Indirect versus direct laryngoscopy for routine nasotracheal intubation

Study Objective

To compare the effectiveness of the indirect laryngoscopes, Airtraq (A) and GlideScope (G), with the Macintosh (M) laryngoscope in routine nasotracheal intubation.

Design

Randomized, single-blinded study.

Setting

University-affiliated, tertiary-care hospital.

Patients

62 adult, ASA physical status 1 and 2 patients with normal airways requiring nasotracheal intubation for dental or maxillofacial surgery.

Intervention

Patients in Groups A and G underwent nasal intubation with the Airtraq and GlideScope, respectively, while laryngoscopy in Group M was performed with the Macintosh blade.

Measurements

Performance of the intubating tools was judged by the ease [Intubation Difficulty Scale (IDS) and numeric rating scale (NRS)] and time to intubation (laryngoscopy and endotracheal tube advancement). In addition, hemodynamic parameters, severity of postoperative sore throat, and posture of the intubator were recorded.

Main Results

IDS score was significantly lower with the Airtraq and GlideScope than with the Macintosh laryngoscope (mean ± SD: A 0.1 ± 0.3, G 0.3 ± 0.6, M 0.8 ± 1.0; P = 0.013). NRS reported by the intubators showed a similar preference for indirect over direct laryngoscopy (A 0.9 ± 0.7, G 1.1 ± 0.6, M 1.9 ± 1.1; P = 0.001). Duration of laryngoscopy and endotracheal tube insertion was similar in all groups. No significant intergroup differences in hemodynamic parameters were recorded. Postoperative sore throat was significantly reduced using the GlideScope compared with the other devices (P = 0.048).

Conclusion

The Airtraq and GlideScope facilitated nasotracheal intubation more so than the Macintosh laryngoscope in adults with apparently normal airways.     

O papel do videolaringoscópio em programas de treinamento de intubação endotraqueal

Background

Macintosh laryngoscopes are widely used for endotracheal intubation training of medical students and paramedics whereas there are studies in the literature that supports videolaryngoscopes are superior in endotracheal intubation training. Our aim is to compare the endotracheal intubation time and success rates of videolaryngoscopes and Macintosh laryngoscopes during endotracheal intubation training and to determine the endotracheal intubation performance of the students when they have to use an endotracheal intubation device other than they have used during their education.

Effect of age on cervical spine injuries in children after motor vehicle collisions: effectiveness of restraint devices

Purpose

Despite the devastating consequences of cervical spine (C-spine) injury in children after motor vehicle collisions (MVC), the factors leading to the injury and the appropriateness of protective restraints remain undefined. The authors hypothesized that age-related anatomic factors contribute to inadequate restraints and therefore increase injury severity after MVC.

Methods

Data on children (<18 years, 1997 to 2002) admitted to a level 1 pediatric trauma center were prospectively collected and retrospectively reviewed. Those with C-spine injuries caused by MVC were extracted and divided into 2 groups: young (0 to 8 years) and old (9 to 18 years). Statistical comparison was by Student’s t test or Z-test, with P less than .05 accepted as significant.

Results

Of 5,117 trauma admissions, 94 had C-spine injuries with a mean age of 11 ± 5 years, 66% of which were boys. Among 1,124 patients who had sustained MVC there were 27 C-spine injuries (2.4% incidence), of which, 12 were less than 8 and 15 were older than 8 years. Restraint devices were utilized at least as frequently in younger children (young, 58% v. old, 43%; not significant). However, younger children had an increased incidence of permanent cord deficit (young, 57% v. old, 13%; P <.05) and closed head injury (young, 50% v. old, 7%; P <.05) even while wearing restraint devices, suggesting that restraint devices are inadequate or improperly used in younger patients. This is supported by the increased injury severity scores of the younger group (young, 37.7 ± 8.5 v. old, 16.5 ± 4.6; P <.05).

