Comparison between the safety profile and clinical results of the Cook detachable and Gianturco coils for transcatheter closure of patent ductus arteriosus in 272 patients

OBJECTIVES: We evaluated the occlusion rate and safety of Cook detachable coils versus Gianturco coils in transcatheter closure of patent ductus arteriosus (PDA). BACKGROUND: The Cook detachable coil recently was introduced in an attempt to improve the safety of transcatheter closure of PDA. METHODS: Between January 1994 and September 1998, 272 patients underwent transcatheter PDA closure. Cook detachable coils were used in 137 patients, with a mean age of 43.9 months and weight of 13.8 kg. In 135 patients, Gianturco coils were used, with a mean age of 56.8 months and weight of 17.8 kg. The mean narrowest diameter of the PDA in the Cook detachable coil group was 2.85 mm versus 2.32 mm for the Gianturco coil group. RESULTS: The Cook detachable coil group was younger and weighed less than the Gianturco group (P < 0.05 and 0.02, respectively). Their narrowest PDA diameter was larger (P < 0.01). Embolization rate was significantly lower in the Cook coil group (9[6.5%] of 137 vs 22 (16.3%) of 135; P = < 0.013). The mean follow-up for the Cook coil group was significantly shorter (0.55 years) than for the Gianturco coil group (1.18 years; P < 0.001). On an intention-to-treat basis, complete occlusion by echocardiography was achieved in 99 (72.3%) of 137 patients in the Cook detachable coil group, which was significantly less than the Gianturco coil group (114 [84.4%] of 135; P = 0.008). CONCLUSION: Cook detachable coils for transcatheter closures of the PDA are safer than Gianturco coils. Hence, children with large ductal can be treated earlier in life. Short-term complete occlusion rate was lower in the Cook detachable coil group. This rate can be explained by a shorter follow-up time, larger ductal diameter, and the different materials used for the detachable coils.     

Safety and efficacy of using 0.052-inch Gianturco coil for closure of large ( > or = 4mm) patent ductus arteriosus

Transcatheter closure of patent ductus arteriosus (PDA) is now a well-established treatment alternative to surgery in many cardiology centers. Of all the methods used, transcatheter coil occlusion is the preferred therapy. For small PDA, the method using 0.038" Gianturco coils has proven safe and effective. However, this therapeutic strategy has encountered some difficulties with large PDA. This study provides an alternative strategy, using 0.052" Gianturco coil and complete closure of residual shunt with multiple coils to close large PDA. Fifteen patients underwent transcatheter coil occlusion of large ( > or = 4mm) patent ductus arteriosus. The intermediate success rate was 86.7%. There were four complications and only two patients had to be referred for surgery.     

应用Cook可控弹簧栓子封堵动脉导管未闭

目的 :应用 Cook可控弹簧栓子封堵动脉导管未闭 （PDA）并对其疗效进行评价。方法 :全组共 10例 ,年龄 2～ 35 （平均 11.6 ）岁 ,体重 8～ 6 4（平均 30 .6 ） kg,PDA最窄处直径 1.4～ 3.2 （平均 2 .6 ） m m。经导管置入 Cook可控弹簧栓子封堵 PDA。封堵后 10 min行胸主动脉造影评价疗效。术后 3天、1月、6月及 12月行超声心动图检查观察有无残余分流及 PDA再通。结果 :全组技术成功率为 10 0 % ,术后 10 m in胸主动脉造影及术后 3d超声心动图未见残余分流。随访 12个月 ,均未发现 PDA再通及弹簧栓子移位。结论 :应用 Cook可控弹簧栓子封堵小型 PDA是一种安全、有效的非手术方法     

Transcatheter coil embolization of large-size patent ductus arteriosus in adult patients: usefulness and problems

