The role of B cells in solid organ transplantation

The role of antibodies in chronic injury to organ transplants has been suggested for many years, but recently emphasized by new data. We have observed that when immunosuppressive potency decreases either by intentional weaning of maintenance agents or due to homeostatic repopulation after immune cell depletion, the threshold of B cell activation may be lowered. In human transplant recipients the result may be donor-specific antibody, C4d+ injury, and chronic rejection. This scenario has precise parallels in a rhesus monkey renal allograft model in which T cells are depleted with CD3 immunotoxin, or in a CD52-T cell transgenic mouse model using alemtuzumab to deplete T cells. Such animal models may be useful for the testing of therapeutic strategies to prevent DSA. We agree with others who suggest that weaning of immunosuppression may place transplant recipients at risk of chronic antibody-mediated rejection, and that strategies to prevent this scenario are needed if we are to improve long-term graft and patient outcomes in transplantation. We believe that animal models will play a crucial role in defining the pathophysiology of antibody-mediated rejection and in developing effective therapies to prevent graft injury. Two such animal models are described herein.     

Early acute antibody-mediated rejection of a negative flow crossmatch 3rd kidney transplant with exclusive disparity at HLA-DP

Donor-specific alloantibodies (DSA) to HLA-DP may cause antibody-mediated rejection (AMR), especially in re-transplants. We describe the immunization history of a patient who received 3 kidney transplants; the 3rd kidney was completely matched except at DPA1 and DPB1. Prior to the 3rd transplant, single antigen bead analysis (SAB) showed DSA reactivity against DPA1 shared by the 1st and 3rd donors, but B and T flow crossmatch (FXM) results were negative. Within 11 days the 3rd transplant underwent acute C4d+ AMR which coincided with the presence of complement (C1q)-binding IgG1 DSA against donor DPA1 and DPB1. Using HLAMatchmaker and SAB, we provide evidence that eplet (epitope) spreading on DPA1 and eplet sharing on differing DPB1 alleles of the 1st and 3rd transplants was associated with AMR. Since weak DSA to DPA1/DPB1 may induce acute AMR with negative FXM, donor DPA1/DPB1 high resolution typing should be considered in sensitized patients with DP-directed DSA.     

Renal thrombotic microangiopathy associated with chronic humoral graft versus host disease after hematopoietic stem cell transplantation

Thrombotic microangiopathy (TMA) is a known complication of hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (HSCT). The pathogenesis of TMA is controversial but considered to involve various factors such as total body irradiation, use of calcineurin inhibitors for prophylaxis against graft versus host disease (GVHD), viral infection, and GVHD. Herein we describe a case with renal TMA after HSCT, which was probably associated with antibody-mediated endothelial cell injury from chronic GVHD (termed here 'chronic humoral GVHD'). A 49-year-old man presented two years after HSCT with renal dysfunction and proteinuria but without the clinical features of TMA. Histopathological examination of renal biopsy showed chronic glomerular endothelial cell injury with double contour of the glomerular basement membrane, microthrombi and the deposition of complement split product C4d along the glomerular capillaries. Renal tubulitis and peritubular capillaritis were also noted with a multilayered basement membrane and patchy C4d deposition on peritubular capillaries. These findings resemble those of chronic antibody-mediated rejection after kidney transplantation. Furthermore, C4d deposition suggests complement activation. Although circulating anti-blood type and anti-human leukocyte antigen antibodies were not detected, the renal TMA in this case was probably associated with chronic humoral GVHD.     

移植肾穿刺病理组织中抗体介导的排斥反应

背景：体液性排斥以激素耐受和难治性为其显著的特点,常常发生在免疫高敏的受者身上。 目的：对肾功能不全移植肾进行常规穿刺病理活检,根据病理诊断观察抗体介导性排斥反应的治疗效果,分析移植肾穿刺病理活检的安全性。 方法：选取肾移植后有移植肾穿刺活检指征的患者84例,在B超引导下应用BARD(美国)活检穿刺针行移植肾穿刺活检,活检组织行常规苏木精-伊红染色,组织化学染色,同时常规行C4d免疫组织化学染色,依据Banff’05标准进行病理分型,根据病理状态明确诊断进行相应的临床治疗,观察治疗效果。 结果与结论：84例患者除1例由于组织少难以诊断,其余病理诊断移植肾超急性排斥反应1例,急性抗体介导性排斥反应5例,慢性抗体介导性排斥反应2例,C4d免疫组织化学染色阳性16例。经过治疗8例抗体介导性排斥反应患者中4例移植肾功能得以恢复,3例未恢复,1例移植肾失功,移植肾切除。患者无不良反应发生。结果表明移植肾穿刺病理活检对移植肾无不良影响。     

