Low-dose treatment of cervical dystonia, blepharospasm and facial hemispasm with albumin-diluted botulinum toxin type A under EMG guidance. An open label study

Several studies support the hypothesis that low-dose botulinum toxin treatment may be as beneficial as high-dose regimen. Therefore, we studied 115 patients (aged 27-84; mean 58.0, SD = 12.9 years; 68% females, 32% males) suffering from cervical dystonia (n = 66), blepharospasm (n = 28), and facial hemispasm (n = 21) over a period of 2 years in an open label, non-controlled pilot study. Patients received low-dose treatment with botulinum toxin type A (Dysport((R))). The toxin was diluted in 20 ml of 0.1% albumin solution to arrive at a concentration of 25 MU/ml and injected under EMG control. Patients responded to the treatment about 1 week after injection (mean 7.3 days, SD = 4.6). The mean duration of beneficial effects was 11.7 weeks (SD = 5.6). Patients evaluated the clinical global improvement on a scale ranging from 0 to 4. For the whole population, the mean was 2.7 points (SD = 1.1). In none of the subjects could antibodies to botulinum toxin type A be detected, and only a few side effects were observed. In conclusion, low-dose therapy with botulinum toxin A merits further controlled studies.     

Antibody-induced botulinum toxin therapy failure: can it be overcome by increased botulinum toxin doses?

In some patients treated with botulinum toxin type A (BT) therapy failure occurs due to the formation of antibodies against BT (BT-AB). We investigated whether increased BT doses can overcome this form of therapy failure. Eight patients with cervical dystonia, secondary BT therapy failure and evidence of BT-AB formation in the mouse diaphragm bioassay received BT test doses (Dysport, Ipsen Ltd., Maidenhead, Berks, UK) into one of their sternocleidomastoid muscles. Test doses were increased in three steps at 3-month intervals and their effect on the amplitude of the electromyographic activity of the sternocleidomastoid muscle under maximal isometric activation (M-EMG) was measured and compared to a control group. In step 1 (200 or 300 MU) the M-EMG reduction was 12 +/- 13% compared to 85 +/- 10% (200 MU) and 83 +/- 9% (300 MU) in the control group. In step 2 (400, 600 or 800 MU) the M-EMG reduction was 25 +/- 21% compared to 78 +/- 7% (400 MU) in the control group. In step 3 (1,600 or 1,800 MU) the M-EMG reduction was 24 plus minus 10%. Side effects were not observed in any of the patients studied. In 1 patient with partial secondary BT therapy failure, with a low BT-AB titre (0.0015 U/ml) and with a moderately pathological M-EMG reduction of 40% with 200 MU a normal M-EMG reduction of 71% could be regained with 800 MU. In three subsequent therapeutic injection series with quadrupled BT doses in all target muscles the original therapy outcome could be regained and maintained. Side effects or increasing BT-AB titres were not observed. Even massively increased BT doses cannot overcome BT-AB-induced complete secondary therapy failure. However, in patients with partial secondary therapy failure, low BT-AB titres and a moderately pathological M-EMG reduction, increased BT doses might regain and maintain normal BT efficacy without induction of side effects or increasing BT-AB titres.     

Efficacy and safety of botulinum type A toxin (Dysport) in cervical dystonia: results of the first US randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled study.

Botulinum toxin type A (Dysport) has been shown in European studies to be a safe and effective treatment for cervical dystonia. This multicenter, double-blind, randomized, controlled trial assessed the safety and efficacy of Dysport in cervical dystonia patients in the United States. Eighty patients were randomly assigned to receive one treatment with Dysport (500 units) or placebo. Participants were followed up for 4 to 20 weeks, until they needed further treatment. They were assessed at baseline and weeks 2, 4, 8, 12, 16, and 20 after treatment. Dysport was significantly more efficacious than placebo at weeks 4, 8, and 12 as assessed by the Toronto Western Spasmodic Torticollis Rating Scale (10-point vs. 3.8-point reduction in total score, respectively, at week 4; P < or = 0.013). Of participants in the Dysport group, 38% showed positive treatment response, compared to 16% in the placebo group (95% confidence interval, 0.02-0.41). The median duration of response to Dysport was 18.5 weeks. Side effects were generally similar in the two treatment groups; only blurred vision and weakness occurred significantly more often with Dysport. No participants in the Dysport group converted from negative to positive antibodies after treatment. These results confirm previous reports that Dysport (500 units) is safe, effective, and well-tolerated in patients with cervical dystonia.     

