Well-being and occupational rights: An imperative for critical occupational therapy

Abstract

Background: One of occupational therapy's core assumptions is that engagement in occupations influences well-being. Because occupational engagement is integral to human well-being, and because well-being is integral to human rights, this paper contends that the ability and opportunity to engage in occupations is an issue that concerns rights. Aims: To outline well-being and its centrality to human rights; to explore the relationships between well-being and occupation and between well-being and occupational rights; and to highlight the consequent imperative to engage in critical occupational therapy. Key issues: The World Federation of Occupational Therapists asserts that all people have the right to participate in a range of occupations that enable them to flourish, fulfil their potential, and experience satisfaction congruent with their culture and beliefs; and further asserts the human right to equitable access to participation in occupation. Conclusions: If occupational therapists are to take seriously their espoused commitment to enabling equitable access to participation in occupation, the inequitable conditions of people's lives will need to be addressed. Critical occupational therapy is a committed form of practice which acknowledges that well-being cannot be achieved solely by enhancing individuals' abilities, and that consequently endeavours also to address the conditions of people's lives.     

The Rights of Persons With Dementia and Their Meanings

Concern about the lack of human rights afforded to persons living with dementia has emerged in recent years. Although the literature addresses certain rights, it does not include a holistic framework of rights in terms of the lived experience of older persons with cognitive impairment. Inspired by the 20 rights advocated for children by physician-educator Janusz Korczak, this article analyzes his formulation of rights in the context of persons with dementia, linking them to the ethical principles of Beneficence, Autonomy, and Justice. The analysis thus provides a holistic framework for addressing the human rights of persons with dementia, and their meanings for the lived experiences of persons with dementia and their caregivers. It offers new insights into the philosophy and practice of care, with implications for dementia care research, public health policy, practice guidelines for health care professionals, and the instruction of family and other caregivers of persons with dementia.     

Contraceptive knowledge and use among women with intellectual,physical, or sensory disabilities: A systematic review

Background

Women spend most of their reproductive years avoiding pregnancy. However, we know little about contraceptive knowledge and use among women with disabilities, or about strategies to improve contraceptive knowledge and decision-making in this population.

Dual loyalties and the ethical and human rights obligations of occupational health professionals

BACKGROUND: Underlying most ethical dilemmas in occupational health practice is the problem of Dual Loyalties where health professionals have simultaneous obligations, explicit or implicit, to a third party, usually a private employer. METHODS: A literature review was undertaken of case studies of workplace occupational health conflicts, international human rights and ethical codes and strategies for managing dual loyalties, complemented by iterative discussions in an international working group convened to address the problem of Dual Loyalties. RESULTS: Violations of the worker-patient's human rights may arise from: (1) the incompatibility of simultaneous obligations; (2) pressure on the professional from the third party; and (3) separation of the health professional's clinical role from that of a social agent. The practitioner's contractual relationship with the third party is often the underlying problem, being far more explicit than their moral obligation to patients, and encouraging a social identification at the expense of a practitioner's professional identity. CONCLUSIONS: Because existing ethical guidelines lack specificity on managing Dual Loyalties in occupational health, guidelines that draw on human rights standards have been developed by the working group. These guidelines propose standards for individual professional conduct and complementary institutional mechanisms to address the problem.     

Perspectives on quality of life of people with intellectual disabilities: The interpretation of discrepancies between clients and caregivers

Large discrepancies have sometimes been found between the quality of life (QOL) experienced by clients with intellectual disabilities and their QOL as described by their caregivers. Olsen and Schober (Soc Indi Res 1993; 28: 173–193) may have provided a framework useful to conceptualize such discrepancies. They suggested that lack of concordance between objective circumstances (i.e. poverty) and perceived QOL must not be treated as measurement noise, but as a source of information. They speculated on the psychological processes that underly and explain this lack of concordance; particularly processes that try to deal with the stress induced by cognitive dissonance and learned helplessness. In this study low to moderate agreement was found between caregivers judgement of QOL of individual clients and clients’ own perception of QOL. In some areas and for some clients the discrepancies indicated dissonance (caregivers are satisfied, clients are not) and in other areas and for other clients adaptation (clients are satisfied, caregivers are not). There were systematic differences between clients falling in these groups with respect to their personal characteristics and with respect to factual conditions of care. These outcomes are interpreted with respect to Olson and Schober’s contentions regarding the psychological processes that underly a person’s experience of QOL. The Olson and Schober framework appears to be a fruitful way to combine different sources of information regarding QOL.     

