Advantages and disadvantages of coils for transcatheter closure of patent ductus arteriosus

Different coils have been used to close the patient ductus arteriosus (PDA). In small- and moderate-sized PDA, coils are an adequate alternative to surgery and/or to other devices. The aim of the study is to review and discuss the advantages and disadvantages of using coils (excluding PFM coils PFM Medical, Germany) to close PDA. Cambier was the first to successfully close a PDA using a Gianturco coil. To date, thousands of patients worldwide have undergone transcatheter closure of PDA using this or other types of coils. The use of coils is analyzed with regard to costs in comparison with other therapeutic modalities; techniques--anterograde, retrograde approach, selection of coil size--in relation to the size of the PDA and the available sizes of coils; efficacy of the rate of complete occlusion and the need for reocclusion; and safety in relation to embolization rate, other complications including hemolysis, left pulmonary artery LPA stenosis and coarctation. It is concluded that coils are a cheap alternative for the occlusion of PDA in the small-to-moderate PDA. The technique can be learned quite quickly, it has a high rate of complete occlusion, and has an acceptable rate of safety. The disadvantages include a moderate rate of coil embolization and of hemolysis in patients with residual shunt after coil occlusion in large PDAs. When more than one coil is used, the potential for developing LPA stenosis is high.     

Severe intravascular hemolysis after transcatheter coil occlusion of patent ductus arteriosus

Severe intravascular hemolysis is a rare complication of transcatheter closure of patent ductus arteriosus (PDA). It is thought to be secondary to red blood cell damage from a high-velocity jet from a residual shunt. However, only a small minority of patients with a residual shunt develop this complication. We report a case of intravascular hemolysis after partial coil occlusion of a PDA in which the Dacron strands were stripped off the coils during bioptome-assisted deployment. The exposure of the blood flow jet to bare metallic coils may have contributed to the occurrence of the severe hemolysis.     

Bioptome-assisted simultaneous delivery of multiple coils for occlusion of the large patent ductus arteriosus.

We describe a novel method that allows bioptome-assisted delivery of multiple Gianturco coils simultaneously for occlusion of the large patent ductus arteriosus (PDA). Two or more coils were intertwined at one end and held by a bioptome (5.2 Fr) and pulled into a short introducer. The coils were then deployed in the PDA via a long sheath (7-11 Fr) previously placed across the duct via the femoral vein. Twelve patients (6 months to 64 years; median, 10.5 years) with large PDAs (4.7 +/- 1.3 mm; range, 3.1-8.4 mm; PA mean pressure, 40 +/- 17 mm Hg; pulse pressure 63 +/- 18 mm Hg) underwent bioptome-assisted occlusion with multiple coils at our institutions. The procedure was uneventful in nine patients (fluoroscopy time, 6-23 min) and prolonged in three patients (fluoroscopy time, 26, 72, and 120 min) because of dislodgment of the coil mass and embolization of an additional coil. Successful coil deployment was feasible in all patients. Three patients required repeat coil deployment for flow elimination (hemolysis occurred in two). Flow elimination was demonstrated on the last follow-up evaluation in all except two patients. One infant has developed significant left pulmonary artery stenosis. Bioptome-assisted PDA occlusion using multiple coils delivered simultaneously may be a promising alternative to devices for transcatheter closure of large PDAs. Cathet Cardiovasc Intervent 2001;54:95-100.     

Hemolysis complicating coil occlusion of patent ductus arteriosus

We report on 5 patients who developed hemolysis (the Hemolysis group) following coil occlusion for PDA, and compare their data to 66 cases which were not complicated by hemolysis despite residual leak (the No Hemolysis group). A significant leak with a heart murmur was more frequent in the Hemolysis group than in the No Hemolysis group. The ratio of the sum of the loop diameter of coils to the minimal diameter of the ductus (C/D) in those who developed persistent hemolysis that needed a second intervention (2.2 ± 0.4) was significantly smaller than in the No Hemolysis group (3.1 ± 1.1). Persistent hemolysis can occur if a significant residual shunt remains after implantation of coils with small C/D. As this complication may be avoided by complete closure or, if not complete, a minimal leak, we should be careful to make residual leaks as small as possible by the use of multiple coils. Cathet. Cardiovasc. Diagn. 43:50–53, 1998. © 1998 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Retrograde transcatheter occlusion of patent ductus arteriosus: preliminary experience in Gianturco coil technique without heparinization

