Intentional limited resection for small peripheral lung cancer based on intraoperative pathologic exploration

Objective: The aim of this study was to assess the adequacy of our intentional limited resection for small peripheral lung cancer based on intraoperative pathologic exploration. Methods: Patients who had stage IA non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) with a maximum tumor diameter of 2 cm or less were candidates for limited resection. If bronchioloalveolar carcinoma (BAC) was suspected on computed tomography and intraoperative pathologic exploration revealed the lesion as BAC without foci of active fibroblastic proliferation (Noguchi type A and B), wedge resection was performed. If the tumor was not suspected of being Noguchi type A or B, extended segmentectomy with intraoperative lymph node exploration was performed. Results: Limited resection was performed in 34 patients, wedge resection in 14, and extended segmentectomy in 20. The median follow-up period after wedge resection was 36 months, and all patients are alive with no signs of recurrence. The median follow-up period after extended segmentectomy was 54 months. No local recurrences were found, but distant metastasis was diagnosed in one patient. The 5-year survival rate after extended segmentectomy was 93%. In the same period, lobectomy was performed in 57 patients with stage IA NSCLC with a maximum tumor diameter of 2 cm or less, and the 5-year survival rate was 84%. There were no significant differences in 5-year survival between extended segmentectomy and lobectomy. Conclusions: Careful selection of patients based on high-resolution computed tomography findings and intraoperative pathologic exploration makes intentional limited resection an acceptable option for the treatment of small peripheral NSCLC. Read at the Fifty-sixth Annual Meeting of the Japanese Association for Thoracic Surgery, Panel Discussion, Tokyo, November 19–21, 2003.     

Intentional limited resection for small peripheral lung cancer based on intraoperative pathologic exploration

OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study was to assess the adequacy of our intentional limited resection for small peripheral lung cancer based on intraoperative pathologic exploration. METHODS: Patients who had stage IA non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) with a maximum tumor diameter of 2 cm or less were candidates for limited resection. If bronchioloalveolar carcinoma (BAC) was suspected on computed tomography and intraoperative pathologic exploration revealed the lesion as BAC without foci of active fibroblastic proliferation (Noguchi type A and B), wedge resection was performed. If the tumor was not suspected of being Noguchi type A or B, extended segmentectomy with intraoperative lymph node exploration was performed. RESULTS: Limited resection was performed in 34 patients, wedge resection in 14, and extended segmentectomy in 20. The median follow-up period after wedge resection was 36 months, and all patients are alive with no signs of recurrence. The median follow-up period after extended segmentectomy was 54 months. No local recurrences were found, but distant metastasis was diagnosed in one patient. The 5-year survival rate after extended segmentectomy was 93%. In the same period, lobectomy was performed in 57 patients with stage IA NSCLC with a maximum tumor diameter of 2 cm or less, and the 5-year survival rate was 84%. There were no significant differences in 5-year survival between extended segmentectomy and lobectomy. CONCLUSIONS: Careful selection of patients based on high-resolution computed tomography findings and intraoperative pathologic exploration makes intentional limited resection an acceptable option for the treatment of small peripheral NSCLC.     

Limited resection for small peripheral lung cancer using intraoperative pathologic examination

From 1996 to 2002, we performed intentional limited resection for small peripheral lung cancer using intraoperative pathologic examination. Wedge resection was performed in patients who had small peripheral adenocarcinoma (< or = 20 mm), suspected of being Noguchi type A or B, and confirmed by intraoperative pathologic examination. Extended segmentectomy was performed in the rest of patients (tumor diameter < or = 20 mm), and not suspected of being Noguchi type A or B. Hilar and mediastinal lymph nodes sampling was performed in this group. If lymph node metastasis was detected by the intraoperative pathologic examination, the surgical procedures was converted into a lobectomy with lymph node dissection. Limited resection was performed in 27 patients, wedge resection in 8, and extended segmentectomy in 19. All patients received wedge resection are alive without sign of recurrence. In extended segmentectomy, 17 patients are alive with no evidence of disease, 1 patient died of non-pulmonary disease, and 1 patient is alive with recurrent disease. The overall survival rate at 5 years was 100% in wedge resection, 91% in extended segmentectomy, and 79% in standard lobectomy. We conclude that limited resection for small peripheral lung cancer using intraoperative pathologic examination may be safe and effective procedure.     

