Comparison of transvaginal and transabdominal sonography in the detection of early pregnancy and its complications

Ninety women with a positive pregnancy test and signs and symptoms of threatened abortion or ectopic pregnancy had endovaginal and abdominal sonography in order to compare the value of the two techniques for the detection of gestational abnormalities. Either a normal delivery occurred or surgical and/or pathologic confirmation of the diagnosis was available in all cases. Fifty-five women had normal intrauterine pregnancies, 22 had ectopic pregnancies, seven had blighted ova, and six had missed abortions. All 55 normal intrauterine pregnancies were detected by endovaginal sonography, while only 11 (20%) were diagnosed by transabdominal sonography. The yolk sac, fetal pole, and fetal heart motion were seen as early as 34 days from the last menstrual period with endovaginal sonography, compared with 42 days with transabdominal sonography. Fetal heart motion was detected with endovaginal sonography in fetal poles with a crown-rump length of 3 mm or greater, whereas the fetal pole had to be at least 6 mm before fetal heart motion could be detected with the transabdominal technique. In the 22 ectopic pregnancies, a specific diagnosis of an extrauterine sac containing a fetal pole with heart motion or yolk sac was possible in three cases with the endovaginal technique, but it was not possible in any case with transabdominal sonography. Both techniques showed that each of the seven patients with final diagnosis of blighted ova had a gestational sac that was 1.7 cm or larger without visualization of the fetal pole or yolk sac. All six missed abortions were detected by endovaginal sonography, but only three were diagnosed on transabdominal sonograms. Our findings show that endovaginal sonography is more sensitive than transabdominal sonography in the detection of early pregnancy and its complications.     

Outcome of first-trimester pregnancies with slow embryonic heart rate at 6-7 weeks gestation and normal heart rate by 8 weeks at US

PURPOSE: To determine retrospectively the outcome of pregnancies in which the embryo has a slow heart rate at 6.0-7.0 weeks gestation and a normal heart rate at follow-up ultrasonography (US) by 8.0 weeks gestation. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Institutional review board approval was granted; informed consent was not required. The study was Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act compliant. Singleton pregnancies with an embryonic heart rate measured on a 6.0-7.0-week US scan were identified. The heart rate was classified as slow if it was fewer than 90 beats per minute prior to 6.3 weeks or fewer than 110 beats/min at 6.3-7.0 weeks, normal if it was 100 or more beats/min at less than 6.3 weeks or 120 or more beats/min at 6.3-7.0 weeks, or borderline if it was 90-99 beats/min prior to 6.3 weeks or 110-119 beats/min at 6.3-7.0 weeks. Pregnancies were excluded from the analysis if they were lost to follow-up before the end of first trimester. The Fisher exact test was used for all statistical comparisons. RESULTS: The rates of first-trimester demise were 60.6% for pregnancies with slow heart rates at 6.0-7.0 weeks (188 of 310), 17.4% for those with borderline heart rates (103 of 593), and 9.1% for those with normal heart rates (186 of 2034). There were 59 pregnancies with a slow heart rate at 6.0-7.0 weeks and a normal heart rate at follow-up US by 8.0 weeks; 15 (25.4%) resulted in first-trimester demise. This rate of demise was significantly higher than that of 7.2% (28 of 390) in pregnancies with a normal heart rate at 6.0-7.0 weeks and a normal heart rate by 8.0 weeks (P <.001, Fisher exact test). Pregnancies with a borderline heart rate early in pregnancy followed by a normal heart rate had a demise rate of 7.6% (nine of 118), which is similar to those with normal heart rates early in pregnancy followed by normal heart rates at follow-up (P = .84). CONCLUSION: When a slow embryonic heart rate is detected at 6.0-7.0 weeks, the likelihood of subsequent first-trimester demise remains elevated (approximately 25%) even if the heart rate is normal at follow-up. In such pregnancies, at least one follow-up scan in late first trimester is warranted.     