Preformed cytotoxic antibodies in potential allograft recipients: recent data

Presensitization to donor human leukocyte antigen (HLA) remains a major barrier to cell and organ transplantation, thereby contributing to patient mortality. The risks associated with transplantation in the presence of preformed antidonor HLA antibodies range from hyperacute rejection and increased frequency and severity of rejection to no appreciable effect on transplant outcome. Recent evidence has emphasized the importance of immunologic history, anti-HLA antibody class and titer, and differential organ susceptibility to antibody-mediated damage to explain differences in risk for antibody-mediated rejection. Furthermore, in studies of endothelial cells, ligation of class I molecules by subsaturating concentrations of antibodies stimulated expression of cell survival proteins, raising the possibility that, under certain conditions, antibodies promote graft accommodation providing a mechanism for the endothelium to resist immune and inflammatory damage. The discovery of capillary-bound C4d as a robust diagnostic marker for antibody-mediated rejection, coupled with the development of solid-phase assays for the identification of HLA-specific antibodies, has enhanced our ability to detect antibody-mediated rejection and interpret cross-match results. With new diagnostic tools and immunosuppression regimens such as plasmapheresis and intravenous immunoglobulin therapy targeting the humoral immune response, it is time for a concerted effort to reassess the role of alloantibodies in acute and chronic rejection.     

C4d positivity is often associated with acute cellular rejection in renal transplant biopsies following Campath-1H (Alemtuzumab) induction

Peritubular capillary C4d positivity, a marker for antibody-mediated rejection, is observed in approximately 20-50% of indicated renal transplant biopsies and in just 2% of unremarkable protocol biopsies. However, C4d staining has not been evaluated in protocol renal biopsies from patients with Campath-1H induction treatment, and the association between various types of inflammatory cells and acute antibody-mediated rejection is unclear. This study investigated the rates of C4d positivity in unremarkable protocol renal biopsies, biopsies with acute tubular necrosis (ATN), and biopsies with acute cellular rejection (ACR), all following Campath-1H treatment and post-operative immunosuppression. There was low positivity of C4d staining in both the protocol and ATN groups, but the ACR group had a 47.2% rate of positivity (combining focal and diffuse positive cases). Since Campath-1H treatment caused significant depletion of circulating lymphocytes but not circulating monocytes in renal recipients, this study also investigated the role of monocytes in humoral rejection. In ACR cases, CD68 positive monocytes were composed of 59.4 +/- 4.69% inflammatory cells, which was significantly higher than CD3 positive lymphocytes (38.9 +/- 4.4%). Co-localization of positive C4d staining in endothelium and marginating CD68 positive monocytes was illustrated by double staining. Our data indicate that acute antibody-mediated rejection occurs much more frequently in renal transplants with ACR. Moreover, the high percentage of monocytes observed in ACR cases (due to monocytes being less sensitive to Campath-1H depletion) suggests that monocytes are involved in antibody-mediated rejection.     

Expression of silencer of death domains and death-receptor-3 in normal human kidney and in rejecting renal transplants

We have previously reported the pattern of cellular expression of tumor necrosis factor receptors (TNFR) in human kidney and their altered expression in transplant rejection. We have extended our studies to examine the expression of Silencer of Death Domains (SODD), a protein that binds to the cytoplasmic portion of TNFR1 to inhibit signaling in the absence of ligand. In normal human kidney SODD is expressed in glomerular endothelial cells where it colocalizes with TNFR1. During acute rejection both SODD and TNFR1 are lost from glomeruli, but we found strong expression of SODD on the luminal surface of tubular epithelial cells. This occurs in the absence of detectable TNFR1 expression, suggesting that SODD could interact with other proteins at these sites. Several other members of the TNF superfamily, including Fas and death receptors (DR)-3, -4, and -5, also contain intracellular death domains, but SODD only interacts with the death domain of DR3. We therefore studied the expression of DR3 in human kidney, and report that this death receptor is up-regulated in renal tubular epithelial cells and endothelial cells of some interlobular arteries, in parallel with SODD, during acute transplant rejection. In less severe rejection episodes, DR3 and SODD were more focally induced, generally at sites of mononuclear cell infiltrates. In ischemic allografts, eg, with acute tubular necrosis but no cellular rejection, DR3 was induced on tubular epithelial cells and on glomerular endothelial cells. These data confirm that TNF receptor family members are expressed in a regulated manner during renal transplant rejection, and identify DR3 as a potential inducible mediator of tubular inflammation and injury.     

