An analysis of the air-bone gap closure obtained by a crimping and a non-crimping titanium stapes prosthesis in otosclerosis

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the hearing results of stapes surgery with two different titanium stapes prostheses. A crimping and a non-crimping prosthesis. METHODS: Retrospective analyses were carried out on the pre- and postoperative hearing results obtained after 126 primary stapedotomies with two different prostheses in patients with otosclerosis. Sixty-three patients had a stapedotomy with a K-piston Titanium (No. 1006107) type and 63 patients received a CliP-piston àWengen Titanium (No. 1006807) type after stapedotomy. The results were compared according to mean audiometrical parameters. A Chi-square Test analysis (a contingency table) was performed with odds ratio to analyze this retrospective case-control study. RESULTS: The hearing results of both titanium stapes prostheses were comparable. There was no difference in the final hearing results between the two pistons studied. No statistically significant difference between the postoperative air-bone gap closures by the two titanium stapes prostheses studied could be demonstrated. CONCLUSIONS: Because of the different properties of the two titanium piston studied (CliP-piston àWengen Titanium type, no crimping and K-piston Titanium crimping necessary) a difference in the closure of the air-bone gap could be suspected. This comparative study could not demonstrate a statistical better air-bone gap closure for one of the titanium pistons. Both stapes prostheses showed good results in reconstruction of the hearing loss due to otosclerosis.     

Comparison of titanium and Robinson stainless steel stapes piston prostheses.

OBJECTIVE: Although stainless steel stapes prostheses have generally been considered magnetic resonance imaging safe, there is concern that this may change with the development of more powerful imaging systems. The objective of the study was to determine whether a titanium piston stapes prosthesis would be audiometrically and surgically equivalent to a Robinson stainless steel piston for stapedectomy. STUDY DESIGN: Retrospective chart review. SETTING: Private otology practice. PATIENTS: In all, 50 patients underwent stapedectomy with a Gyrus titanium piston prosthesis. These patients were matched on the basis of age and preoperative bone-conduction scores with patients who underwent stapedectomy with a Robinson stainless steel piston prosthesis. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Audiometric results are analyzed, and surgical complications noted. RESULTS: There was no significant difference between groups in hearing improvement or postoperative air-bone gap. The mean four-frequency hearing improvement was 27.7 dB for the stainless steel group and 27.8 dB for the titanium group. The mean postoperative air-bone gap was 2.65 dB for the stainless steel group and 2.60 for the titanium group. Neither group had a surgical complication. CONCLUSION: The titanium stapes prosthesis is a good alternative to a stainless steel prosthesis.     

Teflon-wire piston or stainless-steel bucket stapes prosthesis: does it make a difference?

The goal of this study was to determine whether postoperative (implantation of a stapes prosthesis) hearing gain and the amount of air-bone gap overclosure are more improved with the Teflon-wire piston or with the stainless-steel bucket prosthesis. We retrospectively reviewed the outcomes of 82 surgeries that had been performed by the primary author; 41 of these patients had received a Fisch Teflon-wire piston, and 41 had received a Bailey-modified Robinson stainless-steel bucket prosthesis. The mean hearing gain for the patients who received the Teflon-wire piston was 23.3 dB after primary stapes surgery and 20.5 dB after revision surgery. Patients who received the stainless-steel bucket prosthesis experienced a mean hearing gain of 20.7 and 20.3 dB, respectively. Following primary stapes surgery, the air-bone gap overclosure was 4.4 dB with the Teflon-wire piston and 5.2 dB with the stainless-steel bucket prosthesis. There was no statistically significant difference in either hearing gain or air-bone gap overclosure between the two prostheses.     

First experience with a new stapes clip piston in stapedotomy.

