Massively parallel sequencing of 17 commonly used forensic autosomal STRs and amelogenin with small amplicons

The next-generation sequencing (NGS) method has been utilized to analyze short tandem repeat (STR) markers, which are routinely used for human identification purposes in the forensic field. Some researchers have demonstrated the successful application of the NGS system to STR typing, suggesting that NGS technology may be an alternative or additional method to overcome limitations of capillary electrophoresis (CE)-based STR profiling. However, there has been no available multiplex PCR system that is optimized for NGS analysis of forensic STR markers. Thus, we constructed a multiplex PCR system for the NGS analysis of 18 markers (13CODIS STRs, D2S1338, D19S433, Penta D, Penta E and amelogenin) by designing amplicons in the size range of 77–210 base pairs. Then, PCR products were generated from two single-sources, mixed samples and artificially degraded DNA samples using a multiplex PCR system, and were prepared for sequencing on the MiSeq system through construction of a subsequent barcoded library. By performing NGS and analyzing the data, we confirmed that the resultant STR genotypes were consistent with those of CE-based typing. Moreover, sequence variations were detected in targeted STR regions. Through the use of small-sized amplicons, the developed multiplex PCR system enables researchers to obtain successful STR profiles even from artificially degraded DNA as well as STR loci which are analyzed with large-sized amplicons in the CE-based commercial kits. In addition, successful profiles can be obtained from mixtures up to a 1:19 ratio. Consequently, the developed multiplex PCR system, which produces small size amplicons, can be successfully applied to STR NGS analysis of forensic casework samples such as mixtures and degraded DNA samples.     

Screening for single nucleotide polymorphisms in highly degraded DNA by using the amplified fragment length polymorphism technique

Short tandem repeat (STR) analysis is generally used for human identification of forensic samples; however, standard STR analysis sometimes fails to generate full profiles since DNA is frequently degraded by various environmental factors. Recently, single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) analysis has attracted attention for human identification since the shorter amplicons are better suited for degraded samples. Though various SNP loci are used for analysis of degraded samples, it is unclear which ones are more appropriate. To identify SNPs that were resistant to degradation, we artificially degraded DNA obtained from the buccal swabs of six volunteers and the K562 cell line by heat treatment. Subsequently, the amplified fragment length polymorphism (AFLP) technique was used for SNP screening. We focused on the AFLP bands detected in both the heat-treated and untreated samples, and DNA extracted from these bands was directly sequenced. DNA degradation increased as the duration of heat treatment increased, and no STR profiles could be generated after 6 h of heat treatment. When the AFLP band patterns were compared between 6 h heat-treated and untreated samples, eight common bands were detected. The sequences of the DNA fragments of these common bands had higher adenine-thymine (A-T) content and included 17 SNPs. The SNPs detected in the heat-treated and untreated samples were considered to be resistant to degradation. Although there was a little information available in databases regarding the nine SNPs identified in this study, this study shows that some of these SNPs might be useful for human identification of extremely degraded DNA.     

Investigation of single nucleotide polymorphism loci susceptible to degradation by ultraviolet light

DNA in biological fluids is often degraded by environmental factors. Given that single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) analyses require shorter amplicons than short tandem repeat (STR) analyses do, their use in human identification using degraded samples has recently attracted attention. Although various SNP loci are used to analyze degraded samples, it is unclear which ones are more appropriate. To characterize and identify SNP loci that are susceptible or resistant to degradation, we artificially degraded DNA, obtained from buccal swabs from 11 volunteers, by exposure to ultraviolet (UV) light for different durations (254 nm for 5, 15, 30, 60, or 120 min) and analyzed the resulting SNP loci. DNA degradation was assessed using gel electrophoresis, STR, and SNP profiling. DNA fragmentation occurred within 5 min of UV irradiation, and successful STR and SNP profiling decreased with increasing duration. However, 73% of SNP loci were still detected correctly in DNA samples irradiated for 120 min, a dose that rendered STR loci undetectable. The unsuccessful SNP typing and the base call failure of nucleotides neighboring the SNPs were traced to rs1031825, and we found that this SNP was susceptible to UV light. When comparing the detection efficiencies of STR and SNP loci, SNP typing was more successful than STR typing, making it effective when using degraded DNA. However, it is important to use rs1031825 with caution when interpreting SNP analyses of degraded DNA.     

