Agreement between patient and proxy assessments of oral health-related quality of life after stroke: an observational longitudinal study

Summary  This study aimed to assess agreement between patient and proxy assessment of patients' oral health-related quality of life (OHRQoL) during the acute stroke phase and 6 months after hospital discharge. As part of an observational longitudinal study, 161 consecutive patients hospitalized after stroke and their caregivers (CGs) were monitored during acute stroke and 6 months after hospital discharge. Patient–CG agreement of health-related quality of life as assessed by the General Oral Health Assessment Index (GOHAI) and Medical Outcomes Study 12-item Short Form (SF-12) which comprises physical (PCS-12) and mental component summaries (MCS-12) was determined by comparison and correlation analyses. Complete data were available for 65 patients and CGs. Compared with acute stroke, there were improvements in GOHAI and SF-12 scores from patient's and CG's perspective at 6-month follow-up. Caregivers overestimated the impact of stroke on MCS-12 over a period of time ( P  < 0·01) and underestimated the impact on GOHAI during acute stroke ( P  < 0·001) and on PCS-12 6 months later ( P  < 0·05). Patient–CG agreement was substantial to excellent during acute stroke [intra-class correlation coefficient (ICC 0·69–0·86)] and fair-to-moderate 6 months later (ICC 0·28–0·60). Agreement was adequate between patients' and CGs' assessment of patient OHRQoL during acute stroke but it was less reliable 6 months after hospital discharge. These findings suggest that proxy assessment of OHRQoL after stroke is effective in assessing stroke-related oral impairments that affect life quality without placing additional burden on stroke patients themselves to assess OHRQoL.     

Attitudes, awareness and oral health-related quality of life in patients with diabetes

Summary  The purpose of this study was to assess the knowledge diabetic patients have of their risk for periodontal disease, their attitude towards oral health and their oral health-related quality of life (OHRQL). One hundred and one consecutive patients (age range 31–79 years) recruited from a diabetic outpatient clinic participated in the study. Twenty-seven per cent of participants had type 1 diabetes, 66% type 2 and 7% did not know what type of diabetes they had. The length of time since participants were diagnosed as diabetic ranged from 1 to 48 years. Metabolic control of diabetes as determined by HbA1c levels ranged from 6·2% to 12·0% compared with the normal range of 4·5–6·0%. Thirty-three per cent of participants were aware of their increased risk for periodontal disease, 84% of their increased risk for heart disease, 98% for eye disease, 99% for circulatory problems and 94% for kidney disease. Half of the participants who were aware of their increased risk for periodontal disease had received this information from a dentist. Dental attendance was sporadic, with 43% reporting attendance within the last year. OHRQL was not significantly affected by the presence of diabetes in the group surveyed, in comparison with a previous survey of non-diabetic patients. A significant association was found between metabolic control and dentate status. Awareness of the potential associations between diabetes, oral health and general health needs to be increased in diabetic patients.     

Impacts on daily performances attributed to malocclusions by British adolescents

Summary  The aim of this study was to assess the prevalence of condition-specific impacts on daily performances attributed to malocclusion in British adolescents. Two hundred 16- to 17-year-old adolescents were randomly selected from 957 children attending a public college in London, UK. During interviews, participants provided information about demographic variables and socio-dental impacts on quality of life attributed to malocclusions, using the Condition-Specific form of the Oral Impacts on Daily Performances (CS-OIDP) index. Adolescents were also clinically examined using the Index of Orthodontic Treatment Need. Statistical comparison by covariates was performed using chi-squared test and chi-squared test for trends. The prevalence of oral impacts on daily performances attributed to any oral condition was 26·5% whereas the prevalence of CS-OIDP attributed to malocclusion was 21·5%. There was no statistically significant difference by sex, age, ethnicity or orthodontic treatment status of schoolchildren in the prevalence of CS-OIDP attributed to malocclusion ( P  ≥ 0·243 for all cases). However, there was a linear trend for the prevalence of CS-OIDP attributed to malocclusion, by level of normative orthodontic treatment need ( P  = 0·042). The prevalence of such impacts increased from 16·8% for adolescents with no/slight need for orthodontic treatment, to 31·7% for those with definite need for orthodontic treatment. Although findings support the idea that malocclusion has physical, psychological and social effects on quality of life of these adolescents, the inconsistencies in findings between the self-reports of impacts of malocclusion and the assessment of normative needs highlight the shortcomings of using only clinical indexes to estimate orthodontic treatment needs.     

