Reflexes elicited from cutaneous and mucosal trigeminal afferents in normal human subjects

It has been shown that in patients in whom the central stump of the hypoglossal nerve has been anastomosed to the peripheral stump of a lesioned facial nerve, supraorbital nerve stimulation can elicit a short-latency reflex (12.5±0.6 ms; mean±S.D.) in facial muscles similar to the R1 disynaptic blink reflex response, but not followed by an R2 blink reflex component⁴⁶. Thus in addition to replacing the facial neurons at peripheral synapses, these hypoglossal nerves contribute to a trigemino-hypoglossal reflex. The aim of this work was to study the type of reflex activities which can be elicited in both facial and tongue muscles by electrical stimulation of cutaneous (supraorbital nerve) or mucosal (lingual nerve) trigeminal (V) afferents in normal subjects. The results show that although stimulation of cutaneous V1 afferents elicits the well-known double component (R1–R2) blink reflex response in the orbicularis oculi muscles, it does not produce any detectable reflex response in the genioglossus muscle, even during experimental paradigms designed to facilitate the reflex activity. Conversely, stimulation of mucosal V3 afferents can elicit a single reflex response of the R1 type in the genioglossus muscle but not in the orbicularis oculi muscles, even during experimental paradigms designed to facilitate the reflex activity. These data are discussed in terms of two similar but separate circuits for the R1 responses of cutaneous (blink reflex) and mucosal (tongue reflex) origins. They suggest that in patients with hypoglossal-facial (XII–VII) nerve anastomosis, the short-latency trigemino-‘hypoglossal-facial' reflex of the R1 blink reflex type observed in facial muscles following supraorbital nerve stimulation could be due to changes in synaptic effectiveness of the central connectivity within the principal trigeminal nucleus where both cutaneous and mucosal trigeminal afferents project.     

Electrophysiological evidence for crossed oligosynaptic trigemino-facial connections in normal man.

A crossed short latency component (R1) of the human blink reflex could be elicited in orbicularis oculi muscles to stimulation of the contralateral supraorbital nerve, when infraliminal conditioning stimuli were applied to various cutaneous afferents of the body (facial, upper and lower limbs). The crossed R1 responses appeared when the time interval between the conditioning and the test stimuli was of 30 to 40 ms, 50 to 65 ms and 95 to 110 ms for facial, upper and lower limbs afferents respectively. For the same time intervals, these conditioning volleys also exerted a facilitatory effect on the ipsilateral R1 responses. Furthermore, crossed R1 responses were also obtained during supraspinal facilitation induced by a voluntary contraction of the eyelids. These data show that crossed oligosynaptic trigemino-facial reflex connections exist in normal subjects, which become functional when adequate conditioning stimuli are available.     

Corneal reflex in normal and pathological subjects

The orbicularis oculi response can be evoked both by mechanical stimulation of the cornea (corneal reflex) and by electrical stimulation of the skin overlying the supraorbital nerve (blink reflex). Mechanical stimuli to the cornea activate A delta and C free nerve endings of the corneal mucosa. Electrical stimuli to the supraorbital nerve activate A beta, A delta and C fibers of the nerve trunk. Both reflexes present a bilateral late response, but the blink reflex shows in addition an early ipsilateral component (R1), which has never been observed with the corneal stimulation in man. We have developed a simple technique of electrical stimulation of the cornea which provides stable responses and allows precise measurements of threshold and latency of the reflex. In normal subjects, the threshold ranged from 50 to 350 microA, and the maximal stimulus that the subject could bear (tolerance level) ranged from 1000 to 2500 microA. The minimal latency to tolerance level stimuli was 39 +/- 3 msec. The latency difference between the direct responses evoked from the two opposite corneas never exceeded 8 msec and the difference between the direct and consensual responses elicited from the same cornea never exceeded 5 msec. An early ipsilateral component similar to the R1 response of the blink reflex was not observed, even with supramaximal stimulation. The electrically evoked corneal reflex was normal in 10 cases of essential trigeminal neuralgia, while the responses showed significant abnormalities in 18 subjects submitted to thermocoagulation of the Gasserian ganglion as a treatment of neuralgic pain, as well as in 2 cases of symptomatic neuralgia.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Partial restoration of blink reflex function after spinal accessory-facial nerve anastomosis.

