The measurement of psychosis in dementia: a comparison of assessment tools

The precise operational definition of psychosis in dementia lacks consensus, partially owing to incongruence in the various assessment tools used. This study compares assessments of psychotic symptoms in persons with dementia, specifically of hallucinations and delusions, through the 4 most frequently used assessments. Participants were 74 nursing home residents from 9 nursing homes in Israel, diagnosed with dementia. Assessment tools used included the Behavioral Pathology in Alzheimer's Disease Rating Scale (BEHAVE-AD), the Neuropsychiatric Inventory-Nursing Homes (NPI-NH), the Consortium to Establish a Registry for Alzheimer's Disease Behavior Rating Scale for Dementia (CERAD-BRSD), and the Columbia University Scale for Psychopathology in Alzheimer's Disease (CUSPAD). The highest prevalence rates of delusions were found through the CUSPAD, and the lowest through the CERAD-BRSD. Rates identified by the BEHAVE-AD were intermediate and similar to those of the NPI-NH. As for hallucinations, rates indicated by the BEHAVE-AD, the NPI-NH, and the CUSPAD were similar, with small sample-based differences, and higher than those found through the CERAD-BRSD. The CERAD-BRSD, soliciting reports of the fewest specific symptoms, detected the fewest psychotic symptoms. The CUSPAD, soliciting the most items, presented the highest prevalence rates. The BEHAVE-AD and the NPI-NH had similar rates and showed a high convergent validity.     

A double-blind comparison of citalopram and risperidone for the treatment of behavioral and psychotic symptoms associated with dementia.

OBJECTIVE: To compare citalopram and risperidone for the treatment of psychotic symptoms and agitation associated with dementia, with a priori hypotheses that risperidone would be more efficacious for psychosis and citalopram for agitation. METHODS: A 12-week randomized, controlled trial in nondepressed patients with dementia hospitalized because of behavioral symptoms (N = 103) was conducted at the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center. Participants were consecutively recruited on an inpatient unit if they had at least one moderate to severe target symptom (aggression, agitation, hostility, suspiciousness, hallucinations, or delusions). Once they improved sufficiently, they were discharged to nursing homes, personal care homes, or residential homes for continued treatment. Planned pre-post and mixed model analyses of the main outcome measures of Neurobehavioral Rating Scale and Side Effect Rating Scale at baseline and at weekly/biweekly intervals were conducted. RESULTS: Completion rates did not differ for citalopram and risperidone (overall completion rate: 44%). Agitation symptoms (aggression, agitation, or hostility) and psychotic symptoms (suspiciousness, hallucinations, or delusions) decreased in both treatment groups but the improvement did not differ significantly between the two groups. There was a significant increase in side effect burden with risperidone but not with citalopram such that the two groups differed significantly. CONCLUSION: No statistical difference was found in the efficacy of citalopram and risperidone for the treatment of either agitation or psychotic symptoms in patients with dementia. These findings need to be replicated before citalopram or other serotonergic antidepressants can be recommended as alternatives to antipsychotics for the treatment of agitation or psychotic symptoms associated with dementia.     

Correlates of psychotic symptoms among elderly outpatients.

Psychotic symptoms presenting in late life can offer a diagnostic challenge to the clinician. In this study, 140 geriatric outpatients were prospectively examined for psychotic symptoms and assessed on a number of demographic and clinical variables. Cognition was assessed using the Mini-Mental State Exam. Psychiatric diagnoses were made by DSM-III-R criteria. Twenty-seven per cent (N = 38) had psychotic symptoms, delusions being the most common type. Patients with psychosis were significantly more likely to have a previous history of psychosis, to have a lower MMSE and to live in a nursing home. Four diagnoses accounted for 79.5% of all psychotic patients. In order of frequency, these were dementia, major depression, delirium and organic psychosis (organic hallucinosis, organic delusional disorder). Psychotic patients were significantly more likely to have a diagnosis of dementia, delirium or organic psychosis than non-psychotics, but depression was significantly more likely to occur in patients without psychosis. Although psychotic symptoms occur in a variety of illnesses, elderly patients with psychosis should be carefully evaluated for these disorders.     

