Trigemino-cervical reflex abnormalities in patients with migraine and cluster headache

BACKGROUND: Head pain arises within the trigeminal nociceptive system. Current theories propose that the trigeminal system is intimately involved in the pathogenesis of migraine. Short-latency responses can be recorded in sternocleidomastoid muscles after stimulation of the trigeminal nerve (trigemino-cervical reflex). This brainstem reflex could be a suitable method to evaluate the trigeminal system in migraine and CH. OBJECTIVE: The aim of the present study was to further elucidate the pathophysiology of migraine and cluster headache (CH) with special reference to the involvement of the central trigeminal system in the different forms of primary headache. METHODS: The trigemino-cervical reflex was investigated in 15 healthy subjects, in 15 patients having migraine with aura, in 15 patients with migraine without aura, and in 10 patients with CH. RESULTS: Significant abnormalities were observed in a great number of patients with both types of migraine and CH during the headache attacks, but only in migraine patients during the interictal period. The alterations are bilateral in migraine, unilateral in CH. CONCLUSIONS: Our results further support the relevance of brainstem mechanisms in the pathogenesis of migraine rather than of CH. These data, taken together with that from experimental head pain and functional imaging studies, demonstrate that primary headache syndromes may be distinguished on a functional basis by areas of activation specific to the clinical syndrome.     

Trigemino-cervical reflex in patients with headache

Neurophysiological studies have shown abnormal activity of some brainstem nuclei in headache patients. The trigemino-cervical reflex is an anti-nociceptive reflex that gives an opportunity for evaluation of the brainstem interneurone activity. It has not been previously examined in headache patients. We studied 15 patients with predominantly unilateral chronic tension-type headache, 15 patients with migraine without aura and 32 healthy subjects. The trigemino-cervical reflex was recorded bilaterally from the resting sternocleidomastoid muscle using surface electromyographic recordings. In all headache patients the trigemino-cervical reflex on the painful side was with shortened latency compared with the non-painful side and with healthy persons. The results suggest decreased activity of the brainstem inhibitory interneurones. We suggest that although the pathophysiological mechanisms of tension-type headache and migraine are different, they share common mechanisms of abnormal pain control.     

Tumor necrosis factor B gene polymorphism contributes to susceptibility to migraine without area

Migraine without aura (MWOA) and migraine with aura (MWA) are disorders in which multiple factors, including environmental and genetic factors, are involved. In a previous study we hypothesized a protective role of HLA-DR2 antigen, providing additional basis for the proposed genetic heterogeneity between MWOA and MWA. The cytokines TNFA and TNFB are polypeptide effectors of inflammatory reaction and endothelial function. To better define the involvement of HLA region genes in migraine, we performed an association study of the tumor necrosis factor (TNF) genes, located in the HLA class III region, with MWOA and MWA. TNFB alleles 1 and 2 were analyzed by PCR-RFLP in 30 MWOA patients, in 47 MWA patients and in 101 random controls. The frequency of TNFB*2 was significantly increased in MWOA patients as compared with controls (78.72% vs. 61.4%, p _c = 0.004), while no significant differences were found between MWA patients and controls. The distribution of TNFB genotypic frequencies showed a significant decrease of TNFB 1,1 homozygotes in MWOA patients (p _c = 0.0201). The observed increase of TNFB*2 in MWOA is dustributed in TNFB 2,2 and TNFB 1,2 genotypes, meaning that the susceptibility allele could act as “dominant”: people with TNFB 1,1 genotype are less predisposed to the disease. While more studies are needed in larger migraine samples to reinforce the statistical power of the reported data, the present study supports the hypothesis that TNFB is a susceptibility gene in MWOA. Received: 21 August 2000, Accepted in revised form: 18 October 2000     

Migraine without aura and migraine with aura are distinct disorders. A population-based twin survey

