Heterogeneity of antibodies directed against the alpha-bungarotoxin binding site on human acetylcholine receptor and severity of myasthenia gravis

A rapid and sensitive radioimmunological method is described, using decamethonium (DC), which revealed antibodies which blocked alpha-bungarotoxin (alpha-Bgt) binding to human acetylcholine receptor (AChR) in 98% of myasthenia gravis (MG) patients' sera tested. These sera had anti-AChR antibody titres by the conventional assay. The titre of blocking antibodies (1 to 110 nM) could be measured and was found to produce from 1 to 54% inhibition of alpha-Bgt binding. No relationship was found between these titres and anti-AChR antibody titres. MG sera were divided into 2 major groups on the basis of their blocking effects, with and without DC, but there was no correlation between these and the clinical status, as defined by Osserman's classification. However, no sera from asymptomatic or ocular MG patients had the dual capacities of blocking alpha-Bgt binding, directly and in the presence of DC.     

Differences between ocular and generalized myasthenia gravis: binding characteristics of anti-acetylcholine receptor antibody against bovine muscles

We studied the binding characteristics of anti-acetylcholine receptor antibody (AChR Ab) in sera of nine patients with myasthenia gravis (MG) using affinity-purified extraocular muscles (EOM) and foot muscles (FM) of bovine species. The titer of AChR Ab measured with EOM was the same as that measured with FM for both ocular and generalized MG. In patients with ocular MG, the affinity of AChR Ab, determined by Scatchard analysis, was higher for FM than for EOM (P less than 0.05), whereas it was the same for EOM and FM in those with generalized MG. On the other hand, the affinity of AChR Ab for FM was lower in generalized MG than in ocular MG (P less than 0.05), but that for EOM did not differ between the two types of MG. The affinity of AChR Ab did not change after passing the patients' sera through an EOM-affinity column. The EOM-affinity column treatment of the sera decreased the AChR Ab titer measured with EOM in all patients, but the AChR Ab titer measured with FM was decreased in only some of the patients. These data indicate that there are polyclonal or heterogeneous AChR Abs in the sera of MG patients, which does not help to explain the clinical difference between ocular and generalized MG.     

Heterogeneity of antibodies directed against the α-bungarotoxin binding site on human acetylcholine receptor and severity of myasthenia gravis

A rapid and sensitive radioimmunological method is described, using decamethonium (DC), which revealed antibodies which blocked α-bungarotoxin (α-Bgt) binding to human acetylcholine receptor (AChR) in 98% of myasthenia gravis (MG) patients' sera tested. These sera had anti-AChR antibody titres by the conventional assay. The titre of blocking antibodies (1 to 110 nM) could be measured and was found to produce from 1 to 54% inhibition of α-Bgt binding. No relationship was found between these titres and anti-AChR antibody titres. MG sera were divided into 2 major groups on the basis of their blocking effects, with and without DC, but there was no correlation between these and the clinical status, as defined by Osserman's classification. However, no sera from asymptomatic or ocular MG patients had the dual capacities of blocking α-Bgt binding, directly and in the presence of DC.     

Clinical implementation of anti-acetylcholine receptor antibodies.

A multivariate analysis of anti-acetylcholine receptor (AChR) antibodies and clinical parameters other than treatment (modified Osserman groups, age, type of onset, sex, and thymus pathology) was performed for all incident (n = 366) myasthenia gravis (MG) cases in its white population in Denmark during the past 15 years. Sera from 244 healthy individuals and from 295 patients with diseases other than MG were analysed as controls. Formal statistics for the anti-AChR antibodies assay (immunoprecipitation RIA using crude human AChR extract) were calculated. The distribution of antibodies titres greater than 0.1 nMole/l was found to be approximately lognormal. For MG patients the 95% reference interval was 0.2-1549 nMoles/l, and in control sera the range was 0.0-0.4 nMole/l. Using 0.5 nMole/l as the cut-off level and regarding all results less than this value as normal titres, it appeared that the assay was highly specific (> 99.99%) for MG. In a population of MG patients significance should be attributed to values in the range 0.3-0.4 nMole/l. The overall diagnostic sensitivity was found to be 88%. The sensitivity appeared to be proportionate to clinical severity of MG. The percentage with a normal titre was higher (16%) for early onset of MG, compared with 7% for late onset. No significant difference in relation to the frequency of "negative titre" was found in relation to sex. Anti-AChR antibodies titre was found to correlate with clinical severity, female or male gender, and pathology of thymus. The groups of MG patients were not matched for the various clinical parameters but multiple regression analysis controlling for these variables revealed independent effects of clinical severity and sex though not of age. Normal thymus (including involuted gland) and thymoma were correlated with low to intermediate tires, and hyperplastic thymus with high level of antibodies. The clinical implementation of anti-AchR antibodies is reviewed from 1976 and up to the present. The problems with false positive results are thoroughly expounded.     

