Impact of cortical perforations of contiguous donor bone in a guided bone augmentation procedure: an experimental study in the rabbit skull

Background: It has been shown that bone can be augmented beyond the original skeletal envelope by using space‐making barriers. Further, it has been suggested that perforation of the contiguous donor bone enhances bone formation in guided bone augmentation procedures. Purpose: The goal of the present investigation was to evaluate whether perforations into the donor bone marrow through the cortical plate, located contiguous to an extracalvarial experimental space, influence bone generation into this space with regard to augmented bone tissue volume and bone density 3 months postoperatively. Materials and Methods: Two titanium cylinders, each with a titanium lid, were subcutaneously placed with their open ends facing the parietal bones of eight rabbits and secured with miniscrews. The cortical bone plate on the test side was perforated with seven evenly distributed holes, each with a diameter of 1.2 mm, using carbon‐steel burs. Together, these perforations corresponded to about one‐third of the total experimental bone area. The bone on the control side was left intact, and no bleeding occurred during the placement of the titanium lid. The perforation procedure (test side) resulted in various degrees of blood fill. After 3 months, the animals were sacrificed to obtain ground sections for histology and histomorphometry. Results: The cylinders were found to be partly filled with tissue containing slender bone trabeculae and marrow spaces in abundance. The bone consistently reached a higher level at the inner wall compared with the central part of the cylinders (p=.001). Hollow connections between the experimental space and the skull bone marrow were found in the contiguous outer cortical plate in four of the seven control sites. No statistically significant differences could be demonstrated between the perforated test sites and the control sites regarding augmented tissue volume (64.4 ± 18.9% vs. 64.9 ± 22.2%) or bone density, although there was a tendency toward denser bone in the test sites (21.5 ± 11.1%) versus control sites (14.7 ± 5.4%). There was no statistical difference regarding relative bone‐to‐titanium wall contact (27.4 ± 14.7% for test; 38.6 ± 25.9% for control). Thickness (height) and density of the skull bone vault were measured in the area beneath and lateral to the cylinders. No significant differences could be observed regarding these parameters between the test and control side. There were no correlations between thickness (height) or density of donor bone versus amount or density of augmented bone. The degree of immediate blood fill could not be shown to correlate with augmented tissue volume or augmented bone density. Conclusions: In the present model, as observed 3 months postoperatively, cortical perforations of contiguous donor bone or degree of immediate blood fill of an extracalvarial experimental space were not found to enhance augmented tissue volume beyond the skeletal envelope. Although there was a much higher mean value for bone density of augmented bone in the test sites, the large variations failed to show significant intergroup differences.     

Effects of cortical bone perforation on experimental guided bone regeneration

This study was designed to evaluate the effects of cortical bone perforation histologically and histomorphometrically on guided bone regeneration (GBR) in rabbits. After elimination of the periosteum, cortical bone defects of two sizes were made in the external cortical plate of the frontal bone (Group A: 1 x 15 mm; Group B: 3 x 15 mm). A non-resorbable membrane filled with autogenous blood was placed in the experimental area and secured with titanium pins. After 1 and 2 weeks, vascularized connective tissue and new bone were generated in the space surrounding the defects in both the groups. The amount of vascularized connective tissue generated in Group B was greater than that in Group A at 1 week. Alkaline phosphatase (ALP) was expressed on the bone surrounding the perforation. The expression of ALP was more extensive in Group B than in Group A and was proportional to the breadth of perforation. At 2 weeks, the perforated region was almost covered with new bone in Group A. ALP was expressed at the periphery of newly formed bone. The expression of ALP was proportional to the breadth and height of perforation. At 6 weeks, semicircular outgrowth of bone towards the periphery of the perforated region was observed in both the groups. Newly formed bone volume and ALP expression in Group B were more extensive than those in Group A. At 12 weeks, the space was filled with bone and connective tissue in both the groups. There was no difference in ALP expression between Groups A and B. Histomorphometric analysis showed significant differences between both the groups (two-way ANOVA, P<0.01). We conclude that a larger perforation is associated with prompter bone formation in the secluded space during GBR.     