Oral health-related quality of life of stroke survivors on discharge from hospital after rehabilitation

The study aimed to investigate oral health-related quality of life (OHR-QoL) of stroke survivors on hospital discharge after rehabilitation. It was a cross-sectional study involving 43 elderly survivors of mild to moderate stroke about to be discharged from hospital after rehabilitation and a comparison group of 43 community-dwelling elderly people. The Medical Outcomes Short Form 36 (SF-36) measure, the General Oral Health Assessment Index (GOHAI) and an oral health transition scale were administered prior to a dental examination. Median SF-36 subscale scores were significantly different between groups (P < 0.05). In physical function, role-physical, role-emotional and mental health domains, stroke survivors had significantly lower scores indicating poorer health. The median GOHAI score for the stroke group was 52 and 54 for the comparison group with no significant difference between groups although more stroke survivors had difficulty speaking compared with the comparison group. About 75% of stroke survivors considered their appearance to be worse, half of them felt that speech was worse and about a third had difficulty chewing hard food compared with the pre-stroke condition (P < 0.05). Most participants were partially dentate with no significant difference in DMFT scores or prosthetic status between groups (P > 0.05). Health-related quality of life in general was significantly poorer after stroke although patients were considered physically well enough to be discharged from hospital. There was some impairment of OHR-QoL. The nature of the stroke, the hospital environment including diet, coping strategies and elderly Chinese peoples' perception of health should be taken into account when interpreting measures of health status in stroke survivors.     

Widespread pain symptoms and psychological distress in southern Chinese with orofacial pain

Summary  The study investigated the experience of widespread pain (WP) symptoms and psychological distress in southern Chinese with orofacial pain (OFP). A community-based, cross-sectional case–control study involving people aged 35–70 registered with the Hospital Authority/University of Hong Kong Family Medicine Clinic served as the sampling frame. People with recent OFP symptoms and a group without OFP took part. Standard questions were asked about OFP conditions in the previous month. Psychological status was evaluated through depression, and non-specific physical symptoms (NPS) scores were measured with depression and somatization sub-scales of the Symptom Checklist-90. Widespread pain was determined using body outline drawings to identify painful sites prior to a standard clinical examination. Two hundred people with OFP and 200 without OFP participated. Compared with 5·0% in the comparison group ( P  =   0·005), 13·5% of participants with OFP had WP (OFP/WP). Multiple OFP symptoms were more common in the OFP/WP sub-group than the OFP sub-group without WP (OFP/No WP) ( P  <   0·002). Sixty-three percent of the OFP/WP sub-group had moderate/severe depression scores compared with 26·0% in the OFP/No WP sub-group ( P  <   0·001). When pain items were included and excluded, 92·6% and 88·9% of the OFP/WP sub-group had moderate/severe NPS scores, respectively compared with 68·5% and 65·0% in the OFP/No WP sub-group ( P  =   0·004). Co-morbid WP occurred relatively often in southern Chinese with OFP. Psychological distress was common in OFP sufferers, particularly those with WP. A multidisciplinary approach to treatment including cognitive/behavioural therapy should be considered in Chinese people with OFP as part of a WP pattern.     

Supply and demand for prosthetic treatment in Victoria, Australia

Surveys were conducted in Victoria, Australia, to estimate the demand for prosthetic treatment by examining the needs of a randomly selected group of the population. Similar surveys were conducted in relation to the contribution made by the dentists in Victoria and also that of a recently introduced group of workers, the Advanced Dental Technicians. It was found that approximately 19% of the population required prosthetic treatment in the full denture field and that the existing dentists were not meeting this need. When the Advanced Dental Technicians are more fully engaged in clinical work, the need may well be met.     

