Quantitative validation of cineangiographic axial oblique biplane left ventricular volume measurement

Axial oblique left ventriculography allows unique visualization of acquired and congenital cardiac lesions. However, validation of the accuracy of left ventricular (LV) volume with axial oblique projections is limited and clouded by orthogonal violations between biplane projections. Biplane cineradiographic volume measurement of 17 LV casts employing the axial projection 35 degrees right anterior oblique/55 degrees left anterior oblique/30 degrees cranial (35 degrees RAO/55 degrees LAO/30 degrees Cr) was performed and compared to the conventional postero-anterior/lateral (PA/Lat) and 30 degrees right anterior oblique/60 degrees left anterior oblique (30 degrees RAO/60 degrees LAO) views. LV volume was calculated from biplane cineradiograms by area length and Simpson's rule method. True LV volume by water displacement was 33 +/- 28 (mean +/- S.D.), range 15 to 112 ml. LV cast volume calculated by the area length method from cineradiograms was overestimated (p less than 0.002) but no different by Simpson's rule method (pNS). The ideal correlation was best approximated by the 35 degrees RAO/55 degrees LAO/30 degrees Cr biplane view calculated by Simpson's rule, r = 0.99, y = 3.5 + 0.9x, and standard error of estimate (SEE) = 4.3 ml. Biplane LV angiography with the axial projection permitted accurate LV volume measurement, and Simpson's rule provided the best representation of true volume.     

Comparison of determinations of left atrial volume by the biplane area-length and Simpson's methods using 64-slice computed tomography

ObjectivesThere is increasing evidence that left atrial (LA) size is an important predictor of adverse cardiovascular outcomes such as atrial fibrillation, stroke, and congestive heart failure. The aim of this study was to determine whether there is a difference in results of quantification of LA volume by the area-length and Simpson's methods using multislice computed tomography (MSCT).Methods and resultsThe study population consisted of 51 patients with sinus rhythm (sinus group) and 20 patients with atrial fibrillation (af group) clinically indicated for MSCT angiography for evaluation of coronary arteries. Maximum LA volume, obtained at end-systole from the phase immediately preceding mitral valve opening, was measured using the area-length and Simpson's methods. In the sinus group, the mean LA volumes, indexed to body surface area, were 48.4 ± 17.9 ml/m² with the area-length method and 48.3 ± 17.0 ml/m² with the Simpson's method. In the af group, the mean indexed LA volumes with the area-length method and the Simposon's method were 91.5 ± 47.5 ml/m² and 90.3 ± 45.9 ml/m², respectively. LA volumes calculated by the area-length method exhibited a strong linear relationship and agreement with those calculated using Simpson's method in both the groups (sinus group: r = 0.99, P < 0.0001, af group: r = 0.99, P < 0.0001).ConclusionsThe area-length method is a simple and reproducible means of assessment of LA volume. Standardization of LA volume assessment using MSCT is important for serial follow-up and meaningful communication of results of testing among institutions and physicians.     

Single versus biplane right and left ventricular volumetry: A cast and clinical study

True volume (y) and measured volume (x) determined from 23 right and 22 left normal human casts in four biplane angiographic positions and in their eight single-plane components were used to find the correction factor (b) by regression through the origin (y = bx). The correction factors were applied to human studies to assess the validity of the various biplane and single-plane modalities in vivo. The casts studies yield excellent correlations in both right and left biplane methods (right volumetry: 0.555 ≤ b ≤ 0.708, 0.917 ≤ r ≤ 0.954, 4.10 ≤ SEE ≤ 6.01 left volumetry: 0.748 ≤ b ≤ 0.825, 0.974 ≤ r ≤ 0.982, 4.81 ≤ SEE 5.79). Good results were obtained with single-plane volumetries as well (right volumetry: 0.316 ≤ b ≤ 0.887, 0.750 ≤ r ≤ 0.917, 10.75 ≤ SEE ≤ 18.96; left volumetry: 0.728 ≤ b ≤ 0.881, 0.897 ≤ r ≤ 0.976, 5.73 ≤ SEE ≤ 11.97). The correction factors for the single-plane studies depend much more strongly on the spatial position relative to the radiographic system, particularly in the case of the right ventricular volumes. Thus, the application of the appropriate correction factors is mandatory. The human studies (141 left and 60 right volumetric studies in various single-plane and biplane projections) showed a larger scatter of single-plane values, more pronounced for the right ventricle. In certain disease conditions, single plane volumetric studies using cast-derived correction factors cannot be used to obtain meaningful results. Correction factors for the following single or biplane mode volumetry are presented for the first time: biplane hepatoclavicular view (right and left ventricle), biplane long axial oblique view (right ventricle), and their single-plane components; lateral and 60° Left Anterior Oblique (LAO) single plane for the left-sided measurements, Postero-Anterior (PA), lateral, and 60° LAO for the single-plane right-sided calculations.     

