A method for the early evaluation of the Ponseti (Iowa) technique for the treatment of idiopathic clubfoot

The Ponseti casting technique is reported to have a high success rate in the treatment of idiopathic clubfoot. Non-operative treatment of clubfoot provides a lower complication rate, less pain, and higher function as the patient ages than operative treatment. To demonstrate serial post-treatment change in clubfeet over time, three clubfoot rating systems were utilized in the current study. Patients compliant with the Ponseti technique and treated before the age of 7 months, had a 92% success rate at an early follow-up after casting was completed. It is not the purpose of this article to analyze the long-term clubfoot treatment result but to establish tools which can be used to judge initial success with the Ponseti technique. Complications are few and minor, limited to equipment used and cast technique.     

Ponseti versus traditional methods of casting for idiopathic clubfoot

Serial casting is successful in avoiding extensive posteromedial release (PMR) in only 11% to 58% of patients with idiopathic congenital clubfoot. Extensive open surgery is commonly associated with long-term stiffness and weakness. Ponseti claims to avoid PMR in 89% of cases by using his specific technique of manipulation, casting, and limited surgery. The authors report their first 27 patients undergoing the Ponseti technique (34 feet) with a group of 27 matched control patients (34 feet). All patients underwent serial casting, begun within the first 3 months of life. The parameter studied was the need to perform PMR within the first year of life. In the Ponseti group, only 1 (3%) of 34 feet required PMR. In 31 (91%) of 34 feet, percutaneous Achilles tenotomy was performed at age 2 to 3 months. The average duration of casting was 2 months. In the control group, 32 (94%) of 34 feet required PMR within the first year of life, despite a longer casting period. Based on the authors' initial success with the Ponseti method, they no longer believe that PMR is required for most cases of idiopathic clubfoot. Foot abduction splints are crucial to avoid recurrence. Longer follow-up will determine whether the authors can continue to match Ponseti's reported outcomes.     

Therapie des Rezidivklumpfußes und residueller Deformitäten nach kongenitalem Klumpfuß

Relapse and residual deformity after treatment of congenital clubfoot are common problems. Recurrences occur in up to 48?% of cases after successful initial treatment using Ponseti’s technique. By casting and anterior tibial tendon transfer as recommended by Ponseti a flexible and well functioning foot can be achieved in most cases. Neglected clubfoot remains a demanding challenge. Depending on the severity of the deformity, the impairment of function and patient age, conservative and/or different operative treatment options can be considered. Manipulation and casting according to Ponseti is also recommended in toddlers with relapses even after peritalar joint release. Thus the need and extent of operative treatment can be reduced. Additional osteotomy may be indicated in more rigid feet and older children. An accurate evaluation of the existing deformity and functional impairment is mandatory for the individual choice of treatment. The number of previous operative procedures reduces the amount of improvement and mobility of the foot. Therefore, the best and most efficient treatment for recurrent clubfoot is prevention in the form of consistent primary treatment, consistently wearing braces and regular follow-up examinations.     

Treatment of clubfoot with the Ponseti method: a comparison of casting materials

BACKGROUND: Popular initial treatment for congenital clubfoot includes the use of serial manipulations and casting as described by Ponseti et al. Plaster of Paris and semirigid fiberglass are 2 materials commonly used for casting. To our knowledge, no study to date has compared the clinical results of these 2 materials. The objective of this randomized prospective study was to compare the effectiveness of these materials in the initial management of clubfoot. METHODS: All clubfeet presenting to the 2 senior authors' outpatient clinics over a 15-month period were offered enrollment. Patients were randomly assigned for treatment with either plaster or semirigid fiberglass casts. The severity of the clubfoot deformity was documented using the scoring system devised by Diméglio et al. Serial casts were applied according to the technique described by Ponseti et al. At the completion of nonsurgical treatment, the final clubfoot severity was documented. RESULTS: A total of 42 clubfeet in 34 patients were enrolled in the study. After exclusion of 3 patients, 13 patients (16 feet) received fiberglass, and 18 patients (23 feet) received plaster casts. The mean baseline severity scores of the 2 groups were not significantly different. The mean final severity score was significantly higher in the feet treated with fiberglass than those treated with plaster (6.4 vs 4.1; P = 0.037). There was a trend toward higher scores for cast tolerance, durability, and parent satisfaction in the fiberglass group, but this did not reach significance. CONCLUSIONS: This study supports the use of plaster casting with the Ponseti technique. The use of plaster casts resulted in a statistically lower Diméglio-Bensahel score at the completion of serial casting. There was a trend toward higher patient satisfaction in the fiberglass-treated group. Whether this difference has an effect on long-term outcomes and recurrence remains to be studied. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level II. Nonblinded randomized controlled prospective study.     