Successful aging--the case for prosthetic therapy

Reduced chewing ability in community-dwelling older people is linked to the presence of removable dentures and having fewer than 20 natural teeth present. Compensation is provided by chewing longer and swallowing larger food particles. Replacement of posterior tooth loss by fixed or removable prostheses increases the activity of the masticatory muscles, and reduces chewing time and the number of chewing strokes until swallowing. In residents of nursing homes and long-term care facilities undernutrition is prevalent because of general medical problems, reduced appetite, and poor quality of life. Poor oral health and xerostomia are often present and may have a negative effect on masticatory function and nutrition, precipitating avoidance of difficult-to-chew foods. There is no evidence that the provision of prosthetic therapies can markedly improve dietary intakes; however, it might improve oral comfort and quality of life and avoid enteral alimentation.     

Feasibility of oral health-related quality of life assessment in prosthodontic patients using abbreviated Oral Health Impact Profile questionnaires

Summary  To report about the feasibility of oral health-related quality of life assessment using two short forms of the Oral Health Impact Profile – OHIP-J14 and OHIP-J5 – in prosthodontic patients. Using the item pool of the Japanese version of the OHIP, two short forms based on a 14-item English-language version and a 5-item German-language questionnaire were derived. To test construct validity, the associations between summary scores of two short versions and self-reported oral health and self-reported denture quality have been investigated. Responsiveness was tested in 30 patients treated for their removable partial denture. Test–retest reliability using a time interval of 2 weeks and internal consistency were also tested. Associations between the two short form summary scores and self-reported oral health and denture quality supported construct validity of the instruments. Acceptable reliability for OHIP-J14 and OHIP-J5 was indicated by intra-class correlation coefficients of 0·73 and 0·75 (test–retest reliability) and CRONBACH'S alpha of 0·94 and 0·81 (internal consistency) respectively. Responsiveness was sufficient for OHIP-J14 and OHIP-J5 indicated by 'medium' effect sizes (0·50 and 0·57 respectively). In addition to sufficient discriminative psychometric properties, the ability to measure change of perceived oral health make OHIP-J14 and OHIP-J5 suitable for outcomes research.     

Tooth mortality and prosthetic treatment patterns in urban and rural Chinese aged 20–80 years

The study describes tooth mortality levels and pattern of prosthetic treatments in a sample of 1744 Chinese aged 20-80 yr who are residents of Beijing area. Complete edentulousness was rarely seen before the age of 60 yr. Beyond this age up to 26% were edentulous, depending on age and sex. The mean number of teeth present ranged from 10.0 to 29.7 depending on age, sex, and area of residence. Below the age of 60 yr very few persons had experienced extensive loss of teeth but thereafter the number of teeth missing was substantially increased. Prosthetic treatments in the form of partial dentures, crowns, and bridges were frequently observed even in the younger age groups. In all age groups the number of teeth exhibiting caries lesions involving the pulp was much higher than the number of teeth exhibiting extensive mobility. Although many people retain a high number of teeth even late in life our findings indicate a substantial need for, in particular, relief of pain services. Concurrently, emphasis must be placed on preventive programs aiming at interfering with ongoing disease.     

Oral health care needs and oral health‐related quality of life (OHIP‐14) in homeless people

