Patterns of autoreactivity to collagen type II in autoimmune MRL/l mice.

The kinetics and mechanisms for secretion of antibodies against native and denatured collagen type II have been studied in spontaneously arthritic MRL/l mice. Circulating antibodies were quantified by an ELISA assay and frequencies of specific antibody secreting spleen cells by an ELISPOT assay. The degree of humoral immunity to collagen type II increased at late stages of the disease (6 months of age) whereas severe synovitis was seen earlier (5 months of age). Both the appearance of anti-collagen II producing cells and development of synovitis was preceded by and not correlated with a general state of polyclonal B cell activation. In MRL/l mice, collagen II specific antibodies appeared spontaneously and titres were largely unaffected by collagen II immunization. The levels of circulating anti-collagen II antibodies in MRL/l mice were lower, and the antibodies displayed lower avidities and different specificities as compared with the antibodies generated in collagen II high responder DBA/l mice after immunization with collagen II. It is suggested that the antibody response in MRL/l mice against collagen type II does not need MHC-restricted T cell help and that induction of antibody production to collagen II in MRL/l mice is triggered by joint cartilage destruction and subsequent collagen II release.     

CD8 T cell autoreactivity to preproinsulin epitopes with very low human leucocyte antigen class I binding affinity

Beta cells presenting islet epitopes are recognized and destroyed by autoreactive CD8 T cells in type 1 diabetes. These islet-specific T cells are believed to react with epitopes binding with high affinity to human leucocyte antigen (HLA) expressed on beta cells. However, this assumption might be flawed in case of islet autoimmunity. We evaluated T cell recognition of the complete array of preproinsulin (PPI) peptides with regard to HLA binding affinity and T cell recognition. In a comprehensive approach, 203 overlapping 9-10mer PPI peptides were tested for HLA-A2 binding and subjected to binding algorithms. Subsequently, a high-throughput assay was employed to detect PPI-specific T cells in patient blood, in which conditional HLA ligands were destabilized by ultraviolet irradiation and HLA molecules refolded with arrays of PPI peptides, followed by quantum-dot labelling and T cell staining. Analysis of patient blood revealed high frequencies of CD8 T cells recognizing very low HLA binding peptides. Of 28 peptides binding to HLA-A2, a majority was predicted not to bind. Unpredicted peptides bound mainly with low affinities. HLA binding affinity and immunogenicity may not correlate in autoimmunity. Algorithms used to predict high-affinity HLA peptide binders discount the majority of low-affinity HLA binding epitopes. Appreciation that peptides binding HLA with very low affinity can act as targets of autoreactive T cells may help to understand loss of tolerance and disease pathogenesis and possibly point to tissue-specific immune intervention targets.     

Specificity of an HLA-DRB1*0401-restricted T cell response to type II collagen

A panel of HLA-DRB1*0401-restricted CD4⁺ mouse T cell hybridomas specific for bovine type II collagen were generated from transgenic mice expressing the human HLA-DRA1*0101/-DRB1*0401 and CD4 molecules. The vast majority recognized a single peptide determinant corresponding to residues 261–273 (CII 261–273). This determinant was rapidly defined by the use of a predictive algorithm for peptide binding to DRB1*0401. CII 261–273 is conserved in bovine and human type II collagen and overlaps with an important I-A^q-restricted T cell determinant in mice with collagen-induced arthritis. This study demonstrates how HLA-DR and human CD4-transgenic mice can be used to identify a T cell epitope in a potential or candidate autoantigen.     

Identification of conformation-dependent epitopes and V gene selection in the B cell response to type II collagen in the DA rat.