Functional motor control requires perfect matching of the central connections of motoneurons with their peripheral inputs. It is not known, however, to what extent these central circuits are influenced by target muscles, either during development or after a lesion. Surgical interventions aimed at restoring function after peripheral nerve lesions provide an opportunity for studying this interaction in the mature human nervous system. A patient was studied in whom the spinal accessory nerve was anastomosed into a lesioned facial nerve, allowing voluntary contractions of the previously paralysed muscles. This procedure, in addition to replacing the facial neurons at peripheral synapses, allowed a new short latency trigeminospinal accessory reflex of the R1 blink reflex type to be demonstrated, implying that trigeminal neurons had sprouted towards spinal accessory motoneurons over a distance of at least 1 cm. These results show an unexpected influence of the periphery in remodelling central connectivity in humans. The motoneuronal excitability for this R1 reflex response was therefore studied to compare the convergent properties of facial motoneurons (normal side) with those of the spinal accessory motoneurons (operated side) using a classic double shock technique with variable interstimulus intervals (conditioning test stimulus). On the normal side, conditioning stimuli (to the ipsilateral or contralateral infraliminar supraorbital nerve) produced a clearcut facilitation of the R1 blink reflex when the interstimulus interval was 30-80 ms. By contrast, a similar procedure had no effect on the R1 blink reflex mediated via the trigeminal-spinal accessory reflex arc. These data indicate that despite the heterotopic sprouting of some axons from neurons in the XIth nucleus, motoneurons involved in the newly formed reflex arc remain totally inexcitable by other trigeminal afferents and seem unable to ensure a physiological functioning of the normal blink reflex. Thus the functional relevance of the recovered R1 blink response remains unclear.     

Trigeminal sensory input elicited by electric or magnetic stimulation interferes with the central motor drive to the intrinsic hand muscles.

In 6 normal subjects, unilateral supraorbital magnetic or electric stimulation resulted in a consistent symmetrical inhibition of the motor evoked potentials (MEPs) of the relaxed and preactivated first dorsal interosseus (FDI) muscle. A supraorbital stimulus caused a significant reduction in amplitude when the trigeminal CS was given 30 to 65 ms before transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS). In addition, supraorbital magnetic stimulation induced a bilateral EMG suppression of the isometrically contracting FDI muscles, starting about 40 to 50 ms after the magnetic stimulus. In 4 subjects, MEPs evoked by transcranial electric stimulation or by TMS during slight muscle contraction showed a comparable trigeminomotor inhibition. These findings demonstrate that electromagnetic stimulation of trigeminal afferents interferes with the motor output to the intrinsic hand muscles inducing a bilateral inhibition which is probably mediated by a multisynaptic subcortical network. In all 6 subjects, TMS over the motor hand area or the cerebellum elicited a reproducible blink reflex. Since the blink reflex is a sensitive indicator of trigeminal excitation, one has to assume that TMS is associated with a significant excitation of trigeminal afferents. Therefore, trigeminomotor inhibition has to be considered in all TMS studies that use a conditioning-test design.     

Trigeminally induced startle in children with hyperekplexia.

To determine the physiological features of startle reactions in children with hereditary hyperekplexia, motor responses to auditory and trigeminal stimulation were investigated in 2 patients and 3 control subjects by means of multiple surface electromyographic recordings. The pattern of motor activation in auditory startle was similar in the two groups, although the responses in the patients were increased in terms of the extent of the responses. In the patients, nose taps elicited two separate responses in various muscles. The initial, short-latency response was often elicited in all the muscles examined. This reflex was similar to the R1 component of the electrical blink reflex. In addition, the early reflex was immediately followed by the second response, which also appeared widely and was similar to R2 of the blink reflex. Taps on the supraorbital nerve elicited multiple startle patterns consisting of these two responses, although generalization was infrequent. In the control subjects, these responses were elicited in a few muscles. In the hyperekplectic children, both the early and second responses to trigeminal stimulation were increased, in addition to the audiogenic reflex. It was suggested that enhancement of these responses occurred due to hyperexcitability in the brainstem reticular formation in our patients.     