Estimation of left ventricular volumes in man from biplane cineangiograms filmed in oblique projections

In patients with coronary artery disease, right and left anterior oblique views of the left ventricle are considered optimal for assessment of regional wall motion, but the accuracy of ventricular volumes determined from these projections has not been validated. Eleven postmortem left ventricular casts were filmed with the 35 mm cine technique in the 30 ° right anterior oblique and 60 ° left anterior oblique positions, and volumes were calculated using the area-length method. True volume, assessed from volume displacement, ranged from 15 to 185 cc. Calculated volume (V_oblique) slightly but consistently overestimated true volume (V_T), with close correlation and a small standard error of the estimate (SEE):V_T = 0.989 V_oblique ? 8.1 cc, r = 0.99, SEE = 8 cc. With use of this regression equation, values for left ventricular volumes and ejection fraction were calculated from biplane oblique (30 ° right anterior oblique/60 ° left anterior oblique) cineanglograms In 17 normal adults. Values for end-diastolic volume index (72 ± 15 cc/m² [mean ± standard deviation]), end-systolic volume index (20 ± 8 cc/m²), stroke volume Index (51 ± 10 cc/m²) and ejection fraction (0.72 ± 0.08) were similar to those reported by others. Examination of the effects of variable obliquity suggests that strict standardization of the degree of obliquity is necessary to offset variation In the long axis in the left anterior oblique projection caused by foreshortening.     

Determination of left ventricular volumes by Simpson''s rule in infants and children with congenital heart disease.

Regression equations were developed from left ventricular casts of known volumes to calculate left ventricular volumes from biplane cineangiography obtained in non-standard views. Volumes were calculated by Simpson's rule from casts of postmortem specimens from patients with congenital heart disease. The casts were divided into two groups: those that came from patients with abnormal right ventricular haemodynamic function (group 1, n = 11) and those that came from patients in which it was normal (group 2, n = 9). Biplane cinegrams were taken in conventional (anteroposterior/lateral, right anterior oblique/left anterior oblique) and non-conventional (long axis oblique, hepatoclavicular, and sitting up) projections. The true volume of each cast was determined from its weight and specific gravity. Correlations between measured and true volumes (r = 0.96 to 0.99) were excellent in all projections, although each projection overestimated the true volumes (slope = 0.72 to 0.94). The regression equations obtained from conventional views were significantly different from those from the non-conventional views; however, the regression slopes in group 1 were not different from those in group 2 in any view. Regression equations obtained by Simpson's rule do not seem to be affected by the haemodynamic state of the right ventricle. Different regression equations are required to measure left ventricular volumes from non-conventional angiograms.     

A novel technique using biplane cine magnetic resonance imaging to evaluate left ventricular volume in children

The purpose of the study is to determine the feasibility of a novel simplified technique using cine magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) to assess left ventricular (LV) volume and ejection fraction (EF) validated by comparison with biplane LV angiography. Previous MRI studies to assess LV volumes have used multiple axial planes, which are compromised by partial volume effects and are time consuming to acquire and analyze. Accordingly, we developed a simplified imaging approach using biplane cine MRI and imaging planes aligned with the intrinsic cardiac axes of the LV. We studied 20 children (aged 4 months to 10 years) with various heart diseases. The accuracy of cine MRI was compared with that of LV angiography in all patients. LV volumes were calculated using Simpson's rule algorithm, for both MRI and LV angiography. LV volumes determined from MRI were slightly underestimated but correlated reasonably well with angiographic volumes (LVEDV: Y = 0.88X + 1.58, r = 0.99, LVESV: Y = 0.73X + 1.03, r = 0.98). Most importantly, even in patients who had abnormal ventricular curvature such as in tetralogy of Fallot, MRI determined LV volumes correlated well with angiographic values. The MR study was completed within 35 min in all patients. In conclusion, simplified biplane cine MRI, using the intrinsic LV axis planes, permits noninvasive assessment of LV volumes in views comparable to standard angiographic projections and appears practical for clinical use in childhood heart disease since the scan and analysis times are relatively short.     