Agitation and other noncognitive abnormalities in Alzheimer's disease.

Agitation and other noncognitive abnormalities in patients with Alzheimer's disease are present in at least 50% of patients and are a serious problem for caregivers. Agitation can be divided into aggressive agitation, physically nonaggressive agitation, and verbal agitation. Persecutory delusions of suspiciousness and stealing are the most common psychotic symptoms. Auditory and visual hallucinations are also associated with delusions. Similar to delusions are misidentifications, which are false beliefs probably secondary to agnosia. They occur in one third of patients with dementia of the Alzheimer type in the form of the belief that strangers are living in the home and misidentification of the patient's home and reflection in the mirror. Passive personality changes are present early in the disease, whereas agitation and psychotic symptoms occur with disease progression and predict a more rapid rate of cognitive decline. Agitation and wandering are related to more severe cognitive impairment and psychosocial variables, and neurochemical variables that may be related to behavior disturbance require further study. There are few systematic studies of behavioral or environmental interventions for behavioral symptoms in patients with Alzheimer's disease. Current treatment emphasizes education of families, the formation of Alzheimer units in the nursing home, and adjunctive psychotropic agents to treat well-defined target symptoms.     

Prevalence of mental illness in a community nursing home

A research psychiatrist using a standardized interview found that 94% of a random sample of residents at a large, intermediate-care nursing home had mental disorders according to DSM-III criteria. Primary degenerative dementia and multi-infarct dementia were the most common diagnoses. In addition, the majority of demented patients also had noncognitive symptoms such as delusions and hallucinations, and these residents were significantly more likely to have an associated behavioral disorder than were residents without delusions or hallucinations. Replications of these results would point out the need for major revisions in the funding and delivery of psychiatric care for nursing home residents.     

The consequences of non-cognitive symptoms of dementia in medical hospital departments

OBJECTIVE: To our knowledge, there are no studies investigating the non-cognitive symptoms of patients with dementia such as depression, agitation, or delusions among general hospital inpatients. The aim of this study was to investigate the frequency of such non-cognitive symptoms among medical inpatients and to analyze their impact on the length of hospital stay and on admission to nursing homes. METHOD: The sample consisted of 372 elderly inpatients admitted to four internal medical departments (i.e., not including psychiatric wards) in Austria. Patients were investigated by research psychiatrists using the Clinical Interview Schedule. For the analyses of the non-cognitive symptomatology, only marked and severe symptoms were included. To identify predictors for the length of hospital stay and for nursing home placement, multivariate regression procedures were used. RESULTS: Of all inpatients, 27.4% met criteria for dementia according to DSM-III-R. Of those with dementia, 27.8% had marked or severe non-cognitive symptoms. A diagnosis of dementia markedly increased the risk for nursing home referral and prolonged the duration of inpatient treatment. Among the demented, both, cognitive and non-cognitive symptoms turned out to be significant predictors for nursing home placement and for prolonged duration of acute hospital stay, even when controlling for other independent variables. CONCLUSIONS: Non-cognitive symptoms occur frequently among medical inpatients with dementia and considerably increase both the duration of inpatient treatment and the risk of nursing home placement. Since such non-cognitive symptoms are treatable, they should receive attention from the hospital staff.     

The incidence of first-onset psychotic symptoms and paranoid ideation in a representative population sample followed from age 70-90 years. Relation to mortality and later development of dementia

BACKGROUND: Limited data are available on the incidence of psychotic symptoms in the elderly. OBJECTIVE: To elucidate the incidence of first-onset psychotic symptoms in the elderly and their relation to mortality and later development of dementia. METHOD: A population-sample (n = 392) born 1901-1902 was assessed from age 70-90 with psychiatric examinations, medical record reviews and from age 85, also with key-informant interviews. Individuals developing dementia were excluded. RESULT: The cumulative incidence of first-onset psychotic symptoms was 4.8% (8.0% including key-informant reports in the total sample) and 19.8 % in those who survived to age 85. Sixty-four percent of those with first-onset hallucinations later developed dementia, compared to 30% of those with delusions and 25% of those without psychotic symptoms. CONCLUSIONS: One fifth of non-demented elderly who survives up to age 85 develops first-onset psychotic symptoms. Hallucinations predict dementia, but most elderly individuals with first-onset psychotic symptoms do not develop dementia.     

