Hearing results of canal wall reconstruction tympanoplasty for middle ear cholesteatoma in children.

OBJECTIVE: To investigate post-operative hearing results in children with middle ear cholesteatoma, and to analyze the correlation between hearing results and clinical factors and findings before and during the operation. PATIENTS AND METHODS: One hundred and twenty-four ears of 123 children were operated on for middle ear cholesteatoma at the age of 10 years or younger by canal wall reconstruction tympanoplasty and were followed up more than 1 year after the final operation. We evaluated the average air and bone conduction hearing levels at the speech ranges before the first operation (pre-operative hearing) and after the final operation (post-operative hearing). RESULTS: The mean of the average air conduction hearing level of 124 ears was significantly improved from 34.7 to 27.1 dB after the final operation. Among them, 84 ears (67.8%) showed a hearing level of 30 dB or less post-operatively. Post-operative hearing was better in the one-stage group than in the staged group. However, more than one-half of the ears which underwent type IV tympanoplasty in the staged group showed post-operative air conduction hearing level of < or =30 dB. Significant improvement in post-operative hearing was noted in ears with normal middle ear mucosa or middle ear effusion at the final operation. No correlation between hearing improvement and clinical factors such as age, type of cholesteatoma or presence of otitis media with effusion at the first operation was found. CONCLUSIONS: Children with middle ear cholesteatoma at the age of 10 years or younger exhibited good hearing post-operatively. Satisfactory hearing improvement is expected even in ears without the superstructure of the stapes if staged tympanoplasty is conducted. Canal wall reconstruction tympanoplasty for pediatric cholesteatoma was successful in terms of hearing results and the success was unrelated to various clinical factors.     

Eustachian tube patency and function in tympanoplasty with cartilage palisades or fascia after cholesteatoma surgery.

OBJECTIVE: To compare the Eustachian tube patency and function after tympanoplasty with either cartilage palisades or fascia grafting after one-stage surgery in children with tensa cholesteatoma. STUDY DESIGN: In children operated for tensa cholesteatoma, cartilage palisade tympanoplasty was performed in 32 ears and fascia tympanoplasty in 29 ears. The patency of the Eustachian tube was evaluated by the Valsalva maneuver before the operation, 1 to 3 months after the operation, and at a follow-up examination 46(1/2) months later (median). Eustachian tube function was evaluated by the nine-step inflation/deflation tympanometric test and the Toynbee test at the follow-up examination. Otomicroscopy and hearing evaluation were performed before and after surgery as well as at the follow-up. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Eustachian tube patency and function. Hearing, postoperative eardrum perforation/retraction, and cholesteatoma recurrence. RESULTS: The Valsalva maneuver was positive in 30% of the ears before the operation, in 65% primarily after the operation, and in 78% at the follow-up examination. A poor tubal function was found in 57% at follow-up. Overall, the late functional hearing results were better in ears with a positive Valsalva maneuver. There were no differences in tubal patency or function in relation to graft material, cholesteatoma, and tympanoplasty type. In ears with a poor tubal function, the hearing results were significantly better in the palisade group (63% success), compared with the fascia group (17% success). All of the four perforations, most of the retractions, and a single moist eardrum were found in the fascia group at the reevaluation. We found no correlation between the condition of the eardrum and the Eustachian tube function at the last evaluation. However, in ears with a poor tubal function, a nonretracted, nonperforated drum was found with higher frequency in the palisade group. Decision matrix analysis showed that the last postoperative Valsalva maneuver was the best predictor of the drum condition at the reevaluation. CONCLUSIONS: The Eustachian tube patency frequently improves after tympanoplasty after cholesteatoma surgery in children, regardless of graft material. The patency and function of the Eustachian tube seem to be without relation to graft material, cholesteatoma, or tympanoplasty type. Cartilage palisade tympanoplasty may be a better reconstruction technique after cholesteatoma surgery, especially in ears with a poor tubal function.     