A new method of segmental resection for primary lung cancer: intermediate results.

OBJECTIVE: To improve the postoperative results of limited resection for small lung cancer, we have developed a new operative method, pulmonary artery-guided segmentectomy. This resection begins with identification of the pulmonary arterial branches involved in the tumor, then the pulmonary tissue is divided along the pulmonary arteries (i.e. guided by pulmonary arteries) from the hilum toward the periphery by electrocautery. The advantages of this method include the facilitation of securing adequate margin from the tumor, and the feasibility of intralobar lymph node dissection during operation. To examine the efficacy of the new method of segmental resection, we retrospectively reviewed 74 cases of T1N0M0 disease who underwent the pulmonary artery-guided segmentectomy. METHODS: From 1993 to 2000, 74 patients with pathological T1N0M0 lung cancer were treated by the pulmonary artery-guided segmentectomy. Forty-one patients (55.4%) who underwent the segmentectomy had been considered suitable candidates for lobectomy (intentional resection group). The other 33 patients (44.6%) were considered poor candidates for lobectomy because of poor cardiopulmonary reserve (compromised resection group). RESULTS: The overall survival rate at 5 years was 82.0%. The 5-year survivals in the intentional and the compromised resection groups were 81.6 and 77.6%, respectively, and no significant differences were detected between the groups. According to tumor size, the 5-year survival rate for patients with tumors of 20 mm or smaller (92.9%, n=53) was higher than that for the patients with tumors of 21-30 mm (63.0%, n=21), but the difference did not reach statistical significance. Median follow-up time of 27.0 months revealed eight locoregional recurrences and four deaths due to lung cancer. Sixty-three patients (85.1%) are alive with no evidence of disease, and six patients (8.1%) are alive with recurrent disease. Locoregional recurrences occurred in one of 53 patients (1.9%) with tumors 20 mm or smaller and in seven of 21 patients (33.3%) with tumors 21-30 mm, the difference being statistically significant (P<0.01). CONCLUSIONS: Our intermediate results demonstrated that the new pulmonary artery-guided segmentectomy could be an alternative method for selected patients with small lung cancer, particularly with tumors 20 mm or smaller in diameter.     

Intentional limited pulmonary resection for peripheral T1 N0 M0 small-sized lung cancer

OBJECTIVE: The present study was undertaken to demonstrate that limited pulmonary resection for peripheral small-sized lung cancer yields outcomes not inferior to those of lobectomy. METHODS: During the 9-year period from 1992 to 2000, patients with cT1 N0 M0 peripheral non-small cell lung cancer whose maximum tumor diameter was 2 cm or less on diagnostic imaging and in whom lobectomy was determined to be feasible were treated with limited resection if the patient consented to the procedure and with lobectomy if consent to limited resection was not obtained. The survival and clinical outcome of the patients whose tumors were postoperatively staged as pT1 N0 M0 were compared between the limited resection group (n = 74) and the lobectomy group (n = 159). RESULTS: The limited resection group consisted of 60 patients treated with segmentectomy and 14 patients treated with wedge resection. Among patients followed up for a mean period of 52 months after the operation, neither the 3-year nor 5-year survivals differed significantly between the limited resection group (3-year survival, 94.0%; 5-year survival, 89.1%) and the lobectomy group (3-year survival, 97.0%; 5-year survival, 90.1%). Postoperative tumor recurrence was noted in 5 patients after limited resection and in 9 patients after lobectomy, and the difference in the incidence of postoperative recurrence between the 2 groups was not significant. CONCLUSIONS: The results of this study indicate that in patients with peripheral T1 N0 M0 non-small cell lung cancer whose maximum tumor diameter was 2 cm or less, the outcome of limited pulmonary resection is comparable with that of pulmonary lobectomy.     

