Evaluation of ELVIS HSV ID/Typing System for the detection and typing of herpes simplex virus from clinical specimens.

BACKGROUND: Herpes simplex virus (HSV) is a common pathogen with two serotypes: HSV-1 and HSV-2. HSV infection does not pose much of a threat to an immunocompetent host but to an immunocompromised host or a neonate the infection can be fatal. The Enzyme-Linked Virus Inducible System (ELVIS) employs a genetically altered baby hamster kidney (BHK) cell line that allows for the rapid overnight detection of HSV but also includes an immunofluorescent stain for the simultaneous detection and typing of HSV-1 and HSV-2. OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the ELVIS HSV ID/Typing System in comparison with HSV identification and typing in primary rabbit kidney (PRK) cells grown in shell vials. STUDY DESIGN: Over a period of 6 weeks, 130 specimens were submitted to the diagnostic virology laboratory and cultured for the presence of HSV. Two PRK shell vials and one ELVIS BHK shell vial were inoculated with patient specimen. PRK shell vials were observed for cytopathic effect (CPE) for up to 4 days. When CPE was observed the PRK shell vials were fixed and one shell vial was stained with HSV-1 monoclonal antibody (Mab) and the other was stained with HSV-2 Mab. The coverslips were observed under the fluorescent microscope for specific apple-green fluorescence. The BHK shell vials were incubated overnight, fixed, and stained with galactopyranoside (X-Gal). If blue cells were present, the specimen was positive for HSV. The coverslip was then observed under the fluorescent microscope for the presence of specific apple-green fluorescence, indicating HSV-2. If no specific apple-green stain was observed, the coverslip was stained with a fluorescent conjugated goat anti-mouse IgG to determine the presence of HSV-1. RESULTS: Of the 130 specimens, PRK shell vials detected 43 positive HSV; 30 were HSV-2 and 13 were HSV-1. The ELVIS BHK shell vials detected 42 positive HSV; 30 were HSV-2 and 12 were HSV-1. One low titer specimen was not identified as being HSV positive. Two specimens were not directly typed by the ELVIS system. One specimen had only one blue cell present and did not show specific staining for either HSV-1 or HSV-2. The other specimen had only five blue cells present and only one fluorescent cell present that was difficult to type. As suggested by the manufacturer's instructions, both specimens that were not directly typed were re-grown overnight from their supernatants and were correctly identified and typed. CONCLUSION: The ELVIS HSV ID/Typing System is a rapid, highly specific and sensitive method of overnight HSV detection and typing.     

Detection and serotyping of herpes simplex virus in MRC-5 cells by use of centrifugation and monoclonal antibodies 16 h postinoculation.

Monoclonal antibodies (Syva Co., Palo Alto, Calif.) were used for the detection and serotyping of herpes simplex virus (HSV) isolates by immunofluorescence 16 h after inoculation of MRC-5 monolayers in 3.7-ml shell vials and after low-speed centrifugation. A total of 119 specimens were inoculated into conventional tube cell cultures and shell vials. Of 98 specimens inoculated on the same day of receipt in the laboratory (fresh specimens), all 23 (23.5%) HSV-positive specimens were identified by serotype in 16 h in shell vials by immunofluorescence, whereas only 8 of 23 HSV-positive specimens (34.8%) produced cytopathic effects in conventional tube cell cultures in this time period. Similarly, of 21 original specimen extracts previously determined to be culture positive for HSV (stored specimens), all were detected and serotyped by the immunofluorescence test with monoclonal antibodies 16 h postinoculation compared with the recognition of only 8 of these isolates (38.1%) by cytopathic effect that soon. This technique of centrifugal inoculation of HSV in shell vials containing MRC-5 cells permitted detection of this virus in all positive specimens with serotype determination within 16 h postinoculation.     

Detection of cytomegalovirus infections in specimens other than urine by the shell vial assay and conventional tube cell cultures.