Collagen-induced arthritis (CIA) is a widely used model for rheumatoid arthritis. Induction of CIA in rats using rat type II collagen (CII) results in a chronic arthritis in which anti-CII antibodies are believed to play a pathogenic role. In this study, we analyzed the epitope selection and V gene usage in the anti-CII response in the DA rat. A panel of CII-reactive B cell hybridomas was established from the draining lymph nodes 11 days after immunization. All of the CII-specific antibodies bound cartilage in vivo, showing that these are true autoantibodies. These antibodies were all IgG and specific for several distinct triple helical epitopes on CII. Interestingly, the major epitope, recognized by four different antibodies, was identical with the major B cell epitope in the mouse CII located at position 359--369 (denoted as C1(III)). The Q52 and PC7183 V(H) gene families encoded 12 out of 14 sequenced heavy chains. There was a relatively more heterogeneous usage of V(L) genes as the antibodies were encoded by four different V(kappa) families (V(kappa)1, V(kappa)2, V(kappa)12/13 and V(kappa)RF). As in the mouse, some of the V genes used showed germline characteristics. We conclude that the immune response in the rat shares epitope specificity and a constrained V gene repertoire with the mouse. However, the V genes used for recognition of the closely related collagen structures differed considerably between mouse and rat, indicating an influence of the species-specific variation in the V gene repertoire.     

T cell lines generated with type II collagen proliferate in an autologous mixed lymphocyte response.

Collagen-induced arthritis (CIA) is a T cell-dependent disease induced in susceptible rodents by immunizing with bovine type II collagen (bCII). In order to study T cell responses, a programme to generate bCII-specific T cell lines from arthritic rats was initiated. Lymph node cells from bCII-immune WA/KIR/kcl rats were cultured with bCII in vitro, and the T cells were isolated and restimulated with bCII-pulsed antigen presenting cells (APC) (thymus cells or splenic low density cells). However, T cells, generated initially to bCII, subsequently proliferated upon co-culture with syngeneic APC even in the absence of bCII. This suggests that exposure to bCII resulted in the activation of a population of self-reactive T cells which proliferate in an autologous mixed lymphocyte response. In contrast, short-term T cell lines generated to ovalbumin, heat-denatured bCII and the collagen peptide bCII(184-198) proliferated in response to specific antigen-pulsed APC without demonstrating self-reactivity. Since denatured bCII and bCII(184-198) peptide are not arthritogenic and failed to generate self reactivity in vitro, this suggests that the native triple helical conformation of bCII is required for stimulating autoreactive T cell responses.     

T cell regulation of collagen-induced arthritis in mice. II. Immunomodulation of arthritis by cytotoxic T cell hybridomas specific for type II collagen

Injection of native type II collagen (CII) to susceptible strains of mice (H-2^q) induces a rheumatoid arthritis-like disease. To study the role of CD8⁺ T cells in the collagen-induced arthritis (CIA),we generated CII-specific T cell hybridomas by fusion of cells from arthritic C3H.Q mice and an AKR thymoma. Two hybrid clones (P3G8 and P2D9) were selected for their ability to lyse syngeneic CH-pulsed macrophages and recognize different antigenic epitopes in association with K^q molecules. When these T cell clones were irradiated and inoculated into (C3H.Q × AKR)F₁ mice 21 days prior to priming with native CII/ complete Freund's adjuvant, the incidence and the duration of CIA were significantly reduced in comparison to groups receiving saline or control T cell hybridoma. Furthermore, both anti-CII T cell hybridomas were able to attenuate CIA in highly susceptible inbred strains of mice and this suppression was antigen and disease specific. The protective activity seems to require intact cells as neither membrane fractions nor cytosolic preparations of the hybridoma T cells retained the vaccinating activity. Most importantly, one of the hybrid clones (P3G8) had a therapeutic effect on CIA since its administration to arthritic DBA/1 mice on day 30 after priming down-regulated the ongoing disease. Taken together, these findings suggest that anti-CII cytotoxic T cell clones can vaccinate against CIA and even reverse the disease.     

