Refractory sprue

Celiac disease is a T cell-mediated disorder that results from intolerance to gluten. The major cause of failure to respond to a gluten-free diet is continuing gluten ingestion. In poorly responsive patients diagnosis of refractory sprue can be established after exclusion of a limited number of conditions. Refractory sprue may occur after an initial response to the diet or without evidence of preexisting celiac disease. The detection of aberrant, clonally expanded, intraepithelial lymphocytes has led to better definition and classification of patients with refractory sprue. Only a few series of patients with well-characterized refractory sprue have been reported in the literature. The prognosis is poor, though some patients respond to corticosteroids and immunosuppressive agents. The presence of an aberrant clonal intraepithelial T-cell population has led to the designation of refractory sprue as a cryptic intestinal T-cell lymphoma.     

Diagnosis and treatment of refractory sprue

Celiac disease is a gluten-sensitive enteropathy characterized by villous atrophy that is reversed by gluten withdrawal. A minority of these patients is resistant to a gluten-free diet or, after a period of remission, they experience relapse despite continued adherence to treatment, which is called unclassified sprue or refractory sprue.The prognosis of refractory sprue may be poor: patients may die of severe malabsorption or from the development of an enteropathy-associated T-cell lymphoma. We report a 72-year-old-woman with a diagnosis of refractory sprue who responded well to treatment with corticosteroids and a gluten-free diet.     

Free perforation of the small intestine in collagenous sprue

A 67-year-old man with celiac disease developed recurrent diarrhea, profound weakness and weight loss, with evidence of marked protein depletion. His clinical course was refractory to a strict gluten-free diet and steroid therapy. Postmortem studies led to definition of unrecognized collagenous sprue that caused ulceration and small intestinal perforation. Although PCR showed identical monoclonal T-cell populations in antemortem duodenal biopsies and postmortem jejunum, careful pathological evaluation demonstrated no frank lymphoma. Rarely, overt or even cryptic T-cell lymphoma may complicate collagenous sprue, however, small intestinal ulcers and perforation may also develop independently. The dramatic findings here may reflect an underlying or early molecular event in the eventual clinical appearance of overt T-cell lymphoma.     

Etiology of nonresponsive celiac disease: results of a systematic approach

OBJECTIVES: Nonresponse or relapse of symptoms is common in patients with celiac disease treated with gluten free diet. Refractory sprue (RS) is defined as initial or subsequent failure of a strict gluten-free diet to restore normal intestinal architecture and function in patients who have celiac-like enteropathy. The aims of this study were: 1) to identify causes of persistent symptoms in patients referred with presumed diagnosis of nonresponsive celiac disease (NCD); and 2) to characterize patients with true RS. METHODS: Patients were identified who had been systematically evaluated for NCD between January 1997, and May 2001. Patient records and small bowel biopsy results were reviewed. RESULTS: A total of 55 patients were referred with a presumed diagnosis of NCD. Six did not have celiac disease and had other diseases responsible for their symptoms. Diarrhea, abdominal pain, and weight loss were the most common reasons for evaluation in cases of NCD, whereas weight loss, steatorrhea, and diarrhea were the most common presenting features of RS (nine patients). Of the 49 patients with celiac disease, 25 were identified as having gluten contamination. Additional diagnoses accounting for persistent symptoms included: pancreatic insufficiency, irritable bowel syndrome, bacterial overgrowth, lymphocytic colitis, collagenous colitis, ulcerative jejunitis, T-cell lymphoma, pancreatic cancer, fructose intolerance, protein losing enteropathy, cavitating lymphadenopathy syndrome, and tropical sprue. CONCLUSIONS: Based on this study, we conclude the following: 1) gluten contamination is the leading reason for NCD; 2) of NCD cases, 18% are due to RS; and 3) alternative diseases or those coexistent with celiac disease and gluten contamination should be ruled out before a diagnosis of RS is made.     

Heterogeneity of intraepithelial lymphocytes in refractory sprue: potential implications of CD30 expression