Blood, bronchoscopy-lavage, biopsy (lung, liver, kidney), sputum, and other (cecum, bone) specimens were inoculated into shell vials and conventional cell tube cultures seeded with MRC-5 cells over a 23-month period. Of 1,472 specimens, 182 (12.4%) yielded cytomegalovirus (CMV)-positive results from 81 patients. Significantly more CMV-positive specimens were detected in shell vials (n = 154; 84.6%) than in conventional tube cell cultures (n = 126; 69.2%) (P less than 0.01). We found that 98 (53.8%) of the total 182 and 41 (42.7%) of the 96 blood specimens positive for CMV were detected by both the shell vial assay and conventional tube cell cultures. However, 56 (30.7%) of the total 182 and 31 (32.3%) of the 96 blood specimens positive for CMV were obtained exclusively in shell vials after detection with monoclonal antibody. Alternatively, 28 (15.4%) of the total 182 and 24 (25%) of the 96 blood specimens positive for the virus were isolated only in conventional tube cell cultures. Thus, although the shell vial assay was more sensitive and rapid than the conventional tube cell culture method, both systems must be used, especially for blood specimens, for the laboratory diagnosis of CMV infections.     

Detection of herpes simplex virus in conventional tube cell cultures and in shell vials with a DNA probe kit and monoclonal antibodies.

Specimens submitted for diagnosis of herpes simplex virus (HSV) infection were inoculated into shell vials and reacted with a commercial DNA probe kit (Pathogene; Enzo Biochem, Inc., New York, N.Y.) and an immunofluorescence assay at 16 h postinoculation. The results were compared with isolation of the virus in conventional tube cell cultures. Of 504 specimens, 105 (20.8%) were positive for HSV. Of the 105, 93 HSV-positive specimens (89%) were detected by all three assay systems. Maximum detection of HSV (100 of 105 [95%]) was obtained by probe or monoclonal antibody assay in shell vials, which had sensitivities of 98 and 97%, respectively, compared with viral recovery in conventional tube cell cultures (mean time for recognition of cytopathic effects, 2 days). Both shell vial assays were 99% specific. The DNA probe kit may be used as an alternative to a monoclonal antibody and fluorescence assay in shell vials as a diagnostic method for rapid laboratory detection of HSV infection.     

Conventional tube cell culture compared with centrifugal inoculation of MRC-5 cells and staining with monoclonal antibodies for detection of herpes simplex virus in clinical specimens.

During a 15-month period, two methods for detection of herpes simplex virus (HSV) in 699 clinical specimens were compared: (i) 24-well-plate centrifugation (24WPC) with MRC-5 cells and staining with type-specific monoclonal antibodies (Syva Co., Palo Alto, Calif.) after incubation for 16 to 18 h and (ii) conventional tube cell culture with primary rabbit kidney and A549 cells. HSV was identified by conventional tube cell culture in 165 (24%) of 699 specimens and by the 24WPC method in 116 (17%) of 699 specimens. One specimen was positive for HSV by the 24WPC method alone, compared with 50 specimens positive only by conventional cell culture (P less than 0.0001). The sensitivity, specificity, and positive and negative predictive values of the 24WPC technique with MRC-5 cells for detection of HSV in clinical specimens were 70, 99.8, 99, and 91%, respectively. Centrifugal inoculation of MRC-5 cells in 24-well plates and staining with monoclonal antibodies after incubation for 16 to 18 h is an insensitive means of detecting HSV in clinical specimens and should not replace conventional tube cell culture with primary rabbit kidney cells.     

Comparison of shell vials and conventional tubes seeded with rhabdomyosarcoma and MRC-5 cells for the rapid detection of herpes simplex virus.

Shell vials (SV) and conventional tubes (CT) were seeded with rhabdomyosarcoma (RD) and MRC-5 cells and inoculated with clinical specimens, and the systems were evaluated for the rapid diagnosis of herpes simplex virus (HSV) infections by detection of cytopathic effects (CPE) (for CT, for 7 days) and by using fluoresceinated monoclonal antibodies (for SV, 16 h postinoculation). Of 245 genital specimens (16 from males and 229 from females) 56 (23%) seeded with MRC-5 cells (14 type 1 and 42 type 2) and 55 (22%) seeded with RD cells were detected in CT; however, CPE were recognized in only 26 (46%) of the total HSV-positive cultures 1 day postinoculation. Forty-eight (86% sensitivity, MRC-5) and 46 (84% sensitivity, RD) HSV strains were detected immunologically in SV 16 h postinoculation. Early CPE in CT or fluorescent foci in SV were easier to detect in MRC-5 than in RD cell cultures. MRC-5 and RD cells were equally sensitive to infection with HSV. CT cell cultures were more sensitive than SV but less rapid for the detection of HSV infection (P less than 0.01). We recommend using SV for the rapid diagnosis of HSV infections, but in addition, CT must be inoculated with MRC-5 or RD to ensure maximum detection of this virus.     