Validation of attenuation-corrected equilibrium radionuclide angiographic determinations of right ventricular volume: comparison with cast-validated biplane cineventriculography

To determine the accuracy of attenuation-corrected equilibrium radionuclide angiographic determinations of right ventricular volumes, we initially studied 14 postmortem human right ventricular casts by water displacement and biplane cineventriculography. Biplane cineventriculographic right ventricular cast volumes, calculated by a modification of Simpson's rule algorithm, correlated well with right ventricular cast volumes measured by water displacement (r = .97, y = 8 + 0.88x, SEE = 6 ml). Moreover, the mean volumes obtained by both methods were no different (73 +/- 28 vs 73 +/- 25 ml). Subsequently, we studied 16 patients by both biplane cineventriculography and equilibrium radionuclide angiography. The uncorrected radionuclide right ventricular volumes were calculated by normalizing background corrected end-diastolic and end-systolic counts from hand-drawn regions of interest obtained by phase analysis for cardiac cycles processed, frame rate, and blood sample counts. Attenuation correction was performed by a simple geometric method. The attenuation-corrected radionuclide right ventricular end-diastolic volumes correlated with the cineventriculographic end-diastolic volumes (r = .91, y = 3 + 0.92x, SEE = 27 ml). Similarly, the attenuation-corrected radionuclide right ventricular end-systolic volumes correlated with the cineventriculographic end-systolic volumes (r = .93, y = - 1 + 0.91x, SEE = 16 ml). Also, the mean attenuation-corrected radionuclide end-diastolic and end-systolic volumes were no different than the average cineventriculographic end-diastolic and end-systolic volumes (160 +/- 61 and 83 +/- 44 vs 170 +/- 61 and 86 +/- 43 ml, respectively). Comparison of the uncorrected and attenuation-corrected radionuclide right ventricular volumes demonstrated narrower 95% confidence intervals for the attentuation-corrected right ventricular volume determinations over a wide range of cineventriculographic volumes. Thus we conclude that: (1) attenuation-corrected radionuclide right ventricular end-diastolic and end-systolic volumes compare closely with those obtained by a cast-validated biplane cineventriculographic method and (2) attenuation-corrected radionuclide right ventricular volumes correspond more closely to determinations of biplane cineventriculographic right ventricular volumes and are thus likely to be more accurate than uncorrected radionuclide right ventricular volumes.     

Comparison of single and biplane ventriculography for determination of left ventricular volume and ejection fraction.

This study was done to compare single and biplane left ventriculography in quantitating left ventricular (LV) volumes and ejection fraction. LV volumes and ejection fraction were measured from a 30 degrees right anterior oblique single plane ventriculogram and a 30 degrees right anterior oblique 60 degrees left anterior oblique biplane ventriculogram in 152 men (aged 59 +/- 9 [mean +/- standard deviation] years), of whom 102 had hypokinesia, akinesia, or dyskinesia. There was excellent agreement between the results of single and biplane ventriculography with respect to LV end-diastolic volume (r = 0.96), end-systolic volume (r = 0.98) and ejection fraction (r = 0.97). The end-diastolic and end-systolic volumes measured by biplane ventriculography were consistently slightly larger than those measured by single plane, whereas ejection fractions measured by the 2 techniques were remarkably similar, even for the 46 patients with biplane ejection fractions less than 0.50 and the 102 with hypokinesia, akinesia or dyskinesia. Thus, LV volumes and ejection fractions determined by single plane ventriculography correlate very well with those determined by biplane ventriculography, even in patients with hypokinesia, akinesia, or dyskinesia and depressed LV systolic performance. Biplane ventriculography appears to provide little information that cannot be obtained reliably from single plane.     