Acetylcholine receptor antibodies in myasthenia gravis

A multivariate statistical analysis of levels of serum acetylcholine receptor antibody (AChR Ab) obtained from 197 patients with various clinical forms of myasthenia gravis (MG) was performed. Elevated AChR Ab levels are specific for MG, but normal AChR Ab levels do not rule out MG. Patients in remission or with purely ocular MG had the lowest incidence of elevation of serum AChR Ab levels, while patients with generalized, severe MG, particularly in the presence of thymoma, tended to have the greatest antibody elevations. Corticosteroids depressed AChR Ab levels, but thymectomy did not exert a consistent effect on antibody levels within a 24- to 30-month postoperative period. The relatively low 55% positivity of antibody elevations in all 197 patients probably reflects the use of heterologous (rat) AChR.     

Acetylcholine receptor antibody positivity rate in ocular myasthenia gravis: a matter of age?

Journal of Neurology - Anti-acetylcholine receptor antibodies (AChR Abs) are detected in 85% of myasthenia gravis (MG) patients, at higher rates in patients with late-onset disease. AChR Ab...     

Clinical and experimental features of MuSK antibody positive MG in Japan

We investigated the presence of antibodies (Abs) against muscle-specific tyrosine kinase (MuSK) in Japanese myasthenia gravis (MG) patients. MuSK Abs were found in 23 (27%) of 85 generalized seronegative MG (SNMG) patients but not in any of the ocular MG patients. MuSK Ab-positive patients were characterized as having female dominance (M:F, 5:18), age range at onset 18 to 72 (median 45) years old, and prominent oculobulbar symptoms (100%) with neck (57%) or respiratory (35%) muscle weakness. Limb muscle weakness was comparatively less severe (52%), thymoma absent. Most patients had good responses to simple plasma exchange and steroid therapy. MuSK IgG from all 18 patients was exclusively the IgG 4 subclass and bound mainly with the MuSK Ig 1–2 domain. Serial studies of 12 individuals showed a close correlation between the variation in MuSK Ab titers and MG clinical severity ( P  = 0.01 by Kruskal–Wallis). MuSK Ab titers were sharply decreased in patients who had a good response to early steroid therapy or simple plasma exchange, but there was no change, or a rapid increase on exacerbation after thymectomy. Measurement of MuSK Ab titers aids in the diagnosis of MG and the monitoring of clinical courses after treatment.     

Combined effects of a thymic peptide, thymopoietin and myasthenic patient sera in rat myotube culture.

We investigated in a rat myotube assay the combined effect of 26 myasthenic (MG) patient sera and a thymic peptide, thymopoietin (Tpo) which had previously been shown to bind Torpedo and human AChR and to compete with alpha-bungarotoxin (alpha-Bgt) binding. Cultures were first exposed to Tpo alone for 3 h (0.3, 7.5, 15 nM), then MG sera (5% final dilution) were added for an additional 18 h. Reduction in the amount of 125I-alpha-Bgt binding sites in the presence of various concentrations of Tpo were similar with control sera and in all the patients with low or undetectable anti-AChR Ab (11 cases). In cultures exposed to Tpo and sera with high anti-AChR Ab titre (15 cases), Tpo and anti-AChR Ab have an additive capacity to reduce the number of alpha-Bgt binding sites. The results are compatible with the hypothesis that anti-AChR Ab and Tpo could impair neuromuscular transmission by complementary mechanisms.     

Anti-alkaline phosphatase antibody positive myasthenia gravis

Anti-alkaline phosphatase antibody (AP Ab) was specific in 9% of 249 anti-acetylcholine receptor (AChR) Ab-positive myasthenia gravis (MG) (SPMG) patients but not in patients with AChR Ab-negative MG (SNMG), other neurological and immunological diseases, or healthy volunteers. No cross-reactivity and no significant titer correlation were found between AP Ab and AChR Ab. We confirmed immunologically by radioimmunoassay and western blot analysis the presence of antibodies directed against AP. AP Ab-positive SPMG patients were characterized clinically as having female predominance and a more severe form of generalized MG than AP Ab-negative SPMG patients, and about half required artificial ventilation at maximum severity. AP Ab's pathogenic role in MG is yet unclarified, but our findings show AP to be a novel antigen among the various autoantigens present in MG patients and in whom AP Ab may modify clinical symptoms.     

