Three Preservation Solutions for Cold Storage of Heart Allografts: A Systematic Review and Meta‐Analysis

Organ preservation solution has been designed to attenuate the detrimental effects during the ischemic period. The aim of this study was to systematically evaluate the evidence comparing preservation solutions for heart preservation. Studies were searched in PubMed, Embase, the Cochrane Library, the Transplant Library, and the International Clinical Trials Registry Platform. The primary outcomes were patient survival and donor heart dysfunction. The secondary outcomes were in‐hospital mortality and enzyme gene expression. The University of Wisconsin solution (UW) was associated with a significantly improved survival at 30 days and 90 days (hazard ratio = 1.16, 95% confidence interval [CI] = 1.11–1.22, P < 0.00001; risk difference [RD] = 0.03, 95% CI = 0.01–0.05, P = 0.002), compared with Celsior. Hearts preserved with UW exhibited less ischemic necrosis than those preserved with Celsior (RD = ?0.07, 95% CI = ?0.08 to 0.05, P < 0.00001). UW was associated with better survival compared with histidine–tryptophan–ketoglutarate solution (HTK). There was no statistical difference in donor heart dysfunction and in‐hospital mortality outcomes when comparing HTK with Celsior solution. During static cold storage preservation, this study suggests that UW solution has better clinical outcomes for heart transplantation compared with the other two organ preservation solutions. Besides, the protective effect of Celsior solution is similar to HTK solution in donor heart preservation.     

A preliminary report of the HTK randomized multicenter study comparing kidney graft preservation with HTK and EuroCollins solutions

The main goal of transplantation is to restore good renal function and to improve the quality of life of thousands of dialysis patients, something which can only be achieved by providing them with well functioning grafts. Delayed renal allograft function is a serious problem. It is important to prevent this complication because it makes the diagnosis of acute rejection in the early postoperative period difficult, increases the necessity for diagnostic procedures, introduces dialysis treatments and prolongs hospital stay. The aetiology of delayed graft function (DGF) is multifactorial, and factors including donor management, technique used for organ procurement and preservation, age, anatomical variations in the graft, ischemia periods, use of cyclosporine A (CyA) or recipient immunological reactions have been implicated. Using different preservation solutions DGF rates vary from 30% to 60%. Recent clinical data have demonstrated better preservation and improved renal function posttransplant with HTK and University of Wisconsin (UW) solutions compared to EuroCollins solution. In a randomized multicenter study in collaboration with the Eurotransplant organ exchange organization, the efficacy of the HTK solution in renal transplantation was compared to EuroCollins and UW solutions in two parallel prospective randomized trials. The first preliminary results comparing HTK and EuroCollins solutions are reported here.     

Celsior solution compared with University of Wisconsin solution (UW) and histidine–tryptophan–ketoglutarate solution (HTK) in the protection of human hepatocytes against ischemia–reperfusion injury

Celsior, a new preservation solution in thoracic organ transplantation was evaluated for efficacy in cold preservation of human hepatocytes and compared with University of Wisconsin solution (UW) and histidine-tryptophan-ketoglutarate solution (HTK, Custodiol). Human hepatocyte cultures were preserved at 4 degrees C in Celsior, UW and HTK for 2, 6, 12, 24 and 48 h with 6 h of reperfusion. Levels of lactate dehydrogenase (LDH; cell necrosis), 3-(4,5-dimethylthiazol-2-yl)-2,5-diphenyltetrazolium bromide (MTT; mitochondrial function), and adenosine 5'-triphosphate (ATP; loss of intracellular energy) were measured. Cell necrosis, mitochondrial dysfunction, and loss of ATP were significantly ( P<0.001, P<0.001, P<0.002, respectively) lower in Celsior than in HTK. The amount of cell necrosis and mitochondrial dysfunction in Celsior solution (CS) and UW was equal ( P=n.s.) up to 24 h and significantly lower in UW after 48 h ( P<0.001). Additionally, the intracellular level of ATP was significantly higher after ischemia ( P<0.001) and reperfusion from long-term ischemia (24, 48 h) ( P<0.002). We can conclude that Celsior was superior to HTK and equal to UW in the protection of human hepatocytes against cold preservation injury from ischemia and reperfusion. Furthermore, Celsior was effective in long-term preservation of human hepatocytes.     

