Fc‐Silent Anti‐CD154 Domain Antibody Effectively Prevents Nonhuman Primate Renal Allograft Rejection

The advent of costimulation blockade provides the prospect for targeted therapy with improved graft survival in transplant patients. Perhaps the most effective costimulation blockade in experimental models is the use of reagents to block the CD40/CD154 pathway. Unfortunately, successful clinical translation of anti‐CD154 therapy has not been achieved. In an attempt to develop an agent that is as effective as previous CD154 blocking antibodies but lacks the risk of thromboembolism, we evaluated the efficacy and safety of a novel anti‐human CD154 domain antibody (dAb, BMS‐986004). The anti‐CD154 dAb effectively blocked CD40‐CD154 interactions but lacked crystallizable fragment (Fc) binding activity and resultant platelet activation. In a nonhuman primate kidney transplant model, anti‐CD154 dAb was safe and efficacious, significantly prolonging allograft survival without evidence of thromboembolism (Median survival time 103 days). The combination of anti‐CD154 dAb and conventional immunosuppression synergized to effectively control allograft rejection (Median survival time 397 days). Furthermore, anti‐CD154 dAb treatment increased the frequency of CD4⁺CD25⁺Foxp3⁺ regulatory T cells. This study demonstrates that the use of a novel anti‐CD154 dAb that lacks Fc binding activity is safe without evidence of thromboembolism and is equally as potent as previous anti‐CD154 agents at prolonging renal allograft survival in a nonhuman primate preclinical model.     

ASP2409, A Next‐Generation CTLA4‐Ig,Versus Belatacept in Renal Allograft Survival in Cynomolgus Monkeys

Belatacept is the first costimulatory blockade agent approved for maintenance immunosuppression in kidney transplant recipients. Clinical results have indicated that belatacept is associated with superior renal function and improved metabolic profile; however, higher incidence of acute rejection and posttransplant lymphoproliferative disorder are the shortcomings of this agent. In this study, ASP2409, a new cytotoxic T‐lymphocyte associated protein 4‐immunoglobulin possessing 14‐fold higher in vitro CD86 binding affinity than belatacept, was tested for renal allograft survival in cynomolgus monkeys. ASP2409 monotherapy dose‐dependently prolonged renal allograft survival. Low‐dose ASP2409 in combination with a subtherapeutic dose of tacrolimus showed much longer median survival time than monotherapy. Similar allograft survival results were observed in regimens based on high‐dose ASP2409, belatacept, and therapeutic‐dose tacrolimus. The results of renal allograft histopathology with high‐dose ASP2409‐based regimens were not inferior to the belatacept‐based regimen. Moreover, higher frequencies of FoxP3‐positive regulatory T cells in renal allografts were observed in ASP2409‐ and belatacept‐based regimens compared with tacrolimus‐based regimens. No serious side effects related to ASP2409 administration were found during the study. These data suggest that ASP2409 is a promising candidate for calcineurin inhibitor‐sparing or ‐avoidance regimens.     

Belatacept Combined With Transient Calcineurin Inhibitor Therapy Prevents Rejection and Promotes Improved Long‐Term Renal Allograft Function

Belatacept, a T cell costimulation blocker, demonstrated superior renal function, lower cardiovascular risk, and improved graft and patient survival in renal transplant recipients. Despite the potential benefits, adoption of belatacept has been limited in part due to concerns regarding higher rates and grades of acute rejection in clinical trials. Since July 2011, we have utilized belatacept‐based immunosuppression regimens in clinical practice. In this retrospective analysis of 745 patients undergoing renal transplantation at our center, we compared patients treated with belatacept (n = 535) with a historical cohort receiving a tacrolimus‐based protocol (n = 205). Patient and graft survival were equivalent for all groups. An increased rate of acute rejection was observed in an initial cohort treated with a protocol similar to the low‐intensity regimen from the BENEFIT trial versus the historical tacrolimus group (50.5% vs. 20.5%). The addition of a transient course of tacrolimus reduced rejection rates to acceptable levels (16%). Treatment with belatacept was associated with superior estimated GFR (belatacept 63.8 mL/min vs. tacrolimus 46.2 mL/min at 4 years, p < 0.0001). There were no differences in serious infections including rates of cytomegalovirus or BK viremia. We describe the development of a costimulatory blockade‐based strategy that ultimately allows renal transplant recipients to achieve calcineurin inhibitor–free immunosuppression.     