Botulinum toxin F in the treatment of torticollis clinically resistant to botulinum toxin A.

Two reports have shown a Japanese preparation of botulinum toxin type F (BTX-F) to be an effective alternative for patients with torticollis who develop clinical resistance to botulinum toxin type A (BTX-A). A group of patients with torticollis, comprising five secondary non-responders and one primary non-responder, were treated with a preparation of BTX-F produced in the UK (Speywood Pharmaceuticals). A low dose of BTX-F (220 mouse units (MU) in total) was given into clinically affected neck muscles, followed six weeks later by an injection of a total of 520 MU. Antibodies to BTX-A (mouse protection assay) were present in all secondary non-responders but not in the primary non-responder. No patients developed atrophy after injection of Dysport BTX-A (40 MU) into the left extensor digitorum brevis muscle whereas pronounced atrophy occurred in all patients after injection of 40 MU of BTX-F into the right extensor digitorum brevis muscle. Three patients improved subjectively after treatment with 220 MU BTX-F and five (all secondary non-responders) after the subsequent dose of 520 MU (two considerably), with reduced Tsui scores, but group scores were only significantly changed after the higher dose. The primary non-responder remained unchanged after both doses of BTX-F. One patient reported mild dysphagia with 520 MU BTX-F. Mean duration of improvement with 520 MU BTX-F was five (range 4-6)weeks. Thus BTX-F provides benefit for BTX-A non-responders with few side effects but for a shorter period than BTX-A, possibly due to relative underdosing. As with BTX-A, biological sensitivity to BTX-F does not necessarily predict a clinical response.     

Respective potencies of Botox and Dysport: a double blind, randomised, crossover study in cervical dystonia

OBJECTIVES: Botulinum toxin type A is a potent neuromuscular paralyzing agent used in various disorders including cervical dystonia. Two preparations of botulinum toxin are now commercially available ( Dysport and Botox), but much controversy remains about their respective potencies. The aim of the study was to compare the efficacy of Botox with two different ratios of Dysport. METHODS: A double blind, randomised, three period cross over study involving 54 patients with cervical dystonia was performed. The patients received the following treatments in a randomised order: Botox at the usually effective dose, Dysport at a dose of 1:3 (conversion factor of 3 between Botox and Dysport units-that is, one Botox unit=three Dysport units) and at a dose of 1:4 (conversion factor of four). The improvement of the Tsui (primary outcome criteria) and of the TWSTRS pain scales between baseline and a control visit 1 month after each of the three injections, as well as the incidence of adverse events, were assessed. RESULTS: Comparison of the Tsui scores and of the TWSTRS pain scores showed a better effect on impairment and pain with Dysport 1:3 (p=0.02 and 0.04, respectively) and 1:4 (p=0.01 and 0.02, respectively) than with Botox. The number of adverse events was higher with both Dysport treatments. The most frequent adverse event was dysphagia, found in 3%, 15.6%, and 17.3% (Botox, Dysport 1:3 and 1:4, respectively) of the patients. No adverse event required withdrawal of therapy or specific management. CONCLUSIONS: Dysport 1:3 (and Dysport 1:4 to a greater extent) is more efficient than Botox for both impairment and pain in cervical dystonia although with a somewhat higher incidence of minor adverse effects. This strongly suggests that the most appropriate conversion factor between Botox and Dysport units is less than 3 in cervical dystonia.     

