Combined complete C5 and partial C4 deficiency in humans: clinical consequences and complement-mediated functions in vitro

A family is described with two siblings who suffered at different times from a single episode of meningococcal meningitis by Neisseria meningitidis groups B and C, respectively. In the two subjects, hemolytically active fifth component of complement (C5) was not detectable and antigenic C5 was less than 0.05% and less than 0.7% of normal, respectively. Repletion of sera by purified human C5 (70 micrograms/ml) restored total complement hemolytic activities. The asymptomatic first degree family members had C5 levels compatible with a heterozygous state of C5 deficiency. C4 allotyping revealed an inherited partial deficiency (Q0) of C4A and C4B in the family with a combined C4AQ0 and C4BQ0 heterozygous condition in one and C4BQ0 heterozygosity in the other C5 deficient (C5D) subject. To our knowledge, this is the first human kindred with recognized combined C5 and C4 deficiency. No other defect of the humoral and cellular immune system was found in this family, including specific immune response to tetravalent meningococcal vaccine. The effect of partial C4 deficiency on classical pathway function was assessed by inhibition of immune precipitation (IIP) of forming bovine serum albumin (BSA)/anti-BSA immune complexes. Sera from all family members showed normal IIP values, with exception of the subject with combined partial deficiency in C4A, C4B, and complete deficiency in C5. Despite undetectable functional C5 in the C5D sera, the titration of the alternative pathway indicated intact but deficient hemolytic activities when rabbit erythrocytes (EC) were used as indicator cells in the presence of Mg2+ and EGTA in an end-point or kinetic assay. Preincubation of the two sera at 0 degrees C for 60 min with rabbit ECs reduced alternative pathway hemolytic activity by 24 and 100%, respectively. When rabbit ECs were replaced by guinea pig ECs no alternative pathway function could be measured. The results indicate that the apparent functional activity of the alternative pathway in C5D sera strongly depends on a factor(s) present in such serum and/or on the detection system used. We conclude that the two C5D individuals of the family reported here may not have sufficient C5 activity to provide efficient protection against Neisserial infections in conditions where complement functions beyond C3 opsonic activity are required in vivo.     

High incidence of complement C9 deficiency in Koreans

Complement 9 deficiency is the most common complement deficiency in Japan, but it is rare in western countries. Because of Korea's geographical proximity to Japan, C9 deficiency in Korea has also been assumed to be common although this has never before been proven. We investigated complement deficiency in the serum samples of 6,159 Korean hospital outpatients. The deficiency was screened by a sensitive hemolytic assay and was confirmed by immunoassay of each complement component. Three C9-deficient individuals were found, giving an incidence of 0.049%, which is lower than that in Japan but still a considerable figure. Complement deficiencies other than that of C9 were not detected in this study. It is therefore necessary to consider the possibility of C9 deficiency in the interpretation of unexpectedly low complement-mediated hemolytic activity in East Asians.     

A high incidence of C9 deficiency among healthy blood donors in Osaka, Japan

By the use of sucrose gelatin veronal buffer (SGVB), a simple screening test was developed by us to detect sera with low complement activity, including C9-deficient sera. Using this screening test, we were able to identify sera with low complement activity including C9-deficient sera among a large number of samples. Further examinations, estimation of the protein concentration of C9, C4, C3, etc., enabled classification of serum with low complement activity into C9-deficient serum, serum deficient in the other components, and serum with low complement activity caused by non-specific activation of complement through the classical pathway by low temperature in vitro. Among 145,640 sera from Osaka donors, 138 sera were found to be deficient in C9 by these methods. The whole complement activity (CH50) of the 138 sera was 13.1 +/- 3.0 U/ml. The C9 protein in these sera was undetectable, not only by the single radial immunodiffusion method, but also by the sensitive ELISA method. C9 activities in these sera were less than 0.1% of the level in pooled normal human serum. These findings and the family studies revealed that 138 blood donors unquestionably had a hereditary C9 deficiency. The incidence of C9 deficiency among Osaka donors was calculated to be 0.095%.     