Estimation of the detection rate in STR analysis by determining the DNA degradation ratio using quantitative PCR

Performing short tandem repeat (STR) analysis from degraded DNA is a challenge for forensic biologists. For assessing the quality and quantity of DNA, we developed quantitative PCR assays to determine the extent of DNA degradation. Quantitative PCR assays using primers that generate two sizes of amplicons from the same region of genomic DNA were used to determine the extent of DNA degradation. These quantitative PCR assays were used with artificially degraded DNA and degraded DNA extracted from aged bloodstains. Increased DNA degradation correlated with a decrease in the number of detectable loci in STR analysis. The extent of DNA degradation and the number of loci detected by STR analysis varied depending on the method of degradation. The extent of degradation of DNA extracted from aged bloodstains correlated well with that of DNA artificially degraded by DNase I in the presence of Mn²⁺. Thus, determination of the extent of DNA degradation was helpful for estimating the number of detectable loci. Furthermore, this estimation method is expected to save time and labor, and is particularly suitable when only a limited amount of DNA can be extracted from casework samples.     

Differences of PCR efficiency between two-step PCR and standard three-step PCR protocols in short tandem repeat amplification

The effects on STR typing results, using a two-step PCR protocol that combines the annealing and extension steps, were determined using samples at various DNA concentrations. DNA samples ranging from 62.5 to 500 pg were amplified using the reagents contained within the AmpFlSTR Identifiler PCR Amplification Kit. At 250–500 pg of DNA template, the rates of detecting alleles were close to those found when using three-step PCR (the standard Identifiler protocol) and two-step PCR protocols. The two-step PCR increased by 8.1% and 64.2% the average number of amplified alleles compared with the three-step PCR at 125 pg and 62.5 pg of template DNA, respectively. At 62.5–500 pg of DNA, the average peak heights were 23.3–65.0% higher than heights using the three-step PCR protocol. When two different PCR protocols were applied to old bones, the average number of amplified loci was similar. These results suggested that the two-step PCR protocol can generate more STR alleles in low template DNA samples; however, the method may be limited with samples of very low-quality, i.e., degraded DNA, compared with the three-step protocol. A better understanding of the effects of the two-step PCR protocol on amplification conditions might help researchers improve STR typing.     

Assessing PreCR™ repair enzymes for restoration of STR profiles from artificially degraded DNA for human identification

Forensic scientists have used several approaches to obtain short tandem repeat (STR) profiles from compromised DNA samples, including supplementing the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) with enhancers and using procedures yielding reduced-length amplicons. For degraded DNA, the peak intensities of the alleles separated by electrophoresis generally decrease as the length of the allele increases. When the intensities of the alleles decrease below an established threshold, they are described as drop-outs, thus contributing to a partial STR profile. This work assesses the use of repair enzymes to improve the STR profiles from artificially degraded DNA. The commercial PreCR™ repair kit of DNA repair enzymes was tested on both purified DNA and native DNA in body fluids exposed to oxidizing agents, hydrolytic conditions, ultraviolet (UV) and ionizing radiation, and desiccation. The strategy was to restrict the level of DNA damage to that which yields partial STR profiles in order to test for allele restoration as opposed to simple allele enhancement. Two protocols were investigated for allele restoration: a sequential protocol using the manufacturer's repair procedure and a modified protocol reportedly designed for optimal STR analysis of forensic samples. Allele restoration was obtained with both protocols, but the peak height appeared to be higher for the modified protocol (determined by Mann–Kendall Trend Test). The success of the approach using the PreCR™ repair enzymes was sporadic; it led to allele restoration as well as allele drop-out. Additionally, allele restoration with the PreCR™ enzymes was compared with restoration by alternative, but commonly implemented approaches using Restorase™, PCRBoost™, bovine serum albumin (BSA) and the Minifiler™ STR system. The alternative methods were also successful in improving the STR profile, but their success also depended on the quality of the template encountered. Our results indicate the PreCR™ repair kit may be useful for restoring STR profiles from damaged DNA, but further work is required to develop a generalized approach.     

