Establishment and effects of allograft and synthetic bone graft substitute treatment of a critical size metaphyseal bone defect model in the sheep femur

Assessment of bone graft material efficacy is difficult in humans, since invasive methods like staged CT scans or biopsies are ethically unjustifiable. Therefore, we developed a novel large animal model for the verification of a potential transformation of synthetic bone graft substitutes into vital bone. The model combines multiple imaging methods with corresponding histology in standardized critical sized cancellous bone defect. Cylindrical bone voids (10 ml) were created in the medial femoral condyles of both hind legs (first surgery at right hind leg, second surgery 3 months later at left hind leg) in three merino‐wool sheep and either (i) left empty, filled with (ii) cancellous allograft bone or (iii) a synthetic, gentamicin eluting bone graft substitute. All samples were analysed with radiographs, MRI, μCT, DEXA and histology after sacrifice at 6 months. Unfilled defects only showed ingrowth of fibrous tissue, whereas good integration of the cancellous graft was seen in the allograft group. The bone graft substitute showed centripetal biodegradation and new trabecular bone formation in the periphery of the void as early as 3 months. μCT gave excellent insight into the structural changes within the defects, particularly progressive allograft incorporation and the bone graft substitute biodegradation process. MRI completed the picture by clearly visualizing soft tissue ingrowth into unfilled bone voids and presence of fluid collections. Histology was essential for verification of trabecular bone and osteoid formation. Conventional radiographs and DEXA could not differentiate details of the ongoing transformation process. This model appears well suited for detailed in vivo and ex vivo evaluation of bone graft substitute behaviour within large bone defects.     

Histological and mechanical evaluation of self-setting calcium phosphate cements in a sheep vertebral bone void model

We investigated the histological and compressive properties of three different calcium phosphate cements (CPCs) using a sheep vertebral bone void model. One of the CPCs contained barium sulfate to enhance its radiopacity. Bone voids were surgically created in the lumbar region of 23 ovine spines - L3, L4, and L5 (n = 69 total vertebral bodies) - and the voids were filled with one of the three CPCs. A fourth group consisted of whole intact vertebrae. Histologic evaluation was performed for 30 of the 69 vertebrae 2 or 4 months after surgery along with radiographic evaluation. Compressive testing was performed on 39 vertebrae 4 months after surgery along with micro-CT analysis. All three CPCs were biocompatible and extremely osteoconductive. Osteoclasts associated with adjacent bone formation suggest that each cement can undergo slow resorption and replacement by bone and bone marrow. Compressive testing did not reveal a significant difference in the ultimate strength, ultimate strain, and structural modulus, among the three CPCs and intact whole vertebrae. Micro-CT analysis revealed good osseointegration between all three CPCs and adjacent bone. The barium sulfate did not affect the CPCs biocompatibility or mechanical properties. These results suggest that CPC might be a good alternative to polymethylmethacrylate for selected indications.     

Effect of low intensity pulsed ultrasound on healing of an ulna defect filled with a bone graft substitute

A 1.5 cm unilateral rabbit ulna defect model was performed in 18 adult NZ white rabbits. The defects were filled with a beta-tricalcium phosphate bone graft substitute (JAX TCP). The surgical site in half the animals was treated daily with 20 min of low intensity pulsed ultrasound (LIPUS). Animals were sacrificed at 4 weeks (n = 3 per group) or 12 weeks (n = 6 per group) following surgery for radiographic and histologic endpoints. Radiography revealed some resorption of the JAX TCP by 12 weeks in the control and LIPUS treated groups. LIPUS treatment did not accelerate this resorption. Some new bone formation was noted in the control groups at the defect margins while little bone formed in the center of the defect at 4 and 12 weeks. In contrast, radiographs revealed more new bone at 4 and 12 weeks in the LIPUS treated animals throughout the section. Bone mineral density (DEXA) revealed a statistically significant difference at 4 weeks with LIPUS while no differences were found at 12 weeks. Histology of the LIPUS treated sections demonstrated new woven bone formation on and between the JAX TCP bone graft substitute particles across the defect. VEGF expression was increased with LIPUS treatment at 4 weeks and remained elevated at 12 weeks compared with controls. CBFA-1 expression levels were elevated with LIPUS treatment at both time points. LIPUS treatment increased bone formation in ulna defect healing with a beta-tricalcium phosphate bone graft substitute.     