Universally immunogenic T cell epitopes: promiscuous binding to human MHC class II and promiscuous recognition by T cells

To understand the effect of human MHC class II polymorphism on antigen recognition, we analyzed the memory T cell response to three tetanus toxin epitopes defined by three short synthetic peptides (p2, p4 and p30). We found that p2 and p30 are universally immunogenic, since they are recognized by all primed donors, irrespective of their MHC haplotypes. The analysis of specific clones indicates that both peptides are very promiscuous in their capacity to bind to class II. p30 can be recognized in association with DRw11(5), 7, 9 and with DPw2 and DPw4, while p2 can be recognized in association with DR1, DRw15(2), DRw18 (3), DR4Dw4, DRw11(5), DRw13(w6), DR7, DRw8, DR9, DRw52a and DRw52b. On the contrary, the third peptide, p4, can be recognized by only half of the donors in association with only DRw52a and DRw52c. Analysis of truncated peptides shows that p30 contains three distinct epitopes, each recognized in association with different class II molecules. Therefore, the restriction specificity is already set at the level of the peptide-MHC complex and, in all cases, T cells discriminate p30 bound to different class II molecules. On the contrary, p2 contains only one epitope, which is recognized in association with all DR molecules. In this case we found two different restriction patterns. Some clones are monogamous, since they recognize the peptide in association with one DR allele, while others are promiscuous, since they recognize by peptide in association with several different DR molecules. Thus, in this case, the restriction specificity is also set at the level of the T cell receptor. We suggest that both the promiscuous binding of peptides and the promiscuous recognition by T cells are dependent on the particular structure of the DR molecules, having a monomorphic alpha chain associated with a polymorphic beta chain.     

T cell epitopes of type II collagen in HLA-DRB1*0101 or DRB1*0405-positive Japanese patients with rheumatoid arthritis

Rheumatoid arthritis (RA) is a T cell-mediated autoimmune disease, but target antigens (autoantigens) responsible for T cell activation remain unclear. Type II collagen (CII) is a candidate autoantigen that is largely confined to the articular cartilage. To investigate whether CII is an important antigen in patients with RA, we examined peripheral blood T cell reactivity to CII in HLA-DRB1*0101 and DRB1*0405-positive RA patients. Reactivities to candidate T cell epitopes of CII were also examined. Peripheral blood T cell reactivity to CII and CII peptides (256-271, 429-442, 593-610, 1064-1081) were detected by measurement of IL-2, IFN-gamma, and IL-4 in culture supernatant of PBMC after in vitro antigen stimulation. Cytokine concentration was measured by ELISA. In DRB1*0101-positive patients, T cell reactivity to CII as detected by measurement of IL-2 production in culture supernatant, was present in 4 out of 9 patients. IL-2 production upon stimulation with CII 256-271 peptide was found in all of these 4 patients. In DRB1*0405-positive patients, high frequency of positive T cell response to CII was detected in 9 out of 11 patients. IFN-gamma production was also detected in 4 out of 6 patients producing IL-2 by stimulation with CII. T cell response to CII 256-271 and/or CII 1064-1081 was detected in these patients. In DRB1*0101-positive RA patients, CII 256-271 peptide might function as a T cell epitope, whereas either CII 256-271 or CII 1064-1081 peptide may be a major T cell epitope in DRB1*0405-positive RA patients. In DRB1*0405-positive RA patients, CII reactive T cells might play a crucial role in the development of RA through IFN-gamma production.     

T cell response to myelin basic protein epitopes in multiple sclerosis patients and healthy subjects.

T cell lines and clones specific for human myelin basic protein (BP) were selected from three multiple sclerosis (MS) patients and two healthy subjects and tested for their proliferative responses to a battery of synthetic peptides, 9 to 21 amino acid residues long. The combined amino acid sequence of the peptides spanned the complete sequence of the human BP. The results suggest the development of T cells sensitized to at least four independent regions of the human BP, indicating some diversity of the human T cell repertoire to BP. However, an immunodominant T cell epitope was located in the C-terminal region, defined by residues 149-162. This epitope was recognized by T cells from three subjects out of five (one MS patient and both healthy controls) in the context of different DR specificities. Another epitope (located in the 57-75 region) which triggered one MS patient's T cell response was also recognized by a mycobacteria-specific T cell clone cross-reacting with BP.     

The immune response of guinea-pigs to type II collagen: poor cross-reactivity with homologous type II collagen accounts for resistance to collagen-induced arthritis.