Nonpharmacologic interventions for psychotic symptoms in dementia

This article proposes an initial nomenclature and systematic approach for the nonpharmacologic understanding and treatment of psychotic symptoms in dementia. An analysis of delusions and hallucinations must examine alternative etiologies, including misdiagnosis and misunderstanding, the misinterpretation of reality because of cognitive losses, sensory deprivation and vision loss, ambiguous sensations, and delirium and medical causes. Nonpharmacologic treatments frequently follow directly from etiology, such as improving sensory function via hearing aids or eyeglasses, providing stimulation, changing antecedents prone to misinterpretation (eg, reflections in windows), or circumventing misinterpretations (eg, ensuring that an equivalent object is available so there is no sense of loss or theft). Given the differences between psychotic symptoms in Alzheimer's disease and those in other diseases, the term psychosis should be abandoned for most dementia patients, and assessments of etiology should be developed. Future research should clarify what proportion of symptoms currently identified as psychotic are attributable to related etiologies.     

On two kinds of delusion of reference

Although delusions of reference are one of the most common psychotic symptoms, they have been the focus of little research. The aims of the present research were, first, to determine whether it is possible to identify different kinds of referential delusions reliably and, if so, to investigate associations among them and between these delusions and other positive psychotic symptoms. Participants with a diagnosis of schizophrenia (n=57) were recruited from a volunteer register (n=26) and from inpatient psychiatric wards (n=31). They were interviewed with the Scale for the Assessment of Positive Symptoms (SAPS) except that the questions about ideas and delusions of reference were replaced with questions targeted at seven particular delusions and three content areas. Ratings were made independently by two assessors. Agreement between the assessors was high for all of the delusions of reference and other psychotic symptoms. A factor analysis of these ratings revealed two factors that represent delusions of communication and delusions of observation. Only delusions of observation were associated with hallucinations and persecutory ideation. Delusions of communication showed few significant correlations with other symptoms and therefore appear to require different explanations.     

Apolipoprotein E epsilon 4, other risk factors, and course of Alzheimer's disease.

BACKGROUND: The epsilon 4 allele of apolipoprotein E (apoE epsilon 4) is associated with late-onset Alzheimer's disease (AD), but its relationship to various aspects of AD has become increasingly unclear. We studied the relationship of apoE genotype in AD to educational attainment, history of heart disease or head injury, age of onset, gender, severity of illness, depression, psychotic symptoms, rate of dementia progression, and time from initial evaluation to nursing home placement. METHODS: ApoE epsilon 4 genotype was determined for 97 clinically diagnosed AD patients and 61 neuropathologically confirmed cases of AD. RESULTS: Presence of one or more epsilon 4 alleles occurred in 66% of AD cases as compared with 27% in control subjects (allele frequency was .40 for AD, .15 for control subjects). Among AD subjects there was no significant relationship between epsilon 4 alleles and educational attainment, history of heart disease, head injury, age of onset, severity of illness, depression, history of depression, rate of dementia progression, or time to nursing home placement. Marginal correlations emerged between number of epsilon 4 alleles, and delusions (p = .05) and hallucinations (p = .05). There was a trend toward increased epsilon 4 homozygosity in patients with onset between ages 65 and 70 years. CONCLUSIONS: We did not find that individuals with one or two apoE epsilon 4 alleles differed significantly in clinical course of AD from those without epsilon 4 except for a trend toward increased psychotic symptoms in the group as a whole and an increase in epsilon 4 homozygosity in patients with reported symptom onset in the late 60s.     

Association of impaired reality processing with psychotic symptoms in schizophrenia

Reality evaluation (i.e., the discrimination of things existing outside of oneself and figments of others' imagination) may be impaired in patients with schizophrenia, and impairment in reality evaluation may be related to psychotic symptoms such as hallucinations and delusions. In this study, we investigated the nature of impairment of reality processing and its relationship with hallucinations and delusions in schizophrenia. Twenty-six patients with schizophrenia and 25 healthy controls completed the reality evaluation task, in which subjects judged whether scenes in a series of drawings were real or unreal and whether they were familiar or novel. The patient group exhibited significantly lower accuracy in reality evaluation than the control group, and lower accuracy in the patient group was related to more severe hallucinations and delusions. These findings provide preliminary evidence that impaired reality evaluation is related to the formation or maintenance of hallucinations and delusions in schizophrenia.     