Severe polyhydramnios: incidence of anomalies

The sonograms of 195 singleton pregnancies complicated by polyhydramnios were reviewed, and follow-up information was obtained on 191 patients. A grading system was developed that differentiated mild from severe polyhydramnios using real-time or static sonographic equipment. Mild polyhydramnios was present in 138 (71%), and severe polyhydramnios was present in 57 (29%). Previously it has been reported that 60% of cases of polyhydramnios are idiopathic and the pregnancies have a normal outcome. Twenty percent are associated with maternal abnormalities and 20% are associated with fetal anomalies. In this study, pregnancies with severe polyhydramnios had a much greater prevalence of fetal anomalies (75%) than pregnancies with mild polyhydramnios (29%). The 57 singleton pregnancies with severe polyhydramnios were analyzed in depth. Fourteen (25%) of the fetuses were normal; 43 (75%) had significant congenital abnormalities that predominantly involved the CNS, gastrointestinal tract, heart, and genitourinary tract. In all fetuses with primary CNS abnormalities, polyhydramnios was diagnosed at or before 30 weeks of gestation, while in most of the fetuses (83%) with gastrointestinal abnormalities it was diagnosed after 30 weeks. Sonographic findings correlated closely with the findings noted at birth or autopsy. In patients with severe polyhydramnios, normal sonograms were sensitive in excluding major congenital anomalies and, thus, were helpful in providing the parents with favorable prognoses. Sonograms should be performed in patients with polyhydramnios to identify congenital anomalies and to provide information regarding prognosis for fetal outcome.     

Complicated first-trimester pregnancies: evaluation with endovaginal US versus transabdominal technique

Endovaginal ultrasound (US) was performed in 38 pregnant women at 5-12 menstrual weeks, when the initial transabdominal sonograms had been considered inconclusive or equivocal. Clinical follow-up disclosed 32 intrauterine pregnancies (12 living, 18 spontaneous incomplete abortions, and two embryonic demises) and six ectopic pregnancies. In the 32 intrauterine pregnancies (normal and abnormal), the correct diagnosis was made in all cases with endovaginal US. The endovaginal images demonstrated the intrauterine embryo, its heart motion, and the yolk sac more clearly and more often when these structures were not apparent on the transabdominal scans. Abnormal gestational sacs were better resolved. In the six cases of ectopic pregnancy, while an extrauterine ectopic sac was visualized in only three, absence of an intrauterine gestational sac was confirmed in all cases with endovaginal scanning. No endovaginal study yielded less information than its transabdominal counterpart. Endovaginal sonography is likely to be diagnostic when transabdominal images fail to yield a definitive diagnosis in early pregnancies.     

Abnormal pregnancy: early diagnosis by US and serum chorionic gonadotropin levels

Simultaneous sonography and quantitative serum human chorionic gonadotropin (HCG) levels from 126 women with threatened abortion were compared. Of 56 women with normal outcome, 39 (70%) had a gestation sac greater than or equal to 5 mm in mean sac diameter, and in each case the HCG level was 1,800 milli-international units (mIU/ml) or greater. The serum HCG levels strongly correlated with the gestation sac sizes to a mean sac diameter of 25 mm. Of 70 abnormal pregnancies, 31 demonstrated a gestation sac. Of these, 20 women (65%) had disproportionately low HCG levels relative to sac size, including 12 in whom the HCG level was less than 1,800 mIU/ml. One woman with an early molar pregnancy had a disproportionately elevated HCG level. Correlation of sonograms with a simultaneous measurement of serum HCG level is a useful method for evaluating threatened spontaneous abortion. A disproportionately low HCG level relative to gestation sac size is evidence for an abnormal pregnancy.     

Can detection of the yolk sac in the first trimester be used to predict the outcome of pregnancy? A prospective sonographic study.