Comparison of standard tube and shell vial cell culture techniques for the detection of cytomegalovirus in clinical specimens.

A monoclonal antibody was used to detect an early antigen of cytomegalovirus (CMV) by fluorescence 16 h after inoculation of MRC-5 monolayers in 1-dram (ca. 3.7-ml) shell vials and low-speed centrifugation. Of 770 specimens (urine, blood, lung tissue, sputum) processed in shell vials, 124 (16%) were positive for the virus at 16 h postinfection. CMV was isolated in standard tube cell cultures (average time, 9 days) from only 88 specimens, but there were no instances (with the exception of 2 blood specimens) in which CMV was recovered from tube cultures but not from shell vials. Additional specimens from 18 patients were positive in the shell vial assay but negative in the conventional tube cell culture assay. Other specimens from 14 of the 18 patients yielded CMV in conventional tube cell cultures. Of the 4 patients from whom CMV was not recovered from other specimens by conventional tube cell culturing, all had evidence of recent CMV infections, as indicated by a fourfold or greater rise in antibody titer. The specificity of the shell vial assay for the detection of CMV is supported by assays of other specimens from the same patients yielding the virus or serological evidence indicating recent infections, the known enhancement of CMV detection after centrifugation of the shell vials, and the distinct and easily recognizable fluorescence confined to the nuclei of CMV-infected cells. Our data indicate that the shell vial cell culture assay for the detection of CMV is as specific as and more sensitive than conventional tube cell culturing for the diagnosis of CMV infections.     

Diagnosis of herpes simplex virus infections in the clinical laboratory by LightCycler PCR

Herpes simplex virus (HSV) causes several clinical manifestations in both normal and immunocompromised hosts; this agent is the most frequently detected virus in diagnostic laboratories. Recovery of the virus in cell culture is considered the "gold standard" for detection of this virus from sources other than cerebrospinal fluid. LightCycler is a newly developed, commercially available system designed to rapidly perform PCR, with real-time detection of PCR products by a fluorescence resonance energy transfer assay. We compared the detection of HSV for 200 specimens (number of genital specimens, 160; number of dermal specimens, 38; number of ocular specimens, 2) by shell vial cell cultures (MRC-5) and by LightCycler PCR. Of a total of 88 (44%) HSV strains detected, 69 (78%) were detected by both shell vial cell cultures and LightCycler PCR (DNA polymerase target). A total of 19 (22%) specimens were detected exclusively by LightCycler PCR. No specimens were positive by the shell vial assay only. All 19 discrepant samples had HSV DNA detected by an independent PCR directed to the thymidine kinase gene of the virus. The melting curve analysis feature of the LightCycler instrument identified identical genotype results for HSV type 1 (HSV-1) and HSV-2 from 84 of 88 (96%) positive samples. Specimens can be extracted, target HSV DNA can be amplified, and HSV PCR products can be identified by genotype within 2 h after receipt of specimen into the laboratory. The increased level of accurate identification (all 88 positive samples) compared with that of shell vial cell culture (69 of 88 samples identified as positive) and the agreement of LightCycler PCR results with all shell vial positive results indicate the potential for routine implementation of this technology for laboratory diagnosis of HSV infections.     

Rapid detection and identification of herpes simplex virus in cell culture by a direct immunoperoxidase staining procedure.

