Management of gallstones in a district general hospital

This survey reviews 815 consecutive patients undergoing surgery for benign biliary disease. There were no deaths following elective operations and the overall mortality was 0.7 per cent. One-third of patients had one or more complications. The mortality in patients having common bile duct exploration (n = 160) by one or more methods was 2.5 per cent (4 patients) with 46 per cent of these patients having complications. Of 95 patients undergoing duct exploration and postoperative T-tube cholangiography, 7 had unexpected residual calculi after initial cholecystectomy. Five have had further surgery to clear the duct. All patients having duct surgery alone for retained stones (n = 24) had previously had cholecystectomy with or without supraduodenal duct exploration. Of all patients undergoing choledochoduodenostomy or transduodenal sphincter exploration only one has returned with evidence of retained calculi. Patients with choledocholithiasis were examined in an attempt to identify a high risk group. These were found to be elderly patients, having emergency surgery for sepsis and on whom more than one duct procedure was performed (mortality 10 per cent).     

Cholecystectomy in the elderly: a prospective study

The mortality and morbidity of 151 elderly patients (greater than 64 years of age) undergoing biliary surgery for benign disease were prospectively studied. The overall mortality was 3.3 per cent. This comprised a 0.77 per cent mortality in the elective group and a 19 per cent mortality in the emergency group. In spite of 77 per cent of the emergency group having a gangrenous gallbladder, a complication difficult to predict preoperatively, the majority of deaths were from cardiovascular disease. The overall incidence of common bile duct exploration was 36 per cent, which was similar in the elective and emergency groups. A comparison between the old (65-74 years) and the aged (over 74 years of age) revealed twice the number of emergency cases in the aged. Considering elective biliary surgery, there was no difference between the mortality, morbidity, or common bile duct exploration rate comparing the old with the aged. This suggests that elective biliary surgery is safe even in the aged.     

When is routine operative cholangiography necessary? An evaluation of 200 consecutive patients operated on for gallbladder stones.

Operative cholangiography (OC) was performed during open standard cholecystectomy in 195 of 200 consecutive patients. The cholangiography was considered suspicious for choledochal stones in 28 patients (14%). Both choledochotomy and choledochoscopy were carried out. Stones in the biliary tree were found in 17 patients and in 11 cases choledochotomy was negative. Cholecystectomy was performed on an emergency basis in 46 patients, 15 of them underwent choledochotomy and in 11 (24%) bile duct stones were found. In 154 electively operated patients six (4%) had choledochal stones. Based on preoperative history choledochal stones were suspected in 30 electively operated patients but only eight had stones in the biliary tree at the time of operation. The percentage of false positive cholangiograms was 6% in the whole material, and unsuspected choledochal stones were diagnosed in 5% respectively. It is recommended that operative cholangiography should be performed routinely in patients subjected to emergency cholecystectomy. In elective operations selective use is acceptable.     

Benign disease of the common bile duct

The incidence of common bile duct (CBD) pathology in a group of patients with benign biliary disease (n = 505) was found to be 23.2 per cent. The spectrum included 111 patients (90.2 per cent) with CBD stones, 37 of whom (33.3 per cent) had no symptoms or findings pre-operatively indicating CBD involvement. Five patients had papillary stenosis, three had postoperative CBD strictures, one had a choledochal cyst and one had an external biliary fistula. Of the 100 CBDs measuring more than 10 mm in diameter, 90 harboured calculi. In the remaining 23 CBDs measuring less than 10 mm, calculi were present in 21. The presence of CBD calculi was demonstrated by intra-operative cholangiography in 49 patients. In the remaining patients (n = 74), the diagnosis of CBD pathology was made either by percutaneous transhepatic cholangiography, endoscopic retrograde cholangio-pancreatography, T-tube cholangiography or peroperative palpation. The surgical procedures performed included choledochotomy and T-tube drainage (n = 74), transduodenal sphincteroplasty (n = 27) and choledochoduodenostomy (n = 18). The overall mortality and morbidity of CBD exploration was 3.3 per cent and 24.4 per cent respectively, which was significantly greater than that for cholecystectomy alone (0.3 per cent and 8.6 per cent respectively). Transduodenal sphincteroplasty carried a much higher mortality (11 per cent) and morbidity (52 per cent) when compared with other procedures.     

