Phenotypic difference between allergic and irritant patch test reactions in man

Cellular responses in allergic and irritant contact dermatitis were analysed in situ using an immunohistochemical double staining technique with the aim of uncovering phenotypical differences of diagnostic importance. Allergic and irritant patch test reactions were elicited in 9 individuals using the Finn chamber technique. Thirty-nine skin biopsies from these reactions and from petrolatum controls were obtained 4 to 20 days after the test applications. Cell infiltrates were present throughout the observation period in both allergic and irritant reactions, but were usually greater in the former. In both types of reaction, anti-Leu 3a reactive cells predominated over anti-Leu 2a reactive cells. HLA-DR expression on keratinocytes was found in 9 of 14 allergic reactions, but not in irritant reactions or control areas. HLA-DQ antigens were not detected on keratinocytes. The presence of HLA-DR antigens on keratinocytes may reflect an immunological response of the allergic reactions, and thus be of diagnostic relevance.     

Histological distinction between early allergic and irritant patch test reactions: follicular spongiosis may be characteristic of early allergic contact dermatitis

Comparative light microscopic studies have revealed subtle differences between allergic and irritant reactions in the skin. In the search for specific differences, we focussed on the early inflammatory response. This pilot study was conducted to test the hypothesis that follicular spongiosis can differentiate between early allergic and irritant patch test reactions. 8 patients with known contact allergy to either colophony or quarternium-15 participated in the study. In each patient, allergic and irritant patch tests reactions were elicited, and 4-mm punch biopsies were taken after 6 8 h from clinically equipotent reactions. Paired sets of slides were assessed blindly by 2 pathologists. 1 patient showing a pityrosporum folliculitis was excluded from the study. All biopsies from allergic patch tests were characterized by follicular spongiosis, while biopsies from irritant patch tests showed no recognizable changes except a slight follicular spongiosis in 1 patient. The 2 pathologists agreed independently on the correct classification in 6 out of 7 cases (p=0.0156). We tested an optimized model, selecting non-irritant allergens and a well-known irritant. Further investigations are needed to elucidate the diagnostic significance of the histological classification of allergic and irritant cutaneous reactions in punch biopsies.     

Photosensitive dermatitis with actinic reticuloid syndrome: an immunohistological study of the cutaneous infiltrate

Cryostat sections of skin biopsies from five patients with chronic photosensitivity dermatitis with actinic reticuloid syndrome (PDAR) have been examined immunohistologically by the alkaline phosphatase:anti-alkaline phosphatase staining technique using a panel of 24 monoclonal antibodies against lymphoid cells and their subsets. The lymphoid infiltrates in all cases had an essentially identical cellular composition, containing a mixture of T-lymphocytes, T-cell accessory cells (Langerhans cells) and other types of HLA-DR positive dermal macrophages. In two patients there was an excess of T-helper/inducer cells relative to T-suppressor cells, while in the other three patients the numbers of T-cells in these two subsets were approximately equal. Many of the infiltrating T-cells expressed activation (HLA-DR, interleukin-2 receptor) or proliferation (the Ki67 nuclear antigen, transferrin receptor) associated markers. These data indicate that a T-cell immune response is operative in cutaneous PDAR lesions.     

Lymphocyte subsets and Langerhans cells in allergic and irritant patch test reactions: histometric studies

This study has attempted to distinguish between allergic and irritant reactions to patch tests by semiquantitative histological methods. The extent of perivascular chronic inflammatory infiltrate at 72 h in irritant patch test reactions to sodium lauryl sulphate was shown to be small and very consistent, whereas in allergic reactions to nickel sulphate it was generally larger and more variable in size (p less than 0.02). The two major lymphocyte subsets (T4 and T8) were randomly intermixed in both types of reaction and formed the major component of both the perivascular and diffuse dermal infiltrate, without any evidence of selective migration. The T4:T8 ratios were similar in focal and diffuse infiltrates. The number of T6 dendritic (putative Langerhans) cells in the epidermis (per mm inner epidermal length) was usually greatly reduced in irritant reactions (5-16 mm-1, mean 10 mm-1) but remained within normal limits in allergic reactions (6-33 mm-1, mean 21 mm-1) (p less than 0.001). Comparable results were seen with other irritants (mercuric chloride and benzalkonium chloride) and other allergens (neomycin sulphate, ethylene diamine and potassium dichromate). In additional experiments, pairs of biopsies were taken from the reaction and from adjacent unaffected skin. The T6 cell density in the epidermis did not significantly differ between allergic reactions and control skin. By contrast, the irritant reactions had fewer T6 cells than the control skin (p less than 0.001).     

