Scanning electron microscopic evidence for physical segmental boundaries in the anterior presomitic mesoderm

The metameric pattern of the axial skeleton is established during embryogenesis by somite formation from the unsegmented paraxial mesoderm (presomitic mesoderm). Here, we have investigated the morphology of the anterior presomitic mesoderm of chick embryos using scanning electron microscopy. We found periodically arranged transverse clefts in the anterior region of the presomitic mesoderm. These gaps can be regarded as physical boundaries between prospective somites in the determined zone of the presomitic mesoderm. This study provides additional evidence suggesting that prospective somite boundaries are not only marked by defined zones of gene expression, but are also accompanied by changes in cellular morphology that give rise to identifiable morphological segments.     

Eph signaling is required for segmentation and differentiation of the somites

Somitogenesis involves the segmentation of the paraxial mesoderm into units along the anteroposterior axis. Here we show a role for Eph and ephrin signaling in the patterning of presomitic mesoderm and formation of the somites. Ephrin-A-L1 and ephrin-B2 are expressed in an iterative manner in the developing somites and presomitic mesoderm, as is the Eph receptor EphA4. We have examined the role of these proteins by injection of RNA, encoding dominant negative forms of Eph receptors and ephrins. Interruption of Eph signaling leads to abnormal somite boundary formation and reduced or disturbed myoD expression in the myotome. Disruption of Eph family signaling delays the normal down-regulation of her1 and Delta D expression in the anterior presomitic mesoderm and disrupts myogenic differentiation. We suggest that Eph signaling has a key role in the translation of the patterning of presomitic mesoderm into somites.     

Tooth development is independent of a Hox patterning programme.

Hox genes have a critical role in controlling the patterning processes of many tissues by imparting positional information in embryogenesis. Patterning of the pharyngeal component of the skull (the visceroskeleton) has been proposed to be influenced by this "Hox code." Recently, it has been shown that Hox genes are associated with the evolution of jaws, loss of Hox gene expression in the first branchial arch being necessary for the transition from the agnathan condition to the gnathostome condition. Teeth develop on the first branchial arch in mammals and, therefore, might be expected to be under the control of Hox genes in a manner similar to that of the cranial skeletal elements. However, we show that, unlike cartilage and bone, the development of teeth is not affected by alterations in Hoxa2 expression. Tooth development in the first arch was unaffected by overexpression of Hoxa2, whereas recombinations of second arch mesenchyme with first arch epithelium led to tooth development within a Hoxa2-positive environment. These data demonstrate that teeth develop from local interactions and that tooth formation is not under the axial patterning program specified by the Hox genes. We propose that the evolutionary development of teeth in the first branchial arch is independent of the loss of Hox expression necessary for the development of the jaw.     

Cells of all somitic compartments are determined with respect to segmental identity.

Development of somite cells is orchestrated by two regulatory processes. Differentiation of cells from the various somitic compartments into different anlagen and tissues is regulated by extrinsic signals from neighboring structures such as the notochord, neural tube, and surface ectoderm. Morphogenesis of these anlagen to form specific structures according to the segmental identity of each somite is specified by segment-specific positional information, based on the Hox-code. It has been shown that following experimental rotation of presomitic mesoderm or newly formed somites, paraxial mesodermal cells adapt to the altered signaling environment and differentiate according to their new orientation. In contrast, presomitic mesoderm or newly formed somites transplanted to different segmental levels keep their primordial segmental identity and form ectopic structures according to their original position. To determine whether all cells of a segment, including the dorsal and ventral compartment, share the same segmental identity, presomitic mesoderm or newly formed somites were rotated and transplanted from thoracic to cervical level. These experiments show that cells from all compartments of a segment are able to interpret extrinsic local signals correctly, but form structures according to their original positional information and maintain their original Hox expression in the new environment.     

Regulation of the Hoxa4 and Hoxa5 genes in the embryonic mouse lung by retinoic acid and TGFbeta1: implications for lung development and patterning.