BACKGROUND: Refractory sprue is defined as primary or secondary failure to respond to a gluten free diet in patients with coeliac disease-like enteropathy and may signify cryptic or overt enteropathy associated T cell lymphoma. AIMS: To study in detail jejunal morphology and immunophenotypes in patients with refractory sprue in the search for features that might be useful to predict prognosis. PATIENTS: Seven patients are described, representing all such cases identified in our hospital over a 13 year period. METHODS: Biopsy and/or surgical resection specimens were examined by morphology, immunohistochemistry, including enzymatic and immunofluorescent detection, and molecular biology. RESULTS: All patients had phenotypically abnormal intraepithelial lymphocytes (IELs) that lacked CD8, T cell receptor alpha beta (or gamma delta), and/or expressed CD30 in addition to variable expression of the natural killer cell receptor CD94. A monoclonal T cell population was present in six cases, data from the seventh being inconclusive. Three patients had overt lymphoma with CD30+ tumour tissue intervening between intact mucosa that contained neoplastic IELs. Intriguingly, CD30+ IELs were observed both a long way away from, and in direct continuity with, the tumours in these patients. Such CD30+ cells were hardly detected in patients without tumours, two of which are in good health several years after the initial diagnosis. CONCLUSIONS: Our data suggest that abnormal IELs in patients with refractory sprue are phenotypically heterogeneous. CD30 expression by these cells may indicate a worse prognosis, including the occurrence of overt lymphoma.     

Mucosal intra-epithelial lymphocytes in enteropathy-associated T-cell lymphoma, ulcerative jejunitis, and refractory celiac disease constitute a neoplastic population.

Loss of response to a gluten-free diet (refractory sprue) and ulcerative jejunitis are complications of celiac disease that may progress to enteropathy-associated T-cell lymphoma (EATL). Both conditions are characterized by the presence of a nonlymphomatous monoclonal T-cell population in the enteropathic mucosa. In EATL, a similar monoclonal population that shows clonal identity with the lymphoma itself is also present in the enteropathic mucosa. In this study we show that in all three circumstances the monoclonal T-cell population is constituted by cytologically normal, noninvasive intraepithelial T lymphocytes that share an identical aberrant immunophenotype with EATL. Patients with refractory sprue and/or ulcerative jejunitis are, therefore, suffering from a neoplastic T-cell disorder for which hematological treatment strategies need to be devised.     

Defining gluten refractory enteropathy

OBJECTIVE: The diagnosis of coeliac disease (CD) is based on the responsiveness of the enteropathy to a gluten-free diet (GFD). This implies that terms such as 'non-responsive CD' and 'refractory CD' are almost paradoxical. In spite of this, these terms are commonly used in the literature, often with different and confusing meanings. METHODS: On the basis of both a review of the literature and our clinical experience, we propose the following classification. A condition characterized by a refractory enteropathy, not due to lymphoma, ulcerative jejunoileitis or collagenous sprue, but in which gluten sensitivity has been shown previously or could be shown while the patients were on an immunosuppressive therapy should be indicated as refractory CD. Those patients in whom gluten sensitivity can be excluded should be considered to be affected by non-coeliac refractory sprue. Finally, patients in whom the presence of CD cannot be either confirmed or excluded should be considered to be affected by undefined sprue. RESULTS: Twenty-four certain refractory patients are described in the literature. The data suggest a diagnosis of refractory CD in 13 patients, non-coeliac refractory sprue in three patients, and undefined sprue in eight patients. CONCLUSIONS: We define refractory CD as a form of CD that no longer responds to a GFD. Non-coeliac refractory sprue is a condition unrelated to CD. It could be either an independent condition or a common end point of different enteropathies.     

Refractory sprue syndrome with clonal intraepithelial lymphocytes evolving into overt enteropathy-type intestinal T-cell lymphoma

INTRODUCTION: Recently, patients with refractory sprue have been shown to contain a clonal proliferation of phenotypically abnormal intraepithelial lymphocytes in their intestine. Whether this signifies early enteropathy-type intestinal T-cell lymphoma (EITCL) or a reactive condition is not clear. We report on a patient presenting with the findings of refractory sprue who subsequently developed overt EITCL. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Duodenal biopsies from 1997 (refractory sprue) and duodenal and jejunal biopsies from 1998 (intestinal T-cell lymphoma) were compared by immunohistochemistry and PCR for the detection of T-cell receptor (TCR)-gamma gene rearrangements. Clonal PCR products were sequenced. RESULTS: The duodenal biopsies from both 1997 and 1998 and the jejunal tumor biopsy showed villus atrophy and an increase of intraepithelial lymphocytes with an abnormal immunophenotype (CD3+, CD4-, CD8- and TCR-beta-). In all duodenal specimens including the one from 1997, and the jenunal tumor biopsy, an identical clonal amplificate was detected by enzymatic amplification of the TCR-gamma gene. CONCLUSION: These data suggest that refractory sprue containing a clonal proliferation of phenotypically abnormal intraepithelial lymphocytes may represent an early manifestation of EITCL. The detection of immunohistochemical negativity for several antigens normally found on intraepithelial lymphocytes such as CD8 or the TCR-beta chain in combination with clonal T-cell populations by PCR may be helpful in identifying refractory sprue with a malignant transformation.     