Inverse correlation of intracortical inhibition and brain-stem inhibition in humans.

OBJECTIVE: To determine whether intracortical inhibition and the conditioned blink reflex R2 inhibition correlate in healthy subjects. BACKGROUND: In Parkinson's disease and in focal dystonia the intracortical inhibition and the conditioned blink reflex R2 inhibition are abnormally weak. METHODS: In 10 healthy humans (average age 25.7 years) we investigated the intracortical excitability of the optimal representation of the abductor digiti minimi of the dominant hand using transcranial magnetic stimulation with a conditioning pulse (90% active motor threshold) followed by a pulse of 120% resting motor threshold after an interstimulus interval ranging from 1 to 30 ms. We investigated the blink reflex with two suprathreshold stimuli over the supraorbital nerve and EMG recording from the orbicularis oculi ipsilateral to electrical stimulation, the interstimulus intervals were 100, 250 and 500 ms. RESULTS: The intracortical inhibition, but not the intracortical facilitation, was inversely and significantly correlated with the R2 inhibition on the side of transcranial stimulation, but not with the contralateral R2 inhibition. CONCLUSIONS: The correlation of intracortical inhibitory interneurons and ipsilateral blink reflex interneurons may indicate a common influence, possibly from the basal ganglia, on either circuit, or a direct influence of cortical circuits on brain-stem circuits via corticopontine pathways.     

Pathway of the blink reflex in the brainstem of the cat: Interneurons between the trigeminal nuclei and the facial nucleus

Blink reflex responses evoked by electrical stimulation of the supraorbital nerve were examined using cats and the pathway of the blink reflex in the brainstem was elucidated. Both early response (ER) and late response (LR) were mediated by the main sensory trigeminal nucleus and the spinal trigeminal nucleus. However, a lesion of the main sensory trigeminal nucleus had less effect on the blink reflex than a lesion of the spinal trigeminal nucleus. The ER was mediated not only by the shorter disynaptic pathway of 3 neurons through the trigeminal nerve, the trigeminal nuclei and the facial nucleus but also by a polysynaptic pathway of 4 neurons. The interneurons were located between the trigeminal nuclei and the facial nucleus. Some of these interneurons participated in the production of both ER and LR. The area of the brainstem responsible for ER and LR of the blink reflex was the reticular formation from the rostral part of the medulla to the pons except the medial area around the median sulcus. The LR interneurons were distributed more widely than the ER interneurons.     

Neurophysiological evaluation of trigeminal and facial nerves in patients with chronic inflammatory demyelinating polyneuropathy

Cranial neuropathy is clinically uncommon in patients with chronic inflammatory demyelinating polyneuropathy (CIDP), but there is little information on the neurophysiological examination of cranial nerve involvement. To determine the incidence of trigeminal and facial nerve involvement in patients with CIDP, the direct response of the orbicularis oculi muscle to percutaneous electric stimulation of the facial nerve and the blink reflex (induced by stimulation of the supraorbital nerve) were examined in 20 CIDP patients. The latency of the direct response was increased in 12 patients (60%) and an abnormal blink reflex was observed in 17 patients (85%). There was no correlation between electrophysiological findings and the latencies of the direct and R1 responses and disease duration or clinical grade in CIDP patients. Nevertheless, the prevalence of subclinical trigeminal and facial neuropathy is extremely high in patients with CIDP when examined by neurophysiological tests.     