OBJECTIVE: To investigate the co-occurrence of migraine without aura (MWOA) and migraine with aura (MWA) in a population-based twin survey. BACKGROUND: Migraine without aura and MWA are multifactorial disorders. If MWOA and MWA share common genes, co-occurrence should be observed more frequently than expected, ie, the product of the prevalence in the general population. MATERIAL AND METHODS: The study population included all living Danish monozygotic (MZ) and same-gender dizygotic (DZ) twin pairs born between 1953 and 1960: 5360 twins (2026 MZ, 3334 DZ). The sample included 2840 men and 2520 women. All received a posted questionnaire, and those with possible migraine were interviewed via telephone by trained physicians (V.U. or M.G.). Twins who did not respond to the questionnaire and who had a co-twin with possible migraine were contacted by telephone. The questionnaire response rate was 87% (4660 of 5360), and the telephone interview was participated in by 90% (2035 of 2272). The physician interviewers were unaware of questionnaire answers, zygosity, and the clinical diagnosis of the co-twin. The criteria of the International Headache Society were used to establish a diagnosis of migraine. RESULTS: Lifetime prevalence in the twin sample: 7% of men and 19% of women had MWOA, while 7% of men and 8% of women had MWA. Lifetime prevalence of MWA in twin pairs with MWOA: MZ men, 2% (1 of 47); MZ women, 6% (5 of 90); DZ men, 9% (7 of 75); and DZ women, 10% (19 of 182). Lifetime prevalence of MWOA in twin pairs with MWA: MZ men, 3% (1 of 33); MZ women, 5% (3 of 58); DZ men, 9% (4 of 44); and DZ women, 13% (10 of 76). The observed and the expected numbers of twins with co-occurrence of MWOA and MWA based on the prevalence in the general population were not significantly different in either men or women (men, P=.1 and women, P=.5). CONCLUSION: The results strongly suggest that MWOA and MWA are distinct disorders, and identification of common genes for MWOA and MWA, thus, should not be expected to result from future genetic research.     

Sensitization of trigeminal nociception specific for migraine but not pain of sinusitis.

Neurology. 2002;59:1450-1453.
Trigeminal pain processing was studied in 14 patients with unilateral migraine attacks and 14 age- and sex-matched patients with comparable unilateral headache from frontal sinusitis. Using a nociception-specific blink reflex method (nBR), a facilitation of nBR responses predominantly on the headache side was observed in migraine, but not in sinusitis. The facilitation of trigeminal nociception may be specific for migraine rather than a consequence of peripheral pain such as frontal sinusitis.
Comment: Here we have evidence for the central hyperexcitability of migraine, not found in the previously cited article by Boska et al. SJT     

Blink reflex R2 amplitudes in cervicogenic headache, chronic tension-type headache and migraine

Blink reflex R2 amplitude was investigated in seven patients with cervicogenic headache (CEH), 12 patients with chronic tension-type headache, 23 patients with migraine (10 with aura) and 17 headache-free controls. Standard electrical stimulation of the supraorbital nerve was applied and the response was recorded from the ipsilateral and the contralateral orbicularis oculi muscles. Low R2 amplitude was found in CEH patients compared with control subjects. Headache is unilateral in CEH and the ipsilateral and contralateral responses after stimulation on the painful side were most depressed. R2 amplitude was not significantly affected in migraine and tension headache patients. The results suggest that lower brainstem excitability is reduced in CEH. A state of hypoactivity may be present in caudal trigeminal nucleus neurons on the symptomatic side.     

Hypothalamic activation in spontaneous migraine attacks

BACKGROUND: Migraine sufferers experience premonitory symptoms which suggest that primary hypothalamic dysfunction is a likely trigger of the attacks. Neuroendocrine and laboratory data also support this hypothesis. To date, positron emission tomography (PET) scans of migraine sufferers have demonstrated activation of brainstem nuclei, but not of the hypothalamus. OBJECTIVE: To record cerebral activations withH2 15OPET during spontaneous migraine without aura attacks. METHODS: We scanned 7 patients with migraine without aura (6 females and 1 male) in each of 3 situations: within 4 hours of headache onset, after headache relief by sumatriptan injection (between the fourth and the sixth hour after headache onset), and during an attack-free period. RESULTS: During the headache we found not only significant activations in the midbrain and pons, but also in the hypothalamus, all persisting after headache relief by sumatriptan. CONCLUSION: Hypothalamic activity, long suspected by clinical and experimental arguments as a possible trigger for migraine, is demonstrated for the first time during spontaneous attacks.     