Vertebroplasty using bisphosphonate-loaded calcium phosphate cement in a standardized vertebral body bone defect in an osteoporotic sheep model

In the context of bone regeneration in an osteoporotic environment, the present study describes the development of an approach based on the use of calcium phosphate (CaP) bone substitutes that can promote new bone formation and locally deliver in situ bisphosphonate (BP) directly at the implantation site. The formulation of a CaP material has been optimized by designing an injectable apatitic cement that (i) hardens in situ despite the presence of BP and (ii) provides immediate mechanical properties adapted to clinical applications in an osteoporotic environment. We developed a large animal model for simulating lumbar vertebroplasty through a two-level lateral corpectomy on L3 and L4 vertebrae presenting a standardized osteopenic bone defect that was filled with cements. Both 2-D and 3-D analysis of microarchitectural parameters demonstrated that implantation of BP-loaded cement in such vertebral defects positively influenced the microarchitecture of the adjacent trabecular bone. This biological effect was dependent on the distance from the implant, emphasizing the in situ effect of the BP and its release from the cement. As a drug device combination, this BP-containing apatitic cement shows good promise as a local approach for the prevention of osteoporotic vertebral fractures through percutaneous vertebroplasty procedures.     

Histological osseointegration of a calciumphosphate bone substitute material in patients

The aim of this study was to evaluate histological and radiological osseointegration characteristics of implanted di-/tri-calciumphosphate in patients bone substitute material in opening-wedge osteotomies patients. Up to now the hypothesis of bioresorption and replacement with vital bone bases on numerous animal studies showing complete remodelling within 12-26 weeks. Histological patient studies hardly exist. In this study 13 patient biopsies were collected 16 months after tibial osteotomy. Unlike animal studies the results showed mainly incorporated avital cement residues (38%) as well as new bone formation (61%). Radiological scoring confirmed increasing signs of osseointegration and an incomplete resorption. In conclusion degradation and replacement of di-/tri-calciumphosphate seems to be less accelerated in patients than prior animal studies indicated. Nevertheless, it shows excellent biocompatibility, good osteoconductive characteristics and may represents a useful alternative to autogenous graft.     

Experimental evaluation of a gelatin-coated polyester graft used as an arterial substitute

Protein coating and endothelial cell preseeding have been proposed and studied as improvements to arterial prostheses. In this paper, an impervious polyester vascular graft which had been coated with cross-linked gelatin was compared to a porous one over a period of up to 8 months in dogs. This evaluation involved in vivo methods using radio tracers to study patency and thrombogenicity and in vitro controls of the healing processes. The main advantages offered by coated grafts over uncoated include the absence of preclotting and better biointegration.     

钛网包裹打压植骨修复大段骨缺损初步报告

目的：探讨钛网包裹打压植骨修复大段骨缺损的初步治疗效果。方法2009年1月~2012年12月,采用钛网包裹打压植骨修复6例长骨骨折后大段骨缺损。骨折骨缺损部位：股骨和肱骨各1例,胫骨、桡骨各2例。骨缺损长度5.2～9.0 cm,平均6.5 cm。固定方法：髓内钉2例,钢板4例。合并肌腱神经损伤2例。在双侧髂后部或和髂前部等处切取骨缺损体积2倍以上大量松质骨,用钛网包裹骨缺损处两端,将颗粒状骨打压植于钛网内。骨缺损恢复长度5.2～9.0 cm,平均6.3cm。结果切口均I期愈合。术后随访12～46个月,平均18个月,骨缺损处均骨性愈合,临床愈合时间4.0～6.5个月,平均5.1个月,无固定物松动断裂;至末次随访,临近关节活动度：优1例、良4例、可1例。结论钛网包裹打压植骨修复大段骨缺损,具有简便、安全、临床愈合较快、效果良好等优点。     

The use of coral as a bone graft substitute

Experiments have been performed to investigate the use of coral skeletons as bone graft substitutes. Skeletal fragments of different coral genera were implanted into cortical and spongy bone defects and used to bridge transcortical resections in the femur. The implant site was monitored for up to 18 months. Radiographically, both cortical and spongy bone defects were at least partially filled by new bone after 8 weeks while the implants underwent continuous resorption. Coral resorption and replacement by new tissue was also observed in the transcortical resections. The process of resorption was attributed to the enzymatic attack, especially carboanhydrase. This was confirmed by experiments in which dogs were implanted with coral in transcortical resections and treated daily with acetazolamide, a carboanhydrase inhibitor; the absorption appeared delayed and the resections failed to heal.     

