Sex-chromosome pairing through heterochromatin in the African rodent Lemniscomys barbarus (Rodentia, Muridae). A synaptonemal complex study

Giemsa-stained spread preparations and microspread preparations of Lemniscomys barbarus spermatocytes were made to investigate the meiotic behaviour of the peculiar sex chromosomes of this species. A typical sex vesicle is absent, as the X and Y chromosomes appear unfolded at zygotene and pachytene. In most cells, the sex chromosomes are associated at distal segments at metaphase I, probably as a consequence of a distal chiasma. The pairing segment is located in the heterochromatic regions of both sex chromosomes, which include silent ribosomal cistrons interspersed throughout the heterochromatin. This may suggest a possible involvement of ribosomal genes in both pairing and recombination processes. X–Y pairing proceeds beyond the pseudoautosomal region, thus involving heterologous segments of the differential regions, a fact that is clearly evident at the Y centromeric region. This revised version was published online in July 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

X chromosome painting in <Emphasis Type="Italic">Microtus</Emphasis>: Origin and evolution of the giant sex chromosomes

Sex chromosomes in species of the genus Microtus present some characteristic features that make them a very interesting group to study sex chromosome composition and evolution. M. cabrerae and M. agrestis have enlarged sex chromosomes (known as ‘giant sex chromosomes’) due to the presence of large heterochromatic blocks. By chromosome microdissection, we have generated probes from the X chromosome of both species and hybridized on chromosomes from six Microtus and one Arvicola species. Our results demonstrated that euchromatic regions of X chromosomes in Microtus are highly conserved, as occurs in other mammalian groups. The sex chromosomes heterochromatic blocks are probably originated by fast amplification of different sequences, each with an independent origin and evolution in each species. For this reason, the sex heterochromatin in Microtus species is highly heterogeneous within species (with different composition for the Y and X heterochromatic regions in M. cabrerae) and between species (as the composition of M. agrestis and M. cabrerae sex heterochromatin is different). In addition, the X chromosome painting results on autosomes of several species suggest that, during karyotypic evolution of the genus Microtus, some rearrangements have probably occurred between sex chromosomes and autosomes.     

HORMAD2 is essential for synapsis surveillance during meiotic prophase via the recruitment of ATR activity

Meiotic chromosome segregation requires homologous pairing, synapsis and crossover recombination during meiotic prophase. The checkpoint kinase ATR has been proposed to be involved in the quality surveillance of these processes, although the underlying mechanisms remain largely unknown. In our present study, we generated mice lacking HORMAD2, a protein that localizes to unsynapsed meiotic chromosomes. We show that this Hormad2 deficiency hampers the proper recruitment of ATR activity to unsynapsed chromosomes. Male Hormad2‐deficient mice are infertile due to spermatocyte loss as a result of characteristic impairment of sex body formation; an ATR‐ and γH2AX‐enriched repressive chromatin domain is formed, but is partially dissociated from the elongated sex chromosome axes. In contrast to males, Hormad2‐deficient females are fertile. However, our analysis of Hormad2/Spo11 double‐mutant females shows that the oocyte number is negatively correlated with the frequency of pseudo–sex body formation in a Hormad2 gene dosage‐dependent manner. This result suggests that the elimination of Spo11‐deficient asynaptic oocytes is associated with the HORMAD2‐dependent pseudo–sex body formation that is likely initiated by local concentration of ATR activity in the absence of double‐strand breaks. Our results thus show a HORMAD2‐dependent quality control mechanism that recognizes unsynapsis and recruits ATR activity during mammalian meiosis.     

Meiotic analysis of XX/XY and neo-XX/XY sex chromosomes in Phyllostomidae by cross-species chromosome painting revealing a common chromosome 15-XY rearrangement in Stenodermatinae

We analyzed the meiotic behavior of the sex chromosomes of the bats Glossophaga soricina (XX/XY), Artibeus cinereus and Uroderma magnirostrum (neo-XX/XY) using multicolor FISH. The X chromosome and pair 15 autosome probes are from Phyllostomus hastatus and the Y from Carollia brevicauda. On both species with the neo-XX/XY system, the autosome translocated to the sex chromosomes is the pair 15 in P. hastatus, a synapomorphy. The analysis of meiosis confirms that the X and Y have a pseudo-autosomal region, with a typical end-to-end pairing. The autosomal regions of the neo-XX/XY shows different levels of condensation when compared to the original XX/XY. The compound system presented a characteristic shape, as if it was a closed ring with a tail. The ring represents the non-paired segments of the X and Y and the small pairing region of the original sex chromosomes. The tail corresponds to the pairing of the 15 P. hastatus autosomal bivalent, which are translocated to the sex chromosomes. Probably the non-pairing is responsible for the meiotic silencing of these segments.     