Evidence against acetylcholine receptor having a main immunogenic region as target for autoantibodies in myasthenia gravis

We investigated specificities of acetylcholine receptor (AChR) antibodies in 100 seropositive patients with myasthenia gravis (MG). Antibodies in 74 of these sera were inhibited by more than 50% from binding to human muscle AChR by a rat monoclonal antibody (mAb) of "main immunogenic region" (MIR) specificity. The mAb inhibition was not explainable by epitope competition because (1) the mAb was reactive with both Torpedo and human AChR, but antibodies in 85 of the MG sera did not bind to Torpedo AChR, and (2) the mAb blocked binding of rat anti-peptide antibodies to an alpha subunit region of the human AChR unrelated antigenically to the designated MIR region. Individual patients' sera had evidence of extensive antibody heterogeneity and revealed interspecies polymorphisms in AChR antigenicity, near and remote from the neurotransmitter-binding region. The data challenge the concept that a MIR of the AChR is the principal stimulus for antibody production in MG and emphasize a potential pitfall in assuming seronegativity in MG on the basis of a single assay system.     

Immunogenetic heterogeneity and associated autoimmune disorders in myasthenia gravis: a population-based survey in the province of Ferrara, northern Italy

Introduction - The well-established relationship between myasthenia gravis (MG) and HLA antigens varies among different ethnic groups. In Caucasians B8 and/or DR3 alleles have been found associated with young MG women without thymoma and with high titres of acetylcholine-receptor antibody (AChR Ab). An increased frequency of haplotype HLA-A3, B7 and/or DR2 has been observed in older MG patients with low AChR Ab levels. So far, there is no convincing evidence for an association between a specific haplotype HLA and ocular MG or MG with thymoma. MG subjects often show other concurrent autoimmune disorders suggesting a more general inherited predisposition to autoimmunity. We performed a community-based study to verify the HLA-A, B, C, DR and DQ profile on ethnically homogeneous MG patients and with the aim to estimate the frequency of concurrent autoimmune diseases and to compare HLA phenotypes to autoimmune status in different MG patients groups. Methods - Forty-seven patients, living in the province of Ferrara, were followed-up in our neurologic department and typed for HLA Antigens. In addition a set of immunological laboratory tests was performed. Results - We found a trend towards an increased B8 and DR3 frequencies in total affected population; an association between B8 allele and early onset of generalized MG sustained by thymic hyperplasia. The DR3 allele is statistically associated with the presence of additional autoimmune disorders. Conclusions - Our data support the hypothesis of a genetically-based heterogeneity of the disease and show an increased prevalence of associate autoimmune conditions in MG patients.     

Heterogeneity and shifts in distribution of muscle weakness in myasthenia gravis

The distribution of muscle weakness in myasthenia gravis (MG) patients with acetylcholine receptor (AChR) antibodies is highly variable. As muscle groups respond differently to therapeutic interventions, it is important to acknowledge this variability. We analysed the distribution of muscle weakness in 225 AChR MG patients over time. On the basis of combinations of muscle weakness, seven phenotypes were defined: ‘ocular’ (O), ‘bulbar’ (B), ‘neck/limbs/respiratory’ (NLR), or a combination (O+B, O+NLR, B+NLR and O+B+NLR). MG remained restricted to ocular weakness in 5%, whereas 7% never had ocular weakness. At last follow-up, ocular or bulbar weakness had resolved more frequently than NLR weakness (40%, 38% and 25%; p = 0.003, respectively). Patients with O, B or OB phenotype at baseline had a higher age at onset and were more frequently male than patients with NLR, ONLR, BNLR or OBNLR phenotype (52.7 ± 17.5 vs. 44.0 ± 18.9; p = 0.007 and 64% vs. 37%; p = 0.002, respectively). MG patients have heterogeneous distributions of muscle weakness and frequently shift between phenotypes. The phenotypic variations found in AChR MG suggest that also other factors aside from the AChR antibody mediated immune response are of importance in determining the disease expression in MG.     