Surgery for intrathoracic recurrence and second primary tumors in resected lung cancer

From 1986 to 2000, 42 patients (3.7%) underwent resection for intrathoracic recurrence or second primary lung cancer. Survival in 27 patients with recurrent diseases was 60% at 5 years and 35% at 10 years compared with 65% at 5 and 10 years for 15 patients with metachronous lung cancers morphologically. Ten patients had the second operation less than 2 years since the first operation, 19 patients between 2 and 5 years, and 13 patients more than 5 years, while these 5-year survivals were 72%, 53%, 67% respectively. At the first operation lobectomy was performed in 39 patients (93%), wedge resection or segmentectomy in 3. The reoperation was 14 lobectomy or completion pneumonectomy, 24 wedge or segmentectomy (57%), and 4 other procedures, while these 5-year survivals were 35%, 73%, and 100% respectively. The 5-year survival was 78% for 27 patients with stage I disease and 26% for 10 patients with stage III disease at the first operation, compared with 55% for 30 patients with stage I and 53% for 9 patients with stage III at the reoperation. These data suggest that limited resection is recommended for intrathoracic recurrent diseases and metachronous multiple lung cancers whenever possible.     

Review and evaluation of limited resection for early lung cancer

Limited resection for early lung cancer has been associated with significantly higher local recurrence rates based on previous reports such as those from lung cancer study groups. On the other hand, a few groups demonstrated that patients with small peripheral cancer who undergo limited resection have comparable survival rates with those who undergo lobectomy. Recent advances in radiologic investigation and pathologic analysis have broadened the indications for limited resection. Since the introduction of the adenocarcinoma classification by Noguchi surgery for localized bronchioloalveolar carcinoma has focused on limited resection. Caution is necessary when performing wedge resection even if 10 mm or less in diameter and in compromised segmentectomy for early lung cancer. Although limited resection is still controversial intentional segmentectomy for localized bronchioloalveolar carcinoma or less than 20 mm or less in diameter may be recommended without evidence-based medicine. It is important to accumulate further evidence clarifying the survival and function benefits of limited resection. New therapeutic modalities for limited surgery for small-sized lung cancer may increase patient life expectancy.     

Multiple primary lung cancers. Results of surgical treatment

During a 13-year period, multiple primary lung cancers were diagnosed in 80 consecutive patients. Forty-four patients had metachronous cancers. The initial pulmonary resection was lobectomy in 36 patients, bilobectomy in 3, pneumonectomy in 1, and wedge excision or segmentectomy in 4. The second pulmonary resection was lobectomy in 16 patients, bilobectomy in 2, completion pneumonectomy in 7, and wedge excision or segmentectomy in 19. There were two 30-day operative deaths (mortality rate, 4.5%). Actuarial 5- and 10-year survival rates after the first pulmonary resection for stage I disease were 55.2% and 27.0%, respectively. Five-year and 10-year survival rates for stage I disease after the second pulmonary resection were 41.0% and 31.5%, respectively. The remaining 36 patients had synchronous cancers. The pulmonary resection was lobectomy in 18 patients, bilobectomy in 3, pneumonectomy in 10, and wedge excision or segmentectomy in 8. There were two 30-day operative deaths (mortality rate, 5.6%). Actuarial overall 5- and 10-year survival rates after pulmonary resection were 15.7% and 13.8%, respectively. We conclude that an aggressive surgical approach is safe and warranted in most patients with multiple primary lung cancers and that the presence of synchronous primary cancers is ominous.     

