Comparison of the effects of laser, ultrasound, and combined laser + ultrasound treatments in experimental tendon healing

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE: Therapeutic ultrasound (US) and laser (L) treatments accelerate and facilitate wound healing, and also have beneficial effects on tendon healing. This randomized control study was designed to evaluate the effects of low-intensity US and low-level laser therapy (LLLT) on tendon healing in rats. STUDY DESIGN/MATERIALS AND METHODS: Eighty-four healthy male Swiss-Albino rats were divided into three groups consisting of 28 rats, the left Achilles tendons were used as treatment and the right Achilles tendons as controls. The right and left Achilles tendons of rats were traumatized longitudinally. The treatment was started on postinjury day one. We applied the treatment protocols including low-intensity US treatment in Group I (US Group), Sham US in Group II (SUS Group), LLLT in Group III (L Group), Sham L in Group IV (SL Group), US and LLLT in Group V (US + L Group), and Sham US and Sham L in Group VI (SUS + SL Group). The US treatment was applied with a power of 0.5 W/cm2, a frequency of 1 MHz, continuously, 5 minutes daily. A low-level Ga-As laser was applied with a 904 nm wavelength, 6 mW average power, 1 J/ cm2 dosage, 16 Hz frequency, for 1 minute duration, continuously. In the control groups, the similar procedures as in the corresponding treatment groups were applied with no current (Sham method). The treatment duration was planned for 9 days (sessions) in all groups, except the rats used for biochemical evaluation on the 4th day of treatment, which were treated for 4 days. We measured the levels of the tissue hydroxyproline for biochemical evaluation on the 4th, 10th, and 21st days following the beginning of treatment and the tendon breaking strength on the 21st day following the beginning of treatment for biomechanical evaluation. Seven rats in each group were killed on the 4th, 10th, and 21st days for biochemical evaluation and on the 21st day for biomechanical evaluation. RESULTS: The hydroxyproline levels were found to be significantly increased in the treatment groups on the 10th and 21st days compared to their control groups (P < 0.05). In comparison of the treatment groups on the 4th, 10th, and 21st days of the treatment, the levels of tissue hydroxyproline were found to be more increased in combined US+L Group compared with US Group and L Group, but the difference was not significant (P > 0.05). In comparison of the tendon breaking strengths, it was found as significantly increased in the treatment groups compared with their control groups (P < 0.05), although there was no significant difference between the treatment groups. CONCLUSIONS: Although US, L, and combined US + L treatments increased tendon healing biochemically and biomechanically more than the control groups, no statistically significant difference was found between them. Also we did not find significantly more cumulative positive effects of combined treatment. As a result, both of these physical modalities can be used successfully in the treatment of tendon healing.     

The effects of low-level laser irradiation on bone tissue in diabetic rats

Diabetes mellitus (DM) leads to a decrease in bone mass and increase the risk of osteoporosis and in this context, many treatments have shown to accelerate bone metabolism. It seems that low-level laser therapy (LLLT) is able of stimulating osteoblast activity and produced increased biomechanical properties. However, its effects on bone in diabetic rats are not fully elucidated. The aim of this study was to evaluate the effects of LLLT on bone formation, immunoexpression of osteogenic factors, biomechanical properties and densitometric parameters in diabetic rats. Thirty male Wistar rats were randomly distributed into three experimental groups: control group, diabetic group, and laser-treated diabetic group. DM was induced by streptozotocin (STZ) and after 1 week laser treatment started. An 830-nm laser was used, performed for 18 sessions, during 6 weeks. At the end of the experiment, animals were euthanized and tibias and femurs were defleshed for analysis. Extensive resorptive areas as a result of osteoclasts activity were noticed in DG when compared to control. Laser-treated animals showed an increased cortical area. The immunohistochemical analysis revealed that LLLT produced an increased RUNX-2 expression compared to other groups. Similar RANK-L immunoexpression was observed for all experimental groups. In addition, laser irradiation produced a statistically increase in fracture force, bone mineral content (BMC) and bone mineral density compared to DG. The results of this study indicate that the STZ model was efficient in inducing DM 1 and producing a decrease in cortical diameter, biomechanical properties and in densitometric variables. In addition, it seems that LLLT stimulated bone metabolism, decreased resorptive areas, increased RUNX-2 expression, cortical area, fracture force, BMD, and BMC. Further studies should be developed to provide additional information concerning the mechanisms of action of laser therapy in diabetic bone in experimental and clinical trials.     