Accuracy of precordial palpation for detecting increased left ventricular volume

Objective data on the reliability of precordial palpation in detecting left ventricular enlargement are scarce. Therefore, we evaluated 41 patients by physical examination and two-dimensional echocardiography to determine the relation between the location of the apex and left ventricular end-diastolic volume. An apical impulse lateral to the mid-clavicular line or greater than 10 cm from the mid-sternal line was sensitive but not specific as an indicator of left ventricular enlargement. In patients without left ventricular hypertrophy, an apical diameter greater than 3 cm in the left lateral decubitus was sensitive (92%) and specific (91%) for an enlarged left ventricle. The positive and negative predictive values were 86% and 95% respectively. Therefore, the location of the apical impulse in relation to the mid-clavicular line or the mid-sternal line is not a reliable indicator of increased left ventricular end-diastolic volume. However, an apical impulse greater than 3 cm may be an accurate indicator of left ventricular enlargement.     

Correlation of left ventricular angiographic casts and biplane left ventricular volumetry in infants and children

To calculate left ventricular (LV) volumes from biplane cineangiography obtained in nonstandard views, regression equations were developed from LV casts of known volume. Volumes were calculated by the area-length method from casts ranging from 1.4 to 48.9 ml obtained from 30 postmortem cases with heart disease. The casts were divided into 2 groups: group I (n = 17) with abnormal and group II (n = 13) with normal right ventricular hemodynamics. Biplane cinegrams were taken in the anterolateral, anterior and long axial oblique, hepatoclavicular and sitting-up projections. The true volume of each cast was determined from its weight and specific gravity. In both groups, excellent correlations were obtained between measured and true volumes (r = 0.92 to 0.99) in all projections, although each projection overestimated the true volume (slope value less than 1). The regression equations obtained from group I were significantly different from those in group II in all views (p less than 0.025 to 0.05), with smaller mean differences and standard errors of the estimate. These data support the concept that right ventricular hemodynamics influence ventricular septal position and, therefore, LV geometry and measured volumes. Appropriate regression equations are required to allow volume calculation from multiple projections.     

Reproducibility of left ventricular area and volume measurements using a computer endocardial edge-detection algorithm in normal subjects

The variability of serially recorded 2-dimensional echocardiograms in normal subjects was determined. During a 2-week period, 10 normal subjects underwent echocardiography 5 times, in 2 laboratories, with use of different ultrasonographs. The video recordings were analyzed using a computer image analysis system (Quantic 1200) to provide standardized left ventricular short-axis areas and area ejection fraction (EF). Left ventricular volumes and volume EF were calculated. The 95% confidence limits of the percent difference for end-diastolic area and volume between 2 samples in a given subject were +/- 16.8 and +/- 16.7%, respectively. The limits for end-systolic area and volume were +/- 15.8 and +/- 17.0%, respectively. The 95% confidence limits for differences of area and volume EF between 2 recordings were +/- 12.8 and +/- 9.7%, respectively. No correlation was found between clinical grade (image quality) and the variability of area measurements. A good correlation (r = 0.98) was found between area and volume EF for any given subject over the 5 observations. These confidence limits are narrower than those previously recorded.     

Accuracy of biplane analysis of left ventricular ejection fraction based on two consecutive single plane studies

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Mainly due to the high costs of biplane equipment many cardiac laboratories run single plane angiographic equipment only. Consequently, a biplane ventriculogram may only be done with two consecutive single plane studies. The aim of this investigation was to assess the accuracy of a biplane analysis of two consecutive single plane studies. METHODS: A total of 42 patients (62 +/- 10 years, 76% males), able to tolerate two consecutive ventriculograms without arrhythmia during the first study underwent two consecutive biplane studies (LAO 60, RA0 30), using 40 ml of contrast each. After the first injection, the x-ray tube was moved in a neutral position, and then was replaced in the 30 RAO/60 LAO position. Digital data was analyzed by two separate investigators using commercially available software. RESULTS: Intra-observer variability of left ventricular ejection fraction (LVEF) showed a high degree of agreement (single plane 1 vs. 2: r = 0.98; standard error of regression (Sy.x.): 2.8); the variability was slightly higher with two investigators (single plane: r = 0.92, Sy.x: 5.5 ) and with biplane analysis (biplane 1 vs. 2: r = 0.90, Sy. x: 5.7). End-diastolic volume index (EDVI) increased significantly from the first to the second study (84 +/- 28 ml/m2 vs 87 +/- 30 ml/m2; p = 0.017): Still LVEF of the two consecutive biplane studies showed very good agreement (biplane 1 vs. 2: mean difference (MD), -1.0; standard deviation of the difference (SDD), 5.2%). This agreement was almost as good as the one of LVEF values calculated from two consecutive single plane, but biplane analyzed studies compared to simultaneous biplane studies (MD, -0.5; SDD, 4.3%). CONCLUSION: Despite the significant increase in EDVI after contrast injection, LVEF values determined from two consecutive studies remained virtually unchanged. Biplane analysis of LVEF values based on consecutive single plane studies resulted in similar and reliable values as determined by two consecutive biplane studies.     