Direct comparison of post-28-cycle PCR purification and modified capillary electrophoresis methods with the 34-cycle “low copy number” (LCN) method for analysis of trace forensic DNA samples

The investigation of samples with low amounts of template DNA remains at the forefront of forensic DNA research and technology as it becomes increasingly important to gain DNA profile information from exceedingly trace levels of DNA. Previous studies have demonstrated that it is possible to obtain short tandem repeat (STR) profiles from <100 pg of template DNA by increasing the number of amplification cycles from 28 to 34, a modification often referred to as “low copy number” or LCN analysis. In this study, we have optimised post-PCR purification techniques applied after only 28 cycles of PCR, as well as using modified capillary electrophoresis injection conditions and have investigated the progressive application of these enhanced approaches. This paper reviews the characteristics of the profiles obtained by these methods compared with those obtained on the same samples after 34-cycle PCR. We observed comparable sensitivity to 34-cycle PCR in terms of the number of profiles with evidence of DNA and the number of allelic peaks per profile and we noted improved peak height and area magnitude with some sample types. Certain parameters reported to be adversely affected in 34-cycle LCN investigations, such as non-donor allele peaks and increased stutter peak ratio, were reduced by this approach. There are a number of advantages for trace samples in progressing from the standard 28-cycle process to the post-PCR processing method as compared to 34-cycle PCR method, including reduced sample consumption, reduced number of PCR amplifications required, and a staged approach to sample processing and profile interpretation.     

Development of multiplex assay with 16 SNPs on X chromosome for degraded samples

We selected 16 new X chromosomal SNPs (rs4827155, rs471205, rs7884160, rs16982419, rs985251, rs3813932, rs6630351, rs4132871, rs5966270, rs7471388, rs6641116, rs6521038, rs5990560, rs5959408, rs414960, and rs3006142) and developed the two X chromosomal SNPs Octaplex systems using multiplex single base extension reactions. To make the systems more useful for analyzing degraded DNA samples, we designed primers to render amplicons of 100 bp or shorter (shorter PCR products). Statistical analyses of the 16 SNPs indicated a high usefulness for the Japanese forensic practice. In addition, results of tests on degraded DNA confirm the usefulness of this technique in such samples.     

Developmental validation of Mini-DogFiler for degraded canine DNA

Dogs (Canis lupus familiaris) are kept as pets in 39% of American households and are, therefore, a significant source of potentially probative biological evidence. As with any biological evidence, degradation can occur as a consequence of environmental exposure causing fracturing of the DNA and a resulting loss of intact template. Degraded human DNA analysis has benefited from the application of primer sets that amplify shorter nuclear sequences for core STR loci (miniSTRs), resulting in improved DNA profiles. This same approach was applied to our core canine STR loci. The 16-locus “DogFiler” panel was redesigned into three panels of miniSTRs for analysis of degraded canine DNA, with all primer pairs producing amplicons below 205 base pairs in length. These new miniSTR marker panels – known as Mini-DogFiler – were validated according to SWGDAM guidelines, and concordance with the original 16-locus multiplex was demonstrated through genotyping 1244 samples. The combination of these miniSTRs and a half-volume reaction increased the amplification success of degraded and low copy number canine biological samples resulting in a near three-fold increase in reportable alleles. This assemblage of miniSTRs along with the DogFiler panel and associated allelic ladder are the first non-human DNA profiling system to parallel the human forensic paradigm.     