Recent reports have indicated that identification of the yolk sac should precede the detection of the embryo in a normal first-trimester sonographic examination and that failure to visualize a yolk sac strongly suggests an abnormal intrauterine pregnancy. A first-trimester prospective study was performed in 163 normal and 49 abnormal consecutive singleton gestations. All women were examined both abdominally and transvaginally, with pregnancy outcome determined by delivery of a normal infant or a spontaneous abortion. The yolk sac was analyzed in all patients in whom an embryo was not identified (n = 76). When the yolk sac was identified, the following was found: by the abdominal approach with the mean sac diameter (MSD) less than 27 mm (n = 15), nine gestations were normal and six were abnormal, and by the transvaginal approach with the MSD less than 18 mm (n = 13), seven gestations were normal and six were abnormal. The presence of a yolk sac was not consistently predictive of a normal early pregnancy. When the yolk sac was also not identified, the following was found: abdominally with the MSD less than 27 mm (n = 41), 19 gestations were normal and 22 were abnormal, and transvaginally with the MSD less than 18 mm (n = 11), six gestations were normal and five were abnormal. Absence of the yolk sac was not consistently predictive of a spontaneous abortion. When using the MSD range (20-27 mm abdominally and 7-16 mm transvaginally), over which the yolk sac but not the embryo should be identified sonographically, the yolk sac was again not consistently visualized. On abdominal sonograms, the yolk sac was present and absent in three and 10 patients, respectively, for both normal and abnormal pregnancies. On transvaginal sonograms, the yolk sac was present and absent in seven and five normal gestations and in six and four abnormal gestations, respectively. The results of this study suggest that detection of the yolk sac in the first trimester is not an early predictor of pregnancy outcome.     

Use of furosemide in pregnancies complicated by oligohydramnios

To differentiate pregnancies complicated by oligohydramnios due to intrauterine growth retardation from those due to renal agenesis, the authors administered furosemide intravenously to eight pregnant women (19-25 weeks gestation) with oligohydramnios. The fetal abdomen was scanned with ultrasound to demonstrate the fetal urinary bladder. In six fetuses, sonography failed to demonstrate the bladder: two fetuses had growth retardation with normal kidneys and bladder, and four had renal anomalies. It is concluded that administration of furosemide to the mother fails to induce diuresis in growth-retarded fetuses of 19-23 weeks gestation and that failure to see the fetal bladder after furosemide administration does not necessarily indicate absent fetal kidneys.     

Subchorionic bleeding in threatened abortion: sonographic findings and significance

Fifty-six patients with clinical threatened abortion were evaluated by sonography. In six patients, fetal cardiac activity was absent at or beyond 9 weeks of gestation, and fetal death was confirmed in all six cases. In the other 50 patients, fetal cardiac activity was present at or beyond 9 weeks of gestation. In 10 (20%) of these 50 patients, subchorionic bleeding was present in various degrees, appearing sonographically as an extrachorionic crescentic anechoic or complex collection. The final outcome in the 50 patients with fetal cardiac activity was as follows: In the absence of subchorionic bleeding, 100% of the pregnancies progressed to term; in the presence of subchorionic bleeding the positive outcome was reduced to 80%. In addition to signs of fetal life on sonography, subchorionic bleeding is an important factor affecting the outcome of gestations in patients with clinical threatened abortion.     

Fetal echocardiography--four years experience in Bristol

Fetal echocardiography is described as a reliable method for detecting major structural cardiac abnormalities but relatively few hospitals offer the investigation. We report the results of fetal echocardiography in 110 pregnancies referred to our cardiac ultrasound service. Standard imaging techniques were used and scanning was carried out at 18-24 weeks gestation in the majority. Most referrals were made with a history of congenital heart disease in a sibling or close relative, the remainder followed abnormal routine scans or for other reasons. Four structural cardiac abnormalities were diagnosed in the routine scan abnormality group and one in the positive family history group. Referring clinicians reported no subsequent cardiac abnormality following normal scans. We confirm that provided a careful and systematic technique is used fetal echocardiography is reliable in detecting major structural cardiac defects. Particular attention should be paid to the fetal heart in patients with previously abnormal routine scans as this group accounts for the majority of detected congenital cardiac anomalies.     

