Identification of a germ-line pro-B cell subset that distinguishes the fetal/neonatal from the adult B cell development pathway

Studies presented here show that the expression of CD4, MHC class II (Ia,) and B220 cleanly resolves a major and a minor subset within the earliest pro-B cell population (germ-line pro-B) in adult bone marrow (BM). The major subset expresses intermediate B220 and low CD4 levels. The minor subset, which constitutes roughly 20% of the adult germ-line pro-B, expresses very low B220 levels and does not express CD4. Ia is clearly detectable at low levels on the major germ-line pro-B subset, both in wild-type adult mice and in gene-targeted mice (RAG2-/- and microMT), in which B cell development terminates before the pre-B cell stage. A small proportion of cells in the more mature pro-B cell subsets (Hardy Fractions B and C) also express Ia at this level. In contrast, Ia levels on the minor subset are barely above (or equal to) background. Surprisingly, the major germ-line pro-B cell subset found in adults is missing in fetal and neonatal animals. All of the germ-line pro-B in these immature animals express a phenotype (very low B220, no CD4, or Ia) similar to that of the minor pro-B cell subset in adult BM. Because B cell development in fetal/neonatal animals principally results in B-1 cells, these findings demonstrate that the B-1 development pathway does not include the major germ-line pro-B subset found in adult BM and hence identify a very early difference between the B-1 and -2 development pathways.     

Distinct progenitors for B-1 and B-2 cells are present in adult mouse spleen

Recent studies by Dorshkind, Yoder, and colleagues show that embryonic (E9) B-cell progenitors located in the yolk sac and intraembryonic hemogenic endothelium before the initiation of circulation give rise to B-1 and marginal zone B cells but do not give rise to B-2 cells. In studies here, we confirm and extend these findings by showing that distinct progenitors for B-1 and B-2 cells are present in the adult spleen. Furthermore, we show that the splenic B-cell progenitor population (lin(-)CD19(+)/B220(lo/-)/CD43(-)) that gives rise to B-1 cells is likely to be heterogeneous because, in some recipients, it also gives rise to B cells expressing the marginal zone phenotype (B220(hi)IgM(hi)IgD(lo)CD21(hi)) and to some (CD19(-)CD5(hi)) T cells. In addition to the well-known function differences between B-1 and B-2, our studies demonstrate that substantial developmental differences separate these B-cell lineages. Thus, consistent with the known dependence of B-2 development on IL-7, all B-2 progenitors express IL-7R. However, >30% of the B-1 progenitors do not express this marker, enabling the known IL-7 independent development of B-1 cells in IL-7(-/-) mice. In addition, marker expression on cells in the early stages of the B-2 development pathway (CD19(-)/c-Kit(lo/-)/Sca-1(lo/-)) in adult bone marrow distinguish it from the early stages of B-1 development (CD19(hi)/c-Kit(+)/Sca-1(+)), which occur constitutively in neonates. In adults, in vivo inflammatory stimulation (LPS) triggers B-1 progenitors in spleen to expand and initiate development along this B-1 developmental pathway.     

CD4+ T cells derived from B cell-deficient mice inhibit the establishment of peripheral B cell pools

We demonstrate that adoptive transfer of peritoneal cavity B cells fails to replenish the peripheral B-1 cells in adult B cell-deficient (mu(-/-)) mice but does replenish adult RAG-1(-/-) mice. We show that this lack of self-replenishment in mu(-/-) mice is mediated by strongly inhibitory, radiation-sensitive CD4(+) T cells that also function in cotransfer studies to block the reconstitution of B-1 cells and inhibit accumulation of bone marrow-derived B-2 cells in the periphery in irradiated recipients. CD8(+) T cells from mu(-/-) do not mediate this inhibition. The inhibitory CD4(+) T cells develop early in life, because B-1 cell replenishment occurs normally when B-1 cells are transferred into mu(-/-) neonates. Thus, we conclude that the presence of B cells in the neonate conditions the CD4(+) T-cell population to permit the establishment and maintenance of normal B cell pools throughout life.     