Normal complement C4 values do not exclude hereditary angioedema

This report describes a patient with hereditary angioedema (HAE) in whom complement C4 values were consistently normal. There was a family history of HAE, for which the patient had previously been screened, but in view of her normal C4 values she was deemed unaffected. However, at 10 years of age she presented with an eight month history of episodes of swelling affecting her hands and recurrent episodes of abdominal pain over the previous few months. In view of the recent clinical history of swellings and the family history of HAE, C4 and C1 inhibitor (C1inh) were measured. The C4 concentration was found to be within the normal range but the C1inh value was low (0.07 g/litre; normal range, 0.18-0.37). The patient was started on tranexamic acid and at an outpatient review three months later her episodes of swelling were occurring less often and were less severe. Although recent papers have suggested that the diagnosis of HAE can be excluded if complement C4 concentrations are normal, this case highlights the fact that C4 concentrations can be normal in this condition, and it is recommended that both C4 and C1inh concentrations should be measured to exclude HAE.     

Complete Factor I Deficiency Due to Dysfunctional Factor I with Recurrent Aseptic Meningo-Encephalitis

Purpose

Complement regulators control the activated complement system. Defects in this homeostasis can result in tissue damage and autoimmune diseases with a heterogeneity in clinical presentation. Complement factor I (FI), a serine protease, is an important regulator of alternative pathway activation. We report a diagnostic work-up of a patient with relapsing inflammatory mediated meningo-encephalitis. Our work-up revealed a rare genetic factor I (FI) deficiency. So far, all cases of reported complete factor I deficiency have absent serum levels of FI. We present here a unique case of a complete factor I deficiency based on a functional FI defect.

Methods

Complement assays and measurement of FI activity were performed in the patient, her family, factor H-deficient patients, a patient with C3-nephritic factor and 11 healthy controls. Genetic sequencing of the FI coding regions in the patient and her parents was performed.

Results

The patient had absent alternative pathway activity with low levels of C3 and normal serum level of FI. The patient’s plasma FI did not degrade C3b, with normalisation of C3b degradation after adding purified FI. Mutation analysis of the complement factor I gene revealed two heterozygous mutations (I322T and D506V).

Conclusion

To our knowledge, this paper describes a complete FI deficiency caused by a defect of FI activity for the first time. Normal FI concentration does not exclude a complete FI defect, additional functional analysis of FI is required in any patient with a defect of complement activation. Recurrent aseptic meningo-encephalitis is a rare clinical presentation of complete FI deficiency.     

Screening for complement deficiencies in unselected patients with meningitis

Two hundred and nine patients consecutively admitted to hospital with a tentative diagnosis of meningitis were screened for complement deficiency by measuring classical and alternative pathway serum haemolytic complement activity and the plasma concentration of C3d. Abnormal test results were followed up by quantitative immunochemical measurements of individual complement components. No patients with homozygous complement deficiency were found in our material. One patient with pneumococcal meningitis with probable heterozygous C2-deficiency was identified. Patients with purulent meningitis of various etiologies or meningococcal disease had significantly increased plasma C3d concentration at admission compared to patients with serous meningitis or without meningitis. Furthermore, increased plasma level of C3d at admission in patients with purulent meningitis or meningococcal disease was associated with an increased lethality. Our findings do not support the hypothesis that complement deficiency is commonly associated with sporadically occurring meningococcal disease or purulent meningitis.     

