Clinical impact of the M184V mutation on switching to didanosine or maintaining lamivudine treatment in nucleoside reverse-transcriptase inhibitor-experienced patients

Virologic outcome among 104 lamivudine (3TC)-experienced individuals infected with human immunodeficiency virus type 1 who switched to a didanosine (ddI)-containing triple- or quadruple-drug regimen was compared with those who continued receiving a 3TC-containing regimen. A significantly increased independent risk of virologic failure was associated with continuing a 3TC-containing regimen. In addition, most patients for whom the ddI-containing regimen failed lost the M184V/I mutation. These results show that ddI continues to provide activity against viruses with the M184V/I mutation and suggest that the presence of the M184V/I mutation should not preclude the use of ddI in nucleoside-experienced patients.     

Absence of zidovudine resistance in antiretroviral-naive patients following zidovudine/lamivudine/protease inhibitor combination therapy: virological evaluation of the AVANTI 2 and AVANTI 3 studies

OBJECTIVES: To assess the role of resistance mutations in subjects experiencing virological failure on zidovudine (ZDV) and lamivudine (3TC) combined with a protease inhibitor (PI) to those failing on ZDV/3TC alone. DESIGN AND METHODS: Samples were obtained from previously antiretroviral therapy-naive subjects enrolled into two studies, AVANTI 2 and AVANTI 3. Subjects were randomized to receive either: ZDV/3TC or ZDV/3TC plus indinavir (IDV) for 52 weeks (AVANTI 2), and ZDV/3TC or ZDV/3TC and nelfinavir (NFV) for 28 weeks (AVANTI 3). Emergence of viral resistance mutations was monitored by population sequencing and phenotypic resistance was determined by the recombinant virus assay. RESULTS: Genotypic data were obtained for subjects with plasma HIV-1 RNA > 400 copies/ml. In AVANTI 2, ZDV mutations were detected in 27% of ZDV/3TC-treated patients at week 52, but were absent in subjects treated with ZDV/3TC/IDV. No subjects from either arm of AVANTI 3 developed ZDV resistance mutations at week 28. The M184V mutation developed in most ZDV/3TC-treated subjects from both studies. The presence of M184V was, however, associated with significantly lower plasma viral RNA levels when compared with values obtained before initiation of treatment. There was a high frequency (4 of 11) of the protease L10F substitution in ZDV/3TC/IDV-treated patients that was associated with virological failure but did not result in phenotypic resistance to any of the PIs tested. CONCLUSIONS: ZDV mutations were not detected in ZDV/3TC/PI-treated patients and they developed slowly in those treated with ZDV/3TC. Few protease mutations known to confer phenotypic PI resistance developed in the ZDV/3TC/PI arms of either study. The low prevalence of ZDV and PI mutations is encouraging regarding the future treatment options of these patients.     

Selection of drug-resistant HIV-1 mutants in response to repeated structured treatment interruptions

BACKGROUND: A new HIV-1 treatment strategy based on repeated structured treatment interruptions (STI) is currently being evaluated in clinical trials to determine whether immune cell-mediated control of viral replication can be stimulated by intermittent periods of viral replication. The potential for selection of drug-resistant quasi-species remains a major concern of such a treatment strategy. METHODS: Plasma and peripheral blood lymphocyte (PBL) samples from 12 patients who had three consecutive STIs were studied. Genotypic analysis was based on population and clonal sequencing. Drug susceptibility and their corresponding replication capacities were evaluated by a single-cycle growth assay. RESULTS: Consistent with a loss of phenotypic susceptibility to lamivudine, the M184V mutation was detected by genotypic analysis (direct and clonal sequencing) in plasma samples collected from two patients at the end of the second or third STI. Longitudinal analysis of patient samples revealed a step-wise increase in the M184V mutation in each patient virus population over successive STIs, despite the lower replicative capacity associated with this mutation in the absence of antiviral agents. CONCLUSION: Drug-resistant virus can rise to high frequencies in chronically HIV-1 infected individuals during consecutive STIs. Evolution of resistance is likely to be more important in patients with prior suboptimal therapies, particularly when few mutations are required for resistance. Maximum care should be taken in designing STI protocols that minimize development of drug-resistant mutations that may lead to treatment failure. Thus, drug-resistance testing may be useful before restarting treatment during STI studies.     