BACKGROUND: The aim of this study was to report the initial experience of using the Gianturco coil (Cook Cardiology, Bloomington, Indiana) without heparinization to close patent ductus arteriosus (PDA). PATIENTS AND METHODS: Forty consecutive patients (30 females, 10 males) underwent transcatheter closure of a PDA via the right femoral artery approach without heparinization. Patients ages ranged from 7 months to 55 years (median, 6.8 years); weights ranged from 7.8 65 kg (median, 18.3 kg). Twenty-one patients had cardiomegaly (n = 21), congestive heart failure (n = 10), or both (n = 10). The PDAs measured 0.8 4.5 mm (median, 2.6 mm) at the narrowest diameter; the mean Qp/Qs ranged from 1.0 2.6 (1.4 +/- 0.4). The helical diameter of the coil that we chose was 1.7 times the narrowest PDA diameter. The length of the coil was sufficient to produce 4 or 5 loops. RESULTS: Successful coil placement was accomplished in all 40 patients. Thirty-five patients (87.5%) underwent single coil implantation, 2 patients (5%) had 2 coils, and 3 patients (7.5%) had 3 coils. Complete ductus occlusion was achieved in 80% of cases at the end of the procedure, while 8 patients had minimal shunt detected by aortography or echocardiography. The occlusion rate increased to 87.5% by the next day, 90% by 1 month, 92.5% by 3 months, 95% by 6 months, and 97.5% by 9 and 12 months. Only one asymptomatic patient had minimal residual shunt detected by color Doppler at 12 months follow-up. At a median follow-up of 17 months (range, 5 25 months), no patient had thromboembolism, endocarditis, coil migration, diminished femoral pulse or hemolysis. CONCLUSION: Our preliminary results suggest that retrograde transcatheter closure of PDA with the Gianturco coil without heparinization is feasible, safe and efficacious. A single coil allowed complete occlusion of PDA 3 mm in diameter.     

Comparison and results of transcatheter closure of patent ductus arteriosus using the swivel-disk device versus plug occluder in children

The transcatheter closure of certain types of patent ductus arteriosus (PDA) remains a challenge. The investigators report initial clinical experience with 25 patients who underwent PDA occlusion with the use of a swivel-disk device (SDD) or a plug occluder (PO). The patients were divided into 2 groups: in the SDD group, 12 patients aged 1 to 2 years with type A PDA underwent attempted closure using the SDD, a modified Amplatzer duct occluder with a very low profile retention disk that can adapt itself at different PDA insertion angles. The mean PDA diameter was 4.8 +/- 1.5 mm (range 3.8 to 8). In the PO group, 13 patients aged 0.5 to 3 years with type C, D, or E PDA underwent attempted occlusion with the PO, a tubular occluder made of Nitinol wire mesh. The mean PDA diameter was 4.2 +/- 3.5 mm (range 1.2 to 9). The 2 occluders are filled with Dacron patches. The mean device diameters were 6.5 +/- 1.2 and 6.8 +/- 2.2 mm (range 4 to 11) in the SDD and PO groups, respectively. Complete angiographic closure was seen in 24 of 25 patients. The deployment of 4 5-PDA5 coils abolished a residual shunt associated with hemolysis in a 5-month-old patient with a large type C PDA after the implantation of an 11-mm PO. No other complications were observed. In conclusion, the SDD and the PO are promising additions to the armamentarium for PDA closure.     

Transcatheter occlusion of the patent ductus arteriosus with a single device technique: comparison between the Cook detachable coil and the Rashkind umbrella device

