Standard vs atraumatic Whitacre needle for diagnostic lumbar puncture: a randomized trial

In order to define the impact of needle type on post-lumbar puncture headache (PLPH), we performed a prospective, randomized trial comparing the incidence of PLPH in patients undergoing lumbar punctures (LPs) with traumatic vs atraumatic 22-gauge needles. Fifty-eight patients underwent 85 LPs. The incidence of PLPH was 36% in the traumatic vs 3% in the atraumatic group (p = 0.002).     

Reducing post-lumbar puncture headaches with small bore atraumatic needles

Lumbar puncture for testing of Alzheimer’s disease pathophysiology for diagnostic confirmation is likely to become more common in the coming years. Minimizing adverse effects from this testing will be essential for clinical practice. Small bore, atraumatic needles reduce the occurrence of post-lumbar puncture headache (PLPH). Our goal was to extend this recommendation specifically to a well-characterized aging population. We assessed PLPH in the Alzheimer’s Disease Neuroimaging Initiative cohort and found that PLPH occurrence was reduced only when using a 24 gauge atraumatic needle. We recommend that lumbar punctures for clinical and research purposes in Alzheimer’s disease be conducted with 24 gauge atraumatic needles.     

A prospective double-blind clinical trial, comparing the sharp Quincke needle (22G) with an "atraumatic" needle (22G) in the induction of post-lumbar puncture headache

Posture-dependent, post-lumbar puncture headache is most likely caused by continuous leakage of cerebrospinal fluid through the dura mater perforation with a consecutive downward sagging of the intracranial content and an irritation of pain-sensitive structures of meninges and blood vessels. A psychogenic co-factor may also play a role. It is generally acknowledged that the incidence and intensity of the headache correlate significantly with the diameter of the needles used. A second factor, the shape of the needle point plays a crucial role as is shown in our prospective, double-blind, clinical trial with 75 patients: employment of the "atraumatic" Sprotte needle with a rounded off point significantly reduced the incidence of post-puncture headache from 36% to 4%. Beside the discussion of pathogenic factors, remarks on a rational therapy are made.     

Le syndrome post-ponction lombaire. Revue de la littérature et expérience des urgences céphalées

Post-lumbar puncture headache (PLPH) is a well-known syndrome resulting from spinal fluid leakage and delayed closure of a dural defect. The main symptom of PLPH is headache in upright posture relieved by lying down. Outcome is usually benign and complications are uncommon. The functional impact can however be important, leading to delayed discharge, sick leave and, if information delivery is ineffective, iterative consultations. Preventive measures have been published, but the prevalence of PLPH remains high (15 to 40% after diagnostic lumbar puncture). Needle size and type are probably the most important factors for reducing the risk of PLPH. Recovery can be rapid, within a few days. If PLPH persists after four days, an epidural blood patch should be discussed. The objective of this review is to summarize the literature on PLPH, and share the experience of our emergency headache center with an atraumatic 25-gauge needle (pencan, 0.5 × 90 mm or 0.5 × 103 mm, Braun, Germany).     

Safety and acceptability of the research lumbar puncture

Three hundred forty-two subjects underwent 428 research lumbar punctures for studies of cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) biomarkers. Subjects were 67 Alzheimer disease or mild cognitive impairment (AD/MCI) patients and 275 cognitively normal adults aged 21 to 88. Lumbar puncture was performed in the lateral decubitus or sitting position using the Sprotte 24 g atraumatic spinal needle. Up to 34 ml of cerebrospinal fluid were collected. Anxiety and pain experienced during lumbar puncture were rated on a visual analog scale. The frequency of any adverse event (11.7%), clinically significant adverse events (3.97%), and typical post-lumbar puncture headache (PLPHA) (0.93%) was low. Risk of post-lumbar puncture headache was unrelated to age, gender, position during lumbar puncture, ml of cerebrospinal fluid collected, or minutes of recumbent rest following lumbar puncture. The frequency of post-lumbar puncture headache was lower in AD/MCI (P = 0.03) than any other subject group. Anxiety and pain ratings were low. Younger subjects reported more anxiety than old (P = 0.001) and AD/MCI subjects (P = 0.008) and more pain than older normal subjects (P = 0.013). Pain ratings for women were higher than those for men (P = 0.006). Using the Sprotte 24 g spinal needle, research lumbar puncture can be performed with a very low rate of clinically significant adverse events and with good acceptability in cognitively impaired persons and cognitively normal adults of all ages.     