Transcatheter coil embolization of the patent ductus arteriosus (PDA) has been frequently used in children, especially for small lesions. It was attempted in 3 adults using Cook detachable coils. For 2 of the patients, relatively old age and heart failure were the reasons for choosing coil embolization of the PDA. In the remaining patient, who had Wolff-Parkinson-White syndrome, coil embolization was performed after radiofrequency catheter ablation of Kent's bundle. Their respective minimal PDA diameters were 5.0 mm, 4.5 mm and 4.0 mm measured by transesophageal echocardiography. Two coils were placed in 2 patients and 1 coil in the remaining patient. After the procedures, the size of the left ventricle decreased and heart failure was improved in 2 patients, although all 3 patients had a residual shunt, which caused hemolytic anemia in 2 patients. Repeat coil-embolization procedures resulted in complete occlusion and the hemolysis disappeared in these patients. In adult patients who have heart failure due to large PDA, coil embolization with detachable coils, even if residual shunt persists, is useful for improvement of the heart failure. In cases of hemolysis related to residual shunt, a second coil-embolization procedure can improve it completely.     

Simultaneous double or triple coil technique for closure of moderate sized (> or = 3.0 mm) patent ductus arteriosus

One important complication of coil occlusion of patent ductus arteriosus using the conventional Gianturco coil is migration of coils into peripheral vessels. Especially in patients having relatively larger size ductus, the risk for such complication could be increased. In this regard, a detachable coil may have some technical benefits in performing coil occlusion and reducing the incidence of complications such as migration of coil. Based on our clinical experiences, we describe the clinical efficacy of a simultaneous double or triple coil occlusion technique using the Cook detachable coil system to close the ductus arteriosus, especially in patients whose ductus diameter more than 3.0 mm.     

Transcatheter closure of persistent arterial ducts with different types of coils

BACKGROUND: Different types of coils have been designed for transcatheter closure of persistent arterial ducts. We compared the efficacy and safety of three types of coils: Gianturco coils (Cook), Cook detachable coils (Cook), and Duct Occlud devices (pfm). METHODS: Sixty-three patients underwent coil occlusion of arterial ducts between April 1995 and July 2000. The mean age and weight were 4.8+/-3.4 years and 16.5+/-7.6 kg, respectively. The results and complications of ductal occlusion among the three types of coils were compared. Kaplan-Meier analysis was used to assess reduction in the prevalence of residual shunt with time, and multiple regression analysis was performed to identify predictors of complete occlusion. RESULTS: Coil occlusion of persistent arterial ducts that measured 2. 2 +/- 0.8 mm was feasible in 90% (57/63) of patients. Gianturco coils were used in 29, Duct Occlud devices in 16, and Cook detachable coils in 12 patients. The prevalence of residual shunt at 24 hours, 6 months, 12 months, and 24 months was 42%, 20%, 18%, and 14%, respectively. The reduction in prevalence of residual shunt with time tended to be greater when Gianturco coils were used (P =. 067). Logistic regression identified the use of Gianturco coils to be a significant predictor of complete ductal occlusion on follow-up (P =.04). Pull-through of coils occurred in 4.8% (3/63) and coil embolization in 6.3% (4/63). There was no association between the type of coil and the risk of embolization (P = 1.00). CONCLUSIONS: Transcatheter occlusion of small persistent arterial ducts with coils is safe and effective. There is no advantage of detachable coils (Cook detachable coils and Duct Occlud devices) over nondetachable Gianturco coils in reducing the risk of embolization. Our findings are in favor of the inexpensive, but more effective, Gianturco coils for occluding small arterial ducts of 3 mm or less.     

Retrograde transcatheter occlusion of patent ductus arteriosus: preliminary experience in Gianturco coil technique without heparinization