Quantifiler® Trio Kit and forensic samples management: A matter of degradation

DNA collected from crime scenes may have experienced different levels of degradation. This is mainly due to sample exposure to different environmental factors. The impact of DNA degradation on short tandem repeat (STR) profiling can lead to partial or null information and in some cases, the identification of the trace may fail. The availability of a system enabling the assessment not only of the quantity of the DNA but also of its quality in terms of degradation would result in shorter time for sample processing, more reliable identifications and cost reduction by predicting the quality of the DNA profiles prior to STR analysis. We report here a study on 181 selected degraded DNA samples extracted from real crime scene evidence. The selected samples were processed by combining the use of a new commercial quantification kit (Quantifiler^® Trio) with a new 24 marker multiplex PCR amplification kit (Globalfiler^® Kit). Applying different statistical analyses we investigated the reliability of the Degradation Index provided by the Quantifiler^® Trio in determining the level of DNA degradation in a forensic sample. This useful information can be used to predict the quality of the profile obtained after STR amplification. The combination of such a quantification kit with different PCR protocols allowed us to define practical guidelines for processing degraded forensic DNA samples with a simplified and comprehensive approach.     

STRs, mini STRs and SNPs--a comparative study for typing degraded DNA

Short tandem repeat (STR) systems are the most powerful and widely used genetic marker systems in forensic DNA typing. Optimized amplification conditions and PCR reagents in combination with laser fluorescence based detection methods have increased the sensitivity and decreased the detection threshold down to approximately 100 pg. The quality of human DNA from forensic samples can be influenced by environmental factors. These may cause different degrees of degradation which have a negative impact on the amplification process especially of STR systems with large amplicons. Therefore, methods which need only small amplicon sizes to detect DNA markers are a better choice for typing degraded DNA. Here we report investigations on different types of DNA markers and typing methods which should all be applicable for analysing degraded DNA. These are two commercially available mini STR kits and five SNP markers which were analysed with two self established assays, a 5' nuclease assay and a minisequencing (SNaPshot) assay. The investigations comprised sensitivity studies, different types of stain material, as well as intact and degraded DNA. Results indicate that mini STRs are superior to standard STR typing methods, especially for typing old stain material with small amounts of degraded DNA. SNP typing based on the minisequencing (SNaPshot) assay achieved a better success rate in typing aged blood and saliva stains compared to standard STRs and SNP typing using the 5' nuclease assay.     

Reliable genotyping of short tandem repeat loci without an allelic ladder using time-of-flight mass spectrometry

DNA separations which traditionally have been performed by slab gel or capillary electrophoresis, may now be conducted via time-of-flight mass spectrometry (TOF-MS). The advantages of using a mass spectrometry approach for short tandem repeat (STR) characterization include a dramatic increase in both the speed of analysis and the accuracy of mass measurements. We report here typing of the STR loci TH01, TPOX, and CSF1PO as well as the sex-typing marker amelogenin using TOF-MS. Allelic ladders, which are typically used with electrophoretic separation systems to correct for mobility differences of DNA fragments under various conditions, are not needed for accurate genotyping with TOF-MS. A mass precision of 0.1% RSD, which corresponds to approximately 0.1 nucleotide, was routinely observed. Mass accuracies were better than a fraction of a single nucleotide when a daily mass calibration was used. STR microvariants, such as the TH01 allele 9.3, could be detected and resolved from alleles which differ by as little as a single base. In addition, the smaller PCR product sizes (55– 125 bp) examined in this study have the potential advantage of being more successful when amplifying forensic samples with degraded DNA. Received: 16 January 1998 / Received in revised form: 17 March 1998     

Performance of a next generation sequencing SNP assay on degraded DNA

Forensic DNA casework samples are often of insufficient quantity or quality to generate full profiles by conventional DNA typing methods. Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) amplification of short tandem repeat (STR) loci is inherently limited in samples containing degraded DNA, as the cumulative size of repeat regions, primer binding regions, and flanking sequence is necessarily larger than the PCR template. Additionally, traditional capillary electrophoresis (CE) assay design further inherently limits shortening amplicons because the markers must be separated by size. Non-traditional markers, such as single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) and insertion deletion polymorphisms (InDels), may yield more information from challenging samples due to their smaller amplicon size. In this study, the performance of a next generation sequencing (NGS) SNP assay and CE-based STR, mini-STR, and InDel assays was evaluated with a series of fragmented, size-selected samples. Information obtained from the NGS SNP assay exhibited higher overall inverse random match probability (1/RMP) values compared to the CE-based typing assays, with particular benefit for fragment sizes ≤150 base pairs (bp). The InDel, mini-STR, and NGS SNP assays all had similar percentages of loci with reportable alleles at this level of degradation; however, the relatively fewer number of loci in the InDel and mini-STR assays results in the NGS SNP assay having at least nine orders of magnitude higher 1/RMP values. In addition, the NGS SNP assay and three CE-based assays (two STR and one InDel assay) were tested using a dilution series consisting of 0.5 ng, 0.1 ng, and 0.05 ng non-degraded DNA. All tested assays showed similar percentages of loci with reportable alleles at these levels of input DNA; however, due to the larger number of loci, the NGS SNP assay and the larger of the two tested CE-based STR assays both resulted in considerably higher 1/RMP values than the other assays. These results indicate the potential advantage of NGS SNP assays for forensic analysis of degraded DNA samples.     