Conclusions

Younger children suffer more sever cervical spine injuries after motor vehicle collisions than their older counterparts, in part because of the inadequacy of currently existing restraint devices. Design modifications to current restraints, including the use of head straps, might improve outcome after MVC in younger patients.     

Evaluation of the new Viewmax laryngoscope in a simulated difficult airway

BACKGROUND: In this study, we evaluated the learning curve and performance of the Viewmax laryngoscope during simulated difficult laryngoscopy in an intubation manikin (Laerdal Airway Management Trainer). METHODS: To determine the learning curve, 25 anaesthesiologists without previous experience with the Viewmax laryngoscope performed 10 successive intubations in an intubation manikin with a normal airway. Time to intubation and failed intubation attempts were recorded. Another manikin was modified to enable comparison of the Viewmax laryngoscope with Macintosh and McCoy laryngoscopes. The time to intubation, number of failed intubation attempts, modified Cormack and Lehane (MCL) laryngeal view grading, percentage of glottic opening (POGO score), use of gum elastic bougie and subjective rating of degree of difficulty were recorded. RESULTS: The learning curve for the Viewmax laryngoscope showed a progressive decrease in time to successful intubation and reached a plateau at the sixth attempt. In simulated difficult laryngoscopy, the Viewmax laryngoscope demonstrated significantly better laryngeal view than the Macintosh and McCoy laryngoscopes in terms of MCL grading (Macintosh, P = 0.01; McCoy, P < 0.01) and POGO score (Macintosh, P < 0.01; McCoy, P < 0.01). The time required for intubation in simulated difficult laryngoscopy for the Viewmax laryngoscope was significantly longer than that for the Macintosh (P = 0.02) and McCoy (P < 0.01) laryngoscopes. There was no significant difference in the degree of difficulty, number of failed intubations and use of gum elastic bougie. CONCLUSION: When compared with the Macintosh and McCoy laryngoscopes in a manikin, the Viewmax laryngoscope appears to improve the view of the larynx but requires a longer time for tracheal intubation.     

Laryngoscope plastic blades in scheduled general anesthesia patients: a comparative randomized study

Study Objective

To compare two brands of disposable plastic laryngoscope blades, Vital View plastic blades and Heine XP plastic blades, with the reusable Heine Classic+ Macintosh metal blades.

Design

Prospective randomized, controlled, single-blinded study.

Setting

Operating room of a university-affiliated hospital.

Patients

519 patients without criteria for predicted difficult intubation, undergoing scheduled surgery during general anesthesia.

Interventions

Patients were randomized to three groups according to laryngoscope blade brand.

Measurements

Difficult tracheal intubation was evaluated by the Intubation Difficulty Scale (IDS) (IDS > 5 = procedure involving moderate to major difficulty).

Main Results

The percentage of intubations with an IDS > 5 was 3.1% in Group M (metal blade group), 5.1% in Group V (Vital View plastic blade group), and 10.0% in Group H (Heine plastic blade group). A significant difference was noted between Groups M and H (P = 0.02) but not between Groups M and V.

Conclusions

Intubation may be more challenging when using Heine XP plastic blades but no significant difference exists between Vital-View plastic blades and Heine Classic+ metal blades.     

Sequential taxane and anthracycline-containing neoadjuvant regimens: The sequential order impact

Background

One can consider as a standard neoadjuvant treatment for breast cancer, the sequence of 4 cycles of anthracycline-based chemotherapy followed by 4 cycles of docetaxel. Based on the belief that the sequence order between anthracycline and taxane might be of interest, this study assessed the impact of the sequence order.

Methods

One hundred and twenty three patients with breast cancer were treated with neoadjuvant chemotherapy in 5 oncologic centers between 2003 and 2007. This study compared 65 patients treated with 4 cycles of docetaxel followed by 4 cycles of anthracycline-based chemotherapy (cohort T), versus another cohort of 58 patients treated with 4 cycles of anthracycline-based chemotherapy followed by 4 cycles of docetaxel (cohort A).

