Moderators of the effect of preoperative emotional adjustment on postoperative depression after surgery for temporal lobe epilepsy

PURPOSE: Other outcome measures besides seizure control must be considered when assessing the benefit of epilepsy surgery. We investigated the effect of preoperative psychosocial adjustment on postoperative depression in epilepsy patients followed up prospectively for 2 years after temporal lobectomy. METHODS: The Washington Psychosocial Seizure Inventory (WPSI) evaluated psychosocial functioning; the Centre for Epidemiological Studies Depression Scale (CES-D) measured depression. Both were completed at baseline and follow-up. RESULTS: Follow-up occurred in 39 temporal lobectomy patients at 2 years after surgery. Greatest improvement in depression scores was limited to patients with good seizure outcomes (seizure free, or marked reduction in seizure frequency), and seizure outcome was a significant predictor of postoperative depression. Despite this, preoperative scores on the emotional adjustment scale of the WPSI were most highly correlated with depression 2 years after surgery. To clarify this relation, moderated hierarchic regression suggested that good preoperative emotional adjustment (WPSI) was generally associated with less depression after surgery. Moreover, poorer preoperative adjustment combined with older age, generalized seizures, the finding of preoperative neurologic deficits, a family history of psychiatric illness, and/or a family history of seizures was related to higher depression scores 2 years after surgery. CONCLUSIONS: Depression after temporal lobectomy is dependent on a complex interaction of variables and can have a significant effect on indices of postoperative adjustment. The WPSI emotional adjustment scale may help to predict which patients are likely to be chronically depressed after surgery.     

Neuroticism in Temporal Lobe Epilepsy: Assessment and Implications for Pre- and Postoperative Psychosocial Adjustment and Health-Related Quality of Life

Summary: We assessed 77 candidates for epilepsy surgery to determine the association among neuroticism (a dimension of personality characterized by chronic negative emotions and behaviors), psychosocial adjustment as measured by the Washington Psychosocial Seizure Inventory (WPSI), and health-related quality of life (HRQOL) as measured by the Epilepsy Surgery Inventory 55 (ESI-55). Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory 2 (MMPI-2) Neuroticism scale scores were significantly correlated with many domains of patient-perceived psychosocial adjustment and HRQOL regardless of frequency or type of seizures. We then followed 45 of the patients who subsequently underwent epilepsy surgery to determine the influence of neuroticism on postoperative functioning. Two-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) indicated that patients with high preoperative neuroticism had significantly poorer postoperative psychosocial adjustment and HRQOL scores than patients who had low or moderate preoperative neuroticism scores. These results support the validity of the MMPI-2 as a useful measure of neuroticism. Preoperative neuroticism has an important influence on postoperative psychosocial adjustment and HRQOL that is independent of postoperative seizure outcome. Understanding the influence of personality variables, such as neuroticism, on psychosocial functioning both before and after epilepsy surgery is essential in managing intractable seizures.     

Presurgery Expectations, Postsurgery Satisfaction, and Psychosocial Adjustment After Epilepsy Surgery

Summary: Purpose: The medical benefits of epilepsy surgery are well documented, but the psychosocial consequences of surgery have received less attention. This is especially true of the roles of expectations and satisfaction in postsurgery functioning. The present study was designed to examine the relationships between expectation, satisfaction with surgery, and psychosocial functioning in patients and their significant others before and after epilepsy surgery. Methods: The neuropsychology findings of 79 patients undergoing epilepsy surgery were examined from assessments made before, 2 months after, and 1 year after anterior temporal lobectomy (ATL) was performed. The Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory (MMPI) and the Washington Psychosocial Seizure Inventory (WPSI) were used to assess psychosocial functioning. A subset of 32 patients and their significant others were followed prospectively with an additional semistructured interview to assess expectations for and satisfaction with surgery outcome. Results: Before surgery, patients showed considerable problems with psychosocial adjustment. After surgery, patients in the seizure-free group showed improvements on the psychosocial measures at both follow-ups, whereas patients with continued seizures showed improvement at the 2-month follow -up and then a decline to baseline or worse at the time of the 1-year follow-up. Subjects who were studied prospectively had high presurgery expectations for seizure elimination. After surgery, subjects whose expectations were met reported high satisfaction whereas subjects whose expectations were not met reported low satisfaction. Satisfaction with surgery was associated with better psychosocial functioning. Conclusions: Such data help elucidate the ways in which successful epilepsy surgery results in improved psychosocial functioning. The results identify ways to increase the likelihood that both patients who are seizure-free and those with reduced seizure frequency may benefit from surgery.     