Botulinum toxin type B for treatment of axillar hyperhidrosis

Recently, botulinum toxin type B (BT-B) became commercially available for treatment of cervical dystonia. It is the aim of this study to explore its use for treatment of bilateral axillar hyperhydrosis (HH). For this we directly compared the antihyperhydrotic effect of BT-B (NeuroBloc)/MyoBloc) with that of botulinum toxin type A (BT-A) (Botox). 9 patients (HD group) received BT-A 100MU unilaterally and BT-B 4000MU contralaterally. 10 patients (LD group) received BT-A 100MU and BT-B 2000MU. All patients were blinded as to which preparation was used in which side. All patients except one reported excellent HH improvement in both axillae. None of the patients had residual HH on clinical examination. The duration of HH improvement until first recurrence in the HD group was 16.0 +/-4.3 weeks in the BT-A treated axillar and 16.4 +/-4.5 weeks in the BT-B treated axillae (Wilcoxon rank-sum test, p = 0.336). In the LD group it was 16.4 +/-5.3 weeks in the BT-B treated axillae and 17.1 +/-5.7 weeks in the BT-A treated axillae (Wilcoxon rank-sum test, p = 0.059). There was also no difference in the duration of HH improvement between the axillae treated with BT-B 4000MU and BT-B 2000MU (Wilcoxon rank-sum test, p = 0.712). 5 out of 9 patients in the HD group (chi-square test, p = 0.025) and 7 out of 10 patients in the LD group (chi-square test, p = 0.008) reported more application discomfort in the BT-B treated axillae. In 6 out of 9 patients in the HD group (chi-square test, p = 0.014) and in 6 out of 10 patients in the LD group (chi-square test, p = 0.014) the onset of HH improvement appeared earlier in the BT-B treated axillae. One patient in the HD group reported dryness of the mouth and eyes and accomodation difficulties.BT-B is a safe and efficient treatment for axillar HH. Doses of BT-B 2000MU per axilla seem sufficient indicating a conversion factor between BT-A and BT-B in the order of 1:20. With a conversion factor for cervical dystonia in the order of 1:40 the autonomic nervous system seems to be relatively more sensitive to BT-B than to BT-A compared with the motor system.     

Botulinum A toxin: Dysport improvement of biological availability

We investigated the efficacy and potency of Dysport, a botulinum neurotoxin type A complex approved for therapy, under various conditions. Conditions for maximal expression of biological activity were explored in vitro in the phrenic nerve-hemidiaphragm preparation, while conditions for optimal distribution of the toxin were tested in vivo in a double blind trial involving volunteers, using the foot Muscles extensor digitorum brevis. In contrast to the recommendations of the manufacturer, the biological availability of Dysport could be enhanced by (1) lowering its concentration, (2) supplementing with albumin, and (3) increasing the injection volume. On the basis of these experimental findings Dysport was diluted to a final concentration of 50 U/ml for therapeutic purposes. In a blind, single crossover study patients suffering from various forms of dystonia were treated with Dysport, first diluted and dosed as suggested by the manufacturer and then with doses cut by approximately 70% in accordance with the experimental findings. The low-dose treatment was as effective as the treatment with the recommended higher doses, but side effects were considerably less apparent. The benefits to be derived from these adjustments include a low risk of antibody formation, which could preclude continued or future treatment and substantial cost savings.     

Mouse diaphragm assay for detection of antibodies against botulinum toxin type B.