Fetal omphalocele detected early in pregnancy: associated anomalies and outcomes

PURPOSE: To detect omphalocele and associated anomalies at ultrasonography (US) early in pregnancy and to describe the outcomes in fetuses with isolated and nonisolated omphalocele. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Fetal endovaginal US was performed in 43,896 pregnant women at 12-16 weeks gestation. The women found to have fetal omphalocele were offered an amniocentesis to determine the fetal karyotype. For parents who decided to continue the pregnancy, repeat targeted transabdominal fetal US was performed at 20-24 weeks gestation. Additional follow-up US examinations performed until delivery were recommended. Postnatal pediatric examinations were performed in all of these fetuses. For the pregnancies in which no anomaly was detected at early US, the women were advised to undergo repeat US at about 24 weeks gestation for the detection of late-manifesting fetal anomalies. For pregnancies in which the baby was not delivered at the authors' affiliated hospital, the woman, her obstetrician, and her pediatrician were asked to inform the authors of any detected anomaly. RESULTS: Omphalocele was visualized at US in 38 fetuses, who were categorized into two groups. One group consisted of 22 (58%) fetuses with associated structural anomalies. According to the karyotype determined for 18 of these fetuses, 11 of them also had chromosomal anomalies. The pregnancy was terminated at the parents' request in 19 of these 22 cases. There were two cases of missed abortion, and a small omphalocele in one fetus disappeared at 21 weeks gestation. The second group consisted of 16 (42%) fetuses with a normal karyotype and an omphalocele as an isolated US finding. In eight of these fetuses, the omphalocele disappeared at 20-24 weeks gestation and no defect was seen at delivery. In six other fetuses, omphalocele was identified at delivery. There was one case each of missed abortion and pregnancy termination. There were no false-negative diagnoses of omphalocele. CONCLUSION: Isolated omphalocele diagnosed during the early stages of gestation typically has a good prognosis. In cases of a small defect, the anomaly may disappear later in the pregnancy.     

Early diagnosis of nonviable pregnancy with endovaginal US

The mean diameter of the gestation sac and the presence or absence of a yolk sac or embryo and/or cardiac pulsations on endovaginal ultrasound (US) images were correlated with normal and abnormal outcomes of pregnancy. Sixty-two patients who were less than 10 weeks pregnant (menstrual age) underwent endovaginal US. In 59 patients with gestation sacs greater than or equal to 8 mm, the absence of a yolk sac predicted a nonviable pregnancy with a sensitivity of 67% and a specificity of 100%. In 35 patients with gestation sacs greater than or equal to 16 mm, the absence of an embryo predicted a nonviable pregnancy with a sensitivity of 50% and a specificity of 100%. When the absence of cardiac pulsations was added to the latter group of patients, the sensitivity was 100% and the specificity was 100%. The combination of these criteria (gestation sac size; demonstration of yolk sac, embryo and/or cardiac pulsations) enabled the early (less than 10 weeks menstrual age) diagnosis of a nonviable pregnancy with endovaginal US.     

Transvaginal sonography in the evaluation of normal early pregnancy: correlation with HCG level