A case of systemic lupus erythematosus occurred after induced abortion and drug eruption]

We describe a19 year-old woman who was diagnosed as systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) after abortion. She had taken anti-convulsants for epilepsy since she was 8 years old. Induced abortion surgery was performed at six weeks in her pregnancy. She showed pyrexia and a general rash 2 days after the abortion. She was introduced to our hospital because the administration of antibiotics was not effective. Since the anti-convulsants had been changed after pregnancy, we returned to those administered before pregnancy and followed her up. Her eruption improved, but she became aware of thirstiness and dry eye. She was diagnosed as Sj?gren syndrome by ophthalmologic examination, lip biopsy, and elevation of an anti-SS-A antibody and an anti-SS-B antibody in the serum. Since we could not rule out SLE because of the low concentration of complement activity in blood, we followed her up carefully by checking serum markers of SLE. Protein urine developed after the improvement of the eruption 2 weeks later. Low complement activity was recognized and double stranded (ds)-DNA antibody became positive. In addition to these findings, she had an episode of hypersensitivity to sunlight and was therefore diagnosed as SLE. Since induced abortion and drug eruption might be associated with the onset of SLE, the case is thought to be a valuable from the view point of understanding the mechanism of SLE onset.     

A complete selective C1q deficiency in a patient with discoid lupus erythematosus (DLE).

A 32 year old male patient with discoid lupus erythematosus (DLE) was found to have a complete, selective deficiency of C1q subcomponent of the complement assessed either by haemolytic assay or by protein determination. Addition of highly purified C1q completely restored the complement haemolytic activity of the patient's serum. Neither C1q precipitin nor anti-complementary activity was detected. Lymphocytes isolated from the patient's peripheral blood, however, bound as many C1q molecules as those of healthy control individuals. The patient is in good health except for skin lesions. A low level of circulating immune complexes was detected in his serum, but no C1q molecules were bound. Serum complement activities of the patient's mother and two other siblings were within the normal range. An impaired synthesis of C1q protein was strongly suggested as the cause of C1q deficiency in this patient's serum.     

Serum stimulatory activity and polymorphonuclear leucocyte movement in patients with fulminant hepatic failure.

Serum from 27 patients with fulminant hepatic failure and grade IV encephalopathy had reduced ability to stimulate the movement in vitro of normal polymorphonuclear leucocytes. All patients had a deficiency of serum complement factors C3 and C5 and there was a significant positive correlation between C5 and serum stimulatory activity. However, in addition to this complement defect, serum from 22% of patients contained an antagonist to normal serum stimulatory factors. This antagonism was attributed to at least two different substances in the serum on the basis of differences in heat lability, dialysability and action on complement factor C5a. Polymorphonuclear leucocytes from eight of 13 patients had reduced movement toward serum, but serum from only one patient contained an antagonist acting on the cells; this was probably related to an underlying carcinoma of the breast. During the early stages of clinical recovery, serum stimulatory and complement activity returned to normal. These serum and cellular defects have not been reported previously in patients with fulminant hepatic failure and represent major defects in the body's defenses against bacterial infection.     

A new semiquantitative radiometric opsonin assay. Selective measurement of opsonizing capacity of the alternative pathway.

A new semiquantitative radiometric opsonin assay is described. It was found that the opsonin activity generated by incubating brewer's yeast, Saccharomyces cerevisiae, in medium containing less than 5% human serum was exclusively complement dependent. In contrast, C. albicans was effectively opsonized in the absence of complement. Antibodies and the early classical complement pathway did not contribute to the opsonization of S. cerevisiae and neither did C5-9. The brewer's yeast assay can therefore be used for measuring selectively the opsonizing capacity of the alternative pathway. Sera from approximately 7% of apparently healthy adult controls consistently failed to generate significant opsonin activity while 8 out of 26 patients with suspected immune deficiency of unknown cause were defective in this assay. All opsonin deficient sera so far tested had haemolytically normal alternative pathway and Factor B activity.     

Renal transplantation in a patient with hereditary deficiency of the second component of complement.

