Interplay between immune responses to HLA and non-HLA self-antigens in allograft rejection

Recent studies strongly suggest an increasing role for immune responses against self-antigens (Ags) which are not encoded by the major histocompatibility complex in the immunopathogenesis of allograft rejection. Although, improved surgical techniques coupled with improved methods to detect and avoid sensitization against donor human leukocyte antigen (HLA) have improved the immediate and short term function of transplanted organs. However, acute and chronic rejection still remains a vexing problem for the long term function of the transplanted organ. Immediately following organ transplantation, several factors both immune and non immune mechanisms lead to the development of local inflammatory milieu which sets the stage for allograft rejection. Traditionally, development of antibodies (Abs) against mismatched donor HLA have been implicated in the development of Ab mediated rejection. However, recent studies from our laboratory and others have demonstrated that development of humoral and cellular immune responses against non-HLA self-Ags may contribute in the pathogenesis of allograft rejection. There are reports demonstrating that immune responses to self-Ags especially Abs to the self-Ags as well as cellular immune responses especially through IL17 has significant pro-fibrotic properties leading to chronic allograft failure. This review summarizes recent studies demonstrating the role for immune responses to self-Ags in allograft immunity leading to rejection as well as present recent evidence suggesting there is interplay between allo- and autoimmunity leading to allograft dysfunction.     

An important role for autoimmunity in the immunopathogenesis of chronic allograft rejection

Organ transplantation is the treatment of choice for patients with end-stage organ dysfunction. In spite of advances in understanding of donor and recipient physiology, organ preservation, operative techniques and immunosuppression, long-term graft survival still remains a major problem primarily due to chronic rejection. Alloimmune responses to mismatched major histocompatibility antigens have been implicated as an important factor leading to rejection. However, there is increasing evidence pointing towards cross-talk between the alloimmune and autoimmune responses creating a local inflammatory milieu, which eventually leads to fibrosis and occlusion of the lumen in the transplanted organ i.e. chronic rejection. In this review, we will discuss recent studies and emerging concepts for the interdependence of alloimmune and autoimmune responses in the immunopathogenesis of chronic allograft rejection. The role of autoimmunity in the development of chronic rejection is an intriguing and exciting area of research in the field of solid-organ transplantation with a significant potential to develop novel therapeutic strategies towards preventing chronic allograft rejection.     

Chronic rejection: a significant role for Th17-mediated autoimmune responses to self-antigens

Despite progress in the field of organ transplantation for improvement in graft survival and function, long-term graft function is still limited by the development of chronic allograft rejection. Various immune-mediated and nonimmune-mediated processes have been postulated in the pathogenesis of chronic rejection. In this review, the authors discuss the important role of alloimmune responses to donor-specific antigens and autoimmune responses to tissue restricted self-antigens in the immunopathogenesis of chronic rejection following solid organ transplantation. In particular, the authors discuss the role of induction of Th17-type autoimmune responses and the crosstalk between autoimmune and alloimmune responses. These self-perpetuate each other leading to activation of profibrotic and proinflammatory cascades that ultimately result in the development of chronic rejection.     

Immune responses to self-antigens in asthma patients: clinical and immunopathological implications

Asthma leads to chronic airway inflammation that shares pathological features of chronic rejection after lung transplantation. Due to the significant role of autoimmunity in chronic rejection, we hypothesized that immunity to self-antigens may also be present in asthma. The goal was to define immune responses to self-antigens in patients with asthma. Blood and clinical data were collected from 99 asthmatics and 60 controls. Serum was analyzed for antibodies (Abs) to collagen V (ColV) by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay and correlated with disease severity. Asthmatics' sera were tested in a human protein array to determine immune responses to other self-antigens. Asthmatics had higher concentrations of Abs to ColV (predominantly immunoglobulin G isotype) compared with controls (p < 0.01). These Abs correlated with severe asthma (p < 0.01) and corticosteroid use (p = 0.032). Additionally, Abs to novel self-antigens epidermal group factor receptor (EGFr), activin A type 1 receptor, and α-catenin were detected in asthmatics. We conclude that Abs to self-antigens (ColV, EGFr, activin A type 1 receptor, and α-catenin) are present in the sera of asthmatics, correlating with clinical disease. Epithelial damage from airway inflammation during asthma may result in the exposure of cryptic self-antigens or their determinants, resulting in immune response to self-antigens, which may contribute to the pathogenesis of asthma.     