Augmentation of the mandible with GTR and onlay cortical bone grafting. An experimental study in the rat

The aim of the present study was to evaluate the effect of augmenting the mandible with onlay mandibular bone grafts that were covered with e-PTFE membranes according to the principle of guided tissue regeneration (GTR). The experiment was carried out in 30 rats. The inferior border of the mandible and parts of the mandibular body were exposed on both sides. On one side, an autogenous bone graft that was harvested from the angle of the mandible was placed on the inferior border of the mandible and was fixed with a titanium microimplant. Subsequently, the graft was covered with an e-PTFE membrane. The contralateral side, serving as control, was treated the same way except for the placement of the membrane. Groups of six animals were sacrificed 15, 30, 60, 120 and 180 days following surgery, and specimens that were prepared from the experimental and control sites were analyzed histologically. The bone graft underneath the membrane initially presented superficial resorption but, subsequently, the space that was created by the membrane gradually became filled with bone. After 180 days, the area underneath the membrane was completely filled with bone and it was impossible to distinguish between the bone graft and the newly formed bone. Generally, the bone grafts at the control sides were characterized by a gradual resorption during the entire experimental period. At 180 days after transplantation, only a few grafts at the control sites had retained their height, and there was frequently a lack of continuity between the bone graft and the underlying mandibular bone. It can be concluded that onlay mandibular bone grafts combined with GTR may improve the predictability of mandibular augmentation, in comparison to bone grafting alone.     

Lateral ridge augmentation using different bone fillers and barrier membrane application. A histologic and histomorphometric pilot study in the canine mandible

Lateral ridge augmentation has become a standard treatment option to enhance the bone volume of deficient recipient sites prior to implant placement. In order to avoid harvesting an autograft and thereby eliminating additional surgical procedures and risks, bone grafting materials and substitutes are alternative filler materials to be used for ridge augmentation. Before clinical recommendations can be made, such materials must be extensively studied in experimental models simulating relevant clinical situations. The present pilot study was conducted in three dogs. Different grafting procedures were evaluated for augmentation of lateral, extended (8 x 10 x 14 mm) and chronic bone defects in the mandibular alveolar ridge. Experimental sites received tricalcium phosphate (TCP) granules or demineralized freeze-dried bone allograft (DFDBA) particles. Barrier membranes (ePTFE) were placed for graft protection. These approaches were compared to ridge augmentation using autogenous cortico-cancellous block grafts, either with or without ePTFE-membrane application. After a healing period of six months, the sites were analyzed histologically and histomorphometrically. Autografted sites with membrane protection showed excellent healing results with a well-preserved ridge profile, whereas non-protected block grafts underwent bucco-crestal resorption, clearly limiting the treatment outcome. The tested alloplastic (TCP) and allogenic (DFDBA) filler materials presented inconsistent findings with sometimes encapsulation of particles in connective tissue, thereby reducing the crestal bone width. The present pilot study supports the use of autografts with barrier membranes for lateral ridge augmentation of extended alveolar bone defects.     

Changes in cortical bone mineralization in the mouse mandible with regenerated condyle