Belatacept‐Resistant Rejection Is Associated With CD28+ Memory CD8 T Cells

Recently, newer therapies have been designed to more specifically target rejection in an effort to improve efficacy and limit unwanted toxicity. Belatacept, a CD28‐CD80/86 specific reagent, is associated with superior patient survival and graft function compared with traditional therapy, but its adoption as a mainstay immunosuppressive therapy has been tempered by increased rejection rates. It is essential that the underlying mechanisms associated with this rejection be elucidated before belatacept is more widely used. To that end, we designed a study in a nonhuman primate kidney transplant model where animals were treated with either a belatacept‐ or a tacrolimus‐based immunosuppressive regimen. Interestingly, we found that elevated pretransplant frequencies of CD28⁺CD8⁺T_EMRA cells are associated with rejection on belatacept but not tacrolimus treatment. Further analysis showed that the CD28⁺CD8⁺T_EMRA cells rapidly lose CD28 expression after transplant in those animals that go on to reject with the allograft infiltrate being predominantly CD28^?. These data suggest that CD28⁺ memory T cells may be resistant to belatacept, capable of further differentiation including loss of CD28 expression while maintaining effector function. The unique signaling requirements of CD28⁺ memory T cells provide opportunities for the development of targeted therapies, which may synergize with belatacept to prevent costimulation‐independent rejection.     

A Pilot Trial Targeting the ICOS–ICOS‐L Pathway in Nonhuman Primate Kidney Transplantation

Costimulation blockade with the B7‐CD28 pathway‐specific agent belatacept is now used in clinical kidney transplantation, but its efficacy remains imperfect. Numerous alternate costimulatory pathways have been proposed as targets to synergize with belatacept, one of which being the inducible costimulator (ICOS)–ICOS ligand (ICOS‐L) pathway. Combined ICOS–ICOS‐L and CD28‐B7 blockade has been shown to prevent rejection in mice, but has not been studied in primates. We therefore tested a novel ICOS‐Ig human Fc‐fusion protein in a nonhuman primate (NHP) kidney transplant model alone and in combination with belatacept. ICOS‐Ig did not prolong rejection‐free survival as a monotherapy or in combination with belatacept. In ICOS‐Ig alone treated animals, most graft‐infiltrating CD4⁺ and CD8⁺ T cells expressed ICOS, and ICOS⁺ T cells were present in peripheral blood to a lesser degree. Adding belatacept reduced the proportion of graft‐infiltrating ICOS⁺ T cells and virtually eliminated their presence in peripheral blood. Graft‐infiltrating T cells in belatacept‐resistant rejection were primarily CD8⁺CD28^?, but importantly, very few CD8⁺CD28^? T cells expressed ICOS. We conclude that ICOS‐Ig, alone or combined with belatacept, does not prolong renal allograft survival in NHPs. This may relate to selective loss of ICOS with CD28 loss.

     

Selective CD28 Blockade Results in Superior Inhibition of Donor‐Specific T Follicular Helper Cell and Antibody Responses Relative to CTLA4‐Ig

Donor‐specific antibodies (DSAs) are a barrier to improved long‐term outcomes after kidney transplantation. Costimulation blockade with CTLA4‐Ig has shown promise as a potential therapeutic strategy to control DSAs. T follicular helper (Tfh) cells, a subset of CD4⁺ T cells required for optimal antibody production, are reliant on the CD28 costimulatory pathway. We have previously shown that selective CD28 blockade leads to superior allograft survival through improved control of CD8⁺ T cells relative to CTLA4‐Ig, but the impact of CD28‐specific blockade on CD4⁺ Tfh cells is unknown. Thus, we identified and characterized donor‐reactive Tfh cells in a murine skin transplant model and then used this model to evaluate the impact of selective CD28 blockade with an anti‐CD28 domain antibody (dAb) on the donor‐specific Tfh cell–mediated immune response. We observed that the anti‐CD28 dAb led to superior inhibition of donor‐reactive CXCR5⁺PD‐1^high Tfh cells, CD95⁺GL7⁺ germinal center B cells and DSA formation compared with CTLA4‐Ig. Interestingly, donor‐reactive Tfh cells differentially upregulated CTLA4 expression, suggesting an important role for CTLA4 in mediating the superior inhibition observed with the anti‐CD28 dAb. Therefore, selective CD28 blockade as a novel approach to control Tfh cell responses and prevent DSA after kidney transplantation warrants further study.     