Acute and hyperacute humoral rejection in kidney allograft recipients treated with anti-human thymocyte antibodies

Equine and rabbit antihuman thymocyte globulins (ATGs) have been used in renal transplantation for prevention and treatment of acute rejection. We now report that hyperacute and acute antibody-mediated rejection of renal allografts occurred in three newly transplanted patients who received ATG for induction therapy. Antibody studies performed using complement-dependent cytotoxicity, flow cytometry, enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay, and Luminex yielded negative results for antilymphocytic and antiendothelial cell antibodies in the pretransplant sera obtained from these patients. ATG treatment was initiated at the time of transplantation. One of the patients experienced hyperacute rejection and required transplant nephrectomy within 24 h of transplantation. The other two patients developed acute antibody-mediated rejection within 14 days after transplantation. None of the patients developed antihuman leukocyte antigen antibodies when humoral rejection occurred. However, xenoantibodies that strongly bound to human lymphocytes and, importantly, to activated endothelial cells, were identified in the sera obtained at the time of humoral rejection. Hence, our results strongly implicate ATG in the induction of antibody-mediated rejection of kidney allografts. Flow cytometry testing of ATG reactivity to endothelial cells may be useful in identifying and discarding the ATG lots containing xenoantibodies that can bind to activated endothelial cells of the transplant.     

Vascular deposition of complement-split products in kidney allografts with cell-mediated rejection.

Complement activation in 73 renal transplant biopsies was investigated by indirect immunoperoxidase staining using MoAbs reactive with complement-split products. Intense deposition of complement fragments C4d and C3d in peritubular capillaries, indicating activation of the classical pathway, could be detected in the majority of transplanted kidneys with cell-mediated rejections. Abundant deposition of complement-split products was observed in 22 early biopsies from patients with high 'immunological risk' (i.e. previous, rejected transplants and/or circulating antibodies against HLA-antigens). Despite negative results in the crossmatch before transplantation and paucity of immunoglobulins in transplant biopsies, antibodies directed against endothelial cell antigens should be considered as a possible cause of classical complement activation.     

Tubular and endothelial chimerism in renal allografts using fluorescence and chromogenic in situ hybridization (FISH, CISH) technology

The role of endothelial and tubular chimerism in renal allograft adaptation and rejection varies in different studies. We addressed the correlation between different clinico-pathological settings and sex-chromosomal endothelial and/or tubular chimerism in renal allografts. We examined the presence or absence of the X and Y chromosomes by fluorescence and chromogenic in situ hybridization (FISH, CISH) methodology on paraffin embedded kidney biopsies in 16 gender mismatched renal transplants (1 to 12 years post-transplantation). Twelve patients were male, four female. Four groups were selected: (i) Vascular calcineurin inhibitor toxicity without rejection; (ii) T-cell mediated vascular rejection; (iii) antibody mediated rejection; and (iv) C4d-positivity in AB0-incompatible transplants with or without rejection. Twelve non-transplant kidney biopsies (8 female, 4 male) were used as controls. Tubular chimerism was detected more frequently (69%) than endothelial chimerism (12%) in renal transplants. One of 12 control patients had tubular and endothelial chimeric cells (8%). The Y chromosome occurred in 8/12 male recipients (67%) in tubular epithelial cells and in 5/12 male recipients (42%) in endothelial cells. Double X chromosomes were detected in 3/4 female recipients in tubular epithelium. Tubular chimerism occurred more often with endothelial chimerism and capillaritis without correlation with other parameters, such as rejection. Combined Y chromosomal tubular and lymphatic endothelial chimerism correlated with T-cell mediated vascular rejection in two out of three patients (66%). Combined Y chromosomal tubular and peritubular capillary chimerism correlated with antibody mediated C4d+ rejection in one out of two patients (50%). Tubular and/or endothelial chimerism occur frequently in gender mismatched renal allografts and, when combined, this is associated with T-cell mediated rejection.     

The role of B cells and alloantibody in the host response to human organ allografts

Summary:  Some human organ transplants deteriorate slowly over a period of years, often developing characteristic syndromes: transplant glomerulopathy (TG) in kidneys, bronchiolitis obliterans in lungs, and coronary artery disease in hearts. In the past, we attributed late graft deterioration to 'chronic rejection', a distinct but mysterious immunologic process different from conventional rejection. However, it is likely that much of chronic rejection is explained by conventional T-cell-mediated rejection (TMR), antibody-mediated rejection (AMR), and other insults. Recently, criteria have emerged to now permit us to diagnose AMR in kidney transplants, particularly C4d deposition in peritubular capillaries and circulating antibody against donor human leukocyte antigens (HLA). Some cases with AMR develop TG, although the relationship of TG to AMR is complex. Thus, a specific diagnosis of AMR in kidney can now be made, based on graft damage, C4d deposition, and donor-specific alloantibodies. Criteria for AMR in other organs must be defined. Not all late rejections are AMR; some deteriorating organs probably have smoldering TMR. The diagnosis of late ongoing AMR raises the possibility of treatment to suppress the alloantibody, but efficacy of the available treatments requires further study.     