BACKGROUND: The aim of this study was to report the initial experience of using the Gianturco coil (Cook Cardiology, Bloomington, Indiana) without heparinization to close patent ductus arteriosus (PDA). PATIENTS AND METHODS: Forty consecutive patients (30 females, 10 males) underwent transcatheter closure of a PDA via the right femoral artery approach without heparinization. Patients ages ranged from 7 months to 55 years (median, 6.8 years); weights ranged from 7.8 65 kg (median, 18.3 kg). Twenty-one patients had cardiomegaly (n = 21), congestive heart failure (n = 10), or both (n = 10). The PDAs measured 0.8 4.5 mm (median, 2.6 mm) at the narrowest diameter; the mean Qp/Qs ranged from 1.0 2.6 (1.4 +/- 0.4). The helical diameter of the coil that we chose was 1.7 times the narrowest PDA diameter. The length of the coil was sufficient to produce 4 or 5 loops. RESULTS: Successful coil placement was accomplished in all 40 patients. Thirty-five patients (87.5%) underwent single coil implantation, 2 patients (5%) had 2 coils, and 3 patients (7.5%) had 3 coils. Complete ductus occlusion was achieved in 80% of cases at the end of the procedure, while 8 patients had minimal shunt detected by aortography or echocardiography. The occlusion rate increased to 87.5% by the next day, 90% by 1 month, 92.5% by 3 months, 95% by 6 months, and 97.5% by 9 and 12 months. Only one asymptomatic patient had minimal residual shunt detected by color Doppler at 12 months follow-up. At a median follow-up of 17 months (range, 5 25 months), no patient had thromboembolism, endocarditis, coil migration, diminished femoral pulse or hemolysis. CONCLUSION: Our preliminary results suggest that retrograde transcatheter closure of PDA with the Gianturco coil without heparinization is feasible, safe and efficacious. A single coil allowed complete occlusion of PDA 3 mm in diameter.     

Gianturco Coil Occlusion of Patent Ductus Arteriosus

Gianturco coils (Cook Cardiology, Bloomington, IN) are commonly employed to occlude restrictive patent ductus arteriosus. The clinical experience of the 1990s demonstrated efficacy and safety. This article reviews the current status of Gianturco coil occlusion of the patent ductus arteriosus. It covers the design of the available coils, patient selection for the procedure, coil selection and delivery methods, results and complications of occlusion, and financial considerations.     

Transcatheter closure of large patent ductus arteriosus (> or = 4 mm) with multiple Gianturco coils: immediate and mid-term results.

OBJECTIVE: To assess the immediate and mid-term results of transcatheter closure of patent ductus arteriosus (PDA) > or = 4 mm with multiple Gianturco coils. (Transcatheter closure of large PDAs using the Rashkind occluder or the buttoned device is associated with a 7-38% incidence of residual shunt.) METHODS: 19 patients (7 male, 12 female) underwent an attempt at anterograde transcatheter closure with multiple Gianturco coils of a large PDA at a median age of 3.8 yr (range 2 weeks-34 yr) and median weight of 14 kg (range 2.3-80 kg). RESULTS: The median PDA diameter at the narrowest segment was 4.3 mm (range 4-7 mm) and the mean (SD) Qp/Qs was 1.9 (0.8). Each patient had left atrial and left ventricular volume overload. A 4F catheter was used to deliver the coils in all patients. There was immediate and complete closure in 16/18; one patient had residual shunt that was closed at a second procedure and the other had spontaneous disappearance of the residual shunt at the six week visit. A short ductus (angiographic type B) in one patient could not be closed. The median number of coils placed at the first attempt to close the ductus was 4 (range 2-6 coils) and the median fluoroscopy time was 40 minutes (range 13-152 minutes). Mild left pulmonary artery stenosis occurred in the two smallest patients. Coil migration to the lung occurred in 3 patients with retrieval of coils in two patients. All procedures but one were done on an outpatient basis. At a median follow up of 1.6 yr (range 2 weeks-2.2 yr) all patients had complete closure with no new complications. CONCLUSIONS: Anterograde transcatheter closure with multiple Gianturco coils is an effective treatment for most patients with large PDA of diameters up to 7 mm. This technique can be performed in small infants on an outpatient basis without the need for general endotracheal anaesthesia.     

Comparison of two transcatheter device strategies for occlusion of the patent ductus arteriosus