Ambulante Durchführung einer diagnostischen Lumbalpunktion in der Gedächtnissprechstunde

Lumbar puncture (LP) is growing in relevance for the diagnosis of cognitive impairment in the elderly. Due to the expected risk of post-lumbar puncture syndrome or other complications LPs have rarely been performed in the outpatient setting. Using a questionnaire, the post-lumbar puncture symptoms of 100 patients (54-84 years old; mean: 68.87 years; SD: 7.9) have been prospectively gathered after consecutively performed LPs in the Memory Clinic of the Department of Psychiatry, University of Bonn. Some of these patients were included in the early diagnosis program of the German Dementia Competence Network. Of the patients 9% developed a post-lumbar puncture syndrome of mild or middle intensity. The influence of gender, age, cognitive status, as well as a supplementary diagnosis of depression and needle size (G20 or G22 atraumatic Sprotte needle) on the incidence of the post-LP syndrome was evaluated by means of logistic regression. Only the patients' age was identified as a significant risk factor as with increasing age a diminishing risk of developing a post-lumbar puncture syndrome was found (OR=0.83; CI=0.71-0.97 per year). None of the other factors evaluated proved to be of significant influence. The post-LP symptoms did not necessitate supplementary consultations in any of the cases.     

A dedicated lumbar puncture clinic: performance and short-term patient outcomes

The purpose of the study was to evaluate patient outcomes, including success rates, factors associated with unsuccessful procedures and frequency of post-lumbar puncture headaches (PLPH), at a dedicated academic outpatient lumbar puncture (LP) clinic. All patients referred to our LP clinic between June 1, 2014 and May 31, 2015 were included in this consecutive observational series. We collected information about patient characteristics, operational parameters of the procedure, and complications. We also recorded rates of participation in biomedical research involving use of cerebrospinal fluid. Univariate analysis used Student’s t test and Fisher’s exact test. Logistic regression was used to determine independent risk factors associated with unsuccessful LP and PLPH. The mean age of patients referred to our LP clinic was 46 ± 17 years. Of the 307 referrals, 281 patients (92%) started the procedure, with successful acquisition of CSF in 267 (95%). Factors contributing to unsuccessful procedures included higher body mass index [odds ratio (OR) 1.8], older age (OR 1.9), and female sex (OR 10.3). The rate of PLPH was 5.7%. Younger age (OR 0.5), female sex (OR 6.9), high mean arterial pressure (OR 2.2), and a traumatic LP (OR 10.0) were identified as risk factors for PLPH. Notably, 202 patients (72%) consented to biomedical research. A standardized approach to outpatient LP demonstrates high procedural success rate, low PLPH rate, and high participation in biomedical research. Awareness of a group of patients at higher risk for complications including procedure failure or PLPH provides guidance for decision-making regarding referral to the outpatient LP clinic.     

Atraumatic needle reduces the incidence of post-lumbar puncture syndrome

We investigated the occurrence of the post-lumbar syndrome (PPS) in relation to the puncture technique used, in a prospective randomised double-blind study comprising 100 patients. A new atraumatic 22-gauge cannula was compared with a 20-gauge cannula with a Quincke bevel. The atraumatic cannula is a needle with a tip shaped like a closed circular cone with a lateral opening, usually used with an outer cannula (introducer). The study showed that both the frequency of PPS and of acute complaints during lumbar puncture can be dramatically reduced with the atraumatic puncture technique. A marked PPS occurred after lumbar puncture with the 20-gauge cannula in 31% of patients, whereas only 5% of patients reported marked post-puncture symptoms after lumbar puncture with the atraumatic cannula.     

Low frequency of post-lumbar puncture headache in demented patients

The frequency of post-lumbar puncture headache (PLPH) was registered prospectively in 395 consecutive demented patients at a dementia diagnostic unit. The incidence of PLPH was low, occurring in only 8 patients (2.0%), the severity was mild, and the duration was less than 2 days in all cases but one. The reasons for this low frequency of PLPH in patients with dementia disorders may include disease- and/or age-related low pain sensitivity, rigid dural fibres and arteriosclerotic vessels, and large CSF space due to cerebral atrophy. Analysis of CSF is essential to identify secondary causes of dementia, preferentially chronic infections. The low frequency and severity of PLPH found in the present study shows that, with low risk of complications, lumbar puncture can be included in the routine clinical examination of demented patients.     