Transcatheter coil occlusion of the patent ductus arteriosus (PDA) has become the interventional treatment option of choice. Immediate occlusion of any residual shunting results in excellent closure rates, but frequently requires multiple coil deployment. Aims: To assess the efficacy and limitations of single Cook detachable coil PDA closure compared to a preceding series of Rashkind umbrella procedures. Methods and results: Between 1990 and 1999, transcatheter occlusion of a small (<2 mm; n=45) or moderate-sized (2-4 mm; n=47) PDA was successfully attempted in 90/92 consecutive patients (mean age 6+/-4.8 years) with a coil (39/41) or Rashkind device (51/51). Immediate angiographic closure rates for both devices were low, although better for small (54-68%) than moderate ducts (7-22%, P<0.01). A 2-year echocardiographic closure rate of small ducts increased to 92% for the coil group versus 95% for the Rashkind group. By that time, moderate-sized ducts were only occluded in 64% with the coil and 54% with the Rashkind device. A visible residual shunt at post-implant angiography in moderate ducts was associated with a high incidence (59%) of long-term echocardiographic shunt patency and a need for repeat interventions for audible residual shunts (32%). Conclusions: Single coil transcatheter occlusion is the treatment of choice for the small duct as most residual shunts will resolve spontaneously. However, long-term shunt persistence after single coil deployment in moderate sized ducts is as frequent as with the Rashkind device. A primary multiple coil approach is advocated if the postcoil aortogram shows residual ductal shunting and if there is persistence of a ductal murmur on auscultation.     

经导管封堵动脉导管未闭外科及介入治疗术后残余分流

目的 评价经导管封堵动脉导管未闭(PDA)外科结扎及介入治疗术后残余分流的效果.方法 1995年6月至2008年9月,42例外科结扎、1例外科结扎术后又行弹簧栓子法、3例Rashkind法及1例Sidires法介入治疗术后残余分流的PDA患者施行了经导管封堵术,其中男9例,女38例,年龄2～53岁,平均25.0±15.5岁.外科手术至介入治疗的时间为1个月～30年,其中1例曾行两次外科结扎术.第一次介入治疗至本次封堵术的时间为4年～14年.43例经股静脉途径植入封堵器,其中2例采用动静脉轨道法;2例经股动脉途径植入可控弹簧栓子.介入术后24 h～7.8年行X线胸片、心电图及超声心动图随访.结果 残余分流的PDA最窄处直径为1～10 mm,平均4.1±2.0 mm.技术成功率为95.7%(45/47).45例封堵术后10 min.主动脉弓降部造影示无残余分流40例(88.9%),微量残余分流4例(8.9%),少量残余分流1例(2.2%).术后24 h经胸超声心动图示无残余分流44例(97.8%),少量残余分流1例(2.2%),该例术后9 h发生溶血,经保守治疗1周后消失.失败2例,植入封堵器后仍有明显残余分流,收回封堵器,终止介入治疗.本组45例随访1个月～7.8年,除1例于术后4个月发生心房颤动外,余未发现封堵器移位、残余分流及细菌性心内膜炎.结论 经导管封堵动脉导管未闭外科结扎及介入治疗术后的残余分流是一种创伤小、成功率高、并发症少、住院时间短、安全有效的方法,基本可以替代外科手术.     

New technique using temporary balloon occlusion for transcatheter closure of patent ductus arteriosus with Gianturco coils

We describe our early experience with a new technique involving temporary balloon occlusion for transcathether closure of patent ductus arteriosus (PDA) using single or multiple Gianturco coils. Coil occlusion was attempted in 21 patients of median age 3 (range 1–11) years, and angiographic PDA diameter 3.0 mm ± 0.87 mm. The inflated balloon of a pulmonary wedge pressure catheter over a transductal wire was used to mechanically hold the first extruded loop of the coil at the pulmonary end of the duct. If a residual shunt persisted after the delivery of the first coil, additional coils were delivered with or without the balloon support. One to nine coils (median 2) of different sizes varying between 3–12 mm diameter and 4–15 cm length were used. Immediate angiographic occlusion rate was 47.6%. However, color Doppler (CD) at 24 hours and at 6 weeks revealed complete closure in 66.6% and 80.9%, respectively. Blood transfusion was required in 2 (9.5%) patients. Three out of 56 coils (5.4%) embolized during deployment. The use of balloon occlusion is effective and safe in the treatment of ducti up to 4.7 mm. Residual shunts tend to occlude with time. Cathet. Cardiovasc. Diagn. 41:62–70, 1997. © 1997 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Indications, technique, results and clinical impact of reocclusion procedures for residual shunts after transcatheter closure of the patent ductus arteriosus.