Daly B, Newton T, Batchelor P, Jones K. Oral health care needs and oral health‐related quality of life (OHIP‐14) in homeless people. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol 2010. © 2009 John Wiley & Sons A/S Abstract – Objectives: The aim of this study was (i) to determine the oral health status and oral health care needs of this population, (ii) to assess oral health‐related quality of life using OHIP‐14 and (iii) to explore whether there is a relationship between oral health status and oral health‐related quality of life. Methods: A convenience sample was drawn from eight facilities catering for homeless people in south east London. Participants were invited to attend an outreach dental clinic and receive a clinical oral health and treatment needs assessment. The impact of oral disease was assessed using OHIP‐14. Results: There were 102 people from a range of vulnerable housing situations invited to participate in the study. The mean age was 39.5 (SD ± 12.3) and 92% (n = 92) were men. The mean DMFT of dentate participants (n = 94) was 15.5 (SD ± 7.6), mean DT was 4.2 (SD ± 5.2), mean MT was 6.8 (SD ± 6.0) and mean FT was 4.6 (SD ± 4.8). Normative needs were extensive with 76% having a restorative need, 80% having a need for oral hygiene measures and periodontal treatment and 38% having a prosthetic treatment need. Ninety one per cent of homeless people experienced at least one impact and the mean number of impacts (n = 90) was 5.9 (SD ± 4.8).The most commonly experienced oral health‐related quality of life impacts were in the dimension of pain, with aching in the mouth having a prevalence of 65% and discomfort while eating foods having a prevalence of 62%. Forty‐four per cent felt handicapped by their oral condition. The experience of oral impact had only a slight relationship with clinical status and there were no differences in clinical status or oral impact by vulnerability of housing situation. Conclusions: Oral health care needs were extensive and greater than that of the general population in the UK, although disease levels were similar. While homeless people experienced many more oral impacts (as measured with OHIP‐14) compared with adults of the same age in the general population in the UK, there was only a slight relationship with clinical status and oral health‐related quality of life.     

Patterns of missing occlusal units and oral health-related quality of life in SDA patients

Summary  The aim of this study was to explore the relationship between patterns of missing occlusal units (OUs) and oral health-related quality of life (OHRQoL) in subjects with the shortened dental arches (SDAs). Subjects with SDAs were recruited consecutively for 1 month from six university-based prosthodontic clinics. In total, 115 SDA subjects participated (mean age, 58·5 ± 10·0 years; 71% female). The location and number of missing teeth were examined and the number of missing OUs was calculated. To evaluate OHRQoL, the Japanese version of the Oral Health Impact Profile (OHIP-J) was administered and the summary score of OHIP-J was calculated. The SDA subjects were categorized depending upon the anterior-posterior lengths of the missing or remaining OUs. Regression analyses were performed to investigate the OHIP-J differences between groups of subjects with various anterior–posterior SDA lengths. The analyses revealed that subjects who only lost the second molar contact exhibited significantly better OHRQoL than those who lost more teeth [coefficient: 11·1, 95% confidence interval (CI): 2·8–19·2, P  = 0·02]. Furthermore a statistically significant group difference was observed between the groups with and without the first molar occlusal contact (coefficient: 12·8, 95% CI: 1·4 to 24·1, P  = 0·03). In conclusion, although our results are of exploratory nature and need validation, patterns of missing OUs are likely to be related to the OHRQoL impairment in SDA subjects with the presence of first molar contact having a particularly important role.     

Development and evaluation of an index of eating difficulty for older southern Chinese people

Summary  The objectives of this study were to develop and evaluate the validity and reliability of a new index to assess difficulty in eating certain foods among older southern Chinese people. The Index of Eating Difficulty (IED) was developed using a Guttman scaling analysis. After two pilot studies in which subjects were asked to grade 39 typical, frequently eaten Chinese foods, 10 of the 39 foods were selected and divided into five groups based on their texture and frequency of being eaten by older people. In the main study, 1229 Chinese generally healthy subjects aged 55 years and above, attending routine health checks in the Check-up Centre of the First Affiliated Hospital of Guangxi Medical University, Nanning of Guangxi province, China were interviewed to psychometrically test the index. Content, face and criterion validity, coefficients of reproducibility and scalability and test-retest reliability were tested. For criterion validity, the index was significantly associated with three other established eating difficulty measures, namely, general eating difficulty, dissatisfaction with chewing ability and oral impact on daily performances eating scores ( P  < 0·001 for all tests). The coefficients of reproducibility and scalability were 0·99 and 0·89, respectively. Weighted kappa for test-retest reliability was 0·89. The present results indicate that the IED is a valid and reliable measure to be used among older southern Chinese people.     