With the advent of a commercial preparation of botulinum toxin type B (BT-B) for treatment of cervical dystonia detection of antibodies against BT-B (BT-B-AB) becomes necessary. For this purpose, we carried out a mouse diaphragm assay (MDA) by continuous measurement of the twitch force of a mouse hemidiaphragm preparation elicited by electric stimulation of its phrenic nerve. After exposing the preparation to BT-B 3 ng/ml the time to half-maximal twitch force reduction (paralysis time [PT]) was 69 +/- 4 min (n = 25). Addition of sera from patients with antibodies against BT-A produced a PT of 68 +/- 5 min (n = 24), whereas addition of sera from controls with antibodies against tetanus toxoid produced a PT of 67 +/- 6 min (n = 30). When defined amounts of BT-B-AB were added to the MDA, PT was prolonged. This prolongation was correlated closely to the amount of BT-B-AB added, thus producing a calibration curve. The threshold for BT-B-AB detection was 0.4 mU/ml. When sera from 7 patients (4 women, 3 men; age 50.6 +/- 14.2 years) with cervical dystonia (Toronto Western Spasmodic Torticollis Rating Scale score, 18.9 +/- 2.9) and complete secondary failure of BT-B therapy (NeuroBloc; Elan Pharmaceuticals, Shannon, Ireland; 12,229 +/- 2,601 MU/injection series, 1.86 +/- 0.69 injection series before complete secondary therapy failure; 100.4 +/- 15.8 days between injection series with normal therapeutic effect) were tested, BT-B-AB titers of more than 10 mU/ml were found in all of them. The MDA can be used to measure neutralizing BT-B-AB titers quantitatively and with adequate sensitivity and specificity. Further studies are necessary to understand the role of intermediate BT-B-AB titers in partial BT-B therapy failure.     

The broadening application of chemodenervation in X-linked dystonia-parkinsonism (Part I): muscle afferent block versus botulinum toxin-A in cervical and limb dystonias

Botulinum toxin (BoNT) is an established mainstay treatment for dystonia. However, its use, especially in developing countries, is significantly limited by its cost. Chemodenervation with muscle afferent block (MAB) using lidocaine-ethanol may provide a more cost-effective alternative to traditional BoNT injections. A study comparing MAB with BoNT type-A in cases of X-linked dystonia-Parkinsonism (XDP) having cervical dystonia indicated a modest and short-lived efficacy with MAB, while a more robust efficacy in dystonia and pain parameters, lasting up to 11 weeks, was observed in the two BoNT type-A preparations (Dysport? and Botox?). In another study comparing BoNT type-A formulations for limb dystonia of XDP, a prior MAB was used to select target muscles for toxin injection. During toxin injections in the limb muscles, Dysport? and Botox? did not show significant differences with regard to global severity and disability scales, duration of effect, and adverse event (AE) profile. Dysphagia was the most common AE following BoNT type-A injections in cervical dystonia, while weakness was the most frequent AE noted with injections for limb dystonia. MAB injections carried a high incidence of dizziness and pain during injections. However, because MAB is a more cost-effective alternative that can be given repeatedly, it has been used in the XDP population while awaiting funds for BoNT type-A and/or for selecting muscles for injection as a test drug.     

Long-term follow-up of cervical dystonia patients treated with botulinum toxin A.

We followed the course in 100 consecutive patients with cervical dystonia (CD) after they were initially treated with botulinum toxin (BTX) in the form of Dysport 10 to 12 years ago. A total of 4 patients had died, and 6 were lost to follow-up. Of the remaining 90 patients, 57 (63%) were still treated with BTX. In the patients treated at one centre over the whole period with Dysport, mean dose used during each treatment session was 833 (SD +/- 339) units Dysport with a cumulative dose of 20,943 (SD +/- 9462) units Dysport over a mean of 26.8 (SD +/- 8.6) treatment cycles. Secondary nonresponse was detected in 3 of the 90 patients. During follow-up, 12 patients developed blepharospasm, 13 oromandibular dystonia, and 17 patients writer's cramp. We conclude that BTX remains effective and safe for approximately 60% of CD patients for more than 10 years.     