Comparison of histidine-tryptophan ketoglutarate solution and University of Wisconsin solution in prolonged cold preservation of kidney allografts

Although University of Wisconsin (UW) solution is the standard preservation solution for organ transplantation, Histidine-Tryptophan Ketogluatarate (HTK) solution has been increasingly used. This study compared HTK or UW for cold static storage of kidney allografts. In all, 149 renal transplants were performed with cold ischemic times (CI) greater than 16 hr (UW 87, HTK 62) and a subset analysis was performed with CI over 24 hr (HTK 31, UW 38). Data from receiving renal transplant centers focused on delayed graft function (DGF), patient and allograft survival. In CI greater than 16 hr, graft and patient survival were comparable. HTK cohort had lower DGF. In CI greater than 24 hr, there was no difference in patient survival, a trend towards improved graft survival in HTK, and decreased rate of DGF in HTK. This data suggests that UW and HTK have at least similar efficacy in kidney preservation at longer ischemic times.     

Comparison of Histidine-Tryptophan-Ketoglutarate and University of Wisconsin Preservation in Renal Transplantation

Histidine-tryptophan-ketoglutarate (HTK) is replacing University of Wisconsin (UW) solution as the preservation fluid for renal allografts in many centers, but recent large-scale data to support this transition are lacking. We conducted a retrospective analysis of patient and graft outcomes after renal transplantation at our center, comparing 475 consecutive living donor and 317 deceased donor transplants since the adoption of HTK with equal numbers of grafts preserved using UW solution. Data collected included donor and recipient age, race, sex, comorbidities and graft ischemia time. Graft and patient survival, as well as the incidence of delayed graft function (DGF), were studied by Kaplan–Meier and Cox regression analysis. No significant difference was seen in either patient or graft survival. Deceased donor kidneys in the HTK group had a higher incidence of DGF than the UW cohort, whereas this trend was reversed in the case of living donor organs. In multivariate analysis, HTK was associated with a significant risk reduction on the incidence of DGF. Prolonged preservation with HTK compared to UW was not associated with excess risk to the graft or patient. In summary, HTK demonstrated efficacy similar to UW in terms of patient and graft survival.     

Evaluation of rat liver apoptotic and necrotic cell death after cold storage using UW,HTK, and Celsior

BACKGROUND: The benefit of Celsior in liver graft preservation is controversial. In the isolated perfused rat liver model, we compared the effects of Celsior, University of Wisconsin (UW), and histidine-tryptophan-ketoglutarate (HTK) preservation solutions on liver cell death. METHODS: Rat livers were stored at 4 degrees C for 0, 8, 16, or 24 hr in either Celsior, UW, or HTK and reperfused for 90 min (37 degrees C). Bile secretion and perfusate levels of liver enzymes and histone-associated DNA fragments were measured. Apoptosis and oncotic necrosis were analyzed in biopsies by DNA gel electrophoresis, hematoxylin and eosin histology, and enzyme histochemistry for lactate dehydrogenase (LDH) and 5'-nucleotidase (5'-NT). RESULTS: Perfusate flow rate through the liver during perfusion did not significantly differ among preservation solutions. Bile secretion was best preserved in UW livers after 16-hr (versus HTK livers) and 24-hr storage (versus HTK and Celsior livers). Enzyme leakage from UW livers was lower compared with HTK livers after 8-hr storage (serum glutamic oxaloacetic transaminase [SGOT], LDH) and with Celsior and HTK livers after 16-hr (SGOT, LDH) and 24-hr storage (SGOT, serum glutamic pyruvic transaminase, LDH, purine nucleoside phosphorylase). In situ LDH and 5'-NT activities were best preserved in UW livers (up to 24 hr), whereas enzyme activities declined remarkably in HTK livers (after 8 hr) and Celsior livers (after 16 hr of cold storage). Although perfusate DNA fragment levels were repeatedly lowest from Celsior livers, apoptotic DNA laddering and the number of fragmented nuclei in hematoxylin and eosin sections was not different among livers after 8, 16, or 24 hr of storage. CONCLUSIONS: Celsior and UW are equally effective in preventing rat liver cell death after 0-16 hr of cold preservation as compared with the less effective HTK solution. After 24-hr cold storage, rat livers were best preserved in UW. Furthermore, there was no significant difference in mode of cell death (apoptosis or oncotic necrosis) after storage in any of the three solutions.     