Differential association of SMC1α and SMC3 proteins with meiotic chromosomes in wild-type and SPO11-deficient male mice

SMC proteins are components of cohesin complexes that function in chromosome cohesion. We determined that SMC1α and SMC3 localized to wild-type mouse meiotic chromosomes, but with distinct differences in their patterns. Anti-SMC3 coincided with axial elements of the synaptonemal complex, while SMC1α was observed mainly in regions where homologues were synapsed. This pattern was especially visible in pachytene sex vesicles where SMC1α localized only weakly to the asynapsed regions. At diplotene, SMC3, but not SMC1α, remained bound along axial elements of desynapsed chromosomes. SMC1α and SMC3 were also found to localize along meiotic chromosome cores of Spo11 null spermatocytes, in which double-strand break formation required for DNA recombination and homologous pairing were disrupted. In Spo11−/− cells, SMC1α localization differed from SMC3 again, confirming that SMC1α is mainly associated with homologous or non-homologous synapsed regions, whereas SMC3 localized throughout the chromosomes. Our results suggest that the two cohesin proteins may not always be associated in a dimer and may function as separate complexes in mammalian meiosis, with SMC1α playing a more specific role in synapsis. In addition, our results indicate that cohesin cores can form independently of double-strand break formation and homologous pairing. This revised version was published online in July 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Synapsis, recombination, and chromatin remodeling in the XY body of armadillos

Three xenarthrans species Chaetophractus villosus, Chaetophractus vellerosus, and Zaedyus pichiy have been used for the analysis of the structure, behavior, and immunochemical features of the XY body during pachytene. In all these species, the sex chromosomes form an XY body easily identifiable in thin sections by the special and regular packing of the chromatin fibers of the internal region of the XY body (“differential” regions) and those of the peripheral region (synaptic region). Spermatocyte spreads show a complete synapsis between the X- and the Y-axis, which lasts up to the end of pachytene. From the early pachytene substages to the late ones, the X-axis develops prominent branches, which in late pachytene span the synaptic region. Synapsis is regular as shown by SYCP1 labeling. Axial development is followed by SYCP3 labeling and in the asynaptic region of the X-axis by BRCA1. Gamma-H2AX labels exclusively the differential (asynaptic) region of the X chromosome. A single focus is labeled by MLH1 in the synaptic region. The location of this MLH1 focus spans from 0.3 to 1.6 μm from the telomere in the analyzed xenarthrans, covering approximately half of the Y-axis length. It is concluded that xenarthrans, as basal placental mammals, harbor the largest pseudoautosomal regions of presently analyzed mammals, and shows the typical features of meiotic sex chromosome inactivation (MSCI).     

Sororin is enriched at the central region of synapsed meiotic chromosomes

During meiotic prophase, cohesin complexes mediate cohesion between sister chromatids and promote pairing and synapsis of homologous chromosomes. Precisely how the activity of cohesin is controlled to promote these events is not fully understood. In metazoans, cohesion establishment between sister chromatids during mitotic divisions is accompanied by recruitment of the cohesion-stabilizing protein Sororin. During somatic cell division cycles, Sororin is recruited in response to DNA replication-dependent modification of the cohesin complex by ESCO acetyltransferases. How Sororin is recruited and acts in meiosis is less clear. Here, we have surveyed the chromosomal localization of Sororin and its relationship to the meiotic cohesins and other chromatin modifiers with the objective of determining how Sororin contributes to meiotic chromosome dynamics. We show that Sororin localizes to the cores of meiotic chromosomes in a manner that is dependent on synapsis and the synaptonemal complex protein SYCP1. In contrast, cohesin, with which Sororin interacts in mitotic cells, shows axial enrichment on meiotic chromosomes even in the absence of synapsis between homologs. Using high-resolution microscopy, we show that Sororin is localized to the central region of the synaptonemal complex. These results indicate that Sororin regulation during meiosis is distinct from its regulation in mitotic cells and may suggest that it interacts with a distinctly different partner to ensure proper chromosome dynamics in meiosis.     