OBJECTIVE: Hearing results after 23 implantations of a newly designed titanium-clip stapes piston prosthesis (the àWengen Clip Piston prosthesis) in patients with otosclerosis were evaluated. This new type of stapes piston was designed to avoid the crimping onto the incus in stapedotomy. This one clip fits all designs and enables solid fixation by clicking the prosthesis onto the long process of the incus without crimping. STUDY DESIGN: A retrospective pilot study was carried out by microcomputer of the preoperative and postoperative audiological results of patients in whom the titanium-clip stapes piston prosthesis was implanted. SETTING: Ear, nose and throat department of Academic Medical Center, University of Amsterdam, Amsterdam, The Netherlands. PATIENTS: 23 Patients underwent a stapedotomy for hearing improvement suffering from otosclerosis. implantations of a newly designed titanium-clip stapes piston prosthesis (the àWengen Clip Piston prosthesis) in patients with otosclerosis were evaluated. INTERVENTION(S): The stapedotomy was performed with the àWengen Clip Piston prosthesis. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S): Pre and postoperative audiograms were used to evaluate the hearing gain improvement with the new stapes piston. Especially we looked at the airbone gap closure and the sensorineural hearing after the surgical procedure and compared these with the ones before surgery. RESULTS: The hearing results showed a closure of the pure-tone average air-bone gap to within 10 dB in 56.6% of cases (10 of 23 implantations) and to within 20 dB in 100% (23 of 23 implantations). A residual air-bone gap of greater than 20 dB was seen in the present pilot study. Postoperative overclosure of bone-conduction thresholds was discovered only for the frequency of 2 kHz. Sensorineural hearing loss greater than 10% did not occur, and there was no decline in the speech discrimination. CONCLUSIONS: The use of a newly designed titanium-clip stapes piston prosthesis with a diameter of 0.4 mm gives good results in cases of stapedotomy for otosclerosis. The titanium-clip design is a new development in the evolution of stapes piston prostheses. Surgical introduction, placement, and fixation are not always easy, depending on the anatomy of the middle ear and the thickness of the fixation area on the long process of the incus.     

Eliminating the Limitations of Manual Crimping in Stapes Surgery? A Preliminary Trial with the Shape Memory Nitinol Stapes Piston

OBJECTIVE: Manual piston malcrimping in stapedotomy may be the major cause of the occurrence of the significant, interindividual variations of postoperative air-bone gap (ABG), air-bone gap closures (ABGC), and postoperative recurrences of conductive hearing loss. To eliminate the effects of manual crimping on stapedotomy outcomes, the self-crimping, shape memory alloy Nitinol stapes piston was investigated and hearing evaluated. STUDY DESIGN: Prospective, preliminary case-control study in a tertiary care referral center. METHODS: Sixteen patients with otosclerosis undergoing reversed stapedotomy using the Nitinol stapes piston were matched to reference patients out of our conventional titanium piston database. The effects of the self-crimping Nitinol piston on the postoperative ABGC, the postoperative air-bone gap (ABG) variations, and the postoperative short-term hearing results were investigated 3, 6 and 9 months postoperatively. These data were statistically compared with the results of the control patients in our titanium stapes piston database. RESULTS: The mean postoperative ABG and the interindividual variations of the postoperative ABG were significantly smaller in the Nitinol group, the extent of ABGC greater in the Nitinol piston group, but not significant. The postoperative short-term stability of ABGC was similar in both groups. No infections or adverse reactions occurred during follow-up. CONCLUSION: Our preliminary results suggest that the self-crimping shape memory alloy Nitinol stapes piston eliminates the limitations of manual malcrimping in stapedotomy, thus optimising the surgical procedure. This allows reliable, safe, and consistent air-bone-gap closure in patients with otosclerosis up to 1 year after surgery.     

Steigbügelchirurgie

Background

The first hearing results with a new stapes prosthesis with clip function (Soft-CliP® piston) are presented.

Patients and Methods

This new prosthesis was used in 15 patients (mean age 45.2 years; range 21-63 years) undergoing routine stapes surgery. Soft-CliP® piston prostheses with a shaft diameter of 0.4 mm and a length ranging from 4.25 mm to 5.5 mm were used. Postoperative audiological testing and measurement of the air-bone gap were performed after an average of 47.3 days and compared with the preoperative values.