In vivo evaluation of resorbable bone graft substitutes in a rabbit tibial defect model

Calcium sulfate as a bone graft substitute is rapidly resorbed in vivo releasing calcium ions but fails to provide long-term three-dimensional framework to support osteoconduction. The setting properties of calcium sulfate however allow it to be applied in a slurry form making it easier to handle and apply in different situations. This study examines the in vivo response of calcium sulfate alone and as a carrier for a coralline hydroxyapatite in an established bilateral corticocancellous defect model in rabbits. Defects were filled flush to the anterior cortex with a resorbable porous ceramic alone and in combination with calcium sulfate slurry, calcium sulfate slurry alone or calcium sulfate pellets and examined at time points up to 52 weeks. Specimens where assessed using Faxitron X-ray, light and electron microscopy. Calcium sulfate in either slurry or pellet form does indeed support new bone formation alone however, complete filling of the bone defect is not observed. Calcium sulfate in slurry form does however improve the surgical handling of particulate bone graft substitutes such as Pro Osteon 200 R, which remained as an osteoconductive scaffold for up to 52 weeks and may have played an important role in the ultimate closure of the cortical windows.     

Long-term evaluation of a calcium phosphate bone cement with carboxymethyl cellulose in a vertebral defect model

We investigated histological and compressive properties of a calcium phosphate bone cement (BoneSource (CPC); Stryker Orthopaedics, Mahwah, New Jersey) plus carboxymethyl cellulose (CMC) using a sheep vertebral bone void model. Bone voids were surgically created in L3 and L5 in each of 40 sheep, and the voids were filled with the cement. Histological and radiographic evaluations were performed on one vertebral body from each animal at either: 0, 3, 6, 12, 24, or 36 months after surgery; mechanical testing was performed on operated and non-operated vertebral bodies from 35 sheep. Undecalcified sections were digitized, and the area of the original defect, new bone formation, empty space, fibrous tissue, and residual cement were quantified with histomorphometry. Decalcified sections were evaluated qualitatively. The cement was biocompatible, extremely osteoconductive and underwent steady resorption and replacement by bone and bone marrow. Histomorphometry showed variations in the rate of cement remodeling among animals in each time group, but on average, at 36 months the original defect area was occupied by approximately 14% bone, 82% cement, and 4% bone marrow. Even in animals that had greater resorption of cement, there was good bone ingrowth with no fibrous tissue. Compressive testing did not reveal a significant difference in the mechanical properties between vertebral bodies augmented with cement and non-augmented controls, irrespective of the postoperative time. BoneSource mixed with CMC had adequate osteoconductivity, biocompatibility, and adequate compressive strength. There was variability among animals, but histology suggests that considerable cement was still present in most samples after 36 months.     

Calcium sulfate-carboxymethylcellulose bone graft binder: Histologic and morphometric evaluation in a critical size defect

Calcium sulfate (CS) is widely used as a bone graft binder and expander. Recent reports indicate that carboxymethylcellulose (CMC) can improve the clinical properties of CS when used as binder for particulate bone grafts; however, limited information is available on the effects of CMC on bone regeneration. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the histologic and morphometric characteristics of bone formation in calvarial defects grafted with a CS-based putty containing 10% CMC in combination with allogeneic demineralized bone matrix (DBM). Bone formation and graft/binder resorption were compared with a surgical grade CS and DBM in paired critical-sized calvarial defects in 25 Wistar rats (350-450 g). Six animals each provided paired defects at 7, 14, 21, and 28 days postsurgery for nondecalcified processing and microscopic analysis. Defects grafted with CS or CS-CMC putty as the DBM binder exhibited similar patterns and proportions of bone formation, fibrous tissue/marrow, and residual DBM particles. Comparable mean +/- SD proportions of new bone formation (31.7 +/- 9.5 and 33.7 +/- 12.9), fibrous tissue/marrow (54.2 +/- 8.3 and 53.0 +/- 10.8), residual DBM particles (8.3 +/- 6.8 and 10.1 +/- 6.3), and residual binder material (5.5 +/- 4.6 and 3.7 +/- 3.5) were found at 28 days for defects grafted with CS and CS-CMC putty, respectively. Thus, CMC was found to improve the handling characteristics of CS and, when used in conjunction with DBM, supported comparable levels bone formation and patterns of binder/scaffold resorption as CS and DBM in a calvarial defect model.     