Deficiency of C4 from donor or recipient mouse fails to prevent renal allograft rejection

Complement effector products generated in the transplanted kidney are known to mediate transplant rejection, but which of the three main activation pathways of complement trigger this response is unclear. Here we assessed the role of the classical and lectin pathways by studying the common component C4 in mouse kidney transplant rejection. We transplanted wild-type or C4-null H-2(b) donor kidneys into H-2(k) or H-2(d) recipients, or vice-versa, to assess the roles of donor kidney and recipient expression of complement. Intragraft C4 gene expression rose substantially during rejection. However, we found no significant association between graft acceptance and the presence of C4 in either the donor kidney or recipient mouse. At the time of rejection, we found no significant differences in alloantibody response in the different groups. Tubular deposition of C3 to C9 occurred regardless of the absence or presence of C4 in either the donor or recipient mouse, indicating that C4 was dispensable for complement activation at this site. These data suggest that complement activation and renal allograft rejection are independent of the classical and lectin pathways in these models, implying that in the absence of these pathways the alternative pathway is the main trigger for complement-mediated rejection.     

B cells in cardiac transplants: from clinical questions to experimental models

After many years of debate, there is now general agreement that B cells can participate in the immune response to cardiac transplants. Acute antibody-mediated rejection (AMR) is the best defined manifestation of B cell responses, but diagnostic and mechanistic questions still surround AMR. Many complement dependent mechanisms of antibody-mediated injury have been elucidated. C5 has become a therapeutic target that may not just truncate complement activation, but also may tip the balance away from inflammation by altering macrophage function. Additional complement independent effects have been identified. These may escape diagnosis and progress to chronic graft injury. The function of B cell infiltrates in cardiac transplants is even more enigmatic. Nodular endocardial infiltrates that contain B cells and plasma cells have been described in protocol biopsies of cardiac transplants for decades, but an understanding of their significance is still evolving based on more critical morphological and molecular evaluation of these infiltrates. A range of infiltrates containing B cells has also been described in the epicardial fat in transplants with advanced chronic rejection. B cells have been observed in endocardial and epicardial tertiary lymphoid nodules, but their impact on antigen presentation or antibody production remains to be determined. Experimental models in small and large animals suggest that B cells could be essential for the formation of lymphoid nodules through cytokine production. Similarly, the role of proinflammatory adipokines in the formation or function of epicardial lymphoid nodules has not been studied. These clinical observations provide critical questions to be addressed in experimental models.     

Antithymocyte globulin is associated with complement deposition in cardiac transplant biopsies

Polyclonal antithymocyte globulin preparations contain antibodies with reactivity to endothelial cells. Therefore, we investigated whether treatment with this reagent caused complement deposition in human cardiac transplants. Frozen tissue was available from endomyocardial biopsies of 75 patients, who were transplanted between April 1995 and April 2000. Nine of these patients were converted from cyclosporin A (CsA) to horse antithymocyte globulin (ATGAM) in the first month after transplantation. All of the biopsies were stained by immunofluorescence for C4d as evidence of activation of the classical pathway of complement. In addition, biopsies from patients treated with ATGAM and control patients were stained for deposition of horse immunoglobulin (Ig)G. All nine patients who received ATGAM had deposition of horse IgG and C4d. Two color stains demonstrated that the horse IgG colocalized with the C4d staining. No staining for horse IgG or C4d was evident in biopsies obtained before ATGAM treatment. Likewise, no staining for horse IgG was detected in seven control patients who had C4d staining. Most patients treated with ATGAM had no histologic evidence of rejection, but did have myocyte damage and macrophage infiltration. Thus prophylactic treatment with ATGAM is associated with the deposition of horse IgG and activation of complement in the transplant.     