The impact of non-HLA antibodies on outcomes after lung transplantation and implications for therapeutic approaches

The role of donor-specific antibodies (DSA) to mismatched human leukocyte antigens (HLA) in lung allograft rejection has been recognized over the past 20 years. During this time, there has been growing experience and recognition of an important role for non-HLA antibodies in lung allograft rejection. Multiple self-antigens have been identified that elicit autoimmune responses including collagen V, K-α 1 tubulin, angiotensin type 1 receptor, and endothelin type A receptor, but it is likely that other antigens elicit similar responses. The paradigm for the pathogenesis of these autoimmune responses consists of exposure of sequestered self-antigens followed by loss of peripheral tolerance, which then promotes allograft rejection. Studies have focused mainly on the impact of autoimmune responses on the development of Bronchiolitis Obliterans Syndrome or its mouse model surrogate. However, there are emerging data that illustrate that non-HLA antibodies can induce acute antibody-mediated rejection (AMR) after lung transplantation. Treatment has focused on antibody-depletion protocols, but experience is limited to cohort studies and appropriate controlled trials have not been conducted. It is noteworthy that depletion of non-HLA antibodies has been associated with favorable clinical outcomes. Clearly, additional studies are needed to identify the optimal therapeutic approaches to non-HLA antibodies in clinical practice.     

Loss of tolerance to self after transplant

Organ transplantation is the widely accepted treatment for end-stage organ failure. Since the first successful kidney transplant from an identical twin donor in 1954, researchers have been studying the effects of the immune system on transplantation outcomes. Although the surgery is technically successful, the majority of grafts from genetically disparate donors are rejected due to a number of factors that stimulate recipient immune responses, ultimately resulting in graft loss despite the chronic use of immunosuppressive (IS) drugs. Unfortunately, while short-term success has greatly improved with the development of novel IS drugs, the long-term graft survival of solid organs has not improved significantly over the last few decades. The problem of late graft loss is mainly attributed to development of chronic rejection. Therefore, understanding all of the immune mechanisms involved in transplant rejection is important to prevent graft dysfunction, and eventually, graft loss. In this review, we will give an overview of allograft rejection, the progression from acute to chronic rejection, and in addition, the recent discovery of a critical role for loss of self-tolerance and development of IL-17-dependent autoimmunity in chronic rejection.     

Characterization of the immunoregulatory function of human TCR-αβ+ CD4- CD8- double-negative T cells

Regulatory T cells (Tregs) play an important role in the maintenance of immune tolerance to self-antigens and are involved in modulating immune responses in autoimmunity, transplant rejection, and tumor immunity. Recently, a novel subset of TCR-αβ(+) CD4(-) CD8(-) (double negative, DN) T cells has been described to specifically suppress T-cell responses in mice. Here, we demonstrate that human DN T cells are highly potent suppressors of both CD4(+) and CD8(+) T-cell responses. In contrast to naturally occurring CD4(+) CD25(+) Tregs, DN T cells have to be activated by antigen-presenting cells (APCs) to induce their regulatory potential. The suppressive activity of DN T cells is neither mediated indirectly by modulation of APCs nor by competition for T-cell growth factors. Furthermore, DN T-cell-mediated suppression toward responder T cells is TCR dependent and requires novel protein synthesis. In contrast to murine DN T cells, which eliminate effector T cells via Fas/FasL or perforin/granzyme, human DN T cells suppress proliferation of responder T cells by cell contact-dependent mechanisms. Taken together, our data indicate that human DN T cells exert strong immunosuppressive effects on both CD4(+) and CD8(+) T cells and may serve as a new therapeutic approach to treat autoimmunity and transplant rejection.     