Results

The median observed postoperative air-bone gap (ABG) was 8.33 dB ±4.16 dB. All patients had less than 20 dB ABG and in 53.3% of cases was less than 10 dB. The operating time showed a clear difference between the left (66.5 min ±37.79 min) and right ears (47.2 min ±11.08 min).

Discussion

This new prosthesis design greatly facilitates a very difficult step in stapes surgery, the prosthesis fixation to the incus. The first postoperative hearing results are very promising but long-term results in a larger group of patients are still pending.     

Hearing results after stapedotomy with a nitinol piston prosthesis

OBJECTIVE: To compare the hearing results in patients with otosclerosis who underwent a stapedotomy with either a platinum wire prosthesis or a commercially available, heat-activated nitinol stapes piston prosthesis. DESIGN: Retrospective medical chart review. SETTING: Academic tertiary care medical center. PATIENTS: Seventy-nine consecutive patients diagnosed as having otosclerosis who underwent primary stapedotomy (33 men and 46 women) were included in this study (41 ears per group). INTERVENTION: Stapedotomy. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: The operative records of the senior surgeon (B.J.G.) were retrospectively reviewed, and hearing results were obtained. The hearing results of the patients who received a platinum wire prosthesis were compared with those who received a nitinol prosthesis. RESULTS: Results for the platinum wire prosthesis group revealed a postoperative mean (SD) air-bone gap (ABG) of 7 (6) dB, a mean (SD) ABG closure of 21 (12) dB, and a postoperative mean (SD) speech reception threshold of 25 (16) dB. Results for the nitinol prosthesis group revealed a postoperative ABG of 8 (6) dB, an ABG closure of 25 (10) dB, and a postoperative speech reception threshold of 25 (12) dB. CONCLUSIONS: These data show that the nitinol prosthesis is equivalent to the platinum wire prosthesis in closing the ABG in patients with otosclerosis. Comparable efficacy combined with the ease and safety of heat-activated crimping supports the continued use of this prosthesis for stapes surgery.     

Ossicular chain reconstruction: titanium versus plastipore

OBJECTIVE: To compare the complication rate and hearing results of a new, lightweight, titanium ossicular replacement prosthesis with Plastipore prostheses (Xomed, Jacksonville, FL). STUDY DESIGN: Retrospective. METHODS: Charts were reviewed for type of operation, type of prosthesis used, extrusion rate, prostheses failure rate, and hearing thresholds at multiple frequencies and at multiple follow-up points. The dependant variable for hearing results was the four-frequency average air-bone gap. RESULTS: There were 84 patients undergoing tympanoplasty with the Plastipore prosthesis and 53 with the titanium. There was one extrusion in the titanium group. There was an additional single incidence of prosthesis failure in the titanium group. Overall hearing results were comparable with an air-bone gap average of 19.3 dB in the Plastipore group compared with the titanium group with an air-bone gap of 22.0 dB (P =.08). Sixty percent of patients had a postoperative air-bone gap of 20 dB or less in the Plastipore group. In the titanium group, 45.3% achieved a 20 dB or less postoperative air-bone gap. Plastipore had a lower air-bone gap than the titanium when a canal wall up operation was performed (17.8 vs. 23.9 dB) and tended toward a lower air-bone gap when a total ossicular prosthesis was needed (22 vs. 27 dB) (P <.07). CONCLUSION: The titanium prosthesis is a new ossicular replacement prosthesis that provides excellent visualization during insertion and provides hearing results that are comparable with Plastipore. The Plastipore prosthesis performed better in canal wall up mastoidectomy situations and tended toward better performance when a total ossicular replacement prosthesis was needed.     