We have previously described a 5; cis-acting retinoic acid response element that is required for a subset of Hoxa4 expression, including the midgestation mouse lung. As both retinoids and Hox genes have been implicated in lung development and patterning, we have examined Hoxa4 expression in the developing mouse lung and extended our work on its regulation. At E12.5, a Hoxa4/lacZ transgene is expressed in the mesenchymal compartment of the lung. Later in development expression is restricted to the proximal mesenchyme and is also observed in smooth muscle cells, subepithelial fibroblasts, and alveolar cells. We show that both Hoxa4 and Hoxa5 are upregulated when cultured in the presence of all-trans retinoic acid. In addition, retinoic acid extends the domain of Hoxa4 and Hoxa5 expression to the periphery of the explants where the distal epithelia are developing. Interestingly, the effect of retinoic acid on Hoxa5 expression was not observed in a Hoxa4 mutant background. In contrast, TGFbeta1 was found to downregulate both Hoxa4 and Hoxa5 expression in cultured lung explants. We also establish that retinoic acid has the effect of proximalizing the mouse lung when cultured in a serum-free medium, as evidenced by reduced expression of the distal marker surfactant protein-C. Lungs from Hoxa4 mutant embryos exhibited a similar response to retinoic acid, suggesting that Hoxa4 alone is not required for the proximalizing effect. Based on their retinoid-dependent expression, we conclude that members of the group 4 and/or group 5 Hox genes are likely to be involved in patterning of the mouse lung. Dev Dyn 2000;217:62-74.     

Noncyclic Notch activity in the presomitic mesoderm demonstrates uncoupling of somite compartmentalization and boundary formation

To test the significance of cyclic Notch activity for somite formation in mice, we analyzed embryos expressing activated Notch (NICD) throughout the presomitic mesoderm (PSM). Embryos expressing NICD formed up to 18 somites. Expression in the PSM of Hes7, Lfng, and Spry2 was no longer cyclic, whereas Axin2 was expressed dynamically. NICD expression led to caudalization of somites, and loss of Notch activity to their rostralization. Thus, segmentation and anterior-posterior somite patterning can be uncoupled, differential Notch signaling is not required to form segment borders, and Notch is unlikely to be the pacemaker of the segmentation clock.     

Transcriptional oscillation of lunatic fringe is essential for somitogenesis

A molecular oscillator that controls the expression of cyclic genes such as lunatic fringe (Lfng) in the presomitic mesoderm has been shown to be coupled with somite formation in vertebrate embryos. To address the functional significance of oscillating Lfng expression, we have generated transgenic mice expressing Lfng constitutively in the presomitic mesoderm in addition to the intrinsic cyclic Lfng activity. These transgenic lines displayed defects of somite patterning and vertebral organization that were very similar to those of Lfng null mutants. Furthermore, constitutive expression of exogenous Lfng did not compensate for the complete loss of cyclic endogenous Lfng activity. Noncyclic exogenous Lfng expression did not abolish cyclic expression of endogenous Lfng in the posterior presomitic mesoderm (psm) but affected its expression pattern in the anterior psm. Similarly, dynamic expression of Hes7 was not abolished but abnormal expression patterns were obtained. Our data are consistent with a model in which alternations of Lfng activity between ON and OFF states in the presomitic mesoderm prior to somite segmentation are critical for proper somite patterning, and suggest that Notch signaling might not be the only determinant of cyclic gene expression in the presomitic mesoderm of mouse embryos.     

Mouse mutant "rib-vertebrae" (rv): a defect in somite polarity.