Surgical results of canal wall reconstruction tympanoplasty in middle ear cholesteatoma

Materials were 236 ears of 213 patients with middle ear cholesteatoma undergoing canal wall reconstruction during 1993-1998. Subjects were followed up for at least 1 year after final operation. Of 236 ears, 147 (62%) underwent 1-stage operation and 89 ears (38%) required 2-stage operation. Hearing results were successful in 157 ears (67%) based on criteria proposed by the Otological Society of Japan. The success in ears undergoing 1-stage operation was 74% and 54% in ears undergoing 2-stage operation. Postoperative hearing and air-bone gap in the 1-stage group were significantly better than in the 2-stage group. For tympanoplasty, success was 97% in type I, 64% in type III, and 53% in type IV. The likelihood of undergoing 2-stage operation increased with the type of tympanoplasty, from type I to IV. Postoperative hearing was significantly worse in older age groups. Of the 89 ears, 13 (15%) had recurrent cholesteatoma and 29 (33%) had residual cholesteatoma at 2-stage operation. In the 135 in the 1-stage group, recurrent cholesteatoma was observed at follow-up in 13 ears (9.6%). When we analyzed clinical risk factors for both recurrent and residual cholesteatoma in age, gender, otorrhea, types of cholesteatoma, and types of tympanoplasty, no significant factors were seen for recurrent or residual cholesteatoma. These results indicate that canal wall reconstruction tympanoplasty for middle ear cholesteatoma yields relatively good hearing results. However, more effort is needed to reduce the incidence of recurrent and residual cholesteatoma.     

联合径路鼓室成形术方法的改进

对传统的联合径路鼓室成形术式做了部分改进，并采用钛质听骨行骨链重建，治疗胆脂瘤型中耳炎８６例，随访１８－５０个月，未见胆脂瘤复发及耳蜗性听力损伤，鼓膜全部愈合。表明改进的术式对彻底切除病变，防止胆脂瘤残留和复发，扩大手术适应证，方便听力重建和改善鼓室功能具有重要意义。     

One-stage surgery of middle ear cholesteatoma in adults: apropos of 180 cases]

OBJECTIVES: In order to evaluate the results of tympanoplasty in one stage middle ear cholesteatoma surgery, a retrospective study of 180 consecutive cholesteatomas operated on was undertaken. METHODS: 150 single procedures and 30 revision surgeries realized between 1992 and 1997 were analysed by studying anatomical and functional results with a mean follow-up of 24 months. RESULTS: Among the 150 adult patients, 85 (57%) were previously operated on in other centres and presented a recurrence of cholesteatoma. Closed technique was performed in 110 cases (61%) and opened one in the remaining cases (41%). Ossiculoplasty was made in 101 cases (56%) with different materials (15 incus autografts, 14 teflon prosthesis, 35 hydroxyapatite (HA) composite prosthesis and 37 all in HA prosthesis): 91 cases in a one-stage procedure but 10 worse functional results required a closed revision procedure. Twenty cases were also revised after one year of follow up at least: six recurrences of cholesteatoma were operated on by using canal down mastoidectomy (4%), 14 limited residual cholesteatomas (9.3%) had a revision closed technique procedure. CT Scan followed up all the patients operated on by a closed technique. Postoperative air-bone gap (ABG) was 20 +/- 11.3 dB and 27 +/- 10.1 dB in closed and opened techniques, respectively (p < 0.05). ABG was 20 +/- 9.2 dB and 26 +/- 13 dB in type II and type III tympanoplasty, respectively (p < 0.05). CONCLUSION: If the tympanic and posterior cavities are reasonably safe, middle ear cholesteatoma in adults can be well cured by a one-stage procedure including ossicular chain reconstruction with hydroxylapatite prosthesis covered with cartilage graft who achieved a valuable hearing restoration.     