Incidence of post-lumbar puncture headache is independent of daily fluid intake

Summary The clinical practice of advising patients to increase their daily fluid intake after lumbar puncture in order to increase CSF production by re-hydration and thus try to prevent post-lumbar puncture headache (PLPH) has not yet been shown to be effective. In 100 patients the different effects of re-hydration on the incidence of PLPH (1.51 compared with 3.01 oral fluid per day over a period of 5 days) were tested prospectively. The incidence of PLPH was independent of the amount of fluid intake in both groups (18, 36%), as was the duration of PLPH. The physiology of CSF production and resorption suggests that PLPH is not a problem of CSF dynamics but a simple mechanical problem of how to close the dural rent and thereby stop the continuous leakage. It is no longer justifiable to advise patients to drink more than usual since there is no physiological or empirical basis for this and it does not seem to have even a placebo effect.     

Incidence and Effect of Traumatic Lumbar Puncture in the Neonate

The incidence of non-traumatic, traumatic and unsuccessful lumbar punctures in 181 neonates was similar whether a needle with a stylet, a butterfly needle without stylet, or a standard venipuncture needle without stylet was used. Comparison of 20 lumbar puncture pairs in 17 patients showed that traumatic lumbar puncture does not result in a cerebrospinal fluid pleocytosis between two and 13 days after initial traumatic lumbar puncture.     

Addendum to assessment: Prevention of post-lumbar puncture headaches: report of the Therapeutics and Technology Assessment Subcommittee of the American Academy of Neurology

Review of the literature on prevention of post-lumbar puncture headaches (PLPHAs) since the publication of the original assessment in 2000 yielded one study comparing use of cutting to atraumatic needles in diagnostic lumbar punctures, providing Class I evidence in favor of the atraumatic needle. Taken in conjunction with data from most studies in the anesthesiology literature, the Therapeutics and Technology Assessment Subcommittee concluded that use of an atraumatic spinal needle in adult patient populations reduces the frequency of PLPHA (Level A recommendation). It affirmed a previous conclusion that smaller needle size is associated with reduced frequency of PLPHA (Level A recommendation).     

Is obligatory bed rest after lumbar puncture obsolete?

Summary After lumbar puncture (LP) an epidural CSF leakage caused by delayed closure of a dural defect leads to a decrease in CSF pressure. The resultant venous dilatation as well as downward shift of the brain with traction on pain-sensitive blood vessels and nerves frequently evokes post-lumbar puncture headache (PLPH), when the patient assumes the upright position. In previous studies differing opinions have been expressed about the prophylactic value of the posture taken by the patient after LP. The present study was designed to evaluate the benefit of the decrease of hydrostatic CSF pressure on the dural rent, when the patient lies down in a prone position with the head tilted down at an angle of 10° for 30 min immediately after LP: is it possible to accelerate the closure of the dural defect in this way and prevent PLPH? One group of patients (n = 78) lay in a prone position with the head tilted down at an angle of 10° for 30 min, the other group (n = 82) rose immediately after LP. PLPH was found to be independent of the posture in both groups and affected 44% and 41% of the patients, respectively, so that there is no longer any justification for requiring patients to remain in bed after LP.     

Post-lumbar puncture syndrome--its pathogenesis, prophylaxis and treatment

Post-lumbar puncture syndrome (PLPS) is a frequent and important complication of diagnostic lumbar puncture. PLPS is primarily caused by perforation of the dura mater, leading to persistent leak of the cerebrospinal fluid, and, as a result, intracranial hypotension. Effective therapeutic options are limited to symptomatic treatment until natural improvement occurs, or, in cases of prolonged complaints, invasive treatment (epidural blood patch with patient's own venous blood), which makes prophylaxis of PLPS essential. Prophylactic measures of confirmed efficacy are: reducing needle size, positioning the needle bevel parallel to the long axis of the spine, re-inserting the stilet before withdrawal of the needle, and, if possible, using a so-called "atraumatic" needle, minimizing the perforation of the meninx. The volume of the cerebrospinal fluid collected and the position of the patient after the procedure do not have a significant influence on PLPS frequency.     