In order to determine the susceptibility of guinea-pigs to collagen-induced arthritis (CIA), Hartley and Strain 13 guinea-pigs were immunized with heterologous or homologous type II collagen. None of the animals developed CIA. Because immunity to type II collagen plays a critical role in CIA, we characterized the guinea-pig's immune response to determine the basis for this resistance. Guinea-pigs develop cellular and humoral reactivity to heterologous type II collagen similar to that of CIA-susceptible rats. The reactions distinguish type I from type II collagen but not among several heterologous type II collagens. The cell-mediated immune (CMI) response was specific for determinants on the primary amino acid structure of collagen, whether native or denatured collagen was used for immunization; however, the humoral response was specific for the form of the molecule used for immunization. Guinea-pigs differ from CIA-susceptible rats in that immunization with homologous or heterologous type II collagen fails to induce significant cross-reactive immunity with the homologous antigen. A transient arthritis could be induced in animals immunized with heterologous type II collagen by injecting them intra-articularly with heterologous but not with homologous type II collagen. Our results show that the disparity between immunity to type II collagen and the susceptibility to develop CIA in guinea-pigs is due to their poor cross-reactive immune response to autologous type II collagen.     

Characterization of CD4(+) T cell autoreactivity to self-MHC in New Zealand hybrid mice

The New Zealand white (NZW) H2(z) locus is strongly associated with the development of autoimmune disease in (NZB x NZW)F(1) mice, a model of systemic lupus erythematosus. To better understand the role of H2(z) in autoimmunity, we generated CD4(+) T cell hybridomas from the spleen and lymph nodes of unimmunized (NZB x NZW)F(1) mice and characterized their specificity. We found that over 50% of the hybridomas responded to syngeneic (H2(d/z)) spleen cells in the absence of exogenous antigen. Many of these autoreactive hybridomas responded to spleen cells expressing H2(z) and used H2(z) class II (I-A(z) or I-E(z)) molecules for presentation. Interestingly, nearly one third of the H2(z)-reactive hybridomas could not respond to spleen cells expressing only H2(z) class II molecules. These studies characterize a frequent population of autoreactive CD4(+) T cells in lupus mice and indicate that major histocompatibility complex molecules in addition to class II may be important for this self-recognition.     

Evidence for T cell receptor-HLA class II molecule interaction in the response to superantigenic bacterial toxins

The staphylococcal enterotoxins and related microbial T cell mitogens stimulate T cells by cross-linking variable parts of the T cell receptor (TcR) with MHC class II molecules on accessory or target cells. In this report we describe that a given combination of T cell, accessory cell (AC) and toxin can be non-stimulatory. However, the same T cell can respond to the same toxin on another AC and the same AC can present the same toxin to another T cell. This indicates that in the complex formed between TcR, toxin and class II molecule an interaction between TcR and class II molecule takes place.     

Impact of cAMP on the T-cell response to type II collagen

There is considerable interest in the possible use of cAMP-elevating agents in the treatment of autoimmune diseases such as rheumatoid arthritis. The objective of this study was to evaluate the impact of different cAMP-elevating agents on the T-cell response to type II collagen within the context of collagen-induced arthritis, a murine model of rheumatoid arthritis. Spleen cells or lymph node cells from type-II-collagen-immunized DBA/1 mice were cultured in the presence of type II collagen plus one of five different cAMP-elevating agents: rolipram, forskolin, prostaglandin E2, 8-bromo-cAMP, or cholera toxin. Levels of interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma), interleukin-4 (IL-4) and IL-5 were measured in culture supernatants by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay. All of the cAMP-elevating agents tested were found to profoundly suppress IFN-gamma production in a dose-dependent manner. IL-4 and IL-5 production was slightly up-regulated at low concentrations of the cAMP-elevating agents and was modestly suppressed at the highest concentrations of cAMP-elevating agents. Experiments were then carried out to determine whether T cells were directly affected by cAMP-elevating agents or whether the immunomodulatory effects were mediated via antigen-presenting cells. Pulsing T cells alone for a brief period with cholera toxin produced an almost identical effect to pulsing antigen-presenting cells alone, i.e. down-regulation of proliferation, down-regulation of IFN-gamma production with little effect on IL-5 production. It was concluded that cAMP-elevating agents suppressed T helper type 1 responses to type II collagen to a greater extent than T helper type 2 responses. The cAMP-elevating agents could directly influence the activity of T cells but, in addition, influenced the ability of antigen-presenting cells to support T helper type 1 responses.     