The impact of tooth loss on general health related to quality of life among elderly Pomeranians: results from the study of health in Pomerania (SHIP-O)

PURPOSE: It is important to know whether tooth loss has an impact on an individual's quality of life, since tooth loss is common. The aim of this study was to determine whether oral status is associated with general health and related to quality of life. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Data of 1,406 subjects aged 60 to 79 years were taken from the Study of Health in Pomerania (SHIP). Sociodemographic (age, sex, and education level) and medical information (including the most common diseases in Germany) were gathered through an interview, and income data were obtained from a self-administered questionnaire. The prosthetic status in the maxilla and mandible was classified into complete denture or removable partial denture or with > or = 10 natural teeth including teeth replaced with fixed prosthodontics (> or = 10T) or with < or = 9 natural teeth including fixed prosthodontics (< or = 9T). The health-related quality of life was measured using the Short Form (SF-12) questionnaire. Multiple linear logistic regression analyses were used to identify the nonstandardized beta coefficient using physical and psychologic indices from the SF-12 as dependent variables and sociodemographic information, prosthetic status, and disease state as independent variables. RESULTS: Prosthetic status is related to the physical scale of the SF-12. Additionally, we found that < or = 9T had a significant effect on the physical index of general health-related quality of life. CONCLUSION: Reduced dentition without replacement of missing teeth by removable or fixed prosthodontics reduces the physical index of quality of life to the same extent as cancer or renal diseases.     

Impact of prosthodontic status on oral wellbeing: a cross-sectional cohort study

Summary  To assess the impact of the prosthodontic status on oral health-related quality of life and satisfaction. We performed a cohort study at the University Clinic in Salamanca in which a group requesting prosthetic treatment (P0; n  = 31) was compared with a group treated with conventional prostheses (P1; n  = 29) and a control group (C; n  = 18) not requesting or treated with prostheses. A clinical examination for the presence of caries, periodontal disease and edentulism was carried out. An assessment was made on the impact on the quality of life employing the oral impacts on daily performance-Spanish version and the oral health impact profile 14-Spanish version, and wellbeing was assessed by the self-rated satisfaction on a 0–10 scale. The P0 cohort was significantly less satisfied and suffered a greater level of impact as regard their quality of life than the other cohorts. The main benefit of conventional prosthetic treatment was perceived by most of the treated patients (P1) in dimensions related to chewing, the aesthetic function and the assessment of the general state of the mouth. However, an unexpected proportion of patients underwent a worsening of their oral wellbeing after prosthetic treatment, mainly in the chewing ability (23%) and pain discomfort (19%) dimensions. Satisfaction and quality of life were higher in the treated group (P1) and controls (C) than in those requesting prosthetic treatment (P0).     

Depression and diffuse physical symptoms in southern Chinese with temporomandibular disorders

Summary  The study investigated the experience of depressive symptoms and the relationship with diffuse physical symptoms reporting in southern Chinese seeking professional care for temporomandibular disorders (TMD) in Hong Kong. Eighty-seven new patients [77 females/10 males; mean age 39·3 years (SD 12·7)] referred to the specialist TMD clinic at the Prince Philip Dental Hospital, Hong Kong participated in this study. The Research Diagnostic Criteria (RDC)/TMD history questionnaire was used to derive Axis II psychological data. Psychological status was assessed through depression and non-specific physical symptoms (NPS) scores (pain items included and excluded) measured with RDC/TMD Axis II instruments; 42·5% of patients experienced moderate/severe depression symptoms; 59·8% and 57·5% had moderate/severe NPS scores when pain items were included and excluded, respectively. Strong, positive and statistically significant correlations were noted between depression scores and the NPS scores that included pain items ( r  = 0·80) and those that did not ( r  = 0·80). The correlations remained consistent and were of similar magnitude when male patients were excluded from the computation and also when the possible effect of patient age was controlled. While taking into account the modest patient sample which was related to a low rate of treatment seeking, depressive symptoms were common and similar to other western and Chinese patient groups. NPS reports were higher than in Singapore Chinese patients. There appeared to be a clear association between depression and diffuse physical symptoms. The findings should be considered in the holistic care of Chinese people with TMD.     