Histidine-Tryptophan-Ketoglutarate (HTK) Is Associated with Reduced Graft Survival of Deceased Donor Kidney Transplants

Single-center studies have reported equivalent outcomes of kidney allografts recovered with histidine-tryptophan-ketoglutarate (HTK) or University of Wisconsin (UW) solution. However, these studies were likely underpowered and often unadjusted, and multicenter studies have suggested HTK preservation might increase delayed graft function (DGF) and reduce graft survival of renal allografts. To further inform clinical practice, we analyzed the United Network for Organ Sharing (UNOS) database of deceased donor kidney transplants performed from July 2004 to February 2008 to determine if HTK (n = 5728) versus UW (n = 15 898) preservation impacted DGF or death-censored graft survival. On adjusted analyses, HTK preservation had no effect on DGF (odds ratio [OR] 0.99, p = 0.7) but was associated with an increased risk of death-censored graft loss (hazard ratio [HR] 1.20, p = 0.008). The detrimental effect of HTK was a relatively late one, with a strong association between HTK and subsequent graft loss in those surviving beyond 12 months (HR 1.43, p = 0.007). Interestingly, a much stronger effect was seen in African-American recipients (HR 1.55, p = 0.024) than in Caucasian recipients (HR 1.18, p = 0.5). Given recent studies that also demonstrate that HTK preservation reduces liver and pancreas allograft survival, we suggest that the use of HTK for abdominal organ recovery should be reconsidered.     

不同器官保存液对大鼠肝脏缺血再灌注损伤时嘌呤核苷磷酸酶活性和透明质酸吸收率的影响

目的 探讨大鼠肝脏低温保存及常温缺血再灌注过程中在不同的保存液中嘌呤核苷磷酸酶(PNP)活性和透明质酸(HA)吸收率的变化.方法 将大鼠肝脏在三种不同保存液中低温保存16 h和24 h后,用37℃Krebs-Henseleit液连续循环灌注90 min,分别于不同灌注时间检测灌洗液中PNP活性和外源性透明质酸的吸收率的变化.结果 经过16 h的低温保存后,再灌注60 min前,HTK保存的肝脏中PNP明显高于uw和Celsior;60 min后HTK和Celsior保存的肝脏中PNP明显高于UW;经过24 h的低温保存后,再灌注15 min后,HTK保存的肝脏中PNP明显高于Celsior,而Celsior又明显高于UW.低温保存16 h后,再灌注时,3种保存液保存的肝脏对外源性透明质酸的吸收率均为负值,表明肝窦内皮细胞受到一定程度的损伤;保存24 h者,UW液保存肝脏外源性透明质酸的吸收率明显高于Celsior液和HTK液.结论 随着低温保存和再灌注时间的延长,大鼠肝脏中PNP活性逐渐增高,而外源性透明质酸的吸收率下降;二者可作为评价肝脏缺血再灌注损伤的指标.     

A comparative study of the most widely used solutions for cardiac graft preservation during hypothermia.