Emergency cholecystostomy and subsequent cholecystectomy for acute gallstone cholecystitis in the elderly

BACKGROUND: The morbidity and mortality rates associated with acute cholecystitis are higher in the elderly. This study reports the results of treatment of acute cholecystitis in the elderly with emergency ultrasonographically guided percutaneous cholecystostomy followed by elective cholecystectomy after endoscopic treatment of any common bile duct stones diagnosed by percutaneous cholangiography. METHODS: From January 1989 to December 1998, 92 patients aged over 70 years were treated for acute gallstone cholecystitis. A group of 84 patients with ultrasonographic signs of severe cholecystitis or an American Society of Anesthesiologists score of II to IV were submitted to ultrasonographically guided percutaneous cholecystostomy. Transcatheter cholangiography was performed in all patients and endoscopic sphincterotomy was performed before operation in patients with common bile duct stones. After resolution of the acute phase and treatment of any associated diseases, patients were submitted to cholecystectomy. RESULTS: Cholecystostomy was performed successfully in 83 patients and permitted resolution of the acute attack in all after a mean period of 1.8 days. Cholangiography yielded a diagnosis of non-gallstone obstruction in one patient and common bile duct stones in 19 patients; preoperative endoscopic sphincterotomy and stone extraction was performed in 18 patients. Elective cholecystectomy was then performed in 70 patients with no deaths and a morbidity rate of 24 per cent. CONCLUSION: Combining emergency ultrasonographically guided percutaneous cholecystostomy, preoperative endoscopic treatment of common bile duct stones and subsequent elective cholecystectomy constitutes an optimal treatment regimen for acute gallstone cholecystitis in selected elderly patients with a mortality rate of zero in the authors' experience.     

Prospective audit of laparoscopic cholecystectomy experience at a secondary referral centre in South australia

BACKGROUND: Laparoscopic cholecystectomy is now the gold standard procedure for symptomatic gallstone disease. Nevertheless, there are still several controversies such as the need for routine intraoperative cholangiogram (IOC), the indications for and results of early laparoscopic cholecystectomy in the setting of acute cholecystitis and the use of endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography versus laparoscopic common bile duct (CBD) exploration for intraoperatively detected choledocholithiasis. The aim of this study was to investigate some of these controversies. METHODS: All laparoscopic cholecystectomies carried out at our institution, a secondary referral centre in Adelaide, South Australia, over a 9-month period were prospectively audited. Data were collected regarding indications for surgery, rate of conversion to open operation, use of IOC, rate of choledocholithiasis and complication rate. RESULTS: There were 202 patients, of whom 152 were women and 50 men. Age range was 15-83 years. Sixty-one per cent of emergency operations were for acute cholecystitis. The conversion rate for emergency operations was 20.6% and for elective procedures was 4.2% (P = 0.003).One hundred and eighty-four patients had an IOC performed. Twelve of these patients had choledocholithiasis. Six of these 12 patients had both normal preoperative ultrasound and liver function tests. Four of the patients went on to postoperative endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography, four had successful laparoscopic CBD exploration, two had open CBD exploration and two had their distal CBD filling defects flushed away with normal saline. There was no morbidity associated with performance of the IOC. There were three patients with postoperative bile leak and one with a bile duct injury. CONCLUSION: Selective IOC would miss a proportion of patients with choledocholithiasis. Early laparoscopic cholecystectomy for acute cholecystitis is associated with a higher conversion rate than elective laparoscopic cholecystectomy. Overall complication rate is low, with 95% of patients having no complications. Laparoscopic CBD exploration is feasible with a reasonable success rate. This can all be achieved at a secondary referral centre staffed by general surgeons.     

Audit of open cholecystectomy in a district general hospital.

