BHLHA9 homozygous duplication in a consanguineous family: A challenge for genetic counseling

Split-hand/foot malformation (SHFM) with long-bone deficiency (SHFLD) is a rare condition characterized by SHFM associated with long-bone malformation usually involving the tibia. It includes three different types; SHFLD1 (MIM % 119,100), SHFLD2 (MIM % 610,685) and SHFLD3 (MIM # 612576). The latter was shown to be the most commonly reported with a duplication in the 17p13.1p13.3 locus that was narrowed down to the BHLHA9 gene. Here, we report a consanguineous Lebanese family with three members presenting with limb abnormalities including tibial hemimelia. One of these patients presented with additional bowing fibula and another with bilateral split hand. CGH array analysis followed by RQ-PCR allowed us to detect the first homozygous duplication on the short arm of chromosome 17p13.3 including the BHLHA9 gene and involved in SHFLD3. Interestingly, one patient with the homozygous duplicated region, carrying thus four BHLHA9 copies presented with long bone deficiency but no SHFM. The incomplete penetrance and the variable expressivity of the disease in this family as well as the presence of the BHLHA9 homozygous duplication rendered genetic counseling extremely challenging and preimplantation genetic diagnosis almost impossible.     

Split-hand/foot malformation with long-bone deficiency and BHLHA9 duplication: Two cases and expansion of the phenotype to radial agenesis

Split-hand/foot malformation (SHFM) with long-bone deficiency (SHFLD, MIM#119100) is a rare condition characterised by SHFM associated with long-bone malformation usually involving the tibia. Previous published data reported several unrelated patients with 17p13.3 duplication and SHFLD. Recently, BHLHA9 has been proposed to be the major candidate gene responsible for this limb malformation. Here we report two new patients affected with ectrodactyly harbouring a 17p13.3 duplication detected by array-CGH. Both duplications contain 3 genes including BHLHA9 and are inherited from an unaffected parent. One of the patients presents a complete radial agenesis, expanding the phenotype of SHFLD3.     

WNT10B variants in split hand/foot malformation: Report of three novel families and review of the literature

Split‐hand/foot malformation (SHFM) is a genetically heterogeneous congenital limb malformation typically limited to a defect of the central rays of the autopod, presenting as a median cleft of hands and feet. It can be associated with long bone deficiency or included in more complex syndromes. Among the numerous genetic causes, WNT10B homozygous variants have been recently identified in consanguineous families, but remain still rarely described (SHFM6; MIM225300). We report on three novel SHFM families harboring WNT10B variants and review the literature, allowing us to highlight some clinical findings. The feet are more severely affected than the hands and there is a frequent asymmetry without obvious side‐bias. Syndactyly of third–fourth fingers was a frequent finding (62%). Polydactyly, which was classically described in SHFM6, was only present in 27% of patients. No genotype–phenotype correlation is delineated but heterozygous individuals might have mild features of SHFM, suggesting a dose‐effect of the WNT10B loss‐of‐function.     

Genetic regulatory pathways of split-hand/foot malformation

Split-hand/foot malformation (SHFM) is caused by mutations in TP63, DLX5, DLX6, FGF8, FGFR1, WNT10B, and BHLHA9. The clinical features of SHFM caused by mutations of these genes are not distinguishable. This implies that in normal situations these SHFM-associated genes share an underlying regulatory pathway that is involved in the development of the central parts of the hands and feet. The mutations in SHFM-related genes lead to dysregulation of Fgf8 in the central portion of the apical ectodermal ridge (AER) and subsequently lead to misexpression of a number of downstream target genes, failure of stratification of the AER, and thus SHFM. Syndactyly of the remaining digits is most likely the effects of dysregulation of Fgf-Bmp-Msx signaling on apoptotic cell death. Loss of digit identity in SHFM is hypothesized to be the effects of misexpression of HOX genes, abnormal SHH gradient, or the loss of balance between GLI3A and GLI3R. Disruption of canonical and non-canonical Wnt signaling is involved in the pathogenesis of SHFM. Whatever the causative genes of SHFM are, the mutations seem to lead to dysregulation of Fgf8 in AER cells of the central parts of the hands and feet and disruption of Wnt-Bmp-Fgf signaling pathways in AER.     