BACKGROUND: Reports conflict on the benefits of preservative solutions. We investigated the efficacy of the most widely used cardioplegic solutions by comparing extracellular solutions such as Celsior solution, St. Thomas Hospital solutions 1 and 2 (STH-1, STH-2), the modified University of Wisconsin solution (UW-1), Lyon Preservation solution (LYPS) from our laboratory, and intracellular solutions such as standard University of Wisconsin solution (UW), Bretschneider solution (HTK), Stanford solution (STF), and Euro-Collins solution (EC). METHODS: Male rats (n = 110) were randomized into 11 groups: LYPS, Celsior, STH-1, STH-2, UW-1, UW, HTK, STF, EC, and normal saline solution groups, and a control group. All hearts, except controls, were preserved by cold storage (8 hours at 4 degrees C) in the various solutions. We used an isolated non-working-heart model and biopsy specimens to assess heart preservation (n = 5/group). RESULTS: Hearts stored in the EC and saline solutions had poor left ventricular developed pressure (LVDP) x heart rate (HR) (1,407.5 +/- 154 and 1,390 +/- 439 mm Hg/mn, respectively). In contrast, hearts stored in LYPS and Celsior had a LVDP x HR close to control hearts (31,349 +/- 1,847, 27,620 +/- 1,207, and 36,627 +/- 1,322 mm Hg/mn, respectively), whereas hearts stored in STH-1, STH-2, UW-1, UW, HTK, and STF had intermediate functional response (14,278 +/- 2,176, 12,402 +/- 1,571, 11,428 +/- 1,629, 11,603 +/- 2,521, 7,045 +/- 537, and 7,086 +/- 1,206 mm Hg/mn, respectively). Hearts preserved with STH-2, UW, HTK, STF, EC, and saline solution showed significantly increased release of creatine kinase and lactate dehydrogenase than did control hearts or hearts preserved in Celsior, LYPS, STH-1, and UW-1. The energetic charge (EC = [(0.5 adenosine diphosphate + adenosine triphosphate) / (adenosine triphosphate + adenosine diphosphate + adenosine monophosphate)]) in STH-2, UW, HTK, STF, EC, and saline groups was significantly lower (p < 0.05) than in the other groups. CONCLUSION: Extracellular-type solutions provided better preservation than did intracellular-type solutions. However, UW and UW-1 (intracellular- and extracellular-type solutions) provided equivalent preservation of cardiac function. Preservation quality may be attributed to calcium, often added to extracellular solutions. Among extracellular solutions, Celsior and LYPS solution showed comparable efficacy on left ventricular function and seemed to offer better preservation than the other solutions tested in this study.     

Initial experience using histidine-tryptophan-ketoglutarate solution in clinical pancreas transplantation

BACKGROUND: The colloid-based University of Wisconsin (UW) preservation solution has been used extensively in clinical pancreas transplantation. Experimental studies support the use of the crystalloid-based histidine-tryptophan-ketoglutarate (HTK) preservation solution for this purpose. AIM: We report our initial experience with HTK for pancreas allograft preservation and compare this to a contemporary experience with UW solution in conventional multiorgan deceased donors (<50 yr). MATERIALS AND METHODS: Retrospectively collected information on 33 pancreas transplants between September 2001 and October 2002 were analyzed for early graft function and complications up to 30 d after procurement and storage in either HTK or UW solutions. During multi-organ recovery, either UW solution (4-5 L) or HTK solution (8-10 L) was used for aortic perfusion and subsequent back-table flush and storage. Exocrine drainage of 31 pancreas allografts was enteric, while the bladder was used for drainage in two cases. Patient outcomes were analyzed according to the preservation solution used. Sixteen pancreata were used in combination with a kidney allograft (SPK), seven were used in patients after prior kidney transplantation (PAK), while 10 were used in patients who were not in renal failure (PTA). RESULTS: The UW group consisted of 17 patients (10 SPK, three PAK, four PTA) with a mean donor age of 29.5 +/- 10.7, and a mean cold ischemia time of 15.1 +/- 2.1 h. The mean post-transplant pancreas and kidney function on days 1 and 10 were amylase (315 and 99 IU/L), lipase (1727 and 346 IU/L), glucose (121 and 100 mg/dL) and creatinine (5.01 and 1.77 mg/dL). Patient and graft survival was 100% at 1-month post transplant. In the HTK group there were 16 patients (six SPK, four PAK, six PTA) with a mean donor age 21.9 +/- 5.7 and a mean cold ischemia time 14.0 +/- 1.3 h. The mean post-transplant pancreas and kidney function on days 1 and 10 were amylase (588 and 126 IU/L), lipase (4711 and 441 IU/L), glucose (97 and 109 mg/dL) and creatinine (5.28 and 2.42 mg/dL). Patient survival was 100% while graft survival was 94% at 1-month post-transplant. CONCLUSIONS: Early graft function and complications are comparable with HTK and UW solutions for pancreas allograft preservation.     