PARP-1 inhibitor-AG14361 suppresses acute allograft rejection via stabilizing CD4+FoxP3+ regulatory T cells

Acute allograft rejection is the most common complication in organ transplantation leading to organ loss. Treg cells play an important role in preventing acute rejection, but they are unstable and easily lose function. Poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase 1(PARP-1) is involved in the differentiation stabilization of Treg cells, it has been suggested that PARP-1 inhibition could prevent acute rejection and prolong allograft survival. This study investigated AG14361 effects on acute allograft rejection. We used a fully MHC-mismatched murine heart transplantation model to compare the effect of PARP-1 inhibitor-AG14361 on alloimmunity to the control. Mice treated with PARP-1 inhibitors showed a longer median survival time of allografts (MS14 compared with the control group, MST was 8 days, and AG14361 was 6 days, P = 0.019). The combination of sirolimus and AG14361 significantly delayed allograft MST (AG14361 + sirolimus for 30 days, sirolimus for 16 days, P = 0.002). AG14361 markedly augmented the number of the CD25+FoxP3+ Treg cells in the graft and periphery. In addition, it could enhance the suppressive function of Treg cells by upregulating the level of CTLA-4, PD-1 and ICOS. In vivo, the Treg/Th17 ratio increased significantly in the AG14351 group compared to the control. In the combination with sirolimus treatment, AG14361 promoted the long-term allograft survival. Our results highlight novel effects of a PARP-1 inhibitor. PARP-1 inhibitor AG14361 may be a promising agent to attenuate acute allograft rejection as it can maintain the number and function of Treg cells in allografts.     

Chronic cardiac allograft rejection: critical role of ED-A(+) fibronectin and implications for targeted therapy strategies

Chronic cardiac allograft rejection is characterized by cardiac allograft vasculopathy (CAV) and cardiac interstitial fibrosis (CIF) causing severe long-term complications after heart transplantation and determining allograft function and patients' prognosis. Until now, there have been no sufficient preventive or therapeutic strategies. CAV and CIF are accompanied by changes in the extracellular matrix, including re-expression of the fetal fibronectin splice variant known as ED-A(+) fibronectin. This molecule has been shown to be crucial for the development of myofibroblasts (MyoFbs) as the main cell type in CIF and for the activation of vascular smooth muscle cells (VSMCs) as the main cell type in CAV. Relevant re-expression and protein deposition of ED-A(+) fibronectin has been demonstrated in animal models of chronic rejection, with spatial association to CAV and CIF, and a quantitative correlation to the rejection grade. The paper by Booth et al published in this issue of The Journal of Pathology could prove for the first time the functional importance of ED-A(+) fibronectin for the development of CIF as a main component of chronic cardiac rejection. Thus, promising conclusions for the development of new diagnostic, preventive, and therapeutic strategies for chronic cardiac rejection focusing on ED-A(+) fibronectin can be suggested.     

Morphologic and immunohistochemical findings in antibody-mediated rejection of the cardiac allograft

The recognition and acceptance of the entity of antibody-mediated rejection (AMR) of solid organs has been slow to develop. Greatest acceptance and most information relates to cardiac transplantation. AMR is thought to represent antibody/complement mediated injury to the microvasculature of the graft that can result in allograft dysfunction, allograft loss, accelerated graft vasculopathy, and increased mortality. The morphologic hallmark is microvascular injury with immunoglobulin and complement deposition in capillaries, accumulation of intravascular macrophages, and in more severe cases, microvascular hemorrhage and thrombosis, with inflammation and edema of the affected organ. Understanding of the pathogenesis of AMR, criteria and methods for diagnosis, and treatment strategies are still in evolution, and will be addressed in this review.     

Regulatory T-cell homeostasis: steady-state maintenance and modulation during inflammation

Regulatory T (Treg) cells play a vital role in the prevention of autoimmunity and the maintenance of self-tolerance, but these cells also have an active role in inhibiting immune responses during viral, bacterial, and parasitic infections. Although excessive Treg activity can lead to immunodeficiency, chronic infection, and cancer, too little Treg activity results in autoimmunity and immunopathology and impairs the quality of pathogen-specific responses. Recent studies have helped define the homeostatic mechanisms that support the diverse pool of peripheral Treg cells under steady-state conditions and delineate how the abundance and function of Treg cells changes during inflammation. These findings are highly relevant for developing effective strategies to manipulate Treg cell activity to promote allograft tolerance and treat autoimmunity, chronic infection, and cancer.     