Transvaginal sonography (TVS) is the procedure of choice in evaluating the viability of embryos early in pregnancy. However, viability based on TVS can be assessed more accurately when the exact gestational age from the last menstrual period is known or when the findings are correlated with beta human chorionic gonadotropin (HCG) levels. No large series has been reported with correlative data between early pregnancy findings, HCG, and gestational age. We performed 75 transvaginal examinations in 53 patients with proved normal pregnancy in the fifth through seventh weeks of gestation. The presence and size of the gestational sac, presence of a yolk sac, and identification of embryonic heart activity were correlated with the level of HCG. Sac size was correlated with yolk sac and heart activity and the three parameters correlated with gestational age in days. When the level of HCG reached 1000 mIU/ml by using the first International Reference Preparation, a gestational sac was seen sonographically in each patient. When the HCG level reached 7200 mIU/ml, a yolk sac was seen in every patient. Ten of 22 patients with HCG between 1000 and 7200 mIU/ml had a visible yolk sac. Every patient with an HCG level greater than 10,800 mIU/ml had a visible embryo with a heartbeat. A discriminatory level of 32 days was found for the presence of a gestational sac. A yolk sac was first seen in every patient between 36 and 40 days. Every patient with accurate dates greater than 40 days had an embryo with a heartbeat identified. When correlating sac size with structures within the sac, a yolk sac was first seen in a gestational sac between 6 and 9 mm and a heartbeat seen in every patient with a 9-mm or greater gestational sac diameter. These data allow identification of normal intrauterine pregnancy and distinction of normal from ectopic gestation at least 1 week earlier than is possible with transabdominal techniques.     

Nonvisualization of the fetal gallbladder in early pregnancy: comparison with clinical outcome

PURPOSE: To prospectively assess the frequency of a nonvisualized fetal gallbladder in early pregnancy and to determine its prognostic value. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Fetal transvaginal ultrasonography (US) was performed in 29,749 consecutive pregnant women at 14-16 weeks gestation. A nonvisualized fetal gallbladder was defined if the gallbladder could not be depicted during two targeted examinations within 1 week. In such cases, women were offered an amniocentesis for fetal karyotype and hepatic enzyme analysis. Repeat transabdominal fetal US was performed at 22-26 weeks' gestation. If the gallbladder was still not depicted, US was performed postnatally. RESULTS: The gallbladder was not visualized in early pregnancy in 34 fetuses (0.1%; incidence of one in 875 pregnancies). Associated structural malformations were detected in 14 of 34 (41%) fetuses, five of which also had an abnormal karyotype. Pregnancy was terminated in nine of these 14 fetuses. In the remaining five patients who continued pregnancy, the gallbladder was detected later in pregnancy in four. However, only one infant was healthy. Nonvisualization of the gallbladder as an isolated finding was noted in 20 of 34 (59%) fetuses, all of which had a normal outcome. The gallbladder was detected later in pregnancy in 11 of these fetuses and after birth in two neonates, while no gallbladder was detected after delivery in five other neonates. Two patients were lost to follow-up. CONCLUSION: Nonvisualization of the fetal gallbladder in early pregnancy is uncommon but associated in many cases with other fetal anomalies.     

Sonography during early pregnancy: dependence of threshold and discriminatory values on transvaginal transducer frequency

OBJECTIVE: Our goal was to determine if normal and abnormal pregnancies could be distinguished at smaller sac sizes with a higher frequency transvaginal transducer than with a 5-MHz transducer. SUBJECTS AND MATERIALS: Thirty-nine patients with potentially abnormal pregnancies identified with a 5-MHz transvaginal transducer were immediately reimaged with a 9-5-MHz transducer. We compared our ability to visualize the yolk sac, embryo, and cardiac activity relative to mean sac diameter on imaging at both frequencies in women with normal and abnormal pregnancies. RESULTS: Of the 39 pregnancies, 22 (56%) were normal or probably normal. Using the 5-MHz transducer, a yolk sac was first seen in a 6.4-mm gestational sac but was not definitively seen in 12 gestational sacs measuring 5-13 mm. Using the 9-5-MHz transducer, yolk sacs were identified in all gestational sacs measuring 4.6-13 mm, and live embryos were seen in five of eight sacs measuring 8.1-13 mm. The largest normal gestational sac without a live embryo measured 11 mm. When we compared these pregnancies with 17 (44%) abnormal pregnancies, we found that all pregnancies that had no yolk sac by the time the gestational sac measured 5.0 mm or no live embryo by 13 mm had abnormal findings on higher frequency imaging. CONCLUSION: The ability to visualize the yolk sac and embryo in early pregnancy is critically dependent on transvaginal transducer frequency. Threshold values and discriminatory sizes used to distinguish normal and abnormal pregnancies are smaller on higher frequency than on lower frequency imaging and, therefore, should be redetermined for specific transducer frequencies.     