Maladie cœliaque

Celiac disease is an enteropathy due to gluten intake in genetically predisposed individuals (HLA DQ2/DQ8). Celiac disease occurs in adults and children at rates approaching 1% of population in Europe and USA. Clinical features observed in celiac disease are extremely various and anaemia, oral aphthous stomatis, amenorrhea or articular symptoms may be the only presenting manifestations. Diagnosis relies on the evidence of histological villous atrophy in proximal small bowel and the presence of specific serum antibodies. Treatment relies on eviction of gluten (wheat, barley, rye) from diet. Gluten free diet allows prevention of malignant complications such as small bowel adenocarcinoma and lymphoma, and osteopenia. The main cause of resistance to gluten free diet is its poor observance. If not the case, serious complications of celiac disease, such as clonal refractory celiac sprue and intestinal T-cell lymphoma should be suspected. Current therapeutic challenges concern alternative to gluten free diet and new efficient treatments of lymphomatous complications.     

Small bowel malignant lymphoma complicating celiac sprue and the mesenteric lymph node cavitation syndrome

Malignant small intestinal lymphoma may complicate or antedate clinical recognition of celiac sprue. However, histologic diagnosis of lymphoma is made especially difficult in the presence of small bowel ulceration. A 70-yr-old man with celiac sprue and a history of dermatitis herpetiformis was initially seen for recurrent diarrhea; panmalabsorption with steatorrhea and protein-losing enteropathy were documented. Subsequent studies showed ectopic gastric mucosa in the small bowel, hyposplenism with mesenteric lymph node cavitation, and small bowel erosions and ulceration. Despite strong clinical suspicion for more than 2 yr, only 1 of 88 small bowel biopsy specimens was positive for lymphoma. At autopsy, shortly after histologic diagnosis of lymphoma, extensive small bowel involvement and infiltration were observed. This is the first report of lymphoma complicating the recently described nonneoplastic lymphoreticular syndrome associated with celiac sprue characterized by splenic atrophy and mesenteric lymph node cavitation.     

Celiac sprue (review)

Celiac sprue may be defined as a model autoimmune disease with known trigger (gluten), a tight genetic linkage (with HLA-DQ2 and HLA-DQ8) and a specific humoral autoimmune response (autoantibodies to tissue transglutaminase, tTG). Gliadin peptides are repeatedly presented to HLA-DQ2 and HLA-DQ8 positive cells and induce an immune response in small-intestinal mucosa. tTG is a specific endomysial autoantigen released during cellular stress and by deamidation of gliadin peptides as well as by binding with them facilitates their interaction with HLA-DQ2 and HLA-DQ8 cells. CS is the consequence of an inappropriate by T-cells mediated immune reaction to gluten. The diagnosis is based on criteria of the European Society of Paediatric Gastroenterology, Hepatology and Nutrition revised in 1990. The availability of sensitive and specific detection methods of serum antibodies to endomysium (AEA) and tTG (AtTGA) was followed by recognition of a broad spectrum of both the clinical presentation and histologic changes of intestinal mucosa in CS. The majority of patients have atypical clinical symptoms. The present prevalence of CS amounts to approximately 1:250. The following forms of CS are distinguished: classic (typical), latent, potential, subclinical, and silent. CS is frequently associated with other diseases and many of them are also of autoimmune origin. Serologic testing is indicated in subjects with atypical symptoms and autoimmune diseases. In cases with distinct suspicion biopsy should be always performed irrespective of the serologic tests. In refractory sprue the cryptic form of enteritis associated T-cell lymphoma should be excluded. Gluten-free diet is the cornerstone of CS therapy. The Alimentary Codex in individual countries admits different amounts of residual gluten in gluten-free products. In future years new basic knowledge as well as practical diagnostic and therapeutic recommendations may be expected.     

Coeliac disease

Coeliac disease is a genetically-determined chronic inflammatory intestinal disease induced by an environmental precipitant, gluten. Patients with the disease might have mainly non-gastrointestinal symptoms, and as a result patients present to various medical practitioners. Epidemiological studies have shown that coeliac disease is very common and affects about one in 250 people. The disease is associated with an increased rate of osteoporosis, infertility, autoimmune diseases, and malignant disease, especially lymphomas. The mechanism of the intestinal immune-mediated response is not completely clear, but involves an HLA-DQ2 or HLA-DQ8 restricted T-cell immune reaction in the lamina propria as well as an immune reaction in the intestinal epithelium. An important component of the disease is the intraepithelial lymphocyte that might become clonally expanded in refractory sprue and enteropathy-associated T-cell lymphoma. Study of the mechanism of the immune response in coeliac disease could provide insight into the mechanism of inflammatory and autoimmune responses and lead to innovations in treatment.     