T Cell recognition of epithelial self

The presentation of self-antigens to circulating T cells is a critical, precipitating event in the induction of autoimmune injury in parenchymal organs. Epithelia expressing these self-antigens are thought to release such moieties for reprocessing by traditional antigen-presenting cells within the lymphoid system. We now demonstrate, however, that some epithelium possess novel functional mechanisms for presenting their own antigens to a responsive, syngeneic T cell repertoire. The presentation of these self-antigens occurs in the context of MHC class II molecules and depends on CD4 associative-recognition determinants. Our findings strongly suggest that organ epithelium may directly activate cell-mediated events to produce autoimmunity through self-recognition     

Recipient-derived EDA fibronectin promotes cardiac allograft fibrosis

Advances in donor matching and immunosuppressive therapies have decreased the prevalence of acute rejection of cardiac grafts; however, chronic rejection remains a significant obstacle for long-term allograft survival. While initiating elements of anti-allograft immune responses have been identified, the linkage between these factors and the ultimate development of cardiac fibrosis is not well understood. Tissue fibrosis resembles an exaggerated wound healing response, in which extracellular matrix (ECM) molecules are central. One such ECM molecule is an alternatively spliced isoform of the ubiquitous glycoprotein fibronectin (FN), termed extra domain A-containing cellular fibronectin (EDA cFN). EDA cFN is instrumental in fibrogenesis; thus, we hypothesized that it might also regulate fibrotic remodelling associated with chronic rejection. We compared the development of acute and chronic cardiac allograft rejection in EDA cFN-deficient (EDA(-/-)) and wild-type (WT) mice. While EDA(-/-) mice developed acute cardiac rejection in a manner indistinguishable from WT controls, cardiac allografts in EDA(-/-) mice were protected from fibrosis associated with chronic rejection. Decreased fibrosis was not associated with differences in cardiomyocyte hypertrophy or intra-graft expression of pro-fibrotic mediators. Further, we examined expression of EDA cFN and total FN by whole splenocytes under conditions promoting various T-helper lineages. Conditions supporting regulatory T-cell (Treg) development were characterized by greatest production of total FN and EDA cFN, though EDA cFN to total FN ratios were highest in Th1 cultures. These findings indicate that recipient-derived EDA cFN is dispensable for acute allograft rejection responses but that it promotes the development of fibrosis associated with chronic rejection. Further, conditions favouring the development of regulatory T cells, widely considered graft-protective, may drive production of ECM molecules which enhance deleterious remodelling responses. Thus, EDA cFN may be a therapeutic target for ameliorating fibrosis associated with chronic cardiac allograft rejection.     

Clinical relevance of lung-restricted antibodies in lung transplantation

Lung transplant is a definitive treatment for several end-stage lung diseases. However, the high incidence of allograft rejection limits the overall survival following lung transplantation. Traditionally, alloimmunity directed against human leukocyte antigens (HLA) has been implicated in transplant rejection. Recently, the clinical impact of non-HLA lung-restricted antibodies (LRA) has been recognized and extensive research has demonstrated that they may play a dominant role in the development of lung allograft rejection. The immunogenic lung-restricted antigens that have been identified include amongst others, collagen type I, collagen type V, and k-alpha 1 tubulin. Pre-existing antibodies against these lung-restricted antigens are prevalent in patients undergoing lung transplantation and have emerged as one of the predominant risk factors for primary graft dysfunction which limits short-term survival following lung transplantation. Additionally, LRA have been shown to predispose to chronic lung allograft rejection, the predominant cause of poor long-term survival. This review will discuss ongoing research into the mechanisms of development of LRA as well as the pathogenesis of associated lung allograft injury.     

CD28 Function: A Balance of Costimulatory and Regulatory Signals

Both the recognition of MHC/antigen complex by the T-cell receptor and engagement of costimulatory molecules are necessary for efficient T-cell activation. CD28 has been widely recognized as the major costimulation pathway for naive T-cell activation, and the CD28/B7 pathway plays a central role in immune responses against pathogens, autoimmune diseases, and graft rejection. In this review, we will summarize evidence that CD28 is also prominent in the regulation of immune responses and the maintenance of peripheral tolerance. Indeed, CD28 engagement increases the expression of the down-modulatory molecule CTLA-4, induces the differentiation of Th2 cells that have a protective function in autoimmunity, and has an obligatory role in the homeostasis of regulatory T cells. Therefore, CD28/B7 interactions induce a balance of costimulatory and regulatory signals that have opposite outcomes on immune responses. This new perspective on CD28 function suggests that caution should be taken in the development of immunotherapies targeting costimulatory pathways.     