PURPOSE: To assess the results of reocclusion procedures for late residual shunts after transcatheter closure of the patent ductus arteriosus. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Nineteen patients underwent reocclusion procedures either with Rashkind technique (2 patients) or with coils. Mean age was 96.5 months and mean interval between the initial and the additional procedure was 15.7 months. In 5 patients, the duct was balloon-dilated prior to occlusion. RESULTS: In 3 patients the procedure was unsuccessful because it was impossible to cross the duct using either a guide wire or a catheter. Immediate or late complete occlusion occurred in 13 patients. Two patients required a third procedure for complete closure. One patient developed severe intravascular hemolysis after coil implantation and was sent to surgery. The rate of final late residual shunting decreased from 17.1% to 6.6% (5/76) in the umbrella group and from 15.8% to 1.8% (1/56) in the coil group. CONCLUSIONS: Reocclusion procedures are indicated after one year of persistent shunting following the primary procedure. They are generally effective and reduce significantly the rate of late residual shunting. In patients with tiny shunts, the duct may need to be dilated. Coils are preferred because of their low cost.     

经导管封堵动脉导管未闭介入治疗后残余分流

目的探讨经导管封堵动脉导管未闭(PDA)介入治疗后残余分流的可行性和临床疗效。方法自1997年3月至2001年8月16例PDA介入治疗后残余分流的患者,其中男4例,女12例,平均年龄5.9±2.4岁(2～9岁),平均体重17.7±5.4kg(9～28kg),应用不同介入方法经动脉或静脉途径封堵残余分流,首次介入治疗与再次介入治疗的时间间隔平均为1.5±1.1年(1天～3.5年)。结果残余分流直径平均为2.7±0.9mm(1.2～5.0mm)。15例成功完成残余分流封堵术,1例失败,技术成功率为94%(15/16)。单纯应用Cook可控弹簧圈9例(其中双弹簧圈2例),Rashkind双面伞2例,Sidris纽扣式补片1例,Amplatzer蘑菇伞2例,同时应用Cook可控弹簧圈和Sidris纽扣式补片1例。封堵术后即刻造影,3例仍有少量残余分流,完全闭合率为80%(12/15)。平均手术时间为75.0±22.8min(45～120min),平均X线透视时间为10.4±3.9min(5～20min)。股动脉并发症1例,其余无并发症出现。封堵术后24h复查超声心动图,所有残余分流均完全闭合(100%),在平均2年随访中未出现残余分流再通、封堵器移位和左右肺动脉狭窄。结论经导管封堵PDA介入治疗后残余分流安全、疗效确切、创伤小,可作为外科手术治疗PDA介入治疗后残余分流的一种替代方法。     

Intravascular hemolysis following percutaneous occlusion of the ductus arteriosus]

Transcatheter occlusion of patent ductus arteriosus has become a safe and successful technique, but it's not free of complications. We present the case of a two-year-old boy who underwent routine transcatheter closure of his patent ductus arteriosus, using a "coil" device. Twenty hours later he developed severe persistent hemolysis in association with residual ductal flow. Patient's clinical situation became stable when the device was removed. Pulmonary embolization of the device and hemolysis are the main complications of percutaneous closure of the patent ductus arteriosus. Hemolysis occurs rarely (0.5%) and is always associated with the presence of residual ductal flow. Several approaches to this problem have been described. Mild cases may require no intervention; however, when severe hemolysis is present, removal of the device may be needed, proceeding with surgical repair of the patent ductus arteriosus.     

Safety and efficacy of using 0.052-inch Gianturco coil for closure of large ( > or = 4mm) patent ductus arteriosus

Transcatheter closure of patent ductus arteriosus (PDA) is now a well-established treatment alternative to surgery in many cardiology centers. Of all the methods used, transcatheter coil occlusion is the preferred therapy. For small PDA, the method using 0.038" Gianturco coils has proven safe and effective. However, this therapeutic strategy has encountered some difficulties with large PDA. This study provides an alternative strategy, using 0.052" Gianturco coil and complete closure of residual shunt with multiple coils to close large PDA. Fifteen patients underwent transcatheter coil occlusion of large ( > or = 4mm) patent ductus arteriosus. The intermediate success rate was 86.7%. There were four complications and only two patients had to be referred for surgery.     