时间-空间相关成像技术评估中孕期胎儿心功能的初步研究

目的 评估时间-空间相关成像( STIC)技术在中孕期胎儿心功能检查中的应用.资料与方法 110例孕20～27+6周胎儿常规超声筛查心脏无异常,用STIC技术扫描获得胎儿心脏整个心动周期的容积数据,存盘后采用体器官计算机辅助分析软件(VOCAL)进行脱机分析,手动描画出心室舒张末期容积(EDV)、收缩末期容积(ESV).计算心室的每搏量(SV)、心排血量(CO)、射血分数(EF),评价SV、CO、EF与孕龄的相关性.结果 110例胎儿中,94例(85.5％)获得满意的心脏容积数据.左、右心室SV从孕20周的(0.33±0.06) ml和(0.40±0.07) ml增加至孕27+6周的(1.13±0.11) ml和(1.29±0.11) ml,左、右心室CO从孕20周的( 49.66±8.10) ml/min和(59.96±9.43) ml/min增加至孕27+6周的(163.51±17.68) ml/min和(187.57±15.98) ml/min;左、右心室SV和CO随孕龄增加而增加,与孕龄呈正相关(左心室SV及CO r=0.93,P＜0.05.右心室:SV r =0.95,P＜0.05; CO r=0.94,P＜0.05).左、右心室EF分别为(49.48±4.12)％和(51.07±4.00)％,与孕龄无明显相关性(r=0.02、0.04,P＞ 0.05).结论 STIC技术能较为准确客观地测量胎儿心室容积,评价胎儿心功能,有望成为胎儿心功能检查的一种新方法.     

Routine radiographer screening for fetal abnormalities by ultrasound in an unselected low risk population.

A screening programme for fetal abnormalities began at The Hillingdon Hospital in July 1986. Second trimester ultrasound scans are performed by radiographers. A combined prospective and retrospective study of the ultrasound findings and outcome in all pregnancies delivered in 1989-1990 was undertaken. 6412 babies were born during this period, of whom 6183 (96%) were examined by ultrasound in the second trimester; 29 pregnancies were terminated for fetal abnormality. Of the 89 fetuses who were abnormal at birth or at induced termination of the pregnancy (1.4%), 84 were scanned in the second trimester. In 51 cases the abnormality was detected before 22 weeks gestation (sensitivity, 60.7%). 56 of these 84 abnormal fetuses scanned had potentially lethal or major handicapping abnormalities of which 41 were detected by ultrasound before 22 weeks gestation (sensitivity, 73%). There was one false positive diagnosis of abnormality which did not affect outcome. 6352 babies were normal at delivery or on discharge from hospital (specificity, 99.98%).     

Diagnosis of ectopic pregnancy: endovaginal vs transabdominal sonography

During a 25-month period, 193 women with the clinical diagnosis of suspected ectopic pregnancy had transabdominal and endovaginal sonograms. Most had quantitative determinations of serum human chorionic gonadotropin (HCG). Endovaginal sonography was diagnostic of ectopic pregnancy in 23 (38%) of the 60 patients with surgically proved ectopic pregnancies: transabdominal sonography was diagnostic in 13 patients (22%). All 83 intrauterine pregnancies were identified with endovaginal sonography, compared with 34 identified with transabdominal sonography. Endovaginal sonography was somewhat more helpful in the diagnosis of missed abortion and blighted ovum. Eighty endovaginal sonograms were classified as indeterminate as compared with 141 transabdominal studies. This indeterminate group included patients with complete abortions, ectopic pregnancies without sonographic evidence of an extrauterine gestation, incomplete abortions, and patients with subsequent negative serum levels. As in prior reports, endovaginal sonography was superior to transabdominal sonography in the evaluation of suspected ectopic pregnancies. Overall, endovaginal sonography was diagnostic in 113 patients, whereas transabdominal sonography was diagnostic in 52 patients. The finding of an extrauterine fetal pole or embryo was diagnostic for an ectopic pregnancy. Pelvic fluid, the appearance of the endometrium, and a single positive serum HCG determination were not helpful in making the diagnosis of ectopic pregnancy.     