Hearing results with the titanium ossicular replacement prostheses

The purpose was to study the hearing results in patients receiving a Kurz titanium Bell partial ossicular replacement prosthesis (PORP) or an Aerial total ossicular replacement prosthesis (TORP). The study was a retrospective chart review in a tertiary otologic referral center. A computerized otologic database was used to identify 111 patients implanted with either a PORP or TORP prosthesis. Audiograms were reviewed and air-bone gaps were calculated for each patient. The improvement of the average air-bone gap (ABG) was 10.2 and 12.7 dB at 3 and 20 months after ossiculoplasty, respectively. Sixty-six percent of patients (73/111) had a postoperative air-bone gap of 20 dB or less. The ABG for the titanium PORP prosthesis was 14.3±9.7 dB, compared with 25.2±13.7 dB for the TORP prosthesis ( P <0.05). The ABG to within 20 dB or less was obtained in the PORP group in 77% of the cases, versus 52% of the cases in the TORP group ( P <0.05). Two extrusions of the prostheses were observed at 17 and 20 months after surgery (1.8%). Revision procedures for functional failure were carried out in 20 patients (18%). The rate of sensorineural hearing loss was 3.6%. The major factors influencing good audiometric results were the surgical procedure preserving the external auditory canal and the presence of the stapes. The best hearing results were achieved when a PORP was used in an intact canal wall (ICW) procedure, and the worst hearing results were achieved when a TORP was used in a canal wall down (CWD) procedure. The titanium Kurz prosthesis has been an effective implant at our institution for ossicular reconstruction.     

Congenital stapes ankylosis: study of 28 cases and surgical results

OBJECTIVE: The objective of this study was to analyze functional results after stapes surgery in patients with congenital nonprogressive conductive deafness resulting from an isolated fixation of the stapes according to age and surgical procedure. STUDY DESIGN: The authors conducted a retrospective case series from March 1993 to December 2003 in patients from two tertiary referral centers. METHODS: Twenty-eight patients were operated on by stapedotomy or partial stapedectomy using Teflon stapes prostheses. The median age at surgery was 14.2 years (range, 8.3-29.1 years). Main outcome measures were clinical and audiometric evaluation before and after surgery. Mean air conduction (MAC) and bone conduction (MBC) thresholds were recorded at 0.5, 1, 2, and 4 kHz. The evaluation of functional outcome was based on the MAC gain, the MBC comparison, and the mean postoperative and residual air-bone gaps. RESULTS: The median preoperative MAC was 50 dB (range, 19.0-65.0 dB) with a 35.0 dB median dB air-bone gap. With a mean follow up of 19 months, postoperative hearing improvement was statistically significant: median gain of 32.5 dB (P<.001) and median residual air-bone gap of 3.5 dB. The MBC was also statistically improved with median pre- and postoperative MBC of 11.5 and 6.5 dB, respectively (P<.001). Results were not dependent on the age group or type of surgery (stapedotomy or partial stapedectomy). No perceptive hearing loss was observed despite one gusher case. CONCLUSION: Surgical treatment of isolated congenital stapes ankylosis allows good functional results regardless of age or type of surgery.     

Microdrill stapedotomy for otosclerosis with small and large preoperative air-bone gap: a retrospective comparison of results

Abstract

Background: In otosclerosis mixed hearing loss is the most frequent symptom and arises when the focus involves the stapes footplate. Surgeons usually prefer to wait a minimum air-bone gap of 25 – 35?dB before surgery.

Objectives: To evaluate the outcome of microdrill stapedotomy for otosclerosis in patients with a preoperative air-bone gap (ABG) <25?dB versus patients with a preoperative gap ≥ 25?dB.

Material and methods: For this retrospective study, the outcomes and complications after microdrill stapedotomy were compared between adult patients with a preoperative small ABG (n?=?127, ABG <25?dB) and those with a large ABG (n?=?254, ABG ≥25?dB).

Results: The postoperative ABG was significantly smaller than the preoperative ABG (p?<?.05) in both groups; there were no differences in complications rates (severe sensorineural hearing loss, footplate fracture or early postoperative vertigo) between the two groups.