The effect of IGL-1 preservation solution on outcome after kidney transplantation: A retrospective single-center analysis

Institut Georges Lopez-1 (IGL-1) solution is increasingly used for kidney preservation, although little information on outcomes is available. Outcomes of all deceased donor kidneys preserved by IGL-1, University of Wisconsin solution (UW), or histidine-tryptophan-ketoglutarate (HTK) and transplanted in our center (2000-2018) were analyzed. Multivariable analysis for delayed graft function (DGF), functional DGF, estimated glomerular filtration rate (eGFR, CKD-EPI equation), proteinuria, acute rejection, death-censored graft loss, and patient survival were performed. A double robust approach, consisting of propensity score weighting and correction for confounders, minimized the risk of bias. In total, 1943 transplants were included: 234 with IGL-1, 1046 with UW, and 663 with HTK. As IGL-1 was only introduced in 2014, a prespecified sensitivity analysis of 917 kidneys (2010-2018) was performed using the same statistical approach. After weighting, IGL-1 retained a higher proportion of kidneys donated after circulatory death (DCD). IGL-1 was not independently associated with any of the outcomes when compared to UW or HTK. Sensitivity analysis between 2010 and 2018 showed similar results. In this retrospective analysis, using robust methodology to reduce the risk of bias, IGL-1 preservation results in equal outcomes compared to UW or HTK, despite more DCD transplants in the IGL-1 group.     

UW is superior to Celsior and HTK in the protection of human liver endothelial cells against preservation injury.

Celsior solution (CS), a new preservation solution in thoracic organ transplantation, was evaluated for its efficacy in cold preservation of human liver endothelial cells (HLEC) and was compared to University of Wisconsin solution (UW) and histidine-tryptophan-ketoglutarate solution (HTK, Custodiol). HLEC cultures were preserved at 4 degrees C in CS, UW, and HTK, for 2, 6, 12, 24, and 48 hours, with 6 hours of reperfusion. Levels of lactate dehydrogenase (LDH), 3-(4,5-dimethylthiazol-2-yl)-2,5-diphenyltetrazolium bromide (MTT), and adenosine 5'-triphosphate (ATP) were measured after each interval of ischemia and the respective phase of reperfusion. Preservation injury of HLEC as measured by LDH release, intracellular ATP level, and MTT reduction were overall significantly (P CS > HTK.     

Induction of necrosis and DNA fragmentation during hypothermic preservation of hepatocytes in UW,HTK, and Celsior solutions