The objective of this study was to evaluate the effects of condylectomy and of a functional appliance on the mineral content, density, and area of the mandibular cortical bone in a growing mouse model. In the condylectomy group, a unilateral condylectomy was performed on the right side of the mouse mandible. In the condylectomy + appliance group, a functional appliance was used to reposition the mandible after the unilateral condylectomy. All mice were killed 4 wk after surgery. Each mandible was then subjected to analyses of cortical bone mineral content (CRT_CNT), cortical bone density (CRT_DEN), and cortical bone area (CRT_A) by peripheral quantitative computed tomography (pQCT). The CRT_CNT, CRT_DEN, and CRT_A values were significantly lower in the condylectomized mandible (right side) than in the non-condylectomized mandible (left side). However, in the condylectomized animals in which a functional appliance was used, the CRT_CNT, CRT_DEN, and CRT_A values became higher than those in the mice treated with condylectomy alone. No significant differences were found in the CRT_CNT, CRT_DEN, and CRT_A between non-condylectomized (left side) mandibles, mandibles treated with condylectomy + functional appliance (right side), and control mandibles. It was thus shown that a functional appliance used to reposition the condylectomized mandible forward in a symmetric position induced improvement of the cortical bone in a mouse model in terms of cortical bone mineral content, density, and area.     

Augmentation of the rat jaw with autogeneic cortico-cancellous bone grafts and guided tissue regeneration

The aim of the present study was to evaluate the effect of augmenting the maxillary alveolar ridge and the lateral aspect of the mandible with onlay autogeneic cortico-cancellous bone grafts that were covered with e-PTFE membranes. The experiment was carried out in 51 rats. In 15 rats, the edentulous maxillary jaw between the incisor and the first molar was augmented by means of an autogeneic ischiac bone graft that was fixed with a gold-coated microimplant. In one side, the graft was covered with an e-PTFE membrane, while the other side, which served as control, was treated without a membrane. In the other 36 rats, the lateral aspect of the mandible was augmented in both sides by means of an autogeneic ischiac bone graft that was fixed with a gold-coated or a titanium microimplant. In one side, the augmented area was covered with an e-PTFE membrane, while the contralateral side was treated without a membrane. Histological analysis at 60, 120 and 180 days after augmentation of the maxilla showed that, in the case of the test sites (where most of the membranes were either exposed or lost), the bone grafts presented extensive resorption and there was a lack of bone continuity between the graft and the recipient site. Similar findings were made at the non-membrane-treated control sides. In the case of augmentation of the mandible with membranes, the bone grafts were not resorbed, but were integrated into newly formed bone at the recipient site. In the control sides, the grafts presented varying degrees of resorption and integration into the recipient bone. It is concluded that, in comparison to bone grafting alone, onlay ischiac bone grafting combined with guided tissue regeneration eliminates the risk of bone graft resorption and ensures integration of the graft into newly formed bone at the recipient site, provided that closure of the operated area can be maintained during healing.     

Augmentation of the rat mandible using guided tissue regeneration

The aim of the present study was to investigate whether it is possible to increase the height of the rat mandible at its inferior border using a bioresorbable membrane adapted to create a secluded space for ingrowth of bone tissue. The experiment was carried out in 18 rats. The mandibular ramus was exposed at both sides. A standardized titanium microimplant was then inserted in the naturally existing curvature at the inferior border of the mandible, serving as a fixed reference and space maker. The mandibular border on one side was covered with a polyhydroxybutyrate bioresorbable membrane, and the contralateral side, serving as control, received no membrane before closure of the wound. The membranes were placed in such a way that a space was created in the curvature between the membrane and the inferior border of the mandible. Macerated jaw specimens representing 6 months of healing demonstrated substantial amounts of bone formation in the curvature of the inferior border of the mandible, resulting in a flattening of the inferior border. Negligible amounts of bone formation had occurred in the control sides. Histological analysis demonstrated that. in 4 of 6 experimental specimens, the space created by the membrane was completely filled with new bone after 6 months of healing, but in some specimens soft tissue seemed to have migrated into the space through ruptures of the membrane or because of poor membrane adaptation at its lateral borders, thereby inhibiting bone formation. Only negligible bone formation had occurred at the control sides. It can be concluded that augmentation of the mandible can be accomplished using a bioresorbable membrane of polyhydroxybutyrate adapted to create a secluded space for ingrowth of bone tissue. but the membrane must be modified regarding its physical properties before clinical use in maxillofacial surgery.     