完壁式乳突根治鼓室成形术治疗胆脂瘤中耳炎

目的:探讨完壁式乳突根治鼓室成形术治疗胆脂瘤中耳炎的临床效果和相关的经验教训.方法:对57例胆脂瘤中耳炎患者实施完壁式乳突根治鼓室成形术.结果:随访1～8年,平均3.7年.术后5例感染流脓,其中3例经及时处理得到控制并愈合,2例二次手术处理后愈合;3例术后因胆脂瘤复发行开放式乳突手术获干耳;鼓膜完整但有内陷者29例,其中2级内陷者13例;术后8个月及1年人工听骨脱出各1例.术后言语频率气导听阈降低>10 dB HL为72.2%(39/54),气骨导差<20 dB HL为53.7%(29/54),气骨导差缩小25 dB HL以上占42.6%(23/54).结论:施行完壁式乳突根治鼓室成形术,如果适应证掌握得当,技术条件许可,患者能按时随访.可以有效保留原中耳乳突解剖结构和改善听力,提高患者生活质量,应予优先选择该术式.     

A tympanometric comparison of tympanoplasty with cartilage palisades or fascia after surgery for tensa cholesteatoma in children

OBJECTIVE: The aim of the present study is to compare the tympanometric and functional findings of cartilage palisade tympanoplasty with those of tympanoplasty with temporalis fascia grafting after one-stage surgery in children with tensa cholesteatoma. STUDY DESIGN: In children aged 5 to 15 years (mean, 9.5 years) with tensa cholesteatoma, cartilage palisade tympanoplasty was performed in 32 ears and fascia tympanoplasty in 29 ears. Tympanometry was performed in 31 ears with cartilage palisade tympanoplasty (the palisade group) and 28 ears with fascia tympanoplasty (the fascia group) at follow-up a median of 48 months after surgical removal of the cholesteatoma (range, 3-75 months). MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Postoperative perforations, tympanometric parameters (tympanogram type, compliance, tympanometric width), and hearing. RESULTS: All postoperative re-perforations occurred in the fascia group. However, there was no difference between the palisade group and the fascia group in terms of tympanometric parameters, nor between the two groups when dividing into tensa retraction and sinus cholesteatoma subgroups. When comparing the types of tympanoplasty, the type II group reconstructed with cartilage palisades contained a higher number of ears with a normal compliance (0.2-1.6 mL) but a higher number of ears with a tympanometric width of more than 150 mmH2O. Regarding the number of ears with normal tympanometries, there was no significant difference between the palisade and the fascia group. The late functional hearing results were better in ears reconstructed with cartilage palisades, with functional success in 71%, compared with 54% in the group with fascia grafting. This difference in functional results was particularly pronounced in ears with an abnormal tympanogram (68% vs. 29%). CONCLUSION: Compared to fascia grafting, the present study showed better late functional hearing results after drum reconstruction using cartilage palisades, despite comparable tympanometric findings. Cartilage palisade reconstruction seems to provide better functional results, especially in ears with a poor tubal function, which is the common situation after cholesteatoma surgery.     

Congenital aural cholesteatoma: Results of surgery in 60 cases

From 1978 to 1993, 59 patients (60 ears) with congenital middle ear cholesteatoma were treated at the House Ear Clinic. The median patient age at presentation was 5 years, and the period of postoperative follow-up was 4.8 years. An intact canal wall was maintained in 58 of 60 cases and a closed middle ear space in all cases. In 12 operations, lateral graft tympanoplasty eradicated the cholesteatoma in one stage; 32 patients required a second-stage surgery to rule out recurrence, and the remaining 16 cases required three or more operations to eradicate disease and reconstruct the hearing mechanism. Thirty-five (63%) of 56 patients had a postoperative air-conduction threshold pure-tone average (PTA) within 10 dB of the best bone-conduction PTA; 91% were within 20 dB. Average speech reception threshold improved from 32 dB hearing level (HL) preoperatively to 20 dB HL postoperatively.     