This retrospective study audited all non-malignant biliary surgery carried out in a district general hospital between January 1985 and December 1990. Surgery was performed on 722 patients: 555 (77 per cent) were women and 167 (23 per cent) were men. The mean(s.d.) age of the patients was 49(16) years. Elective admissions accounted for 70 per cent of cases and 30 per cent were emergency admissions. Ultrasonography confirmed the diagnosis in 93 per cent of cases. An elective operation was performed in 542 patients and 180 patients underwent an urgent or emergency operation. Simple cholecystectomy was performed on 616 patients (85 per cent); 92 (13 per cent) also underwent common bile duct exploration and 14 (2 per cent) had an additional unrelated procedure. The mean(s.d.) hospital stay was 12.3(6.3) (range 4-34) days. There was one perioperative death. The general overall morbidity rate was 25 per cent and the procedure-related morbidity rate was 7 per cent. For simple cholecystectomy (n = 630) there were no deaths; the general morbidity rate was 15 per cent and the procedure-related rate was 3 per cent.     

Emergency and elective surgery in patients over age 70

Emergency surgery in 100 patients over age 70 was associated with a 31 per cent morbidity and a 20 per cent mortality, significantly greater than the 6.8 per cent morbidity and 1.9 per cent mortality following elective procedures in the same age group (P less than .0005). Sixteen per cent (100 of 613) of all geriatric patients were operated on under emergent conditions and the postoperative hospitalization was often significantly prolonged when compared with similar elective operations (P less than .05). Emergency surgery was most commonly performed on the large bowel (25%), abdominal wall (17%), stomach (17%), biliary tract (11%), and small bowel (10%). Inguinal herniorraphy was the most frequently performed elective procedure (33%), followed by colon resection (25%), and cholecystectomy (12%). Fifty-nine per cent (23 of 39) of complications associated with urgent operation and 39 per cent (16 of 41) following elective surgery involved the cardiorespiratory systems and were frequently related to underlying diseases. Of the 20 patients who died in the intensive care unit of multisystem failure, 16 had undergone emergency procedures. Elective surgery in the elderly may be performed safely; however, emergency surgery entails a high risk to the patient and a high cost in hospital resources.     

Comparison of endoscopic sphincterotomy and laparoscopic exploration of the common bile duct

BACKGROUND: Laparoscopic exploration of the common bile duct is becoming more popular, although endoscopic sphincterotomy remains the usual treatment for bile duct stones. However, loss of the biliary sphincter causes permanent duodenobiliary reflux, and recurrent stone disease and biliary neoplasia may be a consequence. METHODS: A systematic literature review was conducted to compare laparoscopic exploration with endoscopic sphincterotomy. A text word search of the Medline, Pubmed and Cochrane databases, and a manual search of the citations from these references, was used. RESULTS: Endoscopic sphincterotomy is associated with a median (range) mortality rate of 1 (0-6) per cent, compared with 1 (0-5) per cent for laparoscopic bile duct exploration. The median (range) rate of pancreatitis following endoscopic sphincterotomy is 3 (1-19) per cent; this is a rare complication after laparoscopic duct exploration. The combined morbidity rate for laparoscopic cholecystectomy and endoscopic sphincterotomy is 13 (3-16) per cent, which is greater than 8 (2-17) per cent for laparoscopic bile duct exploration. Randomized trials are few and contain relatively small numbers of patients. They show little overall difference in rates of duct clearance, but a higher mortality rate and number of hospital admissions are noted for endoscopic sphincterotomy compared with laparoscopic bile duct exploration. Endoscopic sphincterotomy is associated with recurrent stone formation (up to 16 per cent) with associated cholangitis. It is also associated with bacterobilia and chronic mucosal inflammation. The late development of bile duct cancer has been reported in up to 2 per cent of patients. CONCLUSION: Laparoscopic exploration of the common bile duct may be a better way of removing stones than endoscopic sphincterotomy plus laparoscopic cholecystectomy. :     

Long-term results and risk factors influencing outcome of major bile duct injuries following cholecystectomy