Donor cells can be preserved in University of Wisconsin (UW), histidine-tryptophan-ketoglutarate (HTK), or Celsior solution. However, differences in efficacy and mode of action in preventing hypothermia-induced cell injury have not been unequivocally clarified. Therefore, we investigated and compared necrotic and apoptotic cell death of freshly isolated primary porcine hepatocytes after hypothermic preservation in UW, HTK, and Celsior solutions and subsequent normothermic culturing. Hepatocytes were isolated from porcine livers, divided in fractions, and hypothermically (4 degrees C) stored in phosphate-buffered saline (PBS), UW, HTK, or Celsior solution. Cell necrosis and apoptosis were assessed after 24- and 48-h hypothermic storage and after 24-h normothermic culturing following the hypothermic preservation periods. Necrosis was assessed by trypan blue exclusion, lactate dehydrogenase (LDH) release, and mitochondrial 3-[4,5-dimethylthiazol-2-yl]-2,5-diphenyltetrazolium bromide (MTT) reduction. Apoptosis was assessed by the induction of histone-associated DNA fragments and cellular caspase-3 activity. Trypan blue exclusion, LDH release, and MTT reduction of hypothermically preserved hepatocytes showed a decrease in cell viability of more than 50% during the first 24 h of hypothermic preservation. Cell viability was further decreased after 48-h preservation. DNA fragmentation was slightly enhanced in hepatocytes after preservation in all solutions, but caspase-3 activity was not significantly increased in these cells. Normothermic culturing of hypothermically preserved cells further decreased cell viability as assessed by LDH release and MTT reduction. Normothermic culturing of hypothermically preserved hepatocytes induced DNA fragmentation, but caspase-3 activity was not hanced in these cells. Trypan blue exclusion, LDH leakage, and MTT reduction demonstrated the highest cell viability after storage in Celsior, and DNA fragmentation was the lowest in cells that had been stored in PBS and UW solutions. None of the preservation solutions tested in this study was capable of adequately preventing cell death of isolated porcine hepatocytes after 24-h hypothermic preservation and subsequent 24-h normothermic culturing. Culturing of isolated and hypothermically preserved hepatocytes induces DNA fragmentation, but does not lead to caspase-3 activation. With respect to necrosis and DNA fragmentation of hypothermically preserved cells, UW and Celsior were superior to PBS and HTK solutions in this model of isolated porcine hepatocyte preservation.     

Pulmonary preservation with Bretscheider''s HTK and Celsior solution in minipigs

Background: Pulmonary preservation with high potassium/low oncotic pressure Euro-Collins (EC) solution is associated with endothelial dysfunction and reduced surfactant function. We compared two low potassium solutions, histidine-tryptophane-ketoglutarate (HTK) and Celsior, to EC in lung ischemia-reperfusion injury. Methods: In 19 minipigs, the left lung was perfused in situ with cold preservation solution (EC, n=6; HTK, n=6; Celsior, n=7). Reperfusion was started after 90 min of warm ischemia. The right pulmonary artery and main bronchus were clamped. Bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) was obtained before ischemia and after 2 h of reperfusion. Surfactant activity was determined from the BAL in a pulsating bubble surfactometer. Results: Animals in the EC group survived 3.7±1.4 h. Six Celsior and five HTK treated animals survived the observation period of 7 h (P<0.001). Compliance of the reperfused lung deteriorated less in both Celsior and HTK groups (P<0.001). In EC and HTK animals, the pO₂/FiO₂ ratio was lower (P=0.002), and pulmonary vascular resistance was higher (P=0.02) than in Celsior animals. Surfactant function was impaired after reperfusion in all groups. Conclusions: Compared to EC, HTK solution showed moderate and Celsior distinct improvement of post-ischemic pulmonary function. However, surfactant function was not well preserved in any group.     

Comparison of histidine-tryptophan ketoglutarate and University of Wisconsin solutions as primary preservation in renal allografts undergoing pulsatile perfusion

INTRODUCTION: University of Wisconsin (UW) solution is the standard preservation solution for organ transplantation. Histidine-tryptophan ketogluatarate (HTK) solution has been used increasingly for kidney, pancreas, and liver transplantation. This study compared HTK and UW used during kidney procurement with subsequent pulsatile perfusion. METHODS: Between January and October 2003, 91 deceased renal and simultaneous kidney pancreas transplants were performed (UW, n = 41, and HTK, n = 50). There were no differences with regard to donor and recipient demographics or cold ischemia. RESULTS: Delayed graft function occurred in 3 (7%) of UW and 4 (8%) of HTK-preserved kidneys (P = NS). There were no significant differences between patient or graft survival. There was an anticipated difference between total preservative volumes used (HTK: 4.1 +/- 1.0 vs UW: 3.0 +/- 0.5; P < .005). CONCLUSION: UW and HTK appear to have similar efficacy in kidney preservation with pulsatile perfusion. HTK preservation solution can be used safely in conjunction with pulsatile preservation for cold storage of renal allografts.     

