Recording characteristics of monopolar EMG electrodes

Motor unit action potentials (MUAPs) and the electromyographic (EMG) interference pattern (IP) were recorded from the biceps muscle of 5 normal subjects using both a concentric needle (CN) and a disposable monopolar needle (MN) electrode. The MUAPs recorded by the MN electrode had higher amplitude and area and were more frequently complex than those recorded with the CN electrode. The MUAP duration and area: amplitude ratio were similar for both electrodes. Although the MN electrode had a larger recording surface, its dimensions (maximum diameter and length of the cone shaped tip) were similar to those of the CN electrode (minor and major axes of the elliptical recording tip). Based on these observations, we infer that the MN electrode may be more selective than the CN electrode, ie, the AP amplitude recorded by the MN electrode decreases faster than the AP amplitude recorded by a CN electrode when the distance of the muscle fiber from the recording electrode increases. Photomicrographs of the MN electrode after use demonstrated no evidence that the insulating material had peeled off. There was also no evidence that MUAP measurement values changed during the recordings as would be expected if the recording surface changed due to peeling of the insulating material.     

Detecting single fiber contributions to motor unit action potentials

The ability to detect muscle fiber action potential (MFAP) contributions to motor unit action potentials (MUAPs) measured using single fiber (SF) and concentric needle (CN) electrodes was studied using simulated MUAPs. Various MFAP-acceleration thresholds were used to define significant fiber contributions. Attempts to detect the significant MFAP contributions, by locating peaks in filtered MUAPs or MUAP accelerations using various MUAP-based thresholds, were then made. Considering filtered MUAPs and a significant contribution threshold of 7.5 kV/s2, and using fiber-density peak-detection criteria, at best 46% and 50% of significant MFAP contributions were detected for the SF and CN MUAPs, respectively. Considering MUAP accelerations and a significant contribution threshold of 7.5 kV/s2, 80% and 84% of significant MFAP contributions could be detected, respectively. Most significant contributions were created from fibers located within approximately 350 microm of the electrode. The results suggest that significant peaks, defined using MUAP-based thresholds, within the acceleration of CN MUAPs can strongly correspond to individual fiber activity and may be useful for measuring fiber density and neuromuscular jitter.     

The standard concentric needle cannula cannot replace the Macro EMG electrode

ObjectiveTo establish the usefulness of the single use and affordable standard concentric EMG electrode as a substitute for the expensive standard macro electrode.MethodsMacro EMG performed with macro electrode is compared with recordings from the uninsulated cannula of a standard EMG electrode at two different recording depths in the tibialis anterior muscle. This was performed both in muscles with signs of collateral reinnervation and without.ResultsThe amplitude of the motor units recorded with the uninsulated concentric needle cannula were lower for the deeply recorded motor units compared to motor unit potential (MUP) amplitudes recorded with the standard macro electrode. The deeply recorded concentric needle (CN) cannula recorded MUPs amplitudes were also lower than superficially recorded CN cannula MUPs. The standard Macro EMG signals show no difference between deeply and superficially recorded motor units.ConclusionThe uninsulated cannula of the concentric needle electrode cannot replace the standard Macro EMG electrode due to technical reasons, probably from different effects of shunting of the bare cannula in deep vs. superficially recorded motor units.SignificanceThe standard CN electrode could not be used as substitute for the standard Macro EMG needle.     

Pitfalls and errors in measuring jitter

The safety factor of neuromuscular transmission can be assessed by measuring the neuromuscular jitter, which reflects the time variability of processes in the motor end-plate. Jitter is increased in any condition with disturbed end-plate function, such as myasthenic conditions and ongoing reinnervation. Jitter is increasingly being measured with concentric needle (CN) electrodes, which are more prone to artefacts than single fiber EMG recordings.The objective of this review is to identify and demonstrate pitfalls that can be seen with CN jitter measurements, made with both voluntary activation and electrical stimulation.With voluntary activation, errors are caused by poor signal quality; inappropriate time reference points on the signal; an irregular firing rate; and signals with dual latencies, i.e., “flip-flop.” With electrical stimulation, additional errors result from insufficient stimulation intensity; from abrupt change in firing rate; and from axon reflexes.Many pitfalls cannot be avoided during recording and can only be detected during post-processing.It is critical to be aware of these artefacts when measuring jitter with CN electrodes.     

