Knee stability in meniscal bearing total knee arthroplasty

The effect of a meniscal bearing on knee laxity in anterior cruciate ligament-sacrificing total knee arthroplasty was evaluated in 7 cadaver knees using a knee testing device that measured knee flexion angle as well as laxity to medial-lateral, anterior-posterior [AP], and rotational loads. A standard fixed tibial component and mobile tibial components (AP sliding, rotationally sliding, and AP and rotationally sliding) were used to evaluate AP, rotational, and varus-valgus stability and maximal flexion and extension with the neutrally positioned and malrotated tibial tray. The AP movable components increased AP laxity, and the fixed component decreased rotational laxity significantly when compared with the normal knees. The rotationally movable components did not change knee laxities significantly even when the tibial tray was malrotated. No significant difference among the components was detected when the maximal flexion and extension angles were compared in the neutrally positioned tibial tray. Malrotation of the tibial tray decreased the maximal extension angle in the fixed component. This study showed that the rotationally movable component can achieve near-normal laxity regardless of tibial tray rotation, but AP mobility of the bearing produces AP laxity that could lead to implant failure.     

A radiographic analysis of anterior-posterior translation in total knee arthroplasty

We performed radiological analyses to examine the relationship between the knee flexion angle and the anteroposterior translation movement relative to the prosthetic components (NexGen type) after total knee arthroplasty (TKA). Cruciate-retaining (CR) type TKA was performed in 12 knees with osteoarthritis (OA) and 9 knees with rheumatoid arthritis (RA) in which no posterior cruciate ligament (PCL) tear was present. Posterior-stabilized (PS) type TKA was performed in 7 OA knees and 7 RA knees in which the PCL was defective or resected. The measurements were performed according to the methods of Watanabe. The contact point ratio (percentage) was calculated by dividing the distance to the contact point (CP; the closest point of contact between the femoral and tibial components) by the antero-posterior length of the tibial component. After TKA, the CP at full extension was positioned more posteriorly than in the normal knee both under weight-bearing and non-weight-bearing conditions. Except for the RA knees in the PS group, the CP translated anteriorly in the early phase of flexion and then posteriorly. Under weight-bearing conditions, the posterior translation occurred earlier and was smaller in magnitude. For RA knees in the PS group, the CP moved gently posteriorly right from the beginning. Received: May 16, 2000 / Accepted: April 10, 2001     

Functional medical ligament balancing in total knee arthroplasty

Function of the anterior and posterior oblique portions of the medial collateral ligament and the posterior capsule in flexion and extension was evaluated in eight knee specimens after posterior cruciate retaining total knee arthroplasty. The posterior oblique portion of the medial collateral ligament was released subperiosteally in four specimens, and the anterior portion was released in four specimens. The medial posterior capsule was released in each group, then the remaining portion of the medial collateral ligament was released. Release of the posterior oblique portion produced moderate laxity at full extension and at 30 degrees flexion, and posterior capsule release produced additional laxity in full extension. Release of the anterior portion produced major laxity at 60 degrees and 90 degrees flexion. Complete medial collateral ligament release increased laxity significantly in both groups in flexion and extension. This rationale was tested in a clinical study of 82 knees (76 patients) in which 62 (76%) required medial collateral ligament release to correct varus deformity during posterior cruciate retaining total knee arthroplasty. Twenty-two knees (35.5%) were tight medially in extension only, and were corrected by releasing the posterior oblique portion. Thirty-one knees (50%) were tight medially in flexion only, and were corrected by releasing the anterior portion. Nine knees (14.5%) were tight medially in flexion and extension and required complete medial collateral ligament release, but three knees (4.8%) remained tight in extension and required medial posterior capsule release to correct flexion contracture and medial ligament contracture. Seventeen (27%) had partial posterior cruciate ligament release to correct excessive rollback of the femoral component on the tibial surface.     

