Minimal residual disease assessment in childhood acute lymphoblastic leukaemia: a Swedish multi-centre study comparing real-time polymerase chain reaction and multicolour flow cytometry

Minimal residual disease (MRD) assessment is a powerful prognostic factor for determining the risk of relapse in childhood acute lymphoblastic leukaemia (ALL). In this Swedish multi-centre study of childhood ALL diagnosed between 2002 and 2006, the MRD levels were analysed in 726 follow-up samples in 228 children using real-time quantitative polymerase chain reaction (RQ-PCR) of rearranged immunoglobulin/T-cell receptor genes and multicolour flow cytometry (FCM). Using an MRD threshold of 0·1%, which was the sensitivity level reached in all analyses, the concordance between RQ-PCR and FCM MRD values at day 29 was 84%. In B-cell precursor ALL, an MRD level of ≥0·1% at day 29 predicted a higher risk of bone marrow relapse (BMR) with both methods, although FCM was a better discriminator. However, considering the higher median MRD values achieved with RQ-PCR, a higher MRD cut-off (≥0·2%) improved the predictive capacity of RQ-PCR. In T-ALL, RQ-PCR was notably superior to FCM in predicting risk of BMR. That notwithstanding, MRD levels of ≥0·1%, detected by either method at day 29, could not predict isolated extramedullary relapse. In conclusion, the concordance between RQ-PCR and FCM was high and hence both methods are valuable clinical tools for identifying childhood ALL cases with increased risk of BMR.     

Simultaneous detection and quantification of minimal residual disease in childhood acute lymphoblastic leukaemia using real-time polymerase chain reaction

A number of prospective studies have indicated the clinical utility of measuring minimal residual disease (MRD) in childhood acute lymphoblastic leukaemia (ALL) and have highlighted the need for improved methodology for quantification of residual disease. We describe a novel real-time polymerase chain reaction (PCR) strategy for MRD analysis based on the exonuclease activity of Taq polymerase to cleave a fluorescently labelled probe. Using a consensus probe designed to the framework 2 region of the IgH gene, together with leukaemia-specific primers, the utility of this technique for simultaneous detection and quantification of MRD was demonstrated in samples from six ALL patients. This technique provides a rapid quantitative assay for determining MRD levels which lends itself to the routine monitoring of minimal residual leukaemia.     

Outcome prediction by immunophenotypic minimal residual disease detection in adult T-cell acute lymphoblastic leukaemia

Flow-cytometric detection of minimal residual disease (MRD) identifies patients with high relapse risk in childhood acute lymphoblastic leukaemia (ALL). We studied the efficacy of this method in adult T-ALL treated with the Italian co-operative GIMEMA (Gruppo Italiano Malattie Ematologiche dell'Adulto) LAL0496 protocol. Bone marrow samples from 53 patients were taken at fixed treatment time points and MRD was analysed using a leukaemia-specific immunophenotype (cytoplasmic-CD3/nuclear-terminal desoxynucleotidyl transferase). The median follow-up was 17 months (range 3-61) and a median of 4.5 analyses/patient was performed (range 3-12). Six out of 53 (11.3%) patients were refractory to treatment, 30/53 (56.6%) relapsed and 17/53 (32.1%) remain in continuous complete remission. The probability of relapse at 2 years for MRD-positive patients at preconsolidation was 81.5%vs 38.9% for MRD-negative patients (P = 0.00078). This risk was still 54.5% for MRD-positive vs 15.8% for MRD-negative patients pre-third reinduction (P = 0.0098) and 50.0% for MRD-positive vs 16.4% for MRD-negative patients pre-sixth reinduction (P = 0.032). The relapse-predicting value of MRD did not depend on features at diagnosis such as age, sex and leucocyte count. Our data suggest that immunophenotypic MRD monitoring in the first year of treatment is a useful outcome predictor for adult T-ALL patients.     