The HLA haplotype A 10,B18 has been associated with hereditary deficiency of the second component of complement(C2). In an effort to detect individuals homozygous for C2 deficiency, a thorough audit of HLA serotyping results in 3,100 individuals was performed, and a single patient homozygous for the A10, B18 haplotype was identified. Detailed complement studies in this patient's serum and plasma revealed previously undetected selective absence of C2 antigen and haemolytic activity, and a hereditary basis for this deficiency was indicated by half-normal levels of C2 haemolytic activity in both of his children. The patient was of special interest in that he had previously developed renal failure which was treated by cadaver kidney transplantation. C2 antigen was undetectable in serum and plasma samples taken prior to and up to 9 months following transplantation. This experience suggests that HLA serotyping can be a valuable screening technique for the detection of individuals with C2 deficiency, and that renal transplantation does not reconstitute normal levels of C2.     

Hereditary C6 deficiency in a strain of PVG/c rats.

A chance observation has led to the discovery of a strain of PVG rats (PVG/c-) which are deficient in complement (C) component C6. Analysis of total haemolytic activity (CH50) of PVG/c- serum revealed an absent CH50 activity compared with serum of other rat strains and of a PVG/c rat (PVG/c+) that showed normal C activity. Thus, the PVG/c- rat was unable to activate the C5b-9 membrane attack complex. To gain insight into the complement abnormalities, analysis of individual C components was performed. Testing the PVG/c- serum in a C6 haemolytic assay and using deficient human sera showed a deficiency of C6 in the PVG/c- rat. Highly purified human C6 and human sera deficient in other components were able to reconstitute the CH50 activity of the PVG/c- rat. The possibility that an inactivator of C was present in PVG/c- serum was excluded. The deficiency was found to be inheritable and under the control of an autosomal recessive gene. Furthermore, tissue antigens and immunity of the PVG/c- rat were found to be identical to those determined in the PVG/c+ rat. With regard to their health status, the PVG/c- animals seem to have no disadvantages compared with PVG/c+ rats when held under the same conditions within the protected environment of animal facilities. Taken together, both rat strains provide an unique animal model for studying the biological role of C, particularly the C5b-9 membrane attack complex in experimental medicine.     

Combined total deficiency of C7 and C4B with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE).

The first inherited combined total deficiency of C7 and C4B complement components associated with SLE is described in a young female. Functional C7 assays showed a homozygous C7 deficiency in the propositus and her sister, and an heterozygous one in their parents. C4 molecular analyses showed that both the propositus and her mother had two HLA haplotypes carrying only C4A-specific DNA sequences and a normal C4 gene number. Thus, only C4A proteins could be expressed, with resultant normal C4 serum levels. The coexistence of a combined complete C7 and C4B deficiency may therefore abrogate essential functions of the complement cascade presumably related to immune complex handling and solubilization despite an excess of circulating C4A. These findings challenge the putative pathophysiological roles of C4A and C4B and stress the need to perform both functional assays and C4 allotyping in patients with autoimmune pathology and low haemolytic activity without low serum levels of a classical pathway complement component.     

Hereditary, Complete Deficiency of Complement Factor H Associated with Recurrent Meningococcal Disease

Complement factor H (beta-1H globulin) is an important regulatory protein which inhibits the spontaneous complement activation via the alternative pathway. We describe a 15-year-old girl without any detectable factor H in plasma. She has had two episodes of meningococcal disease, but is otherwise completely healthy. Secondary to the factor-H deficiency, the levels of factor B, properdin, C3, and C5-C9 were strongly reduced due to spontaneous in vivo activation of the alternative complement pathway. Plasma C3dg was strongly elevated in spite of the factor-H deficiency; apparently erythrocyte CR1 substitutes for factor H in C3 degradation. Neither C3 nor complement lesions were demonstrable on her erythrocytes which did, however, show increased, spontaneous haemolysis in vitro in citrate plasma, but not in serum. The patient is a single child and her parents, who are unrelated and healthy, had half-normal levels of factor H. This reduction of factor H is sufficient to cause increased, spontaneous activation of the alternative pathway.     

C3 metabolism in a patient with deficiency of the second component of complement (C2) and discoid lupus erythematosus.