A closed variant of staged tympanoplasty with mastoidectomy in patients with chronic purulent otitis media

127 case records were analysed retrospectively. All the patients had otitis media purulenta chronica and had undergone tympanoplasty (a closed variant). Regular revision of the trepanation cavity was performed in patients with cholesteatoma. Residual cholesteatoma was detected in 5 of 76 patients with cholesteatoma before the first operation, recurrent cholesteatoma occurred in 2 patients. Normal position of the neotympanic membrane and recovery of normal anatomy of the external acoustic meatus were achieved in 116 (91.3%) operated patients. Preservation or improvement of hearing were observed in all the patients. Bone-air gap under 30 dB was obtained in 79%. Thus, the proposed variant of closed staged tympanoplasty is effective for sanation of the infection focus with subsequent hearing improvement.     

Congenital and acquired cholesteatoma middle ear in children

Cholesteatoma of the middle ear in children may cause hypoacusis. Early diagnosis and optimal treatment is neccessary for good functional effect. We present 57 children (58 ears) with cholesteatoma treated in ENT Department of Medical University in Gdańsk in 1991-2002. The age of patients ranged between 3 and 16 years, the most common 11-15 years. In 52 (89.6%) cases acquired cholesteatoma and in 6 (10.4%) congenital cholesteatoma was diagnosed. Epitympanal cholesteatoma was found in 32 children (55.1%) whereas in posterior part of tympanic cavity--in 20 children (34.5%). In 6 cases (10.4%) intact tympanic membrane was found. Mean air-bone gap in acquired cholesteatoma before treatment was 18.7 dB, after treatment 15.7 dB. In congenital cholesteatoma mean air-bone gap before treatment was 13.6 dB, after treatment 14 dB. The most frequent symptom was hearing loss (98.3%) and purulent otorrhea (85.4%). Positive bacteriological culture was obtained in 43.1% of the cases. X-ray revealed sclero-pneumatic mastoid in 26 (34.5%) cases, sclerotic in 25 (43.1%) and pneumatic mastoid in 7 (12.1%) cases. Intracranial complications were found in 2 cases, intratemporal in 2 cases and extracranial complication in 1 case. Radical surgery was performed in 23 cases (39.7%) and in each case, which required reoperation, modified radical mastoidectomy in 20 cases (34.4%), in another 15 children (25.9%) tympanoplasty was done. The most frequent failure was purulent otorrhea in 21 (36.2%) cases. Reoperation in cholesteatoma recurrence was performed in 17 children (29.3%). Improvement or the same as preoperatively hearing level was obtained in 35 (60.3%) ears, hearing loss was revealed in 23 (39.7%) ears. Treatment of temporal bone cholesteatoma in children is difficult due to silent beginning, aggressive growth and frequent recurrence. The best treatment results in children cholesteatoma are obtained in early clinical stage and with open tympanoplasty procedure.     

Combined Heermann and Tos (CHAT) technique in cholesteatoma surgery: surgical technique and preliminary results

The combined Heermann and Tos (CHAT) technique is the combination of Heermann's 'cartilage palisade tympanoplasty' and Tos's 'modified combined approach tympanoplasty = modified intact canal wall mastoidectomy'. The first author (Cem Uzun) performed the CHAT technique as a one-stage operation in 15 ears of 15 patients with cholesteatoma. Two patients (one with a follow up of less than six months and one who did not show up at the final re-evaluation) were excluded from the study. Median age in the remaining 13 patients was 37 years (range: 14-57 years). Cholesteatoma type was attic, sinus (Tos tensa type 1) and tensa retraction (Tos tensa type 2) in six, five and two ears, respectively. Cholesteatoma stage was Saleh and Mills stage 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 in one, three, four, four and one ear, respectively. The eustachian tube was not involved with cholesteatoma in any ear. After drilling of the superoposterior bony annulus, transcanal atticotomy with preservation of thin bridge and cortical mastoidectomy with intact canal wall, the cholesteatoma was removed, and the eardrum and atticotomy were reconstructed with palisades of auricular cartilage. Type I tympanoplasty was performed in two ears, type II in nine ears and type III (stapes absent) in two ears, with either autologous incus (eight cases), cortical bone (two) or auricular cartilage (one). No complication occurred before, during or after surgery. Oto-microscopy and audiometry were done before and at a median of 13 months after surgery (mean 14 months, range 7-30 months). There was no sign of residual or recurrent cholesteatoma in any patient during the follow-up period. At the final examination, all ears were dry and had an intact eardrum except one with a small, central hole, which had been seen since the early post-operative period. Clean and stable attic retraction with a wide access was observed in two ears. Post-operative hearing at the final evaluation was better (change > 10 dB) than the pre-operative one in nine ears and did not change in the remaining four. Pre- and post-operative mean hearing values were, pure-tone average 47 and 35 dB (p = 0.01) and air-bone gap 30 and 20 dB (p = 0.02), respectively. With the CHAT technique, cholesteatoma can be completely and safely removed from the middle ear, and a durable and resistant reconstruction of the middle ear with reasonable hearing can be achieved. However, a further study should analyse long-term results of a larger patient group.     