Radiographic characteristics of Cook detachable and Gianturco coils as well as clinical results of transcatheter closure of the patent ductus arteriosus

PURPOSE: To describe the radiographic appearance of the Gianturco and the Cook detachable coils and present the clinical results in patients who underwent transcatheter closure of patent ductus arteriosus. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Between January 1994 and June 1997, eighty-two patients underwent closure of patent ductus arteriosus (PDA) using either Gianturco or Cook detachable coils. The chest x-ray and echocardiography of all patients were reviewed and the following parameters were evaluated: 1) the size of the heart (cardiothoracic ratio), 2) the position and the type of the coils in the postero-anterior and the lateral projection, 3) the number of coils used, 4) the existence of residual ductal flow, 5) Doppler velocity in the left pulmonary artery. RESULTS: Complete occlusion was achieved in 94%, and cardio-thoracic ratio regressed from 0.57 to 0.53 (p < 0.01), after a mean follow-up of 1.2 years. The identification of the different coils on the chest radiograph was successful in only 47% of cases, difficulties arising especially, when multiple coils were used. In 55 patients (67%) the coil position was judged to be optimal, in 27 patients (33%) suboptimal. The latter correlates with the presence of residual shunt. Multiple coils correlated more with a left pulmonary artery flow velocity exceeding 1.5 m/s. CONCLUSION: Coil-occlusion of patent ductus arteriosus is effective and leads to reduced cardio-thoracic ratio. Radiographic coil identification is possible but may be difficult if multiple coils are deployed. Suboptimal coil position led more often to residual PDA shunt. Multiple coils are more commonly associated with increased LPA velocities, but hemodynamic significant obstruction to flow is rare.     

Stenting small coronary arteries using two second-generation slotted tube stents: acute and six-month clinical and angiographic results.

We report our experience with transcatheter occlusion of the small PDA using Gianturco coils comparing a single coil strategy to a "multiple coil-no residual shunt strategy". Fifteen patients (Group I) had a single coil only placed irrespective of residual shunting and 20 (Group II) were treated using the no residual shunt strategy. Age, minimal PDA diameter, PDA length and PDA types were similar between groups. Closure rates in Group I patients were 60%, 80% and 87% at <1 month, 6 months and 1 year, respectively. In Group II, the <1 month and 6 month closure rates were 100%. The costs and hospital charges for coil closure were comparable to a concurrent surgical group; the total charges (hospital plus physician) were less for Group I, but similar between Group II and the surgical group. The complication rate for coil closure was significantly less than surgical closure. From these data, transcatheter closure with multiple coils can achieve the same closure rate as surgery at similar hospital charges with fewer complications.     

The percutaneous closure of the ductus arteriosus in adults]

From May 1990 to June 1998, 116 patients were submitted to percutaneous closure of patent ductus arteriosus. There were 18 adult patients, aged 18 to 61 years. Two patients had residual ductus after an attempted surgical ligation and two other patients had a calcified ductus. A device was not implanted in three patients, two of whom because of pulmonary hypertension being considered irreversible. Another patient, with a very large duct, underwent attempted occlusion, but the device embolized to the pulmonary artery and was retrieved percutaneously in the same session. This patient was operated later. Complete duct occlusion, confirmed by color Doppler echocardiography, was achieved in 14 of the remaining 15 patients (93%; 95% CL: 81-100). This was performed with a single catheterization in 12 cases, with implantation of one or more detachable coils in 8 patients; with a Rashkind device in 3, and a combination of a Rashkind device and coils in 1. In two cases complete duct occlusion required a second catheterization for implantation of additional detachable coils, including one patient with intravascular hemolysis in whom resolution of this problem was achieved with additional coils. In recent years, we have preferentially used detachable coils implanted through 5 Fr catheters, with a controlled release mechanism. This is a safer and less expensive device. Patients with pulmonary hypertension can be submitted to a trial occlusion of the duct with a balloon catheter to evaluate the response of pulmonary artery pressures. Percutaneous closure of the patent ductus arteriosus can be performed with excellent results in adults. Complete occlusion was achieved in 14 of the 15 patients (93%) without pulmonary hypertension or extremely large ductus. This is similar to our results in the pediatric population.     