Concentric macro electromyography

Concentric EMG electrodes can record from a few (10 to 15) muscle fibers of a motor unit (MU). Macro EMG, is able to record from the majority of muscle fibers in the MU. The macro EMG electrode uses a single fiber action potential (SFAP) on one channel to trigger the time locked cannula (macro) response on the other channel. To study the concentric motor unit action potential (MUAP), alongside the macro potential, we built a needle electrode combining concentric and macro recording surfaces. The study of 240 motor units in 10 healthy subjects with the single fiber (SF macro) and concentric macro (conmac) electrodes revealed no significant differences between macro potentials areas and amplitudes obtained with either electrode. The ability to study a small and a large section of the motor unit simultaneously offers insights into the local or global nature of motor unit changes not otherwise available to the electromyographer. It also reveals which concentric parameters correlate best with the macro potential and, can even be of great help with the newer EMG signal decomposition techniques; by identifying each motor unit by its concentric and macro waveform simultaneously, it will allow for the "marking" of these motor units helping to reduce the risk of their misclassification when the concentric MUAP is used alone.     

Single fiber macro versus concentric trigger macro EMG: a comparison of methods.

The values obtained from two different macro EMG methods were compared, and found to be different. Normally, macro electromyography (EMG) is performed with a modified single fiber (SF) needle using the SF potential as a trigger; a new method recommends a modified concentric needle and triggers on the concentric EMG signal. The concentric macro EMG has a 40% to 50% smaller amplitude and area values than data obtained with a SF macro EMG needle. The different values are the result of variant spatial relationships of the respective needles to the motor unit under study, and may be due to a recruitment-dependent bias resulting from different trigger properties of the two methods. The concentric macro EMG needle can be used to estimate motor unit size, to scan the unit, and to investigate its different concentric EMG signals.     

Surface electromyography using electrode arrays: a study of motor neuron disease

The use of electromyography (EMG) is limited, particularly in the investigation of children, by the invasive nature of needle electrodes. Surface electrode techniques are an attractive alternative but the detected signals are greatly influenced by volume conductor effects, thus making their interpretation problematic. Using finite element analysis we investigated the relationship between surface potential distribution and motor unit depth, incorporating anisotropic conductivity to model muscle tissue and a range of subcutaneous fat thicknesses. The modeling results were used to analyze data recorded with a 16-channel surface electrode array, from 10 normals subjects and 12 patients with motor neuron disease. Differences in the motor units between the two groups were statistically significant (P < 0.01) and are consistent with reinnervation and increased motor unit territory in the patient group. This noninvasive technique shows promise as a more acceptable alternative to the use of conventional needle electrodes for neurophysiological investigations.     

Single-fiber EMG with a concentric needle electrode: validation in myasthenia gravis

We performed a retrospective study to validate whether a disposable concentric needle electrode (CNE) can be used in place of a single-fiber (SF) electrode for jitter measurements in myasthenia gravis (MG). Normal values for voluntary contraction of orbicularis oculi (OO) and extensor digitorum communis (EDC) were collected from 20 healthy subjects. The method was validated by a retrospective analysis of 56 consecutive MG patients, the "gold standard" being a positive acetylcholine receptor (AChR) antibody titer at the time of the electrophysiological (electromyography) study and the clinical diagnosis. Receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves were constructed to define maximal sensitivity and specificity of the technique. The sensitivity was 96.4% (95% confidence interval 87.5%-99.6%), with no false-positive results, similar to traditional SF EMG and confirming that the disposable CNE is a justifiable alternative.     

Recording and physical characteristics of disposable concentric needle EMG electrodes

There is currently considerable interest in using disposable concentric needle (CN) electrodes for clinical electromyography (EMG). To determine how these electrodes compare with reusable CN electrodes, we have compared signals recorded by these two electrode types from the same muscle in normal subjects. We also made similar recordings with two groups of reusable electrodes. There was no difference in the features of motor unit action potentials (MUAPs) recorded by the two groups of reusable electrodes. Disposable electrodes performed satisfactorily in conventional EMG examination. However, compared to reusable electrodes, the disposable electrodes recorded MUAPs with smaller amplitude and area but with the same area:amplitude ratio and MUAP duration. The physical and electrical properties of the CNE groups were also investigated. Disposable electrodes had lower electrical resistance and greater capacitance than reusable electrodes when measurements were made in saline. Photomicrographs showed that the disposable electrodes had smaller recording surfaces and that the central wire was frequently eccentric in the cannula. The differences in electrical recording characteristics could be due to differences in the size of the recording surface, eccentric placement of the central wire in the cannula or differences in the metal used for the central wire. We conclude that electrical and physical testing may not predict the recording characteristics of needle electrodes. Electrophysiologic testing is necessary to determine how EMG signals recorded by new types of electrodes compare with those recorded by currently used electrodes.     