Development of a SNP set for human identification: A set with high powers of discrimination which yields high genetic information from naturally degraded DNA samples in the Thai population

This study describes the development of a SNP typing system for human identification in the Thai population, in particular for extremely degraded DNA samples. A highly informative SNP marker set for forensic identification was identified, and a multiplex PCR-based Invader assay was developed. Fifty-one highly informative autosomal SNP markers and three sex determination SNP markers were amplified in two multiplex PCR reactions and then detected using Invader assay reactions. The average PCR product size was 71 base pairs. The match probability of the 54-SNP marker set in 124 Thai individuals was 1.48 × 10⁻²¹, higher than that of STR typing, suggesting that this 54-SNP marker set is beneficial for forensic identification in the Thai population. The selected SNP marker set was also evaluated in 90 artificially degraded samples, and in 128 naturally degraded DNA samples from real forensic casework which had shown no profiles or incomplete profiles when examined using a commercial STR typing system. A total of 56 degraded samples (44%) achieved the matching probability (PM) equivalent to STR gold standard analysis (successful genotyping of 44 SNP markers) for human identification. These data indicated that our novel 54-SNP marker set provides a very useful and valuable approach for forensic identification in the Thai population, especially in the case of highly to extremely degraded DNA.In summary, we have developed a set of 54 Thai-specific SNPs for human identification which have higher discrimination power than STR genotyping. The PCRs for these 54 SNP markers were successfully combined into two multiplex reactions and detected with an Invader assay. This novel SNP genotyping system also yields high levels of genetic information from naturally degraded samples, even though there are much more difficult to recover than artificially degraded samples.     

Evaluation of new primers for CSF1PO

We describe new primers for the detection of the STR polymorphism at the CSF1PO locus. These primers have been designed to produce shorter amplicons (150–182 bp) than the primers in standard use (295–327 bp). The reliability of the new primers for CSF1PO typing has been demonstrated by testing on known samples and by sequence analysis. These primers are superior to the original primers with regard to electrophoretic resolution and utility for typing of severely degraded DNA.     

Less is more – length reduction of STR amplicons using redesigned primers

PCR primers closely flanking the repeat region were redesigned to reduce the amplicon length of the selected STRs down to approximately 100 bp for the shorter alleles (loci HumTH01, D10S2325, DYS19 and DYS391). Highly degraded DNA (e.g. formalin-fixed tissue) and very low amounts of DNA could be more successfully typed using the new redesigned primers compared to the established sequences generating longer amplicons. Received: 6 January 2000 / Accepted: 26 April 2000     

Comparison of DNA extraction methods for identification of human remains

After mass disasters, where the bodies of victims have been degraded, soft tissues are often completely lost, with the result that bones and teeth are all that remain for identification. The aim of this study was to investigate three DNA extraction methods that are currently used with degraded bones in forensic contexts: a silica-based extraction protocol used by the International Commission for Missing Persons (ICMP), a total demineralisation method used by the US Armed Forces DNA Identification Laboratory (AFDIL) and a standard organic DNA extraction method used by the Australian Federal Police (AFP). The methods were compared by real-time PCR quantitation and STR profiling. The silica and organic methods were not significantly different for either of these measures for bone but were both significantly more successful than the demineralisation method. Bovine serum albumin (BSA) was found to significantly improve the DNA yields from real-time PCR and the number of reportable alleles from STR typing, especially when using bone samples.     