Mutation analysis of the CACNA1A calcium channel subunit gene in 27 patients with sporadic hemiplegic migraine.

Int J Psychophysiol . 2002 Jun;44(3):239-249
The modulation of trigeminal reflex excitability in migraine patients was evaluated during the asymptomatic phase by studying the effects of attention, habituation and preconditioning stimulus on the R2 and R3 components of the blink reflex (BR). Fifty patients suffering from migraine without aura, 20 affected by migraine with aura and 35 sex- and age-matched controls were selected. In subgroups of migraine with-aura and without-aura patients, and normal controls, the blink reflex was elicited during different cognitive situations: (a) spontaneous mental activity; (b) stimulus anticipation; (c) recognition of target numbers. In the remaining subjects, R2 and R3 habituation was evaluated by repetitive stimulation at 1, 5, 10, 15, 20, 25 and 30 s intervals. The R2 and R3 recovery curves were also computed. A reduced R3 threshold with a normal pain threshold was found in migraine with-aura and without-aura patients; the R3 component was not significantly correlated with the pain thresholds in patients and controls. The R2 and R3 components were less influenced by the warning of the stimulus in migraine without-aura and migraine with-aura patients, in comparison with the control group. A slight increase of both R2 and R3 recovery after preconditioning stimulus was also observed in migraine patients, probably caused by a phenomenon of trigeminal hyperexcitability persisting after the last attack. The abnormal BR modulation by alerting expresses in migraine a dysfunction of adaptation capacity to environmental conditions, probably predisposing to migraine.
Comment: Further physiologic and functional evidence for the interictal hyperexcitability of neurons in patients with migraine, in this case trigeminal neurons involved in the blink reflex. SJT     

Acute and interictal allodynia in patients with different headache forms: an Italian pilot study

OBJECTIVE: To investigate allodynia in patients with different primary headaches. BACKGROUND: Many migraineurs have allodynia during headache attacks; some may have allodynia outside attacks; allodynia may also be associated with other primary headaches. METHODS: A total of 260 consecutive primary headache patients presenting for the first time at a headache center, and 23 nonheadache controls answered written questions (subsequently repeated verbally) to determine the presence of acute and interictal allodynia. RESULTS: We divided the patients into: episodic migraine (N = 177), subdivided into only migraine without aura (N = 114) and those sometimes or always reporting migraine with aura (N = 63); episodic tension-type headache (N = 28); chronic headaches (headache > or = 15 days/month, N = 52), including chronic migraine, chronic tension-type headache, and medication-overuse headache; and other headache forms (N = 3). Acute allodynia was present in 132 (50.7%), significantly more often in patients sometimes or always suffering migraine with aura, and those with chronic headache forms, compared to patients with migraine without aura and episodic tension-type headache. Interictal allodynia was present in 63 (24.2%) patients, with significantly higher frequency in those having migraine with aura attacks than controls and common migraine patients. CONCLUSIONS: Allodynia is not specific to migraine but is frequent in all headache patients: acute allodynia was reported in half those interviewed and in over a third of patients in each headache category; interictal allodynia was reported by nearly 25%.     

Vestibulo-Ocular Reflex in Migraine Patients: The Effect of Sodium Valproate

SYNOPSIS
We studied vestibulo-ocular reflex measurements in a group of 12 patients suffering from migraine without aura and evaluated the effect of sodium valproate given as prophylactic migraine therapy. The study was randomized, double blind and placebo controlled, with a crossover design. The horizontal vestibulo-ocular reflex was evaluated by the Sinusoidal Harmonic Acceleration test at 0.01, 0.02, 0.04, 0.08end 0.16 Hz using a computerized rotatory chair system. No abnormalities were found for the vestibulo-ocular reflex gain, phase and asymmetry at each of the frequencies examined during the placebotreatment. These normal vestibulo-ocular reflex measurements contrasted with the repeated complaints of dizziness, vertigo and unsteadiness reported by 7 patients (58%). Sodium valproate affected neither vestibulo-ocular responses nor vestibular complaints but was effective in reducing migraine attacks in 8 of the 12 patients. These results demonstrate that the low frequency vestibulo-ocular reflex measurements are normal in patients suffering from migraine without aura.     