Interaction of cognitive aging and memory deficits related to epilepsy surgery

Temporal lobe epilepsy surgery can cause significant memory impairment. This study was intended to examine whether surgery also could affect prognosis of memory in older age. Age regression of verbal memory was examined in 187 patients (before and 1 year after left temporal lobe surgery) and 264 healthy controls. Eighty patients underwent selective amygdalohippocampectomy, and 107 patients underwent anterior two-thirds temporal lobectomy. Amygdalohippocampectomy patients had mesiotemporal epilepsy; anterior two-thirds temporal lobectomy patients had more extramesial or diffuse seizure onset zones. Memory was assessed by word list learning for its more mesial (consolidation/retrieval) and more neocortical (learning) aspects. Patients showed significant preoperative memory impairment. Independent of seizure outcome and surgical approach, surgery had significant negative effects on learning and consolidation/retrieval. In the amygdalohippocampectomy group, preoperative and postoperative age regressions of learning and consolidation/retrieval were not different from those of controls. In the anterior two-thirds temporal lobectomy group, age regression of verbal learning became steeper after surgery, and consolidation/retrieval was negatively correlated with older age and later onset of epilepsy even before surgery. The data confirm that age regression of verbal memory in left temporal lobe epilepsy is similar to that in healthy controls. Both left anterior two-thirds temporal lobectomy and amygdalohippocampectomy worsen verbal learning and memory and bring patients closer to cognitive disability. Particularly in anterior two-thirds temporal lobectomy patients, surgery and reduced capacities for compensation cause acceleration of lifetime memory decline. The results support earlier and tailored epilepsy surgery and suggest that memory prognosis in older age should be considered if more extensive temporal resections would be inevitable.     

Economical screening for emotional disturbance in epilepsy: Anticipating Minnesota multiphasic personality inventory profile elevations by means of the Washington psychosocial seizure inventory

This study examined the ability of the Washington Psychosocial Seizure Inventory (WPSI) to identify patients with elevated (abnormal) scores on scales of the Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory (MMPI). A sample of 407 adults with epilepsy who were administered both inventories was randomly divided into principal (n = 250) and cross-validation (n = 157) subsamples. Scores of 5 or more on the WPSI Emotional Adjustment Scale best identified the presence of one or more MMPI scale elevations, with 82% accuracy on cross-validation. Scores on the Emotional Adjustment Scale of 12 or more best identified the presence of two or more MMPI scale elevations, with 80% accuracy on cross-validation. High correlations were obtained between several WPSI and MMPI scales. This study suggests that the 132-item WPSI may be useful in screening for emotional disturbances in adults with epilepsy, and in determining when further emotional evaluation via clinical interview or additional testing may be warranted.     

Causal attributions for seizures: Relation to preoperative psychological adjustment and postoperative psychosocial function in temporal lobe epilepsy

In a sample of 65 epilepsy patients who were temporal lobectomy candidates, the links between causal attributions, learned resourcefulness, and preoperative psychosocial adjustment were explored. In addition, attributions as predictors of objective 2-year postoperative psychosocial outcomes were examined prospectively. With illness severity controlled for, attribution of seizures to stress factors and low learned resourcefulness were predictive of poor psychosocial adjustment preoperatively. Taking personal responsibility for seizure occurrence (self-blame) was associated with better psychosocial adjustment. At 2 years, patients were divided into three groups: (a) postoperative seizure-free (n = 21), (b) postoperative not seizure-free (n = 19), and (c) nonoperated controls (n = 25). Seizure-free outcome status was associated with better psychosocial outcome. Of greater interest was the predictive value of preoperative attributions. As expected, attributions involving personal responsibility were predictive of postoperative full-time employment and receipt of disability benefits. The data enhance understanding of the ways in which patients with epilepsy manage the challenges they face and enhance the psychometric prediction of psychosocial behavioral outcomes after epilepsy surgery.     