Surgical treatment for bilateral multiple lung cancers]

We reviewed 21 patients with bilateral multiple bronchogenic carcinomas. Eleven of them had synchronous carcinomas and 10 had metachronous carcinomas. We treated 6 patients with lobectomy and wedge resection under median sternotomy synchronously, and 2 patients with lobectomy on both lungs under standard thoracotomy, 2 patients with lobectomy and wedge resection, 1 patient with segmentectomy on both lung, 1 patient with lobectomy and segmentectomy, 1 patient with pneumonectomy and wedge resection, and 8 patients with lobectomy and thoracoscopic wedge resection on each lung metachronously. Two patients who had lobectomy on both lungs were dead, one of whom of pulmonary edema 2 weeks after second operation and the other of respiratory failure 3 years after second operation. We concluded that lobectomy on both lungs are not recommended because of high mortality rate (10%) and the limited resection under thoracoscopic surgery should be considered to treat the other contra lateral primary lung cancers.     

Indication for limited surgery on small lung cancer tumors measuring 1cm or less in diameter on preoperative computed tomography and long-term results

OBJECTIVE: Non-invasive lung cancers showed a good prognosis after limited surgery. But it is still uncertain about invasive lung cancers. We investigated the indications for limited surgery for small lung cancer tumors measuring 1 cm or less in diameter on preoperative computed tomography (CT). METHODS: This study retrospectively analyzed of 1,245 patients who underwent complete resection of lung cancer between 1989 and 2004 in our hospital. Sixty-two patients (5%) had tumors measuring 1 cm or less in diameter. The probability of survival was calculated using the Kaplan-Meier method. RESULTS: All diseases were detected by medical checkup, 52 % of the patients were not definitively diagnosed with lung cancer before surgery. Adenocarcinoma was histologically diagnosed in 49 patients (79%). Other histologic types included squamous cell carcinoma (8), large cell carcinoma (1), small cell carcinoma (1), carcinoid (2), and adenosquamous cell carcinoma (1). Fifty-seven patients (92%) showed pathologic stage IA. The other stages were IB (2), IIA (1), and IIIB (2). There were 14 bronchioloalveolar carcinomas (25% of IA diseases). The 5-year survival rates of IA patients were 90%. The 5-year survival rate of patients with tumors measuring 1cm or less diameter was 91% after lobectomy or pneumonectomy, and 90% after wedge resection or segmentectomy. There were 3 deaths from cancer recurrence, while there were no deaths in 14 patients with bronchioloalveolar carcinoma CONCLUSION: After limited surgery, non-invasive cancer showed good long-term results, while invasive cancer showed a recurrence rate of 2.3% to 79% even though the tumor measured 1 cm or less in diameter on preoperative CT.     

Cytologically malignant margin without continuous pulmonary tumor lesion: cases of wedge resection, segmentectomy and lobectomy

The surgical margin is usually investigated during the operation using a pathological method, though cytological methods are also used to identify remaining malignant cells. We reviewed cases of pulmonary resection for a malignant tumor. At our institution, an on-site surgical margin examination using a cytological method is mandated for cases of wedge resection and segmentectomy, and an option in lobectomy cases. We examined 21 wedge resection (3 primary lung cancer, 18 metastasis), 17 segmentectomy (13 primary lung cancer, 4 metastasis), and 4 lobectomy (all primarily lung cancer) cases. Six cases showed malignant cells in the surgical margin, of which one had a microscopic skip lesion pattern and five an 'occult' pattern (positive cytology, negative pathology). Cytological malignancy occurred even in cases of wedge resection of a tiny (4 mm in diameter) lesion metastasized from colon cancer, as well as segmentectomy with a sufficient gross margin containing microscopic skip lesions and right middle lobectomy with an additional right upper lobectomy due to two previous cytological malignancies in a residual lobe. Surgical margin cytology revealed remaining malignancy in the residual lobe, which provided important information for deciding additional procedures during surgery.     