The recessive mouse mutant rib-vertebrae (rv) affects the morphogenesis of the axial skeleton. The phenotype is characterized by vertebral defects such as fusion of adjacent segments, hemivertebrae, or open neural arches and rib defects including fusions, forked ribs, and additional ribs. We have analyzed this mutant in detail and are able to show that defective somite patterning underlies the vertebral malformations. The rv mutation leads to an elongation of the presomitic mesoderm and a disruption of the anterior-posterior polarization of somites, as indicated by the abnormal expression of Pax1 and Mox1. Somites are irregular in size but the overall formation of somites appears unaffected. These changes are reminiscent of somite defects obtained in loss of function alleles of the Delta-Notch pathway. Expression of the Notch pathway components Delta-like-1 (Dll1) and lunatic fringe (Lfng) are altered in rv mutants. To investigate possible interactions of rv with components of the Notch pathway, we crossed rv into Dll1(lacZ). Double heterozygous (rv/+; Dll1(lacZ)/+) mice show vertebral defects and homozygous animals with one inactive Dll1 allele (rv/rv; Dll1(lacZ)/+) exhibit a dramatic increase in phenotypic severity, indicating that rv and Dll1 genetically interact. We have mapped rv to a region on chromosome 7 that is syntenic to human chromosomes 11p, 10q, and 11p. rv is phenotypically similar to human vertebral malformations syndromes and can serve as a model for these conditions.     

The bHLH regulator pMesogenin1 is required for maturation and segmentation of paraxial mesoderm

Paraxial mesoderm in vertebrates gives rise to all trunk and limb skeletal muscles, the trunk skeleton, and portions of the trunk dermis and vasculature. We show here that germline deletion of mouse pMesogenin1, a bHLH class gene specifically expressed in developmentally immature unsegmented paraxial mesoderm, causes complete failure of somite formation and segmentation of the body trunk and tail. At the molecular level, the phenotype features dramatic loss of expression within the presomitic mesoderm of Notch/Delta pathway components and oscillating somitic clock genes that are thought to control segmentation and somitogenesis. Subsequent patterning and specification steps for paraxial mesoderm also fail, leading to a complete absence of all trunk paraxial mesoderm derivatives, which include skeletal muscle, vertebrae, and ribs. We infer that pMesogenin1 is an essential upstream regulator of trunk paraxial mesoderm development and segmentation.     

The winged helix transcription factor Foxc1a is essential for somitogenesis in zebrafish

Previous studies identified zebrafish foxc1a and foxc1b as homologs of the mouse forkhead gene, Foxc1. Both genes are transcribed in the unsegmented presomitic mesoderm (PSM), newly formed somites, adaxial cells, and head mesoderm. Here, we show that inhibiting synthesis of Foxc1a (but not Foxc1b) protein with two different morpholino antisense oligonucleotides blocks formation of morphological somites, segment boundaries, and segmented expression of genes normally transcribed in anterior and posterior somites and expression of paraxis implicated in somite epithelialization. Patterning of the anterior PSM is also affected, as judged by the absence of mesp-b, ephrinB2, and ephA4 expression, and the down-regulation of notch5 and notch6. In contrast, the expression of other genes, including mesp-a and papc, in the anterior of somite primordia, and the oscillating expression of deltaC and deltaD in the PSM appear normal. Nevertheless, this expression is apparently insufficient for the maturation of the presumptive somites to proceed to the stage when boundary formation occurs or for the maintenance of anterior/posterior patterning. Mouse embryos that are compound null mutants for Foxc1 and the closely related Foxc2 have no morphological somites and show abnormal expression of Notch signaling pathway genes in the anterior PSM. Therefore, zebrafish foxc1a plays an essential and conserved role in somite formation, regulating both the expression of paraxis and the A/P patterning of somite primordia.     

Hox11 paralogous genes are essential for metanephric kidney induction

The mammalian Hox complex is divided into four linkage groups containing 13 sets of paralogous genes. These paralogous genes have retained functional redundancy during evolution. For this reason, loss of only one or two Hox genes within a paralogous group often results in incompletely penetrant phenotypes which are difficult to interpret by molecular analysis. For example, mice individually mutant for Hoxa11 or Hoxd11 show no discernible kidney abnormalities. Hoxa11/Hoxd11 double mutants, however, demonstrate hypoplasia of the kidneys. As described in this study, removal of the last Hox11 paralogous member, Hoxc11, results in the complete loss of metanephric kidney induction. In these triple mutants, the metanephric blastema condenses, and expression of early patterning genes, Pax2 and Wt1, is unperturbed. Eya1 expression is also intact. Six2 expression, however, is absent, as is expression of the inducing growth factor, Gdnf. In the absence of Gdnf, ureteric bud formation is not initiated. Molecular analysis of this phenotype demonstrates that Hox11 control of early metanephric induction is accomplished by the interaction of Hox11 genes with the pax-eya-six regulatory cascade, a pathway that may be used by Hox genes more generally for the induction of multiple structures along the anteroposterior axis.     