Enteropathy-associated T-cell lymphoma complicating an autoimmune enteropathy

Enteropathy-associated T-cell lymphoma (EATL) is a rare non-Hodgkin lymphoma frequently associated with celiac disease. We report a case of EATL complicating adult autoimmune enteropathy (AIE). Analysis of phenotype, rearrangements in T-cell receptor genes, and chromosome alterations by high-resolution comparative genomic hybridization identified features distinct from those described for types I and II EATL. Furthermore, EATL arose from a single T-cell clone that had been present for several years in AIE-associated, oligoclonal, intestinal T-cell infiltrate. Emerging T-cell clones should be monitored in patients with AIE who receive long-term immunosuppressive therapy.     

Refractory celiac disease

Celiac disease (CD) is a small intestinal inflammatory disorder characterized by an immune-mediated enteropathy triggered by the ingestion of wheat gluten or related rye and barley proteins in genetically predisposed individuals carrying the human leukocyte antigens (HLA)-DQ2 or-DQ8. Nonresponsive CD (NRCD) is a clinical diagnosis defined by the persistence of signs, symptoms, and/or laboratory abnormalities typical of CD despite adherence to a gluten-free diet for at least 6 months. One cause for NRCD is refractory CD (RCD), defined as the persistence of severe villous atrophy on small intestinal biopsy despite strict gluten withdrawal for at least 6 months with no evidence of other pathology. Although rare, RCD should be suspected in individuals with an established diagnosis of CD who fail to respond primarily or secondarily to a strict gluten-free diet, particularly if they manifest significant weight loss. A thorough evaluation must be performed to distinguish RCD from other causes of NRCD. RCD may be categorized into type I or type II. Type I RCD has a more favorable prognosis compared with type II and can often be managed with nutritional supplementation and possibly low level immunosuppressive therapy. Type II RCD carries a poor prognosis and is more likely to progress to life-threatening malnutrition or intestinal T-cell lymphoma. Immunosuppressive agents and, more recently, autologous stem cell transplant have been used to treat type II RCD.     

Collagenous sprue associated with an extensive T-cell lymphoma

A 79-year-old woman developed collagenous sprue, a rare small intestinal mucosal disorder. Later, extensive T-cell lymphoma was documented, a neoplasm known to complicate celiac disease. Although the precise relationship of collagenous sprue to celiac disease has been debated and remains controversial, the findings here provide additional evidence that collagenous sprue and celiac disease are closely linked. In the past, long-term survival with collagenous sprue may have been compromised due to severe pan-malabsorption. With improved treatment measures, including modern nutritional support, it is likely that there will be an increased opportunity in future for improved appreciation of the complications of collagenous sprue, specifically, lymphoma.     

Frequency of clonal intraepithelial T lymphocyte proliferations in enteropathy-type intestinal T cell lymphoma, coeliac disease, and refractory sprue

BACKGROUND: Clonal T cell receptor (TCR) gene rearrangements and loss of T cell antigens such as CD8 and TCR-beta in intraepithelial lymphocytes (IELs) may indicate the development of an enteropathy-type intestinal T cell lymphoma (EITCL) in patients with refractory sprue. AIMS: To define the diagnostic value of these markers in duodenal biopsies from patients with villous atrophy as a result of various underlying disorders. PATIENTS AND METHODS: Duodenal biopsies from eight patients with coeliac disease and five patients with villous atrophy caused by defined disorders were compared with three patients with refractory sprue evolving into overt EITCL, two patients with ulcerative jejunitis, and with eight patients with overt EITCL, for expression of CD3, CD4, CD8, and TCR-beta in IELs using immunohistochemistry and for clonal TCR-gamma gene rearrangements using polymerase chain reaction. In addition, biopsies from six consecutive patients with refractory sprue of uncertain cause were examined. RESULTS: Clonal TCR-gamma gene rearrangements were found in all resected tumours of patients with EITCL, in 3/8 duodenal biopsies of patients with EITCL, in 2/2 patients with ulcerative jejunitis, in 2/3 patients with refractory sprue evolving into overt EITCL, and in 1/6 patients with refractory sprue. No rearrangements were found in biopsies from patients with refractory sprue caused by defined disorders or those with coeliac disease. Clonality in duodenal biopsies was associated with an abnormal phenotype of IELs in all cases and in all but one case in patients with evidence of underlying coeliac disease. Specificity for detection of an EITCL using immunohistology was 77% for CD8 and for TCR-beta staining, and 100% for detection of a clonal TCR-gamma gene rearrangement. Sensitivity was 62% for staining with CD8 and clonality investigation, while sensitivity reached 100% for TCR-beta staining in all investigated patients with EITCL. CONCLUSIONS: Clonal proliferations of phenotypically abnormal IELs in refractory sprue represent an early manifestation of EITCL, for which the term "sprue-like intestinal T cell lymphoma" is proposed. This constellation is also found in duodenal biopsies from patients with an overt EITCL and is not related to other sprue syndromes, resulting in a high specificity for detection of an EITCL or refractory sprue evolving into EITCL. Overt EITCL may develop directly from coeliac disease without a precursor lesion (refractory sprue with clonal IELs) being demonstrable in duodenal biopsies or via a "sprue-like intestinal T cell lymphoma". This latter entity is a complication of coeliac disease.     