Patients' rights, quality of life, and health care system performance

The purpose of this paper is to promote the development of a social contract between patient and clinician that permits patients to state how they want to live as they survive rather than what they are willing to lose to extend their survival. To do this, patients must have sufficient leverage to affect the nature of the care they receive. This leverage, it is proposed, can be achieved by first making a Declaration of Patients Rights Relative to Their Quality of Life' and then evaluating the extent to which the patient's providers comply with this rights statement. The paper also reviews The World Health Report 2000 [Health Systems: Improving Performance Geneva: WHO, 2000] as an example of an alternative approach to defining a health care social contract and evaluating a health system's performance. Also discussed, were steps that could be taken to facilitate the integration of the patients' rights statement into medical practice and health care systems performance.     

Routine identification of patients with disabilities in primary care: A mixed-methods study

BackgroundPeople with disabilities experience barriers to receiving healthcare and often have worse health outcomes, but data on disability is rarely routinely collected in a standardized way.ObjectiveThis study examined how patients responded to being asked about disabilities as part of a routine, self-administered sociodemographic survey.MethodsWe conducted a mixed-methods study in a multi-site primary care organization. We compared the characteristics of people who responded to a question about disabilities to those who did not respond using logistic regression. We also compared survey responses to data available in medical charts. In-depth interviews were conducted with a sample of patients following survey completion.ResultsOver 28 months, 15,221 patients were offered the survey and 14,247 (93.6%) responded to at least one question. Of these, 11,275 (79.1%) patients answered the question about disabilities. Older patients, patients who rented their home, and non-White patients were less likely to respond to the question. When comparing survey responses to data from medical charts we identified discrepancies. Patients interviewed reported they had difficulty judging what constituted a disability. Stigma related to mental illness and substance use led them to avoid disclosing those conditions.ConclusionsDirectly asking patients whether they have a disability may be challenging given confusion about what constitutes a disability and stigma associated with certain disabilities. Future research should examine whether asking about barriers faced in accessing health services could adequately identify patients with disabilities and also be used to identify tangible actions an organization could take to lower barriers to care.     

The application of client-centred occupational therapy for Korean children with developmental disabilities

The aim of this paper was to investigate the effectiveness of client-centred occupational therapy using the Canadian Occupational Performance Measure (COPM) and the Assessment of Motor and Process Skills (AMPS). Eight girls and 23 boys from Korea, with developmental disabilities and from 3 to 10 years of age participated in this study. Each child participated in 20 to 24 sessions of client-centred occupational therapy. Both the COPM and the AMPS change scores demonstrated statistically significant improvement (p < 0.01) in occupational performance. Significant correlations were found between COPM - Performance and AMPS - Motor skills (r(s) = 0.64, p < 0.05), and COPM - Satisfaction and AMPS - Process skills (r(s) = 0.62, p < 0.05) in a group positive towards client-centred occupational therapy. The COPM was a valuable tool in guiding and measuring the client-centred occupational therapy for children with developmental disabilities. The small sample size of 31 children limits the generalizability of the study's results. Future research needs to use a larger and more diverse sample of children to further validate the effectiveness of client-centred occupational therapy.     

Human rights,public health and medicinal cannabis use

This paper explores the interplay between the human rights and drug control frameworks and critiques case law on medicinal cannabis use to demonstrate that a bona fide human rights perspective allows for a broader conception of ‘health’. This broad conception, encompassing both medicalised and social constructionist definitions, can inform public health policies relating to medicinal cannabis use. The paper also demonstrates how a human rights lens can alleviate a core tension between the State and the individual within the drug policy field. The leading medicinal cannabis case in the UK highlights the judiciary’s failure to engage with an individual’s human right to health as they adopt an arbitrary, externalist view, focussing on the legality of cannabis to the exclusion of other concerns. Drawing on some international comparisons, the paper considers how a human rights perspective can lead to an approach to medicinal cannabis use which facilitates a holistic understanding of public health.     

Non-communicable diseases and human rights: Global synergies,gaps and opportunities

The incorporation of human rights in health policy and programmes is known to strengthen responses to health problems and help address disparities created or exacerbated by illness yet this remains underexplored in relation to non-communicable diseases (NCDs). Aiming to understand existing synergies and how they might be further strengthened, we assessed the extent to which human rights are considered in global NCD policies and strategies and the degree of attention given to NCDs by select United Nations human rights mechanisms. Across global NCD policies and strategies, rhetorical assertions regarding human rights appear more often than actionable statements, thus limiting their implementation and impact. Although no human rights treaty explicitly mentions NCDs, some human rights monitoring mechanisms have been paying increasing attention to NCDs. This provides important avenues for promoting the incorporation of human rights norms and standards into NCD responses as well as for accountability. Linking NCDs and human rights at the global level is critical for encouraging national-level action to promote better outcomes relating to both health and human rights. The post-2015 development agenda constitutes a key entry point for highlighting these synergies and strengthening opportunities for health and rights action at global, national and local levels.     