BACKGROUND: Major bile duct injuries usually need operative repair and remain a challenge even for surgeons who specialize in hepatobiliary surgery. The purpose of this study was to evaluate management and short- and long-term outcomes of patients with major complications after cholecystectomy. METHODS: Data were analysed for 54 patients who underwent operation for major bile duct injuries after cholecystectomy between January 1990 and January 2002. Univariate and multivariate analyses were performed to identify risk factors for the development of biliary complications. RESULTS: Complete follow-up data were available for all 54 patients (median duration 61.9 (range 2.6-154.3) months). All underwent Roux-en-Y hepaticojejunostomy. Three patients (6 per cent) died from biliary tract complications during follow-up. Long-term biliary complications occurred in ten patients (19 per cent). Nine patients developed biliary stricture of whom five developed secondary biliary cirrhosis. A successful long-term result was achieved in 50 (93 per cent) of 54 patients, including those who required subsequent procedures. Biliary reconstruction in the presence of peritonitis (P = 0.002), combined vascular and bile duct injuries (P = 0.029), and injury at or above the level of the biliary bifurcation (P = 0.012) were significant independent predictors of poor outcome. CONCLUSION: Successful repair of bile duct injuries after cholecystectomy can be achieved in specialized hepatobiliary units.     

The utilization of cystic duct cholangiography

The patient records at two hospitals were reviewed to ascertain the incidence of unsuspected common duct stones and to evaluate the patterns of utilization of routine and selective intraoperative cystic duct cholangiography. The incidence of unsuspected common duct stones discovered only by cystic duct cholangiography was 4.3 per cent. Unnecessary common duct exploration was performed on 5.3 per cent of patients undergoing routine cystic duct cholangiography because of false-positive cholangiograms. The use of routine and preexploratory cystic duct cholangiography was significantly different at the two hospitals studied. Choledochotomy without preexploratory cystic duct cholangiography resulted in unnecessary common bile duct explorations in 44 per cent of patients. Although routine cystic duct cholangiography will identify unsuspected common duct stones, it is associated with an equal incidence of unnecessary common duct exploration. Preexploration cholangiography is an essential procedure which diminishes unnecessary choledochotomy and facilitates accurate demonstration of biliary tract pathology.     

术中胆道造影在腹腔镜胆囊切除术中的应用

目的 :探讨术中胆道造影在腹腔镜胆囊切除术 (LC)中应用的临床价值。方法 :回顾总结 6 7例LC术中行胆道造影的技术要点。结果 :LC术中行胆道造影 6 7例 ,发现胆管结石 19例 ,近端胆囊管小结石 1例 ,乳头部狭窄 1例 ,胆道畸形 2例 ,假阳性 3例 ,准确率 95 5 %。结论 :有选择的在LC中胆道造影可以避免胆管残留结石及胆囊管残株结石 ,减少不必要的胆管阴性探查 ,发现乳头部狭窄 ,辨明胆道解剖 ,避免胆道损伤。     

Acquired abnormalities of the biliary tract from chronic gallstone disease.

BACKGROUND: Acquired abnormalities of the biliary tract from chronic gallstone disease are rare. The aim of this study was to examine the frequency with which these abnormalities occur and to assess the probability of encountering such an abnormality at laparoscopic cholecystectomy. STUDY DESIGN: We conducted a prospective study of all patients undergoing elective and emergency cholecystectomy under the care of one surgeon between January 1991 and December 1997. RESULTS: Biliary tract abnormalities from chronic gallstone disease were encountered in 10 (2%) of 486 patients undergoing cholecystectomy. Four were observed in patients undergoing elective laparoscopy cholecystectomy, and the remainder were observed at open cholecystectomy. Five had a cholecystocholedochal fistula (Mirizzi Syndrome Type II), and one had a stone impacted at the cystic duct-bile duct junction (Mirizzi Syndrome Type I). Two had cholecystoduodenal fistulas and two had an absent cystic duct with a normal bile duct. Both instances of an absent cystic duct were encountered at laparoscopic cholecystectomy; in one the bile duct was mistaken for the cystic duct and a 2-cm segment was excised at operation, and in the other the abnormality was recognized and confirmed by cholangiography. CONCLUSIONS: This study demonstrates a similar incidence of acquired abnormalities of the biliary tract from chronic gallstone disease to that already reported. But acquired absence of the cystic duct may occur more frequently than previously suspected. Patients with this condition are at high risk for bile duct injury during laparoscopic cholecystectomy. Clinical awareness of this problem with strict adherence to the principles taught at open cholecystectomy may prevent or reduce the severity of bile duct injury in these patients.     