Objectives: The present study evaluates two transcatheter closure strategies utilized at a single center and makes recommendations for device selection when occluding the patent ductus arteriosus. Background: A variety of devices are available for transcatheter closure of the patent ductus arteriosus (PDA) but no guidelines exist to guide operator device choice. Methods: A total of 132 patients underwent attempted transcatheter PDA closure utilizing one of two consecutive closure strategies between January 2000 and June 2005. Strategy A (n = 64; January 2000–May 2003) utilized Gianturco coils only. Strategy B (n = 68; June 2003–June 2005) utilized a single Gianturco coil for the PDA with a minimal diameter ≤1 mm (n = 28) or an Amplatzer Duct Occluder (ADO) if the PDA diameter exceeded 1 mm (n = 40). Success was defined as complete occlusion on a follow up echocardiogram. Results: 58 of 64 (90.6%) patients treated utilizing strategy A had successful coil implantation. 68 of 68 (100%) patients treated utilizing strategy B had successful coil/device implantation. At follow up echocardiography, 32 of 44 (72.7%) strategy A patients had complete ductal closure, as compared with 57 of 58 (98.3%) strategy B patients (P < 0.0001). Stepwise logistic regression analysis identified closure strategy as the most powerful predictor of procedural success (OR = 85.9; CI 5.6–9.99). Conclusions: A transcatheter PDA closure strategy consisting of a single Gianturco coil for PDA ≤ 1 mm or an ADO for larger sized PDA (strategy B) achieves superior outcomes compared to the use of coils alone. © 2008 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

Evaluation of Gianturco Coils for Closure of Large (≥3.5 mm) Patent Ductus Arteriosus

Objectives. This report evaluates the use of Gianturco coils to close large patent ductus arteriosus (PDAs) (≥3.5 mm) and describes transvenous delivery of 0.052-in. (0.132-cm) Gianturco coils.

Background. Coil closure of PDAs has become increasingly popular. However, the technique has significant limitations when used to close large PDAs. This report evaluates patient characteristics, PDA anatomy, hemodynamic variables, delivery technique and coil geometry to determine predictors of success.

Methods. Between January 1995 and January 1997, 16 of 118 patients undergoing catheterization for PDA closure were found to have large PDAs. Their median age and weight were 14 months (range 3 months to 43 years) and 8.5 kg (range 3.5 to 73), respectively. The mean PDA diameter was 4.3 mm (range 3.5 to 5.9). Closure of PDAs was attempted using transcatheter delivery of 0.038-in. (0.096-cm) and 0.052-in. coils. Differences in clinical, anatomic, hemodynamic and technical variables between successes and failures were compared.

Results. Eleven (69%) of 16 patients had successful closure of their PDA. Failures occurred only in patients <8 months of age with an indexed PDA diameter >7 mm/m and a pulmonary/systemic flow ratio ≥2.8:1. Use of 0.052-in. coils tended to reduce the incidence of embolization and the number of coils needed for closure.

Conclusions. Patients >8 months of age can have successful closure of large PDAs with currently available Gianturco coils. The 0.052-in. Gianturco coils can be used safely to close large PDAs in infants as small as 6 kg. Increased experience and improved coil design may improve closure rates of large PDAs in infants.     

Transcatheter coil embolization for patent ductus arteriosus in the elderly: Report of a case and review of the published work

Patent ductus arteriosus is the third most common congenital cardiovascular anomaly, however, it is rarely found in the elderly. We describe a case of patent ductus arteriosus in a 72-year-old woman in whom patent ductus arteriosus was successfully managed by transcatheter coil embolization. The patient had been diagnosed with a heart murmur for the first time 1 year earlier at the age of 71. She was asymptomatic but a continuous murmur was heard. Cardiac catheterization revealed migration of a catheter from the main pulmonary artery into the descending aorta through a patent ductus arteriosus and a significant step-up of oxygen saturation in the main pulmonary artery with a pulmonary-to-systemic flow ratio of 1.68. Aortograms demonstrated a communication between the aorta and the pulmonary artery through a patent ductus arteriosus with a minimal diameter of 3.7 mm. Transcatheter coil embolization of the patent ductus arteriosus was successfully carried out with two 0.052-inch-diameter Gianturco coils. Doppler echocardiographic study confirmed no residual shunt in the main pulmonary artery after the procedure. Non-surgical transcatheter occlusion using coil embolization appears to be an effective and minimally invasive technique for treatment of patent ductus arteriosus in the elderly.     