Resective surgery for intractable focal epilepsy in patients with low IQ: predictors for seizure control and outcome with respect to seizures and neuropsychological and psychosocial functioning

PURPOSE: To investigate possible predictive factors for seizure control in a group of children and adults with low IQs (IQ, < or =70) who underwent resective surgery for intractable focal epilepsy and to study outcome with respect to seizures and neuropsychological functioning. We also studied psychosocial outcome in the adult patients. METHODS: Thirty-one patients (eight children younger than 18 years) with a Wechsler Full Scale IQ of 70 or less underwent comprehensive neuropsychological assessments before and 2 years after surgery. Adults also completed the Washington Psychosocial Seizure Inventory (WPSI). Univariate analyses were used to identify variables differentiating between patients who became seizure free and those who did not. Pre- and postoperative test results were compared by t test for dependent samples. RESULTS: Forty-eight percent of the patients became seizure free, 52% of those with temporal lobe resection and 38% of those with extratemporal resection. Only one variable was predictive for seizure outcome: duration of epilepsy. In one third of the patients, who had the shortest duration of epilepsy (<12 years), 80% became seizure free. Significant improvement was seen regarding vocational adjustment in adults (WPSI). Seizure-free adults improved their Full Scale IQ scores. No cognitive changes were found in seizure-free children or in patients who did not become seizure free. CONCLUSIONS: A good seizure outcome was obtained after resective surgery in patients with intractable focal epilepsy and low IQ, provided that treatment was done relatively shortly after onset of epilepsy. No adverse effects were seen on cognitive and psychosocial functioning.     

Patient Expectations of Temporal Lobe Surgery

Summary: Purpose: The purpose of this study was to examine expectations of postoperative quality of life expressed by patients undergoing anterior temporal lobectomy (ATL) for the control of intractable seizures. An important component of this study was an exploration of the relationship between preoperative expectations and perceived success of the operation.
Methods: Psychosocial functioning of 60 patients was assessed preand postoperatively, using a standardised, semistructured clinical interview. Preoperative assessment included a detailed examination of the patients' expectations of surgery, while postoperative assessment at 6 months examined the patients' perception of surgical success with respect to seizure outcome and postoperative psychosocial status.
Results: A range of expectations were expressed about postoperative outcome. These were classified into 11 posthoc categories. Patients who perceived the operation as a success tended to endorse 'practical' expectations (i.e., driving, employment, activities) preoperatively, rather than expectations of a psychologic or social nature (i.e., self-change, relationships). These patients experienced fewer postoperative seizures and psychosocial difficulties. In contrast, a perceived lack of success was associated with greater emphasis on psychosocial expectations preoperatively. These patients experienced a greater number of perceived postoperative psychosocial difficulties, and more postoperative seizures.
Conclusions: Preoperative expectations of surgery formed an important baseline against which to assess postoperative outcome, and should constitute a routine part of assessment in studies of psychosocial outcome of ATL.     

The Development and Standardization of a Spanish Version of the Washington Psychosocial Seizure Inventory

The Washington Psychosocial Seizure Inventory (WPSI) was translated from English into Spanish, reviewed by a bilingual panel, and then standardized on 107 Spanish-speakers and 45 bilinguals in Miami, Florida. The 152 subjects were active clients of the Epilepsy Foundation of South Florida. Subjects were assigned to one of three treatment groups: Monolingual (Spanish WPSI only), Bilingual (Spanish WPSI first), or Bilingual (English WPSI first). All three groups were given two administrations of the WPSI at least 30 days apart. Resulting data were submitted to measures of split-half reliability, test-retest reliability, and concurrent validity. The psychosocial scales were found to be internally consistent and showed stability across administrations with a marked similarity between the Spanish and English forms. The concurrent validity of the Spanish scales was established at the 0.01 level of significance or better. It was concluded that the Spanish WPSI was statistically comparable to the original English language version, thus establishing a basis for its usage in the psychological assessment of Spanish-speaking epileptics throughout the world.     