Results

The overall dose intensity of docetaxel and clinical complete responses were significantly higher in cohort T. No statistically significant differences were observed in terms of conservative surgeries or histological responses. The sequence of chemotherapy did not significantly influence other treatment-related toxicities. Mild neurotoxicity was higher in patients treated in cohort T. Anemias (≥Grade 1) were higher in cohort A (52% versus 81%; p = 0.0008).

Conclusion

The present study failed to identify an impact of the sequence of taxane administration on the efficacy. Nevertheless, starting neoadjuvant chemotherapy by taxane reduces the occurrence of anemia. These findings might allow a selection of the sequence order based on the toxicity profile.     

Prompt correction of endotracheal tube positioning after intubation prevents further inappropriate positions

Study Objective

To determine whether the timely correction of endotracheal tube (ETT) positioning prevents further inappropriate positions.

Design

Prospective crossover study.

Setting

University-affiliated hospital.

Patients

44 adult, ASA physical status 1, 2, and 3 patients undergoing open or laparoscopic abdominal procedures.

Interventions

ETT positioning was verified by both auscultation and fiberoptic bronchoscopy (FOB), after intubation, and before extubation. In laparoscopic procedures, two additional measurements were performed: after maximal abdominal gas insufflation and with head-down position. An ETT in the bronchus or at the carina was considered an inappropriate placement. An ETT ≤ one cm from the carina was considered a critical placement.

Measurements

The frequency of inappropriate and critical ETT positioning with both auscultation and FOB and the number of ETTs that remained in an incorrect position despite repositioning.

Main Results

FOB detected 5 inappropriately positioned ETTs, 4 of which were also detected by chest auscultation (P = 0.99). Critical positioning was detected by FOB in 6 patients, three of which were also detected by auscultation (P = 0.24). There were 15 other "out-of-desired range” positions (out of the 3-5 cm range) - one placed too high and 14 placed too low, while 18 were placed within the range of positions. All patients with inappropriate ETT positioning were women (P = 0.005). Age, body mass index, Mallampati grade > 3, thyromental distance < 6 cm, or laryngoscopy grade ≥ 2 were not associated with either inappropriate or critical placement. No episodes of inappropriate or critical positioning were detected by FOB or auscultation at the end of surgery.

Conclusions

Early detection and prompt correction of inappropriate ETT positioning after intubation prevented further ETT migration into undesired positions.     

Comparação do C‐MAC convencional e C‐MAC D‐blade com laringoscópios diretos em simulação de lesão da coluna cervical–estudo em modelo

Background

CMAC videolaryngoscope has recently been introduced for videoscope guided intubation. The aim of our study was to compare and evaluate the efficacy of the conventional blade and the angulated D blade of the CMAC videolaryngoscope with the direct laryngoscopes in simulated cervical spine injury patients on the airway manikin.

Materials and methods

Following power analysis, 33 resident doctors were enrolled to perform endotracheal intubation using all the 4 different laryngoscopes namely the Macintosh laryngoscope, McCoy laryngoscope, conventional CMAC videolaryngoscope and the D blade of the CMAC videolaryngoscopes on the airway manikin in simulated cervical spine injury. The demographic variables of the resident doctors were recorded. The outcomes measured included vocal cord visualization (Cormack–Lehane grading), time taken to intubate, number of attempts for successful intubation and optimizing maneuvers required.

Results

The use of indirect videolaryngoscopes resulted in better glottic visualization in comparison to the direct laryngoscopes (CL‐I) in 20/33 (60.6%) in the Macintosh group, 24/33 (72.7%) in McCoy group, 30/33 in (90.9%) in Vlc group and 32/33 (96.9%) in Vld group. The time taken to intubate averaged to 15.54 ± 2.6 in Macintosh group, 18.90 ± 4.47 in McCoy group, 20.21 ± 7.9 in Vlc group and 27.42 ± 9.09 in Vld group. The 1st attempt intubation success rate was 84.8% (Macintosh), 72.7% (McCoy), 90.9% (Vlc) and, 78.7% (Vld).