Results of surgical treatment for small (2 cm or Under) adenocarcinomas of the lung

Purpose The objectives of this study were to identify the clinicopathologic characteristics and prognostic factors of small (2 cm or less in diameter) adenocarcinomas, and furthermore to assess the acceptability of performing a limited pulmonary resection in such patients. Methods We retrospectively reviewed 523 cases of cT1N0M0 peripheral adenocarcinoma measuring 2 cm or less on diagnostic images treated by a complete resection between 1991 and 2004. Results The overall 5-year survival rate of the patients with small adenocarcinomas was 83.6%. Univariate and multivariate analyses identified an older age, male sex, wedge resection, advanced stage, and Noguchi classification of C, D, E, or F as independent prognostic factors that adversely affected overall survival. However, there were no significant differences in the survival according to surgical procedure in the patients whose tumors had a maximum diameter of 1.0 cm or less or in Noguchi type A and B cases. Conclusions Age, sex, surgical procedure, p-stage, and Noguchi classification were independent prognostic factors for survival in patients with small adenocarcinomas. A segmentectomy is therefore considered to be an acceptable alternative to a lobectomy for adenocarcinomas of 2 cm or less in diameter. A wedge resection may be acceptable for tumors measuring 1 cm or less in diameter or Noguchi type A and B tumors.     

Surgical treatment of non-small cell lung cancer 1 cm or less in diameter

BACKGROUND: Routine lung cancer screening does not currently exist in the United States. Computed tomography can detect small cancers and may well be the screening choice in the future. Controversy exists, however, regarding the surgical management of these small lung cancers. METHODS: The records of all patients were reviewed who underwent resection of solitary non-small cell lung cancers 1 cm or less in diameter from 1980 through 1999. RESULTS: The study included 100 patients (56 men and 44 women) with a median age of 67 years (range 43 to 84 years). Lobectomy was performed in 71 patients, bilobectomy in 4, segmentectomy in 12, and wedge excision in 13. Ninety-four patients had complete mediastinal lymph node dissection. The cancer was an adenocarcinoma in 48 patients, squamous cell carcinoma in 26, bronchioloalveolar carcinoma in 19, large cell carcinoma in 4, adenosquamous cell carcinoma in 2, and undifferentiated in 1. Tumor diameter ranged from 3 to 10 mm. Seven patients had lymph node metastases (N1, 5 patients; N2, 2 patients). Postsurgical stage was IA in 92 patients, IB in 1, IIA in 5, and IIIA in 2. There were four operative deaths. Follow-up was complete in all patients and ranged from 4 to 214 months (median 43 months). Eighteen patients (18.0%) developed recurrent lung cancer. Overall and lung cancer-specific 5-year survivals were 64.1% and 85.4%, respectively. Patients who underwent lobectomy had significantly better survival and fewer recurrences than patients who had wedge excision or segmentectomy (p = 0.04). CONCLUSIONS: Because recurrent cancer and lymph node metastasis can occur in patients with non-small cell lung cancers 1 cm or less in size, lobectomy with lymph node dissection is warranted when medically possible.     

Indications for intentionally limited resection for non-small-cell lung cancer

Radiographically, there have been new advances in spiral computed tomography (CT) scanning are currently being studied as a screening tools. As a result, many cases of small-sized lung cancer have been discovered. Some are noninvasive or minimally invasive bronchioloalveolar carcinoma, which is characterized by a the unique sign of ground-glass opacity (GGO) on high-resolution CT (HRCT) scanning. In such cases, lymph node metastases are extremely rare. However, there is currently no definitive surgical modality for such lesions. To clarify the indications of limited resection (segmentectomy or wedge resection), preoperative tumor diameter, location, and, GGO area on HRCT were estimated in patients with clinical T1N0 disease. In patients whose tumor included > or = 50% GGO area and was 15 mm or less in diameter, or patients with pure GGO regardless of tumor size, wedge resection without lymph node dissection should be considered as an acceptable treatment. Video-assisted thoracic surgery is a useful approach for selected patients. On the other hand, in patients with tumors < 50% GGO area in the range of 10-15 mm in diameter, segmentectomy with systematic lymph node dissection or diligent lymph node sampling should be considered.     

