Skewing of TCR V genes to CD4+ and CD8+ subsets of T lymphocytes is not determined by amino acid composition of CDR3

TCR V genes show differing expression patterns, termed skewing, in CD4+ and CD8+ subsets of T lymphocytes. To determine which elements of the TCR V regions contribute to these observed TCR V gene skewing patterns, we have performed an in-depth analysis, taking advantage of RT-PCR and DNA sequencing, which was focused on the multi-member TCRBV6 gene family. These studies allowed us to evaluate the contributions of the various elements, that constitute the TCR beta chain variable region, to the observed TCR V gene skewing patterns. The results of these analyses revealed that within the TCRBV6 family individual members exhibited differing skewing patterns, i.e. TCRB6S7 was significantly skewed towards the CD4+ T cell subset, whereas TCRBV6S5 was significantly skewed towards the CD8+ subset. Scrutiny of the usage of TCRBV6 family members in combination with TCRBJ gene usage and amino acid composition of CDR3 did not reveal obvious structural characteristics which would explain the differing skewing patterns between TCRBV6S7 and TCRBV6S5. Further examination of these TCR V regions showed that the CDR1 and 2 regions within these TCRBV elements were composed of different amino acids. These observations suggests that these components contribute to the observed TCR V gene skewing patterns.      

Diffuse large cell lymphomas are derived from mature B cells carrying V region genes with a high load of somatic mutation and evidence of selection for antibody expression

In the Revised European American Lymphoma (REAL) classification, several subtypes of high-grade lymphomas were combined in the entity diffuse large cell lymphoma (DLL). In the present study, a total of 19 cases of DLL (10 cases of centroblastic lymphoma, 5 cases of mediastinal B cell lymphoma, 2 cases of immunoblastic lymphoma, 1 case of T cell-rich B lymphoma and one case of large cell anaplastic lymphoma) were analyzed for somatically mutated immunoglobulin V region genes. Somatic mutations are acquired in the course of the germinal center (GC) reaction and are thus found in GC B cells and their descendants, i.e. memory B cells. The V gene sequences revealed that the tumor cells of all five subtypes of DLL harbored mutated V region genes and are thus derived from antigen-experienced (post) GC B cells. This indicates that from the point of view of the stage of development of the tumor precursor, the combination of those five subtypes to one entity, i.e. DLL, seems reasonable. In some cases, an unusually high frequency of somatic mutations was detected. This may indicate that DLL are derived from GC B cells, which, due to transforming events, stayed in the GC for prolonged periods of time, thereby accumulating a high load of somatic mutation. An analysis of the mutation pattern suggests that the tumor clone or its precursor were selected for antibody expression while acquiring somatic mutations. The latter observation discriminates DLL from classical Hodgkin's disease, where we recently also observed a high load of somatic mutation within rearranged V region genes, but a frequent occurrence of crippling mutations.     

Clonal dominance and selection for similar complementarity determining region 3 motifs among T lymphocytes responding to the HLA-DR3-associated Mycobacterium leprae heat shock protein 65-KD peptide 3–13

In order to establish whether specific MHC class II-peptide complexes are capable of selecting TCR V regions, we investigated in detail the TCR β chain used in the recognition of HLA-DR3 restricted hsp65 peptide 3–13 in a tuberculoid leprosy patient. Using RT-PCR, a clear dominance of the TCRBV5 gene family was observed in a hsp65 peptide 3–13-specific T-cell line; however, not in fresh, unstimulated PBMCs, PHA-stimulated PBMCs, or a T-cell line specific for tetanus toxoid.

DNA sequence analysis of the TCR V regions, comprising TCRBV5 genes, derived from the hsp65 peptide 3–13-specific T-cell line revealed the exclusive usage of the TCRBV5S1 gene segment and a predominance of one V-D-J gene rearrangement, which is indicative of clonal expansion of these T lymphocytes. Additional highly similar V-D-J gene rearrangements were detected at a low level in this hsp65 peptide 3–13-specific T-cell line. These conserved junctional regions (CDR3 regions) could not be detected within the TCRBV5 gene family of fresh PBMCs, PHA-stimulated PBMCs, hsp65, and tetanus-toxoid-specific T-cell lines from this patient.

The observations in this tuberculoid leprosy patient reveal that an HLA class-II-restricted T-cell response results in selection of TCRBV regions which are highly similar in amino acid composition to the CDR3 region within the expanding TCRBV regions.     