Relationship of Age at Onset, Chronologic Age, and Adequacy of Preoperative Performance to Verbal Memory Change After Anterior Temporal Lobectomy

Summary We examined the relationship of age of onset of epilepsy, chronological age at time of operation, and adequacy of preoperative memory performance to pre- to postoperative verbal memory decline. Patients who underwent left (n = 50) or right (n = 51) anterior temporal lobectomy (ATL) were administered tests of verbal episodic (list learning, paragraph recall) and semantic memory (visual naming, vocabulary), both preoperatively and 6 months postoperatively. As a group, left ATL patients showed the classic selective decrease on measures of episodic but not semantic memory. However, examination of episodic memory outcome showed considerable individual variability. Stepwise regression analyses indicated that both later age at onset and older chronologic age were significant and selective predictors of episodic memory decrease for left ATL patients. Adequacy of preoperative memory performance was a nonspecific predictor, associated with decrease in postoperative memory performance for both left and right ATL patients and for multiple types of memory indices. The clinical and theoretical implications are discussed.     

Predictors of postoperative memory function after left anterior temporal lobectomy

Patients who undergo left anterior temporal lobectomy (ATL) for intractable epilepsy are at risk of postoperative memory decline. This study attempts to identify the best predictors of memory after ATL using preoperative tests. Thirty-two consecutive patients who underwent left ATL with preoperative and postoperative neuropsychological testing were retrospectively identified. The following independent variables were analyzed by multiple regression: age of onset of seizures, age of temporal lobe damage, gender, MRI results, preoperative memory testing, and intracarotid amytal procedure (IAP) results. Neuropsychological measures of verbal and nonverbal memory served as dependent variables. Male gender (P<0.005), failing the IAP with both left and right hemispheres (P<0.001), and higher logical memory (LM) scores preoperatively (P<0.001) were associated with greater declines in LM after surgery. Our data demonstrate that the IAP predicts postoperative memory independent of other factors known to affect memory after left ATL.     

Psychosocial and Neurobehavioral Factors Related to Surgical Treatment for Partial Epilepsy: A Multivariate Analysis

Studies of temporal lobe surgery rarely include anatomical and neurobehavioral data in the analysis of outcome. We carried out a retrospective study on 50 patients, using clinical data from case notes, resection volumes, and preoperative imaging data. Three main conclusions emerge from this study: (1) Psychosocial outcome is related to postoperative seizure control. (2) Late postoperative aggression and clinical depression are associated with bad psychosocial outcome. (3) Right-sided hippocampal sclerosis, as suggested by measurements with T2 relaxometry, correlates with interictal psychopathology, as measured with the Beck Depression Inventory, the Leyton Obsessional Inventory, and the Bear-Fedio personality inventory.     

Depression, Locus of Control, and the Effects of Epilepsy Surgery

The purposes of this investigation were (a) to determine the relationship between interictal depression and a potential psychosocial risk factor (locus of control), (b) to examine changes in self-reported depression after anterior temporal lobectomy (ATL), and (c) relate postoperative changes in depression to alterations in surgical outcome and locus of control. Thirty-seven patients with intractable seizures of temporal lobe origin were administered measures of depression and locus of control both preoperatively and 6 months postoperatively. Results revealed a significant preoperative relationship between depression and an external locus of control, but this relationship no longer existed postoperatively. Postoperative declines in depression were independent of any alterations in locus of control. Further analyses revealed that depression declined significantly only in patients rendered completely seizure-free by ATL, whereas patients who were significantly improved (greater than or equal to 75% reduction in seizure frequency) but continued to experience some seizure activity showed no changes in self-reported depression. Finally, a wide variety of neurologic and seizure-related variables were shown to be unrelated to depression. The clinical and theoretical significance of these findings is discussed.     

Language-related cognitive declines after left temporal lobectomy in children.

Presented is a case series demonstrating that clinically significant language-related cognitive declines not detected by intelligence quotient (IQ) testing occur after left temporal lobectomy in school-aged children. In this series, comprehensive preoperative and postoperative neuropsychologic evaluations were completed in eight school-aged patients who underwent temporal lobectomy (five left, three right) for temporal lobe epilepsy. Mean age at surgery was 13 years, 11 months +/- 2 years, 1 month. Testing included measurement of IQ, verbal learning, naming, visual memory, sight word recognition, reading comprehension, and calculation. All five left temporal lobectomy patients demonstrated significant language-related cognitive declines on postoperative neuropsychologic testing, including deficits in verbal IQ (one patient), verbal learning (four patients), naming (one patient), and reading comprehension (one patient). These deficits were clinically evident in four of the five left temporal lobectomy patients, leading to declines in educational performance. IQ testing alone did not reliably identify these deficits. No significant declines were found after surgery in three right temporal lobectomy patients. Average or high preoperative functioning may have predisposed patients to postoperative deficits in this series, whereas magnetic resonance imaging or pathologic abnormalities did not protect against postoperative deficits. Outcome studies of temporal lobectomy in childhood should use comprehensive neuropsychologic testing to identify cognitive deficits.     

