ONYX-015 works synergistically with chemotherapy in lung cancer cell lines and primary cultures freshly made from lung cancer patients

p53 mutations and loss of heterozygosity (LOH) have been detected in >50% of lung cancers. Wild-type p53 can prevent replication of damaged DNA and promote apoptosis of cells with abnormal DNA. A human adenovirus, ONYX-015, which has a deletion in the E1B region, has shown tumor-specific cytolytic effect in tumor cells with nonfunctional p53 and antitumor efficacy that can be augmented by chemotherapeutic agents. A recent report from an independent group, however, indicates that wild-type p53 is necessary for the infection of this replicating virus, and it is in direct contradiction to previous observations of the ONYX group. In this study, we carried out cytopathic effect (CPE) assays using ONYX-015 on five human lung cancer cell lines with known p53 status. Two of these cell lines, NCI-H522 and NCI-H1703, have mutations and LOH in their p53 gene. Both lines were lysed in a dose-dependent manner and showed 100% cytolysis at a multiplicity of infection of 0.1. Two additional cell lines, NCI-H2347 and NCI-H838, both of which have wild-type p53 gene, showed near complete lysis at a multiplicity of infection of 1. We demonstrate here that the lung cancer cells with nonfunctional p53 are at least 10 times more sensitive to ONYX-015 cytolysis than the lung cancer cells with wild-type p53. In addition, standard chemotherapeutic agents (paclitaxol and cisplatin) showed a synergistic effect when combined with ONYX-015, and this effect was p53 mutant dependent. Furthermore, we tested the cytolytic effect of ONYX-015 on a panel (n = 7) of primary first-passage cultures made from freshly resected lung cancers. ONYX-015 lysed primary lung cancer cells in six of seven (86 %) primary cultures. Two of four primary cultures treated with chemotherapeutic agents had a synergistic effect with ONYX-015. Our data indicate that wild-type p53 is not required for the infection of this replicating virus, and also we demonstrate that ONYX-015 is effective alone and works synergistically with chemotherapeutic agents in lung cancer cell lines and primary cultures. This study suggests that ONYX-015 may be effective, especially in combination with conventional chemotherapy, in the treatment of patients with lung cancer.     

In vivo antitumor activity of ONYX-015 is influenced by p53 status and is augmented by radiotherapy

The E1B-deleted, replication-competent ONYX-015 (dl1520) adenovirus was originally described as being able to selectively kill p53-deficient cells due to a requirement of p53 inactivation for efficient viral replication. This hypothesis has become controversial because subsequent in vitro studies have demonstrated that the host range specificity of ONYX-015 is independent of p53 gene status. Using a pair of isogenic cell lines that differ only in their p53 status, we demonstrate here that although ONYX-015 can replicate in both p53 wild-type and mutant cells in vitro, the virus demonstrates significantly greater antitumor activity against mutant p53 tumors in vivo. Moreover, ONYX-015 viral therapy can be combined with radiation to improve tumor control beyond that of either monotherapy. The results demonstrate that ONYX-015 can discern in vivo between tumors having a different p53 status and that it may be an effective neoadjuvant to radiation therapy.     

Selective replication and oncolysis in p53 mutant tumors with ONYX-015, an E1B-55kD gene-deleted adenovirus, in patients with advanced head and neck cancer: a phase II trial

ONYX-015 is an E1B-55kDa gene-deleted adenovirus engineered to selectively replicate in and lyse p53-deficient cancer cells. To evaluate the selectivity of ONYX-015 replication and cytopathic effects for the first time in humans, we carried out a Phase II clinical testing of intratumoral and peritumoral ONYX-015 injection in 37 patients with recurrent head and neck carcinoma. Patients received ONYX-015 at a daily dose of 1 x 10(10) plaque-forming units (pfu) via intratumoral injection for 5 days during week 1 of each 3-week cycle (n = 30; cohort A), or 1 x 10(10) pfu twice a day for 10 days during weeks 1 and 2 of each 3-week cycle. Posttreatment biopsies documented selective ONYX-015 presence and/or replication in the tumor tissue of 7 of 11 patients biopsied on days 5-14, but not in immediately adjacent normal tissue (0 of 11 patients; P = 0.01). Tissue destruction was also highly selective; significant tumor regression (>50%) occurred in 21% of evaluable patients, whereas no toxicity to injected normal peritumoral tissues was demonstrated. p53 mutant tumors were significantly more likely to undergo ONYX-015-induced necrosis (7 of 12) than were p53 wild-type tumors (0 of 7; P = 0.017). High neutralizing antibody titers did not prevent infection and/or replication within tumors. ONYX-015 is the first genetically engineered replication-competent virus to demonstrate selective intratumoral replication and necrosis in patients. This agent demonstrates the promise of replication-selective viruses as a novel therapeutic platform against cancer.     