Flow cytometric analysis of intestinal intraepithelial lymphocytes in the diagnosis of refractory celiac sprue

The etiology of refractory celiac sprue (RCS) is unclear. In a high proportion of cases, the clonal nature of intestinal intraepithelial lymphocytes (IEL) can be demonstrated and a pathogenetic implication of intestinal IEL has been postulated. The prognosis of this subgroup of RCS is poor, with a high risk to develop an overt lymphoma and uncontrolled malabsorption despite steroid/immunosuppressive therapy. Cases with a relatively indolent clinical course, however, exist and their early diagnosis may be difficult. To gain insight into the pathogenic implication of intestinal IEL in refractory celiac sprue, we have performed an extensive phenotypic and functional characterization of clonal intestinal IEL in a patient with an indolent form of refractory celiac sprue, using multiparametric flow cytometry. The abnormal lymphocyte infiltrate lacked surface membrane expression of CD3/T-cell receptor (TCR) complexes (TCR(-), CD4(-), CD8(-), sCD3(-)), but contained intracellular CD3(epsilon) (CyCD3(+)) and surface CD103(+) and CD7(+). In particular, these cells showed a unique spontaneous ex-vivo cytokine secretion profile with an increased percentage of CD3(-) IEL containing TNF-alpha and IL-10, in the absence of IL-2, IL-4 and IFN-gamma. Altogether our results suggest that flow cytometry immunophenotyping of intestinal IEL, in cases suspected of celiac disease and their complicated forms, could be of great help in the correct diagnosis of RCS and the understanding of the immunopathogenic mechanisms of the disease and their clinical and/or therapeutical implications.     

T-cell intestinal lymphoma associated with celiac sprue

A patient with a long history of celiac sprue developed a pleomorphic intestinal lymphoma. Cell suspensions of tumor cells and immunoperoxidase labeling of cell surface antigens in frozen tissue sections clearly showed the lymphoma to be of T-cell origin, despite the presence of other nontumor cells bearing enzyme markers of histiocytes. These findings may have important implications on the cellular origin of lymphomas developing in patients with celiac sprue.     

Celiac sprue

Celiac sprue, celiac disease, or gluten-sensitive enteropathy, is a malabsorption disorder of the small intestine that occurs after ingestion of wheat gluten in genetically susceptible individuals. This disease is characterized by intestinal malabsorption associated with villous atrophy of the small intestinal mucosa, clinical and histological improvement after adherence to strict gluten free diet, and relapse when gluten is reintroduced. Celiac sprue has a high prevalence in Western Europe and North America where it is estimated to affect 1:120 to 1:300 individuals. The pathogenesis of celiac sprue is related to inappropriate intestinal T-cell activation in HLA-DQ2 positive individuals triggered by antigenic peptides from wheat gluten or prolamins from barley and rye. Although previously thought to be mainly a disease of childhood onset, the diagnosis is increasingly being made in adults. There are a wide variety of presentations, which range from asymptomatic forms to severe diarrhea, weight loss and nutritional deficiencies. Extraintestinal manifestations including anemia, osteopenia or neurological disorders and associated conditions such as diabetes or hypothyroidism are commonly present. The availability of highly sensitive and specific serologic markers has dramatically facilitated the diagnosis of celiac sprue. However, the demonstration of characteristic histological abnormalities in a biopsy specimen of the small intestine remains the mainstay of diagnosis. Treatment consists of life-long avoidance of dietary gluten to control symptoms and to prevent both immediate and long-term complications.