In vivo cytokine profiles in allergic and irritant contact dermatitis

Local cytokine profiles in skin biopsies from allergic and irritant patch test reactions were determined by in vivo immunohistochemistry to differentiate between these 2 clinically identical afflictions especially at the time of final reading in diagnostic patch testing. Biopsies were taken from established allergic persons after specific allergic patch test.-, to epoxy resin (1%) and formaldehyde (1%) and from non-allergic individuals with irritant patch tests to sodium lauryl sulfate (10%) and formaldehyde (8%). At 72 h after application of the agents, significantly enhanced frequencies of dermal infiltrating cells, producing IL-1α, TNF-α. IL-2. and IFN-γ per 100 infiltrating cells in the dermis. were observed in allergic as well us irritant patch test reactions, as compared to normal skin. Significantly higher frequencies of IL- Iα-producing cells were observed in biopsies from epoxy resin (1%) allergen-affected and sodium lauryl sulfate (10%) irritant-affected skin as compared to formaldehyde (1%) allergen-affected skin. In addition, significantly higher frequencies of TNF -α reproducing cells were observed in epoxy resin allergen-affected skin us compared to Formaldehyde (1%) allergen-affected and formaldehyde (8%) irritant affected skin. The allergic and irritant patch test reactions showed similar levels of expression of the Thl cytokines IL-2 and IFN-γ in the dermis. confirmed by probe based detection of IL-2 mRNA and IFN-γ- mRNA, In conclusion, the described similarity shows that allergens and irritants can induce the same profile of IL-la. TNF-α. IL-2. and IFN-γ production, resulting in the near impossibility of discriminating between allergic and irritant contact dermal is at the lime of patch test reading.     

Common pathogenetic pathways in allergic and irritant contact dermatitis.

Despite their different pathogeneses, allergic and irritant contact dermatitis show a remarkable similarity with respect to clinical appearance, histology, and immunohistology. To further analyze this apparent contradiction, our study was designed to meticulously compare cellular infiltrates in irritant and allergic patch-test reactions by immunostaining with a broad panel of monoclonal antibodies. For this purpose, skin biopsies from allergic and irritant patch-test reactions of similar inflammatory degree were obtained from the same probands. We found that after 72 h both types of reaction were characterized by an identical dermal infiltrate consisting mainly of memory T cells, many of which were activated, and macrophages. Dermal and epidermal Langerhans cell density and HLA--DR expression of keratinocytes were also virtually identical. Our results show that antigen recognition by specific memory T cells as well as irritants can finally induce the same pattern of inflammation, including activation of T cells obviously independent of exogenous antigen.     

The CXCR3 activating chemokines IP-10, Mig, and IP-9 are expressed in allergic but not in irritant patch test reactions.