Conclusions

The overall performance of the conventional CMAC blade proved to be the best when compared with the D‐blade CMAC, Macintosh blade and the McCoy blade for intubation in simulated cervical spine patients by anesthesia residents.     

Oncologic outcomes after resection of rectal cancer: Laparoscopic versus open approach

Background

This study examined outcomes of laparoscopic and open rectal cancer surgery in a community hospital setting.

Methods

A community health care system cancer registry was reviewed retrospectively (2004-2007) for rectal cancer patients undergoing surgical treatment. Primary end points were rates of recurrence and survival.

Results

Both open and laparoscopic resection groups had similar demographic, treatment, and tumor characteristics. Most patients in the open resection and laparoscopic resection populations experienced no recurrence (79% vs 83%, respectively; P = .5). Overall, the groups had similar mean (88% vs 96%, respectively; P = .4) and disease-free (21 and 23 months, respectively; P = .5) survival.

Conclusions

In a community hospital setting, laparoscopic resection of rectal cancer was found to be as safe and effective as open resection in selected patients.     

George Peters Award: How does breast-specific gamma imaging affect the management of patients with newly diagnosed breast cancer?

Background

We sought to determine the number of patients with known breast cancer who were found to have an additional, mammographically occult lesion detected on breast-specific gamma imaging (BSGI).

Methods

An institutional review board-approved review of all patients who underwent BSGI at Beth Israel Medical Center from 2006 to 2008 was performed.

Results

A total of 82 patients underwent BSGI for newly diagnosed breast cancer. Of these, 18 had an additional abnormality, and 17 were biopsied. There were 4 cases of invasive ductal carcinoma, 1 invasive lobular carcinoma, 1 ductal carcinoma in situ, 1 lobular carcinoma in situ, 2 papillomas, and 8 benign biopsies. One patient proceeded directly to mastectomy and an area of ductal carcinoma in situ was found, corresponding to the BSGI.

Conclusions

In our study group, 22% of patients had a surgical change in management based on BSGI findings. BSGI detected additional carcinoma in 9%. BSGI plays an important role in the clinical management of patients with known breast cancer.     

Primary closure of persistent tracheocutaneous fistula in pediatric patients

Objective

The aim of the study is to review the safety and efficacy of partial fistulectomy with 3-layered primary closure without postoperative intubation for persistent tracheocutaneous fistula (TCF).

Design

This is a retrospective study.

Setting

The study was conducted in a tertiary care pediatric hospital.

Patients

Records of 49 children treated for persistent TCF between 1996 and 2005 were reviewed. Patients were studied if the TCF was closed using a 3-layered primary closure, and they had at least 1 year of follow-up. Thirty-nine patients met inclusion criteria.

Results

All patients were extubated immediately after surgery. Drains were removed, and all patients were discharged on the first postoperative day. The most common indications for tracheostomy were prolonged intubation and subglottic stenosis. There were 2 major and 3 minor complications. One major complication involved subcutaneous emphysema that developed on the seventh postoperative day because of cough. The other involved a poorly controlled diabetic patient who developed a postoperative infection with dehiscence. All fistulas remained closed at follow-up.

Conclusion

Partial excision and primary closure of persistent TCF is safe and effective. Drain placement and overnight observation are imperative. Careful patient selection is important. Routine postoperative intubation is not necessary.     

Survival in oral cavity minor salivary gland carcinoma

Objective

To describe the epidemiology and comparative survival for minor salivary gland cancer of the oral cavity.

Study Design

Historical cohort study.

Setting

Academic medical center.

Subjects and Methods

Cases of minor salivary gland cancer of the oral cavity were extracted from the Surveillance, Epidemiology, and End Results database (1988-2005) and staged. Kaplan-Meier survivals were compared according to histology as well as T stage and N stage. A Cox proportional hazards model incorporating histology, T stage, N stage, age, and sex was analyzed.