Hoxa2 knockdown in Xenopus results in hyoid to mandibular homeosis.

The skeletal structures of the face and throat are derived from cranial neural crest cells (NCCs) that migrate from the embryonic neural tube into a series of branchial arches (BAs). The first arch (BA1) gives rise to the upper and lower jaw cartilages, whereas hyoid structures are generated from the second arch (BA2). The Hox paralogue group 2 (PG2) genes, Hoxa2 and Hoxb2, show distinct roles for hyoid patterning in tetrapods and fishes. In the mouse, Hoxa2 acts as a selector of hyoid identity, while its paralogue Hoxb2 is not required. On the contrary, in zebrafish Hoxa2 and Hoxb2 are functionally redundant for hyoid arch patterning. Here, we show that in Xenopus embryos morpholino-induced functional knockdown of Hoxa2 is sufficient to induce homeotic changes of the second arch cartilage. Moreover, Hoxb2 is downregulated in the BA2 of Xenopus embryos, even though initially expressed in second arch NCCs, similar to mouse and unlike in zebrafish. Finally, Xbap, a gene involved in jaw joint formation, is selectively upregulated in the BA2 of Hoxa2 knocked-down frog embryos, supporting a hyoid to mandibular change of NCC identity. Thus, in Xenopus Hoxa2 does not act redundantly with Hoxb2 for BA2 patterning, similar to mouse and unlike in fish. These data bring novel insights into the regulation of Hox PG2 genes and hyoid patterning in vertebrate evolution and suggest that Hoxa2 function is required at late stages of BA2 development.     

Patterning the neural crest derivatives during development of the vertebrate head: insights from avian studies

Studies carried out in the avian embryo and based on the construction of quail-chick chimeras have shown that most of the skull and all the facial and visceral skeleton are derived from the cephalic neural crest (NC). Contribution of the mesoderm is limited to its occipital and (partly) to its otic domains. NC cells (NCCs) participating in membrane bones and cartilages of the vertebrate head arise from the diencephalon (posterior half only), the mesencephalon and the rhombencephalon. They can be divided into an anterior domain (extending down to r2 included) in which genes of the Hox clusters are not expressed (Hox-negative skeletogenic NC) and a posterior domain including r4 to r8 in which Hox genes of the four first paraloguous groups are expressed. The NCCs that form the facial skeleton belong exclusively to the anterior Hox-negative domain and develop from the first branchial arch (BA1). This rostral domain of the crest is designated as FSNC for facial skeletogenic neural crest. Rhombomere 3 (r3) participates modestly to both BA1 and BA2. Forced expression of Hox genes (Hoxa2, Hoxa3 and Hoxb4) in the neural fold of the anterior domain inhibits facial skeleton development. Similarly, surgical excision of these anterior Hox-negative NCCs results in the absence of facial skeleton, showing that Hox-positive NCCs cannot replace the Hox-negative domain for facial skeletogenesis. We also show that excision of the FSNC results in dramatic down-regulation of Fgf8 expression in the head, namely in ventral forebrain and in BA1 ectoderm. We have further demonstrated that exogenous FGF8 applied to the presumptive BA1 territory at the 5-6-somite stage (5-6ss) restores to a large extent facial skeleton development. The source of the cells responsible for this regeneration was shown to be r3, which is at the limit between the Hox-positive and Hox-negative domain. NCCs that respond to FGF8 by survival and proliferation are in turn necessary for the expression/maintenance of Fgf8 expression in the ectoderm. These results strongly support the emerging picture according to which the processes underlying morphogenesis of the craniofacial skeleton are regulated by epithelial-mesenchymal bidirectional crosstalk.