Cell monolayers were inoculated with 169 fresh and 76 previously frozen clinical specimens and examined for the presence of herpes simplex virus (HSV) by noting the appearance of characteristic cytopathic effect (CPE) and by using direct immunoperoxidase (IP) stain for viral antigen. HSV was detected by IP staining in 40 of 169 (23.7%) monolayers and by CPE in 39 of 169 (23.1%) monolayers inoculated with fresh specimens. All 40 isolates were detected and confirmed by IP staining within 24 h. Although 39 of 40 isolates were detected by CPE, only 9 of 39 (23%) were positive within 24 h. CPE was observed at 2.7 days on the average, but 4 days were required before 90% of the cultures were positive and more than 5 days were required before all HSV isolates were recognized. Similar results were observed for frozen specimens. HSV was detected earlier with IP staining, which demonstrated more extensive infection of cell monolayers inoculated with titrated fresh culture isolates and clinical specimens than did CPE. IP staining reduces the amount of time required for detection and identification of HSV in culture, is readily adaptable for use in the clinical laboratory, and permanent stained preparations can be made.     

Simultaneous seeding and infecting of shell vials for rapid detection of cytomegalovirus infection.

Fifty cytomegalovirus isolates were used to infect shell vials containing confluent MRC-5 cell monolayers and shell vials which were seeded with MRC-5 cells at the time of inoculation. All 50 of the isolates were detected by immunofluorescence in shell vials containing confluent monolayers, whereas 39 (78%) of the isolates were detected in shell vials that had been seeded and inoculated simultaneously (P less than 0.001). Preformed monolayers of cells in shell vials provide the most sensitive system for the detection of cytomegalovirus infection.     

Evaluation of number of shell vial cell cultures per clinical specimen for rapid diagnosis of cytomegalovirus infection.

Specimens submitted for the diagnosis of cytomegalovirus (CMV) infection were inoculated into three (blood) or two (urine, tissue, bronchoalveolar lavage [BAL]) shell vials seeded with MRC-5 cells for the diagnosis of CMV infection. We evaluated the detection of 993 specimens that were positive for CMV according to the number of shell vial cell cultures inoculated per specimen. For blood cultures, and considering one CMV-positive shell vial as 100%, inoculation of three shell vials versus one increased the detection rate of the virus by 51%. Inoculation of three shell vials compared with two yielded a 20% increase in the detection rate of CMV. For urine, tissue, and BAL specimens, inoculation of two shell vials compared with one resulted in increases of 7, 10, and 5%, respectively. For maximum detection of CMV in shell vial cell cultures, at least three vials should be inoculated with blood specimens, and two vials should be used for urine, tissue, and BAL samples.     

Comparison of the Scott Selecticult-HSV kit with conventional culture and direct immunoperoxidase staining for detection of herpes simplex virus in cultures of clinical specimens.

In a comparative study, clinical specimens were cultured for herpes simplex virus (HSV). The presence of virus was noted by the appearance of characteristic cytopathic effect, as determined by standard direct immunofluorescence techniques, by using a direct immunoperoxidase stain for viral antigen, or by using the Selecticult-HSV (SC-HSV) stain for viral antigen. There was 100% correlation between the SC-HSV stain and immunofluorescence staining in recognizing HSV-infected cells (81 of 81 positive specimens). In comparison with observation of cytopathic effect, the SC-HSV system and conventional culture detected 93 and 78% of positive cultures at 48 h postinoculation and 76 and 32%, respectively, at 24 h. By 5 days postinoculation, SC-HSV detected 100% of the positive specimens. As compared with the direct immunoperoxidase stain, SC-HSV stain was slightly more sensitive and gave less background stain. HSV serotypes 1 and 2 were both detected by the SC-HSV stain. The Scott SC-HSV kit appears to be an effective system for the diagnosis of HSV infections.     

Comparison of two rapid culture methods for detection of cytomegalovirus in clinical specimens.

The conventional virus isolation technique was compared with a 24-h shell vial centrifugation culture technique and with a 48-h tube culture method for the detection of cytomegalovirus (CMV) in MRC-5 cells. Of 200 clinical specimens tested, 41 were positive for CMV by at least one procedure. Indirect immunoperoxidase staining was positive for 32 (78.0%) of 41 specimens in the tube culture method and for 30 (73.2%) of 41 specimens in the shell vial centrifugation method. CMV was detected in 23 (56.1%) of 41 specimens by the development of cytopathic effect within 14 days.     