Differentiation between allergic and irritant contact dermatitis reactions is difficult, as both inflammatory diseases are clinically, histologically, and immunohistologically very similar. Previous studies in mice revealed that the chemokine IP-10 is exclusively expressed in allergic contact dermatitis reactions. In the present study, we investigated whether the mRNA expression of IP-10 and the related CXCR3 activating chemokines, Mig and IP-9 are also differentially expressed in human allergic contact dermatitis and irritant contact dermatitis reactions. Skin biopsies from allergic (13 cases) and sodium lauryl sulfate-induced irritant patch test reactions (13 cases), obtained 1-72 h after patch testing, were studied by means of an in situ hybridization technique. Results of chemokine mRNA expression were correlated with clinical scoring, histology, and immunohistochemical data including the proportion of inflammatory cells expressing CXCR3, the receptor for IP-10, Mig, and IP-9, and ICAM-1 and HLA-DR expression on keratinocytes. IP-10, Mig, and IP-9 mRNA were detected in seven of nine allergic contact dermatitis reactions after 24-72 h, but not in sodium lauryl sulfate-induced irritant contact dermatitis reactions. ICAM-1 expression by keratinocytes was only found in allergic contact dermatitis reactions and correlated with chemokine expression. Moreover, up to 50% of the infiltrating cells in allergic contact dermatitis expressed CXCR3, in contrast to only 20% in irritant contact dermatitis reactions. In conclusion, we have demonstrated differences in chemokine expression between allergic contact dermatitis and irritant contact dermatitis reactions, which might reflect different regulatory mechanisms operating in these diseases and may be an important clue for differentiation between allergic contact dermatitis and irritant contact dermatitis reactions.     

Lymphocytes and Langerhans cells in patch tests

The distribution of immunocompetent cells was analysed in allergic (nickel) and irritant (dithranol) patch tests using conventional transmission electron microscopy and labelling with monoclonal antibodies in an avidin-biotin immunoperoxidase study. The biopsies were taken 24 or 48 h after the allergen/irritant application. In allergic and irritant reactions, most inflammatory cells were OKT11 positive (pan T lymphocytes). The majority of these cells were also OKT4 positive (helper/inducer T lymphocytes), while the minority were OKT8 positive (suppressor/cytotoxic T lymphocytes). NK9 positive cells (natural killer cells) were observed in small numbers. The number of dendritic OKT6 and OKIal positive cells (Langerhans cells) in the epidermis was unaffected in allergic reactions. In irritant reactions, a normal number of OKT6 positive Langerhans cells was observed, while the number of OKIal positive cells had increased in the epidermis. Dithranol caused prominent fine structural changes in the mitochondria of the Langerhans cells, while the keratinocytes appeared largely unaffected. The present study indicates that allergic and irritant patch tests cannot be differentiated reliably using current immunohistopathological or electron microscopic techniques, in spite of the small differences observed.     

Immunopathological and ultrastructural findings in human allergic and irritant contact dermatitis

The histopathological features of allergic contact dermatitis were compared with those of irritant contact dermatitis in a group of 17 subjects. Each patient received simultaneous patch tests of a known allergen and a standardized irritant (benzalkonium chloride). The cellular changes occurring between 3 h and 7 days after patch test application were studied by light and electron microscopy and immunocytochemistry. No differences were observed between the induced allergic contact dermatitis (ACD) and the irritant contact dermatitis (ICD), either in the responding cell types or the sequence of cellular events. Both reactions showed a predominantly T lymphocyte infiltrate with no polymorphonuclear leukocyte involvement. Apposition of Langerhans cells to lymphocytes in the epidermis was seen in both types of response. Considerable variability in the intensity of reaction to irritant and allergen occurred within individuals. There was no statistically significant difference between the intensity of the reactions to the irritant and the allergen.     

Macro-video documentation patch tests

An unequivocal distinction between allergic and irritant patch test reactions is often difficult with patch tests. This study was designed to evaluate the worth of video-macro camera documentation for differentiation between allergic and irritant test reactions and to investigate whether there are characteristic clinical differences in patch test responses between metal salts and fragrances. Patch testing was performed with nickel sulfate, fragrance mix and an irritant, sodium lauryl sulfate 1% aq., on the upper back of 82 patients, with evaluation and computer-aided video documentation after 48 and 72 hr. No reliable clinicomorphological criterion was found for assessing a weak patch test reaction as being definitely allergic. Even characteristic papules and vesicles were not regularly found in allergic reactions. However, unlike fragrance mix, patch test reactions to nickel sulfate were characteristic in that they showed a heterogeneous spread and an association with hair follicle openings, independent of reaction intensity. Evaluation based on additional computer-aided video-macro camera documentation did not add further advantage for the differentiation of allergic and irritant reactions. But well-defined clinicomorphological features and reaction patterns to single test substances or even whole substance categories could be helpful additional criteria for evaluating patch test responses in clinical practice.     