Soft tissue effects of the holmium-YSGG laser in the canine trachea

A holmium-yttrium scandium gallium garnet laser is a pulsed mid-infrared crystalline laser (wavelength, 2.1 microns), which is easily transmissible through flexible quartz fibers. With use of a 300-microns fiber delivery system, this laser was applied in the canine trachea to create a standard 5-mm diameter lesion through mucosa and submucosa. Power settings of 400 mJ and 600 mJ per pulse at 2 pulses per second were used, and wound healing was studied over a 2-week period. Excellent control of depth of tissue ablation was noted, with uncomplicated wound repair. Although healing was somewhat slower compared with healing when the CO2 laser was used, less granulation and fewer inflammatory changes were noted. Further studies need to be performed to determine ideal laser dosimetry before this laser is applied clinically.     

Pulsed Ho:YAG laser meniscectomy: Effect of pulsewidth on tissue penetration rate and lateral thermal damage

Background and Objective: Studies need to define the optimal parameters under which the holmium laser should operate for arthroscopic meniscectomy. This study was designed to analyze the effect of various Holmium wavelength pulsewidths on human meniscal tissue penetration rates and lateral thermal injury. Study Design/Materials and Methods: Using a pulsed Holmium: YAG laser at a wavelength of 2.1μm, the effect of various pulsewidths on tissue penetration rates as well as the degree of accompanying thermal damage in human meniscal tissue was evaluated in a specially designed jig. Holding the energy constant at 500 mJ per pulse, the pulsewidth was varied between 100 and 600 microseconds. Results: Fiber penetration of meniscal tissue was found to be fastest at a pulsewidth of 250 microseconds. As the pulsewidth was increased or decreased around this number, the observed penetration time decreased, although no statistical difference was found. The size of the hole created was inversely related to the penetration time. Microscopic examination revealed zones of lateral thermal effect extending 800 μm from the ablation site. Conclusion: No relationship between the pulsewidth and the lateral thermal effect could be found. © 1995 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Effects of alternating current electrical stimulation on lengthening callus

Limb lengthening by the callotasis method has been clinically applied to patients who suffered from limb length inequality, micromelia, angular deformation and partial bone defect on long bones. However, this technique was time consuming and led to various complications, such as infection at the pin insertion sites, limitation of the range of motion in adjacent joints, muscular weakness and peripheral neuroparalysis. This study was undertaken to investigate whether alternating current electric (AC) stimulation could shorten the maturation period during callotasis. The tibiae of 20 immature male Japanese white rabbits were osteotomized and fixed with external lengthener (Orthofix M100; Orthofix Srl, Bussolengo, Italy). The experimental schedule lasted 5 weeks consisting of 1 week for the latency period, 2 weeks for distraction and 2 weeks for maturation. Twenty rabbits were equally divided into two groups: the control group and the electrical stimulation (ES) group. The control group was not stimulated with an AC stimulator. The ES group was stimulated for 5 weeks just after osteotomy. The obtained results revealed radiologically, electrophysiologically and histologically that AC stimulation accelerated the maturation of lengthened callus and that it could shorten the time course of callus lengthening.     

The use of the contact Nd:YAG laser in arthroscopic surgery: effects on articular cartilage and meniscal tissue

The contact Nd:YAG laser's small size, tip variety, fiberoptic application, and suitability for use in a saline medium make it a particularly appealing tool for use in arthroscopic procedures. This study was performed to investigate the laser's effects on articular cartilage and meniscal tissue with respect to depth of damage (canine cadaver model) and healing response (rabbit model). Depth of damage in the canine cadaver model was greater in meniscal tissue than in articular cartilage at each wattage level. In the presence of a saline bath, depth damage in both tissues was diminished. Scalpel articular cartilage lesions showed no response over time. Electrocautery lesions uniformly showed significant wide margins of hyaline cartilage necrosis which increased over time. Laser articular cartilage lesions showed vigorous healing responses characterized by fibrocartilage healing by 6 weeks. Scalpel meniscectomies showed characteristic fibrocartilagenous remodeling by 6 weeks, while electrocautery meniscectomies showed wide margins of necrosis with no specimen showing remodeling capability. Laser meniscectomies showed an intermediate response with a small number of menisci remodeling in a normal fashion. This article represents the first comprehensive look at the effects of the Nd:YAG laser on articular cartilage and meniscal tissue in terms of depth of damage and healing response over time, and indicates this laser's biological advantage over scalpel and electrocautery in arthroscopic procedures.     

Soft tissue effects of the THC:YAG laser on canine vocal cords.