Multiple sex chromosomes in the light of female meiotic drive in amniote vertebrates

It is notable that the occurrence of multiple sex chromosomes differs significantly between major lineages of amniote vertebrates. In this respect, birds are especially conspicuous, as multiple sex chromosomes have not been observed in this lineage so far. On the other hand, in mammals, multiple sex chromosomes have evolved many times independently. We hypothesize that this contrast can be related to the different involvement of sex-specific sex chromosomes in female meiosis subjected to the female meiotic drive under male versus female heterogamety. Essentially, the male-specific Y chromosome is not involved in female meiosis and is therefore sheltered against the effects of the female meiotic drive affecting the X chromosome and autosomes. Conversely, the Z and W sex chromosomes are both present in female meiosis. Nonrandom segregation of these sex chromosomes as a consequence of their rearrangements connected with the emergence of multiple sex chromosomes would result in a biased sex ratio, which should be penalized by selection. Therefore, the emergence of multiple sex chromosomes should be less constrained in the lineages with male rather than female heterogamety. Our broader phylogenetic comparison across amniotes supports this prediction. We suggest that our results are consistent with the widespread occurrence of female meiotic drive in amniotes.     

Evolution of the karyotype and sex chromosome systems in basal clades of araneomorph spiders (Araneae: Araneomorphae)

Concepts of spider karyotype evolution are based mostly on advanced and most diversified clade, the entelegyne lineage of araneomorph spiders. Hence the typical spider karyotype is supposed to consist exclusively of acrocentric chromosomes including the multiple X chromosomes. However, our data show considerable diversity of chromosome morphology and sex chromosome systems in basal clades of araneomorphs. Karyotypes of basal araneomorphs consist of holocentric (superfamily Dysderoidea) or normal chromosomes with localized centromere. In males of basal araneomorphs the prophase of first meiotic division includes a long diffuse stage. Multiple X chromosomes are less common in basal clades. The sex chromosome system of many families includes a Y chromosome or nucleolus organizer region that occurs rarely in the entelegyne spiders. A derived X₁X₂Y system with an achiasmatic sex-chromosome pairing during meiosis was found in the families Drymusidae, Hypochilidae, Filistatidae, Sicariidae, and Pholcidae. This suggests a monophyletic origin of the families. In some lineages the X₁X₂Y system converted into an X0 system, as found in some pholcids, or into an XY system, which is typical for the family Diguetidae. The remarkable karyotype and sex chromosome system diversity allows us to distinguish four evolutionary lineages of basal araneomorphs and hypothesize about the ancestral karyotype of araneomorphs.     

Meiotic recombination in <Emphasis Type="Italic">Caenorhabditis elegans</Emphasis>

The faithful segregation of homologous chromosomes during meiosis is dependent on the formation of physical connections (chiasma) that form following reciprocal exchange of DNA molecules during meiotic recombination. Here we review the current knowledge in the Caenorhabditis elegans meiotic recombination field. We discuss recent developments that have improved our understanding of the crucial steps that must precede the initiation and propagation of meiotic recombination. We summarize the pathways that impact on meiotic prophase entry and the current understanding of how chromosomes reorganize and interact to promote homologous chromosome pairing and subsequent synapsis. We pay particular attention to the mechanisms that contribute to meiotic DNA double-strand break (DSB) formation and strand exchange processes, and how the C. elegans system compares with other model organisms. Finally, we highlight current and future areas of research that are likely to further our understanding of the meiotic recombination process.     

The evolution of the mammalian Y chromosome

There is a predominant theory for the evolution of the mammalian Y chromosome. This theory hypothesizes that genes for sex determination and male-specific traits, as well as sequences for X-Y meiotic pairing, are conserved on the mammalian Y chromosome across all lineages and that all other Y chromosomal genes or sequences have been or will be lost in each mammalian lineage. There are effects of mouse Y chromosomal genes on behaviors and other traits that are not male specific. Under the predominant theory, these Y chromosomal genes could be the same as the conserved genes for sex determination or malespecific traits, or they could be genes that have been lost from the Y chromosomes of other mammalian lineages and that will eventually be lost from the Y chromosome of the rodent lineage. Recently, the evolution of the primate and rodent Y chromosomes has been studied at the DNA level. These studies are summarized and reviewed in this article. The findings of these studies are not fully consistent with the predominant theory for the evolution of the mammalian Y chromosome. Also, they imply that there are other possibilities for the phylogenetic history of Y chromosomal genes of mice with effects on behavior. These are that Y chromosomal genes with effects on mouse behaviors or other traits could be conserved genes other than those for sex determination or malespecific traits or that they could be novel genes on the Y chromosome of the rodent orMus lineage.     