Alterations of epidermal lectin binding sites in acute contact dermatitis

We investigated alterations of epidermal lectin binding sites, as well as of pemphigus and bullous pemphigoid antigens, in 28 human patch test reactions, both allergic (nickel, formaldehyde, N,N'-1,3-dimethylbutyl-N'-phenylenediamine) and irritant (sodium lauryl sulfate). The epidermal reactivity to a panel of lectins and human antisera to pemphigus vulgaris and bullous pemphigoid antigens was compared with samples obtained from normal skin and from skin under tape occlusion. We observed selective perturbations of lectin and antibody binding in acute contact dermatitis, whether allergic or irritant. The main findings were a loss of terminal sialic acids and longer bi- and triantennary mannosyl residues as well as a loss of pemphigus vulgaris antigen. The only difference between allergic and irritant patch test reactions was in topography of loss of WGA binding sites: in the former, it was most pronounced in the lower and middle epidermis, whereas in the latter it was seen in the uppermost subcorneal layers. Our findings support a common pathway of cell membrane alterations of keratinocytes in acute contact dermatitis.     

CD30 antigen expression in cutaneous inflammatory infiltrates of scabies: a dynamic immunophenotypic pattern that should be distinguished from lymphomatoid papulosis

BACKGROUND: Expression of CD30 antigen is a distinct marker of lymphocyte activation that was originally described in the Reed-Sternberg cells of Hodgkin's disease. The observation of CD30+ cells has been considered a diagnostic feature of cutaneous CD30 lymphoid proliferations. However, CD30 expression has also been reported in some cutaneous benign inflammatory infiltrates. METHODS: Eleven skin biopsies from patients with scabies were double-blindly and retrospectively analysed. A panel of histopathological parameters and immunophenotypic expression of CD4, CD8, CD30 and S-100 antigens was studied. CD30 and S-100 antigens expression were related to clinical features. RESULTS: Large CD30+ cells were demonstrated in eight (8/11) biopsies, corresponding to patients with long-standing lesions (3 months or longer). However, no expression of the CD30 antigen was observed in all biopsy specimens (3/11) corresponding to early lesions (2 months or less). The presence of S-100 positive cells in the papillary dermis was an almost constant feature. CONCLUSIONS: CD30+ large cells seem to be a common feature in long-standing infiltrates of scabies. CD30 expression in scattered cells of a cutaneous lymphoid infiltrate cannot be assessed as a strong diagnostic argument of neoplastic cutaneous CD30+ lymphoid proliferation (lymphomatoid papulosis/cutaneous CD30+ lymphoma). Therefore, the possibility that large atypical CD30+ cells may be also present in several benign inflammatory diseases should be always considered.     

Patch testing with methyldibromo glutaronitrile, a multicentre study within the EECDRG

Contact allergy to and allergic contact dermatitis from methyldibromo glutaronitrile (MDBGN) have frequently been reported. As there has been no agreement on which MDBGN test preparation to use, a study was initiated to help determine the optimal patch test preparation for MDBGN. 2661 consecutively patch tested patients at 11 test clinics representing 9 European countries participated. Petrolatum preparations with MDBGN at 1.0%, 0.5%, 0.3% and 0.1% were inserted in the standard series. Contact allergy rates were noted in the range 4.4-1.1% following decreasing test concentrations. Reactions not fulfilling all criteria to be classified as allergic reactions could represent either weak allergic or irritant reactions, and such reactions were noted in the range 8.2-0.5% with decreasing concentrations. A significant number of these reactions represented weak allergic reactions, as allergic reactions were obtained to higher patch test concentrations in the same individual. Morphologically irritant reactions were noted only for the highest test concentrations. In summary, the contact allergy rates and frequencies of doubtful and irritant reactions vary with the patch test concentration. The final decision on patch test concentration for MDBGN should not only rely on these factors but also include information on patch test concentrations required to diagnose individual cases with allergic contact dermatitis from MDBGN as well as results of repeated open application tests.     