Intravenous administration of ONYX-015, a selectively replicating adenovirus, induces antitumoral efficacy.

Replication-incompetent viral vectors are being developed for the gene therapy of cancer. Although some of these may eventually be proven to have significant localized antitumoral activity, none to date have been shown to infect and cause regression of established tumors following i.v. administration. Because cancer is a systemic disease in almost all fatal cases, the lack of i.v. efficacy is a major limitation to treatment with replication-incompetent viral vectors. ONYX-015 (d11520) is an attenuated adenovirus that replicates in and causes selective lysis of cancer cells. We carried out i.v. efficacy and distribution studies in nude mice with s.c. and intraparenchymal tumor xenografts. ONYX-015 infected and replicated efficiently within tumors following i.v. administration. Viral titers in livers were relatively high 3 h after administration but decreased rapidly, becoming undetectable after 24 h. Effective antitumor doses were not associated with hepatic toxicity. Viral replication within tumors was associated with regressions in several tumor models. Selectively replicating viruses like ONYX-015 hold promise as agents to treat metastatic cancer.     

Late viral RNA export, rather than p53 inactivation, determines ONYX-015 tumor selectivity

ONYX-015 is an adenovirus that lacks the E1B-55K gene product for p53 degradation. Thus, ONYX-015 was conceived as an oncolytic virus that would selectively replicate in p53-defective tumor cells. Here we show that loss of E1B-55K leads to the induction, but not the activation, of p53 in ONYX-015-infected primary cells. We use a novel adenovirus mutant, ONYX-053, to demonstrate that loss of E1B-55K-mediated late viral RNA export, rather than p53 degradation, restricts ONYX-015 replication in primary cells. In contrast, we show that tumor cells that support ONYX-015 replication provide the RNA export function of E1B-55K. These data reveal that tumor cells have altered mechanisms for RNA export and resolve the controversial role of p53 in governing ONYX-015 oncolytic selectivity.     

53基因及CAR受体对ONYX-015肿瘤杀伤作用的影响

目的:利用肿瘤特异性增殖型腺病毒ONYX-015分别感染具有柯萨奇病毒和腺病毒联合受体(CAR)水平正常、p53正常或突变的,以及CAR水平低下、p53突变的肿瘤细胞株,研究ONYX 015对这些肿瘤细胞的特异性增殖及杀伤能力。方法:以正常的肝细胞株L02作为对照,用细胞病变效应(CPE)实验观察ONYX-015对细胞的选择性杀伤效应;病毒增殖实验检测野生型腺病毒(Ad5)、ONYX 015在多种肿瘤细胞中的增殖能力。结果:ONYX 015对正常的肝细胞L02无杀伤性,但能够有效地杀伤p53突变的肝癌细胞Hep3B、p53正常的肝癌细胞HepG2及肺癌细胞A549,不能杀伤p53突变的人乳腺癌细胞株MDA-MB 231。在CAR受体水平正常的癌细胞株Hep3B、HepG2和A549中,Ad5和ONYX-015均可增殖。在CAR受体水平低下、p53突变的人乳腺癌细胞株MDA-MB 231中,两种病毒均不增殖。结论:CAR受体对ONYX-015的增殖力起着至关重要的作用。在CAR受体水平正常的前提下,无论肿瘤细胞的p53基因正常与否,ONYX-015均可以有效增殖并杀伤细胞;相反,如果CAR受体水平低下,即使该种肿瘤细胞p53基因突变,ONYX-015在该细胞中的增殖力也会受到限制。ONYX-015不杀伤CAR受体及p53基因均正常的正常肝细胞。     

The dl1520 virus is found preferentially in tumor tissue after direct intratumoral injection in oral carcinoma.