Canal wall-down procedure with soft posterior meatal wall reconstruction in acquired cholesteatoma: focus on postoperative middle ear status*

Objectives: We reviewed surgical results of canal wall-down tympanoplasty (CWDT) with soft posterior meatal wall reconstruction (SWR) for acquired cholesteatoma (AC), and identified factors associated with surgical outcomes.

Methods: Results from 119 ears with AC (pars flaccida, n?=?99; pars tensa, n?=?20) that underwent CWDT with SWR were retrospectively reviewed. We defined postoperative balloon-like retraction (PBR) with web formation, which needed reoperation to clean accumulated cerumen, as postoperative deep retraction pocket (PDRP).

Results: Residual cholesteatoma was found in 11 ears (9.2%). Seven residual cholesteatomas were treated with outpatient operation. Seven ears (5.9%) showed PDRP. A transcanal approach was applied to all PDRPs. Postoperative mastoid reaeration was observed in 57 ears (47.9%). No factors significantly associated with residual cholesteatoma or PDRP were identified. The frequency of postoperative mastoid reaeration was significantly higher among cases with young age (<50 years), stage I cholesteatoma, or type I ossiculoplasty.

Conclusion: CWDT with SWR showed low rates of residual cholesteatoma or postoperative deep retraction pocket (PDRP). Most residual cholesteatomas and PDRPs could be dealt with using a minimally invasive procedure. Young age, stage I cholesteatoma, and type I ossiculoplasty were associated with postoperative mastoid reaeration. This procedure seems fully feasible for surgical treatment of AC.     

Butterfly cartilage graft inlay tympanoplasty for large perforations

OBJECTIVE: Butterfly graft inlay tympanoplasty is a well-established technique for the repair of small perforations. However, the efficacy of the technique for medium and large tympanic membrane perforations remains unknown. STUDY DESIGN: Retrospective case series. METHODS: Postauricular tympanoplasty and tympanomastoidectomy using a large butterfly cartilage inlay graft (>4 mm diameter to total drum replacement) were analyzed in 90 pediatric patients (99 ears). RESULTS: Patient ages ranged from 2 to 20 years; mean follow-up duration was 27.6 months. Successful closure occurred in 92% of the ears. No graft lateralized nor displaced into the middle ear. No retraction pocket occurred during the follow-up period. In 62 cases, intact canal wall or canal wall window tympanomastoidectomy was performed; Fifty-one (82.2%) of the patients having mastoidectomy procedures had chronic otitis media with cholesteatoma. The mean preoperative to postoperative four-tone air-bone gap improved from 23 to 21 dB; the number of patients with 0 to 10 dB hearing results increased from 16 ears preoperatively to 32 ears postoperatively. Postoperative suboptimal results included eight patients with postoperative perforations in the residual tympanic membrane adjacent to an intact cartilage graft; two of these patients were the only individuals who exhibited otorrhea. CONCLUSIONS: Cartilage butterfly graft inlay tympanoplasty is effective in the vast majority of patients with moderate to large perforations. The closure rate exceeded 90% with no graft displacement, postoperative adverse events were respectably low, and hearing results improved or remained stable despite the need for concurrent mastoidectomy in the majority of patients.     