Results

A total of 639 salivary gland cancers of the oral cavity (55% female; mean age, 56 years) were identified with complete staging information, consisting of 318 mucoepidermoid, 169 adenoid cystic, 139 adenocarcinoma, and 14 acinic cell cancers. The hard palate and gums were the most common subsites involved (87.6%), followed by lip (7.2%) and tongue (5.2%). At presentation, T1 and T4 tumors predominated (42.6% and 35.2%, respectively); 93.4 percent were N0. Overall mean survival (months) was 157.9 and was similar across histologic subtypes: mucoepidermoid (172.4), adenoid cystic (141.4), acinic cell (138.7), and adenocarcinoma (147.2). Survival for low- and intermediate-grade mucoepidermoid carcinoma (171.0 and 182.3, respectively) was better than survival for high-grade mucoepidermoid carcinoma (50.3, P < 0.001). On multivariate analysis, N stage (P < 0.001) was the most powerful predictor of survival, along with T stage (P = 0.013), age (P < 0.001), and sex (P < 0.001).

Conclusion

T stage and N stage are the most powerful predictors of survival in minor salivary gland carcinoma of the oral cavity. With the exception of high-grade mucoepidermoid carcinoma, survival for these lesions is generally favorable.     

Trends in the prevalence of Helicobacter pylori in symptomatic children in the era of eradication

Purpose

Helicobacter pylori infection is common in Asia and is associated with dyspepsia, peptic ulcer, and gastric cancer. Eradication of the organism remains an important goal. Here, we looked at the trends in the prevalence of H pylori in symptomatic children over an 8-year period to assess the impact of an aggressive eradication program.

Method

A retrospective review was carried out between 1997 and 2004. All children with a history of dyspepsia or acute gastrointestinal bleeding were included and underwent gastroscopy. Three antral biopsies were taken during endoscopy and sent for histological analysis. Positivity of H pylori was treated aggressively with quadruple therapy under protocol. The demographic data, the histological findings, and the H pylori status were recorded.

Results

There were a total of 159 patients (71 males, 88 females) who underwent gastroscopy in this period. One hundred nineteen patients showed histological evidence of gastritis, and the positive rate of H pylori was 25.6%. The overall prevalence has not decreased (33.3% in 1997, 27.7% in 2004). Increasing age, however, was associated significantly with the higher risk of H pylori infection.

Conclusion

H pylori has a high prevalence in Chinese children with increasing age. Eradication efforts seem to be unsuccessful in the reduction of prevalence. We hypothesize that this may be owing to cross-infection at meal times from sharing chopsticks.     

Spot urine 5-hydroxyindoleacetic acid levels in the early diagnosis of acute appendicitis

Background/Purpose

The significance of spot urine 5-hydroxyindoleacetic acid (5-HIAA) levels in the early diagnosis of acute appendicitis (AA) is questioned.

Methods

Forty young, pigmented, male rabbits were divided into 4 groups. Groups are summarized as follows: group 1, control (n = 10); group 2, laparotomy, sham (n = 10); group 3, peritonitis with cecal ligation and puncture (n = 10); and group 4, experimental appendicitis (n = 10). Spot urine samples were obtained for 5-HIAA determination, and appendectomy materials were examined histopathologically and peritoneal fluid cultures were obtained after 12 hours in the study groups. The results were analyzed statistically with 1-way analysis of variance and Scheffé and Tukey's HSD tests.

Results

The mean 5-HIAA levels in the control group was 5.7 ± 0.6 mg/L, whereas it is 5.9 ± 0.9 mg/L, 6.6 ± 0.6 mg/L, 9.4 ± 0.9 mg/L in the sham, peritonitis, and appendicitis groups, respectively. The levels of 5-HIAA in the appendicitis group were higher than those in the other groups, which was statistically significant (P < .001).