Percutaneous tendo-achilles lengthening with a large-gauge needle: A modification of the ponseti technique for correction of idiopathic clubfoot

The Ponseti technique has become standard for the treatment of congenital idiopathic clubfoot. Treatment includes serial manipulations and casting, accompanied by percutaneous tenotomy of the Achilles tendon. In this article, the authors describe a modification in the Achilles tenotomy technique by using a large-gauge hypodermic needle in the outpatient setting.     

Frühfunktionelle Behandlung des angeborenen Klumpfußes

The concept of conservative clubfoot treatment beginning in the neonatal period has changed considerably in the last 2 decades. The rate of clubfeet requiring surgery (20%) and the extent of surgical interventions have dropped significantly. The early functional Montpellier method has proved to be highly effective for all degrees of deformity. It is used for patients from birth until the age of 1 year. The treatment during the first 3 months of life is decisive and consists of daily physical therapy, use of a continuous passive motion machine, and taping. This method represents an efficient alternative to the popular treatment of serial casting. Nevertheless, conservative clubfoot treatment reaches its limits as the degree of deformity increases and it should be complemented by a selective minimally invasive surgical concept. The technique is described systematically and its current value is discussed.     

Early functional treatment of congenital clubfoot

The concept of conservative clubfoot treatment beginning in the neonatal period has changed considerably in the last 2 decades. The rate of clubfeet requiring surgery (20%) and the extent of surgical interventions have dropped significantly. The early functional Montpellier method has proved to be highly effective for all degrees of deformity. It is used for patients from birth until the age of 1 year. The treatment during the first 3 months of life is decisive and consists of daily physical therapy, use of a continuous passive motion machine, and taping. This method represents an efficient alternative to the popular treatment of serial casting. Nevertheless, conservative clubfoot treatment reaches its limits as the degree of deformity increases and it should be complemented by a selective minimally invasive surgical concept. The technique is described systematically and its current value is discussed.     

Results of Modified Ponseti Technique in Difficult Clubfoot and a review of literature

IntroductionSerial Ponseti casting achieves deformity correction in early presenting idiopathic clubfoot cases normally in around 7 casts. However, there are resistant patients where correction requires more casts than usual. In such patients a modification in standard technique might be required right from the beginning. Such patients were collectively called as difficult clubfoot. The aim of this study was to assess the outcome of our modification to Ponseti technique in difficult clubfoot.MethodsAll idiopathic clubfoot cases who were 75th percentile or more in WHO age for weight chart (chubby infants) or untreated clubfoot patients presenting for first time to our clinic at more than 5 months age (late presenters and neglected cases) were included in the study. Patients who had been previously surgically intervened elsewhere, patients over 7 years of age, patients with syndromic clubfoot or clubfoot associated with neurological conditions were excluded from the study. The patients were treated by early tenotomy of tendoachillis and a plantar fascia release before starting serial casting by Ponseti technique. Post correction, strict bracing protocol was followed with regular follow up. Pirani scoring was done at each stage. Measurement of Talocalcaneal angle on AP radiograph, maximum degree of abduction and dorsiflexion was noted once every year.ResultsThere were total 28 patients in our study. In all, 47 feet were subjected to modified Ponseti protocol. There were 21 male patients. Median age at presentation was 4 months. Mean centile of weight for age as per WHO growth chart was 64. Mean Pirani score at presentation was 5.86 (S.D. ± 0.34). Mean number of casts required for correction was 3.75 ± 1.10. Maximum followup period was 25 months.ConclusionThis modification of Ponseti casting for difficult clubfoot patients achieves correction in shorter duration with less number of casts.     

Management issues of congenital talipes equinovarus in the neonatal intensive care unit: A systematic review

BackgroundThe Ponseti method is the standard of care for managing idiopathic congenital talipes equinovarus (clubfoot) in the outpatient setting, but there are no clinical guidelines for inpatient treatment. Children in the neonatal intensive care unit (NICU) with clubfoot often delay treatment initiation due to medical reasons.MethodsWe systematically reviewed literature related to the treatment of clubfoot in the NICU, non-idiopathic clubfoot, and older infants, as well as barriers to care.ResultsIn a mixed NICU population of syndromic and idiopathic clubfoot, the Ponseti method has good functional outcomes with minimal interference with medical management. The Ponseti method has good functional outcomes with reduced need for extensive surgical procedures in non-idiopathic clubfoot and idiopathic clubfoot with delayed presentation (under one year of age).ConclusionsIt is possible to begin Ponseti treatment in the NICU without compromising medical management. It is not clear if this confers an advantage over waiting for outpatient casting.     