Blood-filled spaces with and without deproteinized bone grafts in guided bone regeneration. A histomorphometric study of the rabbit skull using non-resorbable membrane

This experimental study evaluated the effects of deproteinized bone grafts on guided bone regeneration (GBR). A groove was made in the bone marrow of the external cortical plate of the skull. A dome of non-resorbable membrane was placed on the groove and secured with titanium pins. The secluded graft space was filled with autogenous blood clots (control group) and deproteinized bone particles (experimental group). The rabbits were sacrificed 2, 4, 8 and 12 weeks after the operation. Decalcified and paraffin-embedded, transverse 3-mum-thick sections were made and stained with hematoxylin and eosin. The proportions of newly formed bone and newly formed bone-graft particle contact surfaces were histomorphometrically measured in the basal, central, and peripheral areas from the cortical plate to the top of the dome. In the control group, the basal area showed a significant increase at 4 weeks (P<0.01) and a significant decrease at 8 weeks (P<0.01). The central and peripheral areas showed gradual increases in the proportion of newly formed bone. The experimental group showed significant increase at 4 weeks in the basal area and at 8 weeks in central and peripheral area (P<0.01). There were significant differences between both groups in basal and central area (P<0.01). The proportion of newly formed bone-graft particle contact length showed significant increases at 4 weeks (P<0.01) and no significant decreases at 8 and 12 weeks in three areas. The present study showed that deproteinized bone grafts maintain newly formed bone in extensive areas for a prolonged period during GBR.     

S-nitroso albumin enhances bone formation in a rabbit calvaria model

Nitric oxide (NO) is a mediator involved in bone regeneration. We therefore examined the effect of the novel NO donor, S-nitroso human serum albumin (S-NO-HSA) on bone formation in a rabbit calvaria augmentation model.Circular grooves (8 mm diameter, two per animal) were created by a trephine drill in the cortical bone of 40 rabbits and titanium caps were placed on the rabbit calvaria bone filled with a collagen sponge soaked with either 100 μL S-NO-HSA (5%, 20%) or human albumin (5%, 20%). After 4 weeks the titanium hemispheres were subjected to histological and histomorphometric analysis. Bone formation and the volume of the residual collagen sponge were evaluated.S-NO-HSA treatment groups had a significantly higher volume of newly formed bone underneath the titanium hemispheres compared to the albumin control groups (5%: 15.5 ± 4.0% versus 10.6 ± 2.9%; P < 0.05; 20%: 14.0 ± 4.6% versus 6.0 ± 3.8%; P < 0.01). The volume of residual collagen sponge was also significantly lower in the S-NO-HSA groups compared to the control groups (5%: 0.4 ± 0.5% versus 2.6 ± 2.4%; P < 0.05 and 20%: 1.5 ± 2.7% versus 13.0 ± 18.7%; P < 0.01).This study demonstrates for the first time that S-NO-HSA promotes bone formation by slow NO release. Additionally, S-NO-HSA increases collagen sponge degradation.     

The role of cortical perforations in bone regeneration: a systematic review

The aim of this review was to determine the effect of cortical perforations in bone regeneration considering the surgical technique. An electronic search in the PubMed (MEDLINE) and ScienceDirect databases and a hand search of the literature was conducted covering the period July 2008 to December 2018. Studies that specified the creation of perforations in the recipient area as a study variable associated with the regenerative technique were included. The quality of the randomized clinical trials included in this systematic review was also assessed. A total of 16 articles met both inclusion criteria and were eligible for analysis. Studies were grouped into three blocks according to the associated surgical technique. All studies were performed in an experimental model except for one. Qualitative assessment of the studies showed a moderate to high risk of bias of the overall studies. The evidence for creating perforations in guided bone regeneration and also in combination with autologous bone blocks in order to increase bone formation is limited according to the publications analysed. Although the number and size of perforations do not appear to interfere with the result, their effect in the upper maxilla and in the mandible should be evaluated separately due to the structural anatomical differences.     