Fabrication and evaluation of a new composite composed of tricalcium phosphate, gelatin, and Chinese medicine as a bone substitute

This study investigates the biological effects of traditional Chinese medicines on the activities of bone cells using rat bone cells. Then, a mixture of a GGT composite, that is, a novel biodegradable composite containing genipin crosslinked gelatin and tricalcium phosphate, and traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) was prepared as a GGT-TCM composite. A cultured neonatal rat calvarias organ was used to measure the potential of GGT-TCM composite for use in promoting the regeneration of defective bone tissue. The mitochondria activity of the bone cells following exposure to various concentrations of crude extracts of five herbal Chinese medicines was measured by colorimetric assay. Biochemical markers, such as alkaline phosphatase (ALP) and tartrate-resistant acid phosphatase (TRAP) titers were analyzed to evaluate the activities of bone cells. Finally, we examined the organ culture units, which were maintained in cultured medium for 5 weeks. Morphology of tissue was observed, and the quantitative evaluation of the regenerated bone was determined. In a bone cells culture experiment, adding Cuscuta chinensis Lam. (TCM-5) to the bone cells culture clearly promoted the proliferation and differentiation of the osteoblasts from their precursor cells; but the reduced amount of TRAP indicated that the medicine significantly inhibited the osteoclasts activities. Opposite bone cell responses were observed when Loranthus parasiticus Merr. (TCM-3) and Achyranthes bidentata Bl. (TCM-4) were added to the bone cells culture. Eucommia ulmoides Oliv. (TCM-1) and Dipsacus asper Wall. (TCM-2) potentially influence the proliferation and differentiation of the osteoblasts from their precursor cells, but they did not affect the osteoclasts activities. The finding from the organ culture indicated that Chinese medicine effectively increased the rate of tissue regeneration of damaged bones.     

Use of a novel bone graft substitute in peri-articular bone tumours of the knee

We treated three patients with aneurysmal bone cysts and seven with giant cell tumours who presented with a large osteolytic lesion in peri-articular areas of the knee. The patients age ranged from 8 to 49 years (mean 25 years). The average tumour volume was measured at 39.8 cm³ (range 18 to 65 cm³). The tumour cavities were treated with curettage, phenolisation and application of a composite bone graft substitute containing 35% calcium-sulphate hemihydrate and 65% hydroxyapatite granules. All patients were followed up for 4.0 to 5.2 years (mean 4.5 years). Tumour recurrence was noted in two cases. In the remaining patients consolidation of the lesion was considered complete at a mean of 4.5 months (3–6.5 months). During follow-up no deformities developed and no radiological signs of joint degeneration were noted. All patients regained close to normal function, with a mean Musculoskeletal Tumour Society Rating Score of 95.1%.

Due to their good osteoconductive abilities, composite synthetic bone graft substitute combining porous hydroxyapatite with calcium-sulphate appears to be an effective alternative to autologous cancellous bone graft in the treatment of large osteolytic lesions in peri-articular areas around the knee joint. They bear major advantages through ubiquitous availability and the avoidance of morbidity associated with iliac crest harvest. Concerns remain as the radio-opaque appearance of the bone graft substitute may potentially delay the detection of tumour recurrence.     

Mechanical evaluation of a porous bone graft substitute based on poly(propylene glycol-co-fumaric acid)

A porous, resorbable polymer composite based on poly(propylene glycol-co-fumaric acid) (PPF) was mechanically evaluated in vitro for use as a bone graft substitute and fracture fixative. The test material created a dynamic system capable of initially providing mechanical integrity to bony voids and a degradative mechanism for ingrowth by native bone. The unsaturated polymer, PPF, was crosslinked in the presence of effervescent agents to yield a porous microstructure upon curing. An in vitro degradation study first assessed the temporal mechanical properties of the test material. This research was followed by an ex vivo study using a long-bone osteotomy model to characterize the mechanics of fixation. Results showed the initial compressive strength of the cross-linked PPF system was comparable to cancellous bone. The rate of strength loss was commensurate with the predicted mechanical recovery of healing bone with analogous results in a composite that comprised also 25% (by weight) autograft. Mechanical testing in the long-bone model demonstrated that PPF-based bone-graft substitute increased the flexural strength of K-wire stabilized osteotomies. These results suggest that this type of bone graft substitute may have clinical utility in the stabilization of complex tubular bone fractures.     

BMP-2 incorporated in a tricalcium phosphate bone substitute enhances bone remodeling in sheep