Conclusions: Our findings show that microdrill stapedotomy is safe and can be performed even in patients with a preoperative small ABG without increasing the risk of sensorineural hearing loss due to inner ear damage.     

Meningitis following stapedotomy: a rare and early complication

Controversy exists concerning stapedotomy for patients with small unilateral air-bone gaps. Surgical treatment of otosclerosis involves an opening to the labyrinth and accordingly, a risk of complications, usually vertigo and sensorineural hearing loss and infrequently anacusis. In this paper we present a 33-year-old woman with a small unilateral air-bone gap, who developed bacterial labyrinthitis with meningitis and anacusis three days after stapes surgery. The patient had a stapedotomy with the small fenestra piston prosthesis technique. Due to the potential for serious complications, patients with unilateral otosclerosis and mild hearing loss should be given the possibility to choose between a hearing aid and surgery. Although stapedotomy in the vast majority of interventions is a highly successful procedure and the best method of treatment for otosclerosis if successful, there is a high price to pay in the event of failure.     

Stapedectomy outcomes: titanium versus teflon wire prosthesis

OBJECTIVE: To compare the effectiveness of two stapes prostheses in hearing improvement of patients undergoing stapes surgery for otosclerosis. STUDY DESIGN: Retrospective chart review. METHODS: Titanium and Teflon wire stapes prostheses were compared with regard to effectiveness in closing the air-bone gap. The charts of 461 stapedectomies performed by one surgeon from 1996 to 2001 were reviewed. Patients who underwent stapedectomy for reasons other than otosclerosis, revision cases, and those with inadequate preoperative or postoperative bone-conduction threshold data were excluded. Small fenestra technique using either laser or drill was used for all patients. Inclusion criteria were met by 218 patients. Patients were then grouped according to type of prosthesis used, and hearing outcomes were compared. Measured outcomes were four frequency air-bone gap closure, pure-tone threshold, and rate of sensorineural hearing loss (SNHL). RESULTS: The study group was comprised of 35 titanium and 183 Teflon wire prostheses. Closure of the air-bone gap to less than 10 dB was achieved in 86% of the patients with Teflon prosthesis compared with 71% of those with titanium prostheses. The groups were equivalent in regard to site of otosclerotic disease as well as technique, laser or drill, used to create the fenestra. Rate of SNHL was low for both groups and not significantly different. CONCLUSIONS: Both prostheses provided comparable results, although the Teflon platinum wire prosthesis was slightly superior. The smaller numbers in the titanium group may confound these results. The design of the titanium prosthesis provides a crimp that is circumferential around the incus, and that prosthesis was selected in cases with a narrow incus. The selection bias may also influence the results seen in this study.     

不同术式治疗耳硬化症的疗效比较

目的：比较治疗耳硬化症不同术式的疗效。方法：回顾性分析1993～2005年行手术治疗且资料完整的耳硬化症患者70例（76耳）的临床资料，按术式分为3组：镫骨全切除术30例（33耳），足板小孔开窗术24例（27耳）和镫骨撼动或提高术16例（16耳），统计3组患者术后各频率段气骨导差闭合、骨导损失及眩晕发生率等指标，比较3种术式问的差异，同时比较镫骨撼动术5例（5耳）与镫骨提高术11例（11耳）2组手术亚型间的疗效差异。结果：3种术式术后言语频率气骨导差闭合无明显差异，但在高频气骨导差改善及减少术后高频感音神经性听力损失和眩晕方面，足板小孔开窗术和镫骨撼动或提高术明显优于镫骨全切除术，并有统计学意义。镫骨撼动术与镫骨提高术无论在听力改善或术后并发症发生率方面差异均无统计学意义。结论：3种术式在提高耳硬化症患者的听力方面均具有较好的疗效，其中以足板小孔开窗术疗效最佳，其次是镫骨撼动或提高术，并且在减少术后并发症方面均优于镫骨全切除术。足板小孔开窗术是治疗耳硬化症较理想的术式。     