Assessment of variability in the shape of the motor unit action potential,the “jiggle,” at consecutive discharges

A method for quantifing shape variability, the jiggle, of motor unit potentials (MUPs) recorded with conventional EMG electrodes is presented. Amplitude variability at each point of time of the MUP was analyzed. Two new parameters are proposed: the normalized value of the consecutive amplitude differences (CAD), and the crosscorrelational coefficient of the consecutive discharges (CCC). Simulations showed that increased jitter of the constituent single fiber potentials increases the jiggle as expressed by an increase in CAD and decrease in CCC values. Even when the jitter value of each component was fixed, increased temporal dispersion increased the jiggle whereas an increased number of fibers decreased the jiggle. This new method has been applied in normal subjects, patients with chronic neurogenic diseases and patients with ALS. Jiggle was significantly increased in the ALS group, in agreement with visual observations. We believe that this method for quantifying jiggle will increase the information obtainable from routine EMG investigations. © 1994 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Concentric and single fiber needle electrodes yield comparable jitter results in myasthenia gravis

The single fiber needle electrode (SFNE), which is designed to isolate single muscle fiber action potentials, has played an important role in the diagnosis of myasthenia gravis (MG). However, the concentric needle electrode (CNE) has been recently adopted by some workers to study neuromuscular instability in MG, and reference data have also been obtained in healthy subjects. In this study we wanted to establish whether data acquired using the SFNE is comparable to that obtained using the CNE when studying patients with MG. We established reference data for our laboratory using the CNE for orbicularis oculi (OO) and extensor digitorum communis (EDC). We compared data from 24 MG patients using both SFNE and CNE and found no significant differences in mean jitter values for either muscles. We correlated the neurophysiological data obtained by either electrode with various clinical assessments, the ice pack test, OO and EDC strength measurement, and MGFA classification of disease, and we found no significant relation. We compared discomfort scores for the two needle electrodes for each muscle and found that the discomfort scores for CNE are significantly lower (P = 0.0004). We conclude that the CNE is a useful alternative electrode for studying single fiber potentials, but more reference data from normal control subjects is desirable. Muscle Nerve, 2008     

Concentric needle electrode for neuromuscular jitter analysis

We used a concentric needle electrode (CNE) with 2 kHZ low-cut filter and a single fiber electrode (SFE) in the same subjects for neuromuscular jitter measurement in the extensor digitorum communis (EDC) and orbicularis oculi (OOc) muscles. At the same session, 20 jitter values were obtained from each subject with each electrode. For EDC (during voluntary contraction), mean jitter values with SFE and CNE were 23.4 +/- 8 micros and 23.3 +/- 8 micros in 10 normals; and 56.8 +/- 28 micros and 57.4 +/- 33 micros in 10 myasthenics. For OOc (during electrical stimulation), mean jitter values with SFE and CNE were 17.9 +/- 5 micros and 16.3 +/- 4 micros in 11 normal subjects, and 41.2 +/- 29 micros and 36.7 +/- 27 micros in 10 myasthenics. For both muscles, the numbers of individual abnormal jitter values with SFE and CNE were highly comparable. Both needles labeled the same patients as having "normal" or "abnormal" neuromuscular transmission. CNE may be an alternative to SFE in neuromuscular jitter analysis.     