In vivo determination of total knee arthroplasty kinematics: a multicenter analysis of an asymmetrical posterior cruciate retaining total knee arthroplasty

The objective of this study was to determine if consistent posterior femoral rollback of an asymmetrical posterior cruciate retaining (PCR) total knee arthroplasty was mostly influenced by the implant design, surgical technique, or presence of a well-functioning posterior cruciate ligament (PCL). Three-dimensional femorotibial kinematics was determined for 80 subjects implanted by 3 surgeons, and each subject was evaluated under fluoroscopic surveillance during a deep knee bend. All subjects in this present study having an intact PCL had a well-functioning PCR knee and experienced normal kinematic patterns, although less in magnitude than the normal knee. In addition, a surprising finding was that, on average, subjects without a PCL still achieved posterior femoral rollback from full extension to maximum knee flexion. The findings in this study revealed that implant design did contribute to the normal kinematics demonstrated by subjects having this asymmetrical PCR total knee arthroplasty.     

Observations of femoral rollback in cruciate-retaining knee arthroplasty

The current study evaluated kinematics of the knee during a stair-climbing activity after total knee arthroplasty. All patients received a posterior cruciate ligament retaining prosthesis of the same design, having an anatomically shaped femoral component and an unconstrained tibial insert. All patients had the same surgical technique done by two experienced surgeons. Patients had some posterior femoral rollback and screw-home type axial rotations during weightbearing activities. However, patients treated by different surgeons had different patterns of tibiofemoral motions. In Group 1, rollback occurred early in the flexion range and was maintained until 80 degrees flexion. In Group 2, the lateral condyle had rollback in early flexion, but both condyles translated forward as flexion increased to 80 degrees. An anatomic femoral component seems to be necessary to produce consistent early femoral rollback. However, soft tissue balance can have a significant effect on the kinematics of sagittally unconstrained posterior cruciate retaining total knee arthroplasty, because it may vary among surgeons.     

Differences in the stress distribution in the distal femur between patellofemoral joint replacement and total knee replacement: a finite element study

ABSTRACT: BACKGROUND: Patellofemoral joint replacement is a successful treatment option for isolated patellofemoral osteoarthritis. However, results of later conversion to total knee replacement may be compromised by periprosthetic bone loss. Previous clinical studies have demonstrated a decrease in distal femoral bone mineral density after patellofemoral joint replacement. It is unclear whether this is due to periprosthetic stress shielding. The main objective of the current study was to evaluate the stress shielding effect of prosthetic replacement with 2 different patellofemoral prosthetic designs and with a total knee prosthesis. METHODS: We developed a finite element model of an intact patellofemoral joint, and finite element models of patellofemoral joint replacement with a Journey PFJ prosthesis, a Richards II prosthesis, and a Genesis II total knee prosthesis. For each of these 4 finite element models, the average Von Mises stress in 2 clinically relevant regions of interest were evaluated during a simulated squatting movement until 120 degrees of flexion. RESULTS: During deep knee flexion, in the anterior region of interest, the average Von Mises stress with the Journey PFJ design was comparable to the physiological knee, while reduced by almost 25% for both the Richards II design and the Genesis II total knee joint replacement design. The average Von Mises stress in the supracondylar region of interest was similar for both patellofemoral prosthetic designs and the physiological model, with slightly lower stress for the Genesis II design. CONCLUSIONS: Patellofemoral joint replacement results in periprosthetic stress-shielding, although to a smaller degree than in total knee replacement. Specific patellofemoral prosthetic design properties may result in differences in femoral stress shielding.     

The variation in medial and lateral collateral ligament strain and tibiofemoral forces following changes in the flexion and extension gaps in total knee replacement. A laboratory experiment using cadaver knees

Achieving deep flexion after total knee replacement remains a challenge. In this study we compared the soft-tissue tension and tibiofemoral force in a mobile-bearing posterior cruciate ligament-sacrificing total knee replacement, using equal flexion and extension gaps, and with the gaps increased by 2 mm each. The tests were conducted during passive movement in five cadaver knees, and measurements of strain were made simultaneously in the collateral ligaments. The tibiofemoral force was measured using a customised mini-force plate in the tibial tray. Measurements of collateral ligament strain were not very sensitive to changes in the gap ratio, but tibiofemoral force measurements were. Tibiofemoral force was decreased by a mean of 40% (SD 10.7) after 90 degrees of knee flexion when the flexion gap was increased by 2 mm. Increasing the extension gap by 2 mm affected the force only in full extension. Because increasing the range of flexion after total knee replacement beyond 110 degrees is a widely-held goal, small increases in the flexion gap warrant further investigation.     