PURPOSE: dl1520 (also known as Onyx-015) is an E1B-deleted adenovirus designed to selectively lyse p53-deficient cancer cells. Clinical trials involving patients with recurrent squamous cell carcinoma of the head and neck have shown clinical efficacy, but no direct evidence as to the tumor or p53 selectivity of the virus was demonstrated. We wanted to determine whether dl1520 is selective for survival and replication within tumor tissue after direct injection and whether this is determined by p53 status of the tissues. We also wanted to ascertain whether the virus has any macroscopic effect on normal tissue. EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN: An open-label Phase II trial was devised in which a fixed dose of the virus was administered to 15 patients via a direct intertumoral injection before surgery for untreated oral squamous cell carcinoma. The agent was also delivered into an area of adjacent normal buccal mucosa. Specimens of the excised tumor and of biopsies of the injected normal tissue were assessed for viral presence and p53 status. RESULTS: We demonstrated that the virus replicates selectively in tumor as opposed to normal tissue after this direct injection. It was not possible to determine whether this selectivity was p53 related. It was found that dl1520 triggers an early rise in apoptosis levels in injected normal tissues. No adverse effects of viral injection were noted. CONCLUSIONS: This is the first report of injection of dl1520 into previously untreated squamous cell cancer. The data support the concept that dl1520 is replication deficient in normal, compared with cancerous, tissues and has potential as a selective anticancer agent against tumor tissues.     

Infectivity and expression of the early adenovirus proteins are important regulators of wild-type and DeltaE1B adenovirus replication in human cells.

An adenovirus mutant lacking the expression of the large E1B protein (DeltaE1B) has been reported to replicate selectively in cells lacking the expression of functionally wild-type (wt) p53. Based on these results the DeltaE1B or ONYX-015 virus has been proposed to be an oncolytic virus which might be useful to treat p53-deficient tumors. Recently however, contradictory results have been published indicating that p53-dependent cell death is required for productive adenovirus infection. Since there is an urgent need for new methods to treat aggressive, mutant p53-expressing primary tumors and their metastases we carefully examined adenovirus replication in human cells to determine whether or not the DeltaE1B virus can be used for tumor therapy. The results we present here show that not all human tumor cell lines take up adenovirus efficiently. In addition, we observed inhibition of the expression of adenovirus early proteins in tumor cells. We present evidence that these two factors rather than the p53 status of the cell determine whether adenovirus infection results in lytic cell death. Furthermore, the results we obtained by infecting a panel of different tumor cell lines show that viral spread of the DeltaE1B is strongly inhibited in almost all p53-proficient and -deficient cell lines compared to the wt virus. We conclude that the efficiency of the DeltaE1B virus to replicate efficiently in tumor cells is determined by the ability to infect cells and to express the early adenovirus proteins rather than the status of p53.     

Elucidation of the molecular mechanism underlying tumor-selective replication of the oncolytic adenovirus mutant ONYX-015

Tumor-selective replicating viruses offer appealing advantages over conventional cancer therapy. ONYX-015 (dl1520) is the prototype for oncolytic adenoviral therapy. It has undergone extensive clinical testing with proven safety and evidence of promising clinical efficacy. The strategy underlying its tumor-selective cell killing is based on deletion of the viral E1B-55K gene, which is crucial for efficient viral replication in normal cells but dispensable in tumor cells. Originally, the successful replication of ONYX-015 was thought to strictly depend on deregulated p53 signaling in tumor cells. However, recent preclinical as well as clinical evidence questions this mechanism. The study by O'Shea and colleagues is of immense importance as it sheds new light into the molecular mechanism underlying the tumor-selective replication of ONYX-015. Based on these findings, modulation of the proposed molecular mechanism by pharmacologic agents or hyperthermia may largely enhance the therapeutic index of ONYX-015 for tumor cells versus normal tissue and improve clinical efficacy. Finally, new strategies to allow successful patient stratification for future clinical trials appear to be in reach, based on the reported results.     

Phase I trial of intraperitoneal injection of the E1B-55-kd-gene-deleted adenovirus ONYX-015 (dl1520) given on days 1 through 5 every 3 weeks in patients with recurrent/refractory epithelial ovarian cancer.