Hearing ability after cholesteatoma surgery

Five years after cholesteatoma surgery (primary operation in 1981 and 1982) we examined 112 patients to determine the hearing and clinical results in follow-up. In 12 (10.7%) patients Cholesteatoma recurred. During the period of follow-up 28 (25%) ears underwent second surgery. Comparing the open (50.9%) with the closed (49.1%) technique a better air bone gap was gained for the closed technique procedures. This was confirmed when the different types of tympanoplasty were compared between the two groups. In 69.5% of the closed procedures the air bone gap was less than 20 dB, whereas the value for the open technique was 51.1%. In 30 patients a second-look operation was recommended, which was performed in 15 persons; 8 recurrent cholesteatoma were detected. Reducing the application of the closed procedures from a rate of 78.1% in the years 1971/1972 to 49.1% in 1981/1982, we saw a distinct reduction of cholesteatoma recurrence from 25% in 1971/1972 to 10.7% in the present study. The data show that the advice for a second-look operation should be seriously considered. Furthermore, the study indicates that due to modern tympanoplastic techniques also in longterm follow-up good hearing results can be obtained.     

Why do some children have good hearing results following type III and IV tympanoplasty? Current theories of middle ear mechanics

INTRODUCTION: Middle ear reconstruction in children following tympanomastoidectomy for cholesteatoma is commonly limited to a Wullstein type III or IV reconstruction owing to ossicular erosion. The hearing outcomes of this procedure have been unpredictable. Nevertheless, there are children who have remarkably good hearing results despite having extensive and aggressive cholesteatoma surgery and limited reconstruction. METHODS: The current theories of middle ear mechanics following tympanoplasty and ossicular reconstruction are reviewed. In addition, a selective retrospective chart review of pediatric type III and IV tympanoplasty at The Hospital for Sick Children between 1998 and 2003 is presented. RESULTS: Nine patients were reconstructed with a type III (n = 3) or IV (n = 6) tympanoplasty. The mean pre- and postoperative air-bone gaps were 43.6 and 24.9 dB. Speech reception threshold improved from 37.5 to 22.8 dB. The changes were statistically significant (p < .05). CONCLUSIONS: This series of patients demonstrated a statistically significant hearing improvement at long-term follow-up. The improvements are consistent with optimal hearing outcomes predicted by current theories of middle ear mechanics.     

中耳胆脂瘤和慢性化脓性中耳炎手术临床分析

目的　探讨中耳胆脂瘤和慢性化脓性中耳炎术式选择及临床效果。方法　对110例中耳乳突病变,包括中耳胆脂瘤和慢性化脓性中耳炎,根据范围显微镜下实施完壁式或开放式乳突根治,部分同时鼓室成形术,随访术后干耳状况、并发症、复发情况以及术后听力改善程度等。结果　110例患者中66例中耳胆脂瘤、44例慢性化脓性中耳炎,出现颅内外并发症者7例。手术方式：51例（46.36%）行完壁式乳突根治术,46例（41.81%）同时行鼓室成形术,59例（53.64%）行开放式乳突根治术。完壁式乳突根治术后听 力提高＞25 dB 37例（33.64%）,＞15 dB 14例（12.72%）;开放式乳突根治术后听力提高＞15 dB 5例（4.55%）,听力减退4例（3.64%）,比较手术前后言语频率区平均听阈,差异有统计学意义（P＜0.05）。术后随访1年发现开放式和完壁式两组胆脂瘤复发共4例。结论　中耳胆脂瘤与慢性化脓性中耳炎通过选择恰当手术方式可获得较好的临床疗效。     