Concurrent detection of minimal residual disease (MRD) in childhood acute lymphoblastic leukaemia by flow cytometry and real-time PCR

Minimal (i.e. submicroscopic) residual disease (MRD) predicts outcome in childhood acute lymphoblastic leukaemia (ALL). To be used clinically, MRD assays must be reliable and accurate. Two well-established techniques, flow cytometry (FC) and polymerase chain reaction (PCR), can detect leukaemic cells with a sensitivity of 0.01% (10(-4)). We analysed diagnostic samples of 45 ALL-patients (37 B-lineage ALL, eight T-lineage ALL) by four-colour FC and real-time PCR. Leukaemia-associated immunophenotypes, at a sensitivity of MRD detection by FC at the 0.01% level, were identified in 41 cases (91%); antigen-receptor gene rearrangements suitable for MRD detection with a sensitivity of 0.01% or better by PCR were identified in 38 cases (84%). The combined use of FC and PCR allowed MRD monitoring in all 45 patients. In 105 follow-up samples, MRD estimates by both methods were highly concordant, with a deviation factor of <5 by Bland-Altman analysis. Importantly, the concordance between FC and PCR was also observed in regenerating bone marrow samples containing high proportions of CD19(+) cells, and in samples studied 24 h after collection. We conclude that both MRD assays yield generally concordant results. Their combined use should enable MRD monitoring in virtually all patients and prevent false-negative results due to clonal evolution or phenotypic shifts.     

Pre‐ and post‐transplant minimal residual disease predicts relapse occurrence in children with acute lymphoblastic leukaemia

Relapse remains the leading cause of treatment failure in children with acute lymphoblastic leukaemia (ALL) undergoing allogeneic haematopoietic stem cell transplantation (HSCT). We retrospectively investigated the prognostic role of minimal residual disease (MRD) before and after HSCT in 119 children transplanted in complete remission (CR). MRD was measured by polymerase chain reaction in bone marrow samples collected pre‐HSCT and during the first and third trimesters after HSCT (post‐HSCT1 and post‐HSCT3). The overall event‐free survival (EFS) was 50%. The cumulative incidence of relapse and non‐relapse mortality was 41% and 9%. Any degree of detectable pre‐HSCT MRD was associated with poor outcome: EFS was 39% and 18% in patients with MRD positivity <1 × 10⁻³ and ≥1 × 10⁻³, respectively, versus 73% in MRD‐negative patients (P < 0·001). This effect was maintained in different disease remissions, but low‐level MRD had a very strong negative impact only in patients transplanted in second or further CR. Also, MRD after HSCT enabled patients to be stratified, with increasing MRD between post‐HSCT1 and post‐HSCT3 clearly defining cohorts with a different outcome. MRD is an important prognostic factor both before and after transplantation. Given that MRD persistence after HSCT is associated with dismal outcome, these patients could benefit from early discontinuation of immunosuppression, or pre‐emptive immuno‐therapy.     

Low burden of minimal residual disease prior to transplantation in children with very high risk acute lymphoblastic leukaemia: The NOPHO ALL2008 experience

The population-based Nordic/Baltic acute lymphoblastic leukaemia (ALL) Nordic Society for Paediatric Haematology and Oncology (NOPHO) ALL2008 protocol combined minimal residual disease (MRD)-driven treatment stratification with very intense first line chemotherapy for patients with high risk ALL. Patients with MRD ≥5% at end of induction or ≥10⁻³ at end of consolidation or following two high risk blocks were eligible for haematopoietic cell transplantation (HCT) in first remission. After at least three high risk blocks a total of 71 children received HCT, of which 46 had MRD ≥5% at end of induction. Ten patients stratified to HCT were not transplanted; 12 received HCT without protocol indication. Among 69 patients with evaluable pre-HCT MRD results, 22 were MRD-positive, one with MRD ≥10⁻³. After a median follow-up of 5·5 years, the cumulative incidence of relapse was 23·5% (95% confidence interval [CI]: 10·5–47·7) for MRD-positive versus 5·1% (95% CI: 1·3–19·2), P = 0·02) for MRD-negative patients. MRD was the only variable significantly associated with relapse (hazard ratio 9·1, 95% CI: 1·6–51·0, P = 0·012). Non-relapse mortality did not differ between the two groups, resulting in disease-free survival of 85·6% (95% CI: 75·4–97·2) and 67·4% (95% CI: 50·2–90·5), respectively. In conclusion, NOPHO block treatment efficiently reduced residual leukaemia which, combined with modern transplant procedures, provided high survival rates, also among pre-HCT MRD-positive patients.     