Advantages of multiple cell culture systems for detection of mixed-virus infections.

Simultaneous infections by two or more viruses occur frequently, especially in immunosuppressed patients. In order to detect more than one viral agent in a single specimen, multiple cell systems have been employed in our laboratory. Specimens are routinely inoculated into four different cell cultures, namely: MRC-5, a human diploid lung fibroblast cell strain; A549, a human continuous cell line; primary guinea pig embryo (GPE) cell culture, and primary rhesus monkey kidney (RhMK) cell culture. For rapid detection of cytomegalovirus (CMV) antigen, MRC-5 cells grown in shell vials containing coverslips are also inoculated with the same specimens followed by centrifugation. During 1989, nine cases of multiple-virus isolations were obtained in this laboratory. In all nine patients, CMV was detected in MRC-5 cells. Five of the nine cases were co-infected with HSV-1, three were co-infected with adenovirus, and one was co-infected with both HSV-1 and adenovirus. All four adenovirus isolates were obtained in A549 cells. Of the six HSV-1 isolates, one was detected in all three cell cultures, e.g. MRC-5, A549 and GPE; one was detected in both MRC-5 and A549 cells, and four were isolated in a single-cell type only. For nine CMV-positive cases, five were obtained by both conventional and centrifugation cultures, two each were detected by centrifugation or conventional culture only. Thus for a maximum detection of viruses present in a single specimen, it is suggested that multiple-cell-culture systems, together with more than one technique, should be employed.     

Increased detection of herpes simplex virus in MRC-5 cells treated with dimethyl sulfoxide and dexamethasone.

Treatment of MRC-5 cells with dexamethasone, dimethyl sulfoxide, or a combination of the two enhanced the detection of herpes simplex virus by three- to fourfold in these cells. Fluorescent plaques were noticeably larger on cover slips treated with the enhancing agents. Low-positive clinical specimens were stored and tested in parallel in treated and untreated shell vials, and 6 to 40% of these stained positive in the treated cultures but not in the untreated controls. In standard tube cultures, cytopathic effect began earlier and was more extensive in treated tubes.     

Continuous high-speed rolling versus centrifugation for detection of herpes simplex virus.

Specimens submitted for diagnosis of herpes simplex virus infections were inoculated into shell vials and conventional culture tubes. Inoculated culture tubes were incubated with rolling at 96 rpm. Immunoperoxidase (IP) staining and cytopathic effects (CPE) were used to detect positive cultures. At 24 h, 42 (53%) of the rolled cultures were positive for CPE, while only 16 (21%) of the shell vials were CPE positive (P less than 0.01). No difference in sensitivity was seen between rolled and shell vial cultures that were inoculated with high-titered viral preparations and IP stained at 16 h. However, when low-titered preparations were used, 39 of 41 (95%) were IP positive by the high-speed roller method at 64 h postinoculation, while only 24 of 41 (58%) were IP positive with shell vials (P less than 0.01). These results indicate that high-speed roller method at 64 h postinoculation, while only 24 of 41 (58%) were IP positive with shell vials (P less than 0.01). These results indicate that high-speed rolling is better than the shell vial technique for the detection of herpes simplex virus by IP staining.     

CV-1 and MRC-5 mixed cells for simultaneous detection of herpes simplex viruses and varicella zoster virus in skin lesions.