Nonthymoma early-onset- and late-onset-generalized myasthenia gravis--a retrospective hospital-based study

OBJECTIVE: Acquired myasthenia gravis (MG) is predominantly due to nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (AChR) autoantibodies (Ab). Differences between nonthymoma early-onset and late-onset MG were reported. We studied the clinical and serological characteristics of nonthymoma AChR Ab-positive-generalized MG patients. PATIENTS AND METHODS: Chinese AChR Ab-positive-generalized MG patients who had generalized disease for 3 years or longer were studied. RESULTS: Among 41 such patients, 25 (61%) were female. The mean onset age was 43.5 years (range 9-78 years) and the mean follow-up duration was 7.8 years (range 3-20 years). Sixteen (39%) patients had late-onset disease (onset age >or=50 years). Compared to early-onset patients (onset age <50 years), late-onset patients were characterized by male predominance (p=0.002), absence of thymic lymphofollicular hyperplasia (p=0.036), and a higher striated muscle Ab seropositivity rate (94% versus 4%, p<0.001). Although there was no statistically significant difference in clinical severity and outcome or response to treatment between late-onset and early-onset patients, 50% and 75% of late-onset patients had moderate or severe disease at onset and worst status, respectively, compared to 28% and 52% for early-onset patients at onset and worst status, respectively. Also 63% of late-onset patients had disease progressed within first 3 years compared to only 40% of early-onset patients did. CONCLUSION: Nonthymoma late-onset-generalized MG patients were common among Hong Kong Chinese, with a statistically non-significant trend that it was clinically more severe than early-onset MG but with similar clinical outcome or response to treatment; >90% of these patients were seropositive for striated muscle Ab.     

肌球蛋白抗体在重症肌无力病人血清中的表达及其在发病机制中的作用

目的:探讨myosin-Ab在MG发病机制中所起的作用。方法:采用ELISA法检测重症肌无力(MG)组54例,正常人组92例及其他疾病对照组28例血清中myosin-Ab的表达。结果:Myosin-Ab在血清中的正常值P/N(病人与正常人OD值之比)范围:0~2.98。高于2.98则为阳性。Myosin-Ab阳性率与肌无力严重程度呈正相关。Myosin-Ab效价与AChR-Ab呈正相关。结论:Myosin-Ab虽然不是诱发MG的必要条件,但由于myosin与AChR存在抗原交叉性,myosin-Ab在MG的发病机制中可能起重要作用。     

Multiple forms of anti-acetylcholine receptor antibody in myasthenia gravis

Sera of patients with myasthenia gravis (MG) contain anti-acetylcholine receptor (AChR) lgG antibodies (Ab) which have different antigenic specificities. Three Ab types were detected: (1) MG-I, which forms immune complexes with AChR; (2) MG-C, which decreases binding of AChR to concanavalin A; and MG-B, which blocks α-bungarotoxin binding to AChR. Sera from 152 MG patients were screened for the Ab types. Sixty-one percent contained MG-I, 26% contained MG-C, 10% contained MG-B, and 5% contained both MG-C and MG-B. The latter Ab types were associated with more severe forms of MG but showed no other clinical correlations. IgG antibodies of defined type were purified, and their interaction with unlabeled and toxin-prelabeled AChR from denervated rat muscle was studied in detail. Receptors are homogeneous with respect to determinants recognized by MG-I, but heterogeneous with respect to determinants recognized by MG-C (3 subpopulations, 22%, 28%, and 50% of AChR) and by MG-B (2 subpopulations, 30% and 70% of AChR). The stoichiometry of AChR interaction with the antibodies indicates that for each toxin-binding site, the receptor is divalent as an antigen for MG-I and MG-C but is tetravalent for MG-B. Denervated muscle AChR appears to be a mixture of at least 3 molecular forms of AChR, each of which has distinct immunological features as well as components common to all the receptor subpopulations.     

Experimental autoimmune myasthenia gravis in mice expressing human immunoglobulin loci

Antibodies (Abs) specifically directed against the muscular acetylcholine receptor (AChR) mediate the pathogenesis of myasthenia gravis (MG). The animal model experimental autoimmune MG (EAMG) can be induced by passive transfer or by active immunization of anti-AChR Abs. We report a new EAMG mouse model that generates human anti-AChR Abs upon immunization with Torpedo AChR (tAChR). Mice transgenic for human mu, gamma1, and kappa germ line genes (HuMAb-Mice) were immunized with tAChR. Serum titers of anti-tAChR Abs were in the nanomolar range, and anti-rodent AChR Abs were in picomolar range. Some HuMAb-Mice had signs of muscle weakness, clearly indicating their susceptibility to EAMG. Human Ab-mouse AChR complexes were found at the neuromuscular junction, while AChR loss was up to 65%. Spleen and lymph nodes were used for producing hybridomas. Of the anti-tAChR monoclonal Ab-producing hybridomas, 2% had cross-reactivity with rodent AChR and none with human AChR. Immunization with a fusion protein, Trx-Halpha1-210, displaying the human main immunogenic region did not result in EAMG or the generation of human anti-human AChR monoclonal Abs. These experiments show that the HuMAb-Mouse represents a suitable model to generate and study the effects of human anti-AChR Abs in vivo.     