Current practice in biliary surgery

A questionnaire enquiring about current practices in biliary surgery was sent to over 25 per cent of consultant general surgeons in the UK; 90 per cent replied. Only 56 per cent use antibiotic prophylaxis for elective cholecystectomy, and 84 per cent for emergency cholecystectomy. Duration of use, choice of agent and absence of prophylaxis for high-risk cases were inappropriate in up to 20 per cent of cases. Of the respondents 84 per cent routinely perform operative cholangiography and use T tubes, and 75 per cent routinely place a peritoneal drain after cholecystectomy. Despite controversies in the literature, most UK surgeons still follow traditional practices in biliary surgery.     

Towards T-tube free laparoscopic bile duct exploration: a methodologic evolution during 300 consecutive procedures.

OBJECTIVE: To establish a simple, reproducible, and safe technique of laparoscopic common bile duct exploration (CBDE) with high clearance rates and low morbidity and mortality rates. SUMMARY BACKGROUND DATA: For most general surgeons, laparoscopic CBDE appears an unduly complex and demanding procedure. Since the introduction of laparoscopic cholecystectomy, many surgeons use endoscopic cholangiography (ERC) and endoscopic sphincterotomy as their only option in treating bile duct stones. ERC is more specific if used after surgery, but it carries an appreciable morbidity rate and has the disadvantage of requiring a second procedure to deal with bile duct stones. To this end, various methods of laparoscopic CBDE have been developed. METHODS: Between August 1991 and February 1997, 300 consecutive unselected patients underwent laparoscopic CBDE. RESULTS: Of 300 laparoscopic CBDE procedures, 173 (58%) were managed using a transcystic approach and 127 (42%) with choledochotomy. Successful laparoscopic stone clearance was achieved in 271 (90%). Of the 29 (10%) patients not cleared laparoscopically, 10 had an elective postsurgical ERC, 12 were converted to an open procedure early in the series, and 7 had unexpected retained stones. There was one death (mortality rate 0.3%) and major morbidity occurred in 22 patients (7%). The last 100 procedures were performed from July 1995 to February 1997, and stone clearance was unsuccessful in only two patients. CONCLUSIONS: Laparoscopic transcystic basket extraction of common duct stones under fluoroscopic guidance is a relatively quick, successful, and safe technique. Choledochotomy, when required, is associated with a higher morbidity rate, particularly with T-tube insertion, and the authors advocate primary bile duct closure with or without insertion of a biliary stent as a more satisfactory technique for both surgeon and patient. Most patients with gallbladder and common duct calculi should expect a curative one-stage laparoscopic procedure without the need for external biliary drainage or ERC.     

Role of biliary scintiscan in predicting the need for cholangiography

BACKGROUND: Currently used predictors for bile duct calculi in patients undergoing cholecystectomy have low specificity resulting in unnecessary cholangiograms being performed. The role of biliary scintiscan in predicting the presence of bile duct calculi was assessed. METHODS: Seventy-five patients with symptomatic gallstone disease were studied prospectively regard- ing the value of a history of jaundice or acute pancreatitis, raised serum bilirubin and serum alkaline phosphatase levels, and visualization of stones or presence of dilated bile ducts on ultrasonography (standard criteria) in detecting bile duct calculi. Results of biliary scintiscan were evaluated against a combination of standard criteria. The 'gold standard' for evaluation was endoscopic or peroperative cholangiography. RESULTS: Biliary scintiscan had a higher sensitivity and specificity (93 and 94 per cent) than a combination of the above standard and modified predictors for biliary calculi (89 and 71 per cent). A combination of ultrasonography and selective use of scintiscan, in the absence of bile duct dilatation only, had higher values (96 and 98 per cent). CONCLUSION: A combination of ultrasonography and biliary scintiscan can accurately predict bile duct calculi and could be used as a guide for selective cholangiography.     