Ultrasound for assessment of allergic and irritant patch test reactions

The oedema formation of patch test reactions was quantified by high-frequency ultrasound measurement of skin thickness. Patch testing with nickel sulphate, nickel chloride and sodium lauryl sulphate 1, 2, 5 and 10% was performed in 12 individuals with known nickel allergy. Oedema was greater in allergic than in irritant reactions similar in strength according to the clinical reading. In allergic reactions, the oedema appeared more transcutaneous, while in irritant reactions, more superficial. For differentiation of the 2 types of reaction, application of substances for a 24-h period with measurements the following day is preferable. For rating of allergic and irritant reactions, 48 h of application is preferable with measurements performed on the day patches are removed.     

Para‐phenylenediamine‐specific lymphocyte activation test: a sensitive in vitro assay to detect para‐phenylenediamine sensitization in patients with severe allergic reactions

Please cite this paper as: Para‐phenylenediamine‐specific lymphocyte activation test: a sensitive in vitro assay to detect para‐phenylenediamine sensitization in patients with severe allergic reactions. Experimental Dermatology 2010; 19: 435–441. Abstract: Patients sensitized to para‐phenylenediamine (PPD) by semi‐permanent tattoos increasingly develop threatening allergic reactions in response to black hair dye. The gold standard to diagnose allergic contact dermatitis is to perform epicutaneous patch tests, however, iatrogenic sensitizations and severe patch test reactions to PPD have been described, the latter especially in patients with severe allergic reactions. We examined nine patients with severe allergic reactions in response to permanent hair dyes. Patch tests using the standard concentration of 1% or 0.5% PPD resulted in severe and sometimes even bullous reactions in all patients responsive to PPD. Titration revealed that at 1% of the standard concentration (0.01% PPD), patch test sensitivity decreased and only 50% of patients responded. Consequently, we established an in vitro assay to diagnose PPD allergy. Freshly isolated peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) were cultured with titrated concentrations of PPD with or without IL‐2 supplementation, and cell proliferation was determined by [3H]‐thymidine incorporation. Lymphocyte activation test (LAT ) detected PBMC cell proliferation specific to PPD, with at least 3.5‐fold increase in [3H]‐thymidine uptake in all PPD allergic patients. Most importantly, PPD – LAT without IL‐2 supplementation remained negative in three out of eight PPD allergic patients. Thus, PPD‐LAT with IL‐2 supplementation demonstrated a sensitivity of 100%, remained unresponsive in controls not sensitized to PPD, and in one patient sensitive to other p‐amino compounds. These data demonstrate that LAT with PPD can be used to detect PPD sensitization as a possible alternative to patch testing at least in patients with severe allergic reactions to PPD.     

Fc epsilon R11/CD23 receptor distribution in patch test reactions to aeroallergens in atopic dermatitis.