PURPOSE: Resistance to chemotherapy in ovarian cancer is frequently associated with mutations in the p53 gene. The adenovirus dl1520 (ONYX-015) with the E1B 55-kd gene deleted, allowing selective replication in and lysis of p53-deficient tumor cells, has shown preclinical efficacy against p53-deficient nude mouse-human ovarian carcinomatosis xenografts. PATIENTS AND METHODS: We undertook a phase I trial of intraperitoneal dl1520 in patients with recurrent ovarian cancer. Sixteen women with recurrent/refractory ovarian cancer received 35 cycles (median, two cycles) of dl1520 delivered on days 1 through 5 in four dose cohorts: 1 x 10(9) plaque forming units (pfu), 1 x 10(10) pfu, 3 x 10(10) pfu, and 1 x 10(11) pfu. RESULTS: The most common significant toxicities related to virus administration were flu-like symptoms, emesis, and abdominal pain. One patient receiving 1 x 10(10) pfu developed common toxicity criteria grade 3 abdominal pain and diarrhea, which was dose-limiting. The maximum-tolerated dose was not reached at 10(11) pfu, and at this dose level patients did not experience significant toxicity. There was no clear-cut evidence of clinical or radiologic response in any patient. Blood samples were taken for adenovirus DNA and neutralizing antibodies. Polymerase chain reaction data indicating presence of virus up to 10 days after the final (day 5) infusion of dl1520 are suggestive of continuing viral replication. CONCLUSION: This article therefore describes the first clinical experience with the intraperitoneal delivery of any replication-competent/-selective virus in cancer patients.     

Oncolytic activity of the E1B-55 kDa-deleted adenovirus ONYX-015 is independent of cellular p53 status in human malignant glioma xenografts

Treatment of malignant gliomas remains a major challenge in adults and children because of high treatment failure. The E1B 55 kDa-gene deleted adenovirus, ONYX-015 (ONYX Pharmaceuticals), was demonstrated to replicate selectively in and lyse tumor cells. Currently ongoing clinical trials of ONYX-015 in head and neck tumors are promising. Here, we demonstrate ONYX-015-mediated cell lysis and antitumor activity in three of four s.c. human malignant glioma xenografts deriving from primary tumors. Intratumoral injections of ONYX-015, 1 x 10(8) plaque-forming units daily for 5 consecutive days, yielded significant tumor growth delay in the p53 mutant xenografts IGRG88 and the p53 wild-type IGRG93 and IGRG121 treated at an advanced tumor stage. The p53 wild-type tumors IGRG93 and IGRG121 experienced 45% and 82% complete tumor regressions. Four and 8 of 11 animals, respectively, survived tumor free 4 months after treatment. Widespread intratumoral adenoviral replication was observed in tumor cells of these two xenografts compared with only scattered replication in the p53-mutant tumors. In addition to a fast tumor growth rate, wild-type p53 status was associated with increased antitumor activity of the E1B-attenuated virus, and induction of functional p53 may therefore determine adenoviral cytolysis in tumor cells. In conclusion, ONYX-015 displayed a major antitumor activity in human xenografts derived from primary malignant glioma supporting its development in the treatment of these highly malignant tumors.     

Heat shock phenocopies E1B-55K late functions and selectively sensitizes refractory tumor cells to ONYX-015 oncolytic viral therapy

ONYX-015 is an E1B-55K-deleted adenovirus that has promising clinical activity as a cancer therapy. However, many tumor cells fail to support ONYX-015 oncolytic replication. E1B-55K functions include p53 degradation, RNA export, and host protein shutoff. Here, we show that resistant tumor cell lines fail to provide the RNA export functions of E1B-55K necessary for ONYX-015 replication; viral 100K mRNA export is necessary for host protein shutoff. However, heat shock rescues late viral RNA export and renders refractory tumor cells permissive to ONYX-015. These data indicate that heat shock and late adenoviral RNAs may converge upon a common mechanism for their export. Moreover, these data suggest that the concomitant induction of a heat shock response could significantly improve ONYX-015 cancer therapy.     

Efficacy with a replication-selective adenovirus plus cisplatin-based chemotherapy: dependence on sequencing but not p53 functional status or route of administration.