Predicting seizure frequency after epilepsy surgery

OBJECTIVE: To identify clinical features related to seizure frequency after epilepsy surgery in patients with recurrent seizures. BACKGROUND: No studies have examined the differences between patients who have rare seizures and patients who experience frequent seizures after epilepsy surgery. Since seizure frequency correlates with morbidity and quality of life, it is desirable to know which preoperative clinical features predict postoperative seizure frequency. METHODS: Patients with recurrent seizures were placed in two categories: rare postoperative seizures (< or =2 per year) and frequent postoperative seizures (> or =12 per year) using seizure frequency in the second postoperative year. Variables included preoperative seizure frequency, age of first risk, age at first seizure, epilepsy duration, age at surgery, history of febrile convulsions, tonic-clonic seizures, status epilepticus, or family history, IQ, magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), and positron emission tomography (PET). Variables were analyzed using non-parametric tests to assess relationship to postoperative seizure frequency. RESULTS: Of 475 patients who had epilepsy surgery, 111 had rare or frequent seizures in the second postoperative year. After anterior temporal lobectomy (ATL), age of first risk< or =5 years and presence of mesial temporal sclerosis on MRI were associated with rare seizures (66% of patients), whereas lack of these risk factors was associated with frequent seizures (75% of patients) (p<0.03). For non-ATL operations, preoperative seizure frequency of > or =20 seizures per month was associated with frequent postoperative seizures (p=0.03). No other variables influenced outcome. CONCLUSIONS: Some preoperative clinical features correlate with postoperative seizure frequency in patients with recurrent seizures after epilepsy surgery. This has implications for the surgical decision making process and early postoperative management.     

Seizure Outcome after Temporal Lobectomy: Current Research Practice and Findings

PURPOSE: The literature regarding seizure outcome and prognostic factors for outcome after temporal lobectomy is often contradictory. This is problematic, as these data are the basis on which surgical decisions and counseling are founded. We sought to clarify inconsistencies in the literature by critically examining the methods and findings of recent research. METHODS: A systematic review of the 126 articles concerning temporal lobectomy outcome published from 1991 was conducted. RESULTS: Major methodologic issues in the literature were heterogeneous definitions of seizure outcome, a predominance of cross-sectional analyses (83% of studies), and relatively short follow-up in many studies. The range of seizure freedom was wide (33-93%; median, 70%); there was a tendency for better outcome in more recent studies. Of 63 factors analyzed, good outcome appeared to be associated with several factors including preoperative hippocampal sclerosis, anterior temporal localization of interictal epileptiform activity, absence of preoperative generalized seizures, and absence of seizures in the first postoperative week. A number of factors had no association with outcome (e.g., age at onset, preoperative seizure frequency, and extent of lateral resection). CONCLUSIONS: Apparently conflicting results in the literature may be explained by the methodologic issues identified here (e.g., sample size, selection criteria and method of analysis). To obtain a better understanding of patterns of long-term outcome, increased emphasis on longitudinal analytic methods is required. The systematic review of possible risk factors for seizure recurrence provides a basis for planning further research.     