Eliminating the limitations of manual crimping in stapes surgery: mid-term results of 90 patients in the Nitinol stapes piston multicenter trial

OBJECTIVE: To present our mid-term results of our multicenter study using the Nitinol self-crimping stapes piston, focusing on the interindividual variations of postoperative air-bone gap closures (ABGC), postoperative hearing results, and postoperative recurrences of conductive hearing loss and to compare these findings with our pilot group of patients. STUDY DESIGN: Prospective, multicenter cohort study involving three academic tertiary care referral centers from Australia, Switzerland, and the United States. METHODS: Ninety patients with otosclerosis undergoing laser-stapedotomy with the Nitinol stapes piston were matched to reference patients from our titanium piston database. The effects of the self-crimping Nitinol piston on the postoperative ABGC, the postoperative interindividual air-bone gap (ABG) variations, and the postoperative hearing results were investigated 3, 6, 12, 18, and 24 months postoperatively. These data were statistically compared with the results of the control patients in our titanium stapes piston database and the results of our previously published pilot study. RESULTS: The mean postoperative ABG and the interindividual variations of the postoperative ABG continue to be significantly smaller in the Nitinol group; the extent of ABGC now is significantly larger in the Nitinol piston group. The postoperative mid-term stability of ABGC was similar in both groups. No adverse reactions occurred during follow-up. CONCLUSION: Our mid-term results continue to show that the self-crimping shape memory alloy Nitinol stapes piston overcomes the limitations of manual malcrimping in stapedotomy, thus simplifying and optimizing the surgical procedure. This so far has allowed reliable, safe, and consistent ABGC in patients with otosclerosis.     

Audiological results of endoscopic surgical repair of the long process of incus

ObjectiveThe purpose of this study is to evaluate our experience with endoscopic repair of ossicular discontinuity at the incudostapedial joint, with or without an intact stapes suprastructure, and present our hearing results. We classify results based on the causative pathology, the type of ossiculoplasty, and type of lesion. We demonstrate the ability to endoscopically place a total ossicular replacement prosthesis (TORP), measuring 4.25 mm, between the stapes footplate and the incus remnant to reestablish ossicular continuity.MethodsThis was a retrospective case series conducted in tertiary referral center (Hopital de la Timone) Marseille, France. 25 patients underwent incudostapedial rebridging ossiculoplasty between 2009 and 2013. Fifteen cases of chronic otitis media and 10 otosclerosis revisions were included in the study. Three different materials were used in ossiculoplasty, hydroxyapatite cement, incus remnant, and partial/total ossicular replacement prostheses. Audiometric results were evaluated before and after ossiculoplasty. Twelve month follow-up data is provided.ResultsThe mean postoperative air-bone gap was 15 dB (5–25 dB). Hearing results were better inotosclerosis revisions. Hydroxyapatite cement produced an air-bone gap of 5 dB, TORP placed under the incus produced a 12 dB gap, and TORP placed under the malleus resulted in a 12 dB gap and one deaf ear. In cases of chronic otitis media, the residual air-bone gap was 17 dB with PORP, 12 dB with TORP, and 20 dB with incus transposition.ConclusionThe hydroxyapatite cement is effective in the reconstruction of ossicular discontinuity but the high price limits its utilization. TORP placed under the incus is a reliable and stable method of ossicular reconstruction that is cost effective and offers satisfactory hearing results in selected patients.     

Short- and long-term results of stapedotomy and stapedectomy with a teflon-wire piston prosthesis

We analyzed the results of 604 cases of primary stapes surgery performed between 1974 and 1997 with replacement of the stapes by a 0.6- or 0.8-mm Schuknecht Teflon-wire piston. At long-term follow-up (1 to 21 years; mean, 7 years), the residual air-bone gap was 10 dB or less in 79% of the cases. The hearing results and postoperative complications were comparable to those reported by authors who used the same evaluation criteria. Although the aim of the surgery was to perform a small stapedotomy with a narrow footplate perforation (0.8 mm), a large stapedotomy or a stapedectomy was performed in 134 cases (22.2%) because of surgical or anatomic conditions. Our results show that the larger footplate perforations allowed a better correction of the air-bone gap at the lower frequencies. The ears with larger perforations did not show a higher incidence of sensorineural hearing loss.     