The somatosensory blink reflex in upper and lower brainstem lesions

The brainstem pathways that mediate the somatosensory blink reflex (SBR) are not completely understood. We hypothesized that the circuits of the SBR might be affected separately from those of the trigeminal blink reflex (TBR). We examined 7 patients with mesencephalic lesions and 8 patients with medullary lesions. The SBR was elicited by median nerve stimulation. The TBR was elicited by supraorbital nerve stimulation. In patients with upper brainstem lesions, the TBR was normal, whereas the SBR was generally abnormal. The SBR was either absent or small and was significantly delayed with respect to control subjects. The opposite was the rule in patients with lower brainstem lesions who had delayed or absent TBR and no abnormal findings in the SBR. The SBR is mediated through circuits in the upper brainstem. Study of the SBR can be helpful in the neurophysiological assessment of patients with mesencephalic lesions.     

Sensorimotor integration in patients with parkinsonian type multisystem atrophy

Sensorimotor integration is an essential feature of the central nervous system that contributes to the accurate performance of motor tasks. Some patients with multiple system atrophy with parkinsonian features (MSAp) exhibit clinical signs compatible with an abnormal central nervous system excitability to somatosen– sory inputs, such as action myoclonus or enhanced cutaneo–muscular reflexes. To investigate further the site where such dysfunction in sensorimotor integration takes place, we examined the inhibitory effects of a cutaneous afferent volley at two different levels of the motor system in 10 MSAp patients and in 10 agematched healthy volunteers. Electrical digital nerve stimuli were given as the conditioning stimulus for the motor evoked potentials (MEP) elicited by transcranial magnetic stimulation in hand muscles, and for the blink reflex responses obtained in the orbicularis oculi muscles by supraorbital nerve stimulation. Intervals for the conditioning were 20 to 50ms for the MEP and 90 to 110ms for the blink reflex. The MEP was significantly inhibited in test trials in healthy volunteers, reaching a mean of 32% of the baseline values at the ISI of 35 ms. Significant inhibition occurred also in the blink reflex, in which the R2 response was a mean of 12% of baseline values at the ISI of 100 ms. The inhibitory effects were abnormally reduced in 8 patients on the MEP, and in 7 patients on the blink reflex. There were significant group differences between patients and control subjects in the size of the conditioned MEP and blink reflex. These results suggest that sensorimotor integration is abnormal in patients with MSAp in at least two central nervous system sites: the sensorimotor cortex, and the brainstem reticular formation.     

Unmasking of the trigemino-accessory reflex in accessory facial anastomosis

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the possible blink reflex responses in facial muscles reinnervated by the accessory nerve. METHOD: Eleven patients with a complete facial palsy were submitted to a surgical repair by an accessory facial nerve anastomosis (AFA). In this pathological group, blink reflex was studied by means of percutaneous electrical stimulation of the supraorbital nerve and recording from the orbicularis oculi muscle. A control group comprised seven normal people and seven patients with a complete Bell's facial palsy; in this group, responses on the sternocleidomastoideus (SCM) muscles were studied after supraorbital nerve stimulation. RESULTS: All the patients with AFA showed a consistent degree of facial reinnervation. Ten out of the 11 patients with AFA showed reflex responses; in six, responses were configured by a double component pattern, resembling the R1 and R2 components of the blink reflex; three patients had an R1-like response and one patient showed a unique R2 component. Mean values of latencies were 15.2 (SD 4.6) ms for the R1 and 85.3 (SD 9.6) ms for the R2. In the control group, eight out of 14 people had evidence of reflex responses in the SCM muscles; these were almost exclusively configured by a bilateral late component (mean latency 63.5 (SD15.9) ms) and only one of the subjects showed an early response at 11 ms. CONCLUSION: The trigemino-accessory reflex response in the pathological group was more complex and of a significantly higher incidence than in the control group. These differences could be tentatively explained by a mechanism of synaptic plasticity induced by the impairment of the efferent portion of the reflex. This could unmask the central linking between the trigeminal and the accessory limbs of the reflex. The findings described could be a demonstration of neurobionomic function in the repairing process of the nervous system.     