Clubfoot in children

Clubfoot, or talipes equinovarus, is a deformity consisting of equinus, varus, and adductus foot deformity. The true etiology of congenital clubfoot is unknown; several theories have been proposed. The pathology of the individual bones contributes to the clubfoot deformity and soft tissue contractures around the ankle and talocalcaneonavicular joint maintains the deformity and involve muscles, tendons, tendon sheaths, ligaments and joint capsules. Various treatment regimens have been proposed, including the use of corrective splinting, taping, and casting. Surgery in clubfoot is indicated for deformities that do not respond to conservative treatment by serial manipulation and casting. Surgery in the treatment of clubfoot must be tailored to the age of the child and to the deformity to be corrected. The main goals of treatment is the painless, functional and anatomical normal foot without need for custom made footwear, and those can be achieved after detailed, indivudial approach with great experience in pediatric orthopedics.     

Minimal-invasive Therapieverfahren angeborener Fußdeformitäten im Säuglingsalter

In the last decade treatment of foot deformities has changed from extensive surgery to casting and minimally invasive surgery. The Ponseti method has become the most preferred treatment for clubfoot deformities and early evaluations showed promising results. Mid-term results for idiopathic clubfoot revealed the need for additional surgery by anterior tibial tendon transfer in 11–32?% of cases depending on the duration of bracing. Anterior tibial tendon transfer is the most important surgical procedure for relapses in the Ponseti concept. Casting, recasting in cases of relapses, bracing and anterior tibial tendon transfer altogether represent the Ponseti method and cannot be considered as single entities. The Dobbs method is a new concept for the treatment of vertical talus. Treatment of vertical talus should start with the Dobbs method but in comparison to clubfoot treatment there has not been a complete change to minimally invasive treatment. Especially in non-idiopathic vertical talus cases open reduction of the talonavicular and calcaneocuboid joint are often necessary.     

Accelerated Ponseti method: First experiences in a more convenient technique for patients with severe idiopathic club feet

BackgroundCongenital Idiopathic Talipes Equinovarus (CTEV), or clubfoot, is a complex deformity that involves pathological anatomy in the foot with ankle equinus, hindfoot varus, midfoot cavus and forefoot adductus [1]. Universal agreement is established about Ponseti technique as the initial management for this deformity. This preliminary study aims to investigate the possibility of having a braceable foot through a proposed accelerated Ponseti method by which, manipulations, 5 castings and Achilles tendon tenotomy are implemented in a week.MethodsThis study included 11 patients with 16severe congenital idiopathic clubfeet treated by an accelerated Ponseti method. The method involves manipulation of the deformed foot, and 1st casting in one day, with the 2nd, 3rd, 4th, 5th castings in the 4th, 5th, 6th, 7th day post-manipulation. After the 4th cast removal, Achilles tenotomy was performed with subsequent three-week casting for all patients. Nonparametric tests were used for comparing the Pirani scores before starting the treatment and after removal of final cast.ResultsFive patients had bilateral club foot deformity. Average age at treatment was 54.8 days (range 8–150 days). All patients, who had severe congenital idiopathic club feet with a Pirani score of 6, underwent the accelerated Ponseti technique. After removal of the three-week cast, the scores median was 0.59, (range 0–1.5), indicating a correction of the deformity and having braceable feet in all patients without experiencing any short-term complication.ConclusionsThe first step accelerated Pnoseti technique was found to be safe and effective for initial correction of severe idiopathic clubfoot deformity in children below three months of age , though it is an initial study that needs more studies with more follow up data.     

Ponseti method in the treatment of post-operative relapsed idiopathic clubfoot after posteromedial release. A short term functional study

BackgroundRelapsed clubfeet deformity after surgical treatment by posteromedial release are frequently encountered in pediatric orthopedic practice and further revision surgery may be needed. As surgery adds more fibrosis and scaring, complication may be devastating and treatment is challenging. Ponseti method, the gold standard technique for treatment of clubfoot may be of a value in the management of postoperative relapses.Aim of the studyDetermine the effectiveness of Ponseti casting Method in treatment of relapsed idiopathic clubfoot in children after being treated with surgical posteromedial release.Materials and methodsProspective interventional study of 17 patients (25 feet) presented with a relapsed idiopathic clubfoot deformity after previous surgical posteromedial release. The patients were reviewed using Pirani and Dimeglio score. Ponseti method was done to obtain supple, flexible foot rather than a fully corrected foot, the residual deformity were treated by, heel cord lengthening or tenotomy, tibialis anterior transfer, follow up was for a minimum of 12 months.Result17 Patients (25 feet) their age ranging from 1 to 10 years were evaluated and treated. Casts were applied until the only deformities remaining were either hindfoot equinus and/or dynamic supination.22 feet required a heel cord procedure for equinus and 13 required tibialis anterior transfer for dynamic supination. The follow up (average 56.1 months) was for a minimum of one year. 4 feet had persistent heel varus deformity which required Calcaneal osteotomy later. Three feet didn’t need more casting and 2 feet were resistant cases that required further Ilizarov procedure, 4 needed lateral arch shortening and other 4 needed posterior capsulotomy. Improvement in the Pirani and Dimeglio scores was highly statistically significant.ConclusionPonseti method for treatment of relapsed clubfeet after a previous posteromedial soft tissue surgical release is an effective, non invasive, with excellent results.     