Changes in Knee Kinematics Reflect the Articular Geometry after Arthroplasty

We hypothesized changes in rotations and translations after TKA with a fixed-bearing anterior cruciate ligament (ACL)-sacrificing but posterior cruciate ligament (PCL)-retaining design with equal-sized, circular femoral condyles would reflect the changes of articular geometry. Using 8 cadaveric knees, we compared the kinematics of normal knees and TKA in a standardized navigated position with defined loads. The quadriceps was tensed and moments and drawer forces applied during knee flexion-extension while recording the kinematics with the navigation system. TKA caused loss of the screw-home; the flexed tibia remained at the externally rotated position of normal full knee extension with considerably increased external rotation from 63° to 11° extension. The range of internal-external rotation was shifted externally from 30° to 20° extension. There was a small tibial posterior translation from 40° to 90° flexion. The varus-valgus alignment and laxity did not change after TKA. Thus, navigated TKA provided good coronal plane alignment but still lost some aspects of physiologic motion. The loss of tibial screw-home was related to the symmetric femoral condyles, but the posterior translation in flexion was opposite the expected change after TKA with the PCL intact and the ACL excised. Thus, the data confirmed our hypothesis for rotations but not for translations. It is not known whether the standard navigated position provides the best match to physiologic kinematics. One or more of the authors (AAA, AMJB) have received funding by Stryker (Europe). Each author certifies that his or her institution has approved the human protocol for this investigation, that all investigations were conducted in conformity with ethical principles of research, and that tissue specimens were obtained in accordance with the laws of France.     

Posterior cruciate ligament balancing in total knee replacement: the quantitative relationship between tightness of the flexion gap and tibial translation

We have examined the relationship between the size of the flexion gap and the anterior translation of the tibia in flexion during implantation of a posterior cruciate ligament (PCL)-retaining BalanSys total knee replacement (TKR). In 91 knees, the flexion gap and anterior tibial translation were measured intra-operatively using a custom-made, flexible tensor-spacer device. The results showed that for each increase of 1 mm in the flexion gap in the tensed knee a mean anterior tibial translation of 1.25 mm (SD 0.79, 95% confidence interval 1.13 to 1.37) was produced. When implanting a PCL-retaining TKR the surgeon should be aware that the tibiofemoral contact point is related to the choice of thickness of the polyethylene insert. An additional thickness of polyethylene insert of 2 mm results in an approximate increase in tibial anterior translation of 2.5 mm while the flexed knee is distracted with a force of between 100 N and 200 N.     

Flexion instability in primary total knee replacement

Although the results of TKR are highly successful at long-term follow-up, failures occur. One of the more frequent causes of failure is instability. In distinction to instability in the medial-lateral plane, AP instability in flexion has been poorly described until recently. Although acquired ligamentous incompetence can occur, particularly with cruciate retaining prostheses, many cases of flexion instability result from an intraoperative failure to create symmetric balanced flexion and extension spaces. In primary TKR, use of a well-designed posterior stabilized prosthesis and creation of symmetric balanced flexion and extension gaps should minimize the incidence of postoperative flexion instability. If flexion instability occurs, the role of nonoperative treatment is limited. In most cases, revision TKR using the same basic principles is required. When symmetric flexion and extension spaces cannot be produced intraoperatively in complex primary or revision surgery, use of a more constrained articulation, such as a constrained condylar prosthesis or hinged prosthesis, is required.     