Interaction between the blink reflex and the abnormal muscle response in patients with hemifacial spasm: results of intraoperative recordings

Patients with hemifacial spasm (HFS) have an abnormal muscle response (AMR) that can be elicited by stimulating one branch of the facial nerve and recording electromyographically from muscles innervated by other branches of the facial nerve. In addition, the R1 component of the blink reflex can be elicited from the affected side in patients with HFS who are undergoing microvascular decompression (MVD) operations under inhalation anesthesia. A synkinetic component of the blink reflex response that corresponds to the R1 component can be recorded from the mentalis muscle. In the present study we show that the blink reflex elicited by electrical stimulation of the supraorbital nerve can suppress the AMR elicited by electrical stimulation of the temporal branch of the facial nerve in patients with HFS when the interval between stimulation of the supraorbital nerve and stimulation of the temporal branch of the facial nerve (interstimulus interval, ISI) is such that the blink reflex response would appear later than the AMR if they had been elicited independently. Within a short range of ISIs the two responses suppress each other partially or totally. We find evidence that the suppression of the AMR is the result of an interaction in the facial motonucleus. We believe that the results of the present study support the hypothesis that the facial motonucleus is hyperactive in patients with HFS, and we suggest that the AMR is a result of backfiring from the facial motonucleus and that it may thus be an exaggerated F-response.     

Blink reflex in patients with hemifacial spasm. Observations during microvascular decompression operations

The blink reflex cannot normally be elicited during surgical anesthesia using inhalation anesthetics. However, in patients with hemifacial spasm (HFS) the early component of the reflex response (R1) can be elicited on the affected side but not on the unaffected side during such anesthesia. The electromyographic (EMG) response from the mentalis muscle to stimulation of the supraorbital nerve was recorded during microvascular decompression (MVD) of the facial nerve to relieve HFS and compared to the response from the same muscle to stimulation of the zygomatic branch of the facial nerve in four patients. During the operation before the facial nerve was decompressed, contractions in both the orbicularis oculi and the mentalis muscles could be elicited by stimulation of the supraorbital nerve (mean latencies 12.2 +/- 1.9 and 12.9 +/- 2.0 ms, respectively). When the facial nerve had been decompressed the blink reflex could no longer be elicited, and there was no response from the mentalis muscle to stimulation of the zygomatic branch of the facial nerve. Compound action potentials (CAP) recorded from the 7th cranial nerve in response to stimulation of the supraorbital nerve had latencies of 7.5 ms +/- 1.4 ms to the negative peak.     

Influences on blink reflex induced by IA afferents in human subjects

The effects induced by IA volleys, evoked with H reflex, on the blink reflex elicited upon electric activation of supraorbital nerves were investigated in 14 healthy subjects as well as in 4 cerebrovascular patients. In both groups a significant increase in amplitude of the early component (R1) of ipsilateral blink reflex has been observed. A brief discussion of possible neural systems which might be involved in these effects is given.     

Gating of trigemino-facial reflex from low-threshold trigeminal and extratrigeminal cutaneous fibres in humans.

Changes in the size of the test components (R1 and R2) of the trigemino-facial reflex were studied after electrical subliminal conditioning stimulation were applied to the trigeminal, median and sural nerves. After conditioning activation of the trigeminal nerve (below the reflex threshold), the early R1 reflex component showed phasic facilitation, peaking at about 50 ms of interstimulus delay, followed by a long-lasting inhibition recovering at 300-400 ms. The same conditioning stimulation resulted in a monotonic inhibition of the late R2, starting at 15-20 ms, with a maximum at 100-150 ms and lasting 300-400 ms. Intensity threshold for both the R1 and R2 changes ranged from 0.90 to 0.95 times the perception threshold. A similar longlasting inhibition of the R2 reflex response was also seen after conditioning stimulation applied to low-threshold cutaneous afferents of the median and sural nerves. The minimum effective conditioning-test interval was 25-30 ms and 40-45 ms respectively and lasted 600-700 ms. By contrast the early R1 reflex response exhibited a slight long-lasting facilitation with a time course similar to that of the R2 inhibition. The threshold intensity to obtain facilitation of the R1 and inhibition of the R2 test responses after conditioning volley in the median and sural nerves was similar and ranged from 0.9 to 1.2 times the perception threshold. These results demonstrate that low-threshold cutaneous afferents from trigeminal and limb nerves exert powerful control on trigeminal reflex pathways, probably via a common neural substrate. There is evidence that, in addition to any post-synaptic mechanism which might be operating, presynaptic control is a primary factor contributing to these changes.     

