Serrated lesions of the colorectum: review and recommendations from an expert panel

Serrated lesions of the colorectum are the precursors of perhaps one-third of colorectal cancers (CRCs). Cancers arising in serrated lesions are usually in the proximal colon, and account for a disproportionate fraction of cancer identified after colonoscopy. We sought to provide guidance for the clinical management of serrated colorectal lesions based on current evidence and expert opinion regarding definitions, classification, and significance of serrated lesions. A consensus conference was held over 2 days reviewing the topic of serrated lesions from the perspectives of histology, molecular biology, epidemiology, clinical aspects, and serrated polyposis. Serrated lesions should be classified pathologically according to the World Health Organization criteria as hyperplastic polyp, sessile serrated adenoma/polyp (SSA/P) with or without cytological dysplasia, or traditional serrated adenoma (TSA). SSA/P and TSA are premalignant lesions, but SSA/P is the principal serrated precursor of CRCs. Serrated lesions have a distinct endoscopic appearance, and several lines of evidence suggest that on average they are more difficult to detect than conventional adenomatous polyps. Effective colonoscopy requires an endoscopist trained in the endoscopic appearance of serrated lesions. We recommend that all serrated lesions proximal to the sigmoid colon and all serrated lesions in the rectosigmoid >5?mm in size, be completely removed. Recommendations are made for post-polypectomy surveillance of serrated lesions and for surveillance of serrated polyposis patients and their relatives.     

Serrated polyps of the large intestine: current understanding of diagnosis, pathogenesis, and clinical management

Approximately 30 % of colorectal carcinomas develop via the serrated neoplasia pathway characterized by widespread DNA methylation and frequent BRAF mutation. Serrated polyps represent a heterogeneous group of polyps which are the precursor lesions to serrated pathway colorectal carcinomas. The histological classification of serrated polyps has evolved over the last two decades to distinguish three separate entities: hyperplastic polyp, sessile serrated adenoma (SSA), and traditional serrated adenoma (TSA). The malignant potential of SSAs and TSAs has been clearly demonstrated. SSAs are more challenging to detect by colonoscopy and are likely to account for some interval carcinomas of the proximal colon. Serrated polyposis syndrome is now widely recognized as conferring a high risk of colorectal carcinoma although its cause remains elusive. The current understanding of the actual malignant potential of each serrated polyp subtype is still limited due to the lack of large-scale prospective studies. Patient management guidelines have been recently updated although high-level evidence to support them is still required.     

Sessile serrated adenoma/polyps: Where are we at in 2016?

It is currently known that colorectal cancers(CRC) arise from 3 different pathways: the adenoma to carcinoma chromosomal instability pathway(50%-70%); the mutator "Lynch syndrome" route(3%-5%); and the serrated pathway(30%-35%). The World Health Organization has classified serrated polyps into three types of lesions: hyperplastic polyps(HP),sessile serrated adenomas/polyps(SSA/P) and traditional serrated adenomas(TSA),the latter two strongly associated with development of CRCs. HPs do not cause cancer and TSAs are rare. SSA/P appear to be the responsible precursor lesion for the development of cancers through the serrated pathway. Both HPs and SSA/Ps appear morphologically similar. SSA/P are difficult to detect. The margins are normally inconspicuous. En bloc resection of these polyps can hence be troublesome. A careful examination of borders,submucosal injection of a dye solution(for larger lesions) and resection of a rim of normal tissue around the lesion may ensure total eradication of these lesions.     

Clinicopathological features of serrated lesions of the colorectum

We reviewed 428 subjects with colorectal serrated lesions resected endoscopically or surgically at our institution. Colorectal serrated lesions were pathologically divided into 3 groups: hyperplastic polyp (HP), sessile serrated adenoma/polyp (SSA/P), and traditional serrated adenoma (TSA). SSA/P was detected frequently in the right colon and SSA/P was mainly flat-elevated. Cancers occurring in SSA/P were found more frequently than HP or TSA. The incidence of cancer in SSA/P was equivalent to that of cancer in traditional adenoma. Further studies are warranted to clarify clinicopathological features of serrated lesions of the colorectum.     