Pre-B cell loss in senescence coincides with preferential development of immature B cells characterized by partial activation and altered Vh repertoire

Senescent mice show decline in B lymphopoiesis marked by reduced pre-B cells. Analysis of bone marrow from aged (approximately 2 years old) BALB/c mice indicates that, in senescence, an increased proportion of immature B cells exhibit a CD43/S7+ surface phenotype. This results from continued production of new CD43/S7+ B cells in aged mice from their limited pre-B cell pool while production of CD43/S7- immature B cells is highly reduced. CD43/S7 is ordinarily observed on a minor subset of immature B cells in young mice and is indicative of their partial activation. Senescent immature B cells, both ex vivo and derived in vitro, also demonstrate increased expression of VhS107 concomitant with CD43/S7. These alterations in the phenotype and Vh repertoire among senescent immature B cells likely originate prior to surface Ig expression. In aged mice with depleted pre-B and immature B cells in vivo, pre-B and immature B cells exhibited increased apoptosis in vitro. Dexamethasone-induced apoptosis among B lineage cells in young adult mice also resulted in pre-B cell loss and increased expression of CD43/S7 and VhS107 among immature B cells similar to that observed spontaneously in aged mice. These results suggest that old age, possibly due to increased apoptosis, results in loss of pre-B cells and alterations in the phenotype and Vh repertoire of newly derived B cells.     

Characterization of lymphocyte subsets in rhesus macaques during the first year of life

Establishing reliable phenotypic data sets from the analysis of peripheral blood lymphocytes of normal animals is required to assess disease states. The rhesus macaque animal model is well established with respect to adult animals, but limited data are available that characterizes lymphocyte subsets in normal neonates. To address this, we used four-color flow cytometric analysis to follow phenotypic changes in 29 normal rhesus animals through their first ten months of life. From birth to 44 wk of age, the white cell count and absolute lymphocyte count were both elevated compared to adults. CD4+ cells constituted over 80% of all T cells at birth, a percentage that declined gradually over the first 12 wk of life, coincidental with increases in the percentages of CD8+ T cells, CD3-8+ natural killer cells and CD20+ B cells. This difference in relative frequency of CD4 and CD8 results in a significant skewing of CD4:CD8 ratio from 0.7:1 in adults to 3.5:1 in neonates. In addition, the predominant population of T lymphocytes consisted of CD45RA+CD62L+ naive cells. This subset continues to be the predominant phenotype for at least the first year of age. After birth the expression of activation markers (CD25) increased particularly on CD4+ T cells, although these levels generally reached a frequency similar to that observed in adults between 12 and 20 weeks after birth. These results are similar to those seen in humans and further confirm the reliability of the rhesus macaque animal model to study human diseases.     

Different expression of CD41 on human lymphoid and myeloid progenitors from adults and neonates

The glycoprotein (Gp) IIb/IIIa integrin, also called CD41, is the platelet receptor for fibrinogen and several other extracellular matrix molecules. Recent evidence suggests that its expression is much wider in the hematopoietic system than was previously thought. To investigate the precise expression of the CD41 antigen during megakaryocyte (MK) differentiation, CD34(+) cells from cord blood and mobilized blood cells from adults were grown for 6 days in the presence of stem cell factor and thrombopoietin. Two different pathways of differentiation were observed: one in the adult and one in the neonate cells. In the neonate samples, early MK differentiation proceeded from CD34(+)CD41(-) through a CD34(-)CD41(+)CD42(-) stage of differentiation to more mature cells. In contrast, in the adult samples, CD41 and CD42 were co-expressed on a CD34(+) cell. The rare CD34(+)CD41(+)CD42(-) cell subset in neonates was not committed to MK differentiation but contained cells with all myeloid and lymphoid potentialities along with long-term culture initiating cells (LTC-ICs) and nonobese diabetic/severe combined immune-deficient repopulating cells. In the adult samples, the CD34(+)CD41(+)CD42(-) subset was enriched in MK progenitors, but also contained erythroid progenitors, rare myeloid progenitors, and some LTC-ICs. All together, these results demonstrate that the CD41 antigen is expressed at a low level on primitive hematopoietic cells with a myeloid and lymphoid potential and that its expression is ontogenically regulated, leading to marked differences in the surface antigenic properties of differentiating megakaryocytic cells from neonates and adults. (Blood. 2001;97:2023-2030)     

Reduced production of B-1-specified common lymphoid progenitors results in diminished potential of adult marrow to generate B-1 cells

B-1 B cells have been proposed to be preferentially generated from fetal progenitors, but this view is challenged by studies concluding that B-1 production is sustained throughout adult life. To address this controversy, we compared the efficiency with which hematopoietic stem cells (HSCs) and common lymphoid progenitors (CLPs) from neonates and adults generated B-1 cells in vivo and developed a clonal in vitro assay to quantify B-1 progenitor production from CLPs. Adult HSCs and CLPs generated fewer B-1 cells in vivo compared with their neonatal counterparts, a finding corroborated by the clonal studies that showed that the CLP compartment includes B-1- and B-2-specified subpopulations and that the former cells decrease in number after birth. Together, these data indicate that B-1 lymphopoiesis is not sustained at constant levels throughout life and define a heretofore unappreciated developmental heterogeneity within the CLP compartment.     