Psychiatric outcome after temporal lobectomy: a predictive study

PURPOSE: The occurrence of psychiatric symptoms after temporal lobectomy is well documented. The aim of the present study was to identify preoperative factors that predict postoperative psychiatric outcome. METHODS: We studied the case notes of 121 patients (from an initial sample of 167) who underwent temporal lobectomy at the National Hospital of Neurology and Neurosurgery, Queen Square, London, between 1988 and 1997. Data concerning gender, laterality of lesion, pathology, seizure outcome, psychiatric history, psychiatric outcome, resection volume, telemetry, and MRI scans were systematically collected. Factors that predict the occurrence of postoperative psychiatric symptomatology were investigated using correlational, chi(2), and logistic regression techniques. RESULTS: Poor postoperative psychiatric outcome in general was positively associated with preoperative bilateral independent spike discharges at telemetry. The size of surgical resection was positively correlated with the occurrence of postoperative emotional lability. The laterality of the epileptogenic lesion was not associated with a poor psychiatric outcome. Developmental lesions were associated with a good psychiatric outcome at a marginally significant level. Patients with a preoperative psychiatric history and de novo psychiatric symptomatology had a poorer surgical outcome in terms of seizure frequency, also at a marginally significant level. A significant correlation was found between a past psychiatric history and seizure outcome. CONCLUSIONS: We identified a high frequency of psychiatric symptoms both before and after temporal lobectomy, demonstrating that it is not a benign procedure from the point of view of psychopathology. Our results show that there are certain predictive factors that may help identify patients most at risk for postoperative psychiatric disorders.     

The Application of WPSI to Epilepsy Patients

Abstract: Eighty-five epilepsy patients were questioned using the Washington Psychosocial Seizure Inventory (WPSI). It was confirmed that uncontrollable epilepsy patients had more severe psychosocial problems than other patients. WPSI was also useful in clinical work.     

Cognitive Consequences of Two-Thirds Anterior Temporal Lobectomy on Verbal Memory in 144 Patients: A Three-Month Follow-Up Study

Previous studies have shown that left temporal lobectomy for intractable epilepsy can lead to verbal memory deficits. However, patients with left temporal lobe epilepsy (LTLE) frequently have impaired verbal memory preoperativel. The present analysis of 144 patients who underwent temporal lobe resections for either left (n = 68) or right (n = 76) temporal lobe epilepsy (LTLE, RTLE) addressed the questions of (a) whether a left two-thirds anterior temporal lobectomy (ATL) increases deficits in these qualitative aspects of verbal memory already impaired preoperatively, and (b) whether other aspects of verbal memory are additionally affected. We also evaluated possible determinants of preoperative abilities and postoperative changes, using multiple regression analysis. Preoperatively, patients with LTLE differed from patients with RTLE only in poorer performance on measures of long-term consolidation/retrieval (delayed recall). This was related to hippocampal pathology and seizure severity. Only left temporal lobe resections resulted in significant deterioration in verbal learning and memory. Acquisition over learning trials and recognition deteriorated most markedly, whereas performance in long-term consolidation/retrieval showed only minor changes. Preoperative performance levels, chronological age, the extent of the en bloc resection, preoperative performance on figural memory, and preoperative seizure severity were valuable determinants of postoperative changes in acquisition and recognition. In contrast, changes in consolidation/retrieval related only to preoperative ability. Left two-thirds ATL leads to new impairment in addition to preexisting memory deficits. The finding that left temporal lobectomy affects verbal acquisition and recognition more than long-term consolidatiodretrieval, including the different determinants of these changes, most likely reflects the differential effects of surgery on mesial temporal and neocortical temporal functions.     

Health-related quality of life and seizure control in temporal lobe epilepsy

We conducted a prospective study over 24 months to compare health-related quality of life in surgically and medically treated patients with intractable temporal lobe epilepsy. Seizure frequency and health-related quality of life were assessed in 81 patients before and 6, 12, and 24 months after treatment. Using the Epilepsy Surgery Inventory 55 (ESI-55), we compared (1) different seizure outcome groups and (2) temporal lobectomy with continuing medical management. Follow-up was satisfactory in 72 patients (89%), 51 treated with temporal lobectomy and 21 with no surgery. Pretreatment seizures and health-related quality of life were comparable in the two groups. Seizure outcome was significantly better at 6, 12, and 24 months after surgery. At 24 months, seizure-free patients and those with at least a 90% reduction in seizure frequency reported significant improvements in health-related quality of life (on 5 of 10 subscales and overall Epilepsy Surgery Inventory 55 scale). Deterioration in quality of life occurred with less than 90% seizure reduction. Only one Epilepsy Surgery Inventory 55 subscale at 6 months and two subscales at 12 months showed a significant difference. Patients with good seizure outcome experience improved health-related quality of life after treatment. Since temporal lobectomy results in considerably better seizure control than continued medical management, the findings support surgery as the preferred treatment, although changes in health-related quality of life may not be evident until the second postoperative year.