Serrated polyps – a concealed but prevalent precursor of colorectal cancer

Serrated polyps have long been considered to lack malignant potential but accumulating data suggest that these lesions may cause up to one-third of all sporadic colorectal cancer. Serrated polyps are classified into three subtypes, including sessile serrated adenomas/polyps (SSA/Ps), traditional serrated adenomas (TSAs), and hyperplastic polyps (HPs). SSA/P and TSA harbour malignant potential but TSA represents only 1–2%, wheras SSA/P constitute up to 20% of all serrated lesions. HPs are most common (80%) of all serrated polyps but are considered to have a low potential of developing colorectal cancer. Due to their subtle appearence, detection and removal of serrated polyps pose a major challenge to endoscopists. Considering that precancerous serrated polyps are predominately located in the right colon could explain why interval cancers most frequently appear in the proximal colon and why colonoscopy is less protective against colon cancer in the proximal compared to the distal colon. Despite the significant impact on colorectal cancer incidence, the aetiology, incidence, prevalence, and natural history of serrated polyps is incompletely known. To effectively detect, remove, and follow-up serrated polyps, endoscopists and pathologists should be well-informed about serrated polyps. This review highlights colorectal serrated polyps in terms of biology, types, diagnosis, therapy, and follow-up.     

Serrated pathway in colorectal carcinogenesis

Serrated adenocarcinoma is a recently described subset of colorectal cancer(CRC),which account for about10%of all CRCs and follows an alternative pathway in which serrated polyps replace the traditional adenoma as the precursor lesion to CRC.Serrated polyps form a heterogeneous group of colorectal lesions that includes hyperplastic polyps(HPs),sessile serrated adenoma(SSA),traditional serrated adenoma(TSA)and mixed polyps.HPs are the most common serrated polyp followed by SSA and TSA.This distinct histogenesis is believed to have a major influence in prevention strategies,patient prognosis and therapeutic impact.Genetically,serrated polyps exhibited also a distinct pattern,with KRAS and BRAF having an important contribution to its development.Two other molecular changes that have been implicated in the serrated pathway include microsatellite instability and the CpG island methylator phenotype.In the present review we will address the current knowledge of serrated polyps,clinical pathological features and will update the most recent findings of its molecular pathways.The understanding of their biology and malignancy potential is imperative to implement a surveillance approach in order to prevent colorectal cancer development.     

225例结直肠锯齿状腺瘤的临床、内镜及病理学特征分析

目的探讨结直肠锯齿状腺瘤(serrated adenoma,SA)的临床、内镜及病理学特征。方法回顾性分析北京军区总医院消化内镜中心2009年1月-2013年10月检出的225例结直肠SA的临床、内镜及病理学资料。结果全部患者中男148例,女77例,年龄19~89岁,平均年龄(53.5±14.3)岁。以单发型多见(87.1%)。在同期结肠镜中的检出率为2.1%。内镜下形态以扁平型和广基型居多(64.3%、20.0%),多数病变直径在10 mm以下(83.1%);左半结肠和右半结肠的病变大小和形态分布的差异均有统计学意义(χ2=14.2662、12.2168,P0.05)。全部病例中广基锯齿状腺瘤息肉(SSA/P)30例(13.3%),非广基锯齿状腺瘤(包括增生性息肉、传统锯齿状腺瘤)195例(86.7%)。SSA/P中有20例位于右半结肠(66.7%),平均直径13.3 mm。其中6例SSA/P呈侧向发育型息肉,均位于升结肠及回盲部。伴腺上皮异型增生12例,另有3例腺瘤癌变。结论结直肠SA临床相对少见,内镜下形态及分布部位有其自身特点,尤其是SSA/P。有必要对结直肠SA进行明确分类,并对其发展、转归做长期随访研究。     

High prevalence of sessile serrated adenomas with BRAF mutations: a prospective study of patients undergoing colonoscopy