Conclusions

Spot urine 5-HIAA determination may be a practical, objective, and noninvasive method in the early diagnosis of AA. Because other radiological and laboratory tests can be insufficient, especially in the early period of AA, this test may be used effectively instead. Clinical studies are necessary for further conclusions.     

GreenLight HPS 120-W laser vaporization versus transurethral resection of the prostate for the treatment of lower urinary tract symptoms due to benign prostatic hyperplasia: a randomized clinical trial with 2-year follow-up

Background

High-level evidence to support the use of photoselective vaporization of the prostate (PVP) is limited.

Objective

Assess the efficacy and safety of GreenLight HPS 120-W laser PVP compared with transurethral resection of the prostate (TURP).

Design, setting, and participants

A randomized clinical trial was performed with 50 patients having lower urinary tract symptoms due to benign prostatic hyperplasia in each treatment arm.

Intervention

Random allocation to PVP or TURP.

Measurements

International Prostate Symptom Score (IPSS), quality of life (QoL), and changes in maximum flow rate (Q_max) were the main end points. Patients were evaluated at a follow-up time of 2 yr. Five patients were lost to follow-up. A last observation carried forward analysis was done.

Results and limitations

Both laser PVP and TURP resulted in the same IPPS reduction at 2 yr (−15.7 and −14.9, respectively; p = 0.48) and in the same gain in Q_max (+14.5 ml/s and +13.1 ml/s, respectively; p = 0.65). QoL was equivalent for both treatment modalities. These results were independent of prostate size, American Society of Anesthesiologists risk category, and prior indwelling catheter. No statistically significant differences were detected between arms in terms of complication rates. In the laser PVP group, three patients were readmitted to the hospital and two developed a urethral stricture. In the TURP group, two patients were readmitted, six developed a urethral stricture, and two developed bladder neck sclerosis. In-hospital stay and time to catheter removal were significantly shorter with PVP. Limitations are the potential lack of power to detect differences in the complications between groups and the lack of blindness due to the nature of the intervention.

Conclusions

GreenLight HPS 120-W laser PVP is as effective as TURP for symptom reduction and improvement of QoL. No differences were seen in the response of storage and voiding symptoms. Laser PVP and TURP have the same complication rate. Length of stay is shorter for laser PVP group.     

The optimal effect-site concentration of remifentanil for lightwand tracheal intubation during propofol induction without muscle relaxation

Study Objective

To determine the most suitable effect-site concentration of remifentanil during lightwand intubation when administered with a target-controlled infusion (TCI) of propofol at 4.0 μg/mL without neuromuscular blockade.

Design

Prospective study using a modified Dixon's up-and-down method.

Setting

Operating room of an academic hospital.

Patients

28 ASA physical status 1 and 2 patients, aged 18-65 years, scheduled for minor elective surgery.

Interventions

Anesthesia was induced by TCI propofol effect-site concentration to 4.0 μg/mL, and the dose of remifentanil given to each patient was determined by the response of the previously tested patient using 0.2 ng/mL as a step size. The first patient was tested at a target effect-site concentration of 4.0 ng/mL of remifentanil. If intubation was successful, the remifentanil dose was decreased by 0.2 ng/mL; if it failed, the remifentanil dose was increased by 0.2 ng/mL. Successful intubation was defined as excellent or good intubating conditions.

Measurements and Main Results

The remifentanil effect-site concentration was measured. The optimal effect-site concentration of remifentanil for lightwand tracheal intubation during propofol induction using 2% propofol target effect-site concentration to 4 μg/mL was 2.16 ± 0.19 ng/mL. From probit analysis, the effect-site concentration of remifentanil required for successful lightwand intubation in 50% (EC50) and 95% (EC95) of adults was 2.11 ng/mL (95% CI 1.16-2.37 ng/mL) and 2.44 ng/mL (95% CI 2.20-3.79 ng/mL), respectively.

Conclusion

A remifentanil effect-site concentration of 2.16 ± 0.19 ng/mL given before a propofol effect-site concentration of 4 μg/mL allowed lightwand intubation without muscle relaxant.     