Bone reconstruction following implantation of rhBMP-2 and guided bone regeneration in canine alveolar ridge defects

BACKGROUND: Alveolar ridge aberrations commonly require bone augmentation procedures for optimal placement of endosseous dental implants. The objective of this study was to evaluate local bone formation following implantation of recombinant human bone morphogenetic protein-2 (rhBMP-2) in an absorbable collagen sponge (ACS) carrier with or without provisions for guided bone regeneration (GBR) as potential treatment modalities for alveolar augmentation. METHODS: Surgically induced, large, mandibular alveolar ridge saddle-type defects (2 defects/jaw quadrant) in seven young adult Hound dogs were assigned to receive rhBMP-2/ACS, rhBMP-2/ACS combined with GBR (rhBMP-2/GBR), GBR, and surgery controls. The animals were euthanized at 12 weeks post-surgery when block sections of the defect sites were collected for histologic analysis. RESULTS: Clinical complications included swelling for sites receiving rhBMP-2 and wound failure with exposure of the barrier device for sites receiving GBR (4/6) or rhBMP-2/GBR (3/7). The radiographic evaluation showed substantial bone fill for sites receiving rhBMP-2/ACS, rhBMP-2/GBR, and GBR. In particular, sites receiving rhBMP-2/GBR presented with seroma-like radiolucencies. The surgery control exhibited moderate bone fill. To evaluate the biologic potential of the specific protocols, sites exhibiting wound failure were excluded from the histometric analysis. Sites receiving rhBMP-2/ACS or rhBMP-2/GBR exhibited bone fill averaging 101%. Bone fill averaged 92% and 60%, respectively, for sites receiving GBR and surgery controls. Bone density ranged from 50% to 57% for sites receiving rhBMP-2/ACS, GBR, or surgery controls. Bone density for sites receiving rhBMP-2/GBR averaged 34% largely due to seroma formation encompassing 13% to 97% of the sites. CONCLUSION: rhBMP-2/ACS appears to be an effective alternative to GBR in the reconstruction of advanced alveolar ridge defects. Combining rhBMP-2/ACS with GBR appears to be of limited value due to the potential for wound failure or persistent seromas.     

引导骨组织再生膜应用于自身骨移植的研究现状

自身骨移植是种植术前骨增量的一种重要的技术手段。对于在常规骨移植后是否在移植物上覆盖引导骨组织再生膜,临床上存在着较大争议。笔者拟就引导骨组织再生膜在自身骨移植中的应用研究作一综述。     

Influence of decortication of the donor bone on guided bone augmentation. An experimental study in the rabbit skull bone

The aim of the present study was to evaluate if early access to the endosteal bone compartment by removal of the outer cortical bone plate will enhance bone augmentation in a secluded space. Two titanium cylinders were placed on the skull of each of 8 rabbits. Each cylinder was placed into a circular slit, secured to the skull bone via two mini-screws and supplied with a titanium lid. On the test side, the outer plate of the cortical bone, demarcated by the slit, was removed. The subsequent bleeding resulted in blood fill of the cylinders to various degrees. On the control side, the corfical bone plate was left intact and no bleeding was observed at the time of the placement of the titanium lids. After 3 months, the animals were sacrificed to obtain histology and histomorphometry. No differences in the total amount of augmented bone tissue, in relation to the total experimental area (75.5% +/- 10.9% at the test sites and 71.2% +/- 13.5% at the control sites) or of the augmented mineralized bone tissue in relation to the total amount of augmented bone tissue, was revealed (17.8% +/- 3.0% and 16.0% +/- 4.9% respectively). There was no difference in the morphological appearance of the augmented bone between test and control sites and there were no obvious similarities in the appearance between the newly formed bone tissue and the donor bone. The augmented bone consisted of slender bone trabeculae, distributed in abundant marrow spaces. A conspicuous finding was that the bone trabeculae tended to climb along the inner walls of the titanium cylinder. It is concluded that decortication of the calvarial bone in the rabbit does not result in more bone formation beyond the skeletal envelope after a healing period of 3 months compared to no removal of the cortical bone plate inside a secluded experimental area.     