Efficacy and safety of a standardised 500 unit dose of Dysport (clostridium botulinum toxin type A haemaglutinin complex) in a heterogeneous cervical dystonia population: results of a prospective,multicentre, randomised,double-blind,placebo-controlled,parallel group study

Results from a dose-ranging study in a selected group of de novo patients with rotational cervical dystonia (CD) suggest that 500 units of Dysport (Clostridium botulinum toxin type A haemaglutinin complex) is the optimal starting dose. The present study aimed to confirm the efficacy and safety profile of this dose in a population of CD patients more representative of those seen in a typical dystonia clinic. A total of 68 patients with moderate to severe CD (Tsui score ≥ 9) were randomly assigned to receive placebo or Dysport 500 units. Treatment was administered according to the clinical pattern of head deviation, using a standardised injection protocol. A total of 21 patients (11 Dysport, 10 placebo) had not previously received botulinum toxin type A (BtxA) injections, and 47 patients (24 Dysport, 23 placebo) had received BtxA more than 12 weeks previously. Assessments were performed at baseline and weeks 4, 8 and 16. Patients defined as non-responders at week 4 were re-treated in an open phase with 500 units of Dysport at week 6, and were followed up at week 10. Significant between-group differences in Tsui scores were present at weeks 4 (p=0.001) and 8 (p=0.002). Similarly, there were significant between-group differences (p < 0.001) in patient and investigator assessments of response in favour of Dysport at weeks 4 and 8. Also, more Dysport (49 %) than placebo (33 %) patients were pain-free at week 4 (p=0.02). Overall, 30/35 (86 %) Dysport patients and 14/33 (42 %) placebo patients were classified as responders at week 4. Adverse events were reported by 15/35 Dysport patients and 9/33 placebo patients. Open phase treatment produced improvements in Tsui (p < 0.001) and pain scores (p=0.011), and 23/24 patients were classified as responders. Although individual dose titration and muscle selection is desirable, this study demonstrated that a dose of 500 units of Dysport injected into clinically identified neck muscles without electromyographic guidance is safe and effective in the treatment of patients with the major clinical types of cervical dystonia. Received: 3 October 2000, Received in revised form: 20 March 2001, Accepted: 2 May 2001     

Therapy of dystonia in Japan]

A questionnaire about the treatment of dystonia was sent out to 585 councilors of Societas Neurologica Japonica. One hundred and sixty-eight replies (28.7%) were collected, although some of them were excluded from the analysis because of inappropriateness. 1) The number of patients previously experienced was < 10; 37 respondents (22.7%), 10-50; 83 (50.9%), 50-100; 26 (16.0%), and > 100; 17 (10.4%). 2) Oral medication was most often the first line treatment in either of generalized dystonia, blapharospasm, cervical dystonia, and writer's cramp. Botulinum toxin injection was the first or the second line treatment in 147 (87.5%) and 116 (69.0%) respondents for blepharospasm and cervical dystonia, respectively. In these two conditions, the more experienced doctors tended to prefer botulinum toxin injection to the other treatments as the first choice (Cochran-Armitage analysis; p = 0.003 for blepharospasm and p = 0.002 for cervical dystonia). 3) Among the oral drugs, anticholinergics, especially trihexyphenidyl, were the most frequent choice in generalized dystonia, cervical dystonia, and writer's cramp. For blepharospasm, clonazepam was most favored. Sedatives, especially diazepam, were also often the drug of choice in either of these disorders. The favored drugs were not related to the respondent's experience. 4) The success rate of treatment, designated as the percentage of patients who improved through any treatment so much that the respondent was satisfied with it, was the highest in blepharospasm (65.4 +/- 24.1; mean +/- SD), followed by cervical dystonia (41.2 +/- 23.4), writer's cramp (32.9 +/- 22.5), and generalized dystonia (20.4 +/- 19.8). Only in cervical dystonia, the rate was significantly higher in more experienced respondents (regression analysis; p = 0.008). In blepharospasm (p < 0.001) and cervical dystonia (p = 0.002), regression analysis indicated that the success rate was higher in the group who preferred botulinum toxin injection to oral medication as the first line treatment. These results indicate that in Japan the treatment of choice for dystonia does not always follow the therapeutic guidelines for dystonia proposed in some foreign countries. Adopting more evidence-based rationale of treatment is encouraged, because the recent progress about the treatment of dystonia, e.g. botulinum toxin injection or the stereotaxic surgery, is reshaping dystonia from a devastating to a treatable disorder.     