Ilizarov external fixation for management of severe relapsed clubfeet in older children

BackgroundAlthough the standard treatment of clubfoot deformity is conservative by serial casting techniques, relapses are not uncommon. Management of relapsed clubfoot deformity in older children is an orthopedic challenge. There is a growing interest in management of such complex deformities using the Ilizarov technique.MethodsIn this study, the Ilizarov frame was used to correct severe relapsed clubfoot deformities in older children, whom underwent previous surgical interventions. 42 relapsed clubfeet were included. The Dimeglio classification was used for clinical assessment of the relapsed feet pre-operatively as well as post-operatively.ResultsAfter an average follow-up period of 4.6 years, and according to the Beatson and Pearson numerical assessment, favorable results (excellent or good) were found in 37 feet, while poor results took place in only five feet.ConclusionBased on the final clinical and radiographic results, the Ilizarov technique could be considered as a good management alternative for such severe deformities.     

Stress radiography in the assessment of residual deformity in clubfoot following postero-medial soft tissue release

X-ray is important in the assessment of clubfoot. Stress radiographs give more information than routine radiographs. Because of the inaccuracy of the positioning and the disadvantages of radiation, paediatric orthopaedic surgeons do not like and do not use X-ray examination. In this study we report a technique we use to obtain stress radiographs in paediatric patients with clubfoot using a custom-made radiolucent modular splint. This technique provides better assessment of the initial status and the result of treatment. Although this method has limitations it can help to compare different feet and treatment results with regard to axis and angle. We validated this splint by means of a prospective study in 11 patients with 21 feet having type 2 clubfoot who underwent (PMSTR) in our centre. Two sets of radiographs were taken, one with manual positioning and one with our splint. We found significant differences in the values of midfoot and forefoot radiological parameters between the two sets. We found that the correlation between the clinical and radiological assessment of residual deformity improved significantly for these values when a splint was used to obtain stress views. Hence we recommend routine use of a radiolucent splint for taking stress views to assess residual deformity in clubfoot.     

The influence of brace type on the success rate of the Ponseti treatment protocol for idiopathic clubfoot

Purpose  

The success of the Ponseti method for treating idiopathic clubfoot deformity is dependent on the casting techniques and the adherence of the patient to the foot abduction brace protocol. Newly developed brace designs claim to be more comfortable, to be easier to use and to prevent dislodgement of the foot from the brace, making them more efficient and improving patient compliance. They are, however, more costly, and, therefore, accessible to fewer patients. We compared the compliance and treatment outcome using two brace designs, the traditional simple brace of pre-walking shoes attached to a Dennis Browne (DB) bar and the new sophisticated Mitchell brace.     

Wound complications from idiopathic clubfoot surgery: a comparison of the modified Turco and the Cincinnati treatment methods

PURPOSE: Treatment protocols using the Turco and the Cincinnati incisions are widely used for the surgical correction of clubfoot deformity. However, it is unclear which surgical approach leads to fewer wound problems. We therefore sought to determine which treatment method led to a lower incidence of wound complications. STUDY DESIGN: A retrospective chart review of 217 consecutive patients (308 feet) who underwent a primary posteromedial release for the treatment of idiopathic clubfoot under the age of 24 months via either the modified Turco or Cincinnati treatment methods was used to document the incidence of postoperative wound complications. The modified Turco protocol involved immediate postoperative casting in neutral, whereas the Cincinnati method involved staged casting with the foot initially in equinus, then to neutral with a cast change 7 days later. RESULTS: A significantly lower incidence of wound complications was seen in the Cincinnati treatment group when compared with the modified Turco treatment method (6.9% vs 19.6%, respectively, P < 0.003). When patients were stratified based on immediate versus staged postoperative casting methods, there was a significantly lower incidence of wound complications (P < 0.05) in feet in the Cincinnati treatment group versus the modified Turco treatment method; however, the statistical populations were markedly unequal. Among all feet treated with the Cincinnati method, patients who underwent a staged cast change had significantly fewer wound problems when compared with those who underwent immediate casting with the foot in neutral (5.1% vs 16.7%, respectively, P < 0.04). CONCLUSIONS: In the surgical correction of idiopathic clubfoot, the incidence of wound complications is significantly decreased with the use of the Cincinnati treatment method rather than the modified Turco treatment protocol. Whether this effect is a result of the incision or the postoperative casting protocol is unclear.