A prenatal case of split-hand malformation associated with 17p13.3 triplication – A dilemma in genetic counseling

Copy number gain of 17p13.3 has been shown to be associated with developmental delay/autism and Split-Hand-Foot malformation. We report a case of fetus with bilateral split-hand malformation detected on prenatal ultrasound. Array comparative genomic hybridization detected 2 maternally inherited copy number gains in the 17p13.3 region with one of them involving the BHLHA9 gene and part of the YWHAE gene. The mother is normal in intelligence with mild right foot anomaly only. Although the BHLHA9 copy gain is known to be associated with split-hand-foot malformation, the penetrance and expressivity is highly variable. More challenging is the effect of partial YWHAE copy number gain on neurodevelopment is inconclusive based on current literature. This case highlights the difficulties of prenatal genetic counseling in array comparative genomic hybridization findings in clinical situation with incomplete understanding of genotype–phenotype correlation.     

Mechanisms for the Generation of Two Quadruplications Associated with Split‐Hand Malformation

Germline copy‐number variants (CNVs) involving quadruplications are rare and the mechanisms generating them are largely unknown. Previously, we reported a 20‐week gestation fetus with split‐hand malformation; clinical microarray detected two maternally inherited triplications separated by a copy‐number neutral region at 17p13.3, involving BHLHA9 and part of YWHAE. Here, we describe an 18‐month‐old male sibling of the previously described fetus with split‐hand malformation. Custom high‐density microarray and digital droplet PCR revealed the copy‐number gains were actually quadruplications in the mother, the fetus, and her later born son. This quadruplication‐normal‐quadruplication pattern was shown to be expanded from the triplication‐normal‐triplication CNV at the same loci in the maternal grandmother. We mapped two breakpoint junctions and demonstrated that both are mediated by Alu repetitive elements and identical in these four individuals. We propose a three‐step process combining Alu‐mediated replicative‐repair‐based mechanism(s) and intergenerational, intrachromosomal nonallelic homologous recombination to generate the quadruplications in this family.     

First direct evidence of involvement of a homozygous loss‐of‐function variant in the EPS15L1 gene underlying split‐hand/split‐foot malformation

Split‐hand/split‐foot malformation (SHFM) is a severe form of congenital limb deformity characterized by the absence of 1 or more digits and/or variable degree of median clefts of hands and feet. The present study describes an investigation of a consanguineous family of Pakistani origin segregating SHFM in an autosomal recessive manner. Human genome scan using SNP markers followed by whole exome sequencing revealed a frameshift deletion (c.409delA, p.Ser137Alafs*19) in the EPS15L1 gene located on chromosome 19p13.11. This is the first biallelic variant identified in the EPS15L1 gene underlying SHFM. Our findings report the first direct involvement of EPS15L1 gene in the development of human limbs.     

First case of compound heterozygous BHLHA9 variants in mesoaxial synostotic syndactyly with phalangeal reduction

Mesoaxial synostotic syndactyly with phalangeal reduction (MSSD) is an extremely rare autosomal recessive limb abnormality characterized by the fusion of third and fourth fingers. To date, only homozygous missense and frameshift mutations have been reported in BHLHA9 associated to MSSD. In this study, we report a patient who presented with clinical and radiological features of MSSD. A customized skeletal dysplasia NGS panel revealed the presence of two novel compounds heterozygous variants in BHLHA9: NM_001164405.1: c.[226A>T][269G>C]; p.[(Lys76*)][(Arg90Pro)]. Thus, this is the first case of MSSD in a nonconsanguineous family.     

Split hand/foot malformation associated with 20p12.1 deletion: A case report

Split hand/foot malformation (SHFM) or ectrodactyly is a rare congenital disorder affecting limb development characterized by clinical and genetic heterogeneity. SHFM is usually inherited as an autosomal dominant trait with incomplete penetrance. Isolated and syndromic forms are described. The extent of associated malformations is highly variable and multiple syndromes with clinical and genetic overlap have been described. We report here a 28 year-old man presenting with SHFM, sparse hair and widespread freckles. Array-CGH identified a 450 kb de novo 20p12.1 microdeletion encompassing three exons (exon 6 to 8) of MACROD2. Although MACROD2 mutations have not been associated with limb malformation until now, it is located next to KIF16B, which is involved in fibroblast growth factor receptor (FGFR) signaling. Additionally, the deletion encompassed a histone modification H3K27ac mark, known as a provider of quantitative readout of promoter and enhancer activity during human limb development. Altogether, these findings suggest that the 20p12.1 CNV is causative of SHFM in the present case through disturbance of regulatory elements functioning.     