Phenotypic and functional analysis of T-cell precursors in the human fetal liver and thymus: CD7 expression in the early stages of T- and myeloid-cell development

It has been proposed that the CD7 molecule is the first antigen expressed on the membrane of cells committed to the T-cell lineage during human fetal T-cell ontogeny. To further identify the pre-T cell subpopulation that migrates to the thymus early in ontogeny, we analyzed the phenotypic and functional characteristics of the fetal liver populations separated on the basis of CD7 expression. Three populations expressing different levels of CD7 were observed: CD7bright, CD7dull, and CD7-. A CD7bright population depleted of mature T, B, and myeloid cells (lineage negative, lin-) and mostly composed of CD56+ CD34- natural killer cells did not mature into T cells in a fetal thymic organ culture (FTOC) assay and was devoid of myeloid progenitors in a clonal colony-forming cell assay. In contrast, the CD7-/dull CD34+ lin- populations were capable of differentiating into phenotypically mature T cells after injection into FTOC and contained early myeloid progenitors. Here we phenotypically compared the fetal liver CD7 populations with the most immature fetal thymic subset that differentiated in the FTOC assay, namely the triple negative (TN, CD3- CD4-CD8-) thymocytes. Fetal TN lin- expressed high levels of CD34 marker and were further subdivided by their expression of CD1 antigen, because CD1- TN thymocytes express higher levels of CD34 antigen compared with CD1+ TN cells. CD1- lin -TN thymocytes are characterized by expressing high levels of CD2, CD7, and CD34 markers and dull levels of CD5, CD10, and CD28 molecules. We could not find fetal liver pre-T cells with a phenotype equivalent to that of TN thymocytes. Our data show that CD7 does not necessarily identify T-cell precursors during fetal T-cell development and strongly support the hypothesis that the acquisition of early T-cell markers as CD2, CD28, and CD5 molecules on the cell surface of T-cell progenitors takes place intrathymically.     

Characterization and functional analysis of adult human bone marrow cell subsets in relation to B-lymphoid development

To study the frontiers between pluripotent stem cells and committed progenitors and to further define the B-cell pathway in adult bone marrow (BM), CD34+ subpopulations and CD34- B-lineage cells were analyzed by multiparameter flow cytometry, studied by light and electron microscopy, and in short-term and long-term cultures (LTC). While the total CD34+ cells represent 4.9% +/- 0.8 of BM mononuclear cells within the lymphoid-blast window, 73.8 +/- 3.5%, 14.4 +/- 1.8% and 8.8 +/- 2.9% of them were CD34+ CD10- CD19-, CD34+ CD10+ CD19+, and CD34+ CD10+ CD19-, respectively. CD34+ CD10+ CD19+ cells represent a smal homogeneous TdT4 c micro-blast population. Although expressing CD38 and high level of HLA-DR antigens, like myeloid committed progenitors, they did not generate LTC, myeloid, and T lymphoid colonies suggesting that the CD34+ CD10+ CD19+ population represents exclusively B lymphoid committed progenitors. By contrast, all myeloid progenitors and LTC-initiating cells were found in the CD34+ CD10- CD19- cell fraction. This fraction appeared more heterogeneous and contained CD38- HLA-DRlow small cells, larger blasts, and promonocyte-like cells exhibiting small peroxidase-positive granules. Interestingly, CD10 was also present on CD34+ CD19- cells. This population mainly coexpressed CD33 and gave rise to macrophagic colonies.     

Changes in frequencies of clonable pre B cells during life in different lymphoid organs of mice