Stapes surgery preserving the superstructure of stapes (Takagi’s stapedotomy) in otosclerosis: A retrospective study of 24 consecutive cases

Objective

The aim of this study was to evaluate the hearing outcomes and complications of stapedotomy in which the stapes superstructure was preserved (Takagi’s stapedotomy). In this surgical approach, the lenticular process of the incus rather is removed, than the superstructure of the stapes.

A new L-shaped titanium prosthesis for total reconstruction of the ossicular chain.

OBJECTIVE: To describe the technique used for total ossiculoplasty with the Fisch titanium total prosthesis and evaluate the 1-year postoperative functional results in patients presenting with the stapes (or footplate) without the malleus handle. STUDY DESIGN: Prospective trial with preoperative and postoperative comparison. SETTING: Academic and private practice tertiary care center for otologic surgery. PATIENTS: Forty-nine consecutive patients operated on from September 1996 to December 2000. SURGERY:: Staged ossicular reconstruction with a Fisch titanium total prosthesis placed between the footplate and the tympanic membrane without regard to the presence or absence of the stapes arch. Coupling of the prosthesis to the footplate was achieved by various techniques, including perforation, foot and spike on the footplate without perforation, and shaft alone (without foot) with tragal cartilage fixation (disc or small wedges). There was no interposition of cartilage between the prosthesis head and the tympanic membrane. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Pre- and postoperative air and bone-conduction thresholds and air-bone gaps for pure-tone averages of three and four frequencies and for single frequencies. RESULTS: Postoperative air-bone gap closures within 20 dB distributed equally (50%) between 0.5, 1, and 4 kHz and reached the highest rate (89%) at 2 kHz (p < 0.05). The postoperative air-bone gaps for pure-tone averages reached 0 to 20 dB in 57% and 0 to 30 dB in 87% of the cases. There were no dead ears and no partial or total extrusions of prostheses. The best functional results were achieved through perforation coupling of the spiked foot to the footplate in large oval windows and after fixation of the shaft (without foot) with tragal cartilage disc in narrow oval windows. CONCLUSION: The functional results of the L-shaped Fisch titanium total prosthesis implanted in ears with the stapes but no malleus handle are best at 2 kHz and better than those of comparable columellar titanium prostheses over the remaining tested frequencies.     

Gold and titanium in the oval window: a comparison of two metal stapes prostheses.

OBJECTIVE: The objective of this study was to evaluate the hearing results of stapes surgery with 2 different full metal stapes prostheses. STUDY DESIGN: Retrospective analyses were carried out on the pre- and postoperative hearing results obtained after primary stapedotomy with 2 different prostheses. PATIENTS: We studied 106 patients with otosclerosis treated by stapes surgery. INTERVENTION: Fifty-three patients had a stapedotomy with a gold piston and 53 patients received a titanium piston after stapedotomy. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: The results were compared according to mean audiometric parameters. Furthermore, the individual audiologic results were demonstrated with the Amsterdam Hearing Evaluations Plot (AHEP). This method is a visual presentation of the hearing result for each operated ear. RESULTS: These AHEPs showed that the heavier gold piston (shaft ? 0.4 mm and weight 10192.0 microg) gives more overclosure gain (28.3%) than the lightweight (shaft ? 0.4 mm and weight 2541.0 microg) titanium piston (9.4% cases of overclosure). CONCLUSIONS: Because of the different properties of the 2 pistons (gold very malleable, titanium rather stiff), a choice can be made for different anatomic or pathologic situations in the operated middle ear. The "overclosure effect" of the gold piston is higher compared with the titanium piston.