TCR gamma chain diversity in the spleen of the duckbill platypus (Ornithorhynchus anatinus)

TCR gamma (TRG) chain diversity in splenic gammadelta T cells was determined for an egg-laying mammal (or monotreme), the duckbill platypus. Three distinct V subgroups were found in the expressed TRG chains and these three subgroups are members of a clade not found so far in eutherian mammals or birds. Each subgroup contains approximately five V gene segments, and their overall divergence is much less than is found in eutherians and birds, consistent with their recent evolution from an ancestral V gene segment. The platypus TRG locus also contains three C region genes and many of the residues involved in TCR function, such as interactions with CD3, were conserved in the monotreme C regions. All non-eutherian mammals (monotremes and marsupials) lacked the second cysteine residue necessary to form the intradomain disulfide bond in the C region, a loss apparently due to independent mutations in marsupials and monotremes. Monotreme TRGC regions also had among the most variation in the length of the connecting peptide region described for any species due to repeated motifs.     

T cell-independent somatic hypermutation in murine B cells with an immature phenotype

Somatic hypermutation contributes to the generation of antibody diversity and is strongly associated with the maturation of antigen-specific immune responses. We asked whether somatic hypermutation also plays a role in the generation of the murine immunoglobulin repertoire during B cell development. To facilitate identification of somatic mutations, we examined mouse systems in which only antibodies expressing lambda1, lambda2, and lambdax light chains can be generated. Somatic mutations were found in cells, which, by surface markers, RAG expression, and rapid turnover, had the phenotype of immature B cells. In addition, expression of AID was detected in these cells. The mutations were limited to V regions and were localized in known hotspots. Mutation frequency was not diminished in the absence of T cells. Our results support the idea that somatic hypermutation can occur in murine immature B cells and may represent a mechanism for enlarging the V gene repertoire.     

Single-cell PCR analysis of T helper cells in human lymph node germinal centers

The T helper cell population of human lymph node germinal centers (GCs) was analyzed for clonality and signs of antigen selection. Frozen sections of lymph node biopsies taken from three different individuals were used to micromanipulate single T cells from one particular GC for each of the specimens. T cell receptor (TCR) beta gene rearrangements were amplified from these single cells and directly sequenced. Although only unique rearrangements were amplified from T cells of GC2 and GC3, 11 of 28 potentially functional rearrangements amplified from GC1 originated from four different clones. In all three GCs, TCR gene rearrangements neither showed obvious biases in gene segment usage nor similarities in complementarity determining region 3 amino acid sequence. Thus, it appears that T lymphocytes in human GCs usually represent a diverse population of cells. Sequence analysis of V region genes did not provide evidence that in the human the process of somatic hypermutation acts on the TCRbeta loci. For one of the GCs (GC3), immunoglobulin heavy chain (IgH) gene rearrangements were amplified and sequenced from single micromanipulated GC B cells. The detection of clonal expansions accounting for more than half of the sampled B cells in addition to ongoing somatic hypermutation of Ig V region genes suggested that GC3 was a fully developed GC.     

Somatic hypermutation of immunoglobulin genes is independent of the Bloom's syndrome DNA helicase

Immunoglobulin gene somatic mutation leads to antibody affinity maturation through the introduction of multiple point mutations in the antigen binding site. No genes have as yet been identified that participate in this process. Bloom's syndrome (BS) is a chromosomal breakage disorder with a mutator phenotype. Most affected individuals exhibit an immunodeficiency of undetermined aetiology. The gene for this disorder, BLM, has recently been identified as a DNA helicase. If this gene were to play a role in immunoglobulin mutation, then people with BS may lack normally mutated antibodies. Since germ-line, non-mutated immunoglobulin genes generally produce low affinity antibodies, impaired helicase activity might be manifested as the immunodeficiency found in BS. Therefore, we asked whether BLM is specifically involved in immunoglobulin hypermutation. Sequences of immunoglobulin variable (V) regions were analysed from small unsorted blood samples obtained from BS individuals and compared with germ-line sequences. BS V regions displayed the normal distribution of mutations, indicating that the defect in BS is not related to the mechanism of somatic mutation. These data strongly argue against BLM being involved in this process. The genetic approach to identifying the genes involved in immunoglobulin mutation will require further studies of DNA repair- and immunodeficient individuals.     

Genetic plasticity of V genes under somatic hypermutation: statistical analyses using a new resampling-based methodology