Prosthetic treatment need in a representative German sample

Regarding declining resources epidemiological data on needs for oral rehabilitation are required. Within the framework of an oral health survey a non-stratified two-stage random sample was taken to represent the over 14-year-old population of Saxony/Germany. The participation rate was 55%. Normative need was determined by dental assessment and guidelines developed in a consensus process, subjective prosthetic treatment need by self-complete questionnaire. About 97% of the realized sample could be planned within the guidelines. About 81% had normative prosthetic treatment need. Compared with the rate of normative need the rate of subjective need (13%) was considerably lower (chi(2) P < 0;01). Different predictive parameters of subjective need were identified by logistic regression. Besides other factors subjective need was associated with giving dentist's recommendation as significant reason for prosthetic restorations [odds ratio (OR)=5;43], not believing that the own teeth were all right (OR=0;17), and the existence of prosthetic restorations (OR=3;87 for fixed restorations; OR=4;05 for removable dentures). The guidelines proved their suitability to assess normative prosthetic treatment need in oral health surveys. Further research is necessary to find adequate options for including patients' preferences in an adequate need definition.     

成都市社区中老年人口腔健康相关生活质量评价及其影响因素分析

目的　了解成都市社区中老年人的口腔健康相关生活质量状况并分析影响因素。方法　随机抽取成都市600名社区中老年人调查，收集人口社会学特征、全身健康状况、口腔健康行为等信息，使用口腔健康影响程度量表（OHIP-14）评估口腔健康相关生活质量。结果　中老年人的口腔健康相关生活质量得分为（3.91±6.67）分，回归分析显示，收入水平（OR=0.387，P<0.05）、患慢性病（OR=0.665，P<0.05）、患口腔疾病（OR=0.260，P<0.05）、自评心理健康状况（OR=0.338，P<0.05）、每天刷牙2次（OR=1.846，P<0.05）、吸烟（OR=0.566，P<0.05）、主动获取口腔健康知识（OR=2.431，P<0.05）、就医方便程度（OR=0.499，P<0.05）是影响因素。结论　口腔健康相关生活质量受多重因素影响，积极开展社区口腔综合干预措施，提高居民口腔健康行为，改善社区中老年人口腔健康相关生活质量。     

Assessing change in quality of life using the Oral Health Impact Profile

Abstract— Traditionally longitudinal studies of oral health have measured only disease progression and ignored improvements in health. Objectives: This study examines methodological issues that arise in longitudinal assessment of change in oral health-related quality of life (OHRQOL). Methods: Baseline and 2-year follow-up data were used from an observational longitudinal study of 498 people aged 60 years or more living in South Australia. Oral health-related quality of life was measured using the Oral Health Impact Profile (OHIP). Three hypothesized risk predictors (tooth loss, problem-based dental visits and financial hardship) were selected to examine the effects of four methods of measuring change: categorical measures of improvement, deterioration and net change, and a quantitative measure of net change in OHIP scores. Results: Some 31.7% of people experienced some improvement and 32.7% experienced some deterioration in OHRQOL. All three high-risk groups had approximately twice the rate of deterioration in OHRQOL compared with their corresponding low-risk groups. Surprisingly, high-risk groups also had higher rates of improvement. When measured categorically, these effects did not cancel one another, indicating that improvement and deterioration in OHRQOL can be experienced simultaneously. However, quantitative analyses cause improvements and deteriorations to cancel, and analysis of mean OHIP scores created a spurious impression that change in OHRQOL did not differ between dental visit groups. Furthermore, changes in mean OHIP scores were masked by regression to the mean. Conclusions: Oral health-related quality of life measures capture both improvement and deterioration in health status, creating new complexities for conceptualizing and analyzing change in longitudinal studies.     

Prosthetic needs and demands for services of a group of elderly people in Israel

Abstract Prosthetic needs and demands for care were investigated in a group of the elderly, residing in Romema, Jerusalem, Israel. Of the population aged 60 and above residing in the neighborhood, 34% (n= 116) were selected at random. These were examined under standardized conditions and prosthetic status and denture requirements were recorded. The findings indicate that the prosthetic status was poor and the treatment needs extensive. In all, over 83% of the study population were edentulous, the majority in both arches. Although 86.3% of the edentulous subjects possessed dentures, over 86% of these subjects needed some form of prosthetic treatment. About 60% needed new full or partial dentures and over 25% had dentures whose fit and retention could be improved by rebasing, relining or minor adjustments.