A patient with a hereditary deficiency of the second component of complement and discoid lupus erythematosus with features of systemic lupus erythematosus was studied. The propositus had a 9-year history of rash and arthralgia. Transient renal disease had completely resolved; there was a history of seizures. Examination of his serum disclosed antinuclear antibodies but no total haemolytic complement activity. C2 was absent. Serum concentrations of C1s, C3, C5 and C9 were elevated; other complement components were present in normal concentration, including C3 pro-activator. The patient's C3 pro-activator was electrophoretically converted by inulin and four of five lipopolysaccharides, but was poorly converted by aggregated human IgG. Two separate turnover studies with radiolabelled C3 showed fractional catabolic rates of 3-03 and 2-48% of the remaining plasma pool/hr (range of three normals: 1-62-2-18%/hr); and estimated C3 synthetic rates of 2-74 and 2-31 mg/kg/hr (range of three normals: 0-89-1-40 mg/kg/hr). Serum complement profiles of the patient's family demonstrated that the C2 deficiency was inherited as an autosomal codominant. One sibling, homozygous for C2 deficiency, and three other siblings, both parents and one daughter, all heterozygous for C2 deficiency, are in good health. Immunofluorescent studies of the patient's diseased skin exhibited substantial deposits of IgG, IgM, C1q, and C4 but not of later acting complement components, properdin, or C3 proactivator. These studies do not support the notion that inflammation in C3-deficient individuals with lupus erythematosus is mediated by the alternative complement pathway.     

Difficulties in the ascertainment of C9 deficiency: lessons to be drawn from a compound heterozygote C9-deficient subject

A group of patients with long-surviving mismatched kidney allografts were investigated for complement function using haemolytic assays in agarose gels. One patient was found to have no alternative pathway activity but a low normal classical pathway. Surprisingly, investigation revealed that the patient’s complement was normal for all components except C9, which was functionally absent. The patient was shown to be heterozygous for DNA markers in the C6, C7 and C9 region of chromosome 5 and therefore appears to be a compound heterozygote for two uncharacterized C9 deficiency genes. Serological analysis by ELISA revealed that he has trace concentrations of a non-functional C9 molecule. Western blot analysis was not sufficiently sensitive to permit detection of this molecule. We hypothesize that the patient is heterozygous for a complete deficiency of C9 and for a gene directing hyposynthesis of a defective C9. We also suggest that C9 deficiency may be more common among Caucasians than has been reported.     

Study on C3-like factor in the serum of a C3-deficient subject.

Analysis of the serum of an individual having a deficiency of C3 (C3D) revealed that despite the fact that the C3 could not be detected immunochemically, a small amount of C3 haemolytic activity and total complement activity was indeed found to be present. The present study was performed to analyse the C3-like factor, responsible for this C3 activity in C3D serum. It was found that the C3-like factor was not neutralized by anti-C3 but was neutralized by anti-C5. The electrophoretic mobility of the C3-like factor corresponded to that of purified C5. Thus, C3-like factor was shown to have the antigenicity and electrophoretic mobility of C5. This factor was found in the sera of three other C3D subjects and even in pooled normal human serum (NHS). These findings suggest that, in cases of C3D, C5 compensates for the genetic lack of C3 and serves a protective function and that sensitized erythrocytes (EA) may be lysed by complement components without participation of C3.     

Genetic and metabolic analysis of the first adult with congenital disorder of glycosylation type Ib: long-term outcome and effects of mannose supplementation

We report the diagnosis and follow-up of two sibs reported in 1980 with recurrent venous thromboses and protein-losing enteropathy; one sib with biopsy-proven hepatic fibrosis died at age 5. The combination of symptoms was suggestive of the recently characterized congenital disorder of glycosylation type Ib (CDG-Ib), which is caused by a deficiency of the enzyme phosphomannose isomerase (PMI). An abnormal serum transferrin isoelectric focusing (IEF) pattern and a reduced PMI activity confirmed the diagnosis of CDG-Ib. Furthermore, mutational analysis of the MPI gene revealed two missense mutations, 419 T --> C (I140T) and 636 G --> A (R219Q), a single base substitution in intron 5, 670 + 9G --> A, as well as a polymorphism 1131A --> C (V377V) in both sibs. The surviving 33-year-old sib has had no further symptoms following childhood. Short-term low-dose oral mannose supplementation improved her transferrin IEF pattern and normalized her antithrombin III activity, further substantiating the beneficial effect of mannose in CDG-Ib. When her mannose blood level was measured, she showed a lower steady-state level but a faster mannose clearance rate. These results suggest that the clinical manifestations of PMI deficiency, although serious in childhood, can improve with age, even without mannose therapy, and allow for a normal adult life. However, the long-term prognosis may vary from patient to patient.     