Long‐term survival of pig‐to‐rhesus macaque renal xenografts is dependent on CD4 T cell depletion

The shortage of available organs remains the greatest barrier to expanding access to transplant. Despite advances in genetic editing and immunosuppression, survival in experimental models of kidney xenotransplant has generally been limited to <100 days. We found that pretransplant selection of recipients with low titers of anti‐pig antibodies significantly improved survival in a pig‐to–rhesus macaque kidney transplant model (6 days vs median survival time 235 days). Immunosuppression included transient pan–T cell depletion and an anti‐CD154–based maintenance regimen. Selective depletion of CD4⁺ T cells but not CD8⁺ T cells resulted in long‐term survival (median survival time >400 days vs 6 days). These studies suggested that CD4⁺ T cells may have a more prominent role in xenograft rejection compared with CD8⁺ T cells. Although animals that received selective depletion of CD8⁺ T cells showed signs of early cellular rejection (marked CD4⁺ infiltrates), animals receiving selective CD4⁺ depletion exhibited normal biopsy results until late, when signs of chronic antibody rejection were present. In vitro study results suggested that rhesus CD4⁺ T cells required the presence of SLA class II to mount an effective proliferative response. The combination of low pretransplant anti‐pig antibody and CD4 depletion resulted in consistent, long‐term xenograft survival.     

Selective Targeting of High‐Affinity LFA‐1 Does Not Augment Costimulation Blockade in a Nonhuman Primate Renal Transplantation Model

Costimulation blockade (CoB) via belatacept is a lower‐morbidity alternative to calcineurin inhibitor (CNI)‐based immunosuppression. However, it has higher rates of early acute rejection. These early rejections are mediated in part by memory T cells, which have reduced dependence on the pathway targeted by belatacept and increased adhesion molecule expression. One such molecule is leukocyte function antigen (LFA)‐1. LFA‐1 exists in two forms: a commonly expressed, low‐affinity form and a transient, high‐affinity form, expressed only during activation. We have shown that antibodies reactive with LFA‐1 regardless of its configuration are effective in eliminating memory T cells but at the cost of impaired protective immunity. Here we test two novel agents, leukotoxin A and AL‐579, each of which targets the high‐affinity form of LFA‐1, to determine whether this more precise targeting prevents belatacept‐resistant rejection. Despite evidence of ex vivo and in vivo ligand‐specific activity, neither agent when combined with belatacept proved superior to belatacept monotherapy. Leukotoxin A approached a ceiling of toxicity before efficacy, while AL‐579 failed to significantly alter the peripheral immune response. These data, and prior studies, suggest that LFA‐1 blockade may not be a suitable adjuvant agent for CoB‐resistant rejection.     

Renal Allograft Survival in Nonhuman Primates Infused With Donor Antigen‐Pulsed Autologous Regulatory Dendritic Cells

