending the antenatal services of two hospitals in a rural area of Malawi and 561 of their babies were enrolled in a follow-up study. There were 128 with a low birthweight (LBW, <2500 g), 138 with fetal anaemia (FA, cord haemoglobin <12.5 g/dl), 42 with both and 228 with a normal birthweight and no FA. Infants were seen monthly for 1 year. Risk factors for post-neonatal infant mortality (PNIM) were calculated using Cox regression analysis adjusting for LBW and FA. PNIM was 9.3%. Respiratory infections and diarrhoeal disease were the principal attributable causes of death. PNIM increased with LBW (RR 3.08, 95% CI 1.51-6.23) but not significantly so with FA (RR 1.60, 95% CI 0.78-3.27). An additional effect on PNIM was observed with maternal HIV (RR 3.44, 95% CI 1.63-7.26) and malaria at the first antenatal visit (RR 2.26, 95% CI 1.09-4.73). Illiteracy was not associated with mortality. Placental malaria in HIV-seronegative mothers was significantly associated with increased PNIM. Improving birthweight through effective antimalarial control in pregnancy will lead to a reduction in PNIM. Reduction of HIV prevalence and prevention of mother-to-child transmission of HIV must be a main target for government health policy.     

Psychosocial predictors of maternal and infant health among adolescent mothers

Past work suggests that stressful life events and social support are significantly associated with a broad range of child health outcomes. Such associations have remained, however, generally modest in magnitude, suggesting that stress and support may be only proxy measures for a deeper, more central aspect of childhood psychosocial experience. One aspect of young people's lives that could plausibly mediate the effects of stress and social support on health is the sense of stability and "permanence" in ongoing life experience. We developed a standardized psychometric instrument for measuring a "sense of permanence" and employed the measure in a prospective 1-year study of health outcomes among 89 adolescent mothers and their infants. Psychosocial and demographic factors were significantly predictive of maternal, but not infant, health outcomes, and the sense of permanence appeared to operate as a "final common pathway" in the influence of psychosocial variables on health and illness end points. Results of the study underscore the importance of continuity and stability in childhood and suggest that changes in an individual's sense of permanence may underlie the previously documented health effects of stressful life events and social support.     

The evidence for public health recommendations on infant feeding

Public health recommendations should be based on the best available scientific evidence, and this necessitates careful appraisal of the available data and management of scientific uncertainty. This paper discusses the difficulties in collecting and interpreting scientific data on infant feeding, in particular the fact that since it is not feasible to randomise healthy infants to be breast or formula-fed, the majority of available data come from observational studies with associated methodological limitations. The scientific evidence available to underpin recommendations for breastfeeding and for 6 months exclusive breastfeeding are presented in the context of these limitations, noting disagreement between expert groups considering the same scientific data. Finally, the use of science to formulate infant feeding recommendations, and communication of information, including scientific uncertainty, to parents are discussed.     

Separation distress call in the human neonate in the absence of maternal body contact

Few studies have used the baby's cry as a means of evaluating the quality of neonatal care. In this randomized trial the newborn's cry was registered during the first 90 min after birth when infants were cared for either: (a) skin–to–skin with the mother; (b) in a cot; or (c) in a cot for the first 45 min of the 90–min observation period and then skin–to–skin with the mother. The results suggested that human infants recognize physical separation from their mothers and start to cry in pulses. Crying stops at reunion. The observed postnatal cry may be a human counterpart to the "separation distress call" which is a general phenomenon among several mammalian species, and serves to restore proximity to the mother. Our results suggest that in human newborns this cry is not dependent on earlier social experience and may be a genetically encoded reaction to separation. The findings are compatible with the opinion that the most appropriate position of the healthy full–term newborn baby after birth is in close body contact with the mother.     

Treatment of infant colic with amino acid-based infant formula: a preliminary study

Infant colic, a common disorder of infancy, is characterized by excessive crying and fussing. In this preliminary study we examined whether Neocate, an amino acid-based formula, would be accepted by formula-fed infants with colic, 3-7 wk of age, and whether Neocate would improve their symptoms. Six infants with colic were studied using Barr-type infant behavior diaries for 3-6 d on their current formula and then for 5-17 d on Neocate exclusively. All infants tolerated Neocate well and all improved, usually within 1-2 d. The total time spent crying and fussing was reduced by an average of 45%, representing a decrease of 1.0 to 5.2 h daily. After colic symptoms improved, infants were challenged with oral doses of 75 mg of bovine IgG at a 1 mg/ml concentration in order to assess its potential role in colic. Bovine IgG challenges resulted in increased crying and fussing behavior, suggesting that this protein may be etiologically important.     

The effects of maternal social phobia on mother-infant interactions and infant social responsiveness

BACKGROUND: Social phobia aggregates in families. The genetic contribution to intergenerational transmission is modest, and parenting is considered important. Research on the effects of social phobia on parenting has been subject to problems of small sample size, heterogeneity of samples and lack of specificity of observational frameworks. We addressed these problems in the current study. METHODS: We assessed mothers with social phobia (N = 84) and control mothers (N = 89) at 10 weeks in face-to-face interactions with their infants, and during a social challenge, namely, engaging with a stranger. We also assessed mothers with generalised anxiety disorder (GAD) (N = 50). We examined the contribution to infant social responsiveness of early infant characteristics (neonatal irritability), as well as maternal behaviour. RESULTS: Mothers with social phobia were no less sensitive to their infants during face-to-face interactions than control mothers, but when interacting with the stranger they appeared more anxious, engaged less with the stranger themselves, and were less encouraging of the infant's interaction with the stranger; infants of index mothers also showed reduced social responsiveness to the stranger. These differences did not apply to mothers with GAD and their infants. Regression analyses showed that the reduction in social responsiveness in infants of mothers with social phobia was predicted by neonatal irritability and the degree to which the mother encouraged the infant to interact with the stranger. CONCLUSIONS: Mothers with social phobia show specific parenting difficulties, and their infants show early signs of reduced social responsiveness that are related to both individual infant differences and a lack of maternal encouragement to engage in social interactions.