Long-term follow-up and phenomenologic differences distinguish among late-onset schizophrenia, late-life depression, and progressive dementia.

OBJECTIVE: The diagnosis of patients with late-life onset of hallucinations and delusions but an absence of mood or cognitive disorder remains controversial. The authors used long-term follow-up and phenomenology to assess whether outcome varied by diagnosis. METHODS: Twenty-eight individuals with late-life psychosis but no mood or cognitive disorder were compared with 48 individuals with late-life major depression and 47 individuals with psychotic symptoms and late-life dementia. All subjects were followed for a minimum of 1 year. Data from the last time examined were used to determine likelihood of death at 84 months by Kaplan-Meier analysis in all groups and the likelihood of developing dementia in the depression and late-life onset psychosis groups at 120 months. RESULTS: Patients with dementia-plus-psychosis were more likely to die at 84 months than those with major depression or late-onset hallucinations and delusions. Subjects with depression or late-onset hallucinations and delusions did not differ in likelihood of developing dementia at 120 months. CONCLUSIONS: These results support the hypothesis that a condition characterized by psychiatric symptoms and no mood symptoms can begin in later life and that this disorder is not a precursor to dementia.     

Characteristics and outcomes of dementia residents in an assisted living facility

BACKGROUND: Assisted living (AL) is the fastest growing segment of residential long-term care in the US. At least half of the estimated 1 million AL residents have dementia or cognitive impairment, with many AL facilities offering specialized dementia services. Little research has been done on the demographics, outcomes, or clinical variables of this population.METHODS: Participants were a cohort of 144 residents admitted to the AL unit of Copper Ridge, a specialized dementia-care facility. Comparison samples included 737 patients with dementia residing in other locations (home, nursing home, and other assisted living facilities). Selected measures of cognition, behavior, medical health, and function were taken at admission to AL and at 6-month intervals.RESULTS: When compared with residents of the dementia-specialized AL facility, dementia patients at home were younger, less cognitively impaired, and less likely to exhibit wandering, delusions, or aggression. Residents of a dementia-specialized nursing home had more cognitive impairment, greater medical comorbidity, and were more dependent on caregivers. The 2-year mortality rate in the dementia-specialized AL was 23%, significantly lower than rates reported for nursing homes. Primarily due to increasing care needs, most residents in the specialized AL relocated to a nursing home after a median stay of 10.9 months. Depression, falling, and wandering were significant predictors of the transition.CONCLUSION: Dementia-specialized AL facilities occupy a unique position in the long-term care continuum that is distinct from home-care and nursing home facilities. This research is the first step toward understanding the significant dementia population residing in assisted living.     

Cognitive deficits of patients with Alzheimer's disease with and without delusions.

OBJECTIVE: The goal of this investigation was to study the prevalence of delusions in Alzheimer's disease and to compare the performance of the delusional and nondelusional groups on a neuropsychological test battery. METHOD: The authors studied 107 patients with Alzheimer's disease and 51 age- and education-comparable normal subjects using a standardized psychiatric interview and a neuropsychological test battery. RESULTS: Thirty-seven patients with Alzheimer's disease had delusions with or without hallucinations. Patients with delusions were significantly more impaired than those without delusions (and the normal comparison group) on the Mini-Mental State examination; Blessed Information-Memory-Concentration Test; Dementia Rating Scale, especially its conceptualization and memory subtests; and a test of verbal fluency. The delusional group also tended to be somewhat more impaired than the nondelusional group on the modified Wisconsin Card Sorting Test and the similarities subtest of the Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale-revised. CONCLUSIONS: Approximately one-third of patients with Alzheimer's disease had developed psychotic symptoms sometime after the onset of dementia. The presence of psychotic symptoms in Alzheimer's disease was associated with greater cognitive impairment, especially frontal/temporal dysfunction, and possibly with a more rapidly progressive dementia.     