Diuretic abuse and central pontine myelinolysis

Patients with eating disorders often use diuretics to eliminate fluid to achieve lower body weight. Diuretic abuse can lead to severe hyponatremia. Central pontine myelinolysis, a disruption of the myelinated neurons of the pons, has been associated with rapid correction of severe hyponatremia. A case is presented of a 35-year-old woman who was brought to the emergency service by ambulance complaining of vomiting for 7 days and that she could not hear well because she was 'worn out'. Initial laboratory values included serum Na 91 mEq/l, K 1.6, Cl 46, bicarbonate 33, BUN 4 mg/dl, glucose 306 mg/dl. After 32 h of intravenous fluids, the serum Na was 126, K 4.0, Cl 89, bicarbonate 25, glucose 118 mg/dl. On the 3rd hospital day the serum Na was 139. On the 4th hospital day she was alert and appropriate. On the 5th hospital day, however, she was confabulating and chatty. The serum Na was 139. She progressed to develop a spastic quadriparesis, speech and swallowing difficulties. A magnetic resonance imaging scan showed central pontine myelinolysis. She acknowledged taking 400 mg daily of furosemide and drinking much water. She had a past history of anorexia nervosa. She had a residual weight phobia and strove to keep her weight below 106 lb. Her height was 5 feet, 6 inches. As illustrated by this case, diuretic abuse can cause severe hyponatremia and the subsequent risk of central pontine myelinolysis. In patients with severe chronic or subacute hyponatremia, a safe restoration rate for serum Na has been less than 0.55 mEq/l/h. Serum Na should be below 135 within the first 48 h and hypernatremia should be avoided.     

Mouse strains with typical mammalian levels of complement activity

Common laboratory mouse strains have very low complement levels relative to humans, rats, guinea pigs, rabbits and other mammals, which limits the value of the mouse as an experimental model. We therefore tested serum complement levels of 43 mouse strains and 11 rat strains, for the purpose of selecting a convenient laboratory animal having high complement levels. Total complement activity was determined with both erythrocytes and human tumor cells as targets. Eight mouse strains were identified that have complement levels comparable to those of other mammals. These mouse sera lyse tumor cell targets as well as sera from humans, rats or guinea pigs, although they are somewhat less active than rabbit sera. They are relatively inefficient in lysing erythrocyte targets, yet are as active as rabbit serum in this assay. Target cell lysis was demonstrated to be via the classical pathway of complement activation. Of the eight 'high complement' mouse strains, four were recently derived from wild mice, and one, SF/CamEi, was derived from wild mice in 1951. The three other strains, BUB/BnJ, DA/HuSn and RIIIS/J, were developed more than 40 years ago, but apparently were not tested previously for complement activity. Using the BUB mouse as a representative of the 'high complement' mice, we assayed levels of the nine complement components, in an attempt to identify the cause of high complement activity. No difference in levels of C1, C2, C4, C8 or C9 was detected between BUB and BDF1 mice. C2 activity was very low in both strains. C3, C5, C6 and C7 activities were higher in BUB mice than in BDF1 mice, indicating that variation in these complement components is responsible for the difference in total complement activity. The genes determining the 'high complement' phenotype appeared to be semi-dominant in F1 hybrids. The 'high-complement' mouse strains, and recombinant strains derived from them, will be useful in a wide range of biomedical research.