Canadian C-spine Rule and the National Emergency X-Radiography Utilization Low-Risk Criteria for C-spine radiography in young trauma patients

Purpose

The Canadian C-spine (cervical spine) Rule (CCR) and the National Emergency X-Radiography Utilization Low-Risk Criteria (NLC) are criteria designed to guide C-spine radiography in trauma patients. It is unclear how these 2 rules compare with young children.

Methods

This study retrospectively examined case-matched trauma patients 10 years or younger. Two cohorts were identified—cohort A where C-spine imaging was performed and cohort B where no imaging was conducted. The CCR and NLC criteria were then applied retrospectively to each cohort.

Results

Cohort A contained 125 cases and cohort B with 250 cases. Seven patients (3%) had significant C-spine injuries. In cohort A, NLC criteria could be applied in 108 (86.4%) of 125 and CCR in 109 (87.2%) of 125. National Emergency X-Radiography Utilization Low-Risk Criteria suggested that 70 (58.3%) cases required C-spine imaging compared to 93 (76.2%) by CCR. National Emergency X-Radiography Utilization Low-Risk Criteria missed 3 C-spine injuries, and CCR missed one. In cohort B, NLC criteria could be applied in 132 (88%) of 150 and CCR in 131 (87.3%) of 150. The NLC criteria identified 8 cases and CCR identified 13 cases that would need C-spine radiographs. Fisher's 2-sided Exact test demonstrated that CCR and NLC predictions were significantly different (P = .002) in both cohorts. The sensitivity of CCR was 86% and specificity was 94%, and the NLC had a sensitivity of 43% and a specificity of 96%.

Conclusions

Although CCR and NLC criteria may reduce the need for C-spine imaging in children 10 years and younger; they are not sensitive or specific enough to be used as currently designed.     

Comparaison de l’Airtraq™ et du laryngoscope Macintosh pour l’intubation trachéale chez l’adulte avec stabilisation manuelle en ligne du rachis cervical

Introduction

Airtraq laryngoscope is a new and single use device for endotracheal intubation. Few studies showed the superiority of the Airtraq comparing to Macintosh laryngoscope in the setting of difficult intubation.

Study design

To compare the performance of these two laryngoscopes by simulating a situation of reduced mobility of the cervical spine by applying the Manual in-line stablization (MILS) maneuver.

Patients and methods

After obtaining the approval of the ethic committee, we realized a prospective single blind randomized study. During a 6-month period, 120 consenting patients scheduled for ORL or ophthalmologic surgery were included. They all had general anesthesia and orotracheal intubation. These patients were randomly and equally divided in two groups (n = 60), depending on the type of the laryngoscope used (Airtraq or Macintosh). Were excluded from the study the patients with history or criteria predicting difficult intubation. Each patient was intubated by one of the five experimented anesthetists selected for this work. The principle judgment criteria were: i) the time taken for the orotracheal intubation and ii) the intubation difficulty score (IDS). The secondary judgment criterion was the hemodynamic modifications after the endotracheal intubation.

Results

Demographic and upper airway track variables were comparable between the two groups. There was no case of failure of intubation in this serie. Nonetheless, all the patients of the Airtaq group were intubated from the first attempt, whereas half of the patients of the Macintosh group were intubated after the third attempt. Comparing to the Macintosh, the Airtraq reduces the time taken for the orotracheal intubation (14 ± 1 s vs 19 ± 3 s, P = 0.01), the necessity of additional maneuver to facilitate the intubation, and the intubation difficulty score (0.7 ± 0.3 vs 3.8 ± 1, P < 0.001). Orotracheal intubation using the Airtraq laryngoscope caused less hemodynamic stimulation than using the Macintosh.

Conclusion

Our study showed the usefulness of the Airtraq laryngoscope for endotracheal intubation for patients presenting conditions of difficult intubation such as reduced mobility of the cervical spine.