Systemic administration of autologous regulatory dendritic cells (DCreg; unpulsed or pulsed with donor antigen [Ag]), prolongs allograft survival and promotes transplant tolerance in rodents. Here, we demonstrate that nonhuman primate (NHP) monocyte‐derived DCreg preloaded with cell membrane vesicles from allogeneic peripheral blood mononuclear cells induce T cell hyporesponsiveness to donor alloantigen (alloAg) in vitro. These donor alloAg‐pulsed autologous DCreg (1.4–3.6 × 10⁶/kg) were administered intravenously, 1 day before MHC‐mismatched renal transplantation to rhesus monkeys treated with costimulation blockade (cytotoxic T lymphocyte Ag 4 immunoglobulin [CTLA4] Ig) and tapered rapamycin. Prolongation of graft median survival time from 39.5 days (no DCreg infusion; n = 6 historical controls) and 29 days with control unpulsed DCreg (n = 2), to 56 days with donor Ag‐pulsed DCreg (n = 5) was associated with evidence of modulated host CD4⁺ and CD8⁺ T cell responses to donor Ag and attenuation of systemic IL‐17 production. Circulating anti‐donor antibody (Ab) was not detected until CTLA4 Ig withdrawal. One monkey treated with donor Ag‐pulsed DCreg rejected its graft in association with progressively elevated anti‐donor Ab, 525 days posttransplant (160 days after withdrawal of immunosuppression). These findings indicate a modest but not statistically significant beneficial effect of donor Ag‐pulsed autologous DCreg infusion on NHP graft survival when administered with a minimal immunosuppressive drug regimen.     

Dual targeting: Combining costimulation blockade and bortezomib to permit kidney transplantation in sensitized recipients

Previous evidence suggests that a homeostatic germinal center (GC) response may limit bortezomib desensitization therapy. We evaluated the combination of costimulation blockade with bortezomib in a sensitized non‐human primate kidney transplant model. Sensitized animals were treated with bortezomib, belatacept, and anti‐CD40 mAb twice weekly for a month (n = 6) and compared to control animals (n = 7). Desensitization therapy–mediated DSA reductions approached statistical significance (P = .07) and significantly diminished bone marrow PCs, lymph node follicular helper T cells, and memory B cell proliferation. Graft survival was prolonged in the desensitization group (P = .073). All control animals (n = 6) experienced graft loss due to antibody‐mediated rejection (AMR) after kidney transplantation, compared to one desensitized animal (1/5). Overall, histological AMR scores were significantly lower in the treatment group (n = 5) compared to control (P = .020). However, CMV disease was common in the desensitized group (3/5). Desensitized animals were sacrificed after long‐term follow‐up with functioning grafts. Dual targeting of both plasma cells and upstream GC responses successfully prolongs graft survival in a sensitized NHP model despite significant infectious complications and drug toxicity. Further work is planned to dissect underlying mechanisms, and explore safety concerns.     

Increased Pretransplant Frequency of CD28+ CD4+ TEM Predicts Belatacept‐Resistant Rejection in Human Renal Transplant Recipients

While most human T cells express the CD28 costimulatory molecule constitutively, it is well known that age, inflammation, and viral infection can drive the generation of CD28^null T cells. In vitro studies have demonstrated that CD28^null cell effector function is not impacted by the presence of the CD28 costimulation blocker belatacept. As such, a prevailing hypothesis suggests that CD28^null cells may precipitate costimulation blockade‐resistant rejection. However, CD28⁺ cells possess more proliferative and multifunctional capacity, factors that may increase their ability to successfully mediate rejection. Here, we performed a retrospective immunophenotypic analysis of adult renal transplant recipients who experienced acute rejection on belatacept treatment as compared to those who did not. Intriguingly, our findings suggest that patients possessing higher frequency of CD28⁺ CD4⁺ T_EM prior to transplant were more likely to experience acute rejection following treatment with a belatacept‐based immunosuppressive regimen. Mechanistically, CD28⁺ CD4⁺ T_EM contained significantly more IL‐2 producers. In contrast, CD28^null CD4⁺ T_EM isolated from stable belatacept‐treated patients exhibited higher expression of the 2B4 coinhibitory molecule as compared to those isolated from patients who rejected. These data raise the possibility that pretransplant frequencies of CD28⁺ CD4⁺ T_EM could be used as a biomarker to predict risk of rejection following treatment with belatacept.     