BACKGROUND & AIMS: Sporadic colorectal cancers with a high degree of microsatellite instability are a clinically distinct subgroup with a high incidence of BRAF mutation and are widely considered to develop from serrated polyps. Previous studies of serrated polyps have been highly selected and largely retrospective. This prospective study examined the prevalence of sessile serrated adenomas and determined the incidence of BRAF and K-ras mutations in different types of polyps. METHODS: An unselected consecutive series of 190 patients underwent magnifying chromoendoscopy. Polyp location, size, and histologic classification were recorded. All polyps were screened for BRAF V600E and K-ras codon 12 and 13 mutations. RESULTS: Polyps were detected in 72% of patients. Most (60%) were adenomas (tubular adenomas, tubulovillous adenomas), followed by hyperplastic polyps (29%), sessile serrated adenomas (SSAs; 9%), traditional serrated adenomas (0.7%), and mixed polyps (1.7%). Adenomas were more prevalent in the proximal colon (73%), as were SSAs (75%), which tended to be large (64% >5 mm). The presence of at least one SSA was associated with increased polyp burden (5.0 vs 2.5; P < .0001) and female sex (P < .05). BRAF mutation was rare in adenomas (1/248 [0.4%]) but common in SSAs (78%), traditional serrated adenomas (66%), mixed polyps (57%), and microvesicular hyperplastic polyps (70%). K-ras mutations were significantly associated with goblet cell hyperplastic polyps and tubulovillous adenomas (P < .001). CONCLUSIONS: The prevalence of SSAs is approximately 9% in patients undergoing colonoscopy. They are associated with BRAF mutation, proximal location, female sex, and presence of multiple polyps. These findings emphasize the importance of identifying and removing these lesions for endoscopic prevention of colorectal cancer.     

Endoscopic diagnosis of sessile serrated adenoma/polyp with and without dysplasia/carcinoma

Sessile serrated adenoma/polyps(SSA/Ps) are early precursor lesions in the serrated neoplasia pathway, which results in colorectal carcinomas with BRAF mutations, methylation for DNA repair genes, a Cp G island methylator phenotype, and high levels of microsatellite instability. Some of these lesions can rapidly become dysplastic or invasive carcinomas that exhibit high lymphatic invasion and lymph node metastasis potentials. Detecting serrated lesions, including SSA/Ps with and without dysplasia/carcinoma, is critical, but SSA/Ps can be difficult to detect, are inconsistently identified by endoscopists and pathologists, and are often incompletely resected. Therefore, SSA/Ps are considered to be major contributors to "interval cancers". If colonoscopists can identify the specific endoscopic characteristics of SSA/Ps, their detection and the effectiveness of colonoscopy may improve. Here, the endoscopic features of SSA/Ps with and without dysplasia/carcinoma, including the characteristics determined using magnifying endoscopy, are reviewed in the context of previous reports. Endoscopically, these subtle polyps are like hyperplastic polyps, because they are slightly elevated and pale. Unlike hyperplastic polyps, SSA/Ps are usually larger than 5 mm, frequently covered by a thin layer called the ‘‘mucus cap', and are more commonly located in the proximal colon. Magnifying narrow-band imaging findings, which include dark spots inside the crypts and varicose microvascular vessels, in addition to the type II-open pit patterns detected using magnifying chromoendoscopy, effectively differentiate SSA/Ps from hyperplastic polyps. The lesions' endoscopic characteristics, which include their(semi)pedunculated morphologies, double elevations, central depressions, and reddishness, and the use of magnifying endoscopy, might help to detect dysplasia/carcinoma within SSA/Ps. Greater awareness may promote further research into improving the detection, identification, and complete resection rates of SSA/Ps with and without dysplasia/carcinoma and reduce the interval cancer rates.     

Serrated lesions of the colorectum, a new entity: what should a clinician/ endoscopist know about it ?

Serrated polyps of the colorectum have received much attention in recent literature. Several classifications have been proposed and created considerable confusion. Morphology and molecular biology have greatly contributed to the better identification of these entity. The recently published WHO classification, proposed using the term of "serrated polyp" as a generic term and defined sporadic serrated polyps as "a heterogeneous group" of lesions characterized morphologically by a serrated (sawtooth or stellate) architecture of the epithelial component which include hyperplastic polyps (HP), sessile serrated adenomas/polyps (SSA/P) and traditional serrated adenomas (TSA). With the development of molecular biology, it is now clear that the serrated pathway is one of the new carcinogenic pathways in the colon. There is now strong evidence that some serrated polyps correspond to precursors of some sporadic colorectal cancer (CRC). The aim of this article is to summarize the present data concerning the morphological and molecular characteristics of these serrated lesions and to give some recommendations for the management of such lesions.     