Botulinum toxin type B de novo therapy of cervical dystonia

Botulinum toxin induced therapy failure type B antibody (BT–B, BT–B–AB) has so far only been reported after previous formation of antibodies against botulinum toxin type A (BT–A, BTA– AB).We wanted to explore the risk of BT-B-AB-induced therapy failure in patients who were exposed to botulinum toxin for the first time. For this purpose we followed nine patients with cervical dystonia receiving BT-B (NeuroBloc^®/Myo- Bloc™, Elan Pharmaceuticals) in a dose of 11435 ± 2977MU during 4.9 ± 3.0 injection series. All patients showed a satisfactory initial therapeutic response as documented by a Toronto Western Spasmodic Torticollis Rating Scale score reduction from 17.7 ± 9.4 to 5.3 ± 4.8 and an overall subjective improvement of 56.1 ± 28.3%. Seven patients experienced systemic anticholinergic side effects. Five patients had stable therapeutic responses over subsequent injection series. Four patients experienced complete therapy failure with BT–B–AB titres in excess of 10mU/ml on the mouse diaphragm assay. Doubling the last effective BT–B dose produced neither therapeutic effects nor side effects. Subsequent applications of botulinum toxin type A produced a continued therapeutic response in one patient and complete therapy failure in the other.Despite the small sample size a frequency of 44 % indicates a high risk for BT–B–AB-induced complete therapy failure. The high amount of neurotoxin administered when NeuroBloc^®/MyoBloc™ is used might be a contributory factor. Further prospective comparative studies are necessary to monitor the frequency and time course of BT–B–AB formation.     

Electromyographic guidance of botulinum toxin treatment in cervical dystonia

We report the results of electromyographic (EMG) guidance in the treatment of cervical dystonia with botulinum toxin. Eight-four patients received a total of 225 injection sessions. Overall there was moderate objective improvement in 78.7%. The mean dose of toxin was 269 +/- 39 mouse lethal units and the mean duration of maximum effect was 107 +/- 49 days. Complications included excessive neck weakness in 16.0% and dysphagia in 11.1% of the injection sessions. We conclude that EMG guidance is a safe and effective method of administering botulinum toxin in the treatment of cervical dystonia.     

Molding the sensory cortex: spatial acuity improves after botulinum toxin treatment for cervical dystonia.

Disorganization of sensory cortical somatotopy has been described in adult onset primary torsion dystonia (AOPTD). Although botulinum toxin type A (BTX-A) acts peripherally, some studies have suggested a central effect. Our primary hypothesis was that sensory cortical reorganization occurs after BTX-A treatment of AOPTD. Twenty patients with cervical dystonia and 18 healthy age-matched control patients had spatial discrimination thresholds (SDTs) measured at baseline and monthly for 3 months. Mean baseline SDT (+/-SD) was 1.75 +/-0.76 mm in the dystonia group, greater than the control group mean of 1.323 +/- 0.45 mm (P = 0.05). Mean control group SDT did not vary significantly over time. A transient improvement of 23% from baseline (P = 0.005) occurred in the dystonia group 1 month after injection, which did not positively correlate with changes in physician and patient ratings of torticollis severity. The presumed mechanism of SDT improvement is a modulation of afferent cortical inputs from muscle spindles. Society.     