Increased Pancreatitis in Allografts Flushed with Histidine-Tryptophan-Ketoglutarate Solution: A Cautionary Tale

We reviewed pancreas transplantation outcomes after Histidine-Tryptophan-Ketoglutarate (HTK) and University of Wisconsin (UW) preservation solution use between 2001 and 2007 at two transplant centers. While equivalence has been claimed for kidney and liver transplant outcomes after the use of HTK or UW preservation solution, consensus has not been reached on equivalence when flushing pancreata. Others have reported comparable patient and graft survival rates, but found an association between the use of HTK and an increase in the incidence of acute rejection and pancreatitis. In reviewing our experiences, we found in pancreata flushed with HTK a higher incidence of postoperative complications including graft pancreatitis, use of octreotide and a decreased rate of insulin-independence at hospital discharge. These findings prompted us to critically review our centers' experience to determine if there is a basis for suspecting a causal relationship.     

Improved microcirculation by low‐viscosity histidine– tryptophan–ketoglutarate graft flush and subsequent cold storage in University of Wisconsin solution: results of an orthotopic rat liver transplantation model

As previously shown in a model of isolated rat liver perfusion, the combined use of an initial graft flush with low‐viscosity histidine–tryptophan–ketoglutarate (HTK) solution followed by cold storage in University of Wisconsin (UW) solution markedly improved the preservation during an extended cold storage period. In this study, we aimed to transfer our results into an in vivo model of orthotopic rat liver transplantation, and to elucidate the potential mechanism of the improved preservation by focusing on the hepatic microcirculation. Livers were harvested from male Wistar rats. Aortic perfusion with a pressure of 100 cm H₂O was performed with either UW (group UW) or HTK (groups UW and HTK_UW), followed by additional back‐table perfusion with UW (group HTK_UW). After 20‐h cold storage at 4 °C, livers were orthotopically transplanted with reconstructing the hepatic artery. As measured by bile flow and liver enzymes, HTK flush followed by UW storage was superior compared to single use of either UW or HTK solution. The hepatic microcirculation was significantly improved, as shown by the increased percentage of reperfused sinusoids and reduced sinusoidal leucostasis. HTK and UW effectively reduce ischaemia‐reperfusion injury after liver transplantation. By combining the comparative advantages of both solutions, a cumulative effect resulting in an improved preservation was shown. Thus, this mechanism improves microcirculatory reperfusion.     

Pancreas preservation with University of Wisconsin and Celsior solutions: a single-center, prospective, randomized pilot study

BACKGROUND: Celsior is an extracellular-type, low-viscosity, preservation solution already used for heart, lung, liver, and kidney transplantation. We report the results of a single-center, prospective, randomized pilot study specifically designed to compare the safety profile of Celsior solution with University of Wisconsin (UW) solution in clinical pancreas transplantation. METHODS: A total of 105 consecutive procurements were randomized to graft preservation with UW (n=53) solution or Celsior (n=52) solution. The groups were comparable with regard to all donor and recipient characteristics. RESULTS: Five grafts were discarded and 100 grafts (50 UW vs. 50 Celsior) were transplanted. Mean cold and warm ischemia times were 11.0 +/- 2.1 hr and 37.2 +/- 6.0 min for UW compared with 10.8 +/- 1.8 hr and 38.1 +/- 5.9 min for Celsior (P =not significant). Delayed endocrine pancreas function was recorded in one graft preserved with UW solution. Eleven recipients (UW 12% vs. Celsior 10%, P =not significant) required a relaparotomy. The mean serum levels of glucose, amylase, and lipase remained comparable between the study arms at equivalent intervals after transplantation. One recipient died with functioning grafts in each study arm; two further grafts were lost to arterial thrombosis (Celsior) and chronic rejection (UW), respectively. Actuarial 1-year patient and graft survival rates overlapped in the two study arms (98% and 96%, respectively). CONCLUSIONS: Within the range of cold ischemia time reported in this study, UW and Celsior solutions have similar safety profiles for pancreas preservation.     