Revisiting the Efficacy of Sumatriptan Therapy During the Aura Phase of Migraine

Objective.— To reexamine the efficacy of terminating migraine headache by administration of sumatriptan during the visual-aura phase of the attack.
Background.— Although the antimigraine action of triptans is most effective soon after onset of the headache, treatment during the aura phase has been found to be ineffective.
Methods.— Nineteen subjects having migraine with aura were studied using a 4-way crossover, open-label design. Each patient was asked to treat 8 consecutive attacks with 100 mg of sumatriptan RT: 3 attacks treated at a timing of the patient's discretion (baseline); 1 attack treated 4 hours after onset of pain (late); 2 attacks treated within 1 hour of onset of pain (early); 2 attacks treated during the aura phase – before the onset of pain (aura). Pain level and cutaneous allodynia were reported by the patients at the onset of pain, at the time of treatment, and 2 and 24 hours after treatment.
Results.— Sumatriptan treatment during the aura preempted the development of headache in 34/38 (89%) attacks. The same patients were rendered pain-free in 30/38 (79%) of attacks treated within 1 hour of pain onset, and in 4/19 (21%) of attacks treated 4 hours after the onset of pain. The incidence of allodynia at the time of treatment was 2/38 (5%) in attacks treated during aura, 8/38 (21%) in attacks treated early, and 14/19 (74%) in attacks treated late.
Conclusion.— Considering the discrepancy between the present and previous clinical studies, it is worthwhile revisiting the efficacy of preemptive triptan therapy during the aura phase of migraine attacks, using larger-scale, 3-way, crossover, placebo-controlled studies.     

Electrophysiological evidence for trigeminal neuron sensitization in patients with migraine.

Neurosci Lett . 2002 Jan 14;317(3):135-138
The electrically elicited corneal reflex is a useful tool for exploring the trigeminal system in humans and it may provide additional evidence pointing to a dysfunction of this system in migrainous patients. Tactile perception, corneal reflex and pain thresholds were studied in 48 migraine without aura patients during pain-free periods and compared with those observed in 24 controls. Twenty-eight of the patients had strictly unilateral headache, while the other 20 had bilateral or side-shifting pain during attacks. Both migraine subgroups (bilateral and unilateral) showed significantly lower thresholds compared with controls. The lowest values were observed on the symptomatic side of unilateral migraine patients. These findings suggest that sensorimotor mechanisms and/or pain control systems at the trigeminal level are impaired in migraine. The bilateral location of these abnormalities seems to point to a centrally located dysfunction.
Comment: This is an important paper which describes a noninvasive method of studying sensorimotor/pain control mechanism in humans. This approach may help in the development of potential prophylactic agents, to establish likely clinically effective doses and duration of treatments in small-scale phase II trials, before exposing larger numbers of subjects to potentially ineffective doses in phase III trials. DSM     

Cluster headache with aura

The objective of our study is to report the frequency and characteristics of cluster headache with aura among the population of patients with cluster headache treated in our outpatient neurology clinic. 254 patients were submitted to semi-structured interviews to identify the presence of symptoms similar to the migraine aura. 5 patients who suffered from a cluster headache with aura filled a diary with the characteristics of the pain attacks and the aura. All the patients with either episodic or chronic cluster headache were studied. The pain attacks were associated with symptoms similar to the migraine aura in five patients (2%). These disorders were usually ipsilateral to the pain and consisted of paresthesias of the trigeminal territory, clumsiness of the limbs or visual disturbances. Neither paresis nor hypoesthesia could be proved by clinical examination during the attack. We propose to reserve the name of cluster headache with aura to these cases that show similar symptomatology to the migraine aura. These manifestations suggest the participation of the central nervous system in this type of cluster headache. Received: 16 July 2001, Accepted in revised form: 4 December 2001 Correspondence to E. Martínez-Fernández     

Increased cerebrovascular pCO2 reactivity in migraine with aura- a transcranial Doppler study during hyperventilation