Split hand-foot malformation and a novel WNT10B mutation

We report an Indian girl with split-hand/foot malformation (SHFM), sparse hair, and interrupted eyebrows, who carries a novel homozygous deletion c.695_697delACA in WNT10B. The variant is deduced to cause an in-frame deletion of Asn residue 232 (p.Asn232del). According to the protein model, this single amino acid deletion at the critical position in the protein structure is likely to severely affect the protein structure and function. This deletion is likely to lead decreased lifetime and make it unable to bind to its receptors and other ligands. The patient and all family members had normal bone density and they were not obese like some of the patients with WNT10B variants. Here we report a patient with SHFM6 who carried a novel WNT10B mutation. Sparse hair and interrupted eyebrows may be associated findings of SHFM6.     

A genomic rearrangement resulting in a tandem duplication is associated with split hand-split foot malformation 3 (SHFM3) at 10q24

Split hand-split foot malformation (SHFM) is characterized by hypoplasia/aplasia of the central digits with fusion of the remaining digits. SHFM is usually an autosomal dominant condition and at least five loci have been identified in humans. Mutation analysis of the DACTYLIN gene, suspected to be responsible for SHFM3 in chromosome 10q24, was conducted in seven SHFM patients. We screened the coding region of DACTYLIN by single-strand conformation polymorphism and sequencing, and found no point mutations. However, Southern, pulsed field gel electrophoresis and dosage analyses demonstrated a complex rearrangement associated with a approximately 0.5 Mb tandem duplication in all the patients. The distal and proximal breakpoints were within an 80 and 130 kb region, respectively. This duplicated region contained a disrupted extra copy of the DACTYLIN gene and the entire LBX1 and beta-TRCP genes, known to be involved in limb development. The possible role of these genes in the SHFM3 phenotype is discussed.     

Wolf-Hirschhorn syndrome and a split-hand malformation

Ectrodactyly has not previously been reported in children with Wolf-Hirschhorn syndrome (WHS). Based on this premise and the identification of an unbalanced translocation between chromosomes 4p15 and 10q25 in a fetus with ectrodactyly and hemimelia, a second locus for dominantly inherited split hand/foot malformation (SHFM3) was mapped to chromosome 10q24–q25. We present the clinical findings of an infant with WHS and SHFM and suggest that the presence of additional loci on 4p which modify/cause SHFM cannot be excluded. Am. J. Med. Genet. 75:351-354, 1998. © 1998 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

17p13.3 microduplications are associated with split-hand/foot malformation and long-bone deficiency (SHFLD)

Split-hand/foot malformation with long-bone deficiency (SHFLD) is a relatively rare autosomal-dominant skeletal disorder, characterized by variable expressivity and incomplete penetrance. Although several chromosomal loci for SHFLD have been identified, the molecular basis and pathogenesis of most SHFLD cases are unknown. In this study we describe three unrelated kindreds, in which SHFLD segregated with distinct but overlapping duplications in 17p13.3, a region previously linked to SHFLD. In a large three-generation family, the disorder was found to segregate with a 254 kb microduplication; a second microduplication of 527 kb was identified in an affected female and her unaffected mother, and a 430 kb microduplication versus microtriplication was identified in three affected members of a multi-generational family. These findings, along with previously published data, suggest that one locus responsible for this form of SHFLD is located within a 173 kb overlapping critical region, and that the copy gains are incompletely penetrant.     