The effects of bone grafting material and a collagen membrane in the ridge splitting technique: an experimental study in dogs

Objectives: This study was designed to evaluate the effect of bone graft materials and collagen membranes in ridge splitting procedures with immediate implant placement using a dog model. Materials and methods: Mandibular premolars were extracted in five beagle dogs. After 3 months, ridge splitting and placement of three OsseoSpeed^? implants were performed bilaterally. The gaps between the implants were allocated according to the following eight treatment modalities; Group 1(no graft), Group 2 (autogenous bone), Group 3 (Bio‐Oss^® Collagen), Group 4 (Bio‐Oss^®), Group 5 (no graft+BioGide^®), Group 6 (autogenous bone+BioGide^®), Group 7 (Bio‐Oss^® Collagen+BioGide^®), and Group 8 (Bio‐Oss^®+BioGide^®). The dogs were sacrificed after 8 or 12 weeks and the specimens were analyzed histologically and histometrically. Results: The gaps between the implants were filled with the newly formed bone, irrespective of which of the eight grafting techniques was used. Group 1 revealed a significantly lower percentage of bone‐to‐implant contact (BIC) than Group 5 at 8 and 12 weeks (P<0.05). Group 1 showed the most prominent marginal bone loss (MBL) at 12 weeks (P<0.05). Regarding the use of membranes, Groups 1 and 2 showed significantly more MBL than Groups 5 and 6 at 12 weeks (P<0.05). Conclusions: After ridge splitting, if the gaps between implants were grafted or covered with collagen membranes, a higher percentage of BIC was obtained. Based on our results, we suggest that the use of bone graft materials and/or collagen membranes is better for the prevention of MBL after ridge splitting procedures. To cite this article:
Han J‐Y, Shin S‐I, Herr Y, Kwon Y‐H, Chung J‐H. The effects of bone grafting material and a collagen membrane in the ridge splitting technique: an experimental study in dogs.
Clin. Oral Impl. Res. xx , 2011; 000–000
doi: 10.1111/j.1600‐0501.2010.02127.x     

A clinical and histomorphometric study of calcium sulfate compared with freeze-dried bone allograft for alveolar ridge preservation

Background: Many materials have been found to be effective in ridge preservation. The purpose of this study is to determine whether calcium sulfate (CS) is as effective as freeze‐dried bone allograft (FDBA) in preserving postextraction ridge dimensions and to evaluate the amount of new bone formation and graft clearance through histologic analysis. Methods: Thirty‐one extraction sites were selected. Postextraction clinical measurements were made, and sites were divided randomly into the test group (CS) or the control group (FDBA). After graft placement, all individuals received the same postoperative treatment and instructions. Participants were recalled after 3 months, measurements were made, and sites were re‐entered. Bone samples were harvested and analyzed with histologic methodology for new bone formation and remaining residual graft. Results: Thirteen test and 15 control sites were evaluated. There was no significant change in vertical ridge height before or after surgery within the test and control groups (P = 0.57, P = 0.68, respectively). There was a significant decrease in bucco‐lingual ridge width for both groups (P = 0.0003, P = 0.0075, respectively), but the difference between groups was not significant (P = 0.11). Histologic analysis revealed an average of 32% new bone formation with 2.5% graft remaining for the test group and 16.7% new bone formation with 21% graft remaining for the control. Conclusions: Results indicate that CS is as effective as FDBA in preserving postextraction ridge dimensions in non‐molar extraction sites. There is greater clearance of CS with more new bone formation after ≈3 months compared with FDBA in these sites. This paper received the Maynard K. Hine Award for Excellence in Dental Research presented by the Indiana Section of the American Association for Dental Research and supported by Procter & Gamble.