Neutralization of tetanus toxin by distinct monoclonal antibodies binding to multiple epitopes on the toxin molecule.

Fifty-seven hybridomas producing antibodies to tetanus toxoid or to the Ibc or B-IIb fragment of the toxin were isolated independently. Competitive inhibition studies demonstrated that monoclonal antibodies from mice immunized with the toxoid bound to at least 20 different epitopes on the toxoid molecule. Similar competitive binding studies revealed eight distinct epitopes on the B-IIb fragment and three to five epitopes on the Ibc fragment of the toxin. Neutralization of toxicity was effected by nine distinct monoclonal antibodies from hybridomas of toxoid-immunized mice and by one monoclonal antibody from B-IIb-immunized mice. Mixtures of two, three, and four different monoclonal antibodies in a variety of combinations exerted a synergistic effect of ca. 200-fold over that observed with individual monoclonal antibodies, indicating that efficient neutralization may involve the simultaneous binding of at least two antibody molecules to different specific regions of the toxin molecule. Only one toxoid-induced monoclonal antibody failed to bind to tetanus toxin. All neutralizing antibodies bound to epitopes on the heavy chain of tetanus toxin. Six of these were directed toward epitopes on the NH2-terminal half, whereas four bound to epitopes on the carboxy-terminal half of the heavy chain. Only one monoclonal antibody bound preferentially to the light chain, but two other monoclonal antibodies appeared to bind to both chains, indicating some homology between these two chains.     

The potential use of T cell epitopes to alter the immune response.

Recent advances in the understanding of T cell specificity and activation have lead to the design of T cell specific immunomodulators. T cell epitope containing peptides have been proposed as agents which may either enhance or dampen the immune response. In this review, we examine two systems which can benefit from the application of this novel technology. Vaccine development is moving toward the use of defined cloned or synthetic molecules. T cell epitope identification and design can be used to augment the ability of a weak antigen to generate an immune response. In contrast, traditional allergy immunotherapy has been shown to alter the immune response to the allergenic antigen. T cell epitope approaches to allergy desensitization offer a new therapeutic modality.     

Involvement of autoimmunity against type II collagen in the development of arthritis in mice transgenic for the human T cell leukemia virus type I tax gene

We previously reported that transgenic mice carrying the human T cell leukemia virus type I (HTLV‐I) env‐pX region ( pX ‐transgenic mice) develop rheumatoid‐like inflammatory arthropathy, and suggested involvement of autoimmunity in the pathogenicity. In this report, to elucidate pathogenesis of the arthritis, we investigated arthritogenic antigens in the joints. The TCR β‐chain variable region (Vβ) repertoires in the lymphatic organs were normal in transgenic mice, however, specific Vβ‐positive T cells were expanded oligoclonally in the affected joints, suggesting that specific antigens, but not superantigens, were involved in the expansion of these T cells. These expanded T cells had the same TCR as those of lymphnode T cells reactive to type II collagen (IIC). Moreover, these mice were susceptible to IIC‐induced arthritis and oligoclonal T cells of the same Vβ specificity as that found in spontaneously developed arthritic joint accumulated in the arthritic joints after immunization with IIC. These observations show that endogenous IIC is one of the arthritogenic antigens in the joint, suggesting tolerance break to this antigen in pX ‐transgenic mice.     