Impaired long-term potentiation-like plasticity of the trigeminal blink reflex circuit in Parkinson's disease.

We investigated the hypothesis that Parkinsons's disease (PD) is associated with abnormal plasticity of the neuronal circuits mediating blink reflex. We induced long-term potentiation (LTP)-like plasticity in trigeminal wide dynamic range neurons of the blink reflex circuit by pairing an high-frequency train of electrical stimuli over the right supraorbital nerve (SO) coincident with the R2 response elicited by a preceding SO stimulus. The facilitation of the R2 response after the induction protocol was markedly decreased in patients relative to controls. Treatment with dopaminergic drugs normalized the LTP-like plasticity of the R2 response. We conclude that nigrostriatal denervation disrupts LTP-like plasticity in the trigeminal reflex circuit.     

Intracranial stimulation of the trigeminal nerve in man. II. Reflex responses.

The reflex responses evoked by direct electrical stimulation of the intracranial portion of the trigeminal nerve have been studied in 16 subjects undergoing percutaneous retrogasserian thermocoagulation for the treatment of trigeminal neuralgia affecting the second or third division. In the obicularis oculi muscle, early and late responses similar to the R1 and R2 components of the blink reflex were recorded. The former could be evoked only by stimulation of the second division and its latency was consistent with intermediately fast afferents. A late reflex (50-70 ms) was occasionally recorded from the anterior belly of the digastric muscle. The response was sometimes followed by a later activity and showed the features of a polysynaptic reflex. No response was obtained in the jaw elevators when fully relaxed. With the subject voluntarily clenching his teeth, both an early "H-like" response and two silent periods in the background EMG were obtained. The second silent period was similar in the muscles ipsi- and contralateral to intracranial stimulation, while the first silent period was longer in the ipsilateral muscles. Possible mechanisms contributing to the inhibition following stimulation of the mixed portion of the nerve are discussed.     

Abnormal muscle responses in hemifacial spasm: F waves or trigeminal reflexes?

OBJECTIVE: In patients with hemifacial spasm (HFS), abnormal muscle responses (AMR) are frequently present. The objective of this study was to investigate whether the afferent input of AMR is mediated by antidromic facial nerve stimulation or orthodromic trigeminal nerve stimulation. METHODS: AMR in the orbicularis oris muscle were recorded in 28 patients with HFS. When AMR were present, they were recorded after subthreshold stimulation of the facial nerve and weak stimulation delivered to the skin. RESULTS: AMR were recordable in 24 (86%) of the patients, and usually consisted of the early constant component (mean onset latency, 10.0 ms) and late variable component (35.3 ms), similar to R1 and R2 of the blink reflex. The early or late components of AMR, or both, were frequently elicited after subthreshold stimulation of the facial nerve (43%) and skin stimulation (88%). CONCLUSIONS: AMR are likely to be mediated by trigeminal afferent inputs, rather than antidromic activation of the facial nerve, and are a type of trigeminal reflex.     

The corneal reflex and the R2 component of the blink reflex

A reflex contraction of the human orbicularis oculi muscles can be evoked by stimulation of either the supraorbital region ("blink reflex") or the cornea ("corneal reflex"). We found that the latency of the corneal reflex was longer, and the duration was longer than the R2 component of the blink reflex. The absolute refractory period of the R2 component of the blink reflex was longer after supraorbital than after corneal conditioning stimulation. When the R2 component of the blink reflex was habituated by repetitive stimuli, stimulation of the cornea still evoked a reflex, but supraorbital stimulation produced only a depressed R2 response. These findings suggest that the two reflexes do not have identical neural connections.