Recently, a laser based on a thulium-holmium-chromium (THC) doped Yttrium-aluminum-garnet (YAG) rod has been developed that produces light of 2.15 microns wavelength and can be transmitted through a low OH- silica fiberoptic cable. This wavelength falls on one of the peaks of the energy absorption spectrum of water. Thus, the THC:YAG laser eliminates the disadvantage of a cumbersome delivery system found in the CO2 laser while still providing precise cutting and minimal tissue injury inherent in lasers emitting light absorbed by water. We evaluated the soft tissue effects of this laser on canine vocal cords. Ablative lesions were produced by the THC:YAG laser and histologically examined on postoperative days 1, 7, and 28. Results indicate that the depth of tissue penetration is easily controlled and the healing response to tissue injury is comparable to that of the CO2 laser. The THC:YAG laser should prove to be a superior laser for use in otorhinolaryngology, especially when adapted to a flexible endoscope.     

Intravasular ultrasound can be used to evaluate pulsed laser ablation of arterial tissue

Background and Objective: Intravascular ultrasound (IVUS) has been used successfully to detect intravascular lesions. This study evaluates the ability of IVUS to detect acoustic damage to the arterial wall following high power, pulsed laser ablation. Study Design/Materials and Methods: Arterial ablation and disruption were performed in necropsy bovine aorta with a Ho:YAG laser using energy ranging from 140–720 mJ/pulse at 5 Hz. Laser energy was delivered with 2 mm diameter, multifiber over-the-wire catheters. A 20-MHz IVUS catheter was used to image the arterial damage prior to tissue fixation and morphometry. Results: IVUS images revealed ablation craters surrounded by high acoustically backscattering zones. By histology, the arteries revealed ablation craters lined with thermal coagulation surrounded by a region of dissection and vacuolization. The depth and width of the highly backscattering zones on IVUS images correlated strongly with the corresponding morphometric measurements of tissue dissection (r = 0.92, P = 0.0001 and r = 0.80, P = 0.0001, respectively). Morphometric measurements of the ablation crater depth correlated strongly with laser energy (r = 0.90, P= 0.0001), whereas crater width was not correlated with laser energy (r = 0.27, P = 0.09). Conclusion: This study demonstrates that IVUS can detect and measure the extent of arterial damage following pulsed laser ablation. This may provide a means of detecting the extent of tissue disruption and help develop approaches to reduce or prevent extensive tissue damage. © 1995 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

The effects of laser energy on the arterial wall

Laser energy has been proposed as a method of resecting atherosclerotic plaque since the mid 1960s. However, only over the past several years have we come to understand some of the unique interactions of the laser with cardiovascular tissue. In laser angioplasty a major challenge has been choosing the optimal laser and duration of laser exposure to achieve adequate resection of plaque, while minimizing such complications as thrombosis, perforation, embolization, aneurysm formation, and accelerated atherosclerosis. Ultimately we must develop a more selective laser that resects plaque while leaving adjacent arterial wall uninjured. This review describes the physics of laser energy, the different lasers available for use in the cardiovascular system, laser-arterial wall interactions, and some of the limitations of laser angioplasty.Section Editor - Bruce L. Gewertz, MD, (Chicago, Illinois)     

Comparative study of the effects of low-intensity pulsed ultrasound and low-level laser therapy on bone defects in tibias of rats

The aim of this study was to investigate and to compare the effects of low intensity ultra-sound (LIPUS) and low-level laser therapy (LLLT) during the process of bone healing by means of histopathological and morphometric analysis. The animals were randomly distributed into three groups of 30 animals each: the control group (bone defect without treatment); the laser-treated group: (bone defect treated with laser), and the LIPUS-treated (bone defect treated with ultrasound). Each group was further divided into three different subgroups (n = 10) and on days 7, 13, and 25 post-injury, rats were killed with an intra-peritoneal injection of general anesthetic. The rats were treated with a 30-mW/cm² low-intensity pulsed ultrasound and a 830-nm laser at 50 J/cm². The results showed intense new bone formation surrounded by highly vascularized connective tissue presenting a slight osteogenic activity, with primary bone deposition being observed in the group exposed to laser in the intermediary (13 days) and late stages of repair (25 days). This was confirmed by morphometric analysis in which significant statistical differences (p < 0.05) were noticed when compared to the control. No remarkable differences were noticed in the specimens treated with ultrasound with regard to the amount of newly formed bone in comparison to the control group. Taken together, our results indicate that laser therapy improves bone repair in rats as depicted by histopathological and morphometric analysis, mainly at the late stages of recovery. Moreover, it seems that this therapy was more effective than US to accelerate bone healing.