Evidence for somatic hypermutation of immunoglobulin genes has been observed in all of the species in which immunoglobulins have been found. Previous studies have suggested that codon usage in immunoglobulin variable (V) region genes is such that the sequence-specificity of somatic hypermutation results in greater mutability in complementarity-determining regions of the gene than in the framework regions. We have developed a new resampling-based methodology to explore genetic plasticity in individual V genes and in V gene families in a statistically meaningful way. We determine what factors contribute to this mutability difference and characterize the strength of selection for this effect. We find that although the codon usage in immunoglobulin V genes renders them distinct among translationally equivalent sequences with random codon usage, they are nevertheless not optimal in this regard. We find that the mutability patterns in a number of species are similar to those we find for human sequences. Interestingly, sheep sequences show extremely strong mutability differences, consistent with the role of somatic hypermutation in the diversification of primary antibody repertoire in these animals. Human TCR V(beta) sequences resemble immunoglobulin in mutability pattern, suggesting one of several alternatives, that hypermutation is functionally operating in TCR, that it was once operating in TCR or in the common precursor of TCR and immunoglobulin, or that the hypermutation mechanism has evolved to exploit the codon usage in immunoglobulin (and fortuitously, TCR) rather than vice-versa. Our findings provide support to the hypothesis that somatic hypermutation appeared very early in the phylogeny of immune systems, that it is, to a large extent, shared between species, and that it makes an essential contribution to the generation of the antibody repertoire.     

A novel approach for preparing anti-T cell receptor constant region antibodies

To obtain antibodies against the individual chains of the T cell receptor (TCR) complex, we have produced chimeric proteins containing domains from immunoglobulin (Ig) and TCR polypeptide chains. Basically, the Ig light chains were used as carriers for the TCR constant (C) region domains. The exons which encode the main body of the C regions of the alpha, beta and the related gamma polypeptide chains were "engineered" into the intronic region between the rearranged Ig variable (V) region and C kappa region genes. All three chimeric genes were expressed in myeloma cells, and the proteins of expected apparent molecular weight were produced. Secreted proteins containing the C beta domain were purified from the culture supernatant by using anti-kappa antibody affinity columns, and two rabbits were then immunized with the purified protein. Both rabbits produced antibodies able to immunoprecipitate the heterodimeric TCR protein.     

High levels of AID cause strand bias of mutations at A versus T in Burkitt's lymphoma cells

Ig gene somatic hypermutation in the germinal center (GC) B cells occurs at C and G at roughly the same frequency. In contrast, there is a 2-fold increase of mutations at A relative to T on the non-transcribed strand of the V genes but it is unclear what triggers such strand bias. Using an efficient mutagenesis system that recapitulates characteristic features of Ig gene hypermutation in the GC B cells, we found that low levels of AID induced similar frequency of mutations at A and T. However, high levels of AID specifically increased mutations at A, but not T, leading to strand bias. These results explain why strand bias of A:T mutations is observed only in the highly mutated V genes but not in the less mutated switch region or the BCL-6 gene. High levels of AID also increased the proportion of transversions at G relative to transversions at C. Our results identify a clue to the strand bias of A:T mutations and provide an in vitro model to elucidate this unsolved mystery in the hypermutation field.     

Molecular Ig gene analysis reveals that monocytoid B cell lymphoma is a malignancy of mature B cells carrying somatically mutated V region genes and suggests that rearrangement of the kappa-deleting element (resulting in deletion of the Ig kappa enhancers) abolishes somatic hypermutation in the human

Five cases of monocytoid B cell lymphoma (MBCL) were analyzed for somatic mutations in the rearranged V region genes. Somatic mutations were found in four of the five cases, whereas one unusual CD5⁺ lymphoma harbored unmutated V region genes. Since somatic mutations are introduced into V regiongenes of antigen-activated B cells in the course of T cell-dependent immune responses, these results suggest a derivation of the tumor B cells in MBCL from antigen-experienced mature B cells. An analysis of the ϰ-deleting element in two of the cases in which mutated V_H but unmutated and nonfunctional V_ϰ gene rearrangements were found suggests that somatic hypermutation does not take place in human rearranged V_ϰ region genes when the C_ϰ gene and the ϰ enhancers have been deleted in cis by rearrangement of the ϰ-deleting element.     

Imprint of somatic hypermutation differs in human immunoglobulin heavy and lambda chain variable gene segments

Somatic hypermutation (SHM) introduces mutations into immunoglobulin (Ig) variable gene segments, thus diversifying the B cell repertoire prior to positive selection of high affinity variants during maturation of T cell-dependent B cell responses. Somatic hypermutation of Ig heavy chain generates predominantly single base substitutions, favoring transition rather than transversion substitutions, and tends to direct mutations to specific 4-mer target sequences with G in second and C in third position. Here we have analyzed heavily mutated, nonproductively rearranged Ig lambda chain variable gene segments from human intestinal plasma cells, controlling for germline composition of the genes and local sequence variability. We have observed significant G.C strand bias in IgV(lambda), and differences in some di- and trinuleotide target preferences in IgV(lambda) compared to IgV(H). There is also a significant tendency to accumulate adjacent triplet mutations in IgV(lambda), which is not evident in IgV(H) in normal circumstances. These observations suggest that some aspect of the mechanism of somatic hypermutation operates differently in human immunoglobulin heavy and lambda light chain variable gene segments.     