BACKGROUND: Culture for varicella zoster virus (VZV) is relatively insensitive. Herpes simplex viruses (HSV) culture methods, which rely on primary rabbit kidney (pRK), mink lung (Mv1Lu) or the ELVIS HSV culture system fail to detect VZV. Culture of atypical vesicular skin lesions should be able to detect both HSV and VZV. OBJECTIVES: In this study, we evaluated the sensitivity of a newly developed mixture of CV-1/MRC-5 cells for the concurrent detection of both HSV and VZV. STUDY DESIGN: The CV-1/MRC-5 mixed cells were compared with pRK cells and Mv1Lu cells for the detection of HSV and to MRC-5 and A-549 cells for the detection of VZV. Fresh clinical samples submitted for HSV culture, VZV culture, and/or direct immunofluorescent assay (DFA) as well as frozen clinical samples previously positive for VZV were used for these comparisons. RESULTS: This preliminary study suggest that CV-1/MRC-5 mixed cells are as sensitive as pRK and Mv1Lu cells for the detection of HSV and appear to be more sensitive than MRC-5 and A-549 cells for the detection of VZV. Although the sample size is small, pre-CPE staining with VZV specific monoclonal antibody (Mab) at day 2 post-inoculation may provide a rapid detection of VZV with these mixed cells, but not with MRC-5 or A549 cells. In addition, culture of VZV in mixed cells from fresh clinical specimens appears to be as sensitive as antigen detection by DFA. Finally, 1% of specimens from skin lesions submitted for HSV culture grew VZV, highlighting the importance of culturing for both VZV and HSV, particularly in the case of atypical lesions. CONCLUSION: CV-1/MRC-5 mixed cells are highly sensitive for the simultaneous culture of HSV and VZV. The ability to detect either HSV or VZV from skin lesions is important for patient management.     

Rapid detection of cytomegalovirus in clinical specimens by immunofluorescent staining of shell vial cultures

A recently described rapid technique for detection of cytomegalovirus (CMV) was evaluated in clinical specimens utilizing indirect immunofluorescent staining (IFA) of shell vial cultures. A total of 266 clinical specimens received for viral isolation were inoculated to commercially available shell vials seeded with human lung fibroblasts (MRC-5), centrifuged at 700 X g for one hour, and stained after 18 hours incubation with monoclonal antibody to CMV early nuclear protein (Biotech Research Laboratories) and fluorescein conjugated goat antimouse IgG (Cappel Laboratories). All specimens were also inoculated to tubes of human lung fibroblasts and observed for cytopathic effect (CPE) for 28 days. Of 54 specimens positive for CMV, 36 were positive by both IFA and CPE, 3 were positive by CPE only, and 15 were positive by IFA only (P less than 0.01 by the chi-square test). Failure to detect CMV associated CPE in 10 of these 15 samples was probably due to concomitant infection with herpes simplex virus or heavy bacterial or fungal contamination. Nine of the 13 patients with IFA-positive CPE-negative specimens had CMV infection documented by other positive cultures. It was concluded that the shell vial IFA rapid technique for detection of CMV is highly specific, more sensitive than conventional isolation, and well suited for application in a clinical virology laboratory.     

Evaluation of direct immunofluorescence, enzyme immunoassay, centrifugation culture, and conventional culture for the detection of respiratory syncytial virus.

Four methods of detecting respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) from clinical specimens were evaluated. A total of 410 specimens consisting of nasopharyngeal washes, aspirates, and swabs were simultaneously tested for the presence of RSV by direct immunofluorescence assay (DFA), enzyme immunoassay (EIA) (Kallestad Pathfinder), shell vial centrifugation culture (SVC), and conventional culture. DFA identified 146 (83%) of the 175 positive cases, EIA detected 153 (87%), SVC detected 127 (73%), and conventional culture detected 70 (40%). Conventional culture isolated an additional 19 respiratory viruses other than RSV. DFA and EIA were able to detect nonviable virus not isolated by a culture method, and SVC isolated low-titer virus not detected by conventional culture. DFA and EIA gave similar results; however, the EIA system was less dependent on technical expertise. The use of SVC enhanced the conventional culture system with 63 RSV isolates not recovered from the tube culture. We recommend complementary use of both culture and nonculture methods in the detection of RSV.     

Evaluation of a monoclonal antibody for detection of varicella-zoster virus infections using a shell vial technique

Standard cell culture and a shell vial technique using a monoclonal antibody were compared for the detection of varicella-zoster virus in 167 mucocutaneous specimens. Of 75 specimens from patients clinically diagnosed with varicella or zoster, a total of 40 (53.3 %) were positive by either method (4 positive only by conventional culture and 4 only by shell vial). No false-positive results were obtained with shell vials stained after 48 h of incubation. This technique is rapid, 100 % specific, and should be a good alternative to cell culture. Both techniques are equally influenced by antiviral treatment or by the time of evolution of disease.