Whole‐genome amplification for the detection of molecular targets and minimal residual disease monitoring in acute lymphoblastic leukaemia

Accurate genomic characterization requires sufficient amounts of optimal quality DNA. An approach for increasing the DNA amount is the whole‐genome amplification (WGA) method. We applied WGA to the molecular quantification and minimal residual disease (MRD) evaluation of acute lymphoblastic leukaemia (ALL), aiming to compare the results obtained from genomic DNA and amplified DNA with WGA, and to evaluate the applicability and the reliability of WGA‐DNA. Twenty paired samples from adult ALL patients were sequenced to identify the functional germline V‐D‐J segment at diagnosis; real‐time quantitative polymerase chain reaction (RQ‐PCR) quantitative analysis was performed both at diagnosis and follow‐up. Genomic DNA and WGA‐DNA screening identified equivalent 87 rearrangements. At diagnosis, the quantitative evaluation of genomic DNA samples showed 1 logarithm difference to WGA‐DNA samples; these levels are comparable, being within the degree of acceptability and confidence. In the follow‐up samples, RQ‐PCR analysis on genomic DNA and WGA showed concordant MRD results in 16/18 samples, while 2/18 were MRD‐positive outside the quantitative range by RQ‐PCR (i.e. <5 × 10^?5) on genomic DNA and MRD‐negative on WGA‐DNA. WGA‐DNA enables: (i) the design of accurate targets for MRD evaluation in ALL patients, (ii) accurate disease quantification at diagnosis, (iii) MRD quantification comparable to genomic DNA.     

Resolution of ambiguous low-level positive quantitative polymerase chain reaction results in TEL-AML1 positive ALL using a post-PCR fluorescent oligoligation method

The interpretation of low-level or non-reproducible amplification results in clinical quantitative polymerase chain reaction (Q-PCR) assays can be difficult to definitively resolve. Concerning minimal residual disease detection in leukaemia, indeterminate low-level results might create prognostic or therapeutic dilemmas. We evaluated low-level, ambiguous Q-PCR results in a study of paired diagnostic and end-induction (day 29) TEL-AML1 positive acute lymphoblastic leukaemia samples utilising a novel fluorescent primer ligation detection assay. The data presented here indicate that a significant number of low-level apparent Q-PCR positive results may be spurious or non-specific in nature, requiring additional technical manoeuvres for confirmation of true positive cases.     

Low frequency of clonotypic Ig and T-cell receptor gene rearrangements in t(4;11) infant acute lymphoblastic leukaemia and its implication for the detection of minimal residual disease