Somatic hypermutation of TCR γ V genes in the sandbar shark

In a recent publication we demonstrated that somatic hypermutation occurs in the V region of the TCR γ gene of the sandbar shark (Carcharhinus plumbeus). We hypothesize that similar mechanisms are used to generate somatic mutations in both immunoglobulin and TCR γ genes of the sharks. Two distinct patterns of mutation occur, single nucleotide mutations (point mutations) and mutations comprising 2-5 consecutive bases (tandem mutations). Our data indicates that point mutations occur by a mechanism similar to that of somatic hypermutation in immunoglobulin genes of mammals, whereas tandem mutations may be generated by an error-prone DNA polymerase with terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase (TdT)-like activity. Shark hotspot motifs identical to those of higher vertebrates were identified. We confirm that, as in immunoglobulin of sharks and higher vertebrates, highly significant targeting of AID activity to the classical DGYW/WRCH motif occurs in somatic hypermutation of sandbar shark TCR γ V genes. Our analysis suggests that the purpose of somatic mutations in shark TCR γ V-regions is to generate a more diverse repertoire in γ/δ receptors, rather than receptors with higher affinity.     

TCRBV3S1 and TCRBV18 gene segment polymorphisms in Brazilian Caucasoid and Black populations

The T‐cell receptor (TCR) repertoire plays an important role in shaping specific immune responses. Genetic polymorphisms at the TCR locus, in both constant and variable regions, seem to represent an important mechanism for generating inter‐individual and inter‐population differences. Considering the scarcity of immune parameters characterized for normal human populations, we decided to determine the frequency of two TCRBV polymorphisms (located in the TCRBV3S1 and TCRBV18 gene segments) in two ethnically distinct groups of the general Brazilian population. Both polymorphisms are related to the expression of these segments at the T‐cell surface and can consequently modulate the T‐cell repertoire, potentially modifying the capacity of a given individual to develop an immune response. These DNA polymorphisms were analysed in material obtained from adult, normal South‐American Caucasoid and Black individuals. A total of 139 individuals were analysed for the TCRBV3S1 and 141 for the TCRBV18 gene segment polymorphisms. The data indicated statistically significant differences in allelic frequencies for the two ethnic groups analysed, suggesting that any correlation between TCR usage or T‐cell repertoire and development of a given disease should take in account the ethnic origin of the population studied.     

Detection of a T cell receptor delta chain with an anti-TCR alpha chain serum.

Two types of T cell antigen-specific receptors have been described. Most peripheral blood T lymphocytes express, at their surface, an antigen receptor consisting of alpha and beta subunits, while a small subset of thymocytes and a minority of mature T lymphocytes express a heterodimeric receptor termed gamma delta. Whereas the gene segments localization corresponding to the TCR gamma and beta chains are separate, genes encoding the joining and the constant regions of TCR delta chain are located between the TCR V alpha region and the J alpha-C alpha gene cluster. To determine whether V alpha gene segments are used by delta chains, immunoprecipitations from human TCR gamma delta expressing cell clones were performed with an anti-alpha serum. The results show that a rabbit antiserum raised against the purified REX TCR alpha subunit immunoprecipitates a TCR delta chain from the cell surface of only one human T cell clone termed SO1. However, since no SO1 RNA hybridization is observed with REX TCR V alpha probe and SO1 cloned cells do react with an anti-V delta 2 monoclonal antibody, we conclude that TCR delta and alpha chains expressed a limited structural homology and that REX TCR V alpha gene do not seem to be frequently used in a functional delta chain.     

Alteration of T-cell receptor repertoires during thymic T-cell development

The majority of thymocytes die in the thymus, whereas small populations of T cells that are able to specifically recognize an antigen are considered to survive. Although the thymic selection is thought to have a profound effect on T-cell receptor (TCR) repertoire, little is known how TCR repertoire is formed during the thymocyte developmental process. We examined TCRalpha- and beta-chain variable regions (TCRAV and TCRBV) repertoire in thymic T-cell subpopulations from mice bearing different major histocompatibility (MHC) haplotypes. In Balb/c mice, but not C57BL/6, remarkable alterations of the TCR repertoire were observed in mature T-cell subpopulations as previously reported. In contrast, there were no significant differences of TCRBV repertoire between DN3 (CD25(+)CD44(-)) and DN4 (CD25(-)CD44(-)), and between DN4 and DP. These results suggest that (1) TCR repertoire of mature T cells was formed mainly under the influence of endogenous superantigens, while MHC haplotypes played the least role; (2) the 'beta-selection' process during immature stages had little impact on TCRBV repertoire formation; and (3) TCR repertoire in immature T-cell subpopulations was extremely similar between different strains of mice. We thus consider that pre-selection TCR repertoire in immature T cells could be determined by some genetic factors conserved among different strains.