Ultrasound of the empty gestation sac in threatened abortion

The major concern when an empty gestation sac is encountered during threatened abortion is whether or not the pregnancy is viable. Viable pregnancies are managed expectantly, whereas non-viable pregnancies are treated by evacuation of the uterus. Early evacuation of the non-viable pregnancy spares the patient considerable anxiety and discomfort. This study shows that a single ultrasound examination is useful in differentiating viable from non-viable empty gestation sacs. The size of the empty gestation sac was found to be the most useful criterion for determining non-viability. Empty gestation sacs with sizes greater than 26 mm were non-viable, a specificity of 100%, accounting for 43% (42 out of 102) of patients in our series. Other ultrasound criteria found to be useful were shape, position, wall and decidual reaction. The positive predictive value for a successful outcome to a pregnancy was low, being only 41% (9 out of 22).     

Placental abruption and subchorionic hemorrhage in the first half of pregnancy: US appearance and clinical outcome

In 30 pregnant patients who experienced vaginal bleeding between 10 and 20 weeks gestation, subchorionic hematomas were demonstrated on ultrasound examination. In 18 patients (60%), the margin of the placenta was separated from the uterine wall. In 15 patients the outcome was favorable (full-term delivery of normal infant) and in 15 patients the outcome was unfavorable (seven preterm births, four stillbirths, three spontaneous abortions, one therapeutic abortion). The major prognostic factor related to pregnancy outcome was the volume of the hematoma and, to a lesser extent, the relative volume of the hematoma (volume of hematoma divided by volume of gestational sac). For a volume less than 60 ml, the outcome tended to be favorable, and for a relative volume less than 0.4, the outcome tended to be favorable.     

Assessment of congenital heart disease (CHD): is there a role for fetal magnetic resonance imaging (MRI)?

Purpose

To review our experience with fetal magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) to evaluate congenital heart disease (CHD).

Methods

We performed fetal MRI in 32 fetuses with an echocardiographically assessed CHD. Both direct and indirect signs of CHD were investigated. Direct signs considered were: morpho-volumetric abnormalities of the heart; malrotations; ventricular and atrial septal defects; anomalies of the origin, size and course of the great arteries. Indirect signs considered were: difficulty to recognize a “normal” anatomical structures in the reference projections; increase of the vascular size before a stenosis; hypertrophy of the papillary muscles; cardiomegaly and pericardial effusion. All MRI findings were compared with postnatal or autoptic findings.

Results

MRI allowed the CHD to be visualised by direct signs in 17 fetuses, indirect signs in 5 and both direct and indirect signs in 9 fetuses, excluding the prenatal echocardiographic suspect of hypoplastic left heart syndrome in 1 fetus.Postnatal echocardiograms or autoptic findings confirmed a normal heart in 1 fetus and CHD in 31 fetuses including a single cardiac anomaly or syndrome in 19 fetuses, 2 associated cardiac abnormalities in 11 and 3 cardiac anomalies in 1 fetus.However, in 2 fetuses MRI detected a ventricular septal defect successively disclosed by gold standard.

Conclusions

MRI is a promising method for further assessment of the cardiovascular pathologies diagnosed by echocardiography, and may be a valuable tool in assessing associated extracardiac anomalies.