Immunosuppression With CD40 Costimulatory Blockade Plus Rapamycin for Simultaneous Islet–Kidney Transplantation in Nonhuman Primates

The lack of a reliable immunosuppressive regimen that effectively suppresses both renal and islet allograft rejection without islet toxicity hampers a wider clinical application of simultaneous islet–kidney transplantation (SIK). Seven MHC‐mismatched SIKs were performed in diabetic cynomolgus monkeys. Two recipients received rabbit antithymocyte globulin (ATG) induction followed by daily tacrolimus and rapamycin (ATG/Tac/Rapa), and five recipients were treated with anti‐CD40 monoclonal antibody (mAb) and rapamycin (aCD40/Rapa). Anti‐inflammatory therapy, including anti–interleukin‐6 receptor mAb and anti–tumor necrosis factor‐α mAb, was given in both groups. The ATG/Tac/Rapa recipients failed to achieve long‐term islet allograft survival (19 and 26 days) due to poor islet engraftment and cytomegalovirus pneumonia. In contrast, the aCD40/Rapa regimen provided long‐term islet and kidney allograft survival (90, 94, >120, >120, and >120 days), with only one recipient developing evidence of allograft rejection. The aCD40/Rapa regimen was also tested in four kidney‐alone transplant recipients. All four recipients achieved long‐term renal allograft survival (100% at day 120), which was superior to renal allograft survival (62.9% at day 120) with triple immunosuppressive regimen (tacrolimus, mycophenolate mofetil, and steroids). The combination of anti‐CD40 mAb and rapamycin is an effective and nontoxic immunosuppressive regimen that uses only clinically available agents for kidney and islet recipients.     

Inflammation Causes Resistance to Anti‐CD20–Mediated B Cell Depletion

B cells play a central role in antibody‐mediated rejection and certain autoimmune diseases. However, B cell–targeted therapy such as anti‐CD20 B cell–depleting antibody (aCD20) has yielded mixed results in improving outcomes. In this study, we investigated whether an accelerated B cell reconstitution leading to aCD20 depletion resistance could account for these discrepancies. Using a transplantation model, we found that antigen‐independent inflammation, likely through toll‐like receptor (TLR) signaling, was sufficient to mitigate B cell depletion. Secondary lymphoid organs had a quicker recovery of B cells when compared to peripheral blood. Inflammation altered the pharmacokinetics (PK) and pharmacodynamics (PD) of aCD20 therapy by shortening drug half‐life and accelerating the reconstitution of the peripheral B cell pool by bone marrow–derived B cell precursors. IVIG (intravenous immunoglobulin) coadministration also shortened aCD20 drug half‐life and led to accelerated B cell recovery. Repeated aCD20 dosing restored B cell depletion and delayed allograft rejection, especially B cell–dependent, antibody‐independent allograft rejection. These data demonstrate the importance of further clinical studies of the PK/PD of monoclonal antibody treatment in inflammatory conditions. The data also highlight the disconnect between B cell depletion on peripheral blood compared to secondary lymphoid organs, the deleterious effect of IVIG when given with aCD20 and the relevance of redosing of aCD20 for effective B cell depletion in alloimmunity.     

Prolonged Survival Following Pig‐to‐Primate Liver Xenotransplantation Utilizing Exogenous Coagulation Factors and Costimulation Blockade

Since the first attempt of pig‐to‐primate liver xenotransplantation (LXT) in 1968, survival has been limited. We evaluated a model utilizing α‐1,3‐galactosyltransferase knockout donors, continuous posttransplant infusion of human prothrombin concentrate complex, and immunosuppression including anti–thymocyte globulin, FK‐506, methylprednisone, and costimulation blockade (belatacept, n = 3 or anti‐CD40 mAb, n = 1) to extend survival. Baboon 1 remained well until postoperative day (POD) 25, when euthanasia was required because of cholestasis and plantar ulcers. Baboon 2 was euthanized following a seizure on POD 5, despite normal liver function tests (LFTs) and no apparent pathology. Baboon 3 demonstrated initial stable liver function but was euthanized on POD 8 because of worsening LFTs. Pathology revealed C4d positivity, extensive hemorrhagic necrosis, and a focal cytomegalovirus inclusion. Baboon 4 was clinically well with stable LFTs until POD29, when euthanasia was again necessitated by plantar ulcerations and rising LFTs. Final pathology was C4d negative and without evidence of rejection, inflammation, or thrombotic microangiopathy. Thus, nearly 1‐mo rejection‐free survival has been achieved following LXT in two of four consecutive recipients, demonstrating that the porcine liver can support life in primates for several weeks and has encouraging potential for clinical application as a bridge to allotransplantation for patients with acute‐on‐chronic or fulminant hepatic failure.     