Meiotic chromosomes and stages of sex chromosome evolution in fish: zebrafish, platyfish and guppy

We describe SC complements and results from comparative genomic hybridization (CGH) on mitotic and meiotic chromosomes of the zebrafish Danio rerio, the platyfish Xiphophorus maculatus and the guppy Poecilia reticulata. The three fish species represent basic steps of sex chromosome differentiation: (1) the zebrafish with an all-autosome karyotype; (2) the platyfish with genetically defined sex chromosomes but no differentiation between X and Y visible in the SC or with CGH in meiotic and mitotic chromosomes; (3) the guppy with genetically and cytogenetically differentiated sex chromosomes. The acrocentric Y chromosomes of the guppy consists of a proximal homologous and a distal differential segment. The proximal segment pairs in early pachytene with the respective X chromosome segment. The differential segment is unpaired in early pachytene but synapses later in an ‘adjustment’ or ‘equalization’ process. The segment includes a postulated sex determining region and a conspicuous variable heterochromatic region whose structure depends on the particular Y chromosome line. CGH differentiates a large block of predominantly male-specific repetitive DNA and a block of common repetitive DNA in that region. This revised version was published online in July 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

HORMAD1-dependent checkpoint/surveillance mechanism eliminates asynaptic oocytes

Meiotic pachytene checkpoints monitor the failure of homologous recombination and synapsis to ensure faithful chromosome segregation during gamete formation. To date, the molecular basis of the mammalian pachytene checkpoints has remained largely unknown. We here report that mouse HORMAD1 is required for a meiotic prophase checkpoint that eliminates asynaptic oocytes. Hormad1-deficient mice are infertile and show an extensive failure of homologous pairing and synapsis, consistent with the evolutionarily conserved function of meiotic HORMA domain proteins. Unexpectedly, Hormad1-deficient ovaries contain a normal number of oocytes despite asynapsis and consequently produce aneuploid oocytes, indicating a checkpoint failure. By the analysis of Hormad1/Spo11 double mutants, the Hormad1 deficiency was found to abrogate the massive oocyte loss in the Spo11-deficient ovary. The Hormad1 deficiency also causes the eventual loss of pseudo sex body in the Spo11-deficient ovary and testis. These results suggest the involvement of HORMAD1 in the repressive chromatin domain formation that is proposed to be important in the meiotic prophase checkpoints. We also show the extensive phosphorylation of HORMAD1 in the Spo11-deficient testis and ovary, suggesting an involvement of novel DNA damage-independent phosphorylation signaling in the surveillance mechanism. Our present results provide clues to HORMAD1-dependent checkpoint in response to asynapsis in mammalian meiosis.     

A repeat DNA sequence from the Y chromosome in species of the genus <Emphasis Type="Italic">Microtus</Emphasis>

In most mammals, the Y chromosome is composed of a large amount of constitutive heterochromatin. In some Microtus species, this feature is also extended to the X chromosome, resulting in enlarged (giant) sex chromosomes. Several repeated DNA sequences have been described in the gonosomal heterochromatin of these species, indicating that it has heterogeneous and species-specific composition and distribution. We have cloned an AT-rich, 851-bp long, repeated DNA sequence specific for M. cabrerae Y chromosome heterochromatin. The analysis of other species of the genus Microtus indicated that this sequence is also located on the Y chromosome (male-specific) in three species (M. agrestis, M. oeconomus and M. nivalis), present on both Y and X chromosomes and on some autosomes in M. arvalis and absent in the genome of M. guentheri. Our data also suggest that the mechanism of heterochromatin amplification operating on the sex chromosomes could have been different in each species since the repeated sequences of the gonosomal heterochromatic blocks in M. cabrerae and M. agrestis are different. The absence of this sequence in the mouse genome indicates that its evolutionary origin could be recent. Future analysis of the species distribution, localization and sequence of this repeat DNA family in arvicolid rodent species could help to establish the unsolved phylogenetic relationships in this rodent group.     

Protein immunolocalization supports the presence of identical mechanisms of XY body formation in eutherians and marsupials

The meiotic sex chromosomes of the American marsupials Monodelphis dimidiata and Didelphis albiventris were studied with electron microscopy (EM) and with immunofluorescence localization of meiotic proteins SYCP1 and SYCP3, and proteins essential for meiotic sex chromosome inactivation (MSCI), γ-H2AX and BRCA1. The chromatin of the non-synaptic X and Y chromosomes contains γ-H2AX, first as foci and then as homogeneous staining at late stages. The thick and split X and Y axes are labelled with BRCA1 except at one terminus. The bulgings of the axes contain SYCP1 as well as the inner side of the dense plate. The evenly spaced and highly packed chromatin fibres of the conjoined XY body in these species have the same behaviour and the same components (γ-H2AX in the chromatin, BRCA1 in the axes) as in the XY body of eutherian species. These observations and recent data from the literature suggest that XY body formation is ancestral to the metatherian–eutherian divergence.     