结直肠锯齿状癌变途径的分子基础

锯齿状癌变途径是近年提出的概念．用来解释一部分缺乏染色体不稳定性结直肠癌的发生，包括部分增生性息肉、无蒂锯齿状息肉、锯齿状腺瘤和混合性息肉。早期发生BRAF突变、DNA高甲基化以及微卫星不稳定是大部分这类息肉的分子特征．经典的Wnt信号通路在这条途径中可能不起主要作用。     

Significance of serrated polyps of the colon

The fundamental view that colon adenocarcinomas arise only from conventional adenomas has been challenged by the now recognized hyperplastic polyp-serrated adenoma-adenocarcinoma pathway. This article describes the history of the serrated adenoma (both the traditional serrated adenoma and the sessile serrated adenoma) as well as the histology and endoscopic appearance of these lesions in comparison with hyperplastic polyps and mixed polyps. Although the exact pathway is the subject of ongoing research, compelling histologic associations and molecular phenotypes that define the model of the serrated polyp-carcinoma sequence, including microsatellite instability, BRAF/KRAS mutations, and CpG island methylator phenotype, provide strong evidence that this is a genuine pathway. Management of serrated neoplasia of the colon includes careful colonoscopy, complete removal of colonic polyps, sampling fields of diminutive polyps of the rectosigmoid, and basing surveillance on histology of removed polyps.     

Progression of a sessile serrated adenoma to an early invasive cancer within 8 months

Recent studies suggest that serrated polyps, including hyperplastic polyps, traditional serrated adenomas, and sessile serrated adenomas, may be morphologically and genetically distinct and linked to microsatellite unstable colorectal cancers, and thus the concept of a hyperplastic polyp–serrate adenoma–carcinoma pathway has been suggested. Furthermore, it has been suggested that transformation from serrated polyps to invasive cancers can be rapid and occurs when the lesions are small; however, direct evidence for this issue is scant. We herein describe a case of a sessile serrated adenoma showing rapid transformation into a submucosal invasive carcinoma with remarkable morphological change in a short period of 8 months. This case is unique and suggestive, as it provided information about the natural history of a sessile serrated adenoma.     

Sessile serrated adenoma/polyp showed rapid malignant transformation in the final 13 months

Based on the concept of the adenoma-carcinoma sequence, most colorectal cancers are considered to arise from conventional adenomas. However, recent studies suggested that a subset of colorectal cancers develop through the serrated neoplastic pathway. It has also been documented that serrated polyps can rapidly transform into invasive cancers even when they are small in size. We now describe a case of a sessile serrated adenoma/polyp which had been followed up for 4 years but eventually showed rapid transformation into an advanced cancer accompanied by a remarkable morphological change within only 13 months. Retrospective genetic and epigenetic analyses showed microsatellite instability, CpG island methylator phenotype-positive, and BRAF mutation in the lesion, suggesting the tumor had developed through the serrated neoplastic pathway. This case may provide valuable information about the natural history of sessile serrated adenoma/polyps which eventually progress to advanced cancers.     

结直肠无蒂型锯齿状腺瘤的临床病理特征

无蒂型锯齿状腺瘤（SSA）属结直肠锯齿状病变之一,具有独特的形态学特点、生物学行为和分子基因学改变,其内镜形态和组织学特征有别于其他结直肠锯齿状病变,且与新近提出的结直肠癌变的锯齿状通路密切相关.近年研究发现SSA是微卫星不稳定性癌的前期病变,可直接发生癌变.但目前国内尚缺乏对这一病变的认识.本文就SSA的定义、形态学特征和病理组织学诊断标准作一综述,旨在提高临床医师对这一病变的认识.     

Clinicopathologic findings of colorectal traditional and sessile serrated adenomas in Korea: a multicenter study

Background/Aims: Serrated polyps have emerged as important evidence supporting the serrated polyp-neoplasia pathway in colorectal carcinogenesis, an alternate to the classical adenoma-carcinoma sequence. However, there is confusion over the diagnostic criteria for serrated polyps including traditional serrated adenoma (TSA) and sessile serrated adenoma (SSA). In addition, clinical and pathologic characteristics of each are largely unknown and need further exploration. Methods: The 753 polyps that were previously diagnosed as serrated adenoma (SA) from 14 tertiary care university hospitals in Korea between 2003 and 2005 were evaluated for the clinicopathologic findings of TSA and SSA. Results: Among 753 cases, 420 (55.8%) were reclassified as TSA and 56 (7.4%) as SSA. Among the pathologic parameters, crypt branching, crypt dilatation, and horizontal crypts were more frequent in SSA than in TSA (p < 0.001). SSA was larger than TSA (12.6 +/- 7.3 vs. 9.8 +/- 6.9 mm, p = 0.005), was more likely to be flat type (p = 0.006), and was more frequently located in the proximal colorectum (p = 0.012). There were no significant differences in age, sex, and body mass index between TSA and SSA. Conclusions: Locationand endoscopic features of the polyps with abnormal crypt morphology in histologic findings could be helpful for the diagnosis and classification of SAs.     