CSF RBC count in successful first-attempt lumbar puncture: the interest of atraumatic needle use

The objective of this study is to analyze CSF red blood cell (RBC) count from first-attempt lumbar punctures and to analyze parameters associated with first-attempt lumbar punctures and hemorrhagic lumbar puncture. This is a prospective analysis of consecutive patients who underwent lumbar puncture for any reason other than suspected acute subarachnoid hemorrhage. Analyzed parameters were the following: age, indication for lumbar puncture, aPTT ratio, PTT, platelet count, patient’s position, needle type (atraumatic/standard), needle diameter, person performing lumbar puncture (medical student/resident/attending physician), number of lumbar levels punctured, necessity of needle repositioning, CSF RBC and white blood cell count, and protein level. Lumbar puncture resulting in RBC count > 5 RBC/mm² was classified as hemorrhagic lumbar puncture (different cut-offs were studied: > 5/> 10/> 100/> 500/> 1000 RBC). In total, 169 elective lumbar punctures in 165 different patients were included. First-attempt lumbar puncture occurred in 22% > 5 RBC, in 19.5% > 10 RBC, in 4.5% > 100 RBC, in 3% > 500 RBC, and 1.5% > 1000 RBC count. First-attempt lumbar puncture was associated with non-hemorrhagic lumbar puncture for each of the RBC count cut-offs (OR for non-hemorrhagic lumbar puncture in first-attempt lumbar puncture 2.8, 95% CI 1.4–5.7). The presence of a hemorrhagic disorder (concerning cerebral amyloid angiopathy in all patients) and higher aPTT ratio were associated with hemorrhagic lumbar puncture. Atraumatic needle use was associated with non-hemorrhagic lumbar puncture for RBC count cut-offs ≤ 5 and ≤ 10 RBC (OR for non-hemorrhagic lumbar puncture in atraumatic needle use 2.5 [95% CI 1.3–4.8] and 2.2 [95% CI 1.1–4.4], respectively). First-attempt lumbar puncture and hemorrhagic lumbar puncture were not associated with other parameters. Slightly elevated CSF RBC count after first-attempt lumbar puncture occurs relatively frequently, but is even more frequent in non-first-attempt lumbar puncture. Atraumatic needle use is associated with non-hemorrhagic lumbar puncture.     

Cerebral blood flow characteristics in patients with post-lumbar puncture headache

The aim of this study was to verify if diagnostic lumbar puncture (DLP) in post-lumbar puncture headache (PLPH) patients is related to significant changes in cerebral blood flow which could be visualized by transcranial Doppler (TCD). Sixty-six patients were enrolled in this study. TCD was performed 24 h before DLP and repeated within 24 h after the procedure. The measurements included mean velocity (V _mean), peak systolic velocity (V _max), and Gosling’s pulsatility index (PI), in the left and right middle cerebral artery (MCA). PLPH was observed in 21 patients (32%). No significant differences were noted in V _mean, V _max and PI between the right and left MCAs—both before DLP and following this procedure. In patients who developed PLPH, bilateral pre-puncture values of V _mean and V _max were significantly higher and PI was significantly lower compared to unaffected individuals. No significant differences were observed between these groups in terms of post-puncture V _mean and V _max, but the post-puncture PI was still significantly lower in PLPH cases. In PLPH cases, the post-puncture values of V _mean and V _max were significantly lower than the respective baseline parameters. A significant inverse correlation was present between PLPH severity and bilateral pre-puncture PI. In conclusion, this study revealed that higher baseline values of V _mean and V _max and low PI in bilateral MCAs predispose patients to PLPH.     