Early results of a prospective study of limited resection for bronchioloalveolar adenocarcinoma of the lung

BACKGROUND: We reported that bronchioloalveolar adenocarcinoma (BAC) without active fibroblastic proliferation of the lung had no lymph node and pulmonary metastasis and had a favorable prognosis. However, there has been no prospective trial regarding limited pulmonary resection for this type of BAC. The purpose of this study is to confirm the effectiveness of limited resection for histologically confirmed BAC without active fibroblastic proliferation. METHODS: From 1996 through 1999, 42 patients who had small peripheral lung tumors (< or = 20 mm), suspected of being BAC, were enrolled in this trial. The patient population consisted of 24 men and 18 women with a mean age of 58.4 years. Limited resection was completed when BAC, without both active fibroblastic proliferation and lymph node metastasis, was confirmed histologically by intraoperative pathologic examination. RESULTS: Limited resection was completed in 36 patients, wedge resection in 34, and segmentectomy in 2 patients. In 6 patients, the procedure was converted into lobectomy because of pathologic invasive sign in 3, active fibroblastic proliferation in 1, and for other reasons in 2 patients. All patients have been followed for a median follow-up period of 30 months and are alive without sign of recurrence. CONCLUSIONS: Our early results indicate that limited resection may be an acceptable alternative to lobectomy for histologically confirmed BAC without active fibroblastic proliferation.     

Clinical study of limited operation of lung cancer with reference to the operative procedure

From 1977 to 1987, 27 cases of primary lung cancer were resected by the limited operation, 7 segmentectomy and 20 wedge resection. All cases of segmentectomy were considered to be potentially curative and 2 cases of them were X-ray negative early squamous cell carcinoma originated from the subsegmental bronchus. The mean tumor size of the other 5 peripheral cases performed segmentectomy was 37.6 mm in diameter. Two cases of segmentectomy died from cancer recurrence, but 2 cases are still alive more than 4.5 years after operation. All cases of wedge resection were originated peripherally, and 6 cases were thought to be potentially curative and the mean tumor size was 22.4 mm in diameter. Three cases of them died, 1 from the tumor metastasis and 2 from the other diseases than lung cancer, but the other cases undergone potentially curative wedge resection are alive without recurrence 1-3.6 years after operation. The limited operation should be indicated for the peripheral lung cancer without lymph node metastasis in the patients with marked cardiac and/or pulmonary impairment. The small nodule located in subpleural lung can be resected easily by the wedge resection, but the segmentectomy should be recommended for the tumor which is larger in size or located more deeply under the visceral pleura. Especially X-ray negative early squamous cell carcinoma of the bronchus can be curatively resected by the segmentectomy with lymph node dissection, if the tumor exists in the level of subsegmental bronchus or more peripherally. Palliative minimal resection for the advanced lung cancer seemed to be not effective of their long-surviving.     

Results of resection for bronchogenic carcinoma in patients over the age of 80.

Thirty three patients aged over 80 years underwent resection for bronchogenic carcinoma. The operations performed were: lobectomy (21), segmentectomy (4), wedge resection (2), pneumonectomy (3), carinal resection (1). In two patients no resection was feasible. Three patients died within two months of surgery. The cumulative five year survival rate was 55%, 79% for patients with stage I carcinoma and 31% for stage III. It is considered that resection has an acceptable outcome in patients over 80 years.     

Surgical results for second primary lung cancer

Of 897 patients who underwent operation for lung cancer between April 1996 and March 2010, 57 patients underwent pulmonary resection for 2nd primary lung cancer. There were 44 men and 13 women. The average age at the 2nd operation was 71. The initial pulmonary resection was lobectomy in 49 patients, segmentectomy in 4 and wedge resection in 4. The 2nd pulmonary resection was lobectomy in 10 patients, segmentectomy in 12 and wedge resection in 35. Preoperative stage of the 2nd primary lung cancer was IA in 43, IB in 13 and IIB in 1. Postoperative stage was IA in 38, IB in 10, IIA in 1, IIB in 3, IIIA in 2 and IIIB in 3. Surgical complications occurred in 4, but there were no perioperative deaths. The 5-year survival rate for 2nd primary lung cancers was 59.9%. The 5-year survival rate for patients treated with wedge resection was 71.1%. The 5-year survival rate of the patients with p-stage IA was 72.7%, and that for patients with p-stage IB or more advanced diseases was 32.9%. We conclude that an aggressive surgical approach for a 2nd primary lung cancer is effective and is linked with good outcome if the tumor is detected at stage IA, when the possible cure by performing wedge resection is promissing.     