Cerebrovascular reactivity during hypocapnia was tested in 20 migraineurs (8 with aura, 12 without aura) and 30 sex- and age-matched healthy subjects, and during nitroglycerin-induced headache in 12 healthy subjects. Before and during hyperventilation, mean blood-flow velocity (V_mean) in the middle cerebral artery was measured with transcranial Doppler. In each subject a pCO₂ reactivity index (RI) was calculated as DV_mean/baseline V_mean)/ DpCO₂. Interictally, patients with migraine with aura showed higher RI ( p < 0.05 ANOVA and multiple range test) than controls, whereas migraineurs without aura did not differ from healthy subjects. Ictal and interictal RIs were similar in 9 patients suffering from migraine without aura. No side-to-side differences were detected in RI. During nitroglycerin-induced headache, the RIs were no different from those recorded during migraine attacks and in non-nitroglycerin-provoked healthy controls (p > 0.05, ANOVA and multiple range test). The exaggerated response in migraine with aura might predispose for the characteristic changes in rCBF seen during attacks.     

Enhanced trigemino-cervical-spinal reflex recovery cycle in pain-free migraineurs

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate trigemino-cervical-spinal reflexes (TCSRs) in a group of migraine patients during the pain-free period. BACKGROUND: TCRSs are part of a complex nocifensive response involving the cervical and the upper limb muscles, and are modulated by supraspinal inhibitory pathways; it may, thus, be possible to use TCRSs to explore the trigeminal system in migraineurs. METHODS: A total of 43 migraine patients without aura (MWoA, 32 patients) or with typical aura (MWA, 11 patients) and 30 age- and sex-matched healthy subjects took part in the study. TCRSs were obtained by stimulating the supraorbital nerve and recorded from the semispinalis capitis muscle and the biceps brachii. The latency (L, msec), area (A, mVms) and recovery cycle of the reflexes were recorded. The effects of heterotopic painful stimulation on the neurophysiological parameters were studied by a validated cold pressor test (CPT). RESULTS: No significant changes were found between either migraine patients and controls or MWoA and MWA patients in the mean values in the L and A of TCRSs (t-test, P > .05). The recovery curve of the trigemino-cervical reflexes (TCRs) was significantly faster in migraine patients than in controls, while no differences were found in the trigemino-spinal reflexes (TSRs) (t-test, P < .01). Activation of the diffuse inhibitory controls through the CPT induced a significant reduction in the TCRs and TSRs area in both migraine patients and controls (paired t-test, P < .01), though the extent of this reduction did not differ significantly between migraineurs and controls (t-test, P > .05). COMMENTS: Our data suggest that the pain-free period in migraine patients is characterized by a hyperexcitability of the trigeminal pathways and of their anatomical and functional connections with the upper cervical cord neurons, and that this abnormal hyperexcitability does not appear to be due to a lack of a supraspinal inhibitory modulation.     

Hungarian migraine epidemiology

OBJECTIVE: A population-based epidemiological survey of migraine without aura and migraine with aura completed by mailed questionnaire in Hungary. The diagnosis and classification of migraine was according to the criteria of the International Headache Society. METHODS: The validity of the self-administered headache questionnaire was evaluated by a neurologist using clinical interviews. The study population was a random sample of 2000 men and women aged between 15 and 80 years. The questionnaire was completed by 813 of 1910 people (392 men and 421 women), providing a 42.6% participation rate. RESULTS: Sixty-seven percent of these people experienced some kind of headache during their lives. The 1-year prevalence of migraine without aura was 7.6% (the female/male ratio was 3:1), while the 1-year prevalence of migraine with aura was 2% (female/male ratio was 2:1). Most migraineurs experienced headache attacks 1 to 4 times monthly, which lasted 24 hours. The most characteristic accompanying signs were nausea and phonophobia. Stress, sleep deprivation, hot weather, and fasting were the most common precipitating factors of a migraine attack. In the migraine with aura group, the most common aura was a visual disturbance. Only 43% of migraineurs had ever consulted a physician for headache, and only 15% of patients had missed work or school because of a migraine attack in the previous year. Most of the patients suffering from migraine without aura were between 20 and 40 years old, while migraineurs with aura were over 40 years old. According to this investigation, the prevalence of migraine was not lower than in Western countries.     