Progenitor and precursor B lymphocytes with the capacity of long-term proliferation on stromal cells in the presence of interleukin-7 (IL-7) can be cloned ex vivo from fetal liver, neonatal blood, and spleen, and from adult bone marrow (BM) in frequencies that are similar in different strains of mice and that change with age. A wave of clonable cells appears before birth and disappears after birth in liver. Up to 2 weeks after birth, high frequencies of clonable cells are present in spleen but become undetectable at 6 to 8 weeks of age. In BM, high frequencies (1 in 50) of clonable cells are present early after birth, and then decrease continuously to 10- to 20-fold lower levels at 6 to 8 months of age. The earliest clonable cells have at least part of their IgH genes in germline configuration. Clones of pro/pre B cells apparently continue to rearrange DH to JH segments on both chromosomes. Rearrangements without insertion of N-sequences at the DHJH joints are found in fetal liver, while DHJH joints in pre B cells of spleen and BM throughout life have N-regions inserted. At least half of all primary pre B-cell clones develop mitogen-reactive B cells after differentiation to sIg+ B cells. Clonable pro and pre B cells are enriched in B220- c-kit(low) as well as in B220+ c-kit+ and B220+ CD43+ cell populations of BM. The frequencies of clonable cells in the B220- c-kit(low) BM cell population decrease 10- to 20-fold during 8 months of life, while those in the B220+ c-kit+ population remain constant, although their absolute numbers drop 5- to 10-fold during that time. All long-term proliferating clones express the surrogate L chain VpreB/lambda 5 as well as c-kit and CD43 on all cells. The number of total clonable pro and pre B cells is at best 10% of the number of cells required to produce the estimated daily output of 5 x 10(7) B- lineage cells in a mouse. This suggests that the production of a relatively constant number of B cells during adulthood may be effected by precursors, which are not clonable on stromal cells and IL-7 with long-term proliferative capacity. On the other hand, BM transplantation experiments indicate that a mouse retains B220- progenitors throughout life, from which pre B and B cells can be generated in old mice in frequencies characteristic of young mice.     

B220- bone marrow progenitor cells from New Zealand black autoimmune mice exhibit an age-associated decline in Pre-B and B-cell generation

New Zealand Black (NZB) autoimmune mice exhibit progressive, age- dependent reduction in bone marrow pre-B cells. To ascertain the capacity of NZB bone marrow B220- cells to generate pre-B cells in a supportive environment, B-lineage (B220+) cell-depleted and T-cell- depleted bone marrow cells from NZB mice at 1 to 3, 6, and 10 to 11 months of age were adoptively transferred into irradiated (200R) C.B17 severe combined immunodeficient (SCID) mice. Bone marrow pre-B cells (sIgM- CD43[S7]- B220+) were assessed 3 and 10 weeks posttransfer. Pre- B cells and B cells were reconstituted in SCID recipients of older NZB progenitor cells by 10 weeks posttransplant, in contrast to the very low numbers of pre-B cells present in the donor bone marrow. However, B220- bone marrow progenitor cells from greater than 10-month-old NZB donors were deficient in the reconstitution of both pre-B and B cells in SCID recipients at 3 weeks post-transfer. This reflected a slower kinetics of repopulation, because older NZB-->SCID recipients had numbers of both pre-B and B cells similar to recipients of young NZB progenitor cells by 10 weeks posttransplant. Adoptive transfer of equal mixtures of BALB/c and older NZB bone marrow B220- progenitor cells into irradiated C.B17 SCID recipients failed to demonstrate active suppression. These results suggest that, with age, NZB bone marrow has reduced numbers and/or function of early B220- B-lineage progenitors. Consistent with this hypothesis, B220- bone marrow cells from older NZB mice were deficient in progenitors capable of yielding interleukin-7 (IL-7) responsive pre-B cells in vitro on stimulation with the pre-B- cell potentiating factor, insulin-like growth factor 1 (IGF-1).     

A developmental switch in B lymphopoiesis.

B and T lymphocytes are generated from hematopoietic stem cells during both fetal and adult life. A critical unresolved issue is whether the differentiation pathways in lymphopoiesis are the same in fetal and adult animals or whether they differ, similar to the hemoglobin switch in erythropoiesis. We report here that a developmental switch occurs in B lymphopoiesis. We isolated "pro-B" cells (i.e., cells that have initiated, but not completed, heavy-chain gene rearrangement) from fetal and adult sources and investigated their B-cell progeny generated both in vitro and in vivo. Most of the cells from fetal liver, but few from adult bone marrow, expressed CD5. Further, fetal pro-B cells failed to generate cells expressing high levels of IgD in severe combined immunodeficiency mice, whereas adult pro-B cells gave rise to CD5-B cells bearing IgD at levels comparable to the bulk of cells in the spleen of adult mice. Thus, all committed B progenitors in fetal liver of day 16 gestation mice give rise to phenotypically distinct progeny when compared to cells at a comparable differentiation stage in the bone marrow of adult animals. We conclude that the cohort of B-lineage progenitors in early fetal development is committed to a differentiation pathway distinct from that seen in the adult.     