Infant t(4;11) acute lymphoblastic leukaemia (ALL) is a rare but cytogenetically well defined subgroup of immature B-cell precursor (BCP) ALL. To date, the configuration of their antigen receptor genes has not been studied in a large group of patients so far. In this study on 27 t(4;11) infant ALL, we have used standardized primer sets for the detection of all incomplete and complete immunoglobulin (Ig) heavy chain (IGH) rearrangements, as well as for the Ig light chain kappa (IGK), T-cell receptor delta (TCRD) and gamma (TCRG) rearrangements that are most common in childhood BCP ALL. Only 52% of cases displayed clonotypic antigen receptor gene rearrangements (IGH in 48%, IGK, TCRD and TCRG in 12%, 41% and 6% respectively). This low frequency suggests, together with the findings of predominantly incomplete DJh joins and monoallelic IGH rearrangements, that they are derived from an immature progenitor cell. As 48% of the t(4;11) infant ALL cases had no detectable antigen receptor gene rearrangements that could be used for minimal residual disease (MRD) analysis, we established an expression-independent, leukaemia-specific polymerase chain reaction (PCR) using the genomic sequence of the MLL-AF4 fusion genes. This method had high sensitivity and specificity and resulted in identical estimations of tumour loads when compared with IGH targets. Thus, genomic MLL-AF4 fusion genes are a good alternative target for the analysis of MRD in patients with t(4;11) leukaemias.     

Applicability of IG/TCR gene rearrangements as targets for minimal residual disease assessment in a population‐based cohort of Swedish childhood acute lymphoblastic leukaemia diagnosed 2002–2006

Minimal residual disease (MRD) detection during the early treatment phase has become an important stratification parameter in many childhood acute lymphoblastic leukaemia (ALL) treatment protocols. Here, we aimed to address the applicability of rearranged antigen‐receptor genes as potential MRD markers using real‐time quantitative polymerase chain reaction (RQ‐PCR) in a Swedish population‐based cohort. From 334 childhood ALL cases diagnosed during 2002–2006, we analysed 279 diagnostic samples (84%) by screening for rearranged immunoglobulin (IG) and T‐cell receptor (TCR) genes. Allele‐specific oligonucleotides were designed, and the sensitivity and quantitative level was determined for each target. Overall, clonal IG/TCR rearrangements were detected in 97% (236/244) of B‐cell precursor ALL (BCP ALL) and 94% (33/35) of T‐ALL. A sensitive RQ‐PCR analysis (≤10^?4) was obtained in 89% (216/244) of BCP ALL and in 74% (26/35) of T‐ALL, whereas two sensitive targets were only available in 47% (115/244) of BCP ALL and 29% (10/35) of T‐ALL cases. With the stratification threshold of ≥10^?3, which is applied in the current Nordic treatment protocol (NOPHO‐ALL 2008) for the identification of high‐risk patients, 93% of BCP ALL and 86% of T‐ALL reached this quantitative range by at least one target gene. Taken together, this national retrospective study demonstrates that an IG/TCR target for MRD monitoring can be identified in the majority of childhood ALL cases, whereas identification of a second sensitive target gene needs to be improved.     

Clinical significance of minimal residual disease at day 15 and at the end of therapy in childhood acute lymphoblastic leukaemia

Detection of minimal residual disease (MRD) after induction and consolidation therapy is highly predictive of outcome for childhood acute lymphoblastic leukaemia (ALL) and is used to identify patients at high risk of relapse in several current clinical trials. To evaluate the prognostic significance of MRD at other treatment phases, MRD was measured by real-time quantitative polymerase chain reaction on a selected group of 108 patients enrolled on the Australian and New Zealand Children's Cancer Study Group Study VII including 36 patients with a bone marrow or central nervous system relapse and 72 matched patients in first remission. MRD was prognostic of outcome at all five treatment phases tested: at day 15 (MRD ≥ 5 × 10⁻², log rank P  < 0·0001), day 35 (≥1 × 10⁻², P  = 0·0001), 4 months (≥5 × 10⁻⁴, P  < 0·0001), 12 months (MRD ≥ 1 × 10⁻⁴, P  = 0·006) and 24 months (MRD ≥ 1 × 10⁻⁴, P  < 0·0001). Day 15 was the best early MRD time-point to differentiate between patients with high, intermediate and low risk of relapse. MRD testing at 12 and particularly at 24 months, detected molecular relapses in some patients up to 6 months before clinical relapse. This raised the question of whether a strategy of late monitoring and salvage therapy will improve outcome.