Replication-selective adenoviruses are being developed as novel anticancer therapeutics. Clinical trials with dl 1520, an E1B-Mr 55,000 gene-deleted adenovirus (ONYX-015), have demonstrated selective viral replication and biological activity in head and neck and ovarian carcinomas, but durable objective responses were not demonstrated. However, clinical results suggested potentially synergistic interactions with platinum-containing chemotherapy. To better characterize and optimize this interaction, we carried out combined modality treatment with ONYX-015 and cisplatin-based chemotherapy in three nude mouse-human tumor xenograft models with differing tumor locations or p53 functional status. Superior efficacy was demonstrated with combination therapy over either agent alone in all three models, independent of the route of ONYX-015 administration (intratumoral or i.p.). Virus replication was not demonstrably inhibited by cisplatin plus 5-fluorouracil chemotherapy. To assess the role of p53 function or cisplatin resistance in this interaction, we treated ovarian carcinomas that were matched except for p53 functional status (A2780, A2780/CP70). Combination therapy led to improved survival over either agent alone in both the p53(-) and the p53(+) carcinomatosis models. Efficacy was highly dependent on the sequencing of the agents; treatment with ONYX-015 prior to, or simultaneously with, chemotherapy was significantly superior to chemotherapy followed by ONYX-015. These results support further evaluation of replication-selective adenoviruses and cisplatin-based chemotherapy in clinical trials.     

ONYX-015 selectivity and the p14ARF pathway.

ONYX-015, dl1520, is an adenovirus that lacks the E1B 55K gene and therefore lacks the capacity to neutralize p53 during infection. This virus induces high levels of p53 and fails to grow efficiently in primary epithelial cells. However, it does replicate in many tumor cells, including those expressing wild-type p53. In these cells, ONYX-015 fails to induce active p53. This is because the pathway from Ela to p53 is disrupted through loss of p14ARF. We propose that high levels of Mdm2 activity resulting from loss of p14ARF, and high levels of Mdm2 protein resulting from activated Ras prevent accumulation of functional p53 during infection of tumor cells that retain wild-type p53.     

Phase II clinical trial of intralesional administration of the oncolytic adenovirus ONYX-015 in patients with hepatobiliary tumors with correlative p53 studies.

PURPOSE: ONYX-015 is a genetically modified adenovirus with a deletion of the E1B early gene and is therefore designed to replicate preferentially in p53-mutated cells. A Phase II trial of intralesional ONYX-015 was conducted in patients with hepatobiliary tumors to determine the safety and efficacy of such a treatment. EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN: All patients had biopsy-proven, measurable tumors of the liver, gall bladder, or bile ducts that were beyond the scope of surgical resection. Patients received intralesional injections of ONYX-015 at either 6 x 10(9) or 1 x 10(10) plaque-forming units/lesion up to a total dose of 3 x 10(10) plaque-forming units, and i.p. injections were allowed in patients with malignant ascites. The status of p53 was assessed by immunohistochemistry or Affymetrix GeneChip microarray analysis. Studies were conducted for viral shedding and for the presence of antiadenoviral antibodies before and after the injection of ONYX-015. Patients were assessed for response and toxicity. RESULTS: Twenty patients were enrolled, and 19 patients were eligible. Half of the patients had primary bile duct carcinomas. Serious toxicities (> grade 2) were uncommon and included hepatic toxicity (three patients), anemia (one patient), infection (one patient), and cardiac toxicity (one patient, atrial fibrillation). Sixteen patients were evaluable for response. Among these evaluable patients, 1 of 16 (6.3%) had a partial response, 1 of 16 (6.3%) had prolonged disease stabilization (49 weeks), and 8 of 16 (50%) had a >50% reduction in tumor markers. Of the 19 eligible patients, 18 (94.7%) had specimens available for p53 analysis. Fifteen of these 18 patients (83.3%) had evidence of p53 mutation by one or both methods, although the methods correlated poorly. Viral shedding was confined to bile (two of two patients) and ascites (four of four patients). Pretreatment adenoviral antibodies were present in 14 of 14 patients and increased by 33.2% after ONYX-015 treatment. CONCLUSIONS: Intralesional treatment with ONYX-015 in patients with hepatobiliary tumors is safe and well tolerated, and some patients had evidence of an anticancer effect. The high incidence of p53 mutations in these tumors makes this a logical population in which to test this therapy but precludes definitive evaluation about the necessity of a p53 mutation for ONYX-015 clinical activity.     