HTLV‐1–associated myelopathy/tropical spastic paraparesis and peripheral neuropathy following live‐donor renal transplantation

Introduction: Our aim in this study was to provide an updated literature review of electrodiagnostic testing in myasthenia gravis and Lambert–Eaton myasthenic syndrome. Methods: A systematic review of the recent literature was performed using the following key words: myasthenia gravis (MG); Lambert–Eaton myasthenic syndrome (LEMS); electromyography (EMG); repetitive nerve stimulation (RNS); single‐fiber electromyography (SFEMG); nerve conduction study; and normative values. Results: Several articles supported testing of facial, bulbar, and respiratory muscles in the diagnosis of neuromuscular junction (NMJ) disorders, including muscle‐specific kinase antibody (MuSK)‐seropositive MG. Several articles supported use of concentric needle EMG as an alternative to SFEMG jitter in disorders of neuromuscular transmission. A limited number of articles addressed measurement of area (vs. amplitude) decrement in RNS and decreasing the threshold of post‐exercise facilitation. Conclusions: Electrodiagnostic testing continues to be useful for diagnosis of MG and LEMS, although the quality of the evidence is not great. This literature review summarizes RNS and jitter measurement of facial and respiratory muscles and use of concentric needle EMG for SFEMG. Muscle Nerve 52:455–462, 2015     

EMG of reinnervated motor units: a simulation study

Using computer simulation techniques, reinnervation of motor units (MUs) was studied by increasing the number of muscle fibers in the MU without changing the MU territory. The fiber density (FD) measured by single fiber EMG electrodes, the amplitude, area and number of turns of concentric needle (CN) EMG motor unit action potentials (MUAPs) and the amplitude of macro EMG MUAPs were most affected by partial reinnervation changes. The values of these features increased during simulated advanced reinnervation, as did the number of CNEMG MUAPs that had increased numbers of phases or turns and the mean CNEMG MUAP duration. The increase in macro EMG MUAP amplitude, FD and CNEMG MUAP area were proportional to the increase in the number of muscle fibers in the MU. When loss of muscle fibers due to so-called MU fractionation was simulated, values of all EMG features fell, but were still increased compared to normal. Two patterns of change in SFEMG and macro EMG values were identified that may distinguish between recordings made from reinnervated low force threshold MUs and those from higher force threshold MUs.     

Electrophysiologic study in benign human botulism type B

Conventional electromyography (EMG) and single fiber EMG (SFEMG) were performed in a 64-year-old diabetic woman with mild type B botulism. The main clinical signs were autonomic dysfunction and cranial nerves paresis. Conventional EMG was normal, except for small changes that were consistent with mild mixed peripheral neuropathy in the lower limbs and were related to diabetes. Repetitive stimulation and results of single stimulus before and after full effort were normal. SFEMG showed increased jitter and impulse blocking in clinically normal muscles. The jitter was frequency dependent and improved at a higher innervation rate. Impulse blocking in potentials with only slightly increased jitter was found. The follow-up showed improvement of the jitter in agreement with clinical recovery. Jitter abnormalities were recorded after 16 weeks, when clinical signs of botulism had been reversed to normal. Motor unit fiber density increased progressively, and on examination at 8 weeks, some potentials showed very high jitter values. Both findings might suggest new endplate formation, perhaps due to ultraterminal sprouting development.     

Reference values for jitter recorded by concentric needle electrodes in healthy controls: A multicenter study

Introduction: The aim of this study was to create reference values for jitter measured with concentric needle electrodes. Methods: Operators worldwide contributed recordings from orbicularis oculi (OO), frontalis (FR), and extensor digitorum (ED) muscles in healthy controls. Criteria for acceptable signal quality were agreed upon in advance. Fifteen or 20 recordings of acceptable quality from each muscle were required for voluntary and electrical stimulation recordings, respectively. Results: Recordings from 59 to 92 subjects were obtained for each muscle and activation type. Outlier limits for mean consecutive difference and individual jitter data for voluntary activation were: OO, 31 and 45 µs; FR, 28 and 38 µs; ED, 30 and 43 µs; and for electrical stimulation they were: OO, 27 and 36 µs; FR, 21 and 28 µs; ED, 24 and 35 µs. Conclusion: Reference jitter values from concentric needle electrode recordings were developed from signals of defined quality while seeking to avoid creating supernormal values. Muscle Nerve 53: 351–362, 2016     