In vivo kinematic comparison of posterior cruciate ligament retention or sacrifice with a mobile bearing total knee arthroplasty

Video fluoroscopy and computer photogrammetry was used to evaluate 20 knees with posterior cruciate ligament (PCL) retaining and 19 knees with PCL sacrificing total knee arthroplasties (TKAs) with a mobile bearing total condylar prosthesis compared with 10 normal patients. In extension, femorotibial contact was posterior for TKA patients (P<.05) and demonstrated anterior translation from 60 degrees-90 degrees flexion. However, posterior rollback with limited translation was seen from 0 degrees-40 degrees, which may reflect the high congruity of this prosthesis. Fifty percent of meniscal bearing implants demonstrated bearing translation. Kinematics and weight-bearing range of motion were similar with PCL retention or sacrifice.     

Long-term results of posterior cruciate-substituting total knee arthroplasty

Posterior cruciate ligament-substituting total knee prostheses have been used extensively since the original posterior-stabilized condylar prosthesis was introduced more than 2 decades ago. The key design principle of this prosthesis was the incorporation of a cam and post mechanism on the femoral and tibial components. This mechanism was intended to function as a mechanical substitute for the posterior cruciate ligament, to optimize prosthesis roll back in flexion, and to avoid flexion instability by preventing posterior subluxation. Central to the use of these devices was the surgical technique, which required resection of both cruciate ligaments and creation of symmetric flexion and extension gaps with equal medial and lateral soft tissue tension. Modifications to the original design have been introduced gradually; these include changes to the patellofemoral geometry, and the addition of monoblock and modular metal-backed tibial components. Despite these changes, the key concepts of the prosthesis design and surgical technique have remained constant. The clinical results obtained with the use of these designs have been reported extensively. Long-term results at greater than 10 years continue to duplicate the outstanding early results with prosthesis survivorship exceeding 95% and high levels of patient function.     

Effects of total knee replacement design on femoral-tibial contact conditions

Ten fresh knee specimens with prosthetic components inserted were tested in a loading rig. Compressive and shear force were applied to the femur with the tibia held fixed. The location of the femoral-tibial contact points was measured. The contact reaction forces, the shear forces, and the rocking moments transmitted to the tibial component were calculated. The variations in the test conditions were: high and low compressive force, flexion angles of 0 degree, 45 degrees, and 90 degrees, three curvatures of tibial plastic inserts, and the posterior cruciate retained or resected. When the posterior cruciate was retained, the contact points were close to the center of the component; for cruciate resection, the contacts were close to the anterior of the component. The shear forces and rocking moments were higher for cruciate resection, but the contact reaction forces were lower. There is a wide variety of knee prosthesis designs, but the amount of inherent stability between the femoral and tibial surfaces, and whether the posterior cruciate ligament is retained or sacrificed, are two of the most important design variables. This study shows that cruciate resection increases the shear forces and the rocking moments to the tibial components and that additional fixation means may be necessary to compensate. On the other hand, cruciate retention with low conformity gives higher contact forces, which may lead to more wear in the long term. Cruciate sacrificing designs with intercondylar guiding surfaces are a separate category of design and were not considered in this study.     

Primary total knee arthroplasty in the valgus knee: creating a balanced soft tissue envelope

Lateral tissue releases in valgus total knee arthroplasty frequently produce asymmetric flexion-extension gaps and ligamentous instability. This study compared 2 lateral-release sequences and quantified the effects of sequential lateral capsular ligamentous structure release. One knee from 7 paired specimens was released according to a 4-step sequence: posterior cruciate ligament (PCL), ibiotibial tract (IT band), popliteus tendon/lateral collateral ligament (PT/LCL), and biceps femoris tendon. The contralateral knees were released according to a 5-step sequence: PCL, posterolateral capsule, IT band, PT, and LCL. After each release step, flexion and extension gaps were measured and recorded for the medial and lateral aspects. The 5-step sequence produced more symmetric flexion-extension gaps, whereas the absolute magnitudes of correction were lower than with the 4-step sequence. LCL sacrifice in both sequences produced marked lateral flexion-extension gap asymmetry.     