Radionuclide left ventricular absolute volume determination by ejection fraction measurement data and a left posterior oblique blood pool image

A new method for the calculation of left ventricular volumes called the "semi-geometric" method, was reported by Nichols et al in 1984. This method, however, still had certain limitations for practical use. This paper describes a modified semi-geometric method in which the left ventricular volume was obtained from conventional left ventricular ejection fraction measurement data collected from the modified left anterior oblique position with a caudal tilt of 10 degrees or more and a left posterior oblique blood pool image. The left ventricular end-diastolic volumes obtained by this method were compared with those calculated by combining the thermodilution cardiac output and the left ventricular ejection fraction. The correlation coefficient was r = 0.93 (n = 20). In the phantom experiment, the true volumes and those obtained by this method showed an excellent correlation (r = 0.99). This method is considered accurate and practical.     

Accuracy of left ventricular ejection fraction using the nuclear stethoscope in left ventricular aneurysm

Although the nuclear stethoscope, a nonimaging probe, accurately determines left ventricular (LV) ejection fraction (EF), its reliability in patients with LV aneurysm has not been established. Accordingly, LVEF was determined using the nuclear stethoscope and compared with that determined by equilibrium gated blood pool scanning in 29 patients, 1 studied on 2 separate occasions, for a total of 30 patient studies. Patient studies were separated into 2 groups. Patients in group I (n = 20) had no gated blood pool evidence for aneurysm, and those in group II (n = 10) had discrete focal akinesia or dyskinesia. Nineteen patients (13 in group I and 6 in group II) had 2 separate nuclear stethoscope acquisitions. In group I, EF determined by gated blood pool scanning (53 +/- 4%, mean +/- standard error) did not differ from that determined by nuclear stethoscope (51 +/- 4%). EF determined using either gated blood pool scanning (32 +/- 6%) or nuclear stethoscope (35 +/- 5%) was significantly lower in group II than in group I, although nuclear stethoscope and gated blood pool scanning did not differ. Reproducibility was excellent (r = 0.96). Overall, nuclear stethoscope and gated blood pool EFs correlated closely (r = 0.93), and the correlation coefficients were similar in groups I (r = 0.92) and II (r = 0.92). The slopes of the regression curves for group I (0.97) and group II (0.92) were not statistically different. These results confirm the accuracy and reproducibility of LVEF determination by nuclear stethoscope and specifically demonstrate its reliability in patients with LV aneurysm.     

Comparison of single plane videodensitometry-based right ventricular ejection fraction in right and left anterior oblique views to biplane geometry-based right ventricular ejection fraction

To evaluate the reliability of the videodensitometric assessment of right ventricular ejection fraction, 38 patients were studied during diagnostic cardiac catheterization. Digital subtraction images of the right ventricle were obtained in both the right anterior oblique and the left anterior oblique views, using direct intraventricular injection of dilute contrast medium. From the end-diastolic and end-systolic images obtained in each view, analysis of the relative brightness values generated a videodensitometry-based right ventricular ejection fraction for both the right and the left anterior oblique views. These values were compared with those generated by applying the geometry-based Simpson's rule to the orthogonal images. Right ventricular ejection fraction ranged from 22 to 88%. Videodensitometric ejection fraction in the right anterior oblique view correlated well with that in the left anterior oblique view (r = 0.88) and each correlated well with geometry-based ejection fraction (r = 0.91 and 0.82, respectively). In a subset of 18 patients without significant cardiac disease, mean videodensitometric right ventricular ejection fraction was 68% (versus 61% in the abnormal subset), and it correlated closely with left ventricular ejection fraction (r = 0.82). Videodensitometric analysis of digital subtraction images provides a reliable method for calculating right ventricular ejection fraction that is independent of geometry and reliably separates normal from abnormal values. Application of videodensitometric techniques should simplify analysis of the response of the right ventricle to different interventions in patients with cardiac disease.