Differential expression of p53 and p504s in hyperplastic polyp, sessile serrated adenoma and traditional serrated adenoma

Aims  

Known collectively as serrated polyps, hyperplastic polyps (HP), sessile serrated adenomas (SSA/SSP) and traditional serrated adenoma (TSA) may represent a spectrum of increasing malignant potential with characteristic immunological markers. There is increasing evidence that HP, SSA/SSP and TSA are biologically different and are likely to represent a spectrum along the serrated polyp pathway. Although there is general consensus about the diagnostic features of serrated polyps, the morphological differences between the categories are often subtle. This study compares the expression of p53 and P504S among serrated polyps. Sixty seven randomly selected biopsies (n = 59) and resection specimens (n = 8) histologically diagnosed for SSA/SSP, TSA and HP (19, 30 and 18 specimens, respectively) were obtained.     

Pathogenesis and Management of Serrated Polyps: Current Status and Future Directions

Hyperplastic or serrated polyps were once believed to have little to no clinical significance. A subset of these polyps are now considered to be precursors to colorectal cancers (CRC) in the serrated pathway that may account for at least 15% of all tumors. The serrated pathway is distinct from the two other CRC pathways and involves an epigenetic hypermethylation mechanism of CpG islands within promoter regions of tumor suppressor genes. This process results in the formation of CpG island methylator phenotype tumors. Serrated polyps are divided into hyperplastic polyps, sessile serrated adenomas/polyps (SSA/Ps), and traditional serrated adenomas (TSAs). The SSA/P and the TSA have the potential for dysplasia and subsequent malignant transformation. The SSA/Ps are more common and are more likely to be flat than TSAs. Their flat morphology may make them difficult to detect and thus explain the variation in detection rates among endoscopists. Challenges for endoscopists also include the difficulty in pathological interpretation as well surveillance of these lesions. Furthermore, serrated polyps may be inadequately resected by endoscopists. Thus, it is not surprising that the serrated pathway has been linked with interval cancers. This review will provide the physician or clinician with the knowledge to manage patients with serrated polyps.     

Hyperplastic and serrated polyps of the colorectum

The serrated polyp pathway is a histopathological sequence that begins in a hyperplastic polyp, or precursor serrated aberrant crypt focus, and has the potential to end in a colonic adenocarcinoma that is CIMP-high and, in most cases, also MSI. An activating mutation of the BRAF oncogene is a marker for this pathway. There is evidence that aberrant CpG-island methylation is the molecular engine that drives the progression through sequential steps of the pathway, from hyperplastic polyp to a form of atypical hyperplastic polyp (termed sessile serrated adenoma) to dysplastic serrated polyp and, ultimately to serrated carcinoma. A second serrated pathway, identified by mutations of KRAS in serrated adenoma, is delineated less completely. Its endpoint is a colorectal carcinoma that is CIMP-low and MSS, and both the advanced serrated adenoma and carcinoma stages of this pathway show molecular genetic and morphologic features that overlap with those of the conventional APC carcinogenic pathway. Clinical studies are needed to elucidate the natural history of serrated neoplasia, and provide evidence-based guidance for risk assessment and surveillance of individuals discovered to harbor its various serrated polyp precursors.     

Emerging concepts in colorectal serrated polyps

Colorectal serrated polyps are heterogeneous epithelial lesions characterized by a serrated architecture. They include the classical hyperplastic polyps and the much rarer serrated adenomas and mixed polyps. Whereas serrated adenomas are composed of an unequivocal adenomatous epithelium with architectural serrated, mixed polyps include two separate hyperplastic and adenomatous components. During the past few years, another type of serrated polyp with only very subtle proliferation abnormalities has been described. These atypical serrated polyps may occur either sporadically or in the context of colorectal polyposis. Despite their close resemblance to traditional hyperplastic polyps, some authors argued that they should be regarded as authentically neoplastic lesions and have proposed to call them "sessile serrated adenomas". Their malignant potential requires their removal when discovered during colonoscopy. This article reviews the histological features, the endoscopic appearance, the natural history and the molecular phenotype of the different categories of serrated polyps and introduces the concept of "serrated neoplastic pathway" in the development of colorectal cancer.