Preclinical Efficacy and Immunological Safety of FR104, an Antagonist Anti‐CD28 Monovalent Fab′ Antibody

Antagonist anti‐CD28 antibodies prevent T cell costimulation and differentiate from CTLA4Ig since they cannot block CTLA‐4 and PDL‐1 coinhibitory signals. They demonstrated efficacy in suppressing effector T cells while enhancing regulatory T cells function and immune tolerance. However, anti‐CD28 antibodies devoid of immunotoxicity and with a good pharmacokinetic profile have not yet been developed. Here, we describe FR104, a novel humanized pegylated anti‐CD28 Fab′ antibody fragment presenting a long elimination half‐life in monkeys. In vitro, FR104 failed to induce human T cell proliferation and cytokines secretion, even in the presence of anti‐CD3 antibodies or when cross‐linked with secondary antibodies. Furthermore, in humanized NOD/SCID mice adoptively transferred with human PBMC, whereas superagonist and divalent antibodies elicited rapid cytokines secretion and human T cell activation, FR104 did not. These humanized mice developed a florid graft‐versus‐host disease, which was prevented by administration of FR104 in a CTLA4‐dependent manner. Interestingly, administration of high doses of CTLA4‐Ig was ineffective to prevent GVHD, whereas administration of low doses was partially effective. In conclusion, we demonstrated that FR104 is devoid of agonist activity on human T cells and thus compatible with a clinical development that might lead to higher therapeutic indexes, by sparing CTLA‐4, as compared to CD80/CD86 antagonists.     

Pathogen Stimulation History Impacts Donor‐Specific CD8+ T Cell Susceptibility to Costimulation/Integrin Blockade–Based Therapy

Recent studies have shown that the quantity of donor‐reactive memory T cells is an important factor in determining the relative heterologous immunity barrier posed during transplantation. Here, we hypothesized that the quality of T cell memory also potently influences the response to costimulation blockade‐based immunosuppression. Using a murine skin graft model of CD8⁺ memory T cell–mediated costimulation blockade resistance, we elicited donor‐reactive memory T cells using three distinct types of pathogen infections. Strikingly, we observed differential efficacy of a costimulation and integrin blockade regimen based on the type of pathogen used to elicit the donor‐reactive memory T cell response. Intriguingly, the most immunosuppression‐sensitive memory T cell populations were composed primarily of central memory cells that possessed greater recall potential, exhibited a less differentiated phenotype, and contained more multi‐cytokine producers. These data, therefore, demonstrate that the memory T cell barrier is dependent on the specific type of pathogen infection via which the donor‐reactive memory T cells are elicited, and suggest that the immune stimulation history of a given transplant patient may profoundly influence the relative barrier posed by heterologous immunity during transplantation.     

Interleukin‐7 receptor blockade by an anti‐CD127 monoclonal antibody in nonhuman primate kidney transplantation

IL‐7 is an important cytokine for T cell lymphopoiesis. Blockade of the IL‐7 signaling pathway has been shown to induce long‐term graft survival or graft tolerance in murine transplant models through inhibiting T cell homeostasis and favoring immunoregulation. In this study, we assessed for the first time the effects of a blocking anti‐human cluster of differentiation 127 (CD127) mAb administered in combination with low‐dose tacrolimus or thymoglobulin in a life‐sustaining kidney allograft model in baboons. Contrary to our expectation, the addition of an anti‐CD127 mAb to the treatment protocols did not prolong graft survival compared to low‐dose tacrolimus alone or thymoglobulin alone. Anti‐CD127 mAb administration led to full CD127 receptor occupancy during the follow‐up period. However, all treated animals lost their kidney graft between 1 week and 2 weeks after transplantation. Unlike in rodents, in nonhuman primates, anti‐CD127 mAb treatment does not decrease the absolute numbers of lymphocyte and lymphocyte subsets and does not effectively inhibit postdepletional T cell proliferation and homeostasis, suggesting that IL‐7 is not a limiting factor for T cell homeostasis in primates.