A novel surface marker (B203.13) of human haemopoietic progenitors, preferentially expressed along the B and myeloid lineages

We used a monoclonal antibody (mAb) (B203.13, IgM) generated from a mouse immunized with the human B/myeloid bi-phenotypic B1b cell line, to analyse haemopoietic cells. The antigen recognized by this mAb is expressed on most adult and umbilical cord blood CD21⁺ B cells, at minimal density on mature monocytes, and is undetectable on granulocytes, T, natural killer (NK) cells, and erythrocytes. Within umbilical cord blood and adult bone marrow haemopoietic progenitor cells, the B203.13 mAb recognized a surface marker, present on progenitor cells of several haemopoietic lineages, that was transiently expressed on early erythroid and T/NK progenitors, and was preferentially maintained on cells of the B and myeloid lineages. Within the CD34⁺ cells, B203.13 was expressed on early committed myeloid (CD33⁺) and erythroid (CD71^dim) progenitor cells, as confirmed in colony formation assays. The mAb also reacted with cells of B and myeloid chronic leukaemias and cell lines. These data define B203.13 mAb as a novel reagent useful for the characterization of haemopoietic progenitors and leukaemias.     

Expression of murine CD34 by fetal liver NK cell progenitors

Although 14.5-day murine fetal liver (FL) has few, if any, mature natural killer (NK) cells, culture of FL with recombinant human IL-2 (rhIL-2) and stroma from irradiated NK longterm bone marrow cultures (NK-LTBMC) allows proliferation and differentiation of NK cell progenitors. Using this system, NK cell progenitors were found in both CD34+ and CD34- sorted subpopulations of FL. The CD34 antigen was expressed by 14+/-1.3% of whole FL cells, while mature NK cells cultured from NK cell precursors in FL did not express the CD34 antigen. Anti-TER-119 mAb reacted with 84%+/-10.3% of the FL cells, and NK cell progenitors were enriched in the TER-119- subpopulation. After coculture with rhIL-2 and stroma, neither TER-119- nor TER-119+ cells expressed antigens associated with T cells (CD3, CD4, and CD8) or myeloid cells (Gr-1 and Mac-1). Only the TER-119 subpopulation generated NK1.1+ (77%) and B220+ (87%) cells. Within the TER-119 subpopulation, both CD34+ and CD34- cells generated cytolytic and NK1.1+ cells after culture. By a limiting dilution assay (LDA) of the Lin (i.e., negative for NK1.1, CD3, CD4, CD8, B220, Gr-1, and TER-119) CD34 positive or negative subpopulations, the calculated mean frequency of NK cell progenitors was about 1/100 for the CD34+Lin- subpopulation and about 1/(200-300) for the CD34-Lin- subpopulation. In kinetic studies, we found that NK1.1 antigen expression continued to increase with time in culture for both the CD34+Lin- and CD34-Lin- fractions. In contrast, the percentage of CD34+ cells decreased rapidly and produced CD34- cells, and the CD34- population remained CD34-. These data suggest that both CD34+ and CD34- subpopulations of FL can differentiate into NK cells when cocultured for 13 days with irradiated NK-LTBMC stroma and rhIL-2, and that CD34+ progenitors differentiate to CD34- precursors, which in turn differentiate to CD34- mature NK cells.     

A cell-autonomous requirement for CXCR4 in long-term lymphoid and myeloid reconstitution

Mice lacking the chemokine stromal cell-derived factor/pre-B cell growth stimulating factor or its primary physiological receptor CXCR4 revealed defects in B lymphopoiesis and bone marrow myelopoiesis during embryogenesis. We show here that adoptive transfer experiments reveal a deficiency in long-term lymphoid and myeloid repopulation in adult bone marrow by CXCR4-/- fetal liver cells, although stromal cell-derived factor/pre-B cell growth stimulating factor-/- fetal liver cells yield normal multilineage reconstitution. These findings indicate that CXCR4 is required cell autonomously for lymphoid and myeloid repopulation in bone marrow. In addition, CXCR4-/- fetal liver cells generated much more severely reduced numbers of B cells relative to other lineages in bone marrow. Furthermore, the repopulation of c-kit+ Sca-1(+) linlow/- cells by CXCR4-/- fetal liver cells was less affected compared with c-kit+ Sca-1(-) linlow/- cells. By previous studies, it has been shown that c-kit+ Sca-1(+) linlow/- cells are highly purified primitive hematopoietic progenitors and that c-kit+ Sca-1(-) linlow/- cells are more committed hematopoietic progenitors in mice. Thus, CXCR4 may play an essential role in generation and/or expansion of early hematopoietic progenitors within bone marrow.