Effect of colchicine and telocentric chromosome conformation on centromere and telomere dynamics at meiotic prophase I in wheat–rye additions

Association of telomeres in a bouquet and clustering of centromere regions have been proposed to be involved in the search and recognition of homologous partners. We have analysed the role of these structures in meiotic chromosome pairing in wheat–rye addition lines by applying colchicine for disturbing presynaptic telomere movements and by modifying the centromere position from submetacentric to telocentric for studying centromere effects. Rye chromosomes, wheat and rye centromeres, and telomeres were identified by fluorescence in-situ hybridization. Presynaptic association of centromeres in pairs or in more complex structures involved mainly non-homologous chromosomes as deduced from the behaviour of rye centromeres. While centromere association was not affected by colchicine, colchicine inhibited bouquet formation, which caused failure of homologous synapsis. Homologous centromeres of rye telocentrics associated earlier than those of rye submetacentric chromosomes, indicating that migration of the telocentrics’ centromeres to the telomere pole during bouquet formation facilitated their association. Homologous chromosomes associated in premeiotic interphase can recognize each other and initiate synapsis at zygotene. However, telomere convergence is needed for bringing together the majority of homologous pairs that normally occupy separate territories in premeiotic nuclei.     

The origin and loss of the ubiquitin activating enzyme gene on the mammalian Y chromosome

Mammalian sex chromosomes are thought to be descended from a homologous pair of autosomes: a testis-determining allele which defined the Y chromosome arose, recombination between the nascent X and Y chromosomes became restricted and the Y chromosome gradually lost its non-essential genetic functions. This model was originally inferred from the occurrence of few Y-linked genetic traits, pairing of the X and Y chromosomes during male meiosis and, more recently, the existence of X- Y homologous genes. The comparative analysis of such genes is a means by which the validity of this model can be evaluated. One well-studied example of an X-Y homologous gene is the ubiquitin activating enzyme gene ( UBE1 ), which is X-linked with a distinct Y-linked gene in many eutherian ('placental') and metatherian (marsupial) mammals. Nonetheless, no UBE1 homologue has yet been detected on the human Y chromosome. Here we describe a more extensive study of UBE1 homologues in primates and a prototherian mammal, the platypus. Our findings indicate that UBE1 lies within the X-Y pairing segment of the platypus but is absent from the human Y chromosome, having been lost from the Y chromosome during evolution of the primate lineage. Thus UBE1 illustrates the key steps of 'autosomal to X-specific' evolution of genes on the sex chromosomes.      

MutS homolog 4 localization to meiotic chromosomes is required for chromosome pairing during meiosis in male and female mice

Msh4 (MutS homolog 4) is a member of the mammalian mismatch repair gene family whose members are involved in postreplicative DNA mismatch repair as well as in the control of meiotic recombination. In this report we show that MSH4 has an essential role in the control of male and female meiosis. We demonstrate that MSH4 is present in the nuclei of spermatocytes early in prophase I and that it forms discrete foci along meiotic chromosomes during the zygotene and pachytene stages of meiosis. Disruption of the Msh4 gene in mice results in male and female sterility due to meiotic failure. Although meiosis is initiated in Msh4 mutant male and female mice, as indicated by the chromosomal localization of RAD51 and COR1 during leptonema/zygonema, the chromosomes fail to undergo normal pairing. Our results show that MSH4 localization on chromosomes during the early stages of meiosis is essential for normal chromosome synapsis in prophase I and that it acts in the same pathway as MSH5.     

The frequency of heterologous synapsis increases with aging in Robertsonian heterozygous male mice

The house mouse is characterised by highly variable chromosome number due to the presence of Robertsonian (Rb) chromosomes. During meiosis in Rb heterozygotes, intricated chromosomal figures are produced, and many unsynapsed regions are present during the first prophase, triggering a meiotic silencing of unsynapsed chromatin (MSUC) in a similar mode to the sex chromosome inactivation. The presence of unsynapsed chromosome regions is associated with impaired spermatogenesis. Interestingly, in male mice carrying multiple Rb trivalents, the frequency of germ cell death, defective tubules, and altered sperm morphology decreases during aging. Here, we studied whether synapsis of trivalent chromosomes and MSUC are involved in this improvement. By immunocytochemistry, we analysed the frequency of unsynapsed chromosomes and of those positive to γH2AX (a marker of MSUC) labelling in spermatocytes of 3-, 5- and 7-month-old Rb heterozygotes. With aging, we observed a decrease of the frequency of unsynapsed chromosomes, of spermatocytes bearing them and of trivalents carrying γH2AX-negative unsynapsed regions. Our quantitative results show that both synapsis and MSUC processes are better accomplished during male aging, partially accounting for the improvement of spermatogenesis.