UW与HTK保存液在肝脏移植术中临床效果对比的系统评价和meta分析

目的比较肝脏移植术中两种常用的器官保存液(UW液与HTK液)的临床效果。方法全面检索PubMed、Embase、Cochrane Library、中国期刊全文数据库、中国生物医学文献数据库、万方、维普等中英文数据库,纳入对比UW(UW液组)与HTK(HTK液组)两种保存液对移植肝脏保存效果的研究,提取资料并评价后用RevMan 5.3软件进行分析。结果最终纳入16篇文献共35 024例受者,meta分析结果显示,与UW液组比较,HTK液组的术后胆管并发症发生率[RR=1.30,95%CI(1.07,1.58),P=0.008]和术后7 d内天门冬氨酸氨基转移酶峰值[MD=112.45,95%CI(93.34,131.56),P<0.01]均较低,而术后移植肝原发性无功能发生率[RR=1.07,95%CI(0.52,2.18),P=0.86]、术后不同时间点移植肝和受者存活率(P>0.05)、术后再移植率[RR=0.83,95%CI(0.48,1.45),P=0.51]、急性排斥反应发生率[RR=1.27,95%CI(0.96,1.68),P=0.33]、7 d内丙氨酸氨基转移酶峰值[MD=31.79,95%CI(–161.84,225.42),P=0.75]、总胆红素水平[MD=19.42,95%CI(–10.83,49.67),P=0.21]、凝血酶原时间[MD=1.75,95%CI(0.01,3.49),P=0.838]等指标比较差异均无统计学意义。结论 HTK保存液对移植肝的保存安全且有效,具有与UW保存液相似的效果,关于二者对肝移植术后受者和移植肝远期存活率的影响仍需要大样本、高质量的随机对照试验研究来系统评价。     

Preservation solutions for transplantation.

Eurocollins has almost been abandoned because of the glucose disadvantage. UW is certainly the most used preservation solution for livers, kidneys, and pancreases with excellent clinical and experimental preservation data. UW can certainly be considered the current golden standard solution. However, the disadvantage of high viscosity, high price, uneasy handling of many 1-L bags, and the fact that the radical scavenger glutathion cannot be detected in the bags by chemical analysis (presumably due to diffusion) encourage competitors to produce new compounds with better cost to effect ratios. HTK has a firm place in cardiac preservation; by demonstration of equal safety and efficacy in preserving livers and kidneys, at least in the middle and lower range of cold ischemia time, HTK will be sued more frequently, particularly with the consideration of lower price and more easy handling aspects. The suggested high volume perfusion is not really necessary, calculation based on a total volume of 10 L for a multiorgan donor show significant cost reductions. Celsior is current only used for cardiac preservation. Beyond all aspects of conservation and preservation potencies of all these fluids, it must not be forgotten that cold ischemia itself is a risk factor for organ function. Therefore, cold ischemia time should be kept as short as possible. People are willing to accept 24 hours or more cold ischemia time in kidney transplantation because organ failure can be treated by dialysis. In other organs, where immediate organ function is essential, like in clinical heart transplantation, cold ischemia is hardly ever extended beyond 6 hours. Why are hearts and kidneys so different? Very likely, there is no difference, and the outstanding results in living unrelated kidney transplants is mostly due to short cold ischemia time.