3D打印引导下外伤性脑内血肿微创穿刺引流术

目的通过3D打印技术打印出符合患者面部特征并带有穿刺通道的模型,用于术前定位、术中引导穿刺方向,简化手术过程,提高外伤性颅内血肿穿刺准确性。 方法以1例25岁男性的外伤性脑内血肿颅脑CT二维图像为原始数据,利用Mimics 16.0软件处理,重建形成三维图像,设计穿刺通道,测量穿刺深度,通过3D打印机打印出带有穿刺针颅外段孔道的模型,术前置于术区定位,术中通过穿刺孔道置入引流管,控制穿刺深度,术后复查颅脑CT观察引流管末端位置。 结果在利用计算机软件设计带有穿刺针孔道的"面具"时可在三维空间任意旋转,从各个角度观察,避开重要血管及功能区,达到预定穿刺部位。 结论成功构建符合患者个体特征的三维图像,通过3D打印机将模型打印出来用于手术,可提高穿刺准确性,降低手术难度。     

Incidence of post-lumbar puncture syndrome reduced by reinserting the stylet: a randomized prospective study of 600 patients

The post-lumbar puncture syndrome (PLPS) can best be explained by prolonged spinal fluid leakage owing to delayed closure of a dural defect. Its incidence after spinal anaesthesia is much lower than after diagnostic lumbar puncture (LP). This difference could be caused by a strand of arachnoid, which might enter the needle with the outflowing cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) during diagnostic LP and upon removal of the needle be threaded back through the dura to produce prolonged CSF leakage. To find a technique that further reduces the incidence of PLPS, this hypothesis was tested by evaluating the effect that reinserting the stylet before removing the needle had on the incidence of PLPS. By reinserting the stylet to the tip of the needle, the hypothesized strand would be pushed out, thereby reducing the frequency of PLPS. Sprotte’s “atraumatic needle” (21 gauge) was used for LP. A total of 600 patients participated in the prospective study. They were randomized into two groups and questioned about their complaints every day for up to 7 days after the LP. All LPs were performed by two experienced neurologists (T.B., M.S.). In 300 patients, the stylet was reinserted to the tip of the needle; in the other 300 it was not reinserted. Whereas 49 of the 300 patients without reinsertion developed PLPS, only 15 of the 300 patients with reinsertion did. This significant difference (16.3 vs 5.0%, P < 0.005, chi square test) supports our hypothesis. On the basis of our results, we recommend reinserting the stylet before removing the needle in order to reduce the incidence of PLPS. Received: 30 September 1997 Received in revised form: 9 March 1998 Accepted: 20 March 1998     

Does post dural puncture headache exist in idiopathic intracranial hypertension? A pilot study

Background/ObjectiveOccurrence of post-dural puncture headache (PDPH) after diagnostic lumbar puncture (LP) for idiopathic intracranial hypertension (IIH) may seem very unlikely in clinical practice. Nevertheless, it has been suggested by several studies, mainly in sub-group analyses. We aimed to evaluate the prevalence of PDPH in an IIH population and determine any eventual predictive factors of PDPH occurrence.MethodsWe conducted a retrospective multiple-center observational study. All newly diagnosed IIH patients who met the International Classification of Headache Disorders (ICHD-3) or the Dandy modified criteria were included from three different French hospitals. They all underwent LP following the same process with the same type of needle. We recorded PDPH occurring within five days after LP, as defined by ICHD-3 criteria.ResultsSeventy-four IIH patients were recruited, of whom 23 (31%) presented with PDPH. Neither classical risk factors for PDPH such as body mass index, age or gender, nor cerebrospinal fluid opening pressure, or specific IIH features were associated with occurrence of PDPH.ConclusionPDPH can occur after LP in IIH patients. Clinicians should be aware of this possible event during the IIH diagnosis assessment and should not automatically reconsider IIH diagnosis. PDPH prevention using an atraumatic needle and dedicated PDPH treatment seem relevant in IIH patients.     

Abducens palsy after lumbar puncture.

OBJECTIVE: We report the case of a 43-year-old patient with neuralgic shoulder amyotrophy who developed abducens palsy on the left 4 days after diagnostic lumbar puncture (LP), which recovered completely within 4 months. RESULTS: Side effects after spinal tap are due to prolonged spinal fluid leakage and delayed closure of a dural defect causing intracranial hypotension. Downward 'sagging' of the brain and traction on cranial nerves may lead to abducens palsy. This case and a review of the literature illustrate the higher risk with the use of large-size traumatic needles in LP for cranial sixth nerve palsies. CONCLUSION: The presented case emphasizes the use of atraumatic small-size needles for lumbar puncture.