Dynamics of proviral HIV-1 184M/V in circulating CD4+ T-cells: a 90 days follow-up study after initiation/switch of HAART

HIV-1 viral load falls rapidly on initiation of HAART. This phase of decreasing yet substantial viral production in the presence of antiretroviral drugs could generate resistant HIV-1. Whether switching a drug from a failing regime changes the demography of the mutations associated with it in the CD4+ T-cell compartment is not well-defined. We investigated the presence/absence and quantity of 184M and 184V in the CD4+ T-cell compartment of na?ve patients initiated to HAART (group I), and patients who shifted to a non-lamivudine therapy (group II). We initiated a prospective 90 d follow-up study of 11 patients to detect and quantity proviral HIV-1 184M and 184V in the CD4+ T-cell compartment with a sensitive real time PCR assay. Results showed that the 184V was not detected in the CD4+ T-cell compartment of any of the 7 na?ve patients who started on HAART. Three out of the 4 patients in group II experienced a fall in the percentage of 184V, with reduction to below detection limits in 2 patients. It can be concluded that initiation of HAART does not allow the archiving of the lamivudine associated mutation, 184V, in the CD4+ T-cell compartment. Reduction in the quantity of 184V when therapy is switched to an effective non-lamivudine regime indicates that the mutation in this compartment is dynamic.     

An efficient tool for surveying CRF01_AE HIV type 1 resistance in Thailand to combined stavudine-lamivudine-nevirapine treatment: mutagenically separated PCR targeting M184I/V

Under programs organized by the government of Thailand, HIV-1-infected patients have been treated since 2002 with several regimens, including a tablet known as GPOvir, which contains lamivudine, stavudine, and nevirapine. The aim of this study was to establish an effective assay, based on mutagenically separated PCR (MS-PCR), with the goal of surveying GPOvir-resistant HIV-1 cases. To determine the target mutation point for the assay, we analyzed the patterns of acquired drug resistance in plasma samples from GPOvir-failed cases. Of 428 HIV-1-infected individuals treated with GPOvir at Lampang Hospital in northern Thailand from 2002 to 2004, 66 had detectable viral loads after 3 months of treatment. The HIV-1 sequences of these 66 GPOvir-failed cases and 55 pre-GPOvir baseline samples were analyzed. The most prevalent drug resistance mutation among the samples was the lamivudine resistance M184I/V mutation. Based on this finding, we developed a new MS-PCR assay to detect the M184I/V mutation, and evaluated the assay performance for detecting GPOvir-resistant CRF01_AE cases. Comparing the results of M184I/V MS-PCR and sequence analyses, we found a concordance rate of 95% and an overall sensitivity of the M184I/V MS-PCR for detecting GPOvir-resistant cases of 79%. Considering the relatively low price of the assay, approximately $12.50 per sample, M184I/V MS-PCR may be a candidate for monitoring a large number of GPOvir-treated patients, particularly in developing nations.     

Antiretroviral drug resistance in HIV-1-infected patients experiencing persistent low-level viremia during first-line therapy

Population sequencing was performed for persons identified with persistent low-level viremia in 2 clinical trials. Persistent low-level viremia (defined as plasma HIV-1 RNA level >50 and <1000 copies/mL in at least 2 determinations over a 24-week period, after at least 24 weeks of antiretroviral therapy) was observed in 65 (5.6%) of 1158 patients at risk. New resistance mutations were detected during persistent low-level viremia in 37% of the 54 evaluable cases. The most common mutations were M184I/V (14 cases), K103N (9), and M230L (3). Detection of new mutations was associated with higher HIV-1 RNA levels during persistent low-level viremia.