Severe intravascular hemolysis after transcatheter coil occlusion of patent ductus arteriosus

Severe intravascular hemolysis is a rare complication of transcatheter closure of patent ductus arteriosus (PDA). It is thought to be secondary to red blood cell damage from a high-velocity jet from a residual shunt. However, only a small minority of patients with a residual shunt develop this complication. We report a case of intravascular hemolysis after partial coil occlusion of a PDA in which the Dacron strands were stripped off the coils during bioptome-assisted deployment. The exposure of the blood flow jet to bare metallic coils may have contributed to the occurrence of the severe hemolysis.     

经导管封堵动脉导管未闭介入治疗后残余分流

目的探讨经导管封堵动脉导管未闭(PDA)介入治疗后残余分流的可行性和临床疗效。方法自1997年3月至2001年8月16例PDA介入治疗后残余分流的患者,其中男4例,女12例,平均年龄5.9±2.4岁(2～9岁),平均体重17.7±5.4kg(9～28kg),应用不同介入方法经动脉或静脉途径封堵残余分流,首次介入治疗与再次介入治疗的时间间隔平均为1.5±1.1年(1天～3.5年)。结果残余分流直径平均为2.7±0.9mm(1.2～5.0mm)。15例成功完成残余分流封堵术,1例失败,技术成功率为94%(15/16)。单纯应用Cook可控弹簧圈9例(其中双弹簧圈2例),Rashkind双面伞2例,Sidris纽扣式补片1例,Amplatzer蘑菇伞2例,同时应用Cook可控弹簧圈和Sidris纽扣式补片1例。封堵术后即刻造影,3例仍有少量残余分流,完全闭合率为80%(12/15)。平均手术时间为75.0±22.8min(45～120min),平均X线透视时间为10.4±3.9min(5～20min)。股动脉并发症1例,其余无并发症出现。封堵术后24h复查超声心动图,所有残余分流均完全闭合(100%),在平均2年随访中未出现残余分流再通、封堵器移位和左右肺动脉狭窄。结论经导管封堵PDA介入治疗后残余分流安全、疗效确切、创伤小,可作为外科手术治疗PDA介入治疗后残余分流的一种替代方法。     

A Floating Thrombus After Retrograde Gianturco Coil Embolization of a Patent Ductus Arteriosus in an Adult—Detection by Transesophageal Echocardiography

The occlusion of patent ductus arteriosus (PDA) by Gianturco coils has been performed in a growing number of patients since its introduction at the beginning of this decade. The procedure is considered to be effective and safe. Yet embolization of the coil into the pulmonary artery system and residual shunting are typical complications. In some cases a coil loop may protrude into the aortic or pulmonary artery lumen and thus may result in flow disturbances. We report a case of thrombus formation on an intraaortic coil loop after retrograde embolization of a PDA in an adult.     

Transcatheter occlusion of the patent ductus arteriosus with a single device technique: comparison between the Cook detachable coil and the Rashkind umbrella device

Transcatheter coil occlusion of the patent ductus arteriosus (PDA) has become the interventional treatment option of choice. Immediate occlusion of any residual shunting results in excellent closure rates, but frequently requires multiple coil deployment. Aims: To assess the efficacy and limitations of single Cook detachable coil PDA closure compared to a preceding series of Rashkind umbrella procedures. Methods and results: Between 1990 and 1999, transcatheter occlusion of a small (<2 mm; n=45) or moderate-sized (2-4 mm; n=47) PDA was successfully attempted in 90/92 consecutive patients (mean age 6+/-4.8 years) with a coil (39/41) or Rashkind device (51/51). Immediate angiographic closure rates for both devices were low, although better for small (54-68%) than moderate ducts (7-22%, P<0.01). A 2-year echocardiographic closure rate of small ducts increased to 92% for the coil group versus 95% for the Rashkind group. By that time, moderate-sized ducts were only occluded in 64% with the coil and 54% with the Rashkind device. A visible residual shunt at post-implant angiography in moderate ducts was associated with a high incidence (59%) of long-term echocardiographic shunt patency and a need for repeat interventions for audible residual shunts (32%). Conclusions: Single coil transcatheter occlusion is the treatment of choice for the small duct as most residual shunts will resolve spontaneously. However, long-term shunt persistence after single coil deployment in moderate sized ducts is as frequent as with the Rashkind device. A primary multiple coil approach is advocated if the postcoil aortogram shows residual ductal shunting and if there is persistence of a ductal murmur on auscultation.     