Anti-interleukin-12/23p40 antibody attenuates chronic rejection of cardiac allografts partly via inhibition γδT cells

In our previous study, we showed that treatment with an anti‐interleukin (IL)‐12/23p40 antibody inhibits acute cardiac allograft rejection via inhibiting production of interferon (IFN)‐γ and IL‐17a. However, the impact of this antagonistic anti‐p40 antibody on chronic cardiac rejection was unclear. Hearts of B6.C‐H2bm12/KhEg mice were transplanted into major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II‐mismatched C57Bl/6J mice (wild‐type, γδTCR ^–/– and IL‐17^–/–), which is an established murine model of chronic allograft rejection without immunosuppression. The mice were treated with control immunoglobulin (Ig)G or 200 µg anti‐p40 monoclonal antibody on post‐operative days, respectively. Abdominal palpation and echocardiography were used to monitor graft survival. The mice administered with anti‐p40 antibody showed a significant promotion in graft survival (median survival time >100 days), and histological analyses revealed that cardiac allograft rejection was attenuated. Quantitative real‐time polymerase chain reaction (qRT–PCR) and immunofluorescence analyses demonstrated that anti‐p40 antibody down‐regulated the level of ingraft cytokine and chemokine expression (IL‐6, IFN‐γ, IL‐17a, CCL2 and CCL20). Flow cytometry analyses showed that γδ T cells are an important ingraft source of IFN‐γ and IL‐17a and inhibit the production of inflammation cytokine by anti‐p40 antibody. Compared with the wild‐type group, the graft survival time in the γδ T cell receptor^–/– and IL‐17^–/– mice was prolonged significantly. Therefore we propose that, in the chronic allograft rejection model, treatment with anti‐p40 antibody prolongs graft survival possibly by reducing the amount of reactive inflammatory cells, especially γδ T cells.     

Modulation of immune responses following solid organ transplantation by microRNA

Organ transplantation, an accepted treatment for end stage organ failure, is often complicated by allograft rejection and disease recurrence. In this review we will discuss the potential role of microRNAs in allograft immunity especially leading to rejection of the transplanted organ. microRNAs (miRNAs), originally identified in C. elegans, are short non-coding 21–24 nucleotide sequences that bind to its complementary sequences in functional messenger RNAs and inhibits post-translational processes through RNA duplex formation resulting in gene silencing (Lau et al., 2001). Gene specific translational silencing by miRNAs regulates pathways for immune responses such as development of innate immunity, inflammation, T-cell and B-cell differentiation and signaling that are implicated in various stages of allograft rejection. miRNAs also play a role in development of post-transplant complicacies like fibrosis, cirrhosis, carcinogenesis often leading to graft loss and poor patient outcome. Recent advancements in the methods for detecting and quantifying miRNA in tissue biopsies, as well as in serum and urine samples, has led to identification of specific miRNA signatures in patients with allograft rejection and have been utilized to predict allograft status and survival. Therefore, miRNAs play a significant role in post-transplant events including allograft rejection, disease recurrence and tumor development impacting patient outcome.     

Mast cells and c-Kit expression in liver allograft rejection

AIMS : The pathogenesis of rejection following liver transplantation is not fully understood. It has been postulated that mast cells may play a role in acute and chronic rejection of a number of other solid organ grafts. The aim of this study was to assess the possible role of mast cells and c-Kit+ cells in acute and chronic liver allograft rejection. METHODS AND RESULTS : Biopsy specimens from (i) 'time zero' grafts with a minimal degree of perfusion injury (controls), (ii) transplanted livers with different grades of acute rejection, and (iii) transplanted livers with end-stage chronic rejection, were stained immunohistochemically using monoclonal anti-mast cell tryptase and polyclonal anti-c-Kit antibodies. Tryptase- and c-Kit-positive cell densities were assessed by image analysis. Tryptase-positive mast cell densities (P<0.001) were strongly correlated with acute liver allograft rejection grades and chronic liver allograft rejection. Furthermore, a similarly strong relationship was found between c-Kit+ cell densities and increasing rejection grade (P<0.001). CONCLUSIONS : Tryptase- and c-Kit-positive mast cells form part of the inflammatory infiltrate in both acute and chronic liver allograft rejection, and may be important effector cells in these processes.