Bone morphogenetic protein-2 (BMP-2) is a well-known osteoinductive protein, which requires a carrier for local application. As an alternative to the previously described carriers, an in situ hardening, resorbable, and osteoconductive beta-tricalcium phosphate cement (TCP) is tested. Trepanation defects in the bovine distal femoral epiphysis are filled with a composite consisting of TCP and 200 microg rhBMP-2 per cm3 TCP, autologous bone graft, pure TCP, or left empty. A radiological follow-up is performed after 7 weeks and 3 months. The sheep are euthanized and bone samples are analyzed by microradiography, histology, and histomorphometry. Microradiography and histology show similar results for pure TCP and the composite. The defects are filled with trabecular bone and newly formed bone is in close contact with the remaining TCP-particles. The majority of the cement is resorbed, in the composite group the amount of remaining cement particles is reduced. Defects treated with autologous bone graft are filled completely, while untreated defects shows only a small amount of bone originating from the rim of the defect. Histomorphometry of the defects treated with pure TCP shows a significantly increased bone content in comparison to defects treated with the composite or autologous bone graft. Analysis of the remaining cement particles shows significantly less cement in the TCP/rhBMP-2 group in comparison to pure TCP. The sum of bone and cement content in the rhBMP-2 group shows amounts comparable to the calcified structures found following autologous bone grafting. The addition of rhBMP-2 to the TCP leads to faster remodeling of the defect comparable to autologous bone graft, while defects treated with pure TCP are not completely remodeled.     

Evaluation of a resorbable, in situ setting bone substitute in a sheep model

The gold standard for bone substitution is the autologous bone graft, but because of its limited supply and the associated morbidity, the search for synthetic alternatives is necessary. A new in situ setting tricalcium phosphate cement was implanted in a trepanation defect (9.4 mm diameter, 10 mm depth) in the distal femoral epiphysis of sheep. Empty cavities and autologous bone graft were used as controls. Histologic and histomorphometric examinations were carried out after 12 weeks. Nearly 90% of the implanted cement was resorbed and replaced by ingrown bone with close contact between surrounding bone, new bone, and remaining cement particles. The amount of bone in the defect area was significantly higher in defects filled with cement relative to defects filled with autologous bone graft (mean 27 vs. 21%, 95% confidence intervals 23 to 31 and 18 to 23, p = 0.026). In conclusion, this new in situ setting cement is bioactive, resorbable, and osteoconductive. It will be useful as an alternative to autologous bone graft to fill stable defects.     

Effect of porosity on the osteointegration and bone ingrowth of a weight-bearing nickel-titanium bone graft substitute

Porous nickel-titanium (NiTi) alloy is a promising new material for a bone graft substitute with good strength properties and an elastic modulus closer to that of bone than any other metallic material. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the effect of porosity on the osteointegration of NiTi implants in rat bone. The porosities (average void volume) and the mean pore size (MPS) were 66.1% and 259+/-30 microm (group 1, n=14), 59.2% and 272+/-17 microm (group 2, n=4) and 46.6% and 505+/-136 microm (group 3, n=15), respectively. The implants were implanted in the distal femoral metaphysis of the rats for 30 weeks. The proportional bone-implant contact was best in group 1 (51%) without a significant difference compared to group 3 (39%). Group 2 had lower contact values (29%) than group 1 (p=0.038). Fibrotic tissue within the porous implant was found more often in group 1 than in group 3 (p=0.021), in which 12 samples out of 15 showed no signs of fibrosis. In conclusion, porosity of 66.1% (MPS 259+/-30 microm) showed best bone contact (51%) of the porosities tested here. However, the porosity of 46.6% (MPS 505+/-136 microm) with bone contact of 39% was not significantly inferior in this respect and showed lower incidence of fibrosis within the porous implant.     

An injectable,biodegradable calcium phosphate cement containing poly lactic-co-glycolic acid as a bone substitute in ex vivo human vertebral compression fracture and rabbit bone defect models

Purpose/Aim of the study: To evaluate the biomechanical characteristics and biocompatibility of an injectable, biodegradable calcium phosphate cement (CPC) containing poly lactic-co-glycolic acid (PLGA). Materials and methods: A vertebral compression fracture model was established using 20 human cadaveric vertebrae (T11-L3) divided into CPC/PLGA composite versus PMMA groups for biomechanical testing. In addition, 35 New Zealand rabbits were used to evaluate biodegradability and osteoconductive properties of CPC/PLGA using a bone defect model. In vitro cytotoxicity was evaluated by culturing with L929 cells. Results: The CPC/PLGA composite effectively restored vertebral biomechanical properties. Compared with controls, the maximum load and compression strength of the CPC/PLGA group were lower, and stiffness was lower after kyphoplasty (all p <.05). Degradation was much slower in the control CPC compared with CPC/PLGA group. The bone tissue percentage in the CPC/PLGA group (44.9 ± 23.7%) was significantly higher compared with control CPC group (25.7 ± 10.9%) (p <.05). The viability of cells cultured on CPC/PLGA was greater than 70% compared with the blanks. Conclusions: Our biodegradable CPC/PLGA composite showed good biomechanical properties, cytocompatibility, and osteoconductivity and may represent an ideal bone substitute for future applications.