Cholesteatoma surgery: open vs closed tympanoplasty

The purpose of this report is to compare closed tympanoplasty (canal wall up) and open tympanoplasty (canal wall down) performed in ears with extensive cholesteatoma operated on and followed up during the past 11 years. The study has demonstrated that there are no significant differences between open and closed tympanoplasties in terms of both postoperative subjective problems and auditory results. The only definite difference relates to recurring cholesteatoma: canal wall-up operations are complicated by recurrence of cholesteatoma in a not insignificant number of ears and require a planned two-stage procedure in all the cases. By contrast, the postoperative clinical course of open tympanoplasties has been only rarely affected by cholesteatomatous complications. It is concluded that reduction of cholesteatoma recurrence to the greatest degree possible necessitates removal of the canal wall. Open tympanoplasty is an effective alternative for closed tympanoplasty in all cases in which there is a contraindication to preserving the canal wall and in all patients whose medical or social conditions prevent scheduling an operation in more stages.     

Bilateral myringoplasty in chronic otitis media

OBJECTIVE: A theoretical risk of iatrogenic sensorineural hearing loss (HL) during surgery has induced a reluctance to perform bilateral myringoplasty/tympanoplasty type I among some otosurgeons. This paper presents results of bilateral surgery in 26 patients. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Twenty-six patients with bilateral, dry tympanic membrane perforations caused by chronic otitis media were selected prospectively for bilateral myringoplasty/tympanoplasty type I (52 ears) at a tertiary referral center. All patients had a HL corresponding to the size and localization of the perforation (no suspicion of ossicular chain defect or other pathology). Mean age was 13.3 years, and the male to female ratio was 1.36. All but one ear were operated through a transcanal approach, and the onlay technique was used most frequently (83%), with use of fascia (56%), tragal perichondrium (38%), or cartilage palisades (6%) as graft material. Follow-up examination and hearing tests (pure tone and speech audiometry) were performed at a mean of 13.8 months after surgery. RESULTS: Perforation closure was obtained in 49 (94%) of the 52 ears. Hearing improved significantly, and the air-bone gap was significantly reduced. The air-bone gap was closed to within 10 dB in 92% and within 20 dB in 100% of the ears. Surprisingly good hearing was found during postoperative, bilateral ear canal gauze packing. Iatrogenic sensorineural HL did not occur. CONCLUSIONS: We conclude that bilateral myringoplasty is safe, with good results, reduces costs, and leaves the patient satisfied. The hearing impairment during postoperative ear canal packing is surprisingly modest and readily acceptable by the patients.     

Tympanoplasty on only hearing ears

The management of only hearing ears remains controversial because of the risk of postoperative hearing deterioration. We reviewed 12 cases of hearing ears alone operated on at the Hyogo College of Medicine Department of Otolaryngology from 1999 to 2002. All ears were dry at the final examination. Postoperative hearing results were evaluated based on the guideline of the Japan Otological Society (2000). An air bone gap within 15 dB was found in 9 cases (75%), hearing gain exceeding 15 dB was found in 6 cases (50%), the hearing level was within 30 dB in 4 cases (33.3%), and total successful cases numbered 10 (83.3%). Eight patients wore hearing aids before surgery, and 4 patients (50%) did not need them after the surgery. We suggest that tympanoplasty by skillful surgeons should be done to obtain a dry ear, to avoid a progressive hearing loss, to preserve or improve hearing, and to improve the quality of life. We also suggest that handling of ossicles should minimized in chronic otitis media and cholesteatoma.     

Tympanoplasty: review of 400 staged cases

Staging of tympanoplasty is important in the management of patients with chronic otitis media. It allows establishment of an air-containing middle ear space and adequate postoperative hearing levels in a large proportion of patients with severely diseased ears. The results of 400 staged procedures performed over a 3-year period at the House Ear Clinic, Los Angeles are reported. Staging was performed in 75% of tympanoplasty with mastoidectomy cases and in 15% of ears not requiring mastoid surgery. Closure of the air-bone gap to 20 dB or less occurred in 68% of patients with intact stapes. Mucous membrane problems were the most common reason for staging. Almost one third of cases with middle ear cholesteatoma at the first stage had residual disease on reexploration. Staging of tympanoplasty continues to be an important technique in management of severely diseased ears.