Is segmentectomy with lymph node assessment an alternative to lobectomy for non-small cell lung cancer of 2 cm or smaller?

BACKGROUND: Lesser resection than the standard lobectomy for small-sized cT1N0M0 non-small cell lung cancers continues to be debated. METHODS: We reviewed specimens of 139 patients after lobectomy for cT1N0M0 cancer of 2 cm or less. In addition, we prospectively enrolled 70 patients able to tolerate a lobectomy, in a trial of lesser resection for these lesions. The limited procedure consisted of segmentectomy in which the resection line was delivered beyond the burdened segment, plus exploration of lymph nodes by frozen sectioning. This procedure was modified if the result was positive; this modified procedure was called extended segmentectomy. RESULTS: The nodal status after lobectomy was pN0, 107 patients; pN1, 12 patients; and pN2, 20 patients. Of the pN1 patients, 2 had only intralobar nodal involvement within the same segment of the main tumor. In the remaining 30 patients with nodal involvement, we ascertained the nodal involvement during the operation. Regarding intrapulmonary metastasis, 1 of 8 patients having this metastasis had the lesion at the segment where the main tumor was not located and had N2 disease, which was detected intraoperatively. If extended segmentectomy had been performed instead of lobectomy, the lesion could have been removed completely. The 5-year survival of patients with cT1N0M0 cancer of 2 cm or less was 87.3% after extended segmentectomy. There were no local recurrences and three noncancer-related deaths. Among patients with pT1N0M0 cancer of 2 cm or less, the 5-year survival was 87.1% in the extended segmentectomy group and 87.7% in the lobectomy group (p = 0.8008). CONCLUSIONS: Extended segmentectomy should be considered as an alternative for patients with cT1N0M0 non-small cell lung cancer of 2 cm or smaller.     

Does lobectomy achieve better survival and recurrence rates than limited pulmonary resection for T1N0M0 non-small cell lung cancer patients?

A best evidence topic in cardiac surgery was written according to a structured protocol. The question addressed was: 'Does lobectomy achieve better survival and recurrence rates than limited pulmonary resection for T1N0M0 non-small cell lung cancer patients?' Altogether 225 papers were found using the reported search, of which nineteen represented the best evidence to answer the clinical question. The authors, journal, date and country of publication, patient group studied, study type, relevant outcomes and results of these papers are tabulated. A meta-analysis published in 2005 showed a 0.7% (P=0.3659) survival difference at one year, 1.9% (P=0.5088) at three years and 3.6% (P=0.3603) at five years. The largest study prior to the meta-analysis was a randomized controlled study of 247 patients with T1N0 tumors that showed eight locoregional recurrences in the lobectomy group compared to 21 in the sublobar group, which was statistically significant. Since the meta-analysis we identified three studies, two of which showed no difference in survival and recurrence between wedge resection and lobectomy for T1N0 tumors and one that showed improved survival after lobectomy compared to wedge resection for T1N0 tumors. We conclude that wedge resection is not comparable to lobectomy for stage IA NSCLC. The increased long-term mortality associated with wedge resection is mainly due to non-cancer deaths, reflecting a higher risk patient group with many comorbid conditions. Segmental resection is comparable to lobectomy for small peripheral tumors. Sublobar resection is associated with shorter hospital stay. For bronchioalveolar carcinoma sublobar resection is recommended provided intra-operative pathologic consultation confirms pure bronchioalveolar histology without evidence of invasion, and surgical margins are free of disease.