On fertile ground: An initial evaluation of green care farms in the United States

ABSTRACT

Green care farms (GCF) provide unique opportunities to persons with disabilities to engage in meaningful and therapeutic activities in farm settings. In this pilot study, the researchers examined the feasibility and impact of the first GCF in the United States. Qualitative interviews (N = 19) and thematic analysis were conducted. GCF participants and family members were enthusiastic about participation and identified benefits such as respite and improved mood. Administrators and farmers indicated that GCF challenged the status quo of funding, programming, and farming. Administrators speculated that the future success of GCF relies upon administrative expertise, local relationships, and managing risk and liability.     

医疗资源重组与医院产权制度调整

医疗资源重组与医院产权制度调整之间存在一定的因果关系.产权制度变化不一定会产生资源重组,但多数情况下的医疗资源重组要触及医院的产权制度.随着卫生改革的深化,医疗资源重组和医院产权制度调整的势头还会加强,但不是所有的医院都需要参与资源重组和产权制度调整.     

职业病网络报告系统用户权限管理现状及对策

目的分析职业病网络报告系统用户权限管理现状和问题,为进一步加强权限管理提出建议。方法将截至2018年4月底在"中国疾病预防控制信息系统"的用户身份认证管理系统——"用户认证与授权管理系统"注册的、与职业病网络报告工作相关的系统管理员、业务管理员、本级用户、直报用户,使用SPSS 23.0软件对数据进行处理,对用户分布、用户所在机构设置的用户数、用户权限情况等进行分析。结果职业病与职业卫生信息监测系统共有各级各类用户35 144个,其中直报用户最多(24 788个,占70.53%),业务管理员用户最少(2 138个,占6.08%)。直报用户均设为县区级,绝大部分分布在卫生院(11 208个,占45.22%)和医院(8 435个,占34.03%),88.74%的直报机构仅有1个直报账户,3.06%的直报机构有3个及以上直报账户,个别机构直报用户数甚至超过10个。本级用户分布在3 140家职业病报告业务管理机构中,个别地市级和县区级职业病业务管理机构具有5个以上的本级用户。各类机构中大部分用户设置的角色数在5个以内;有15 022个(占60.60%)直报用户使用了"所有报告卡直报角色",主要分布在卫生院。存在的主要问题:基层尤其是县区级职业病防治机构、职业病报告业务管理机构能力不足;部分基层机构用户数设置过多;部分用户权限设置不合理,业务管理员管理欠规范。结论加强基层职业病报告业务管理机构的能力,进一步规范各级各类机构用户和权限管理,业务管理员严格授权,国家出台细化的用户和权限管理规范等措施来进一步加强权限管理工作。     

HIV epidemic and human rights among men who have sex with men in sub-Saharan Africa: Implications for HIV prevention,care, and surveillance

Recent research has presented evidence that men who have sex with men (MSM) bear a disproportionate burden of HIV and are at increased risk for HIV in sub-Saharan Africa (SSA). However, many countries in SSA have failed to address the needs of MSM in national HIV/AIDS programmes. Furthermore, many MSM face structural barriers to HIV prevention and care, the most significant of which include laws that criminalise male-to-male sexual contact and facilitate stigma and discrimination. This in turn increases the vulnerability of MSM to acquiring HIV and presents barriers to HIV prevention, care, and surveillance. This relationship illustrates the link between human rights, social justice, and health outcomes and presents considerable challenges to addressing the HIV epidemic among MSM in SSA. The response to the HIV epidemic in SSA requires a non-discriminatory human rights approach to all at-risk groups, including MSM. Existing international human rights treaties, to which many SSA countries are signatories, and a ‘health in all policies’ approach provides a strong basis to reduce structural barriers to HIV prevention, care, surveillance, and research, and to ensure that all populations in SSA, including MSM, have access to the full range of rights that help ensure equal opportunities for health and wellness.     

Human rights protections and HIV prevalence among MSM who sell sex: Cross-country comparisons from a systematic review and meta-analysis

Laws and policies can affect the HIV risk of key populations through a number of direct and indirect pathways. We investigated the association between HIV prevalence among men who engage in transactional sex and language in the penal code protecting sexual minorities, including men who have sex with men (MSM), and sex workers. HIV prevalence among men who engage in transactional sex was assessed through meta-analysis of published literature and country surveillance reports. Meta-regression was used to determine the association between HIV prevalence and protective laws for sexual minorities and sex workers. Sixty-six reports representing 28 countries and 31,924 individuals were included in the meta-analysis. Controlling for multiple study- and country-level variables, legal protection for sexual minorities was associated with a 10.9% (95% CI: 3.8–18.0%) and sex workers associated with a 7.0% (95% CI: 1.3–12.8%) decrease in country-level HIV prevalence among men who engage in transactional sex. Laws that seek to actively protect sex workers and MSM may be necessary to decrease HIV risk for this key population.