Phantom boarder symptom in dementia

OBJECTIVE: Phantom boarder symptom (PBS), which has been labelled a misidentification and is commonly observed in cases of Alzheimer's disease, is the perceptual dysfunction where it is imagined that there are people in the home. It may also be encountered in cases of vascular dementia and other variants of this cognitive dysfunction. This study was undertaken to investigate PBS frequency and characteristics for a sample of dementia inpatients, and to determine the strength of the association with other psychotic symptoms. METHODS: The sample population consisted of 240 dementia patients admitted to our geropsychiatric ward. Patients with and without PBS were compared in terms of general characteristics and psychotic symptoms. RESULTS: Of the 240 dementia patients, PBS was identified in 56 (23.3%). There were no significant gender differences between the PBS and non-PBS groups. Means for age and onset-age were higher for the PBS group, and the prevalence of hallucinations and other misidentifications was greater compared to the non-PBS analog. Occurrence of PBS was not significantly associated with delusions or physical aggression. CONCLUSIONS: PBS is a common symptom in dementia of various etiologies. Our association findings suggest that it may be more productive to classify PBS as a type of misidentification, instead of as a delusion.     

Understanding the Delusion of Theft

The elderly with dementing illness often present with psychotic symptoms such as delusions, but the thematic content of delusions in the elderly differs from that of delusions expressed by younger individuals, and can be pathognomonic of early dementia. The aim of this paper is to review the recent literature on the delusion of theft, the most prevalent delusion in the elderly, in order to arrive at a deeper understanding of its sources and to identify successful therapeutic approaches. The literature from 2000 to the present was searched on the Google Scholar database using relevant search terms. Several older classical papers were also referenced. Understanding the origins of the delusion of theft – multiple losses, attempts at attributing such losses to an outside source, attempts at reliving a happier past – helps in devising responses that are comforting to the patient. The distress that often accompanies the delusion of having been robbed can be decreased by nursing home improvements in the handling of personal possessions, by the correction of sensory deficits, and by the provision of activities that distract from loneliness. Attention to stimuli that trigger the delusion helps to limit its occurrence. Medications may help, but can sometimes make matters worse. Understanding that delusional thinking can arise from sensory and cognitive deficits is critical to empathic caregiving and also to the lessening of caregiver burden.     

Classification of psychotic symptoms in dementia sufferers

Little attention has been payed to the classification of psychotic symptoms in dementia sufferers. This article compares the etiology of delusions, visual hallucinations and delusional misidentification and examines the value of factors generated from principal components analysis as a possible classificatory system in a group of 125 patients with DSM-III-R dementia in contact with clinical services who were prospectively evaluated using standardized instruments to describe in detail individual psychotic symptoms. The assessment also included the Geriatric Mental State Schedule, the History and Aetiology Schedule and the CAMCOG. Delusions and visual hallucinations had a distinct cognitive profile as did delusions and delusional misidentification, although there was an overlap between visual hallucinations and delusional misidentification. Four factors were generated from principal components analysis. Three of these closely mirrored the 3 symptom groups delusions, visual hallucinations and delusional misidentification, although the phantom-boarder delusion was correlated with the visual hallucination factor and not delusional misidentification. The fourth factor included visual hallucinations of relatives and delusions that relatives were in the house. This factor was strongly inversely associated with emotional distress and could perhaps best be seen as a comfort phenomena. The pattern of cognitive deficits and etiological associations of each of the factors were independent of one another, supporting the notion that it is useful to consider them as separate entities.     

AGE AND PSYCHOSIS IN DEGENERATIVE DEMENTIA

Among psychiatric inpatients with primary degenerative dementia, those with psychotic symptoms (N=20) were older than those without (N=20) (t=3.48; p<0.001). Persecutory delusions were the most frequent psychotic phenomena. Duration of dementia overlapped, but scores on the Global Deterioration Scale and the Cornell Scale for Depression in Dementia were lower in the psychotic group after correcting for age. The limited literature concerning demographic and clinical correlates of psychosis in dementia is reviewed; the age difference noted is consistent with two other reports. © 1997 by John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.