p14(ARF) modulates the cytolytic effect of ONYX-015 in mesothelioma cells with wild-type p53

ONYX-015 has been reported to kill selectively tumor cells lacking functional p53. Genetic alterations of INK4a/ARF locus, which is a predominant event in malignant pleural mesothelioma, may result in loss of p14(ARF) and subsequent disruption of p53 pathway in cancer cells. In the present study, ONYX-015 was able to kill three mesothelioma cell lines (H28, H513, and 211H) with wild-type p53 but lacking p14(ARF). In contrast, MS-1 mesothelioma cells, which expressed both p53 and p14(ARF), were resistant to ONYX-015. Introducing p14(ARF) gene into the H28 cell, a mesothelioma cell without p14(ARF) expression, significantly increased the resistance of this cell line to the cytolytic effect of ONYX-015. Our results suggest that human mesotheliomas with wild-type p53 yet lacking p14(ARF) are potential candidates for ONYX-015 therapy.     

Cancer cell death enhances the penetration and efficacy of oncolytic herpes simplex virus in tumors

The success of tumor oncolytic virotherapy is limited by the poor penetration of virus in tumors. Interstitial collagen fibers and the narrow spacing between cancer cells are major barriers hindering the movement of large viral particles. To bypass the cellular barrier, we tested the hypothesis that the void space produced by cancer cell apoptosis enhances the initial spread and efficacy of oncolytic herpes simplex virus (HSV). In mice with mammary tumors, apoptosis was induced by doxycycline-regulated expression/activation of CD8/caspase-8, paclitaxel, or paclitaxel plus tumor necrosis factor-related apoptosis-inducing ligand (TRAIL). In both collagen-poor and collagen-rich tumors, apoptosis or necrosis increased the initial intratumoral spread of HSV. Compared with the isolated pattern of HSV infection generally located in the center of control tumors, apoptosis induction and a single i.t. injection of virus produced an interconnected and diffuse pattern of infection, which extended from the tumor center to the periphery. This interconnected pattern of viral infection correlated with the formation of void spaces and channel-like structures in apoptosis-rich tumor areas. We also show that the i.t. injection of HSV after caspase-8 activation or paclitaxel-TRAIL pretreatment retards tumor growth, whereas HSV administration before tumor cell death induction did not improve therapeutic efficacy. Hence, our findings show that the induction of cancer cell death before the injection of oncolytic HSV enhances intratumoral virus delivery/penetration and antitumor efficacy.     

Pilot trial of intravenous infusion of a replication-selective adenovirus (ONYX-015) in combination with chemotherapy or IL-2 treatment in refractory cancer patients

ONYX-015 is an adenovirus that selectively replicates in p53 dysfunctional or mutated malignant cells. We performed a pilot trial to determine the safety and feasibility of treatment with ONYX-015 delivered intravenously in patients with advanced malignancy. One cohort of five patients received ONYX-015 once a week for 6 weeks at a dose of 2 x 10(12) particles per infusion in combination with weekly infusions of irinotecan (CPT11, 125 mg per week) and 5-fluorouracil (5FU, 500 mg per week). A second cohort of five patients received the combination of ONYX-015 at a dose of 2 x 10(11) particles per week for 6 weeks in combination with interleukin 2 (IL 2, 1.1 x 10(6) units daily via subcutaneous injection for 5 days each week for 4 weeks). Toxicity attributable to ONYX-015 was limited to transient fever. All patients demonstrated elevations in neutralizing antibody titers within 4 weeks of the infusion of ONYX-015. Serum levels of IL-6, IL-10, tumor necrosis factor-alpha, and interferon-gamma increased within 6 hours of viral infusion, suggesting immune activation. This response was more pronounced in the cohort of patients who received 2 x 10(12) particles per infusion. Two patients demonstrated uptake of viral particles in malignant tissue by quantitative PCR. Electron microscopy confirmed selective cytoplasmic viral particles within malignant cells but not within adjacent normal tissue in a third patient. In conclusion ONYX-015 can be administered safely in combination with CPT11, 5FU or low-dose IL 2 and is able to access malignant tissue following intravenous infusion. Further investigation of ONYX-015, possibly with agents that may modulate replication activity, or duration of virus survival, is indicated.