Three-dimensional tibiofemoral articular contact kinematics of a cruciate-retaining total knee arthroplasty

BACKGROUND: Accurate knowledge of the location of tibiofemoral articular contact following total knee arthroplasty is important in order to understand polyethylene wear and the mechanisms of component failure. The present study was performed to determine the three-dimensional tibiofemoral articular contact patterns of a posterior cruciate ligament-retaining total knee replacement during in vivo weight-bearing flexion. METHODS: Nine osteoarthritic patients who were managed with a single design of a posterior cruciate ligament-retaining total knee implant were investigated with the use of an innovative dual orthogonal fluoroscopic imaging system. The position of the components during in vivo weight-bearing flexion was measured from full extension to maximum flexion in 15 degrees intervals. Tibiofemoral articular contact was determined by the overlap of the tibiofemoral articular surfaces. The centroid of the surface intersection was used to report the point of contact location. The average tibiofemoral contact points on both the medial and lateral tibial component surfaces were reported as a function of flexion. RESULTS: The average maximum weight-bearing flexion angle was 113.3 degrees +/- 13.1 degrees (range, 96 degrees to 138 degrees ). In the anteroposterior direction, the contact location was relatively constant in the medial compartment and moved posteriorly by 5.6 mm in the lateral compartment as the knee flexed from full extension to 90 degrees of flexion. The range of the contact location in the mediolateral direction was 3.7 mm in the medial compartment and 4.8 mm in the lateral compartment. For both compartments, posterior translation of the contact point was significant from 90 degrees to maximum flexion, but the contact point at maximum flexion was not observed to reach the posterior edge of the polyethylene tibial insert articular surface. CONCLUSIONS: While the minimum anteroposterior translation of the contact point on the medial side might be interpreted as a medial pivot rotation during knee flexion, the contact point did move in the mediolateral direction with flexion. Beyond 90 degrees , both medial and lateral contact points were shown to move posteriorly but stopped before reaching the posterior edge of the polyethylene tibial insert articular surface. It seemed that the current component design did not allow the femoral condyle to roll off the polyethylene edge at high degrees of flexion because of the geometry at the posterior lip.     

Knee biomechanics and total knee replacement

The biomechanics of the knee joint provide an important basis for the rationale in the design and selection of appropriate total knee arthroplasty. This article examines knee biomechanics in terms of patient function, prosthesis design, cruciate ligament retention, alignment, and fixation of the tibial component. While design and surgical technique for total knee replacement progress, a better understanding of the characteristics of joint loading, stress distribution, and the biologic response of bone to stress will provide the potential to improve both function and implant longevity.     

The effect of conformity, thickness, and material on stresses in ultra-high molecular weight components for total joint replacement

Debris resulting from damage to the surface of polyethylene components of total joint replacements has previously been shown to contribute to long-term problems such as loosening and infection. Surface damage has been associated with fatigue processes due to stresses arising from contact between the metal and polyethylene components in these prostheses. In the present study, we used elasticity and finite-element solutions to determine these stresses for total hip replacements with head diameters of twenty-two and twenty-eight millimeters and for a condylar total knee replacement. We also examined the effect on these stresses of using carbon-fiber-reinforced polyethylene instead of plain polyethylene. Stresses associated with surface damage in the tibial component of the total knee replacement were much larger than those in the hip replacements. The analysis of contact stress as a function of thickness of the polyethylene insert for tibial components showed that a thickness of more than eight to ten millimeters should be maintained when possible. The contact stress in the tibial components was reduced most when the articulating surfaces were more conforming in the medial-lateral direction. Contact stresses were much less sensitive to changes in geometry in the anterior-posterior direction. For the hip components, the stresses were lower in the acetabular component of the twenty-eight-millimeter hip replacement than in the twenty-two-millimeter replacement. The use of carbon-fiber-reinforced polyethylene resulted in stresses that were higher by as much as 40 per cent. Because the contact area between articulating surfaces moves during flexion, portions of the surface will be subjected to cyclic stresses. The contact area for the knee replacements in flexion was smaller than for the hip replacements, and the range of the maximum principal stress was larger. Consequently, the combination of the higher stress and the moving contact area is more likely to cause surface damage due to fatigue in tibial components than in acetabular components, which is consistent with clinical observations.     