Altered GPM6A/M6 Dosage Impairs Cognition and Causes Phenotypes Responsive to Cholesterol in Human and Drosophila

Glycoprotein M6A (GPM6A) is a neuronal transmembrane protein of the PLP/DM20 (proteolipid protein) family that associates with cholesterol‐rich lipid rafts and promotes filopodia formation. We identified a de novo duplication of the GPM6A gene in a patient with learning disability and behavioral anomalies. Expression analysis in blood lymphocytes showed increased GPM6A levels. An increase of patient‐derived lymphoblastoid cells carrying membrane protrusions supports a functional effect of this duplication. To study the consequences of GPM6A dosage alterations in an intact nervous system, we employed Drosophila melanogaster as a model organism. We found that knockdown of Drosophila M6, the sole member of the PLP family in flies, in the wing, and whole organism causes malformation and lethality, respectively. These phenotypes as well as the protrusions of patient‐derived lymphoblastoid cells with increased GPM6A levels can be alleviated by cholesterol supplementation. Notably, overexpression as well as loss of M6 in neurons specifically compromises long‐term memory in the courtship conditioning paradigm. Our findings thus indicate a critical role of correct GPM6A/M6 levels for cognitive function and support a role of the GPM6A duplication for the patient's phenotype. Together with other recent findings, this study highlights compromised cholesterol homeostasis as a recurrent feature in cognitive phenotypes.     

4q32�Cq35 and 6q16�Cq22 are valuable candidate regions for split hand/foot malformation

On the basis of the Human Cytogenetic Database, a computerized catalog of the clinical phenotypes associated with cytogenetically detectable human chromosome aberrations, we collected from the literature 102 cases with chromosomal aberrations and split hand/foot malformation or absent fingers/toes. Statistical analysis revealed a highly significant association (P<0.001) between the malformation and the chromosomal bands 4q32–q35, 5q15, 6q16–q22 and 7q11.2–q22 (SHFM1). Considering these findings, we suggest additional SHFM loci on chromosome 4q, 6q and probably 5q. The regions 4q and 6q have already been discussed in the literature as additional SHFM loci. We now show further evidence. In the proposed regions, there are interesting candidate genes such as, on 4q: HAND2, FGF2, LEF1 and BMPR1B; on 5q: MSX2, FLT4, PTX1 and PDLIM7; and on 6q: SNX3, GJA1, HEY2 and Tbx18.     

A novel frameshift variant in BHLHA9 underlies mesoaxial synostotic syndactyly associated with postaxial polydactyly

Mesoaxial synostotic syndactyly (MSSD) with phalangeal reduction is an uncommon congenital limb abnormality characterized by central osseous synostosis at a metacarpal level, mesoaxial reduction of the fingers, and preaxial cutaneous syndactyly in toes. In rare cases, the disease is also associated with fifth finger clinodactyly and postaxial polydactyly. It has autosomal recessive inheritance pattern caused by homozygous variants in the gene BHLHA9 mapped at chromosome 17p13.3.In the present study, a consanguineous family of Pakistani origin segregating MSSD in autosomal recessive form was characterized at clinical and genetic levels. Clinically, the diseased individuals have MSSD associated with clinodactyly and polydactyly. Homozygosity mapping followed by Sanger sequencing of BHLHA9 revealed a novel frameshift variant NM_001164405.1: c.409-409delC; p.(His137Thrfs*61) segregating with the disease phenotypes in the family.This is the second report providing evidence of association of polydactyly with MSSD caused by frameshift variant in the gene BHLHA9. The present molecular investigation will support genetic counselling of the local population carrying diseased variants.     

A novel homozygous missense mutation in WNT10B in familial split-hand/foot malformation

Split-hand/foot malformation (SHFM) is a rare limb developmental malformation, characterized by variable degree of median clefts of hands and feet due to the absence of central rays of extremities. To date, six different forms of SHFM have been described. Four of these SHFM1, SHFM3, SHFM4 and SHFM5 show autosomal dominant, SHFM6 autosomal recessive and SHFM2 X-linked pattern of inheritance. In this study a large consanguineous Pakistani family, with autosomal recessive SHFM, appeared in the last two generations, was investigated. In total 15 individuals including 9 males and 6 females were affected with the syndrome. Affected members of the family exhibited SHFM phenotype with involvement of hands and feet. Most of the affected members showed syndactyly/polydactyly in hands and feet, dysplastic hand, aplasia of radial ray of hand and cleft foot. Investigating linkage to known autosomal SHFM loci mapped the family to SHFM6 locus on chromosome 12p11.1-q13.13. Mutation screening of the gene WNT10B revealed a novel sequence variant (c.986C>G, p.Thr329Arg) in all affected individuals who were studied. This is the third mutation reported in gene WNT10B causing autosomal recessive SHFM syndrome.