Seronegative generalised myasthenia gravis: clinical features,antibodies, and their targets

Myasthenia gravis (MG) is a well-recognised disorder of neuromuscular transmission that can be diagnosed by the presence of antibodies to the acetylcholine receptor (AChR). However, some patients (about 15%) with generalised MG do not have detectable AChR antibodies. There is some evidence, however, that this "seronegative" MG is an antibody-mediated disorder. Plasma from patients with the disorder seems to contain various distinct humoral factors: IgG antibodies that reversibly inhibit AChR function; a non-IgG (possibly IgM) factor that indirectly inhibits AChR function; and an IgG antibody against the muscle-specific kinase (MuSK). The presence of antibodies against MuSK appears to define a subgroup of patients with seronegative MG who have predominantly localised, in many cases bulbar, muscle weaknesses (face, tongue, pharynx, etc) and reduced response to conventional immunosuppressive treatments. Moreover, muscle wasting may be present, which prevents complete response to these therapies.     

Detection of antibody classes and subpopulations in Myasthenia gravis patients using a new nonradioactive enzyme immunoassay

To investigate the presence of antibodies in myasthenia gravis (MG) patients, we have developed a new reproducible and sensitive enzyme immunoassay (EIA-AChR), in which a β subunit-specific monoclonal antibody (mAb 73) immobilizes fetal calf acetylcholine receptors (AChRs). We tested 92 MG patients (42 with positive and 50 with negative antibody titers), 60 healthy controls, and 40 controls with other autoimmune diseases. EIA-AChR detected immunoglobulin G (IgG) titers in all of the seropositive samples, with a significant correlation between these and those obtained using the traditional immunoprecipitation method. Moreover, 5 seronegative patients at immunoprecipitation assay were positive at EIA-AChR. EIA-AChR was also useful in revealing: (1) a seropositive patient subpopulation with generalized MG who had Abs directed against α-Bungarotoxin binding sites; and (2) patients with IgM directed against fetal calf AChR (detected in 13 seronegative and 16 seropositive MG patients, and in 6 of the patients with other autoimmune diseases). © 1997 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Muscle Nerve 20: 800–808, 1997     

Interferon-beta: the neutralizing antibody (NAb) titre predicts reversion to NAb negativity

BACKGROUND: It has been reported that in some patients with MS who develop neutralizing antibodies (NAbs) against interferon beta (IFNbeta), antibody levels can initially increase and then decrease thereafter even when treatment is continued. OBJECTIVE: To determine whether NAb titre correlates with time to reversion to NAb negativity in patients with multiple sclerosis (MS). METHODS: Twenty-eight patients with MS who were NAb-positive during treatment with one of the currently available IFNbetas were included in this retrospective study. NAb titres were determined by the myxovirus resistance protein A induction assay. Patients were considered NAb-positive if they had at least two consecutive samples with titres of > or = 20 neutralizing units (NU). Reversion to NAb-negative status was defined as two consecutive negative samples (NAb titre of < 20 NU) after NAb positivity. RESULTS: When measured two years after treatment initiation, a NAb titre of < 75 NU had a 91.7% sensitivity and a 87.5% specificity for reversion to NAb negativity in the following two years (after a total of four years of treatment). In addition, somewhat surprisingly, patients whose serum converted to NAb-negative generally developed peak NAb titres earlier than patients who remained NAb-positive (mean time of first detection was 21 versus 38 months, respectively). CONCLUSION: The NAb titre might support treatment decisions in patients with MS whose test results are positive for NAbs.     

Myasthenia gravis induced in mice by immunization with the recombinant extracellular domain of rat muscle-specific kinase (MuSK)

Myasthenia gravis (MG) is mostly caused by anti-acetylcholine receptor (AChR) auto-antibodies (Abs). Such Abs are undetectable in 10-15% of MG patients, but many have anti-muscle-specific kinase (MuSK) Abs. We injected recombinant rat-MuSK extracellular domain in H-2(a), H-2(b), H-2(bm12) and H-2(d) mice. Certain strains exhibited exercise-induced fatigue, tremors, weight loss, and some died after 2-3 injections. Compound muscle action potentials showed decrement with low-frequency repetitive nerve stimulation. Miniature endplate potentials decreased, suggesting lower numbers of endplates functional AChRs. Myasthenic sera inhibited agrin-induced AChR aggregation in C2C12 myotubes. Conclusion: Anti-MuSK Abs induce MG, which might also result from blocking the agrin-signaling pathway.