Relationship between migraine and epilepsy in pediatric age

OBJECTIVE: Many studies have supported the hypothesis of alteration of cortical hyperexcitability as a possible pathological mechanism underlying the onset of migraine and epileptic attacks. Different biochemical pathways involving cellular structures may increase or decrease the excitability of neuronal membranes. The aim of this study was to identify a possible link between migraine and epilepsy from a clinical and neurophysiologic point of view. METHODS: One-hundred thirty-seven children and adolescents consecutively diagnosed for tension-type headache and idiopathic migraine with and without aura were studied. Anamnestic, clinical, and instrumental data were collected by a neurological examination, a specific questionnaire, and awake electroencephalogram (EEG) registrations. EEG features of nonheadache and nonseizures control group were compared. RESULTS: Fourteen cases (10.2%) had a positive history for seizures with fever, isolated seizures, or epilepsy. Distribution differed according to headache diagnosis; migraine with aura (MWA) was largely prevalent. Specific electroencephalographic abnormalities were present in 11.7% of the sample, with a significant different distribution across the groups of children with headache and the control group: specific interictal abnormalities were found in 10 of 23 (43.5%) children with MWA. Two factors, seizures and specific interictal electroencephalographic abnormalities, showed a different distribution in patients with MWA compared to other classes of headache and control group (P < or = .01). CONCLUSION: The present study supports the hypothesis of a possible clinical continuum between some types of MWA and epileptic syndromes as entities due to altered neuronal excitability with similar genetic substrates.     

Improved description of the migraine aura by a diagnostic aura diary

We present a diagnostic aura diary for prospective recordings of migraine with aura. Three questionnaires are supplemented with sheets for drawings and plottings of visual and sensory auras. Twenty patients recorded 54 attacks of migraine with aura and 2 attacks of migraine aura without headache. The visual and sensory aura were usually gradually progressive, reaching maximum development in 15 and 25 min (median) respectively and had a total duration of 20 and 55 min (median) respectively. Approximately 13% of the attacks had acute onset of visual aura associated with other features more typical of migraine. The visual and sensory auras always preceded typical migraine headache, and headache occurring before aura symptoms was always of the tension type, The migraine headache was milder than in attacks of migraine without aura and often did not have migraine characteristics. In attacks with unilateral head pain, headache and aura symptoms were contralateral in 90% and ipsilateral in 10%.     

Der trigeminozervikale Komplex

The activation of the trigeminal nociceptive system is the neural substrate of pain in primary headache syndromes such as migraine and cluster headache. The nociceptive inflow from the meninges to the spinal cord is relayed in brainstem neurones of the trigemino-cervical complex (TCC). Two important mechanisms of pain transmission are reviewed: convergence of nociceptive trigeminal and cervical afferents and sensitization of trigemino-cervical neurones. These mechanisms have clinical correlates such as hyperalgesia, allodynia, spread and referral of pain to trigeminal or cervical dermatomes. Neurones in the TCC are subject to a modulation of pain-modulatory circuits in the brainstem such as the periaqueductal grey (PAG). Recent experimental and clinical findings of a modulation of these pain processes are discussed. The review focuses on TCC neurones as integrative relay neurones between peripheral and central pain mechanisms. The understanding of these mechanisms has implications for the understanding of the clinical phenomenology in primary headache syndromes and the development of therapeutical options.     

Platelet superoxide dismutase in migraine and tension-type headache

Superoxide dismutase (SOD) is a radical-scavenging enzyme. We determined Cu, Zn-SOD concentrations and activities in platelets from subjects with migraine and tension-type headaches. Thirty migraine without aura (MWoA) patients, 9 migraine with aura (MWA) patients, and 53 tension-type headache patients were selected for study. Thirty healthy volunteers composed the control group. Concentrations of platelet SOD were determined using enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay techniques. The activity of platelet SOD was determined by measuring reductivity of nitroblue tetrazolium. Low concentrations of platelet SOD were found in patients with MWA and MWoA. Platelet SOD activity decreased in MWA patients but not in patients with MWoA or tension-type headaches. These findings suggest vulnerability to oxidative stress in patients with migraine. It is suggested that low platelet SOD levels may play an important role in the etiology of migraine.