Percutaneous closure of small patent ductus arteriosus: Comparison of Rashkind double-umbrella device and occluding spring coils

We compared our current practice of closing small patent ductus arteriosus (PDA) with coils with our previous experience of using double-umbrellas. Twelve patients underwent percutaneous closure of a small PDA with a coil. Selection criteria were a minimal diameter of ≤2.5 mm and angiographic type A or E. The 12 most recent, non-consecutive patients who had undergone double-umbrella device closure of a PDA and would presently be considered suitable candidates for spring coil occlusion were retrospectively reviewed. The two groups were compared with regard to complications and immediate and midterm results. Eleven of the 12 attempted PDA occlusions using spring coils were successful. The mean follow-up period was 5.8 ± 4.6 months. Color-Doppler echocardiograms have shown no residual leaks, no turbulence in the descending aorta, and no left pulmonary artery stenosis. All 12 attempted double-umbrella device placements were successful. The mean follow-up period was 16.2 ± 5.8 months. Color-Doppler echocardiograms have shown trivial residual leaks in four patients and mild turbulent flow in the left pulmonary artery in one patient. There was no significant difference between the two groups in demographic and hemodynamic data. Although the mean follow-up time was significantly longer in the patients who underwent double-umbrella closure, there was significantly more color-Doppler echocardiographic evidence of residual flow (P < 0.03). Small PDA closure with coils is effective, resulting in less residual leaks compared with the double-umbrella device. © 1996 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Safety and Feasibility of Transcatheter Closure of Large Patent Ductus Arteriosus Measuring ≥4 mm in Patients Weighing ≤6 kg

Objectives: The study aims to find safety of transcatheter closure of large patent ductus arteriosus (PDA) ≥4 mm in patients weighing ≤6 kg.
Background: Large PDA ≥4 mm in patients ≤6 kg challenge the interventionist due to need for large delivery sheath, kink of delivery sheath, and encroachment of aorta or pulmonary artery (PA) by the device. Many institutions refer them for surgery.
Methods: Preterm neonates and ducts with coarctation were excluded. All other patients were taken for catheter closure. Ducts with roomy ampulla were closed with multiple coils aided by bioptome, and others with Amplatzer duct occluders.
Results: Twenty-eight patients aged 2–18 months (median 5.5 months) and weighing 3.8–6 kg (median 4.7 kg) had large PDA (mean diameter 6.3 ± 2 mm) with hyperkinetic pulmonary hypertension. Four patients had bioptome-aided coil closure. Twenty-two other ducts were closed with devices. Two procedures failed due to sheath kink in one patient and device pulling through a duct in the other patient. Four infants needed blood transfusions. The mean procedural time was 42 ± 20 minutes. On a mean follow-up of 25.5 ± 14.8 months, there were no residual flows and no gradients across aorta or pulmonary artery.
Conclusions: Transcatheter closure of large ducts ≥4 mm might be considered safe and effective in infants weighing ≤6 kg also. Decision on coils versus devices depends on ductal morphology. On midterm follow-up with somatic growth, there was no occurrence of aortic or PA gradients.     

Safety and feasibility of transcatheter closure of large patent ductus arteriosus measuring >or=4 mm in patients weighing

Kothandam Sivakumar  Edwin Francis  Prasad Krishnan 《Journal of interventional cardiology》2008,21(2):196-203

Transcatheter coil embolization of large-size patent ductus arteriosus in adult patients: usefulness and problems

Transcatheter coil embolization of the patent ductus arteriosus (PDA) has been frequently used in children, especially for small lesions. It was attempted in 3 adults using Cook detachable coils. For 2 of the patients, relatively old age and heart failure were the reasons for choosing coil embolization of the PDA. In the remaining patient, who had Wolff-Parkinson-White syndrome, coil embolization was performed after radiofrequency catheter ablation of Kent's bundle. Their respective minimal PDA diameters were 5.0 mm, 4.5 mm and 4.0 mm measured by transesophageal echocardiography. Two coils were placed in 2 patients and 1 coil in the remaining patient. After the procedures, the size of the left ventricle decreased and heart failure was improved in 2 patients, although all 3 patients had a residual shunt, which caused hemolytic anemia in 2 patients. Repeat coil-embolization procedures resulted in complete occlusion and the hemolysis disappeared in these patients. In adult patients who have heart failure due to large PDA, coil embolization with detachable coils, even if residual shunt persists, is useful for improvement of the heart failure. In cases of hemolysis related to residual shunt, a second coil-embolization procedure can improve it completely.