Botulinum toxin in cervical dystonia: low dosage with electromyographic guidance

Sixty patients with idiopathic cervical dystonia were treated a total of 240 times with botulinum toxin type A (BTA). Selected muscles were injected with BTA under electromyographic (EMG) guidance. The clinical effect was measured on the Tsui scale and a 10-point anchored visual analogue scale. A dosage of 150–300 mouse units was used in 77% of the treatments (mean 204 mouse units). Based on the Tsui scale, 45% of 240 treatments were still effective at the moment of reinjection (median improvement 2 points). Based on the 10-point anchored visual analogue scale, 73% of treatments were successful (median improvement 3 points). Forty-eight patients (80%) responded favourably to the treatment. Side-effects were mild and transient. Dysphagia occurred in 9% of treatments. Antibody production was investigated in 41 patients and was negative in all. A striking difference from previous reports is the lower dosage used in this study. The clinical response, however, was similar to that of other studies. We conclude that a dosage of 200–400 mouse units BTA (Dysport) may also be effective in the treatment of cervical dystonia, but with fewer side effects. EMG guidance and application of BTA into deep cervical muscles may further improve the clinical effect.     

Prospective study of swallowing function in patients with cervical dystonia undergoing selective peripheral denervation

OBJECTIVE: To characterise swallowing function in patients with cervical dystonia with botulinum toxin treatment failure, before and after selective peripheral denervation surgery. METHODS: Twelve patients with cervical dystonia had a thorough examination including standardised assessment for cervical dystonia, scoring of subjective dysphagia, and videofluoroscopic swallow. Videofluoroscopy was scored by consensus opinion between a speech and language therapist and an independent blinded radiologist using a validated scoring system. RESULTS: Seven patients with cervical dystonia experienced no subjective dysphagia either before or after surgery, although in all these patients there was objective videofluoroscopic evidence of underlying mild to moderate oropharyngeal dysphagia preoperatively and postoperatively. The most common finding was delayed initiation of swallow. Three other patients, also without subjective dysphagia before surgery, developed postoperative dysphagia. In these patients, videofluoroscopy showed a delayed swallow reflex before surgery, which was worse postoperatively in two. The remaining two patients had mild subjective dysphagia before surgery that improved postoperatively in one and deteriorated in the other. In the first, videofluoroscopy was normal preoperatively and postoperatively, and in the second, oral bolus preparation was moderately abnormal preoperatively and swallow initiation was delayed postoperatively. Mean subjective dysphagia scores did not change significantly. Apart from a significant improvement of tongue base retraction, videofluoroscopic scores were not significantly different after surgery. Postoperatively there was significant improvement of overall cervical dystonia severity and abnormal head rotation in the group as a whole. There was no correlation between age, duration of symptoms of cervical dystonia, preoperative or postoperative cervical dystonia severity, subjective dysphagia scores, or videofluoroscopic scores. However, in the five patients with persisting anterior sagittal head shift as part of the torticollis, tongue base retraction was less likely to improve after surgery compared with those without head shift. CONCLUSION: Surgical denervation of dystonic neck muscles, leading to improved neck posture, can also improve tongue base retraction, which is a key component of normal bolus propagation. However, delayed swallow initiation, a common feature in patients with cervical dystonia, can be further compromised by surgery, leading to subjective dysphagia. In general, selective peripheral denervation seems to be a safe procedure with no major compromise of swallowing function.     

Botulinum toxin A (Botox) and sweating-dose efficacy and comparison to other BoNT preparations