Percutaneous closure of patent ductus arteriosus using special screwing detachable coils

Jackson screwing detachable coils, developed for arterial and venous embolization, have been successfully employed recently for the percutaneous occlusion of patent ductus arteriosus (PDA). Special screwing detachable coils were designed for closure of the PDA, and the experience gained by their use is described in this report. Occlusion was attempted in 29 patients with a minimal ductal diameter of 0.9–4.2 mm. Coils were successfully placed in all 29 patients. One coil, which embolized 10 min after detachment, was retrieved. In 26 patients (89%), complete closure was achieved. Only 35 coils were placed in 29 patients. Residual shunts in three patients are minimal, detectable only on color-flow mapping. Screwing detachable coils for closure of PDA are safe and effective for occlusion of PDA with a minimal diameter <4.2 mm. Embolization of the coil is very rare. A high closure rate is achieved with a low number of placed coils. Cathet. Cardiovasc. Diagn. 41:386–391, 1997. © 1997 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Aortic thrombus after coil occlusion of a type E patent ductus arteriosus

A 5-year-old girl was referred to our institution for closure of a silent patent ductus arteriosus. Cardiac catheterization revealed a tiny-to-small patent ductus arteriosus of the elongated, conical type (Type E). Coil occlusion was performed with a Gianturco coil, 0.035-4 cm(-3) mm. A follow-up echocardiogram showed a very small residual ductal shunt and a moderate-sized thrombus at the aortic end of the ductus arteriosus. The patient remained asymptomatic.     

Patent ductal arteriosus occlusion by Rashkind umbrella and by detachable coil

The objective of this study is to report all of our experience of patent ductus arteriosus closure by interventional catheterisation, comparing two systems used successively: Rashkind umbrella and detachable coil. METHOD: Between January 1991 and July 2001, 72 patients underwent cardiac catheterisation in order to occlude patent ductus arteriosus (PDA). In 3 patients closure was not attempted (n = 1) or aborted (n = 2). The 69 patients in whom one or several prostheses were implanted are the object of this retrospective study. The patients were between 10 months and 18 years old (median 4 years), weighing between 6.7 and 54 kg (median 17 kg). The narrowest average angiographic diameter of the PDA was 2.2 mm (1 to 4 mm), type A in the Krichenko classification in 59 cases. The PDA was occluded by an umbrella in 29 patients (group 1), and from 1997 coils were used in 40 patients (group II). The medium term results were evaluated clinically and by colour doppler echocardiography. RESULTS: The age, weight, size and type of PDA were similar in the 2 groups. Group 1: 28 patients were treated with a single umbrella and one patient received 2 umbrellas. Systemic embolisation occurred in one case. The average period of follow-up was from 4 years to 10 years (average 6.5 years). The rate of residual shunt at 24 h, 6 months, and 12 months was 43%, 43%, and 39% respectively. A second implant was necessary in 2 children after 7 months and 30 months. The spontaneous disappearance of residual shunt was observed in 8 patients after between 1 month and 54 months (average 33.5 months). A slight residual shunt persisted in 4 patients (13.7%), 4.5 to 8.5 years after placing one or two umbrellas. The patients with a residual shunt were younger: 37 months versus 73 months (p < 0.05). Group II: 34 patients received a single coil and 6 patients several coils. Two cases of embolic migration and two cases of haemolysis were observed. The follow-up extended from 4 months to 4.5 years (average 2.2 years). The rate of residual shunt at 24 h, 6 months, and 1 year respectively was 35%, 10.5%, and 3.3%. At 6 and 12 months this rate was significantly less in group I (p < 0.01). Implantation of supplementary coils was necessary in 2 children at 24 h and at 9 months. Spontaneous disappearance of residual shunt occurred in 10 children out of 14 with an average interval of 5.5 months. A weak residual shunt remained detectable in 2 patients (5%) at 6 months and 36 months. CONCLUSION: The rate of initial residual shunt is comparable using both techniques. Spontaneous disappearance of residual shunts was observed in the majority of cases, but with the detachable coils this outcome is faster and the final rate for residual shunt is very low.