There is increasing evidence that exposure to organic allergens may induce or exacerbate lesional skin in patients with atopic dermatitis. In this study, patients with atopic dermatitis were patch tested to 11 common organic allergens and to control chambers containing 0.4% phenol and 50% glycerin in 0.9% saline. In biopsies from positive patch test reactions, patch test control skin, lesional eczematous and non-lesional skin from atopic individuals, and normal skin from non-atopic volunteers, the presence and distribution of macrophages (RFD7+), dendritic cells (RFD1+), and Langerhans cells, and the expression of the low-affinity receptor for IgE (CD23) were investigated. In patch test reactions and lesional skin samples, inflammatory infiltrates of diffusely distributed macrophages (RFD7+), dendritic cells (RFD1+), T lymphocytes (RFTmix+), and Langerhans cells (CD1+) were seen, the latter being present in both the epidermis and the dermis. The numbers of Langerhans cells were reduced in the epidermis and increased in the dermis in patch test reactions and lesional skin compared to their controls. Double staining revealed a change in the distribution of CD23 antigen. In patch test control and non-lesional biopsies many macrophages and only a few Langerhans cells within the dermal infiltrates expressed this antigen. In patch test reaction and lesional skin samples, however, the proportion of CD23+ dermal Langerhans cells had increased compared to macrophages. Furthermore, in these latter samples an increased proportion of dermal CD1+ cells expressed the dendritic cell (RFD1+) marker. These results show that following antigen challenge there are marked similarities between the phenotype of the cellular infiltrate in patch test reaction and lesional skin biopsies, and also demonstrate a changing distribution of CD23 on antigen-presenting cells.     

Evaporimetiy in the differentiation of allergic, irritant and doubtful patch test reactions

Background/aims: The aim is to evaluate, using evaporimetry, the possibility of getting further information supporting clinical reading of allergic, irritant reactions and doubtful patch test reactions.
Methods: The investigation was carried out on 204 patients (182 female and 22 male, mean age 31.6 years), patch tested routinely as suspects of allergic contact dermatitis. We evaluated 326 reactions (203 allergic, 123 irritant or doubtful).
Results: Mean values pf TEWL were: for the positive allergic reactions, 7.21 (SD, 2.26) at 48 h, 15.77 (SD, 5.50) at 72 h; and for the irritant or doubtful reactions, 7.55 (SD, 1.72) at 48 h, and 5.77 (SD, 1.41) at 72 h. TEWL in the 2 reactions groups at 72 h was significantly different (p<0.01).
Conclusions: The study shows (i) concordance between the evaporimeter values and the visual score; (ii) at 72 h, the evaporimeter values are increased in the allergic reactions but not in irritant or doubtful reactions; (iii) evaporimetry in the differential diagnoses of patch test reactions was deemed useful.     

Expression of a cell-cycle-associated nuclear antigen (Ki-67) in cutaneous lymphoid infiltrates

Cryostat sections of skin biopsies from 83 patients with benign or malignant cutaneous lymphoid infiltrates were examined immunohistologically for reactivity with Ki-67 (a monoclonal antibody recognizing a nuclear antigen expressed by cycling cells) using the APAAP immunoalkaline phosphatase labeling method and a double immunoperoxidase/alkaline phosphatase staining technique. Ki-67-positive neoplastic lymphocytes were plentiful in all large-cell lymphoma cases and in one-third of the small-cell lymphomas. Some benign disorders (patch test biopsies, cutaneous lymphocytoma, lichen planus) also contained many Ki-67-positive lymphocytes. These data indicate the value of using Ki-67 to assess the proliferative capacities of the lymphoid cells in cutaneous infiltrates. Use of this technique in the future may have important prognostic and therapeutic implications in the management of cutaneous lymphoid malignancies.     

Propylene glycol dermatitis: re-evaluation of an old problem

Evaluation of dermatitis associated with propylene glycol application or ingestion remains a challenge. The research dealing with skin reactions to propylene glycol is revisited and new aspects for future research are outlined. Based on literature review and our own observations, we propose classifying skin reactions to propylene glycol into 4 mechanisms: (a) irritant contact dermatitis, (b) allergic contact dermatitis, (c) non-immunologic contact urticaria, and (d) subjective or sensory irritation. This concept allows a partial explanation of effects observed by different authors. Despite attempts to define objective criteria, biologically, histopathologically, or clinically, the distinction between irritant and allergic reactions remains unclear. Furthermore, the irritation threshold of propylene glycol, and likewise the optimal standard concentration in patch tests, is subjudice. Future studies on propylene glycol dermatitis should include repeated patch tests with serial dose dilutions, repeated open application tests/pro vocative use tests, oral challenge tests, and biopsies for a more complete evaluation of mechanisms and clinical significance.