BACKGROUND: Botulinum toxin type A (BoNT/A) is 20-50 times more effective than Botulinum toxin type B (BoNT/B) concerning the treatment of muscular hypercontractions [Sloop, R.R., Cole, B.A., Escutin, R.O., 1997. Human response to botulinum toxin injection: type B compared with type A. Neurology 49, 189-194]. Botulinum toxins block motor nerves as well as autonomic fibres [Rand, M.J., Whaler, B.C., 1965. Impairment of sympathetic transmission by botulinum toxin. Nature 206, 588-591]. OBJECTIVE: Purpose of this study was to analyse the dose dependent reduction of sweating using the BoNT/A preparation Botox and to compare the results with our earlier results analysing Dysport [Braune, C., Erbguth, F., Birklein, F., 2001. Dose thresholds and duration of the local anhidrotic effect of botulinum toxin injections: measured by sudometry. Br. J. Dermatol. 144, 111-117] and Neurobloc (BoNT/B) [Birklein, F., Eisenbarth, G., Erbguth, F., Winterholler, M., 2003. Botulinum toxin type B blocks sudomotor function effectively: a 6 month follow up. J. Invest. Dermatol. 121, 1312-1316]. METHODS: Different doses of Botox were injected subcutaneously (n=27 healthy subjects). Planimetrical analyses of the area of anhidrosis and quantitative sudomotor-axon-reflex testing (QSART) were done after 3 weeks, 3 and 6 months. RESULTS: A threshold dose of 1.25 MU Botox led to anhidrotic skin spots after 3 weeks. The duration of anhidrosis was prolonged for 3 months when 17.5 MU and for 6 months when 50 MU were injected. Anhidrotic area size decreased with time (p=0.001), indicating partial recovery at the edges. After 3 weeks, QSART had significantly decreased to 29% of baseline. With doses of 70 MU or more it decreased to zero. After 3 months, QSART had returned to 68% of baseline and after 6 months to 87%. CONCLUSIONS: Botox dose-dependently suppressed sweating. Comparison to Dysport and Neurobloc revealed a strikingly similar efficacy after 3 weeks and 3 months for all preparations. BoNT/A in general induced a more sustained anhidrosis than BoNT/B.     

Sporadic failure of botulinum toxin treatment in usually responsive patients with adductor spasmodic dysphonia

Botulinum toxin (BT) injections into vocalis (thyroarytenoid) muscle is currently considered the first-choice treatment for adductor spasmodic dysphonia, producing improvement for an average period of 3 months. In our experience, sporadic failure of BT efficacy can occur even in patients usually responsive to this therapy. The reasons for these episodes have not been clarified. In a retrospective, open trial, we investigated the effect toxin preparation (Botox or Dysport) and injection monitoring (electromyography or laryngoscopy) on the success rate of BT treatment. We studied 15 patients with adductor dysphonia usually responsive to BT therapy. BT was administered into the vocalis muscle in 112 and 36 injections under electromyographic or laryngoscopic guidance, respectively. Botox and Dysport were used in 106 and 42 sessions, respectively. In 29% of all injections, no subjective or objective changes, nor side effects were observed. Failure rate did not differ using electromyographic (28.6%) or laryngoscopic (30.5%) guidance. Failure rates with Botox and Dysport were 30.2% and 26.2%, respectively, but this difference was not statistically significant. These data suggest that treatment failure may occur regardless of the method of injection and of the drug preparation used, possibly due to mislocalisation of vocal folds. Received: 17 June 2001 / Accepted in revised form: 13 September 2001     

Cervical dystonia: Improved treatment response to botulinum toxin after referral to a tertiary centre and the use of polymyography

RationaleCervical dystonia is the most common form of (primary) dystonia. The first line of treatment for cervical dystonia is intramuscular injections with botulinum toxin. To optimise the response to botulinum toxin proper muscles selection is required. Pre-treatment polymyographic EMG in addition to clinical evaluation is hypothesised to be a good tool to improve muscle selection and treatment outcome.ObjectiveTo determine the efficacy of botulinum toxin treatment after adjacent polymyographic EMG in cervical dystonia patients referred to our tertiary referral centre with an unsatisfactory response to botulinum toxin treatment elsewhere.MethodsWe performed a retrospective analysis of 40 consecutive second opinion cervical dystonia patients. Standard polymyographic EMG was performed before treatment. We retrieved the Tsui scores and subjective evaluations from the first visit, after 12 weeks and after one year of treatment. In addition, we assessed the final outcome of treatment in our centre based on the records and asked the patients for their personal opinion about the effect of referral to our centre on their treatment response.ResultsAfter one year of treatment there was a significant improvement on both the Tsui scores (p < 0.01) and the subjective treatment evaluation (p < 0.001.) On their last visit 60% of the patients still continued treatment with a reasonable to good response.ConclusionA substantial amount of CD patients with an unsatisfactory response to botulinum toxin improved after polymyography and subsequent treatment with botulinum toxin in a tertiary referral centre.