Cholecystectomy in the elderly

A two-year retrospective review of 137 patients over 70 years of age undergoing cholecystectomy, from January 1, 1983 to January 1, 1985, was done at Mount Sinai Medical Center of Miami Beach. This study focused on the clinical presentations, surgical management, and overall morbidity and mortality of this operative procedure in the elderly. There were 81 women and 56 men in the study ranging in age from 70 to 96. Elective procedures were performed in (78/137) 57 per cent of the patients while (59/137) 43 per cent underwent emergency surgery. Elective procedures were performed in (55/81) 68 per cent of the women and (23/56) 41 per cent of the men. Emergency surgery was required in (26/81) 32 per cent of the women and (33/56) 60 per cent of the men. Complications developed in (16/78) 20 per cent of the elective cases and (19/59) 32 per cent of the emergency cases. In the elective group, the most common complication involved the cardiovascular system. Sepsis with multiple organ failure accounted for all the deaths in the emergency group. Among the 137 patients in this series, there was a (3/78) 3.8 per cent mortality in the elective group and a (7/59) 12 per cent mortality in the emergency group with an overall mortality of (10/137) 7.3 per cent. The purpose of this study was to highlight the necessity for aggressive surgical management of biliary tract disease in the elderly.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Management of symptomatic gallstones in the elderly

In a study of 544 patients with symptomatic gallstones 158 subjects were aged greater than 70 years. Elderly patients had a significantly higher incidence of emergency presentation, jaundice, cholangitis, ductal stones, biliary drainage procedures, and acute complications requiring urgent or emergency surgery (P less than 0.001); they had more than twice the incidence of postoperative complications in comparison with patients aged less than 70 years. There was an increased perioperative mortality in the elderly (1.3 per cent after cholecystectomy and 2.9 per cent after bile duct exploration, P = 0.039). Conservative treatment in 11 per cent of elderly patients resulted in no mortality due to gallstones, but 3 of 17 patients had recurrent biliary symptoms. It was estimated that 38 per cent of the bile duct explorations in the elderly might have been avoided by referral for endoscopic sphincterotomy, but surgical treatment of gallstones in the district general hospital is relatively safe and specialist referral should be considered only in the relatively small number of 'high risk' cases.     

Laparoscopic surgical treatment of cholecysto-choledochal calculi. A single step solution

The laparoscopic era has created a new basis for the management of choledocholithiasis. Many surgeons now regard laparoscopic cholecystectomy and exploration of the common bile duct as the "gold standard". The main advantages of single-stage treatment consist in a significantly shorter hospital stay, very low complication rates and a reduction of average hospital costs. Among 601 cases of cholelithiasis treated over the period from 1994 to 1999, we report 73 cases of common-bile-duct stones. Surgical sphincterotomy was performed in 20 cases and endoscopic sphincterotomy in 24; only in 7 cases was choledochotomy and/or hepaticojejunostomy (3 cases) performed for critical situations. Twenty-two cases of cholelithiasis were treated by laparoscopic cholecystectomy and exploration of the common bile duct. Stone extraction was obtained with a balloon catheter or Dormia basket via a choledochotomy. Surgery was completed by suturing, cholangiography and the placement of sub-hepatic drainages. No mortality or long-term complications were recorded with the laparoscopic procedure; only two immediate complications were reported, both of which were biliary leakages (9%) that resolved spontaneously. With the other procedures, high rates of mortality, morbidity, hospital admissions and technical failure were registered. We regard laparoscopic exploration of the common bile duct as the treatment of choice for bile-duct stones when combined with cholecystectomy. We reserve ERCP plus endoscopic sphincterotomy only for common-bile-duct stones alone, without a gallbladder or gallstones. Open surgery is performed in particular situations such as Mirizzi's syndrome or when other procedures have failed to yield satisfactory results.     

Intraoperative endoscopy of the biliary tract

Summary This is a prospective series of 328 operations for biliary stone disease in 326 consecutive patients. The overall operative mortality was 0.6%. Routine operative cholangiography was utilized during cholecystectomy, and this identified 19 patients (5.9%) with silent common bile duct stones. Common bile duct explorations were positive in 62 of 74 operations (83.8%). Biliary endoscopy was routinely performed during bile duct exploration. Unsuspected retained common duct stones were discovered postoperatively in 4.5% of these patients. Biliary endoscopy proved essential in the management of 18 patients with radiographically demonstrated distal bile duct obstruction. With patency confirmed by endoscopy, inappropriate duodenotomy and sphincter ablation were avoided in each of these 18 patients.