Investigations into improving the standard DNA testing of trace samples at ESR

ABSTRACT

Since 2007, the Institute of Environmental and Science Research (ESR) has been using the AmpF/STR Identifiler profiling kit as the standard DNA test. Whilst this approach works well for most samples with a DNA input range of 400 pg to 2 ng, samples containing less DNA often have limited to no profiling success. If required, such samples can undergo testing using a more sensitive technique, such as mini-STR analysis or Low Copy Number (LCN) DNA analysis. The introduction of a more sensitive standard DNA test into the laboratory would likely prove to be greatly beneficial. Profiling success should increase, particularly for samples containing trace DNA concentrations, and the number of samples requiring rework and further analysis using an ultra-sensitive technique would potentially reduce. A number of new generation multiplex kits with increased sensitivity are now commercially available. One such kit is the AmpF/STR Identifiler Plus profiling kit, which has enhanced buffer formulation and an optimized PCR cycling protocol. This study investigates the profiling results from trace DNA samples using Identifiler at 28 cycles and Identifiler Plus, at 28 and 29 cycles, analysed using the 3500xL Applied BioSystems Genetic Analyzer. Any further benefits from including a post-PCR clean-up step and enhanced capillary electrophoresis conditions are investigated and discussed.     

Developmental validation of the PowerPlex® ESX 16 and PowerPlex® ESX 17 Systems

We describe the developmental validation study performed on the PowerPlex(?) ESX 16 (European Standard Extended 16) and the PowerPlex(?) ESX 17 Systems, part of a suite of four new DNA profiling kits developed by Promega in response to the ENFSI and EDNAP groups' call for new STR multiplexes for Europe. The PowerPlex(?) ESX 16 System combines the 11 loci compatible with the UK National DNA Database, contained within the AmpFlSTR(?) SGM Plus(?) PCR Amplification Kit, with five additional loci: D2S441, D10S1248, D22S1045, D1S1656 and D12S391. The multiplex was designed to incorporate these five new loci as mini- and midi-STRs while maintaining the loci found in the AmpFlSTR(?) SGM Plus(?) kit as standard size. The PowerPlex(?) ESX 17 System amplifies the same loci as the PowerPlex(?) ESX 16 System, but with the addition of a primer pair for the SE33 locus. Tests were designed to address the developmental validation guidelines issued by the Scientific Working Group on DNA Analysis Methods (SWGDAM), and those of the DNA Advisory Board (DAB). Samples processed include DNA mixtures, PCR reactions spiked with inhibitors, a sensitivity series, and 306 United Kingdom donor samples to determine concordance with data generated with the AmpFlSTR(?) SGM Plus(?) kit. Allele frequencies from 242 white Caucasian samples collected in the United Kingdom are also presented. The PowerPlex(?) ESX 16 and ESX 17 Systems are robust and sensitive tools, suitable for the analysis of forensic DNA samples. Full profiles were routinely observed with 62.5 pg of a fully heterozygous single source DNA template. In mixture analysis, a range of 52-95% of unique minor contributor alleles was observed at 19:1 mixture ratios where only 25 pg of the minor component was present. Improved sensitivity combined with the robustness afforded by smaller amplicons has substantially improved the quantity of information obtained from degraded samples, and the improved chemistry confers exceptional tolerance to high levels of laboratory prepared inhibitors.     

Mini-STRs

The use of the short-tandem repeat (STR) as the DNA marker of choice in forensic profiling has lead to the construction of criminal intelligence databases that now contain millions of profiles used in the detection and linking of suspects and scenes. The incredible size and success rate of current systems have ensured that efforts to move away from STR profiling and toward the use of alternate DNA markers are practically impossible, mainly because of the financial implications involved in such a move. Problems are routinely encountered when template DNA is of suboptimal condition, as is commonly the case in the forensic laboratory, whereby full profile generation of degraded samples is not possible. A redesigned amplification protocol that results in the generation of shorter polymerase chain reaction products yet is fully compatible with current STR databases has been introduced: the MiniPlex.