AAEM minimonograph #25: Single-fiber electromyography

Single-fiber electromyography (SFEMG) is a selective recording technique in which a needle electrode with a small recording surface in the side is used to identify action potentials from individual muscle fibers. The SFEMG parameters of greatest clinical use are fiber density (FD) and neuromuscular jitter. FD reflects the local organization of muscle fibers within the motor unit; jitter reflects the safety factor of neuromuscular transmission at individual neuromuscular junctions. SFEMG can be of great value in demonstrating or excluding abnormalities in mild or questionable disease of nerve, muscle, or the neuromuscular junction. The neuromuscular jitter may be measured during nerve stimulation, which is particularly useful in uncooperative patients or when it is desirable to control the firing rate precisely, or during voluntary muscle activation, which is less subject to technical artifact. The SFEMG findings may not be specific to a particular diseases, but they frequently increase understanding of the disease process by demonstrating abnormal neuromuscular transmission or rearrangement of muscle fibers within the motor unit, which complements information from more conventional EMG examinations. © 1996 American Association of Electrodiagnostic Medicine. Published by John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Influence of time shifting of single muscle fiber potentials (SFPs) on jitter values measured using concentric needle electrode – a simulation study

ObjectivesThe aim of this simulation study was to evaluate the resulting value of jitter measured from a simulated examination recording and to analyze its dependence on both the number of SFPs contributing either to the triggering peak or the non-triggered peak, and time shifting (delays of triggering at the end-plate) of individual SFPs in these paired potentials.MethodsWe simulated potentials recorded using a concentric needle electrode with two well separated peaks, and performed a simulated examination (consisting of 50 trains of 100 discharges) with an assumed number of fibers forming peaks. For each train, fiber diameters were chosen at random within the allowed ranges. For each discharge the delay of triggering for each fiber at the end-plate was selected at random from an assumed range. The mean jitter values were calculated, together with the median and 95% quantile.ResultsThe results suggest that jitter is related to the mean of the individual SFP shifts.ConclusionThese findings extend the understanding of reduced jitter measurements using a concentric needle electrode. If more than one fiber forms the peak, then jitter decreases due to averaging of individual time shifts of potentials constituting the peak, rather than due to detection of the SFP with the earliest peak.     

Intraoperative lateral rectus electromyographic recordings optimized by deep intraorbital needle electrodes

ObjectiveWe demonstrate the advantages and safety of long, intraorbitally-placed needle electrodes, compared to standard-length subdermal electrodes, when recording lateral rectus electromyography (EMG) during intracranial surgeries.MethodsInsulated 25 mm and uninsulated 13 mm needle electrodes, aimed at the lateral rectus muscle, were placed in parallel during 10 intracranial surgeries, examining spontaneous and stimulation-induced EMG activities. Postoperative complications in these patients were reviewed, alongside additional patients who underwent long electrode placement in the lateral rectus.ResultsIn 40 stimulation-induced recordings from 10 patients, the 25 mm electrodes recorded 6- to 26-fold greater amplitude EMG waveforms than the 13 mm electrodes. The 13 mm electrodes detected greater unwanted volume conduction upon facial nerve stimulation, typically exceeding the amplitude of abducens nerve stimulation. Except for one case with lateral canthus ecchymosis, no clinical or radiographic complications occurred in 36 patients (41 lateral rectus muscles) following needle placement.ConclusionsIntramuscular recordings from long electrode in the lateral rectus offers more reliable EMG monitoring than 13 mm needles, with excellent discrimination between abducens and facial nerve stimulations, and without significant complications from needle placement.SignificanceLong intramuscular electrode within the orbit for lateral rectus EMG recording is practical and reliable for abducens nerve monitoring.     

Microneurography for the recording and selective stimulation of afferents: an assessment

The purpose of this study was to examine whether a microneurography electrode could record from and then selectively stimulate the same afferent fiber in cat sural and tibial nerves. Fiber activity was recorded distally with microneurography needle electrodes and proximally with hook electrodes. Records from the hook electrodes allowed the waveform shape and latency following natural stimulation to be compared with that produced by electrical stimuli delivered through the needle electrode. The action potentials from approximately 50% of the recorded fibers failed to propagate beyond the needle electrode. When propagation did occur and the comparison could be made, only 25% of the afferents recorded could be selectively stimulated. This relatively low success rate suggests that a typical microneurography needle is not particularly good for selectively stimulating identified afferents. Thus in human experiments, attempts to microstimulate identified afferents may often include stimulation of unidentified alternative, or additional, afferent fibers at thresholds of sensory perception.