Assessing the binding of four Plasmodium falciparum T helper cell epitopes to HLA-DQ and induction of T-cell responses in HLA-DQ transgenic mice

A subunit vaccine for Plasmodium falciparum malaria will need to contain well-defined T helper cell epitopes that induce protective immune responses to the parasite. One major barrier to the use of subunit vaccines is the requirement for T helper cell epitopes to be presented by the HLA class II molecules that are present in the population being vaccinated. Since the majority of malaria studies have focused on HLA-DR, little information on the role of HLA-DQ in the binding and immune response to malarial epitopes is available. This study used an in vitro peptide-binding assay to predict the extent of HLA-DQ binding of four conserved T helper cell epitopes identified from asexual-stage malaria vaccine candidate antigens. Epstein-Barr virus (EBV)-transformed human B-cell lines expressing 14 different DQ molecules (DQ2.1, -2.2, -4.1, -4.2, -5.1 to -5.3, -6.1, -6.2, -6.4, -7.1, -7.3, -8, and -9) representing all broad serological specificities, including common DQ molecules present in populations in areas where malaria is endemic, were used in the binding assay. Moreover, an HLA-DQ transgenic mouse model was employed to evaluate the correlation between the in vitro DQ binding of the peptides and the generation of in vivo immune responses following peptide immunization. This study identified two broad DQ-binding peptides, ABRA#14 and SERA#9. ABRA#14 also induced T-cell proliferation and Th1-associated cytokine production in DQ8(+) transgenic mice. The combination of peptide binding to EBV-transformed cell lines and DQ transgenic mice provides a method for identifying additional T-cell epitopes for inclusion in a vaccine.     

The influence of HLA-DR4 (0401) on the immune response to type II collagen and the development of collagen induced arthritis in mice

Rheumatoid arthritis (RA) is an autoimmune disease that is genetically associated with the MHC class II molecule HLA-DRbeta1*0401 (DR4). In order to determine if this MHC can influence the immune response to the candidate autoantigen type II collagen (CII), we have studied collagen induced arthritis (CIA) resistant C57BL/6 mice, made transgenic (Tg) for human DR4. These DR4 Tg mice exhibited a strong T cell proliferative response to CII and its DR4 restricted peptide p261-273 after immunization with these antigens that was not seen in the C57BL/6 wild type mice. DR4 Tg mice also exhibited an increase in IFN-gamma production in response to CII, indicating the activation of Th1 cells. While these Tg mice produced IgM anti-CII antibodies, they failed to produce a detectable level of IgG2a (Th1 type) anti-bCII antibody and did not develop CIA. This study shows that a Th1 type T cell response to CII can be established in CIA non-susceptible mice by introducing the human transgene, DR4. This T cell response, however, is not sufficient to induce an antibody isotype switch to IgG2a, nor is it sufficient for the induction of CIA. These results may help to explain why many individuals expressing HLA-DRbeta1*0401 do not develop RA.     

T cell response to myoglobin: a comparison of T cell clones in high-responder and low-responder mice

Mice carrying the H-2b haplotype (e.g., inbred strains C57BL/6 and C57BL/10) are low responders to sperm whale myoglobin when tested in the T cell proliferation assay. Their response is improved by the removal of the Ly-2+ cells from the lymph node population, but it still remains significantly lower than that of cells cells from high-responder strains (e.g., DBA/2, H-2d). To determine whether T cells from the low and high-responder mice recognize the same or different epitopes on the immunizing antigen, we obtained sets of T cell clones from both strains and tested them against peptides representing different regions of the myoglobin molecule, as well as against myoglobins from species other than the sperm whale. Four types of T cell clones were obtained from the DBA/2 mice: 3 types responded to the peptide 107-120 (9 clones altogether), and 1 type responded to the peptide 133-149 (4 clones altogether). The 3 types responding to the peptide 107-120 could be distinguished by their response to horse myoglobin or by the restriction of the response (Ad vs. Ed). Similarly, 5 types of T cell clones were obtained from the C57BL/6 mice: 2 types responded to the peptide 10-22 (1 type, but not the other, responded to horse myoglobin); 1 type responded to the peptide 133-149; and 2 types did not respond to any of the peptides used (1 type, but not the other, responded to dog myoglobin). All 5 types (13 clones altogether) were presumably Ab restricted. These results demonstrate the diversity of epitopes in single antigenic regions and show equivalent heterogeneity of T cell repertoires in high and low responder mice. Attempts to demonstrate specific T cell suppression in the low responder mice failed; only partial, nonspecific suppression was observed.