Movement of the posterior cruciate ligament during knee flexion--MRI analysis.

The movement of the posterior cruciate ligament (PCL) during flexion of the living knee is unknown. The purpose of the present study was to analyze the movement of the PCL using magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). The posterior cruciate ligaments in 20 normal knees were visualized using MRI from extension to deep flexion. Sagittal inclination relative to the longitudinal axis of the tibia was measured and analyzed with reference to the patellar tendon (PT) and the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL). Although the PCL was slack in extension, it straightened with anterior inclination (24.1+/-5.1 degrees ) at 90 degrees flexion. At active maximum flexion (129.2+/-8.1 degrees ), the ligament was almost parallel (3.9+/-7.4 degrees inclination) to the longitudinal axis of the tibia. At passive maximum flexion (158.8+/-5.8 degrees ), the inclination was reversed anteroposteriorly, measuring -23.0+/-6.7 degrees . The PCL and PT moved in a corresponding manner within 20 degrees of discrepancy. The results of this in vivo study of the PCL have clinical relevance to conservative therapy for PCL knee injuries. The results of this study could also be useful in PCL reconstruction surgery to determine the optimum graft position to allow maximum postoperative motion.     

Long-term followup of anatomic graduated components posterior cruciate-retaining total knee replacement.

The purpose of the current study was to evaluate the authors' 15-year experience with the Anatomic Graduated Components total knee replacement. This is a report of the survivorship of 4583 Anatomic Graduated Component total knee arthroplasties. Kaplan-Meier survival analyses were performed with the end point defined as radiographic loosening, revision, or both. This end point was subdivided into the best case scenario in which it was assumed that all the patients lost to followup were doing well throughout the study and a worst case scenario in which it was assumed that all patients lost to followup had failed results at their last clinic visit. There were six (0.18%) femoral, 21 (0.46%) tibial, and 180 (4.2%) all-polyethylene patellar component failures secondary to aseptic loosening. All femoral components and 90% of the tibial components were revised; however, only 15 patellar components were revised. The clinical survival rate with revision of one or more of the components was 98.86% at 15 years. Despite having nearly flat-on-flat geometry and retaining the posterior cruciate ligament, which should increase the stresses in the polyethylene and at the bone-cement interface, this total knee replacement has proved to have minimal wear and excellent longevity with time. The authors think this is a result of the direct compression molded polyethylene articulation and the nonmodular configuration that incorporates metal backing on the tibial component and eliminates back-sided tibial component polyethylene wear.     

Femoral rollback of cruciate-retaining and posterior-stabilized total knee replacements: in vivo fluoroscopic analysis during activities of daily living.

Restoration of the physiological flexor/extensor mechanism at the knee in terms of appropriate muscular lever arms, proper required quadriceps force, and suitable patellofemoral compressive force, is fundamental for the success of total knee replacement. Therefore, measurements of anteroposterior translation of the femoral component over the tibial base-plate against joint flexion during daily living activities are essential for the assessment of the in vivo performance of current prosthesis designs. Patients treated with posterior stabilized and cruciate retaining prostheses with excellent clinical scores were evaluated during stair climbing, sitting and rising from a chair, and step up and down, using a three-dimensional pose reconstruction technique based on videofluoroscopy. The posterior stabilized patients experienced a fairly consistent and physiological rollback specific of each motor task, demonstrating proper function of the spine-cam mechanism. Rollback was somehow inconsistent among subjects in the cruciate retaining group, accompanied with a smaller range of knee flexion. In this group, more posterior locations of the condyles correlated significantly with higher clinical and functional scores. Articular surface conformity restores physiological rollback in the presence of a spine-cam mechanism, but not coherently in the presence of the posterior cruciate ligament.