Acute vascular humoral rejection in a sensitized cardiac graft recipient: diagnostic value of C4d immunofluorescence

A 37-year-old female patient had a cardiac transplantation for dilated cardiomyopathy. She was sensitized by two pregnancies showing anti-human leukocyte antigen I and II antibodies. The pretransplantation crossmatch was negative, but she developed acute humoral rejection characterized by vascular C4d deposits, arteriolitis, and intravascular leukocyte accumulation and adhesion in venules. Although C4d deposits disappeared in 4 weeks, she had persistent endothelial cell activation (endothelial expression of ELAM-1, VCAM-1, or human leukocyte antigen class II) throughout the 6 months of follow-up. Although she received intensive immunosuppression, she presented three episodes of acute cellular rejection during that period of time. This case shows that C4d deposits represent a sensitive marker of acute humoral rejection in cardiac transplantation. Therefore, C4d immunofluorescence should be more frequently assessed in endomyocardial biopsies.     

Immunohistochemical markers of tissue injury in biopsies with transplant glomerulitis

Transplant glomerulitis is associated with suboptimal graft function. To understand its pathogenesis and to assess the parameters of potential prognostic value, we immunostained 25 paraffin-embedded allograft biopsies showing glomerulitis for markers of complement activation (C4d), cytotoxicity (Granzyme-B), apoptosis (Bcl-XL, Bcl-2, and Fas-L), and endothelial injury (von Willebrand factor). Staining was semiquantitatively assessed in different anatomical compartments, and comparison was made with 40 control allograft biopsies without glomerulitis. Biopsies with glomerulitis had more frequent incidence of "mixed" T-cell and antibody-mediated rejection compared with controls [8/25 (32%) versus 4/40 (10%), P = .046]. Furthermore, they had higher glomerular capillary-C4d scores (1.9 ± 1.1 versus 1.2 ± 1.2, P = .015), which tended to persist when biopsies showing transplant glomerulopathy were excluded. Higher glomerular capillary-C4d scores were observed in samples with versus without donor-specific antibody (2.5 ± 0.9 versus 1.2 ± 1.2, P = .01). Compared with controls, biopsies with glomerulitis had more intraglomerular (4.8 ± 4.5 versus 0.9± 0.8 cells/glomerulus, P < .001) and interstitial mainly peritubular capillary (6.1 ± 4.1 versus 3.2 ± 3.4 cells/hpf, P = .002) Granzyme-B(+) leukocytes. Higher mesangial-von Willebrand factor scores were noted in the glomerulitis group (1.8 ± 1.0 versus 0.8 ± 0.8, P = .003) and correlated with the percentage of inflamed glomeruli (r = 0.54, P < .001). Interstitial-von Willebrand factor was associated with a higher peritubular capillaritis score (interstitial-von Willebrand factor: 1.6 ± 1.2 versus no interstitial-von Willebrand factor: 0.6 ± 0.9, P = .02). Glomerular capillary-Bcl-XL was not associated with accommodation. Finally, no difference in Bcl-2 or Fas-L was observed upon comparing glomerulitis to controls. In conclusion, glomerular injury in transplant glomerulitis appears to be mediated by complement activation and cellular cytotoxicity. Mesangial- or interstitial-von Willebrand factor identified cases with more severe microcirculation injury.     

Decreased humoral antibody episodes of acute renal allograft rejection in recipients expressing the HLA-DQβ1*0202 allele

The present investigation was designed to show the effect of human leukocyte antigen (HLA) class II molecular allelic specificities in the recipient on the induction of humoral antibody rejection, identified by C4d peritubular capillary staining, as well as specific antibody identified by Luminex technology. Major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II molecules are expressed on dendritic cells, macrophages, and B lymphocytes and they present antigenic peptides to CD4 positive T lymphocytes. Human renal peritubular and glomerular capillaries express class II MHC molecules upon activation. Expression of class II molecules on renal microvascular endothelial cells exposes them to possible interaction with specific circulating antibodies. We hypothesize that HLA-DQβ1*0202 expression in recipients decreases the likelihood of antibody-mediated renal allograft rejection. We found that 80% (=25) of DQ2 positive haplotype recipients failed to induce humoral antibody renal allograft rejection and 20% (n=25) of DQ2 positive haplotype recipients induced humoral antibody renal allograft rejection (p=0.008). By contrast, 48% (n=46) of DQ2 negative haplotype recipients failed to induce a humoral antibody component of renal allograft rejection and 52% (n=46) of DQ2 negative haplotype recipients induced humoral antibody-mediated renal allograft rejection. Our results suggest that recipients who express the DQβ1*0202 allele are less likely to induce a humoral antibody component of acute renal allograft rejection than are those expressing DQ1, DQ3, or DQ4 alleles. DQβ1*0202 allele expression in recipients could possibly be protective against acute humoral allograft rejection and might serve as a future criterion in recipient selection and in appropriate therapy for acute renal rejection episodes.